r/soccer • u/Benjips • Sep 08 '13
Change My View /r/soccer Thread - for people who have an opinion on something but accept that they may be wrong or want help changing their view
Basically as the thread says, you have an opinion which you hold as correct but may be in the wrong, present that opinion and see if anyone changes your mind.
Here are the rules:
- Explain why you hold your view, not just what that view is
- Direct responses to a CMV (Chnage My View) post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s current view (however minor), unless they are asking a clarifying question.
- You must include an explanation of how your view has changed any time you award a delta (∆) - just copy and paste it
Simple, present your view, have someone refute it, agree or disagree, see if your opinion is different now.
86
Upvotes
81
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
La Liga is a two-team league. I hold this view because the league has been won by Barcelona or Real Madrid since 2004 and I just don't see it changing any time soon. CMV.
35
u/petnarwhal Sep 08 '13
Ribery is individually, not a top 10 player. I know he is a good team player, won the treble this year, and is a good player individually. But I think he is not top ten, He is no Iniesta, Xavi, , Ozil, RvP, Zlatan or even Lahm in terms of actions and impact importance on a match. Can somebody convince me otherwise?
13
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
I was going to post something different, but seeing the post scores in this thread brings a more pressing point to mind.
I don't know what proportion of these people ever comment, but personally I don't think many can as I haven't seen too many that look like someone left a vibrating dildo on their keyboard. However, based on the amount of downvotes in this thread (of all threads), I think there must be a significant percentage of subscribers in this subreddit that are incapable of having an adult discussion.
There are people who hold irrational opinions, but that's fine, it's to be expected in sports discussions. However, the amount of people downvoting and not having the bollocks to reply when the post in question is clearly a valid addition to the thread is a complete farce.
I guess a CMV for this is kind of pointless though, because the shiftless arseholes in question will downvote and run off.
112
u/aykau777 Sep 08 '13
I think Chcharito should leave Man U to become a starting player. Not a sub.
66
u/AliceinHangeland Sep 09 '13
I think this sub need more Fulham fans, we gave Brian McBride, Carlos Bocanegra and Dempsey a chance you ungrateful gits. Even Hangeland was born in Texas.
61
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
Gareth Bale should not cost more than 40 mil. CMV
93
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
Kyle Walker will never succeed as an international footballer as he has a horrific first touch and only does well due to his pace. His complete lack of tactical nous covered by his acceleration.
67
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
Football is a business. Large clubs are no different to international brands in any other walk of life. The biggest clubs are no different to soft drinks, no different to fast food. This clique of teams are actively trying to remove the element of competition to remove personal risk to profit. The modern fan is complicit, and entirely happy for this to happen. Smaller clubs going under are no concern of the modern fan (except for faux outrage), they hedonistically want to be entertained at any cost. The traditional relationship of community and football is becoming nonexistent. We are quickly moving to a setup like Formula One where a few teams will endlessly rotate, the spectacle will take place on your TV. Passion will be drained, excitement gone, meanwhile spectators will argue the minutiae of
tyre temperatureshawk-eye offside calls, distracted from the loss of unpredictability. The loss of risk. The loss of real sport. We won't realise what we had until it is gone.25
u/modano_star Sep 08 '13
Defending is kind of glossed over in modern-day football. Big teams look to attacking players as their marquee signings (very few exceptions) , and kind of wing it defensively. I used to enjoy some of the defensive partnerships at centre-back, but now no-one really gives much of a shit. As much as he moaned, I will miss some of Alan Hansen's defensive analysis because it was kind of interesting.
46
u/TheMuthaFlippin Sep 08 '13
England cannot possibly produce a top quality international team within the next few decades, as that would require a complete change in footballing culture that couldn't possibly be implemented sooner.
10
u/afcmitchell Sep 09 '13
I do not think the Netherlands will be of any international importance for at least 10 years.
103
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
The US is not a top 20 or maybe even 30 team. They have a few average players and one or two above average or good players. they are a growing nation in football, I'll give them that
75
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
/r/soccer is substantially less informed and worse off without /u/devineman.
24
u/dylansavage Sep 09 '13
The unfair label that Arsenal don't like to be kicked by the media has caused 5 broken legs in 6 years and have destroyed 2 promising careers. It is a miracle that Ramsey has managed to overcome his injury.
40
u/dem503 Sep 08 '13
Spurs are in danger of slipping into a pattern of "we'll gel the team this year and really go for it next season" as they are constantly letting their best player go and having to replace him.
31
u/HeeyMaan Sep 09 '13
I have a hard time accepting that fans that don't live near their favourite team are as passionate as local fans (don't kill me for it, it's just my opinion).
This is because I've seen some international fans saying some ludicrous things amongst which are: 'I wouldn't mind if Liverpool and Everton share a stadium' (Liverpool fan) 'I have a soft spot for Tottenham ' (Arsenal fan)
You'd never hear a local say any of that. So I just want to hear what supporting your club means to international fans, if it's more than just a casual interest.
17
u/flaffl Sep 09 '13
I think this subreddit has an incredibly poor infrastructure, especially when comparing it to other sports subreddits. The quality of posts requires a higher standard, as well as the comments. Especially the comments. I don't see why there isn't some sort of a reminder on downvotes. Far too often I see downvotes for people stating legitimately based, yet unpopular opinions throughout this subreddit and it's starting to annoy me, and I'm sure I'm not the only one that feels this way.
6
u/jnhagood Sep 09 '13
If barca was in the Premier league they would not win it. They are not durable enough to withstand the physicality of it week in week out. Most premier league teams have to be able to rotate players at every position to deal with injuries and change tactics but barca doesn't have the kind of depth needed to rotate their big players like messi and iniesta. One of those two would get injured and the wheels would come off the hinges and they would finish in 3rd or 4th
25
u/DY12 Sep 08 '13
Graeme Souness is a cunt.
5
u/Ronaldinhoac11 Sep 09 '13
I think that the away goal rule should be removed from the knockout stages of the Champions League. I feel that it's not fair and it favors one team over another when the actual aggregate score is tied. If the aggregate score is tied, teams should either play extra time then PKs OR if they are too concerned about tiredness, injuries, and their next league game then they can go straight to PKs.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
I don't think saying Ronaldo is 1b to Messi's 1a is a fair comparison. I think Messi is legitimately the best player in the world and it isn't debatable. I base my conclusion on just of what I have I seen ( and I watched them play a lot) and not on stats but if we were to go solely by stats even then Messi has come out on top for the past 4 years in most categories.
4
u/milksteaklover Sep 09 '13
Scrolled through entire page... saw no ∆s
12
u/BDX_LAW Sep 09 '13
Barcelona are boring as fuck to watch.
8
u/natekronos Sep 09 '13
I don't think that just because Arsenal brought in Özil, they suddenly are guarenteed a finish in the top 4. Their biggest problem right now isn't the lack of quality. They have that in players like Walcott and Cazorla. What they need is more depth, which is the reason why people were complaining about in the first place.
13
u/TheRoyalTenenThom Sep 09 '13
I think that if Messi was on Manchester City or Chelsea, and Ronaldo was back at United, that Ronaldo would be considered the better player by almost everyone and would win the Ballon d'Or year-in year-out.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13
Samir Nasri is not the playmaker people think he is. He has good ball control and is a "safe" player, but is too slow and lacks the creativity to actually impose himself on decent competition. Arsenal and City fans, convince me otherwise. Videos might help.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
I think what Man United is doing to Kagawa is wrong. He's a great player and does not deserve to sit on the bench.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13
1 - The Brasileirão is the best and most competitive league behind the spanish, english, german and italian leagues. It is also one with the most equal playing level (no 2-horse race)
2 - World Cup wins at home shouldn't count.
8
u/georgedc Sep 09 '13
England are still one of the best national teams in the world and have been very unlucky in many major tournaments.
7
u/fast_lloris Sep 08 '13
England aren't very good but they're definitely better than the US.
Defoe should be subbed on for England in 90% of games still.
CMV
6
u/tadm123 Sep 08 '13
Thiago Alcantara will fail at Bayern Munich. He's too inconsistent to be a starter.
4
u/Footstepz Sep 08 '13
Explain to me why Dirk Kuyts 'work ethic' is so 'good'.
3
u/CapitalG Sep 09 '13
Salary caps would make football better.
8
u/PapaQuiff Sep 08 '13
I believe Liverpool are more likely than Arsenal and Tottenham to achieve top 4 this season. I believe this as last season Liverpool were one of the top scoring teams in Europe in their respective leagues. They have added to their squad in all the right areas, a squad who already is showing to have already gelled and shown great chemistry. We have been able to show that we can grind out results which is what we lacked last season. We also have fewer matches than both Arsenal and Spurs which in the long run could help us. Come November when we play Arsenal we will be able to tell just how bright this season will be for us depending on the result.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
In a few years there will only be about 10 really relevant teams in Europe and they will kill the soul of football by creating a Super League between them. It's already starting to happen, as you can see in most leagues. At least it seems unlikely that it will happen in South America...
And I think the only way to save football is implementing the following rule: no team can be owned by a single individual at all, specially not oil sheiks or criminals.
2
u/twertyou Sep 09 '13
The UEFA Champions League is the most prestigious tournament in the world
2
u/Magical_Sarcastic Sep 08 '13
I like Adrian Chiles on ITV's football coverage. He has a good sense of humour and doesn't take things too seriously.
2
u/navinho Sep 09 '13
Football fans are morally bankrupt apologists, ready to accept and defend players for racist abuse or dubiously wealthy billionaire owners, simply because they are part of a certain club.
2
u/SkyFoo Sep 09 '13
Vidal will be the best player in the world, or top 3 in a couple of years time
1
u/McBricks Sep 09 '13
FC Augsburg will not have to fear relegation this season, because Daniel Baier is an excellent defensive midfielder/deep lying playmaker; and Weinzierl is a great manager, who introduced a Bayern like 4-1-4-1 last season with Baier in that key DM position. It took the first half of the season until the new formation was established. Augsburg (German first half - second half tables) only had 9 (!) points. The twenty four points in the second half prevented them from being relegated.
This season, they dominated in their loss against Bremen basically the whole game and Bremen created not a single real chance and scored from a half chance. If they had had somebody able to convert up front they would have won easily.
The Dortmund result (0-4) looks much worse than the game actually was. Augsburg created just as many chances from open play as Dortmund. They stand at 6 points from four games, now.
Augsburg was really lacking a striker, since Mölders is unable to convert even after having beaten the goalie. He is midtable second Bundesliga material. Bobadilla and especially Milik are exactly what Augsburg needed (both are injured though).
tl;dr: Augsburg will be the "surprise" team of this Bundesliga season, possibly even able to finish in europa league territory.
1
u/j3zuz911 Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
On paper England had the best player pool in the world in 2006. They should have won the 2006 world cup.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13
I think there are still lingering xenophobic in the premiership that come out in youth development, treatment of foreign players, and playing style of the English national team. This xenophobia is hindering England's chances of being a successful national team. CMV
edit. grammar is hard
1
u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
EDIT: I have a 3rd one
-5
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13
If you do not go to football games then your opinion is worth less than people who do.
0
u/Breklinho Sep 08 '13
Well I have two...
-2
u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Sep 08 '13
The only people who think Ronaldo is better than Messi don't watch either of them play regularly.
Suarez is nowhere near being a world class player. He rarely shows up against top class opposition and would have been a complete flop at Real Madrid had he gone.