r/soccer • u/Alphabet1 • Sep 21 '12
Which teams currently have their best ever player playing for them?
With the recent retirement (or effective retirement) of players like Del Piero, do you think any teams have their best ever player currently playing for them? Especially smaller, less well known teams?
49
Upvotes
83
u/daveduckman Sep 21 '12
Most of these are relative minnows with a marquee signing.
Totti at Roma is the best example I can come up with.
Also OP, I reject that del piero is Juventus' best ever. Keep in mind this is the club that had Platini, Laudrup and Zidane in previous eras.
169
u/Primitive_Poverty Sep 21 '12
Thierry Henry NY Red Bulls
100
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Shanghai with Drogba
73
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
David Beckham LA Galaxy, or Landon Donovan.
92
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Samuel Eto'o for Anzhi, for sure.
62
u/bendtnertime Sep 21 '12
Maybe Barcelona with Messi, although I consider Cruyff bigger. Perhaps even Roma with Francesco Totti.
20
u/Gobbles15 Sep 21 '12
A month or two ago I would have said Eden Hazard at Lille
90
u/JBWill Sep 21 '12
Obviously Juventus with Bendtner.
Or are we talking objectively?
13
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
You won't know for the Eredivisie team as all their players will peak in 5 years abroad.
22
u/thizzmountain Sep 21 '12
Admittedly, I don't know much about their past players, but my two cents is Fabrizio Miccoli for Palermo.
21
u/AnnieIWillKnow Sep 21 '12
There's a strong case for Zola, but you could argue Frank Lampard for Chelsea.
71
u/oxile Sep 21 '12
Toure Yaya or Silva for City
28
u/andresfelipesv Sep 21 '12
Toronto FC's Torsten Frings.
8
u/IlCattivo91 Sep 21 '12
AS Roma - Francesco Totti
21
u/droid_of_flanders Sep 21 '12
Malaga comes to mind. Especially last season with Santi Cazorla.
102
u/croissanwich Sep 21 '12
howard webb, manchester united
11
u/verdevilla Sep 21 '12
In Spain:
Barcelona - Leo Messi (1987) argentina // Málaga - Viverti (1944) argentina // Mallorca - Samuel Eto'o (1981) cameroon // Sevilla - Frédétic Kanuté (1977) mali // Atlético - Larby Ben Barek (1917) morocco // Rayo - ????? // Betis - Rafael Gordillo (1957) spain // Deportivo - Mauro Silva (1968) brazil // Valladolid - Eusebio Sacristán (1964) spain // R.Sociedad - Luis Miguel Arconada (1954) spain // Valencia - Mario Alberto Kempes (1954) argentina // R.Madrid - Alfredo Di Stéfano (1986) argentina // Getafe - David Belenguer (1972) spain // Levante - ???? // Athletic - Telmo Zarra (1921) spain // Celta - Aleksandr Mostovói (1968) russia // Zaragoza - José Luis Violeta (1941) spain // Granada - ???? // Espanyol - Raúl Tamudo (1977) spain // Osasuna - Sabino Andonegi (1931) spain
Bonus track:
Villarreal - Marcos Senna (1976) brazil
23
u/KrazyEyezKilla Sep 21 '12
Messi at barca. They've had some of the best players in the world but Messi is the greatest player I've ever seen.
4
u/NappyPants Sep 21 '12
Jores Okore is probably the best player Nordsjælland have every produced, potentially I could see him play for a top 8 team in the EPL in the next 2-3 years. Right now I'd say hes slightly behind Andreas Bjelland (who I would have otherwise said to have been our best player ever, till he left for Twente in the Summer), purely on an experience basis, but Okore defiantly has the potential to surpass Bjelland.
24
u/yayareapolo123 Sep 21 '12
I'd say Iker has to be up there with real madrid's greatest ever. I'm not saying he's their greatest, but for sure best keeper and should be in the conversation for greatest.
21
u/heightofignorance Sep 21 '12
Surely, surely Gerrard for Liverpool? I mean they've had some incredible talents who have brought the club more success, but Gerrard is Liverpool. I know Dalglish, Keegan and Barnes are legends, but 600 club appearances and the captain of the greatest UCL comeback in history has got to be doesn't he?
6
u/graph1k Sep 21 '12
Montero for Seattle is hard to pass up, yes we had Llundberg, but TBH he didn't play THAT amazing when he was here.
6
u/kyoutenshi Sep 21 '12
Fredy Montero with Seattle Sounders.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
There are some ridiculous answers in this thread...
3
u/AminoManUVA Sep 21 '12
Zanetti at Inter...I feel like he is highly underrated
14
u/derajydac Sep 21 '12
Heskey now.
He is the powerhouse though.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Del Piero Sydney FC, Heskey Newcastle Jets and Ballack if Western Sydney get him!!
5
u/chemelh Sep 21 '12
When henry comes back for his loan in january. him.
2
u/Stoutacus Sep 21 '12
For my team, Houston Dynamo, the answer is yes: Brad Davis.
4
u/verdevilla Sep 21 '12
For F.C. Barcelona
Others legends:
Migueli (Spain), Ramallets (Spain), Maradona (Argentine), Neeskens (Netherlands), Hristo Stòiktov (Bulgaria), Ronald Koeman (Netherlands), Josep Guardiola (Spain), Romario (Brazil), Ramallets (Spain), Ronaldo (Brazil), Laudrup (Denmark), Kocsis (Hungary), Gullermo Amor (Spain), Bernd Shuster(Germany), Quini (Spain), Luis Enrique (Spain), Krankl (Austria), Evaristo (Brazil), Rexach (Spain), Luís Suárez (Spain), Segarra (Spain), Hans Gamper (Switzerland), Piera (Spain), Platko (Hungary), Escolà (Spain), Basora (Spain), César (Spain), Mariano Martín (Spain), Czibor (Hungary), Victor Valdes (Spain), Daniel Alves (Brazil), Villaverde (Uruguay)...................
7
u/5eraph Sep 21 '12
No expert on PSG, but I assume Zlatan. Because Zlatan.
3
u/Element77 Sep 21 '12
Craig Bellamy
3
u/mnap1122 Sep 21 '12
Messi Barcelona.
2
u/donutmanZ Sep 21 '12
Brek Shea for FC Dallas? Either him or David Fererria. Then again, Blas Perez is one hell of a striker.
2
u/KipTheFury Sep 21 '12
Newcastle - Shola Ameobi
/s
2
u/Loggus Sep 21 '12 edited Sep 21 '12
Falcao for Atletico de Madrid?
Edit: just thought of some other players: Pele for Santos and Zico for Flamengo
1
u/joeigglypuff Sep 21 '12
Djamel Mesbah, no contest.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Pretty much anyone on Montreal Impact... We can start with Alessandro Nesta.
1
u/cynikles Sep 22 '12
Brisbane Roar - Thomas Broich
Sydney FC - Alessandro Del Piero
I'm pretty safe in saying that. Won't go out on a limb with the other A-League teams as there'd be some dispute there.
1
u/amosbr Sep 22 '12
Scholes
-1
u/zSolaris Sep 21 '12
United. Either Giggs or Scholes. Seriously, those two are something else.
1
u/TheMaxican93 Sep 21 '12
Swansea City have to have their best ever right now. I'm not sure who it is, but I think Vorm, Michu and maybe a couple others are all better than Gylfi and Joe Allen
1
u/thedeuceabides Sep 21 '12
Michael Laudrup at Swansea. (I know, I know...)
0
u/cherif84 Sep 21 '12
PSG with Zlatan
Ps: or maybe it was Weah or Ronaldinho
1
u/TomTheScouser Sep 21 '12
Gerrard for Liverpool, Totti for Roma, Silva/Yaya Toure/Tevez for City, Messi for Barca (arguably).
1
u/Isaweddiescore Sep 21 '12
As a Cardiff fan, surely Peter Whittingham is right up there with our best ever. The technical ability he shows is incredible, his left foot is a wand. If you're not familiar with him, look for some of his goals on youtube, he scores a few screamers every season.
If we ever get to the Prem, I fully believe he can step up and perform at the top level.
0
u/pusselw Sep 21 '12
Zlatan in PSG, Zlatan in Sweden
0
u/ail33 Sep 21 '12 edited Sep 22 '12
Barca messi Edit:why am I getting downvotes
-1
u/Queefaroni Sep 21 '12
Totti for Roma, Baggio at Brescia. Sheva for Ukraine, George weah for Liberia, Hleb for Belarus