r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Oct 31 '13
All Stars Season 3 Episode 2 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S03E02 "Bitten by the Fashion Bug"
The designers have to create an avant-garde look and insects at the American Museum of Natural History serve as inspiration to them. Season 9 Winner Anya Ayoung Chee and jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer are the guest judges.
4
Upvotes
14
u/makeitworkoryouout Nov 01 '13
After the surprise results last week of Elena winning and Ari going home the world has half returned to normal with Daniel early departure which many people had predicted. Elena continues to defy the prognosticators though. Jeffrey picks up the dubious honor of being the jekyll/Hyde so far with a top and bottom appearance in the first two weeks.
8
u/makeitworkoryouout Nov 01 '13
I'm just glad to see over the top looks instead of more pedestrian fashion for an avant-garde challenge. Not sure if it's due to their "all star" pedigree or not but at least nearly everyone (cough Melissa) gave us something out there fashion-wise.
37
u/Squishter Nov 01 '13
Mentor Zanna:"how does this speak avant garde" Designer: Seth: "have you seen this before?" Mentor Zanna: "....nooo,,"
love that response...shut down on Zanna!
23
u/konfetkak Nov 01 '13
Alyssa Milano sounds like she's drunk and trying really hard not to sound drunk.
21
u/gussets Nov 02 '13
The concept of Anya judging designers like Seth Aaron and Irena (hell, even Daniel) is ridiculous. BUT, I would LOVE to see her as a contestant in All-Stars and get schooled by all the other designers. Still salty over her win.
40
u/bleublancrouge Nov 01 '13
And Isaac Mizrahi proves to be the biggest douche judge the show has ever featured in Project Runway history. "She can't drink a cocktail in this" is a fucking stupid piece of "criticism", especially for an AVANT-GARDE challenge. It's not "constructive" either because it doesn't provide any direction for Jeffrey to learn from, besides "watch out because we might give you totally arbitrary briefs you'll be expected to just know". Good for Jeffrey for standing up for himself and pointing out how ridiculous Mizrahi is. If he gets eliminated from the show, I hope he makes something that will give a big finger to the judges on the way out.
Anyway, I should've expected this kind of bullshittery after watching Mizrahi swoon over every freaking thing Ryan-Anthony made last season. They even go so far as to get Tim Gunn to claim that no part of PR is rigged... how stupid do these producers think we are?
14
u/7seagulls Nov 01 '13
Am I the only one who thinks Zanna kinda blows as a mentor? One white stripe does not a zebra make! I won't even talk about Alyssa, I don't think anyone here is going to be defending her. The reception the designers gave Anya was pretty funny! Overall, I have to say I'm disappointed with most of the designers so far. Korto and Chris seem to be bringing something new (good or bad? not sure yet), but everyone else has shown looks that could have fit into their final collections! Well, except Jeffrey, but only because he seems to have forgotten a good deal of his sewing skills.
19
u/inertia__creeps Nov 01 '13
Booooo, sad to see Daniel go! I know his design wasn't too good, but I just love his attitude and spirit. He was always the one complimenting and being friendly to everyone, even in confessional. Everybody else is just so negative :(
26
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13
Jeffrey sends out a fucking weird, never before seen outfit and its too literal. Elena sends her model out dressed as an actual bug and everyone loves it.
9
u/FormerDittoHead Nov 01 '13
I hope someone will tell Elena to either stop the drama or start losing. She looked like she was going to faint, for crying out loud.
7
u/Bread_Heads Nov 01 '13
Did anyone else find Anya's comment about Elena's amazing choice of fabric and how she had to be "strategic" in her choices ironic, given that Elena was on the verge of having a meltdown at Mood?
5
u/Spinfo Nov 02 '13
I find it so weird to have a past winner as a judge. Kinda like saying "This is what you should have done with this opportunity and you wouldn't be competing still!" to all of the others. Especially Seth Aaron, Irina and Jeffrey that also are previous winners.
4
u/billsuits1 Nov 01 '13
Gee I hope Alyssa's career turns around for her. It looked like she was going to an open casting call for the remake of The Wrath of Khan after the show.
Why does she always talk like is so bored?
5
u/TheLadyEve Nov 02 '13
I think Jeffrey's look was a bit too much of a joke. I thought the fabrics he picked looked cheap (Nina would have called that out, I'm betting) and the big constructed ring around her torso made me think "lampshade" rather than scorpion.
3
u/chelseayn Nov 01 '13
Not surprised with the outcome, I knew he wasn't going to make it long on this season. I like All Stars, if for no other reason that the judges seem to be more objective about the design of outfits, not just loyalties to designers as people. Heidi seems to get stuck on people and they make it through when they don't deserve it. These judges pick the worst designers to go home. Sorry D.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment