r/soccer • • Dec 19 '13

Who is the most overrated player of your team?

Currently, there are no players at my club (Juve) who are being overrated by the media. I don't understand why Conte keeps playing Padoin though..

186 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

38

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Bryan Ruiz, at least by those who don't watch Fulham every week. Too often walks through games and gives the ball away yet is often rated as one of our key players.

14

u/M_McFly Dec 19 '13

You mean how he gets routinely booed by the crowd? Yes, the media overrate him, but I think the crowd at CC really underrate him.

14

u/elquiche Dec 19 '13

I fucking hate Bryan Ruiz. Far too lazy, and not good enough to be so lazy.

1

u/HuYuHaiDing Dec 19 '13

That has always been his main critique when he still played in the Netherlands. In the Dutch competition he has the time and space to do something with the ball. The PL is just to fast paced for him.

→ More replies (5)

31

u/thomasjeff Dec 19 '13

Riccardo Montolivo.

13

u/HuYuHaiDing Dec 19 '13

I'm really curious how Allegri will play after the winter break. I don't think he will start with Honda and Montolivo. That would be far too attacking for his mindset. What's your recommended line-up?

→ More replies (12)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Exactly! He's inconsistent and I honestly don't know how to play Monti and De Jong together. De Jong is the best midfielder we've had in years. I know that 3 years ago we still had Pirlo, Seedorf and Gattuso, but they were way past their prime. It turns out Pirlo needed a change of environment, but still he wasn't playing his best football during his last year(s) in Milan.

Too bad we made Montolivo a captain. He's now practically unbenchable. With Honda arriving in January I can't see Poli getting any playtime.

→ More replies (19)

13

u/godsdog23 Dec 19 '13

Ricky Van Wolfswinkel.

2

u/HuYuHaiDing Dec 19 '13

I was kind of surprised when Norwich contracted him and labeled him has their goalgetter. He never made alot of field goals in his career. Hooper is a far better goalgetter than Van Wolfswinkel. Although I think Ricky is a good bloke.

→ More replies (7)

156

u/apotre Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13

Burak Yılmaz.

He is a striker/winger whose first touch is about as good as your average Sunday League Footballer. He also cannot pass the ball for a goal scoring opportunity or even save his life. His positioning and run timings are horrible as well, he will be offside for 30 times before he can set up his runs not to fall to the offside trap. Cannot head the ball whatsoever either, even if there is no one marking him.

He is also a very egoistical player who lacks any sort of teamwork and his way of putting pressure on the opponents is light jogging towards the ball while making sure that he doesn't have to track back once the player in possession passes it to someone else.

Despite all the negative aspects there are still things he does well. His diving is arguably the best in the league, he does this hip motion where he throws all his lower body forward while pulling his upper body and you can swear that he gets shot by a sniper at every tackle. Very impressive diving form, arguably better than Ashley Young, but doesn't get the recognition he deserves outside of Turkey.

Unfortunately we couldn't offload him to Lazio last summer because of his scumbag agent. One of the most overrated players ever to grace the Turkish League.

77

u/H4d193 Dec 19 '13

That analysis was brutal

27

u/Fatix Dec 19 '13

Yet, very accurate.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/THEBEAST666 Dec 19 '13

I like what in hearing

4

u/apotre Dec 19 '13

Let me tell you about Drogba's amazing form..

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

He scored 32 goals in 39 games for you last year, he can't be that bad, surely?

17

u/apotre Dec 19 '13

After failing to do any sort of impact at Beşiktaş, Fenerbahçe and many others, he managed to find the form of his life at Trabzonspor and had a total of 3 years of reasonable success.

2 of those years were in Trabzonspor, where he had Selçuk who is one of the best playmakers in the league playing behind him feeding through balls all day long and the rest of team only existed to assist Burak as well. He managed to carry that confidence into Galatasaray and got lucky with a couple of strikes on the way and all of a sudden he was being compared to Cristiano Ronaldo.

Not necessarily a bad player, he would be a star for most of the Turkish League sides, but in no way should be the main attacking outlet of Galatasaray, yet alone be the toenail of C.Ronaldo.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Fatix Dec 19 '13

He gets into shitloads of posession and misses majority of them. If any other forward player with some intelligence would score more than him easily. All of my GS fan friends are not satisfied with him.

→ More replies (4)

301

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Jermain Defoe! If I hear another commentator talk about how he'll always score you goals and he only needs one chance because his movement and positioning is so good when I've just watched him bee offside 8 times and miss 6 chances I'll cry.

most goals he scored in a season was 18 and that was when he got 5 against Wigan, he's a 12 goals a season player.

183

u/Astral_Fox Dec 19 '13

Triffic lad, real family man.

37

u/ucd_pete Dec 19 '13

Top, top, top, top, top, top, top, top, top, top player...

25

u/-notthesun- Dec 19 '13

Well I'll gladly take him off your hands for you.

7

u/Astral_Fox Dec 19 '13

You will, don't worry.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/mappsy91 Dec 19 '13

The last two matches he' played hopefully have put a big dent in the "he'll always score goals' myth

→ More replies (18)

5

u/Mr_MacGrubber Dec 19 '13

the main part of his game I don't like is that he almost never passes in the final third. He could have a runner looking at an empty net while Defoe has no angle and he'll let er rip anyway. Occasionally they go in so it reaffirms that he's doing the right thing it seems.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

65

u/borensoren Dec 19 '13

I can only pick one?

2

u/keko191 Dec 19 '13

Adebayor is probably your best striker

→ More replies (2)

287

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Will Hughes. Are you reading this Premier League scouts? Will Hughes is overrated. Don't even bother trying for him. Waste of money. Total garbage. I don't even know who he is and I have a season ticket for Derby. Total passenger.

Honest.

12

u/KeepCalmAndFuckOff Dec 19 '13

If you're lucky he could be the next Giles Barnes

→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Haha on a serious note, how's he getting on? I get so excited about young English prospects, really don't want another disappointment

127

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Looks good but he's far from made it yet. The good thing is he plays like he knows it, he grafts as hard as those with half his ability. People bang on a bit about Jack Wilshere, but I'd honestly rather have Hughes. He tackles, has goals in him, is willing to make himself available, takes passes under pressure and almost always finds a black and white shirt with a pass. And it's almost always the 'right' pass, none of this trying-to-find-highlight-reel-perfection-but-hoofing-it-40-yards-into-touch rubbish that English football seems to wank over. None of this running ten yards with the ball, getting into trouble, turning around and making the easy pass that was on before you made the run either. God dammit I hate that shit about the English game. He seems much more cultured, more intelligent with his use of the ball.

TLDR he's shit, fuck off, find your own kids.

12

u/shard_ Dec 19 '13

I think this is a very good description of him. He's not without the dribbling or long range passing skills but his decision making belies his age because he knows exactly when to keep it simple (which is most of the time).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Nice try.

→ More replies (8)

146

u/Re1nForce Dec 19 '13

I thought Eto'o was gonna be the one but fuck me has he disappointed

46

u/duckman273 Dec 19 '13

Not overrated though, everyone was saying he was past it when he came and most people still think he's shit now.

25

u/Bzamora Dec 19 '13

This, no one expected Eto'o to play like he did back in the days. Most people expected him to be a non-starter.

→ More replies (24)

48

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Tom Ince.

Dire work ethic.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Have to agree after watching him at Pride Park. Seems unwilling to run, tackle, pressure and goes down too easily. He looks like he has talent but an attitude of "I'm better than this club" if I'm honest. He plays like him making it is just a formality.

That's only one game I've seen though. We had a player like that, Giles Barnes. Ever heard of him? Nope. He'd do well to get his head down and graft.

9

u/Astral_Fox Dec 19 '13

The hype machine spins.

I can agree with your assessment; I haven't seen him live but he clearly has that bit of arrogance about him which is revolting for a young player, and frankly, that is concerning for him on a career-level.

I reckon he's waiting for a big club to come calling, we'll see if he changes at all if and when he gets a transfer. If he doesn't he'll be another "almost" player.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/layendecker Dec 19 '13

What I always hear in his defence is that he is 'still young' and 'will grow in time'- but the fact is, he is nearly 22. If he has not grown up by now, I don't see an amazingly bright future for him.

→ More replies (7)

55

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Adam Johnson. Been woeful since we signed him.

44

u/Swinsee Dec 19 '13

Was generally pretty crap for City too. Best description I heard of him was that he's a "Match of the Day player". Scores some good goals and can look good in highlights so people tend to overrate him.

22

u/bobosuda Dec 19 '13

Eh, he wasn't that crap. Personally I don't think he was a good match for City, but he had more than his fair share of moments. I forget what season it was, his last or second-to-last, but he actually had a pretty good amount of goals/assists even without being a starter.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/AlanOC91 Dec 19 '13

All the stick we got from non-city fans when we never played him....Christ.

I love the guy and on his day he could win a match for us but that rarely occurred. He was definitely a hard worker for us though.

→ More replies (5)

150

u/Pway Dec 19 '13

Gerrard is both overrated and underrated by a fair amount of people. He's still an important player for us in many ways, but he doesn't carry us any where near as much as he used to (nor should he be expected to), and some facets of his game are actually detrimental to how we play sometimes.

He's very important for us when it comes to breaking down teams who look to sit deep and defend, and his distribution from set pieces is visibly missing when he doesn't play. That said, his legs and the tempo of his general play have left us a little out matched in midfield vs the better teams this last couple of seasons.

48

u/layendecker Dec 19 '13

In the Merseyside derby he was the worst player on the pitch. Managed to deliver one great free kick, but squandered plenty more, let us in twice with sloppy passing deep and couldn't make a pass.

Not that he is a bad player one bit, but I feel Liverpool still rely on his far too much as a creative outlet.

63

u/Pway Dec 19 '13

That's the thing, against (urgh) top quality opponents he does struggle, it was the same in the Arsenal game. Then against teams where he has a bit more time, and we get a lot more set pieces he has been great. I know it sounds weird but I think his injury has actually helped Rodgers out a little, everyone has seen what a midfield of Allen/Henderson/Lucas offers and when we're playing tough away games in the future I don't think he'll be criticized if he drops Stevie.

Either way I'm still glad he's on our team, and he still has plenty to offer, as well as all the other things he brings to the squad.

39

u/layendecker Dec 19 '13

That's the thing, against (urgh) top quality opponents he does struggle,

What was that? Not sure if I heard that one correctly.. :D


I think his issue is that he needs a second on the ball, and as he is not a quick footed as he once was, he can't steal it with a sneaky sidestep that he used to. Teams who play a very active press will be on him before he has time to set himself up.

He can still be effective, but just not relied upon to deliver all the creativity in the midfield.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/Syggie Dec 19 '13

I think I could replace Gerrard with Riquelme and I would've been the one who wrote this exact same thing.

I totally understand you.

52

u/GonvVasq Dec 19 '13

Let's be real, at least Gerrard can move

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

He's about 82 years old now, can't be expected to carry the team.

→ More replies (14)

36

u/Sheesh_Kebab Dec 19 '13

Deulofeu from non-Everton fans. I've seen people on here say our season is disrupted now he's injured. He doesn't even start for fucks sake and when he does play he's so hit and miss.

17

u/NFeKPo Dec 19 '13

I think most Everton fans rate him fairly. He can come on and change a game but don't expect him to track back and play defense. You are right though I have noticed that non-Everton fans think he is the man of the match (or Lukaku) every match and don't realize that he has had a very limited role in our games until very recently.

5

u/Sheesh_Kebab Dec 19 '13

Yeah I agree. He had a great game against Stoke tracking back as well as ripping them apart. Other than that and the goal against Arsenal he's done very little.

Lukaku is another one as you mentioned. Doesn't offer much with the ball at his feet outside the box but everyone in /r/soccer thinks he's our star player every game.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

528

u/devineman Dec 19 '13

Yaya Toure.

Yaya is a phenomenally good player. On his day.

The problem is that you can't be a world class player without an extremely high "low point". A good example of this is Paul Scholes. The reason Scholes was so good was that when he had a great game he dominated and when he had a bad game, his level of performance was still good enough to be passable in the Premier League and Champions League.

Balotelli on the other hand is extremely good in one game where he will absolutely dominate it, and so poor in others that a Championship team would scoff at him.

I have made this image to demonstrate the different types of players. Don't laugh, fuckers.

The top performance "graph" shows the simplified performance of Mario Balotelli over the season. The highs in this graph are higher than any other but the lowers are lower. This is an inconsistent performer and you cannot have many of these in any squad design as your team becomes totally inconsistent. New Premier League managers seem to make this mistake a lot.

The second performance graph is Paul Scholes. Paul Scholes still has great performances but the lower end of his performances aren't awful. Every time this type of player steps out onto the pitch, you know that you will get at least a decent performance and possibly an excellent one. This has to be the main bulk of any 25 man squad for it to have any chance of winning trophies over a 38 game season. If you cannot predict the game, you cannot manage the game.

The third performance graph is Gareth Barry. Barry will almost never have a bad game but his stand out performances are few and far between. There are two theories on this type of performance player; either you can't have too many of them because they are the most predictable, or you can have too many of them because they are entirely predictable. Managers tend to have their own opinions, I've always thought that this isn't the performance curve that anybody should aim for. It gives you a good chance of a squad place but it also negatively affects your decision making ability as you are constantly looking for the easy ball rather than the right ball.

My problem with Yaya Toure is that he's far too close the graph 1 for my liking. I don't think a graph 1 player can ever really be in the "world class" bracket despite stand out performances.

370

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Label your fuckin axis, mate.

80

u/devineman Dec 19 '13

I also have shitty graphs that covers most of the other players in this thread.

Here's one for why all "stars of the future" turn out average and is just fans tricking themselves

I'm a wiz with Paint. I labelled the axis just for you aswell.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

149

u/adotg Dec 19 '13

We're getting sin and cosine graphs up in here

166

u/devineman Dec 19 '13

In football circles the tangent graph is known as "The Liverpool seasonal chart"

31

u/RedScouse Dec 19 '13

I'm not Glen Johnson. Explain to me what this means so I can laugh?

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

46

u/fuckingFILA Dec 19 '13

We'll fucking take him.

29

u/archylittle Dec 19 '13

I'll go pick him up myself.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Casson8 Dec 19 '13

I like the way you've simplified several types of players into 3 primary groups. Obviously there's gonna be the odd outlier of a player but represents a large amount of the population.

I'd say KdB, and possibly David Luiz due to his inconsistency, mainly due to the point that he can have a brilliant game then have an absolute shocker.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/DIRobertson Dec 19 '13

Stefan Syzmanski would be proud of those graphs.

13

u/Peter_Campbell Dec 19 '13

So Messi and Ronaldo are like the Gareth Barry curve, but at the same level as the top of the Balotelli curve?

28

u/devineman Dec 19 '13

The black line isn't some arbitrary line of "rating of 5 in the paper" but is the "normal" performance of each player and the red curve shows the form. Maybe we can say that the black line is the "expected performance of the player due to their talent levels" and the red line is form.

I would actually say that Messi and Ronaldo have a curve more akin to Paul Scholes, their black line is just considerable better than everybody else's. They do however go through small patches of bad form by their standards yet it is still within the realm of good, if that makes any sense.

13

u/Sgt_peppers Dec 19 '13

More sense than R/soccer in any given day.

29

u/julianface Dec 19 '13

came here for a Yaya Toure comment. Left with a great devineman analysis AND more Barry praising! Christmas came early.

18

u/HyperactiveToast Dec 19 '13

Beat me to it, City have this stigma of assuming they have won some of the easier games before they have happened - Toure is a big factor in that. When he is good, he's great but when he is bad, man, is he bad.

I would say Nasri too, but Pellegrini has fixed that right up and he is playing well every game this season .

14

u/trivialcheese Dec 19 '13

I completely agree. A few weeks ago I was laughed at (not on here) for saying Fernandinho is the more valuable player. I avoided saying the best player because Yaya's peaks are higher but the level that Fernandinho plays at is consistently very high.

Maybe that's why he isn't preferred in the Brazil squad. He doesn't have that many games where he is the best on the pitch (Arsenal game being one if them), so doesn't stand out when compared to some players with more flair.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/SecretPoodle Dec 19 '13

Basically, Yaya is a high variance player.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

85

u/optimus_fuck Dec 19 '13

balotelli

22

u/Alder_ Dec 19 '13

Ever since Reina saved the penalty, all I've heard is how bad Balotelli has been.

→ More replies (12)

28

u/trivialcheese Dec 19 '13

Is he still wildly inconsistent?

91

u/heeero60 Dec 19 '13

What he is, is an asshole. But he is very good at being one.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/FrejDexter Dec 19 '13

He was shit the entire game against Roma. In one split second, he stopped being shit, and Milan salvaged a point. Then he went back to being shit.

2

u/KinneySL Dec 20 '13

Balotelli is Antonio Cassano with more melanin. Ludicrously gifted, but so immature that he's just as likely to ruin your team as he is to star for it.

→ More replies (7)

16

u/godie Dec 19 '13

For new Barca fans, the answer is most of La Masia young players.

After Messi, Xavi, Iniesta, Busquets...etc etc, people are sure that Deloufeu is the next Ronaldo, Tello was amazing, Adama is the new Eto'o....Roberto the new Xavi...

I do believe that La Masia is the best academy, but people don't realize that the current generation of great players was the exception and not the rule.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

You know who was the next Xavi, Thiago.

→ More replies (3)

69

u/layendecker Dec 19 '13

Tough to say really, as Everton had a ton of overrated players when Moyes was around.

This is because of Moyes, and the reason he was so successful. He has a very deliberate, somewhat obvious system that rarely changed. Because of this every player knew exactly what he had to do, the system became second nature to the lads.

This was amazing for Everton, mediocre players were made to look fantastic- because their job had been crafted to suit their skillset (even if it was limited), and they could drill particular techniques week on week that would help them do that exact job.

The first, and perhaps most obvious example of this was Joleon Lescott. At Everton he looked like a real top player, City bought him for a kings ransom, and he took a long time to gain anything close to the form he showed for us.

I digress however.

If you asked me last season, I would have strongly said that Osman was our most overrated player. He is rather weak on the ball, his passing range isn't that good, he makes silly positional mistakes and his shooting is amongst the worst in the league. When Moyes was in the job however he had his job to do (distribute to the flanks from deep), and he did it very well.

This led to him being called up for England and, unsurprisingly bombing in an England shirt. Got to say he deserved the call up based on his commitment to the game and work ethic, that could never be questioned.. His talent however is what always comes short.

Since Martinez has been in charge, he has been more obviously poor. Despite doing well against Villa, and getting a goal vs Fulham (in a game he was pretty damn poor in overall) so I think the non-Bluenoses are beginning to latch onto the fact he isn't that great.


Other than Osman, Pienaar is certainly overrated. Not that he is a bad player, just he is constantly spoken about as one of our biggest talents by non-Evertonians, when the fact is he is probably the worst player in our standard starting 11.

There are times where he looks magical on the ball, but these moments not too common, and they are getting rarer and rarer as he is getting older. That being said, he is hugely important to the way we play, as his defensive workrate is astonishing.

Barkley is also very overrated at this point. He has games where he is magic, but he also has games where he is a significant detriment to the side. He reminds me a lot of Wilshire- they both have an amazing amount of technical ability and potential, but both are yet to really work out how to use it in a game.

That being said, the kid is only 19- and is a huge talent for that age, not taking anything away from that. He is also a real workhorse and a humble lad who would be playing footie for free if he couldn't get paid for it.

37

u/maffu_ Dec 19 '13

disagree about pienaar, one of our most consistent players over the last few years. he makes full backs look absolutely amazing, see his partnership with baines/oviedo.

I understand the Osman bashing, as hes everyones favourite target

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

115

u/turnvknup Dec 19 '13

I hate saying this but I think it's Pique

24

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Pique just needs a good partner, look at him when he plays with Ramos or a fit Puyol, he's a completely different player.

25

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

He's a good follower not a leader. Puyol and Ramos (to a lesser degree) keep him in check. It's like Khedira without Xabi Alonso. Both Pique and Khedira are very good players when played correctly. But without those conditions, they look very lackluster and you wonder if they're actually the same players.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/egcg119 Dec 19 '13

I don't think that's true at all, most people, cules and otherwise, have been establishing this narrative that Pique is a shit defender.

He might not be the world's best at the moment, and he fucks up sometimes, but he is a very good player, and I think he's been playing like it this season.

Him and Bartra are an excellent partnership, and I think Pique's play improved as a result. Masch has been off form and I think makes things more chaotic at the back, and Puyol's not what he used to be. But once paired with a talented, natural defender, who's also a young player who he can mentor, Pique began to perform excellently and consistently.

6

u/PeteyWonders Dec 19 '13

He also has some of the best vision and passing ability of any central defender.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/AhoyDaniel Dec 19 '13

I think we culés agree with you.

22

u/fjperez12 Dec 19 '13

Both him and Ramos are prone to mistakes, but I do not think he is your most overrated. He's solid, especially playing next to Ramos for la roja. Maybe it has to do with Busquets and Xabi (Two most underrated players on Barca and los blancos respectively) playing the double pivot, but I think he has proven his worth.

18

u/Bzamora Dec 19 '13

I think both Busquets and Xabi gets a lot of cred. Xabi have always been rated while Busquets getting his fair share nowadays aswell.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

I think Alves might be overrated this season. As in, the attack does not rely on him like it used to.

2

u/Tezemery Dec 19 '13

Couldn't agree more although he has got better this season, last season he was awful and I still think Bartra is our best central defender personally.

→ More replies (21)

251

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13

Jack Wilshere and it's not even close. I love the guy but he's not been playing consistently well for a while now and he needs lots of time to get back to full sharpness being out for so long.

EDIT: I should add, I'm saying this as an Arsenal fan, not just an England fan.

36

u/bellend1234 Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13

I think his issues this season have arisen when he has to play on the left. Playing centrally or cutting in from the right, he's been decent and consistent.

27

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Even when he's been having mediocre/poor games he's shown flashes of creative brilliance.

He had a horrible game against Man City, then out of nowhere he played an absolutely beautiful ball to Giroud which should really have been put away. Same against West Brom where he played terribly for 70 minutes then smashed home a beautiful shot, followed shortly after by a 30 metre defence splitting pass to Giroud... which was wasted again.

He's so obviously an unbelievably talented player that I find it difficult to say he's over-rated. He's in bad form and being played in the wrong position, but he is without a doubt one of the best young players in the world.

→ More replies (7)

33

u/HansSven Dec 19 '13

Like you said, he's been out for so long:

13/14: 02.11.2013 to 08.11.2013 - Sprained Ankle

12/13: 11.03.2013 to 10.04.2013 - Malleolar injury

11/12: 22.05.2012 to 24.09.2012 - Knee-OP

11/12: 01.02.2012 to 15.05.2012 - Fatigue Fracture

11/12: 26.09.2011 to 31.01.2012 - Some other injury

11/12: 31.07.2011 to 25.09.2011 - Sprained Ankle

09/10: 20.11.2009 to 02.12.2009 - Malleolar injury

And he's been playing out of position this season, and he's still only 21 years old...He'll be fine.

113

u/MethLab Dec 19 '13

08/13 01.01.2008 to 31.12.2013 - Marlboro Lights

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

62

u/layendecker Dec 19 '13

Arsenal look so, so much better when Rosicky plays. Wenger just seems to be madly in love with Wilshire- he has a ton of technique, yes; but fails to deliver results with it far too often.

90

u/SlappyBagg Dec 19 '13

Of course he's gonna play Wilshere. He's only 21 and has a bright future ahead of him, probably going to be at Arsenal for a long time.

→ More replies (13)

40

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Arsenal seems to play much quicker with Rosicky on the pitch. We need Walcott and Podolski fully fit so our five hundred playmakers actually have some direct players to link up with.

16

u/Blubbey Dec 19 '13

Turns out Rosicky is 33. I had no idea he was that old.

33

u/jkonine Dec 19 '13

He claims that his's legs are those of a 27 year old because he's been out so long.

And now that we're seeing him play at a fully fit level, I have to agree. When fit, he is a spectacular player.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (30)

165

u/felixpaulmichael Dec 19 '13

Hate to say it but David Luiz

110

u/archylittle Dec 19 '13

David luiz can be Brilliant for 89 minutes but the 1 minute he loses his concentration is the 1 minute you'll need him to be at his best. Once he can get rid of that, he'll be world class or close to it.

20

u/notsoobviousreddit Dec 19 '13

This throws me back a few years. When he was still playing at Benfica we always used to say this. He's great, but when he fails it results in a goal.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/InBartraWeBelieve Dec 19 '13

I hate to agree with you. I love to see him play and his passing skills are great but he makes to many defensive mistakes.

30

u/felixpaulmichael Dec 19 '13

Even his defensive work rate is always great and he does amazing takles but then out of nowhere does something incredibly stupid

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/jamieflood Dec 19 '13

Luiz would be a quality defender in a different team, Barcelona for example. Him and Terry don't suit each other.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/MiguelCaldoVerde Dec 19 '13

I really have to disagree here. I don't know how much it makes sense to call him overrated when all anybody focuses on are his flaws. He cut out a lot of the silly mistakes at the end of last season and then when Mourinho came in and changed the system, which Luiz had less time to adapt to due to the Confederations Cup (in which he was massive) he started cocking up a bit more. But he still has a lot of qualities are a defender and as a more all round player that get overlooked cause of a few silly mistakes every now and then.

If you want a more overrated player in Chelsea, I'd personally say Cahill. Cahill looks great on highlight reels because of a lot of last ditch tackles and interceptions but it's often his fault for allowing attackers in to those positions in the first place. Ivanovic and KdB are two other honorable mentions for Chelsea's most overrated player.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (36)

12

u/Breklinho Dec 19 '13

Probably Donovan. He's great, don't get me wrong, but he's too anonymous for too much of too many games last year; he's still great when he does get on the ball and offers a lot when he drops into midfield, but last season he was not the game changing player that he had been for the previous ten years.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/f1manoz Dec 19 '13

Sunderland don't have any over-rated players.

Sunderland barely have rated players. Except for Wes Brown this season. He's been magnificent since his return from injury.

45

u/rrayy Dec 19 '13

For the USMNT: Clint Dempsey

Doesn't contribute much to buildup, is getting old, out of form, took the money in favor of competing for a good team, and is unfortunately too much of a talisman to drop at this point. Blasphemy, I know, but hopefully he proves me wrong at the World Cup.

2

u/fluffinatrajp Dec 20 '13

I don't think he is overrated anymore. Even Seattle is trying to drop him already

→ More replies (6)

87

u/Alder_ Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13

Shinji Kagawa for United. It breaks my heart to the point of curling up and crying.

94

u/HansSven Dec 19 '13

He just can't break into that strong Waterford Utd starting XI. You need to give him a chance to play.

17

u/Alder_ Dec 19 '13

Yeah sadly :(

51

u/bosnian_red Dec 19 '13

Kagawa seems to be massively underrated by most English united fans. He just doesn't suit our system that has no off the ball movement, and is pure wing play. It doesn't make him shit, it's just he doesn't suit our style. Put him at arsenal, or back to Dortmund, and he'll look great again. The few times United had a lot of off the ball movement, he's looked great for us. It's not fair to label him shit every time, or think more games will make him come good. It won't, unless we completely change the way we play, which we won't.

United just isn't suited to attacking midfield type players, who are more team players, like ozil, kagawa, silva, etc. for united, you need to have some individualism about you, the ability to take players on and beat a man, to take games by the scruff of the neck and turn them around. Ozil, even though he's probably the best attacking midfielder in the world, would look lost at united as well because there would be no proper midfield giving him balls up the pitch, or he'd be shunted to the wing to cross it in always.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/WestOfAnfield Dec 19 '13

Sell him to us!

4

u/Alder_ Dec 19 '13

Give us Suarez before he gets banned because his celebration promotes violence!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

51

u/slurpherp Dec 19 '13

Marco Reus.

Reus is the best player on the pitch, at times. But he has such a strong tendency to make stupid mistakes and make the wrong decision. He gets caught living offside 4-5 times a game, his on target shot percentage is really low, he always thinks shoot first even when a great pass is there. He shows evidence of greatness probably 2-3 times a game, but he is just wildly inconsistent.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13

The biggest factor, in my opinion, in the recent sting of poor performances for Dortmund (other than injuries) is Marco Reus right now. His creativity has completely dried up and his decision making has been at numerous faults. On his day (such as in the first quarter of this season) he is heads and shoulders above the rest of the team, but ever since that Arsenal game he has blunted the Dortmund attack by providing fairly little going forward.

11

u/slurpherp Dec 19 '13

You're absolutely right, he has lost all creativity.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/Mimogger Dec 19 '13

This sounds like my descriptuon of walcott 2 years ago

9

u/Crys368 Dec 19 '13

To be fair, that description fits all our attackers more or less.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

It definitely applied to Goetze, but I think Lewa is pretty consistent.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Swagolas Dec 19 '13

Most of our attackers have been wildly inconsistent this season, can't just call one out especially when you think about how our current injury problems is probably taking a big toll on their confidence.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/teymon Dec 19 '13

Bojan i think.

4

u/1mdelightful Dec 19 '13

Bojan is the only player that people outside of the Netherlands actually rate. For me its Serero. Sure he has buckets of energy and has a high work rate but he squanders essentially every chance he gets.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Vilhena

4

u/heeero60 Dec 19 '13

Fokking Immers...

Although there was a ery sympathetic piece about him in Metro the other day. Dispite having gained a tiny amount of sympathy with me, I still think he is one of the worst players in the squad.

15

u/teymon Dec 19 '13

Who the fuck overrates Immers?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

He does contribute a lot in defense.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

86

u/BostonFucktard Dec 19 '13

Kevin De Bruyne.

I know he played amazing in the Bundesliga, but ever since he came to the PL, he's very disappointing. He's completely lost in the pitch. They say he needs minutes, but every minute he plays, is worse than the last one.

40

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

In his defense, they were much more patient with him at Bremen. He had a slow start there too while being pretty much a guaranteed starter from day one on. Took him what must have been about 10 games to get his form up.

If he had been given as few opportunities in Bremen he would not have made it there either.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (17)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Well I'm going to have to say Forster since he is the only player in our team I ever see rated at all by neutrals, even though I see more comments about how overrated he is than about how good he is nowadays.

Our own fans are pretty divided. Some swear by Samaras, others think he's dragging the team back. The same is true of Scott Brown. Many of our own fans don't like the guy at all because he lacks technique, while others (myself included) think he is our most important player.

3

u/Nintendo_67 Dec 19 '13

I don't like Brown because he's a moany wee prick, but we're just not the same team without him.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

The top comment in this thread about the peaks and troughs of certain players is spot on with respect to Sammy. There are games where he runs riot and is nearly unplayable, but there are many, many others where he disappears, can't make runs, has sloppy passing etc. I love him and he's as loyal as they come but given how inconsistent he is I can understand why people might want a slightly less talented but more consistent option (like Hooper was).

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

De Guzman.

So slow to make a decision, plenty of sideways passing, very little tackling. Awful at corners and free kicks (for a supposed free kick specialist).

But then he pops in a worldy twice a season and somehow we keep him on. Would far rather of had Ki playing here rather than loaning him to Sunderland.

→ More replies (1)

275

u/Chlax7 Dec 19 '13

Luis Suarez is mediocre at best.

157

u/RKZ87 Dec 19 '13

Agreed. He couldn't even get a hat trick last game.

99

u/pogo123 Dec 19 '13

Minutes without a goal has gone into double figures!

→ More replies (1)

42

u/BigHarold Dec 19 '13

Mignolet is worse. That fucker did nothing against Tottenham.

→ More replies (2)

70

u/legacybranded7 Dec 19 '13

Oh c'mon that was so obviously a joke. Can't believe how many down votes you're getting.

278

u/notsureiflying Dec 19 '13

I guess some people think those jokes do not add to the overall quality of the sub.

→ More replies (11)

51

u/kazez2 Dec 19 '13

Well hes only got 4 assist, don't think thats good enough.

41

u/cbhaxx Dec 19 '13

Yeah even Özil has more than that

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Jack Wilshere has been hit and miss this season. Hope he pulls himself together soon and shows us what he's actually made of.

36

u/cas757 Dec 19 '13

Bastian Schweinsteiger.

He hasn't been the same player since injuring his ankle badly last season. As a matter of fact Martinez played better in the holding midfield role towards the end of last season, and he was a large reason for our success. He's still a great player and leader, but I personally put Kroos and Götze ahead of him this year.

It's a shame he got injured when he did, because he was taking his level of play to another level. I don't know if we will ever see him at his true potential.

12

u/doberlae Dec 19 '13

Anyone who downvoted this comment has obviously never seen Schweinsteiger at his peak...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

In my opinion Cristian Tello is overrated. He's 22 now and hasn't improved much in the past 3 years. He's predictable and his run-up before a shot is really poor. I think Adama Traoré is a better player and he is 5 years younger.

9

u/egcg119 Dec 19 '13

Agreed entirely. IMO, Tello is basically a stopgap until Deulofeu has matured. He'll get one more season at Barca while Deulofeu goes back on loan to Everton, and then he'll be sold.

It's funny, there are very few Barca players I can say are overrated, because Barca fans are such pessimists and hate on their players so much. But because of how much praise and hype the youth get, Tello was definitely going to be my answer.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Yeah, in 2011/12 he was a great prospect, but he just hasnt evolved. His pace is his best attribute, coming off the bench he can break a defense open by running down the wing, the problem is that's all he can do.

3

u/domalino Dec 19 '13

I think Cuenca and tello will never become permanent fixtures in a barca shirt. Neymar and deulefeu will probably be the first choice wingers in a few years time, with Pedro still in the mix, tello and/or Cuenca will be on the fringe until new youth replaces them and they move away.

12

u/bakamonkey Dec 19 '13

Overrated by Liverpool fans: Daniel Agger. We all love him for his commitment to the club, but everyone pretends like he is a world class ball player defender. When in reality, a big reason for our soft defense in recent years and our absolute inability to deal with physical strikers has been Agger.

Whenever we have one of those horrid games, everyone jumps to point at his defensive partner whether it be Carra or Skrtel. But hey, Agger's sitting there the whole time and getting creamed too! His positioning is definitely not up to task for a top level defender, his heading is poor, and he isn't the best at one-on-ones. He just doesn't make you feel safe in defense.

He is an above average, reliable enough defender who is world class with the ball at his feet. Me, I'd much rather have a solid bloke who won't let anybody get near his goal

4

u/Laircaek Dec 19 '13

Just about to post about agger, hes like you say a good defender but nothing special. His heading be it defensively or offensively is very poor and he has a tendency to get bullied by physical strikers. His best trait is his ability to carry the ball out of defence but even sakho trumps him in that these days aswell as everything else.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/eggaz Dec 19 '13

We don't over rate any of our players, therefore can add nothing to this debate.

Iwishicould

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

I'd say Ravel Morrison is verging on being overrated. He's got a great future, but I don't think he's the world beater that some have been saying.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/grelch Dec 19 '13

I would agree with that, although sometimes I think Mark Noble gets off a bit easy because he's an Academy lad.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/fahomnom Dec 19 '13

Morata was hyped way too much, he's been woeful.

15

u/StrikerGuy7 Dec 19 '13

I don't really think he was hyped, per say. Rather, a lot was expected from him by Madrdistas. But yes, he's left a lot to be desired this season.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/n3gotiator Dec 19 '13

Can we have him on loan now?

45

u/unwnkilla Dec 19 '13

No, players only move one way in the Real Madrid - Spurs "partnership"

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (12)

3

u/Dooey123 Dec 19 '13

Lennon's rated pretty much the same as he always has, quick and very one dimensional but you know what you are getting.

3

u/Jalapinho Dec 19 '13

hmm I would say Guarin. That guy makes some pretty bone headed decisions in terms of dribbling and passing. I think my biggest disappointment is he can beat one guy but then he'll try to be two, three guys and inevitably lose the ball. He's strong as an ox, though, I'll give him that.

3

u/Sdemba Dec 19 '13

Sergio Ramos. The guy is just crazy.

Pepe and him together are an accident waiting to happen (in the CL semifinals, normally).

12

u/crookedparadigm Dec 19 '13

I'd have to say Johnson, in my eyes. When he's on, he's on and it's great. But when he's not on, he just give the ball away, tries to run through people rather than pass around them, and is slow getting back in his position. I've definitely said "God dammnit, Johnson" more than for any other player of ours.

5

u/eisenschiml Dec 19 '13

Fully agree. He can be one of the best attacking fullbacks in the world when he's on form, but one game out of every five, he is a possession emporium for the other team.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Dhubrok2 Dec 19 '13

If you ask to Napoli fans, everyone is going to say that Maggio and Inler are quite disappointing, but I can't define them as "overrated".

The most overrated player in Napoli is Insigne.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Zthulu Dec 19 '13

Player..? I can't choose management..?

2

u/abl4zed Dec 19 '13

Lavezzi

2

u/Kompany Dec 19 '13

Sacha Kljestan. waste of a midfielder.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

benzema

2

u/pihsniwBEN Dec 20 '13

Hatem Ben Arfa, he can be one of the best players in the Premiership on his day and score a wonder goal, then be totally absent for the next 10 games, glad Pardew has saw some sense and dropped him onto the bench.

18

u/HeeyMaan Dec 19 '13

Giroud.

58

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Nah, Giroud is rated about right. A good target man who can link play, but isn't quite the great goalscorer Arsenal needs.

14

u/kingaardvark Dec 19 '13

Exactly this, I never hear anyone raving about how good he is to be honest.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Barthez_Battalion Dec 19 '13

He's really goo,d but if Arsenal had a better striker, like a Costa or a Rossi they would be knocking in so many goals. Giroud can't finish up close at all, he panics.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

I feel like a lot of gooners are aware of his strengths and weaknesses. He's great with hold up and link up play, fantastic one touch flicks around the box, great work ethic and physically strong. He's also not a clinical finisher as his pace leaves a lot to be desired.

He's bee a great asset to the team and has much more confidence this season, but is still lacking in a few areas. Everyone knows arsenal need another striker, and the majority of fans want wenger to splash out on a game changing striker. There is an outspoken minority who believe Giroud is the answer and don't want anyone better to come in to hinder his development/game time.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Astral_Fox Dec 19 '13

Paulinho, Dembele, Townsend, Defoe...the list goes on and on.

40

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

i disagree with Dembele

→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

I know it's going to look like I'm just having a biased dig due to my crest, but do Spurs fans really rate Townsend highly? From my limited viewing of him he really doesn't seem to bring that much, especially in his shooting given he wastes so much. Genuine question.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (21)

4

u/Hybride93 Dec 19 '13

Olivier Giroud. And I'm talking as a french guy. This guy is so fucking overrated i can't even believe what's going on in the BPL right now. He can't protect his ball like RvP + in front of the goal he is just rubbish. He will never have the same appeal as Suarez or Ibra, players capable to unlock a game with one goal outside the box. But Giroud ? He can only score with his head and while cutting a center with his foot.

3

u/samuraii889 Dec 19 '13

not my team but i say torres and javier hernandez

2

u/Sgt_peppers Dec 20 '13

Javier Hernandez is the most overrated player I've ever seen.

3

u/TheBoogieman67 Dec 19 '13

Love him to death, but I gotta say Yohan Cabaye. He can make some very stupid decisions sometimes.

3

u/maximmixam Dec 19 '13

Tom Cleverley.

I know he's getting blasted recently, but I've been saying it for a long time.

If he didn't play for united he'd be no where near that England team. Southampton have loads of better midfielders who don't get close to england's team.

I don't think he offers anything particularly - Anderson came on for him a couple of games ago and looked much better. Says a lot.

3

u/SuperToaster93 Dec 19 '13

Gerrard.

I think he is slowing down our midfield.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jason_in_sd Dec 19 '13

Luis Suarez! Trust me, he's a bum.

Now that all the big clubs have turned away...

Hurts me to say, but Glen Johnson just has not been on form this year, but gets every start of course. We get an occasional great cross, but more often than not, I feel like he's getting beat and having trouble marking. And for the international love and pedigree from the past, he gets my vote for most overrated on the team.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/SlappyBagg Dec 19 '13

Kagawa

18

u/cap45 Dec 19 '13

Seems his style of play just doesn't suit United. Always seems like he wants to do little one two's and layoffs, but no ones on the same page. I imagine he'd flourish in a team with a real passing game though.

16

u/Barthez_Battalion Dec 19 '13

Somwhere Veron is shedding a tear reading this comment.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

39

u/Loojay Dec 19 '13

Everyone babbles on about freeshinji and all that bollocks, but in every game I've seen him for Utd he's given the ball away and generally been a waste of a team slot. Kagawa has nothing compared to players like Ozil, Rooney or David Silva.

26

u/SlappyBagg Dec 19 '13

No goals or assists at all this season. A lot of fans seem to rate him because they seen a highlight video on youtube of him playing well for Dortmund.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

4

u/Buckfost Dec 19 '13

Kagawa is overrated IMO. I'm sure he sells a lot of merchandise in Asia but as a fan I care more about winning games than making profit.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Esco9 Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13

My team probably Gerrard...

Edit: people to contribute to the thread you have to pick someone from your team...I could have chose glen Johnson but idk anyone who rates him

→ More replies (15)

3

u/mucco Dec 19 '13

Bonucci is quite overrated. Padoin is playing because we have no other players there... He is also better than Isla at defending.

3

u/alpha1028 Dec 19 '13

Bonucci is massively overrated, if a big offer ever came in for him we would have to sell him. Take away the safety net of playing alongside 2 of the best CB's in the world and he becomes an average player very fast.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/decoy90 Dec 19 '13

Some time ago I'd say Welbeck because his finishing infuriated me. Then I watched him more closely and guy is doing A LOT of work. Now, I'd say Kagawa. I don't know if he fits our team or not, but for me, he is garbage. I think his sole purpose is to lose balls.