r/soccer • u/mrnovember22 • Jul 27 '13
What rule would you change in the game?
Personally, i think the clock should be stopped for injuries, goals and substitutions. The inconsitancies with time added on really annoys me. Especially when we are into added on time and a team makes a substitution and thats not taken into account. I also think the game should be over as soon as the ball goes out of play after the 90 minutes (like rugby).
28
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
The player that is fouled has to take the penalty.
124
u/Fionnland Jul 27 '13
Retroactive diving/simulation bans actually enforced.
30
u/Gaucheist Jul 27 '13
Something something goalies allowed to punch the ball in the opponents box.
62
u/Spisild Jul 27 '13
The only rule I think should be changed is that additional substitutions should be allowed in the case of extra time.
I seem to recall that they have already talked about this, though.
103
u/thugmonkey Jul 27 '13
No back chat to the ref, also like rugby.
29
u/JackGunner93 Jul 27 '13
No yellow card for taking off your shirt (unless there is a provocative slogan underneath) or running into the crowd. Absolutely ridiculous that these warrant punishment.
73
u/Yurilovescats Jul 27 '13
Replace extra time with Hammertime.
12
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
Mick McCarthy and Ian Holloway were both fined for not fielding their "strongest XI". That's bullshit and they should be able to pick whoever they like.
18
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
I think the time "inconsistencies" are pretty ingrained in the game at this point, and I honestly appreciate them. Sure, you pretty much have no idea when the match is over (no chances for "buzzer-beaters") but I think it adds a certain level of suspense and urgency in close games. Arsenal V. Reading comes to mind from last year, really made for a great game (depending on who you support.)
27
u/hazemmad Jul 27 '13
Goal-line technology!!
35
u/caksu Jul 27 '13
Away goal rule.
17
u/harps86 Jul 27 '13
I don't think the goalkeeper should be involved in the offside rule. If he decides to go off galavanting that's his prerogative. The rule should just be an attacking player can not be ahead of the last outfield player rather than second to last player of that team.
9
u/DynamicInABox Jul 27 '13
Players can only hit the ball with their heads, and at least one hand must be kept on the ground at all times. Also goal line technology.
6
u/bonoboboy Jul 27 '13
This question has been asked a few times before, and the answers don't vary much:
http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/swxrk/if_you_could_change_one_rule_in_football_what/
http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/181q3c/whats_one_rule_change_that_you_think_shouldve/
http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/19n2vr/if_you_could_change_one_rule_of_soccer_then_what/
http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/xvn72/if_you_could_change_one_thing_about_football_what/
http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/nzxos/if_you_could_what_rule_changes_would_you_make_to/
http://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/12i10a/if_you_could_change_or_add_one_rule_in_soccer/
Almost all of it is stuff about diving/berating the ref.
14
u/no-longer-inadequate Jul 27 '13
Automatic lifetime ban for racism, just like fans.
4
u/fuckingFILA Jul 27 '13
Why would you wan't to change an already perfect game?
4
u/trademark25 Jul 27 '13
A goalkeeper cannot bring the ball inside his 18-yard box with his feet and pick it up.
2
u/baronboy Jul 27 '13
No away goals rule for extra time
3
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
Not mine but my dad has this idea that making football 9 on 9 would make it much more exciting. He argues that because players have gotten so much bigger and more mobile their is the appearance of less space than in the past. This is particularly apparent in the epl when a player is crowded almost immediately after receiving the ball (unlike la liga, serie a or the bundesliga where a bit more space is afforded). Probably would never happen but I think it might make for more exciting matches, and of course squad rotation would be more necessary as well.
3
u/mesor Jul 27 '13
Ban all clubs named "AC Milan"
2
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
I'd like to modify, not eliminate, the away goal rule. In extra time of the second leg, I feel that the away goal should become null and void. It's not entirely fair that the away team gets 30 extra minutes with the away goal rule on their side.
While it would be poor luck for the team that drew the second leg away, it shouldn't make a monster difference if the two teams couldn't separate themselves after 180 minutes of football.
2
u/SweetClydeDixon Jul 27 '13
No subs in the last 5 minutes of the game. It gets on my nerves a little watching the exciting, dying moments of a match being broken up by substitutes.
2
u/raggisnoora Jul 27 '13
In a knockout matches: Penalty shootout before extra time. (the shootout only matters if there is a draw in extra time).
Instead of having two teams hoping for a draw (which will happen most of the time because most teams will always favor them selves in penalties) you will have at least one team that wants/has to win it.
2
u/1mdelightful Jul 27 '13
Play should not stop for injuries. Let the meds come on and play around them.
2
u/Sslagathor Jul 27 '13 edited Jul 27 '13
If a team has already used all 3 subs, and one of their players gets injured and has to go off, they should be given a 4th sub. Maybe also give the other team a 4th sub if that makes it even.
Edit: I didn't think about players faking injuries, I see how that would be a problem.
1
u/manchester23 Jul 27 '13
I like the fact that goal line technology is being introduced but what I think should happen is that If a goal is a close call then whoever reviews it, reviews it while the game is still continued and then announce it amidst play. One perk about soccer is there is more action and not someone stoppages like in American football.
1
u/kabyle1993 Jul 27 '13
I would honestly push for off side to only count the legs. I think it's a little silly how the chest is out and they'll call offside...
Also, I get why defenders do this.. but shielding the ball till it goes out or bringing it to the corner flag. I think technically shouldn't be allowed. You're not playing the ball.. you're playing the man. While i'm glad when my team does that to ensure a result. I think if they remove that then we'll see a lot more exciting end to games. or at least force teams to play possession football at the end.
1
u/LusoAustralian Jul 27 '13
Maintain the 3 substitution rule but allow each team one extra sub to only be used for goalkeepers. This would be helpful in the case of injuries and the like and could potentially lead to interesting situations.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '13
Introduction of a golden snitch
1
u/dirtyfarts Jul 28 '13
The right to revoke 1 yellow card per game. So if a yellow card is given to a player due to bad call or because they made a mistake, you can revoke it. Less suspensions and especially form when a player to many yellow cards in a tournament they might missntye final of a big game like then world cup or champions league.
1
u/lookitsaidan Jul 28 '13
I think that players should be able to challenge a call like in tennis and then have the play looked at by officials if they think a call is wrong.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '13
ITT: Not really changing rules, and horrible, horrible ideas
1
u/TCBear Jul 28 '13
During extra time they add another ball
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '13
Going by this thread, I would ban reddit users from making rules.
1
u/wildster Jul 27 '13
35 yards run at goal rather than penalty kicks.
-10
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
Goals made after 20+ consecutive passes should count as double. hehe
1
u/PeterLockeWiggin Jul 27 '13
Add a second center ref like they did in hockey a couple years back.
1
u/Jose_Monteverde Jul 27 '13
It's about damn time we start using technology on the field. No more need for "controversial" calls about being offside, EVER
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
The no biting rule...
0
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
Restructure the extra time format to reduce penalty shootouts.
Maybe three or four ten-minute periods of extra time: the first at full strength, but if the game is still tied and a second is needed, both teams must remove a player from the field. They must remove another player before the third if the third is needed, and another player before the fourth and final period.
Basically, this creates a lot more open space and makes goals more likely. But after that, you would go to penalties, because you have played 130 minutes of football and you need this game to be over.
-2
u/TheCruise Jul 27 '13
Golden goal instead of penalties.
0
u/droreddit Jul 27 '13
Referees are supposed to add 30 seconds for every substitution made and they keep track of time during injuries as well.
0
u/ChaosRaiden Jul 27 '13
Should be able to challenge decisions like in cricket and Tennis.
0
u/scotbro Jul 27 '13
I would like to see less red cards in situations where a penalty kick has already been awarded. A penalty against your team is sufficient punishment. Situations where a team concedes a penalty and have a player sent off are too severe and ruin the match.
-2
u/SirTommyHimself Jul 27 '13
I understand this could be controversial, but replacing penalty shootouts would be quite a dashing idea. May I suggest the ice hockey way if doing it, a one on one situation with the keeper starting from maybe the half way line?
-9
u/jetpacksforall Jul 27 '13
Why don't they just stop the clock? That way fans would actually know when the match will end. Added time is confusing and arcane, yet has exactly the same end result as stopping the game clock would have.
Failing that change, at the very least they should have added time clearly and precisely indicated on the scoreboard / onscreen graphics.
0
u/Joga-o_o-Bonito Jul 27 '13
I think if you think someone has gone down easily then it should be a card. Even if there is contact. If you run into someones foot and fall how is that a fucking foul.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
Close the summer transfer window two weeks before the start of the season.
Add a video referee who watches a bank of screens in real time. During stoppages in play he can review and replay incidents. He can radio to the referee on the pitch. Sometimes a foul or dive that the referee missed is plainly obvious to those of us watching on TV so there's no need for special replay stoppages or appeals.
Cap transfer and wage budgets and redistribute transfer revenue to poorer clubs along with giving each club an equal share of league revenue rather than giving more money to already successful clubs. This should encourage league parity and hold transfer inflation in check.
For countries hoping to host a World Cup, impose a set of human rights requirements. Set aside all proceeds from the World Cup for humanitarian assistance.
Set minimum standards of care for head injuries, including a concussion test by neutral medical staff. If a player is concussed, give the team a mandatory extra substitution to replace him. I remember an incident with Gerard Piqué not long ago where he was sent back on after clearly suffering a concussion. While he was removed not long after, it's unacceptable that he wasn't immediately replaced. If one of the richest clubs in the world can't get this right, the governing authorities need to intervene.
0
u/cvillano Jul 27 '13
Ban sugar daddies
0
u/Jackson9Martinez Jul 27 '13
Red cards can't be given for any sort of foul,make it more of a harsh men's game.
0
u/ishouldbeworking69 Jul 28 '13
Abolish FIFA and UEFA
0
u/leagueoffifa Jul 28 '13
the red card. send him off for the rest of the game. dont give him match bans unless he bites people
-7
u/cheftlp1221 Jul 27 '13
The Offsides Rule.
A player would be onsides if any of the their body is level with the last defender. If their trailing foot is even, onsides. An hand, onsides. their ponytail, onsides.
It should make the the Asst. Referee's job easier.
-5
u/Thunderkiss_65 Jul 27 '13
Every week. Oh I think even though the games aren't remotely similar we should adopt rugby's rules and run the players into the ground.
I'd like to go back to old offside rules, that if you're on the pitch you're interfering with the game. It at least gives the lino a chance.
I'm also for calling them linesmen again.
-3
u/IAmAQuantumMechanic Jul 27 '13
In extra time, one player should be taken off from each team every five minutes until one team scores. This will eliminate the penalty shootout.
-14
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '13
At the beginning of each season, all teams are required to offer their best midfielder to Manchester United for the price of "on the house."
-4
u/kiliclimber Jul 27 '13
Every goal should be reviewed. If someone scores, they should check with a ref with a monitor to make sure the ball went over the line, that it wasn't offside etc
-1
u/reekdurden Jul 27 '13
Sometimes I wonder what games would look like if there was no offsides. I understand why the rule exists and agree with it but still would be curious to watch certain games & match ups play out.