r/MonsterHunterMeta • u/EchoesPartOne Guild Marm • Feb 12 '25
Wilds [MHWilds] Statement About the Future Meta Compilations
As the release of MH Wilds approaches, the work on optimization and the requests for meta content will start as well; for this reason, I believe it's important to make a point about how work on meta will be happening here and throughout Wilds lifespan.
Expectations for the First Month
I want to remind you first of all that people who work on designing and optimizing meta sets that are featured for this subreddit are all first and foremost people who enjoy playing Monster Hunter and love trying to figure out how the game works in order to make the most out of the tools that are available. The vast majority of people I have worked with before (including myself) don't get any form of revenue from working on meta sets, whether through a Youtube channel or streaming; we just do it on our spare time because we like the complexity of the game and the collective work of gathering and sharing knowledge with a community looking to improve their own gameplay.
Like most people, I therefore intend to spend several weeks just learning how the game works by myself and with the other people without having to work immediately on making a compilation or an album for public use. For this reason, you shouldn't be expecting any meta compilation for several weeks after the game is released, and it's pointless to ask for it. My goal is indeed to offer some kind of "definitive" work and not to churn out meta sets as quickly as possible just to create content.
Once I determined that I have enough time and that people have gathered enough material and knowledge about the game, I will start working on making a compilation of the best available work made by the community and I will try to keep it updated throughout the entire lifespan of Monster Hunter Wilds.
Selection Process
I'm also going to be changing a bit how the process of selection is gonna work. This time around, I will accept submissions from anyone that is willing to have their work featured on a compilation, regardless of where this work was made. All you have to do in order to submit your work for the compilation is to send me a DM with YOUR personal work on a specific weapon (I will not accept simple suggestions of existing work done by other people, for reasons that will be made clear below).
Obviously, there are some caveats about this:
- Only one work per weapon will still be featured in the compilation (the reasons will be made clear below). For this reason, if multiple people are submitting content for the same weapon they will be highly encourage to work collectively to make a single album together. This shouldn't be an issue, since the majority of work is collective anyway, but this should at least mitigate the disappointment for people whose work can't be featured due to the aforementioned constraint.
- The person(s) who is in charge of the album for a specific weapon should take responsibility for updating the album with every new title update we receive. If I don't receive any news from someone for several weeks after a title update I might end up having to look for other people who are available to do the work.
- The person(s) should put in their work at least one way to contact them directly in order to be informed of mistakes or potential changes. I will obviously pick up comments I read on this subreddit from time to time and report them to the authors if possible, but you shouldn't be expecting me to be the main transmission belt for every comment on the albums.
Selection Criteria
In my past compilations, I always had as my main goal to offer content of the highest possible quality to the users that were looking for meta content; I did it according to my own criteria that I determined through my experience with the game, the meta and the demands from the community. Since however I'm now formally accepting free submissions from everyone, I think it's important to state more clearly what I'm generally looking for in terms of content for the compilation by stating my criteria for selecting among the available work.
- Simplicity: the work should be able to tell what people should be looking for in a straightforward way. After all, if people are looking for a meta album it's most likely because they are lost among the many different options and want to know the "best" option(s) among them.
Ideally, any meta album should be built around the idea of delivering the "one" best set (usually a raw set), and any extra set added beyond that one should be justified clearly - either because it deals more damage (e.g. by using elemental over raw) or because it deals similar damage but with a very different playstyle. (This is a rule that has been more or less unconsciously used by anyone who ever made this kind of work, but it's probably important to spell it out.) - Readability: the page should convey all the informations necessary to use the sets and understand the logic behind them in plain English (to the best of each one's ability of course, since many in the community aren't native English speakers). All the information within the page should be ordered in a way that people can just skip to the part they're looking for - again, people read these pages to be guided, not to get lost.
- Accessibility: the page for the album should be readable by anyone who has access to a web browser without the need to create an account or download an additional app. Any site that fits these criteria works (blog site, Google Docs or equivalent, etc). Be aware also that Imgur has become increasingly unreliable as a way to store meta content, so I would accept an album hosted on that site only as a temporary solution.
- Math & Testing: every set featured should have both been checked through mathematical tools that can compare it to other similar sets and been tested by the players to make sure it can actually help clear hunts consistently.
The former is necessary because it's very hard to compare the global effectiveness of a set throughout the hunt without some form of actual calculation; the latter because we're not just theorycrafting sets that could work in theory, but sets that can work most of the time (at least as long as you understand the basics of the weapon and of MH). - Trustworthiness: the main goal of these albums is to help the community of those who like to optimize their own gameplay. While everyone has their own temper and personality, I do not intend to promote people whose mindset is generally not about helping the other players with their experience and knowledge, and/or who are known to be toxic, no matter how objectively correct their work might be.
Additionally, since I will need to be regularly in contact with the people who work on the albums, any person who dislikes me, my work or my principles can save a lot of time by not sending me anything at all - I'm not anyone's slave, nor I wish anyone to be mine.
I will edit any of these points if I realize I forgot anything important or if they happen not to be clear for everyone.
That's it. I hope everyone will have fun playing the game and figuring out how it work both before and after a compilation will be posted, and that we will all continue working together to overcome anything Capcom is gonna throw at us. Happy hunting!
22
u/Famas_1234 Master Artist Feb 16 '25
As my past work suggests, I will still contribute by providing MHWilds weapon flowcharts like I've done in 5th gen. Compared with 5th gen weapons flowcharts, I will be doing a unified place in Google Drive where I can store all of my flowcharts there. With this, I can streamline the updates with feedback section.
For the meta compilation, can I request something? I want that each document can explain how the weapon mechanic works, at least optimal combos are the minimum, so it's not only the optimal set builds.
17
u/whensmahvelFGC Feb 12 '25
Monster Hunter Meta would really benefit from a platform like poe.ninja
Whereby it aggregates all of the builds people submit and shows usage rates etc. In MHW we have HunterPie that can export builds to automate something like that, since I doubt Capcom is going to expose build data via an API. I hope the people behind that can bring that to Wilds.
I'd love to be able to just compare what I'm running to the rest of the masses, but I fully expect the first month of MHM here to basically be "Is my build meta? What can I change?" followed by a bunch of exhausted comments saying "there's no meta yet and here's why" before we get to any actual build discussion.
Definitely appreciate trying to frontload that, more than willing to be patient while the real nerds math out the optimal stuff but I just hope to find some useful discussion here in the meantime.
7
u/OnePunkArmy Insect Glaive Mar 01 '25
In addition to builds, I would love to see something about optimal moves or a short how-to-play. For example, people say Wilds IG is so different that it's basically a brand new weapon. Therefore, in addition to the IG builds, I would love to see something explaining what's the best thing to do in combat. It doesn't even have to be long - it could even be something like "spam this move" or just a sentence or two, as long as it gets the point across.
3
u/ILikeDillonBrooks Mar 05 '25
My Only question is will the meta build Compilations be pinned in the sub
82
u/ronin0397 Charge Blade Feb 12 '25 edited Feb 12 '25
I plan to do a charge blade compilation for wilds. It will contain a cb guide, skill tier list, progression set guide, weapon tier list, then end game set compilation in that order. Currently working on the guide cuz there are few changes slated for cb in the betas to main game. A matchup breakdown/tier list will be done much later once each monster has been hunted enough to know the matchup.
One of my failings with the risebreak guide was that i didnt document set showcases enough cuz i was on switch (it was a pain to record hunts due to delayed inputs), so i intend to document the progress of my charge blade journey on my own channel this time around, then record my findings in the compilations.
(Ie build/ test sets, new step: have a hunt video accompanying set , then add the set to comp with comprehensive explanations on the benefits and limitations of each set. It will not be required to watch the videos of course, but its more for proof of concept being displayed instead of ' i followed the theory and math, trust me bro'. The video puts the theory into practice).
Expect me to bug all of you for math related questions so i can get the calcs right.
I have 2 weeks off from work during release to get this done as soon as humanly possible. I ak most excited to do the weapon tier list cuz of the weapon skills.
67
u/dragonbronze Sword & Shield Feb 12 '25
For SnS, /u/MOPOP99, /u/DaveTheHungry and I will be working on the compilation. We've all worked on previous compilations for the SnS for different games.
If there's anyone else interested in submitting something for the SnS, please DM any of us so we can talk about working together!
If you guys have any thoughts about the previous SnS meta compilations for World/Rise, we would also like to hear about it so we can incorporate your feedback for the Wilds version.
63
u/Cynic_Ray Dual Blades Feb 13 '25
I will be returning to write the Dual Blades meta compilation. I think this is wise to have a sanction period for the writers, the process is very time consuming. I have a few selected members of the community that will support the work, and I may be interested in adding new motivated members into the crew. For those interested, DM me please. I am also working on another project for the community, but I will disclose this publicly later. It may take a few months and I do not wish to excite folk prematurely.
21
u/Upgrade_In_Progress Mar 03 '25
Continuing to work on Hunting Horn and excited to come back and work on a Horn compilation. Same as with Sunbreak - it will contain a weapon guide, skill lost, prog, and matchup list alongside the obligatory sets.
Hoping to be a bit less long-winded and a little more clear cut, and welcoming any input for what might help for the future.
It's going to take some time; I'm no longer as free due to personal reasons, but rest assured the work will continue!
19
u/Davychu Sword & Shield Mar 01 '25
The people who make these compilations are absolute heroes. Take your time, I hope nobody will be expecting them this early xD
17
u/coleipoo Feb 13 '25
Hammer bonk
13
u/BoxingPanzer Feb 13 '25
Awesome to see many returning names working on builds again. Great to see you putting your got forward about a lot of us begging for the builds too, I sometimes forget how long it can take, and was my mistake with Rise and Sunbreak, forgot to just sit back and enjoy the games at first, because I'm definitely guilty of having been "that guy" before. Looking forward to what you guys find! Super hyped!
3
u/mastergaming234 Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25
I feel like in general during the serval weeks when game first comes out is a good way for everyone to play and see how it play before looking for ways to min max. Like play the story start to finish do different hunts in the avaliable biomes to if the gameplay keeps you hooked enough to want to invest in mid maxing for the end game.
Let me say echos your compilation builds what made really like meta aspects of worlds and rise and I got alot of hours of fun play time as a result of it. So, to all the build makers, take as long as you need to cook some awesome builds.
2
u/3932695 Dual Blades Mar 22 '25
Is this tool worthy of an early pin?
https://www.reddit.com/r/MonsterHunterMeta/comments/1jftiwm/wilds_set_search_open_source/
1
u/Chanze3 Mar 03 '25
I am soooo excited for this
1
u/Nakedninja21 Mar 22 '25
Wonder how the people who make all the weapons are going
1
u/Nuryadiy Feb 14 '25
I’m only looking for the most tank build possible, as much defensive skills as possible for the lance