r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Oct 24 '13
All Stars Season 3 Episode 1 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S03E01 "You Got Punked!"
Three previous winners of Project Runway will try to defend their title against eight other contenders of Project Runway. All designers have to create a look for Blondie's Debbie Harry, who is a guest judge on this episode too.
15
Upvotes
7
u/makeitworkoryouout Oct 27 '13
A surprise exit by Ari who nobody picked to leave before the 3rd week in the prediction contest. Similarly, nobody had Elena winning or Ari losing in the Weekly Picks Plus contest for this week. An upside down week to kick off this season!
5
u/yatcho Oct 25 '13 edited Oct 25 '13
Ari is getting a heavy losing edit this episode, my pick for first out (
and those pants are hideousnow shorts, still dont like the look).20
u/billsuits1 Oct 24 '13
I have set the bar low for Alyssa Milano as host given the performances of the past ones. The last one (Carolyn someone) always talked like she had a cough drop in her mouth.
23
u/TaxonomyAnomaly Oct 25 '13 edited Oct 25 '13
Damn, jeffrey and seth aaron look haggard.
10
u/Yearsnowlost Oct 25 '13
Wow they are really hawking QVC
10
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '13
Am I the only one left feeling a little unconvinced by this season?
I dunno, maybe my tastes are just changing, but this really just seems like a bunch of desperate, mediocre people trying to impress one another. Judges and contestants alike.
27
u/DarcyMcCarbomb Oct 25 '13
How did Seth Aaron not win that?
9
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '13
I didn't know the contestants going in, so seeing Seth Aaron was a very pleasant surprise. GO SETH.
9
u/everydyingember Oct 25 '13
I was surprised when they gave them the mp3 players and DIDN'T go off on a whole marketing shpeel about the product.
9
u/stomper253 Oct 26 '13
Ugggghhhhhh They're back!
This is probably my personal favorite group of designers.
Korto, Christopher, and Irena are some of the most delightfully bitchy designers. I'm so glad they're back.
I had so much stress worrying that someone who I loved was going to bomb, and no one really did. I'm still a little shocked that Ari got sent home because it was not a bad look. No one threw the challenge.
The thing I dislike the most about All Stars are the new judges. It makes me so angry that everyone presented something with good design elements, and Daniel did the same crap he always does. He doesn't understand color, he makes the same blazer over and over. If anyone from his season had been judging he would have been called out.
Also, Seth Aaron is going to run the season, I'm calling it now.
7
u/KateEJHS Oct 25 '13
So who is getting redeemed this season? Christopher or Viktor?
12
u/fragilehearted Oct 25 '13
I'm a little surprised Daniel wasn't on the bottom. His look was very similar to something he's made before: http://imgur.com/a/R9hZv#22
And I don't think it was that punk.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '13
Has Jeffrey adopted the persona of Frito Bandito?
22
u/jenn_xP Oct 25 '13 edited Oct 25 '13
"We love how creative you were to make it look like your jacket was backwards, totally inspired by a straight jacket, its amazing"... NO it IS backwards and your model's way of saving you UGH
EDIT: Done... I... I can't even
5
u/chelseayn Oct 25 '13
I think this will be a decent season of All-Stars; there are some really good competitors on this one! It seems too soon for Daniel to be coming back after his season, and I am surprised at the number of "nice guys" that are on this season--the guys that make it far on their season but if you really look at their clothing it is either one-note (ahem, Christopher and Daniel) or the taste is hit or miss (nudge nudge Daniel and Mychael).
12
u/B_Elanna_Torres Oct 24 '13
GO ELENA!!!
8
u/joeyGibson Oct 25 '13
Not one of those designers knows what "punk" means. Of course, I don't think anyone under the age of 40 can truly understand punk... But that's just my opinion...
6
u/excessiongirl Oct 26 '13
I'm an Aussie and have just gotten the ep, 5 minutes in, my thoughts so far:
Is Irena wearing some crazy ass contouring or has she had work done?? She looks all tight and freaky :/
LOVING Ari!!
Elena looks insanely hot in those leather leggings. Love that crazy bitch.
As someone else said - Jeffrey and Seth Aaron both look kinda rough!!
Totes shallow that I'm just ranting about how they all look, but I am so excited to see them all again...
8
u/lj_arctic Oct 25 '13
How did the judges love Jeffery's look? It was by far the worst one, that fake-leopard-print-stuffed-animal crap on the front was just awful. I thought for sure he would be out.
5
u/Yearsnowlost Oct 25 '13
Woo go Daniel (and moustache)!
2
u/Phoolf Oct 24 '13
OMG It's not even up on realitytv yet
I am sad
2
u/ecokitty Oct 25 '13
ugh I just moved and don't have HD anymore... I have no idea what I'm looking at with like 8 pixels on my TV :(
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '13
Top lel this episode:
Isaac: There's a trashiness to punk, sorry to use that word.
Debbie: Don't look at me and say that!