r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Jan 09 '14
All Stars Season 3 Episode 10 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S03E10 "Are U.N. or Are You Out?"
The season Finale brings the designers to a runway show at U.N. world headquarters.
14
Upvotes
5
u/makeitworkoryouout Jan 10 '14
Seth Aaron had a slow start but he came on strong toward the end and obviously had it when he needed it in the finale. He ends up on top of the final rankings for this season.
32
u/konfetkak Jan 10 '14
Alyssa's bitter stylist strikes again.
47
u/pepperrush Jan 10 '14
This was the most boring finale ever.
22
u/verbiwhore Jan 10 '14
I'm so conflicted about this. I really wanted Korto to win, but I get that what she showed was more ready to wear than runway. I loved most of her collection and that first dress and the jumpsuit were especially wonderful.
Seth Aaron's work was more visually striking, more runway, and there were some amazing looks in there - but he already has a win under his belt, and got a prize package before... Gah, I like the guy, but I really hope he makes more of this win than he did his previous one.
The only place I wasn't conflicted was with Elena - she reverted to type at the worst possible time, and produced an "as expected" collection. Her workmanship is great, but she needs to broaden her range.
36
u/LowerYourBrows Jan 10 '14
Korto's collection is the most wearable.
I was actually impressed by Seth aaron's collection. They all look like Bond girls. I hate that he put all of them in those glasses.
Go Korto!
13
u/konfetkak Jan 10 '14
For those wondering what is written on Elena's tablet:
Украина, моя любимая я за тобой скучаю
Pretty sure this translates to (my Russian is rusty): Ukraine, my favorite, I miss you.
22
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Jan 10 '14
I wonder if they still would've done the UN theme finale if they didn't have Elena and Korto in the finale. It would've been weird to see them try to make that work with three designers who didn't have a strong foreign heritage.
11
u/panda367 Team Swatch Jan 10 '14
Oh, I'm so glad they decided that Elena won't win. I was worried that this whole season was a redemption arc for her when she really didn't deserve one.
20
u/ilwolf Jan 10 '14
I really wanted Korto to win. I think she deserved it, not only for the runway show, but for her performance the whole season.
Still, Seth Aaron's collection was beautiful, and I'm not really a fan of his.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14
I want that first dress from Seth Aaron.
7
u/fragilehearted Jan 10 '14
I have to say, they did at least show their distinct points of view very well.
I miss Seth Aaron's more fitted looks. He can tailor like nobody's business, but I wasn't seeing much of that here. Volume play is fine, but a few weren't interesting enough for me.
Elena's collection was very Elena.
I liked Korto's the best, & I think a lot of women in a lot of age groups would wear that stuff. (And I don't even really like yellow, personally.) She'd be my pick, though Elena's been getting the winner's edit this season. We'll see.
6
u/spoilz Jan 10 '14 edited Jan 10 '14
When did they start teaching Alyssa how to give good critique instead of "I'd buy it!" Or "I'd wear it"
4
u/keyhazel Jan 10 '14
I've been 99% sure that Seth Aaron would win for the last few weeks, based entirely on his Facebook page. He's been having viewing parties for every episode and just sounding really enthusiastic the whole way through. Can't say I mind. I've been rooting for him since the first episode of his season.
4
u/meldolphin Jan 11 '14
When they mentioned the contestants taking a trip somewhere, I really hoped they'd get sent to their respective countries. Obviously no chance in hell that would happen but for a brief moment I foolishly wondered if they would do it.
3
u/konfetkak Jan 10 '14
I like all three designers, but damn Seth Aaron's looks good.
3
u/keziasmiles Jan 10 '14
I'm so happy for Seth Aaron :) But I honestly loved all of the collections this time, it would have been so hard to judge!!
9
u/superfluiter Jan 10 '14
Awful. Awful, awful, awful. Those idiotic hipster 'glasses', the racer-back cocktail dress..oh, gob. I could have lived with Korto's, maybe..but Seth Aaron?
And Alyssa Milano? Someone needs to put that show out of its goddamn misery. It's in pain. It's inhumane!
That was a waste of time. I'm so pissed.
2
u/fragilehearted Jan 10 '14
Aw, I loved the pics of little Elena! So cute.
2
u/meldolphin Jan 11 '14
Looking back on this season, it wasn't the most exciting but I like the All Stars set up. All Stars seasons tend to be quite zippy. There's less designers to begin with, the episodes are shorter, and for the most part there's way less drama. Normal seasons start feeling really tedious and exhausting after a while.
1
u/Stunning-Tea5759 May 29 '26
I have nothing but admiration for what Elena managed to create in just 4 days. I especially loved the dress with the sheer cut-outs on the sides with the print fabric just barely peeking through. She really is an artist. I think only a limited number of women could pull off wearing these (I could not), but runway collections are about concept, and I think she won hands down on that score.
Korto's was lovely and flowy and very wearable, which was the problem. Maybe if she had styled all her models in ugly glasses?
Seth Aaron's was a disjointed mess, hiding behind his unmerited bravado. Cheap tricks like the glasses signal lack of confidence in the integrity of the product.
Elena and Korto both have their customer base, but Seth Aaron was strugging financially. I hoped that he could make the most of the win, but when he came back in Allstars 7 (all winners), he was still struggling financially. Maybe less bravado and a few business classes, Seth?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment