r/soccer • • Dec 19 '13
Why did George Weah win the Balon d'Or (and FIFA World Player of the Year award) in 1995?
I was born in 1992, so couldn't claim to have ever really watched him. I always assumed that that year he must have been absolutely incredible. A physically imposing striker who had an unstoppable goalscoring year, leading his team to numerous trophies (the normal metrics for winning such an award).
However, I looked up his stats the other day. In the 1994-95 season for PSG he only 7 goals in 34 league games and a total of 18 goals in 53 games. He earned a move to Milan over the summer of 1995, where he scored a respectable (but surely not Balon d'Or worthy 11 goals in 26 league games the next season.
For his country, Liberia, he played 5 games that year, scoring 0 goals.
In 1994-95, PSG finished 3rd place in Ligue 1 (which considering the team they had in the mid 90s, must have been considered a disappointment?). To be fair, they did win both French cups and got to the semi finals of the Champions League, but it would seem bizarre to award George Weah the trophy of the back of leading his team to only this medal haul.
Would none of the Ajax players who won the Champions League be more worthy? Or perhaps a Juventus player who got to the final of the Champions League as well as winning the notoriously tough mid 90s Serie A. Or even players like Alan Shearer who had one of the greatest seasons a striker in England has ever had, scoring 34 goals to lead Blackburn to the title.
I'm genuinely curious as to why George Weah won this award. Anybody who followed football around this time who could explain it? Not to be patronising, but it's not a case of FIFA wanting an African to win it for the first time is it?
70
u/HumphreyChimpdenEarw Dec 19 '13
unlike baseball/basketball/american football, football (soccer) is not an exact/accurate/easily quantifiable sport...so stats are a A LOT less relevant
watching many many games, recognizing the dynamics involved (which are much more organic due to continuous play), and understanding the ebb/flow of the game is much more important when getting a clear sense of a player's impact.
this clip pokes fun at the incompatibility of soccer with the stat-breakdown american sports normally receive
50
u/Ofthedoor Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13
George Weah dominated defenses physically and technically. Dominated is not strong enough of a word, actually. He humiliated them. I mean look at THIS! Or THAT, this is Pele-like.
Physically he is still the strongest player I have seen on a pitch. Yes, stronger than Drogba, or even Ibra since he could also run faster than most.
He was the absolute weapon up front. Unstoppable. Especially in the air.
Here is a decent video of his talents.
I have to say Rai + Weah has still to be beaten as a strike force at PSG. Yep I said it.
He didn't get the award for his goal tally. He got it for his overall dominance on the pitch.
Here is his most famous goal.
196
u/Red_Dog1880 Dec 19 '13
He was the Champions League top scorer in 1994-1995 with 8 goals.
When he won it he was also at his peak, the stats don't back it up really but the short period before he left PSG he was brilliant.
Take a look at this goal against Bayern. That was the Weah when he won the Ballon d'Or, a beautiful player who could produce absolutely stunning goals out of nowhere.
Stats aren't everything ;)
19
u/buymepizza Dec 19 '13
He's one of the greatest strikers ever, comparing his stats to todays strikers is mental and the Serie A was a notoriously defensive league in the 90s so it was extremely hard to hit double figures.
96
u/garthcrooks Dec 19 '13
It wasn't Fifa choosing an African - the Fifa World Player of the Year award was voted by the managers and captains of international teams and the Ballon d'Or was voted by sports writers from all over Europe. He really was widely considered the best player in the world at the time.
I think in the age of Messi and Ronaldo we've become a bit obsessed with stats. The best players in the world haven't always had such amazing goal records. Just look at Maradona - he never scored anywhere near as many goals as Messi. He didn't always win things at club level either but he's still considered by many as the best ever.
Unfortunately I don't personally remember Weah in his prime so I can't vouch for him. My earliest memory of him is him missing an absolute sitter in the 2000 FA Cup final and my dad saying my baby sister could have scored it!
6
u/rrayy Dec 20 '13
OP, why are you arguing with people about someone you admitted having no expertise on? They are giving you answers to your questions, but you just seem to be "But- but-"ing as if you have a point. You don't.
Why don't you just trust the collective judgment of history and spend your time instead looking up highlight videos trying to figure out what made this guy great yourself?
27
u/corell Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13
As a Dane i still think Laudrup should have won it that year, stopped Barca's domination (5-0 and all). He was better in 94, but they had to give it to Romario due to the WC.
Weah was a beast though tearing defenses apart with sheer agility, imagine a better Yaya Toure as a striker. FIFA have written article about his career.
12
u/huazzy Dec 19 '13
George Weah was one of my favorite players growing up and he was dominant. As others pointed out it wasn't so much the stats but you could just tell he was the best player on the pitch.
Comparison: Ronaldinho in his prime. You watched because he could take over matches without scoring. Just that much influence.
9
u/maximmixam Dec 19 '13
because this
I know this is after... he was pretty good!
7
u/cjhowareya Dec 19 '13
Weah was a joy to watch.
I can't say I'm fully versed on all his competitors for the Ballon d'Or during his prime, but I loved, loved, loved watching that man.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13
He excelled at being a Complete Forward. He could bring the ball down, move it forward, hold it up. He could tackle, pass and was quick. Baring in mind that he was doing this in the Serie A of the mid 90's, when the style of play was defence first, counter, then transition back and defend again.
He also was top scorer in the 94-95 champions league, helping PSG beat Barcelona, who though not at their best, were still considered better by some margin.
5
u/mlk Dec 20 '13
I just want to say George was my favorite player growing up. I cried when Milan didn't renew his contract.
1
u/Jokeslayer123 Dec 19 '13
Hey OP. Ready to have your mind blown? In 1963, the Ballon d'Or was won by a guy who only scored one league goal in his entire career! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lev_Yashin What a fuckin scrub, eh?
3
u/sarbanharble Dec 19 '13
George Weah still comes down in the summertime for a local soccer tournament we have and he completely dominates other players. I'm pretty sure he doesn't age.
3
u/ElCapo77 Dec 20 '13
Weah was a beast. Think Didier Drogba / Samuel Eto'o at the peak of their powers. His spell with Milan was outstanding.
Look at this goal vs Verona (who back then was very good) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9DltQjBrDk
8
u/fingrar Dec 19 '13
Looking only at stats will make players like Zidane and Ronaldinho quite mediocre.
2
u/spurrier458 Dec 19 '13
Stats always have a context. If Weah was a poacher, then those goal stats would be very relevant, but I get the impression that he was more of an all rounder/creative player in which case the goal numbers aren't as important.
2
u/NoMoreMountains Dec 20 '13 edited Dec 20 '13
If am over reaching, someone please feel free to hammer away.
First off, Serie A was undeniably the best league in the world in the 90s to early 2000s. With Spain a close second, with occasional #1 ranking here and there. Plus, add the fact that dribbling in Serie is no, no. You can ask Ronaldo, the original, about that.
Plus add the fact that changes in FIFA rules...the mother of all of C.Ronaldo and Messi's of today:
Moral of the story, if you could bend Serie A to your will in the 90s you were in contention for player of the year...Italy boosts a staggering 6 FIFA players of the year from 1991 to 2002.
11
u/cea2013 Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13
because "the best player in the world" is not solely specified by basic arithmetics.
cut that crap already. its stupid.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13
He was football's Jonah Lomu. An astonishing mixture of physical and technical gifts, never quite seen before to that degree. He was very deserving.
Defenders also knew how to defend back then. Sadly defending seems to be an increasingly lost art, for a variety of reasons.
2
u/Screwbit Dec 20 '13
I think OP posed a good question. Everyone is being a total ass in this thread.
2
u/BarneyStinson Dec 20 '13
The double standard in this subreddit is ridiculous. The consensus here seems to be "because he was great", "he was a joy to watch", "stats aren't everything", "because of the influence he had on his team", "because he was dominant", etc.
If you contrast this with the threads about this year's ballon d'or, Franck Ribéry is constantly being called "not even on the same level" as Messi and C.Ronaldo, because his stats look weak in comparison. Also "it's not a team award". Never mind that he creates so many opportunities for his team members and is consistently rated man of the match, although he's surrounded by world-class players.
On another note: OP asked a legitimate question and keeps being belittled and downvoted. His question
sits at -18 at the moment. That's a legitimate question which is relevant to the discussion! Why the downvotes?
2
u/EFGsugit Dec 20 '13
Wow this is a pathetic thread, and not by the OP but by most all of you responding. Half of you that are turning up your noses at OP haven't seen Weah ever either and are following the hivemind.
To OP, you asked a legitimate question and you should seek answers on a knowledgeable, mature football forum. This thread has proven to be neither
1
u/jairzinho Dec 20 '13
Before Messi and the Portuguese Ronaldo it wasn't usual for players to score more than 30 goals in a season. We've been spoiled in the last couple of years with some of the greatest goalscoring stats in history.
-41
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13
Yes I think that is pretty obvious.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment