r/soccer • • Sep 08 '13

Change My View /r/soccer Thread - for people who have an opinion on something but accept that they may be wrong or want help changing their view

Basically as the thread says, you have an opinion which you hold as correct but may be in the wrong, present that opinion and see if anyone changes your mind.

Here are the rules:

  1. Explain why you hold your view, not just what that view is
  2. Direct responses to a CMV (Chnage My View) post must challenge at least one aspect of OP’s current view (however minor), unless they are asking a clarifying question.
  3. You must include an explanation of how your view has changed any time you award a delta (∆) - just copy and paste it

Simple, present your view, have someone refute it, agree or disagree, see if your opinion is different now.

86 Upvotes

717 comments sorted by

81

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

La Liga is a two-team league. I hold this view because the league has been won by Barcelona or Real Madrid since 2004 and I just don't see it changing any time soon. CMV.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

All I can say is that if Barca and Madrid were in italy or EPL they would make them 2-team leagues as well.

20

u/Benjips Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

You are forgetting that Manchester United, Manchester City, Chelsea, AC Milan, and Juventus are in those leagues. There is no way Real Madrid and Barcelona would make those 2-team leagues.

7

u/fleckes Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

I think for the comparison to work you'd have to switch the best two English or Italian sides with Batcelona and Madrid. Because I don't think it'd be fair to claim that the best two Spanish sides wouldn't be able to do as well vs. the best EPL sides as they do vs. the La Liga sides that aren't the top 2 teams of the league

So that would mean put Barcelona and Madrid in a league with Chelsea, Arsenal, Tottenham

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

17

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

I'm not sure whether this is a view or a fact.. I wonder if anyone disagrees.

57

u/Bunny_Killer Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 08 '13

From 2004 to 2012 Chelsea and Manchester United were the only winners of the Premier League and no one called it a league between two teams. And from 1996 to 2012 only 3 teams won the league in England. 4 different teams have won the "most competitive league in the world" since 1996 to 2013.

5 different teams have won La Liga since 1996. Since 2004 2 teams have won La Liga which is one year more than the 8 years in which two teams kept winning the EPL. Real Madrid and Barcelona have been power houses in the last 3-4 years, more so than Chelsea and Manchester United in recent times, and they make it look like the rest of the La Liga teams are hopeless because they are just so good. Real Madrid and Barcelona set the all time highest amount of points in their league these past two seasons with 100 points and have been a huge threat in Europe consistently.

If Chelsea and Manchester United were replaced with Real Madrid and Barcelona the gap between them and the rest of the league would probably be as big as it is in La Liga. It's unfair to call La Liga a two team league because the two teams at the top are playing some of their best in their history.

111

u/commentin Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 08 '13

From 2002 to 2012 don't forget the Invincibles, Chelsea and Manchester United were the only winners of the Premier League and no one called it a league between two teams because 5 different teams have held the top two spots during that time period. And from 1996 to 2012 only 3 teams won the league in England. 4 different teams have won the "most competitive league in the world" since 1996 to today. that's cutting off to include Atletico in 1996 but ignoring Blackburn in 1995

5 different teams have won La Liga since 1996. Since 2004 2 teams have won La Liga which is still less than the 10 years actually 8 years, 7 titles. Arsenal in 2003-2004 to Manchester City in 2011-2012 in which two teams kept winning the EPL. Real Madrid and Barcelona have been power houses in the last 3-4 years, 9 years. Valencia last won the league in 2004. The only time Barcelona or Real Madrid were displaced from 1st and 2nd during that time period was Villareal taking 2nd in 2007. Manchester United and Chelsea have been displaced from 1st or 2nd 5 times since 2003. Real Madrid and Barcelona 1 time more so than Chelsea and Manchester United, and they make it look like the rest of the La Liga teams are hopeless because they are just so good. Real Madrid and Barcelona set the all time highest amount of points in their league these past two seasons with 100 points and have been a huge threat in Europe consistently.

If Chelsea and Manchester United were replaced with Real Madrid and Barcelona the gap between them and the rest of the league would probably be as big as it is in La Liga. It's unfair to call La Liga a two team league because the two teams at the top are playing some of their best in their history.

But Chelsea and Manchester United haven't always been historically dominant. Barcelona and Real Madrid have. Between 1985 and 1995, Real Madrid or Barcelona won the league every time. Between 1952 and 1965, Barcelona or Real Madrid won the league 12/13 times. These bubbles of Real Madrid and Barcelona dominance are only pierced occasionally. The last time that Real Madrid or Barcelona weren't in the top 3 was 1970. The last time that Manchester United or Chelsea weren't in the top 3 was 1990. And that is only attributable to a Sir Alex Ferguson, the best manager of all time.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/JamesTreddit Sep 08 '13

From 2002 to 2012 Chelsea and Manchester United were the only winners of the premier league

You're forgetting the 2003-2004 season.

13

u/chezygo Sep 09 '13

And forgetting 2011-12.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

What does 1996 have to do with the current state of the league? Why stop there anyway? Why not 2000? 1992? Plus your figures are wrong which doesn't help your case. Arsenal won the league in 2004 and Man City won it in 2012. So Chelsea and United won the league between them from 2005 to 2011 inclusive, that's 7 years, not 10. This season, there's literally six teams in the PL that could win the league. Obviously Spurs, Arsenal, and Liverpool aren't in as strong a position as Chelsea, City, and United but they have an infinitely better chance of winning their league than Atletico, Valencia etc.

It's unfair to call La Liga a two team league because the two teams at the top are playing some of their best in their history.

What kind of bullshit reasoning is this? The only thing that's unfair here is the messed up TV deal that allows Barca and Madrid to spend a lot more money than their competitors, especially with FFP. Without that TV money, they wouldn't be as dominant as they are now and the league wouldn't be such a blatant two-horse race.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/RedScouse Sep 08 '13

In those 8 years, there were other teams that made a run for the title and had a realistic chance of winning it. Whereas this phenomenon in La Liga is increasingly less prevalent. Winners of a particular league don't necessarily reflect the competitiveness of a league, the competitiveness is reflected in a realistic chance of winning/possible title challenges made by a multitude of teams.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

There reality isn't quite so black and white. It just depends what you mean by a two-team league.

Real Madrid and Barça will always be contenders, and they'll win most seasons; but to think that the difference between the big two and everyone else will always be >20 points is very narrow minded. Ten years ago Madrid outspent every team in the league and they still won fuck all.

It doesn't matter how much money Madrid and Barça have, they won't players like Messi and Ronaldo in a long time. You can't underestimate the effect of having a player who get you 40 goals a season.

Replace Ronaldo or Messi with a good striker who gets you 20 goals a season and all of a sudden it all becomes more interesting. The two would still be favourites, but they'd get a lot more draws and losses. Atlético would look like scary contenders. Random teams would too, Sevilla had a very real chance of winning in 2007.

This Barça team has been the best one of the best teams in the history of the game and Madrid wasn't far behind. If in 5 years no other team has had any chance of winning the league whatsoever then maybe you can call it a two-team league, but to draw long term conclusions from a 5 year period is naive.

5

u/figocosta9 Sep 09 '13

I think this is what people miss very often. Yes, there are problems within La Liga in terms of the distribution of money from the television deals and other factors. However, this Madrid and Barcelona being all dominating idea has only really been happening since the 2009-2010 season, I would say. That's exactly when Messi and Ronaldo started to blow up. There's no way it will last forever. Messi and Ronaldo, the latter probably sooner, will start to decline and I think La Liga will start to go back to closer finishes. Certainly, no more of this 20-25 point gap between 2nd and 3rd business.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/petnarwhal Sep 08 '13

Ribery is individually, not a top 10 player. I know he is a good team player, won the treble this year, and is a good player individually. But I think he is not top ten, He is no Iniesta, Xavi, , Ozil, RvP, Zlatan or even Lahm in terms of actions and impact importance on a match. Can somebody convince me otherwise?

4

u/elbecko85 Sep 09 '13

Your point makes no sense at all: you can't compare a left winger to central midfielders, forwards and so on...

You can compare him to other left wingers. And, in my opinion, currently, he is the best left winger there is. Before you hit the downvote button, hear me out: He doesn't score as many goals as Ronaldo, and he doesn't score the big ones like Bale (if you consider winning goals in a regular EPL match as extremely important). But, nonetheless, Ribery is the key to Bayern's success. Sure, they've got an amazing line up and their depth is incredible. But in the last couple of years, opponents only had a real chance of winning against Bayern when they took Ribery out of the game.

If opponents park the bus against Bayern, which happens a lot in the last couple of months, they rely on Ribery (in collaboration with Alaba) to create something extraordinary. Bayern's build-up play is really nothing special if it wasn't for Ribery. 9/10 attacks go something like this: Boateng to Schweinsteiger who one-twos with the CAM (Götze, Shaq, Kroos, Müller) , plays it out to the left wing, Ribery one-twos with Alaba or vice versa, until Ribery has the ball on the corner of the box.

And, unfortunately for the opponents, you never know what is going to happen at that point. Unlike Robben on the other side of the pitch, Ribery is unpredictable. He will make full use of his options throughout the game.

And if someone feels the need to bring up statistics (but he doesn't give as much assists as XY): Ribery very often plays the "final" pass, so that the receiving player only has to cross it in front of the keeper to Mandzukic/Pizzaro/Müller who only need to hit the open goal from a couple of feet distance.

Without Ribery, Bayern is only half as good. Their success last year heavily relied on Ribery's fitness. Unlike previous seasons he wasn't injured for a longer period and didn't miss any crucial games.

Ribery's only weakness is, that he seems to be really easy to anger. He is always in for a red, if his marker annoys him enough.

15

u/river49 Sep 09 '13

He is definitely a top 10 player. When looking back at last year's treble, Ribery contributed so much to Bayern and was clearly our best player, but is not a spotlight player so some of his work goes unnoticed. Last years CL final is an excellent example of this. On Bayern's first goal Ribery gets the ball on the edge of the box and attracted all 3 defenders near him as well as all the defenders' eyes, only to pass to a wide open Robben who crossed it in for Mandzukic http://i.minus.com/i1mpUi1jFzVjm.gif For Bayern's second goal it was Ribery who brought down the lob and flick a little backheel through to Robben, who was once again open due to Dortmund's focus on Ribery http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2VdAuMsldus

4

u/postdaemon Sep 09 '13

I agree to a certain extent. The fact that he is surrounded by so much talent at Bayern Munich makes him seem better than he really is, though he is still excellent. Replace him with another quality left winger and Bayern would hardly be a worse team for it. Compare that to other top 10 players, who are very hard to replace or irreplaceable in some cases (e.g. Messi, Ronaldo, Iniesta).

→ More replies (14)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

I was going to post something different, but seeing the post scores in this thread brings a more pressing point to mind.

I don't know what proportion of these people ever comment, but personally I don't think many can as I haven't seen too many that look like someone left a vibrating dildo on their keyboard. However, based on the amount of downvotes in this thread (of all threads), I think there must be a significant percentage of subscribers in this subreddit that are incapable of having an adult discussion.

There are people who hold irrational opinions, but that's fine, it's to be expected in sports discussions. However, the amount of people downvoting and not having the bollocks to reply when the post in question is clearly a valid addition to the thread is a complete farce.

I guess a CMV for this is kind of pointless though, because the shiftless arseholes in question will downvote and run off.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Everyone should just stop staring themselves blind at the votes. Turn them off using CSS or something (of course not sub-wide, you can do this easily on your own). Votes mean nothing and anyone with a serious interest in this subreddit knows it. The person with the most downvotes hasn't automatically proven the other party wrong. The person with many more upvotes does not have an automatically amazing /r/bestof type of comment and certainly hasn't trumped his opposition in the debate.

We all get our voices heard and one's opinion is not always the most popular or correct, but people will vote however the fuck they bloody like. That's the truth. No rule will stop that.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Actually, in any thread that generates a lot of comments, it does matter. The downvoted ones will be at the bottom and a lot of people will only read the first couple of parent comments before leaving the thread.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

But then that's their loss, isn't it? They choose not to get the whole picture and hey, I'm not one to judge, I do that myself sometimes. But these upvotes and downvotes have little to no significance when it comes to the debate itself. Consider them applause from the audience at best. Consider them dickriders/haters at worst.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Benjips Sep 09 '13

I had high hopes creating this thread as traditional CMV threads are rich in discussion and provide a great way to discover new points and counterpoints. Football is very much a discussion based sport so I thought it natural to make a CMV thread. I was hoping the inflexible opinions of those here would be challenged in a positive way but again, as a majority of the time, for a lot of submissions on this post, there have been a lot of jokes, downvotes, and no one has been awarded a delta. Those few quality discussions on here, though, have been worth it, I think.

3

u/georgedc Sep 09 '13

No one has downvoted you... yet.

112

u/aykau777 Sep 08 '13

I think Chcharito should leave Man U to become a starting player. Not a sub.

53

u/thisisntmyworld Sep 08 '13

He gets paid well by one of the best clubs in the world, is respected by his the fans of his club and management and his fast paced style suits being a pinchhitter very well. In fact bringing him on after the central backs are tired is probably the best tactic involving him. I don't think a club of the same calibre is interested in signing him as a first team player.

31

u/aykau777 Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
  • He gets paid around 5 million dollars a year in the EPL. Honestly he could make more money in Mexico. Ecuatorian striker Chucho Benitez made 11 2.7 millions a year in my Club FC America. Mexican add agencies pay Chicharo 1 million per advertisement. For chicharo money is not an issue. Almost all Mexican teams are own by billionares. Mexicans are not in Europe to make money they go for the competition.
  • It's a waste of talent to be a super sub and not a starter.
  • I agree, I don't think a club of the same calibre is interested in signing him. But teams like Atletico de Madrid and Valencia are big clubs in La liga and they play the Champions regularly.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

Honestly he could make more money in Mexico. Ecuatorian striker Chucho Benitez made 11 millions a year in my Club FC America.

That was what America paid to Santos for the transfer.

His salary was 2.7 million a year. No one in the Mexican league earns near 5 million, closest one is Suazo with 3.

Source

→ More replies (4)

10

u/HyperionCantos Sep 09 '13

Consider that the reason advertisement agencies are paying him so much is because he plays for Man Utd

7

u/fire_friendly Sep 09 '13

I don't think the average soccer fan in Mexico is watching too many Manchester United games. I think he's mostly famous for his appearances in the national team. It definitely adds to his fame that he plays for MUFC but if he played for any reasonably famous club in Europe he would still be respected.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ziggaroll Sep 09 '13

On your first point, it is worth noting that Chicharito comes from a very well off family as well. Money would not be an issue for Chich even if he was not a footballer.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

What is the best team he could be a starting player for, in your opinion?

9

u/aykau777 Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 08 '13

7

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

So are those the clubs interested or the ones you think are the best he could start for?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/badgarok725 Sep 08 '13

Look at it from his point of view though, you have the points that /u/thisisntmyworld made plus the fact that he's playing for a team that perennially competes for the league title and gets far into the CL. Valencia can't say the same. So he could start a few games alongside some of the best in the world and win trophies or play for a team that competes to get a CL spot

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

2

u/thecavernrocks Sep 09 '13

Ever consider what he wants? A lot of people are projecting their own desires onto him. Whereas he has never complained and said he actually likes being a super sub. Solskjaer was the same, in that he actually enjoyed it.

What if he became a starter somewhere, and started scoring far fewer goals because his pace wouldn't be as much of an issue, and he didn't have the chance to watch from the side reading defenders movements before coming on and exploiting them? Then maybe he'd fall out of favor because he isn't scoring enough, and then in the end would play even fewer minutes? As it is, he scores a lot, gets to be the hero very often, plays with a higher caliber of players, earns more money, has more fame, and has a better reputation as a player. He might lose all of that if he started more often.

→ More replies (2)

66

u/AliceinHangeland Sep 09 '13

I think this sub need more Fulham fans, we gave Brian McBride, Carlos Bocanegra and Dempsey a chance you ungrateful gits. Even Hangeland was born in Texas.

53

u/mthrfkn Sep 09 '13

Nobody hates Fulham though, they're kind of cute.

I mean you all play near a cottage, aww :3

8

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

also that michael jackson statue which has now become a running joke

3

u/Zebulon_V Sep 09 '13

Whenever I tell someone I'm a Fulham fan their reaction is always along the line of "Well that's random." For a guy from Virginia living in North Carolina whose only connection to England is his tv, it's not any more random than being a United or Chelsea fan. I usually explain the Fulham- America connection, but people still seem to think it's silly that I would support a team that's not likely to finish top 5 or that they haven't heard of. Whatever, COYW!

5

u/Ahesterd Sep 09 '13

we gave Brian McBride ... a chance

Hey, so did we!

Well after he was old.

2

u/Devilb0y Sep 09 '13

I live twenty minutes away from the Cottage and always look out for Fulham. Plus you have Berba.

You guys are alright!

2

u/elquiche Sep 09 '13

Yeah, and we're like... the nicest club in the world. Only Premier League team to have a neutral stand.

61

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Gareth Bale should not cost more than 40 mil. CMV

15

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

That's assuming a player's transfer fee should only be based on ability. You gotta take into account market conditions, supply and demand. Do Spurs want to sell? Do they need to sell? How desperate are RM on buying Bale? What is the price that players of similar ability are going for these days? What is the potential value of image rights RM can get from Bale's purchase over the next 5 years?

There are tons and tons of factors that come into play when clubs decide on a transfer fee they demand/ are willing to pay. In Bale's case Perez clearly thought he was worth 100m(?) and that's all that matters.

22

u/SlappyBagg Sep 08 '13

Versatility, Marketability, Potential to go with already world class ability.

21

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Sep 09 '13

Marketability? The only reason i can think of is solely his tag "most expensive transaction ever". He was in some news here and there but wasn't a world wide market monster.

I also don't see that much potential, he is 24 already and there are many world class ability out there.

I think he may get paid if people buy enought shirts because of his price, but that would be it. What Florentino did IMO was a mix of a gamble throught the whole expensive label Bale get and an ego blow of not managing to sign Neymar.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

93

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Kyle Walker will never succeed as an international footballer as he has a horrific first touch and only does well due to his pace. His complete lack of tactical nous covered by his acceleration.

82

u/william701 Sep 08 '13

You're meant to make it possible.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

He's still young with a probable starting berth and a good squad to develop his inadequacies in?

23

u/thafman Sep 08 '13

Whilst he occasionally suffers from the first touch of a rapist, Kyle Walker is a deceptively good passer of the ball. Time and again he delivers wonderful through-balls and regularly feeds the ball to Aaron Lennon's feet after he's snuck in behind the defense.

He's 23 years of age, there is still plenty of time to learn the necessary positioning and reading of the game that he'll need to succeed at the highest levels but it would be a mistake to write him off as merely a pace merchant.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

As of right now, yep. He's young though people forget that

2

u/Eljero Sep 09 '13

people said a lot worse (a lot different) things about Glen Johnson, but he put in a ton of work in his career to vastly improve those areas of his play. For Johnson it was being shambolic defensively as a defender, and making poor decisions, very much harder to improve then the occasional first touch and easier to learn how to go forward then to defend.

4

u/Soccer__fan Sep 08 '13

Theo Walcott.

27

u/Beetlefruice Sep 08 '13

Theo's pace and his ability to finish are actually a pretty good combination though.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

67

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Football is a business. Large clubs are no different to international brands in any other walk of life. The biggest clubs are no different to soft drinks, no different to fast food. This clique of teams are actively trying to remove the element of competition to remove personal risk to profit. The modern fan is complicit, and entirely happy for this to happen. Smaller clubs going under are no concern of the modern fan (except for faux outrage), they hedonistically want to be entertained at any cost. The traditional relationship of community and football is becoming nonexistent. We are quickly moving to a setup like Formula One where a few teams will endlessly rotate, the spectacle will take place on your TV. Passion will be drained, excitement gone, meanwhile spectators will argue the minutiae of tyre temperatures hawk-eye offside calls, distracted from the loss of unpredictability. The loss of risk. The loss of real sport. We won't realise what we had until it is gone.

19

u/fozzy143 Sep 08 '13

Football survived the collapse of an empire, the invention of television, two world wars, the economic recession, the strikes, the invention of the internet, the conversion to PLCs, the creation of the Premier League. It's going to take something pretty big to ruin it.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

The Premier League was the first real implementation in the UK of the business plan I describe, thanks for highlighting that. The rest are strawmen, external things to football - it survived the death of princess Diana too... This is something bigger, it's internal. The removal of risk, the removal of entertainment, in the game, to suck out personal profit and toss the heart of football on the scrap heap.

3

u/Sambuccaneer Sep 09 '13

No one will ever take away the emotion I feel and share with friends when I see Ajax hopelessly lose against Barcelona on TV next week.

3

u/topright Sep 09 '13

I'd say it began in 1983 with clubs bypassing Rule 34 - which was there to limit the ability of owners and directors to make money out of clubs - with the formation of holding companies and Stock Exchange flotation.

Cheers Spurs.

2

u/slotbadger Sep 09 '13

So did almost all sports. Cricket survived all of those things. Rugby did. I don't really see your point.

3

u/cret1n Sep 09 '13

You forget that amateur leagues exist and always will, its not like Formula One where you need a million dollars just for a car.

→ More replies (11)

25

u/modano_star Sep 08 '13

Defending is kind of glossed over in modern-day football. Big teams look to attacking players as their marquee signings (very few exceptions) , and kind of wing it defensively. I used to enjoy some of the defensive partnerships at centre-back, but now no-one really gives much of a shit. As much as he moaned, I will miss some of Alan Hansen's defensive analysis because it was kind of interesting.

26

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

The reason defenders seem less important is because individually they are, defending is more about how the whole team plays not just one player whereas in attack one player can make something out of nothing and win a game singlehandedly.

6

u/ILikeGirlsWithHats Sep 08 '13

Wing it defensively? What big team other than Barcelona clearly needs defensive reinforcements but can't seem to be bothered to do anything about it?

2

u/KinneySL Sep 09 '13

Do Napoli count considering we're a Champions' League club? Also, there's Inter, but they're less of a case of 'can't seem to be bothered' and more of 'don't have any money.'

→ More replies (8)

3

u/topright Sep 09 '13

now no-one really gives much of a shit

47,000 people at The Etihad very much give a shit.

2

u/JapaneseGamer Sep 09 '13

I wouldn't say that, because one of the marquee signings deemed marquee by the club itself was Liverpool acquiring Sakho. I do think there are teams that value defending more so than other teams.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/TheMuthaFlippin Sep 08 '13

England cannot possibly produce a top quality international team within the next few decades, as that would require a complete change in footballing culture that couldn't possibly be implemented sooner.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

The change you mention is already underway IIRC, theyve changed the age of stepup from 7aside to 11aside in youth football up a few years so there is a point of grassroots improvement that's vital (10 year olds should not be playing on a 75x110m pitch). For the national team and it's development squads theyve recently built a sprawlling an ambitious new training complex at St. George's Park.

In the form of these things, I'd say there are the beginnings of the culture change that yiu're on about, it's simply a matter of time until it bears fruit. I for one quit playing when I was young due to the shift up from 7 a side to 11, as the game became entirely about athleticism and had absolutely no emphasis on just having fun.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/SlappyBagg Sep 08 '13

Won the Under 17 european championships a few years back, if that generation is brought through correctly (which they won't be) they would be a top quality team.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

If I'm not mistaken the U21 team got knocked out of the most recent U21 Euro's without gaining a point in the group stage.

31

u/SlappyBagg Sep 09 '13

Because all the best players were on the bench for the first team for very important friendlies

8

u/duckman273 Sep 09 '13

Exactly. Wilshere, Rodwell, Shaw, Jenkinson, Walker, Welbeck, Sterling, Chamberlain, Townsend, Mcmanaman and Jones all didn't go for various reasons.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/fakeplastictrees182 Sep 09 '13

I think they are well on their way. The young players they are producing now are genuinely technically talented. Guys like the Ox, Sturridge, Wilshere and to a lesser extent Cleverly and McEachren have based their games on movement, passing and dribbling. These are very non-traditional English skills and now they just need a national coaching setup to encourage them, rather than someone who will pick guys like scott parker and andy carroll.

3

u/Sambuccaneer Sep 09 '13

Do you think though that these guys can match some of the talent some other countries show? Especially Italy, Germany and Belgium seem to be looking at a stronger generation

→ More replies (1)

2

u/neonmantis Sep 09 '13

Ox isn't that technical, there is a decent amount of power and pace there. He's nowhere near Wilshere's level in that regard.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

10

u/afcmitchell Sep 09 '13

I do not think the Netherlands will be of any international importance for at least 10 years.

→ More replies (4)

103

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

The US is not a top 20 or maybe even 30 team. They have a few average players and one or two above average or good players. they are a growing nation in football, I'll give them that

27

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

The essential problem with this question is that I can guarantee you that 90% of the people answering it watch 2-5 national teams and likely can't name a starting midfielder for a team like Bosnia. Everyone seems to be defending their views based on the FIFA and Elo rankings which are heavily dependent on continental play. FIFA/Elo rankings give you a good idea where a team stands in a given continent but using it as an intercontinental ranking system (in a non-World Cup year) is idiotic.

USAs ranking depends on their success vs Mexico, Jamaica, Honduras, etc. Japan's ranking depends on their success vs Australia, Saudi Arabia, Oman, Iran, etc. How exactly could you judge teams when they've faced different opponents on different continents?

The best way to judge these teams is if you've actually watched them. I only watch international football so I've seen a fair share of teams. I can tell you that the U.S is definitely not a Top 10 team. They're in the middle tier of football teams where anything can happen on any given day. Ukraine has a better squad than the U.S, yet I wouldn't be surprised if the US ever beats them 2-0. The difference between the two is so minimal that it would be foolish to make any judgement without an understanding of each teams coaching situation and squad. There are at least 50 teams in this middle-tier in my opinion.

Look at a team like Serbia that are ranked 41 by FIFA. They are 3rd place in their qualification group with Belgium and Croatia ahead of them. As of now, they missed the World Cup. Now look at their squad. On paper they have one of the best defenses in the world. Are you honestly telling me the U.S are 22 teams better than them at 19? Are you going to definitively tell me the US has a stronger team than Serbia. If the US was stuck in a group with Macedonia, Wales, Scotland, Croatia, and Belgium would they finish better than 3rd. Ask yourselves those questions before calling US a Top 20/30 team.

Now put the US in any qualification table in Africa or South America. How would they fare? Senegal had Papas Cisse, Moussa Sow, and Demba Ba face African defenses in Angola, Uganda, and Liberia and struggled to advance in their group. Do the people in this sub honestly think the USMNT with Omar Gonzalez at defense would have an easy time against Senegalese forwards? Demba Ba himself has made Tim Howard look foolish several times in the EPL. Put into consideration that Senegal is barely a top 10 squad in Africa - the rest of their squad isn't even weak. I already wrote more about Africa below and how the US would likely do. People will likely automatically disagree with me without having ever watched the teams I mentioned or knowing their squads. It's complete jingoistic ignorance.

I'm getting kind of annoyed by individuals who are answering this question who think world football is Spain, Brazil, Italy, Holland, Argentina, Germany, England then USA. C'mon. Your bias is totally showing.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/william701 Sep 08 '13

Who thinks the US is a top 20/30 team?

15

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Would you mind listing top 30. I'm not joking nor implying that they are on top 30 just because there isn't a list. I'm just curious. Feel free to not feed my curiosity.

18

u/Tasslehoff Sep 08 '13

I think the US is a top 30 team, but not top 20.

→ More replies (15)

13

u/RGD365 Sep 08 '13

Of course the USA are top twenty, qualified for every World Cup since Italia '90.

The way Americans put down the national team is really odd, almost as if they are trying to come across as more educated about football by claiming that the US team is shit.

69

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

I probably agree that they're top twenty, but not with your reasoning. How hard is it to qualify out of CONCACAF? It is this hard: not.

36

u/gremwood Sep 09 '13

Yeah, yeah. How hard is it to qualify out of CONCACAF? Even Canada c-

sob

7

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

I do not think the US is a top 20 team, but getting out of the group stages of the world cup means that at least you aren't shit. I mean if we qualified for every world cup out of CONCACAF and finished last in our group every time I'd agree that we suck. But cmon. To even make it out of the group means you are pretty decent.

10

u/PreemptiveDownvote Sep 08 '13

It wouldn't be hard if it wasn't for the environments. Playing away at some of those Caribbean countries are a real game changer. Very hostile, poor facilities and conditions, heat and humidity.

→ More replies (11)

16

u/thejanitorch4 Sep 08 '13

Yeah but it's all well and good qualifying out of N. America. Your only competitors are Mexico.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

And you don't even have to be first. CONCACAF has fucking 3.5 spots. Unbelievable to me. At most, they should get 2.5.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

They're clearly a top 20 team. At least they're 19th in the fifa rankings. Sure, they can't compete with the likes of brazil, germany spain, argentina, colombia, italy, netherlands, but nobody else really can. (Although they did beat germany 4-3 earlier in the year)

In south africa, US finished ahead of England in group C on tiebreakers and qualified for the round of 16. Granted, they might have been the worst team to make it to the final 16, but surely they are within the top 20 teams in the world.

Also, you can just look at their team squad: Landon Donovan was a great player for everton an above average EPL team, Tim Howard is also an above average starting EPL keeper. Jermaine Jones is a regular starter for FC Schalke 04, a strong bundesliga team. The rest of their team doesn't have too much top-flight club experience, but it's a very solid squad nonetheless -- it's not a top10 squad for sure, but after the top ten, how many teams have players like donovan and howard? To boot, they have a world class best coach they ever had in Klinsmann and he's been able to bring the best out of his squad. (edit: Dempsey!)

Ultimately, the question is, can you think of 20 teams better than the US?? You really will not be able to.

18

u/fleckes Sep 09 '13

To boot, they have a world class coach in Klinsmann

What makes Klinsmann a world class coach? It surely wasn't his time at Bayern

→ More replies (8)

6

u/DisgracedCubFan Sep 09 '13

We only beat Germany because of Ter Stegens fail and all germanys starters were in London for the CL Final.

10

u/fleckes Sep 09 '13

I actually didn't mind much losing to the US. I think they are a good team, and I like to follow them now with quite some German-Americans on the team I know from the Bundesliga, plus Klinsmann as coach.

But now that US fans constantly bring it up (at least that's my feeling) in converstation about how good the US is now and what they can accomplish in the future, without mentioning the circumstances of the match in the slightest gets me fed up about it to be honest and I wish Germany had never lost to the US. Just so that some US fans would shut up about it, or at least mention the circumstances

5

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

I know right. Just look at how often they go on about drawing with England years ago thanks to a horrendous goalkeeping error. As if that result is sone indicator of how strong each side is right now. It's like clinging onto any small shred they can.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/AlGamaty Sep 09 '13

It's far from clear.

Argentina, Chile, Brazil, Uruguay, Colombia, Mexico, France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Germany, Russia, Netherlands, Belgium, England, Ghana, Turkey, Greece, Ukraine, Japan, South Korea, Sweden, Switzerland, Ivory Coast, Croatia, and BiH are all teams that are stronger than the US. The US probably would make the top 30, but top 20? No.

5

u/ILikeGirlsWithHats Sep 08 '13

Germany, Brazil, Argentina, Spain, Italy, Uruguay, Colombia, Croatia, Belgium, Japan, Portugal, Ivory Coast, Chile, Netherlands, France, England.

That's 16 I don't really think you can argue with (except for maybe France, who are pretty shit right now). Personally I would also put teams like Switzerland, Russia, Nigeria, Bosnia, Turkey, Sweden, Ukraine, Czech Republic and Ghana in front of them. And there are more I could make an argument for, like Austria or Montenegro.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/aykau777 Sep 08 '13

I can't....

Argentina, Ecuador, Chile, Uruguay, Brazil, Colombia, Portugal, Spain, England, Germany, Holand, France ,Belgium, Italy, Ghana, Ivory Coast, Japan, Sweeden, Switzerland

The US is a fair 20 maybe even a top 15-20. After the top 15 it's simply impossible to classify them.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

75

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

/r/soccer is substantially less informed and worse off without /u/devineman.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

devineman leaving and TopsyTukle getting banned has made r/soccer that little bit less fun the last couple of weeks.

11

u/Schveen15 Sep 08 '13

Why was he banned?

4

u/shellsee Sep 09 '13

That guy was a wanker and clearly said things to get on people's nerves instead of trying to start conversation

6

u/cartola Sep 08 '13

Didn't realize he was banned. He seemed like a cunt but I dunno what got him banned.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/Mister_Anthony Sep 09 '13

He was well informed but still was very pretentious, that's why people didn't like him.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

what happened him?

16

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Maybe he is using an alt account... Hmmmmmm... ¯\(ツ)/¯

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

tolerance break

→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Really? Did anyone else not even notice he was gone or is it just me? I'm pretty sure it's not the first time he's "quit" anyway.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/IDeclareShenanigans Sep 08 '13

Devineman is more obnoxious than all of r/soccer combined.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

He really was, he probably did know more than most but he had to make sure he told everyone just how much more he knew than them, and how much of a better person he was for it.

36

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

Devineman is more informed than all of r/soccer combined.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/dylansavage Sep 09 '13

The unfair label that Arsenal don't like to be kicked by the media has caused 5 broken legs in 6 years and have destroyed 2 promising careers. It is a miracle that Ramsey has managed to overcome his injury.

5

u/neonmantis Sep 09 '13

I honestly fear for Wilshere, the kid takes such a battering every single game and he's already had over a year out. The way he plays the game invites tackles and he can stand up for himself but he worries me. I honestly believe that if one of the Diaby / Eduardo / Ramsey tackles had taken place on a leading english player then the premiership would have followed the french / german and belgian leagues by introducing extended bans for reckless tackles. That a lot of people seem to believe that diving is more of a problem than reckless tackling is a joke in my opinion.

2

u/ox_ Sep 09 '13

Arsenal play a high-possession game where the players spend a lot of time with the ball at their feet which means tackles will often be made around the ankle area.

I'm not excusing the bad challenges, just pointing out that Arsenal are more susceptible.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

40

u/dem503 Sep 08 '13

Spurs are in danger of slipping into a pattern of "we'll gel the team this year and really go for it next season" as they are constantly letting their best player go and having to replace him.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

This season spurs have sold their best player but replaced him with quality all over the midfield and up front. Bale scored 22 last season and only assisted 5. The signings they've made will get more goals and assists than that and allow spurs to push on into the top 4. Although the sheer presence of Bale is something they may never be able to replace.

4

u/Dooey123 Sep 08 '13

We definitely were already in that category with the sales of Carrick, Berbatov and Modric which have tended to make us lose ground in the CL race but we have been very fortunate in Bale having a world class season and Real Madrid willing to break a record transfer for him so now hopefully the new players we've got will be worth more in footballing terms than Bale.

2

u/alexropo Sep 08 '13

I think last year's batch included utility players like Dempsey and Sigurdsson, whereas this season we really filled roles and added long-term talent in a lot of positions. The I think our most irreplaceable current player is Lloris, who seems very committed to the club.

31

u/HeeyMaan Sep 09 '13

I have a hard time accepting that fans that don't live near their favourite team are as passionate as local fans (don't kill me for it, it's just my opinion).

This is because I've seen some international fans saying some ludicrous things amongst which are: 'I wouldn't mind if Liverpool and Everton share a stadium' (Liverpool fan) 'I have a soft spot for Tottenham ' (Arsenal fan)

You'd never hear a local say any of that. So I just want to hear what supporting your club means to international fans, if it's more than just a casual interest.

36

u/SlappyBagg Sep 09 '13

I would agree international fans are more likely to be more casual about their team but not living near your team doesn't automatically make you care less.

3

u/mhegdekatte Sep 09 '13

Yeah, but can most of them be as passionate about a local or historical rivalry as an international? For example, most international fans are likely not even aware of our heated rivalry with Leeds. And its not as if the rivalry has cooled down because they aren't on the same level as us, the FA cup game a few years back is a great reminder of that.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Ahesterd Sep 09 '13

So I just want to hear what supporting your club means to international fans, if it's more than just a casual interest.

I support Dortmund because my mother was born there, and lived there for the first several years of her life. My grandfather was a massive Dortmund supporter his entire life, through the good years and bad, and waking up at 8 AM to cheer for them makes me feel a little closer to someone who I didn't get to know well enough before age and disease had their way.

Yeah, I wear a Fire crest here. They're my hometown team, and I like repping MLS. I love the Fire, I love Chicago, and I love Dortmund. There's no conflict whatsoever, and if you were to ask me if I'd rather have Dortmund win the Bundesliga or the Fire win the MLS Cup, well, I'm not really sure what I'd choose. I do know that the first thing I do after I've put money away and paid for school is traveling to Dortmund in football season.

Now - that's not to say that there aren't plenty of casual fans of international teams. I don't really have an EPL team and, so kind of casually bounce around from team to team - I like Spurs, but I'll readily admit I only started following them when Dempsey joined, and now I'm slowly becoming enamored with Aston Villa. Three months from now, who knows where I'll be - other than watching Dortmund at 8 AM and the Fire at 8 PM.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/DupaZupa Sep 09 '13

I agree that fans making the sort of statements that you used as examples are definitely more casual than any local fan would be. But there are definitely international fans that are just as passionate as locals, look at the crowds when clubs do pre-season tours. I know people around here that are considering getting Liverpool tattoos.

People are not always in control of where they live, so they had to move away from their cities, but they can still support those teams.

Also lots of times, it takes more to be a passionate fan when you aren't a local. It's easy to be a Liverpool fan when everyone on your street is. It's harder when there's only one place in town to watch soccer at all, so you sit with all different fans, instead of having dedicated bars. You have to get up really early on Saturday or Sunday morning to catch your team play, or some other ridiculous hours depending on where you are in the world. Everything you want to purchase from your club's site is going to cost you $20 more because of international shipping. Sometimes you need to purchase expensive cable TV channels to even watch the games (this is better now with streaming and NBC).

Finally, all the while that you are enamoured with your team from across the ocean, everyone else around you is a die-hard hockey, football, baseball or basketball fan, and they just make fun of soccer because "the players fall a lot". Sure this is not an absolute truth, and I myself enjoy some of those other sports. But the culture for other sports is bigger, and you have to share what little soccer culture with any soccer fans you can find. This forces you to associate with Man U, or Chelsea, or Barca or Real fans, even though you hate their team. Even worse when World or Euro Cup rolls around, and now suddenly everyone is a fan, your local pub with the few actual soccer fans is full and you can't get in, but at least there's crowds at most bars. Still annoying hearing people arbitrarily become fans of countries they have no association to, and start acting like huge soccer fans, but they couldn't even explain the Champions League to someone. They argue about calls they don't understand, and insult refs without a clue of why a call was bad. Then the club season rolls around after the WC or EC and suddenly your little pub isn't full with fans anymore, and you have to talk to the Man U guy again.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

In my country, I know of 4 people who support Liverpool. One of is a die hard fan, one is a casual fan, one now supports Manchester United because he couldn't take the heartache of the last couple of seasons and one is me.

Everyone here either supports Barca, Madrid, Arsenal or Chelsea, with a few Man U fans sprinkled in between. Everybody supports City know too since Abu Dhabi bought the team they think it's kind of patriotic to do so, I myself don't hate City, I like their players but I only support them when they play the scum.

Being a Liverpool supporter is hard, when I was a kid I asked my dad to bring me a Liverpool kit back from the UK. I told him it was red He brought me back a Man U kit (along with a Man U gym bag, pencil case, stationary set and Old Trafford poster) I didn't have the heart to tell him he got it wrong so I went to school with a whole bunch of Man U gear but everyone knew I supported Liverpool. They could never understand why I did either, Liverpool never won anything when I was in middle/high school, I didn't care, I had loyalty for my team and I always will. If that's not at least as much as a local fan, I really don't know what supporting football is.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

17

u/flaffl Sep 09 '13

I think this subreddit has an incredibly poor infrastructure, especially when comparing it to other sports subreddits. The quality of posts requires a higher standard, as well as the comments. Especially the comments. I don't see why there isn't some sort of a reminder on downvotes. Far too often I see downvotes for people stating legitimately based, yet unpopular opinions throughout this subreddit and it's starting to annoy me, and I'm sure I'm not the only one that feels this way.

6

u/jnhagood Sep 09 '13

If barca was in the Premier league they would not win it. They are not durable enough to withstand the physicality of it week in week out. Most premier league teams have to be able to rotate players at every position to deal with injuries and change tactics but barca doesn't have the kind of depth needed to rotate their big players like messi and iniesta. One of those two would get injured and the wheels would come off the hinges and they would finish in 3rd or 4th

25

u/DY12 Sep 08 '13

Graeme Souness is a cunt.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Ronaldinhoac11 Sep 09 '13

I think that the away goal rule should be removed from the knockout stages of the Champions League. I feel that it's not fair and it favors one team over another when the actual aggregate score is tied. If the aggregate score is tied, teams should either play extra time then PKs OR if they are too concerned about tiredness, injuries, and their next league game then they can go straight to PKs.

2

u/afcmitchell Sep 09 '13

It doesn't favor on club over the other, since both teams play ine game away and one at home.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

I don't think saying Ronaldo is 1b to Messi's 1a is a fair comparison. I think Messi is legitimately the best player in the world and it isn't debatable. I base my conclusion on just of what I have I seen ( and I watched them play a lot) and not on stats but if we were to go solely by stats even then Messi has come out on top for the past 4 years in most categories.

19

u/SlappyBagg Sep 08 '13

Ronaldo plays out wide and further back. The whole system at Barca revolves around Messi and everything goes through him. Ronaldo had a better Champions League campaign last year.

FYI I think Messi is better, but I think it's 1a and 1b.

24

u/622 Sep 09 '13

The whole system at Madrid is built around Ronaldo too, of course they would try to play to their best player's strengths.

7

u/postdaemon Sep 09 '13

Ronaldo and Messi both play as their team's primary goalscorer and the focus of the attack. Whether Ronaldo plays in a wider position is largely irrelevant, especially considering how he ignores his defensive duties (in order to focus on scoring goals) to an extent that lesser wingers would never be allowed.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

What's your definition of better? More successful, better suited to the system and team around them, better in their position or better in any position, more complete? There are many ways to decide who is better at what, what is your metric specifically?

I would say Messi is more successful and is better suited to the system he plays in but Ronaldo is a more complete striker who could play better in most other teams.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

He's a better dribbler, passer, and defender of the ball.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

4

u/milksteaklover Sep 09 '13

Scrolled through entire page... saw no ∆s

12

u/BDX_LAW Sep 09 '13

Barcelona are boring as fuck to watch.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/natekronos Sep 09 '13

I don't think that just because Arsenal brought in Özil, they suddenly are guarenteed a finish in the top 4. Their biggest problem right now isn't the lack of quality. They have that in players like Walcott and Cazorla. What they need is more depth, which is the reason why people were complaining about in the first place.

2

u/iamveryharsh Sep 09 '13

Depth at striker is a massive problem for Arsenal. Depth everyone else is more than sufficient. Arteta and Vermaelen will return soon while Podolski and Chamberlain will return in time to give them a mid-season push.

This lack of a defensive midfielder everyone thinks Arsenal needs was covered by Flamini, who can also cover both fullbacks in case of injuries. Plus, last season, Arsenal was perfectly fine without a defensive midfielder once they dropped Vermaelen and implemented a better team-pressing system.

Sagna has shown himself to be a decent centerback, and just needs to hang on for another month until Vermaelen returns.

Liverpool have started well but Arsenal have improved quite a bit, and between the two, I think the signing of Ozil pushes Arsenal ahead in the long-run.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/TheRoyalTenenThom Sep 09 '13

I think that if Messi was on Manchester City or Chelsea, and Ronaldo was back at United, that Ronaldo would be considered the better player by almost everyone and would win the Ballon d'Or year-in year-out.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

Out of curiosity, what if Messi was at Man Utd and Ronaldo at Chelsea/Man City?

5

u/TheRoyalTenenThom Sep 09 '13

It's all the same. I should've just said top 4 premier league teams.

2

u/AwkwardMuch Sep 09 '13

Can I ask where you're from? I have seen a good few people say "if so and so played ON Chelsea, city etc". As a native English speaker from Ireland, saying ON seems so grammatically wrong but I have seen a lot more people saying it? Maybe English isn't your first language, I don't know?

"If Messi played for City or Chelsea" or "If Messi was with/at City or Chelsea" are how I would say it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

Samir Nasri is not the playmaker people think he is. He has good ball control and is a "safe" player, but is too slow and lacks the creativity to actually impose himself on decent competition. Arsenal and City fans, convince me otherwise. Videos might help.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

I think what Man United is doing to Kagawa is wrong. He's a great player and does not deserve to sit on the bench.

2

u/Blemlyfe Sep 09 '13

Don't think any sane person would disagree Kagawa has far too much talent to be riding the bench

7

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

1 - The Brasileirão is the best and most competitive league behind the spanish, english, german and italian leagues. It is also one with the most equal playing level (no 2-horse race)

2 - World Cup wins at home shouldn't count.

10

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Sep 09 '13

2 - World Cup wins at home shouldn't count.

You say that just because we didn't win the 1950 one.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

I was actually thinking more about Italy and Argentina (Peru thing and the finals against Netherlands) under fascist dictatorships, Korea 4th in 2002 and 1966 England that didnt have any other spectacular result. 1974 Germany over Netherlands. France 1998 was a good team, this one is okay. And I don't know enough about 1930.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/georgedc Sep 09 '13

England are still one of the best national teams in the world and have been very unlucky in many major tournaments.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/fast_lloris Sep 08 '13

England aren't very good but they're definitely better than the US.

Defoe should be subbed on for England in 90% of games still.

CMV

25

u/postdaemon Sep 09 '13

England aren't very good but they're definitely better than the US.

Can anyone honestly argue that the US is better?

8

u/SlappyBagg Sep 09 '13

Agree with the first point but I think England need to move past Defoe and give Sturridge more time in place of him.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/tadm123 Sep 08 '13

Thiago Alcantara will fail at Bayern Munich. He's too inconsistent to be a starter.

4

u/Footstepz Sep 08 '13

Explain to me why Dirk Kuyts 'work ethic' is so 'good'.

12

u/Flighty_Zeuz Sep 08 '13

He runs up the field to support the attack, then he runs back when they lose the ball. This means that his team will always have an additional man in defence or attack faster then the opposition simply because he runs harder throughout the game.

ie He gets through the transition phase quicker then the oppositions counterpart which puts pressure on the defence when attacking, and strengthens the defence when they are attacked.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Always breaks a sweat on the pitch and performs well even when in a bad position resultwise. He's what Finns call sisu and Swedes call kämpaglöd. I like to think Dirk Kuyt was an important component in what made commentators call Liverpool the "King of Comeback".

3

u/CapitalG Sep 09 '13

Salary caps would make football better.

8

u/PapaQuiff Sep 08 '13

I believe Liverpool are more likely than Arsenal and Tottenham to achieve top 4 this season. I believe this as last season Liverpool were one of the top scoring teams in Europe in their respective leagues. They have added to their squad in all the right areas, a squad who already is showing to have already gelled and shown great chemistry. We have been able to show that we can grind out results which is what we lacked last season. We also have fewer matches than both Arsenal and Spurs which in the long run could help us. Come November when we play Arsenal we will be able to tell just how bright this season will be for us depending on the result.

14

u/emmanuel_eboue Sep 08 '13

Rodgers is still a relatively inexperienced manager at this level, and you had a poor record against the top 4 last year, I think Tottenham were the only top 5 team you beat in the league. I know it might look like things are changing this season with that win over United but you definitely can't underestimate the advantage of having someone as experienced as Wenger. Spurs implosion under Redknapp at the end of the season 2 years ago sort of showed how useful it is to have a manager whose been there and done it all before.

4

u/PapaQuiff Sep 08 '13

/Rodgers had had the same time in the BPL as AVB ( I think anyway ). Rodgers had a nightmare start to his liverpool career last year. Threadbare squad with a fixture list from hell. However, his effects are already taking shape. Liverpool has had a record very similar to Manchester United in both of their last 19 games. The combination of the last 2 windows are already showing to be great windows. Kolo, Coutinho, Sturridge (now its a big loss he's not playing for England as opposed to the reaction when he was in the squad 8 months ago), Mingolet already winning us 4 points at least against Stoke and aston Villa and I go on. Wengers experience is where I do agree the challenge for Liverpool and if Arsenal had a better squad I would not hold my belief.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

Fewer matches is an advantage against arsenal but Tottenham surely have enough depth to be a major force later in the year

→ More replies (11)

2

u/postdaemon Sep 09 '13

9 from 9 is quite deceiving. All three wins have been shaky 1-0 affairs, but I guess that does show an ability to "win badly".

I think we have to wait for a proper challenging match for Liverpool (United played abysmally) before anyone can make a decent judgment.

2

u/chezygo Sep 09 '13

Arsenal was the third best scoring team in the PL (well ahead of Liverpool) and had the second best defensive record (again, well ahead of Liverpool). Their team has only improved for the better, and Liverpool will struggle come November onwards. I think of Liverpool as this year's WBA, start strong, but will falter often before finishing upper-midtable.

4

u/Halithor Sep 09 '13

Arsenal was the third best scoring team in the PL (well ahead of Liverpool)

This was about where i stopped reading because it's obviously wrong to the point where you didn't even look. Arsenal scored 72 and Liverpool scored 71. I don't know how you consider that to be "Well ahead".

West Brom last year clearly didn't have the team Liverpool do this season quality wise so i'd be very interested to know why you hold this view.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

In a few years there will only be about 10 really relevant teams in Europe and they will kill the soul of football by creating a Super League between them. It's already starting to happen, as you can see in most leagues. At least it seems unlikely that it will happen in South America...

And I think the only way to save football is implementing the following rule: no team can be owned by a single individual at all, specially not oil sheiks or criminals.

→ More replies (12)

2

u/twertyou Sep 09 '13

The UEFA Champions League is the most prestigious tournament in the world

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

The Champions League is not even fulfilling what it says as it's name. Arsenal finished fourth and are made to go through qualifying and are still a number one seed. The champions Manchester City a few years back were put in pot 3. The draw giving us the champions of Spain, England, Germany and Holland was so widelly spoken of because the CL was actually meeting it's standard for once.

The World cup for example consists of years of qualifying matches, with countries from all I've the world being given equal opportunity to qualify. It even allocates places based on geography, meaning it's not full of European and South American teams. The World Cup is also older than the CL, and getting into a national team is far more difficult than getting into a Champions League team (for some countries at least) and so players place a huge amount of importance and pride at starting a game for their country in the World Cup.

2

u/Eljero Sep 09 '13

The World Cup by nature is much bigger and prestigious I think, happening every 4 years helps this dramatically to start off with, teams having to qualify for the WC means nothing because teams do that over a year for the CL as well. But when a world cup is on literally the whole world tunes in almost as much as the olympics (not for football olympics in general) While the Champs league final may be tuned into by a majority of Europe and a fairly large portion the rest of the world the world cup is broadcast over a short but intense period of time in summer which stops entire countries all over the world and not just the city/country who is playing in the CL final, it draws on nationalistic pride which beats out club pride in popularity tenfold. The CL is a terrific tournament with possibly an equal level of play (a whole different debate there) but the WC is literally a celebration of the sport for a whole month where thousands flock from around the world to support their team, their culture, and party. This happens in the CL of course but on a much smaller scale. Because of the sheer size of the cultural impact of the WC I think it is much more prestigious.

also as a small addendum you often here people say "oh messi/ronaldo/playerx will never be a true great/better than playerx until he wins the world cup. You don't hear this as much about the CL.

edit: quote from someone further down the thread ironically. credit to /u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO CR and Messi are very good but won't be on the same league as Maradona, Pelé, Ronaldo and the likes untill they win a World Cup. Pelé won his first one at 17 and managed to win another 2. Maradona carried the 1986 squad on his back the entire competition. Ronaldo is the all time top goal scorer anda won twice.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

CR and Messi are very good but won't be on the same league as Maradona, Pelé, Ronaldo and the likes untill they win a World Cup

This is just false. Comparing players from different eras in any sport is almost impossible, and mostly leads to a circlejerk. If CR and Messi never win a WC they will still be remembered as the best players of their era.

Also the WC is pretty irrelevant in terms of the sport itself. It is a month-long party and global spectacle, but it isn't the gold standard of soccer by a long distance.

2

u/Magical_Sarcastic Sep 08 '13

I like Adrian Chiles on ITV's football coverage. He has a good sense of humour and doesn't take things too seriously.

5

u/redletterboy Sep 08 '13

Adrian Chiles came to think that he was exceptionally popular as a presenter because he's an 'everyman' who the average British bloke can relate to. He was the subject of a bit of a tug of war between ITV and the BBC, but when ITV got him, he became quite conscious of what he thought was that everyman appeal. The problem is that this has bred complacency, bad jokes, willful ignorance about England's (or English clubs') opponents, and a deference to his far more qualified guests. After all, he's just an average bloke, what does he know about that small eastern European backwater? How can he possibly question the infinite wisdom of a footballing god like Roy Keane?

Except really, he's quite a capable and bright bloke, and a half decent journalist when he wants to be. He's just caught in this negative feedback loop where he's rewarded for not trying. Or worse still, for trying to not try. I think it's fair for us to expect more from our football presenters.

Edit: If you are just being sarcastic, thanks for at least giving me the chance to get some feelings off my chest.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/navinho Sep 09 '13

Football fans are morally bankrupt apologists, ready to accept and defend players for racist abuse or dubiously wealthy billionaire owners, simply because they are part of a certain club.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

I wouldn't say morally bankrupt, more blinded by loyalty.

2

u/SkyFoo Sep 09 '13

Vidal will be the best player in the world, or top 3 in a couple of years time

1

u/McBricks Sep 09 '13

FC Augsburg will not have to fear relegation this season, because Daniel Baier is an excellent defensive midfielder/deep lying playmaker; and Weinzierl is a great manager, who introduced a Bayern like 4-1-4-1 last season with Baier in that key DM position. It took the first half of the season until the new formation was established. Augsburg (German first half - second half tables) only had 9 (!) points. The twenty four points in the second half prevented them from being relegated.

This season, they dominated in their loss against Bremen basically the whole game and Bremen created not a single real chance and scored from a half chance. If they had had somebody able to convert up front they would have won easily.

The Dortmund result (0-4) looks much worse than the game actually was. Augsburg created just as many chances from open play as Dortmund. They stand at 6 points from four games, now.

Augsburg was really lacking a striker, since Mölders is unable to convert even after having beaten the goalie. He is midtable second Bundesliga material. Bobadilla and especially Milik are exactly what Augsburg needed (both are injured though).

tl;dr: Augsburg will be the "surprise" team of this Bundesliga season, possibly even able to finish in europa league territory.

1

u/j3zuz911 Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

On paper England had the best player pool in the world in 2006. They should have won the 2006 world cup.

2

u/Screwbit Sep 09 '13

Actually, Italy did. They rightfully won. Look at the names on that team: Buffon, Cannavaro, Nesta, Totti, Del Piero, Pirlo, Gattuso, Inzaghi, Zambrotta. All absolute legends of the game.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

I think there are still lingering xenophobic in the premiership that come out in youth development, treatment of foreign players, and playing style of the English national team. This xenophobia is hindering England's chances of being a successful national team. CMV

edit. grammar is hard

1

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
  1. CR and Messi are very good but won't be on the same league as Maradona, Pelé, Ronaldo and the likes untill they win a World Cup. Pelé won his first one at 17 and managed to win another 2. Maradona carried the 1986 squad on his back the entire competition. Ronaldo is the all time top goal scorer anda won twice.
  2. The Brazilian league is the most balanced and unpredictable in the world among the best championships. Since 2000 there were 8 different champions
  3. If you retire from the NT once you shouldn't be allowed back (yes, this is about Boateng)

EDIT: I have a 3rd one

5

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

I think that the first point is very hard to judge, CR and Messi do have some crazy stats. To win a World Cup you must have a lot of luck combined with skill in my opinion. Let's say your team has a 80% chance of winning against every other team in the competition (which is a lot):

To win the World Cup you must win 0.8(round of 16)*0.8 (round of 8)*0.8 * 0.8 (semi) * 0.8 (finals) = 32%. Not even counting the group stage. Zico, Socrates and Falcao didnt win in 1982 and that team was awesome, Zico is arguably on par with Maradona, Pele, Ronaldo and others.

Other legends that never won include Platini, Cruyff, Zizinho, Eusebio, di Stefano, Puskas, Fontaine, Lev Yashin, Baggio, Bergkamp

EDIT: Included more players that didnt win.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/afcmitchell Sep 09 '13

For the first one, how about Cruijff?

2

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Sep 09 '13

He had the likes of Neeskens, Johnny Rep and Krol on his side in 1974 but lost to Beckenbauer and Gerd Müller. Being part of total football was impressive, but not enought to achieve the last step that is winning the WC. Even when Michels was the coach.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

If you do not go to football games then your opinion is worth less than people who do.

15

u/modano_star Sep 08 '13

I would say that is a bit too much of a generalisation. Someone who studies many games from many different leagues, over different seasons, will probably have a better tactical understanding than someone who watches his local club on weekends. What do you mean by 'worth less'? In terms of knowledge of football to back up their opinions or on a kind of moral basis? I think you are looking at it more from the viewpoint 'who do I want to listen to more' , instead of the question you've actually asked.

→ More replies (19)

3

u/PapaQuiff Sep 08 '13

I would like to counter this by saying firstly, who's opinion is it worth less to? The Football club? Other fans? Then, how do you differentiate?

Further more, what about people who buy other Merch? they give the club money just as the attendees of a match, is their opinion less than those who attend a match too? There are many ways to show your support for a team without attending matches, only 50,000 people can go to a match (rough guesstimate) so is there an elite 50,000 fans for top premier league teams. For example, I live in Glasgow and I support Celtic and Liverpool, money and schedules limit my attendances to Celtic matches and I most certainly can't go to Liverpool matches, but i still sure as hell buy a liverpool and Celtic top each season. am I a less worthy fan?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

I agree that to become a well-rounded football fan you should have been to at least a few games, just to gain another perspective.

But going to football games regularly does not give you an edge over someone who watches the same matches on TV. On TV you will always have the best view, you will see replays that show you the little things that make or break a footballer, you will have some commentary analysis which is hopefully enlightening.

There is a reason football coaches use match tapes to improve their teams.

9

u/Dwimer Sep 08 '13

On TV you will always have the best view, you will see replays that show you the little things that make or break a footballer, you will have some commentary analysis which is hopefully enlightening.

I find the opposite to be true honestly. You can see the whole field at a game, you watch what every player on the pitch does, how they move, how they act between transitions etc. You cant watch that on TV. You may be able to see who has the ball better on TV, but you cant see how everyone around him is moving.

There is a reason football coaches use match tapes to improve their teams.

Because they are meant to memorize everyones position and re-enact scenarios that happened instead? How else are you going to get your team to understand how a team 100s of kilometers away play? How are you meant to highlight mistakes that players did in the last game? Visually showing them is much easier. The player can't go back in time and watch what he did wrong. It doesnt mean its better than going to the game, there are a lack of realistic alternatives.

Why do coaches go to the actual matches when they are scouting players or teams instead of staying at home at watching it? Why are managers on the side of the pitch instead of watching the game on a monitor if its better?

you will have some commentary analysis which is hopefully enlightening.

There is only very little superficial analysis, and when it does happen, it only tends to focus on one play of the game. No commentary has ever explained the tactical approach to the game beyond things like possession, defensive, aggressive etc.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13

To add to your argument, you actually have proper experts (most of the time) commenting the game as it goes on, as opposed to fans calling the players names in the stands.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '13 edited Sep 09 '13

Watching on TV gives you a better view of the game. Going to the match is more fun and shows your dedication to your club, but when coaches go back and study film, they don't use cameras from the stands. They use the tv broadcasts because that is what lets you know more about the game.

edit: why the hell are people downvoting? this is a thread mostly for controversial views -- it's a great comment for this thread.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/Breklinho Sep 08 '13

Well I have two...

  1. As a whole the English national team is horribly overrated and the English youth system is a shadow of it's former self; the reliance of top English clubs on importing foreign talent has lead to the stagnation of English youth and young player's, "Fergie's Fledgling's" and "Busby's Babes" are now monuments of England's former youth system. The lack of integrating young English players into their club's first team (Southampton, Everton, Man U and Arsenal do this, but internal development and promotion of players is much rarer in other English clubs) has lead to some of England's most talented players struggling to find playing time and thus further develop; the lack of playing time for England's top talents and the retardation of their growth will lead to the collapse of the Three Lions as a World Cup or European Championship contender within 4-8 years once the current generation of players begin to decline in ability.
  2. The access to nearly 400,000,000 million potential players and the rapid growth of the USL, NASL and MLS as well as youth football as a whole will lead to the US becoming an international powerhouse within twenty to twenty-five years. Also Japan and South Korea with their massive populations and growing football infrastructure will become comparable international sides.

17

u/cartola Sep 08 '13

The access to nearly 400,000,000 million potential players and the rapid growth of the USL, NASL and MLS as well as youth football as a whole will lead to the US becoming an international powerhouse within twenty to twenty-five years. Also Japan and South Korea with their massive populations and growing football infrastructure will become comparable international sides.

There has never been, in history, a correlation between population size and football wins. There is no indication there will be as well.

3

u/TeemL Sep 09 '13

Agreed. If population size was an indicator of a nations footballing ability with regards to a massive population pool, then India, china and other Asian countries with massive populations should be powerhouses

Now evidently they are not, but then again this could be due to a lack of focus on football (in china) as they are clearly athletically talented as seen in the Olympics.

→ More replies (16)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

In response to 1, I don't know what mystical former England youth system you're referring to, the truth is England are probably as good now as they have been for the last 40 years, we may have just looked better in the past because football was less widespread and so there was less talent internationally among what seem to be lesser nations. The truth England have never been that good and it's nothing to do with foreign players in the league, we're not good with them and we weren't good without them.

With 2, there's a lot more to being an "international powerhouse" than population size, Spain's population is only 27th in the world, behind footballing countries like England, France, Italy, Nigeria and Russia, countries they're are all better than.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '13

As a whole the English national team is horribly overrated

How is it that players like Gerrard, Lampard, Terry and Rooney, clearly world class players who perform with their respective clubs do so badly/average when they're in the national team? Do you think they're made to look good by their foreign teammates?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Sep 09 '13

The access to nearly 400,000,000 million potential players and the rapid growth of the USL, NASL and MLS as well as youth football as a whole will lead to the US becoming an international powerhouse within twenty to twenty-five years. Also Japan and South Korea with their massive populations and growing football infrastructure will become comparable international sides.

If that argument was valid, China and Russia would be power houses and tiny countries like the Netherlands wouldn't be so good. There is no correlation between population and football.

Also, in 20-25 years you can produce a handfull of players who would be scouted and playing their whole life, and be hot prospects when they reach adulthood. The USA would have to do it now and i don't think a big fraction of those 400 million potential players would pick the sport against american football, basketball or baseball (heck, even hockey) right now. Europe and South America in comparrisson have been playing for more than 100 years, there is a well stabilished scouting and training as well as football culture and league tradition. Every kid played at least once and every one of them thought of having a life of a football player at least once.

What you are saying is that the USA can build up a league, culture and infra structure and be a contender within one generation against countries that have been doing it since the sport inception.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

-2

u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Sep 08 '13

The only people who think Ronaldo is better than Messi don't watch either of them play regularly.

Suarez is nowhere near being a world class player. He rarely shows up against top class opposition and would have been a complete flop at Real Madrid had he gone.