r/soccer • u/stopdropandlawl • Sep 27 '13
Ask beginner/intermediate soccer questions
I wanted to get a thread going where people could feel free to get answers to things they were always afraid to ask. I'll start off:
What is a false nine? What are the benefits of having one?
How do you know what formation a team employs? When I watch the game, the players are all over the field and obviously aren't in a formation you'd see in a textbook.
How does a defense actually execute an offside trap? It seems like it'll be really easy to mess up and then it'll be a one on one situation with the keeper.
It'll be great if we could get more people to ask questions about things they were curious about in soccer and get a deeper understanding of the game.
9
u/asalin1819 Sep 27 '13
Hope all that is clear, its late and GIS is a frustrating program.
4
u/McGrumble Sep 27 '13
Why do during preseason games/tours during the summer do players not wear names on the back on their kit/jersey. Example during Chelsea v Real Madrid during the Guinness cup final Ronaldo had 7 on the back of his jersey, but not his name.
Sorry on mobile
4
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '13
Why does everyone talk about how stats don't prove anything about how quality a player is, but then in the messi/Ronaldo argument stats are the only thing thrown around? Also why doesn't anyone consider who is more complete?
2
u/REGISTERED_PREDDITOR Sep 27 '13
What's the secret to juggling? I can pass, shoot, and dribble at an American collegiate level but I can never juggle the ball more than three times. It's just something I never practiced growing up.
1
u/BarcaFanSam Sep 27 '13
What is the difference between the "6" and the "8" for midfielders? My friends and I joke about this a lot but we really don't have a great answer for it... My assumptions come from watching barca play and how Xavi wears 6 and Iniesta wears 8
1
u/CommandNotFound Sep 27 '13
A fake nine would be a striker or a player that is a striker a clearly a 9 on paper, but tends to play a little more behind the friont line, I would have sayed that Totti is the best example but Totti just plays like Totti, and more false nine play similar to Totti.
Usually tends to connect more with the midfielders and create chances, is often more a result of the player individual characteristics than a deliberate formation, not every striker can play the position.
As formations, they are more clearly seen at trow ins, or goal kicks, you can easily see the lines that players form, or when the team is defending, most of the time you can see the horizontal 4 line and sometimes a double 4 line.
1
u/JABBAtheFUCK Sep 27 '13
The number 9 is classically the striker who takes up the space in the opposing teams back four, usually in between their CBs. For the most part in the build up play he is expected to make runs back towards his team and lay the ball off, hold it up and wait for team mates, or make runs in behind the defense for a break away or to be played into the corners. Once the play has been built into the opposing teams half, he still takes up the position of being in between the CBs, but will not drift from the center of the field very much because he is expected to be the target of most crosses. (See Torres with Liverpool, Or Ibra)
A 'false' nine is a player who will not make as many runs in behind the opposing defense. He will come further back towards his end of the pitch to collect the ball, and instead of laying off the ball and getting back into position in between the opposing CBs he will float in and around the midfield. Once the attack has built and they are in the opposing teams half, he will again make runs further back towards his end of the pitch, leaving the back four. For CBs this can be very annoying, since they are unsure if they should follow him into these deeper areas, or stay in line with their back four. Often they get dragged out of position and there is a hole for the attacking midfielders or wingers to make positive runs into.
There are other nuances that play into it but for the most part I think that explains it.
1
u/MadeinSomewhere Sep 27 '13
Where is the "sweet spot" when kicking the ball?
1
u/arkot Sep 27 '13
What are the rules regarding awarding of fouls? On many occasions I've seen fouls not given since the challenger got the ball. The player who originally had the ball seems to get tripped up in the process. What are the boundaries when making challenges?