r/soccer • • Feb 17 '14

Who is the most underrated or unappreciated defender?

For me, it's Ivanovic. The man's a tank and can do no wrong. He could easily become a chelsea legend, but still in overshadowed by the whole Cahill/Terry partnership in the back. But for me, the whole back 4 of chelsea is solid.

100 Upvotes

385 comments sorted by

57

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

De Sciglio

14

u/tetraedric Feb 17 '14

you win! i love this player, young, talented and i really hope he can grow up more!

2

u/TheDreaminArmenian Feb 17 '14

I hope he doesn't sell out. I want him to become a club legend you know what i mean? i'm not saying leaving Milan will make him a sell out, but going to Madrid, in my eyes at least, would.

7

u/Exaggerated_Dane Feb 17 '14

To me, it seems like De Sciglio is very level-headed, and I hope he understands, he could very likely become the Maldini of his generation. He may never be as good, but there's a chance he'll be just as important.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/imasssssssssssssnake Feb 18 '14

Would going to Arsenal be selling out? :/

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/TheDreaminArmenian Feb 17 '14

OH! one criticism i have of Ivanovic! if he watch him play, he really likes to cross the ball, and he should because he knows when to cross it! but he shouldnt... He's so bad as crossing, oh lord, just so bad. I rarely see one of his crosses making it to anyones head or foot.

9

u/SciFiRef_UpvoteMe Feb 17 '14

That's the thing, he can't really beat people with pace like many RB or LBs can and he's not a great crosser. He's got a decent shot and is terrific in the air but sometimes he is part of the reason Chelsea struggle to break down lesser teams.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

fit to join us, then! United fan here

→ More replies (1)

218

u/Tomato_Chetkup Feb 17 '14

Sylvain Distin.

40

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I am always amazed at how quick he is given his age

90

u/WandererAboveFog Feb 17 '14

He's quick, he's fast and he's got pace.

80

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

When you're talking about Sylvain Distin... you're talking about a professional footballer... who plays professional football... for Everton

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MJSvis Feb 18 '14 edited Feb 18 '14

I remember watching him at Pompey sprinting after someone who I think was Ronaldo (although it's been a few years) and catching up and with holding, and then realising just how quick he was. He's stayed a Premier League defender for years and still manages to be in a top team challenging in the top half of the table at this age. Great defender.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

and height!

53

u/Evertonian3 Feb 17 '14

you're surprised how tall he his given his age?

34

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I'm surprised how fast he is considering his height.

68

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I'm surprised at how tall he is considering his height.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/DarthNihilus1 Feb 17 '14

*Handsome Squidward

24

u/Jordalordalord Feb 17 '14

Agreed, it's astonishing he doesn't have a single cap at international level. I understand France have had some quality centre backs over his career, but not having a single cap compared to Mexes' 29 is awful.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Mexes was good at Roma though

7

u/Jordalordalord Feb 17 '14

His flaws were always evident - and he played outside of his Roma career.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/potpan0 Feb 18 '14

I don't know much about his earlier career, but didn't Distin peak quite late, meaning he got into that awkward area where he's too old for a first cap, but good enough for international level.

I dunno.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/a_s_h_e_n Feb 17 '14

Fast as lightning and he'll play til he's 65, love him so much

3

u/sixthreetwo Feb 18 '14

Came here to say this. The Milkman!

1

u/WhatWouldSatanDo Feb 18 '14

We really missed him when he was injured this season.

88

u/grelch Feb 17 '14

I don't think Ivanovic is underrated at all. If I could choose one defender from another club in the league it would definitely be Ivanovic. He's a beast in all phases of the game. And he's got a nasty side to him. Under appreciated? We've got one. Winston Reid. We may be fighting to stay in this league, but it's not down to Winston. We just can't score. 13 clean sheets, and he's marshaled the back 4 throughout most of the season. He's composed, he's a leader, he has great positional sense, he's an excellent tackler. I'm surprised one of the larger clubs hasn't come knocking. He'd improve many of them.

15

u/cwl80 Feb 17 '14

Agree on Reid. West Ham really missed him during his injury. No-nonsense defender

10

u/japalian Feb 18 '14

AgReid.

4

u/onegallant Feb 18 '14

It's really astonishing to see how far Winston has come from that first season when we bought him where he could barely make it in the team.

2

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Feb 18 '14

That one season in the Championship has done wonders for Reid's career.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

There were a lot of rumours in the summer and January with Arsenal about a Vermealen + money swap for Reid

7

u/grelch Feb 17 '14

Thank goodness that didn't happen. Winston needs to be a part of the squad that opens the doors of the Olympic stadium (although I don't know if I can bring myself to be a part).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

82

u/Kovet Feb 17 '14

i would say barzagli because hes never mentioned among the best in the world when in reality he is one of the main reasons for Juve's recent success.

1

u/milkman182 Feb 18 '14

Barzagli is great and definitely deserves more credit than he gets

→ More replies (5)

145

u/devineman Feb 17 '14

Ivanovic is a very good shout. Extremely good defender at both right and centre back and never mentioned in the conversation as one of the top defenders.

I've always thought Winston Reid to be an exceptional talent for where he is (with all due respect to West Ham), and he'd fit well in a team challenging for the CL places. Surprised nobody has gone after him to be honest.

41

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 18 '14

We have no idea how Reid is still here either. But everyone loves him for it

19

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I've heard next to no transfer rumours about him at all since he joined and he's fantastic, it's strange. Either he really loves the club or other clubs just aren't paying attention.

22

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Hey, shut up

21

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

It's ok the only club that does its scouting on /r/soccer is Tottenham

→ More replies (1)

3

u/fergious Feb 17 '14

Kiwi here. I see Arsenal rumors every window in the paper but never anywhere else. He is a god, All whites legend with a long career to go.

→ More replies (9)

20

u/flaffl Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14

I think a lot of people who really pay attention to the game would recognize Branislav Ivanovic's talent. A regular starter for Chelsea Football Club, who has won a Champions League, scored of the last-minute Europa League winner, and a 3-time FA Cup winner-- pretty studly track record.

Maybe it's just me and my friends that talk about him often, but he's pretty friggin' good.

13

u/LovinLampard Feb 17 '14

Yet no one talks about him being one of the best defenders. He also scored the winner against napoli in UCL.

13

u/thelenscleaner Feb 17 '14

I think it's because he is quite poor with link-up play and crosses. Although that's not his main job, a full back is supposed to provide an extra attacking outlet and quite often when the ball ends with him in the final third(which happens more than it should really) he doesn't deliver. IMO I would have preferred him in CB, but Cahill-Terry partnership performs so well that it is hard for Iva to displace them.

7

u/SciFiRef_UpvoteMe Feb 17 '14

I don't think he's ever really excelled at CB for Chelsea. I agree with you about his link-up play, it's quite poor and teams allow him tons of time on the ball because he just can't contribute very well in that phase of the game. Of course he finds other ways to make himself useful in the box, interesting player but definitely quite different from your typical RB these days.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/emreuysaler Feb 17 '14

Or winner vs. City

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AgentUmlaut Feb 17 '14

I was gonna say, I don't think I've ever had a conversation with people who actually enjoy the sport not mention Ivanovic on the topic of defenders.

I'm surprised so many people here are calling him underrated, he's pretty well rated unless you're consistently having conversations with people who only talk about the players on Barcelona and Real Madrid.

7

u/empire_Zz Feb 17 '14

Reid is the pride of New Zealand ATM.

21

u/delusion-of-adequacy Feb 17 '14

Actually you're thinking of brendon mccullum.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PoofyHairedIdiot Feb 18 '14

I had never even heard of Reid until he scored that goal against Slovakia. From then on he's been one of my favourite players.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ChaosRaiden Feb 18 '14

Shut Uuuuuuuup

People will start paying attention :(

→ More replies (1)

55

u/bambinoquinn Feb 17 '14

Ron Vlaar, I know people will think 'Villas defense is shocking' but if you look at our record with and without him you will see how much of a difference he makes. Since last December he has missed 13 games and we haven't won any of them. Most of his game is sweeping up terrible mistakes made by Baker

13

u/Footy_Fanatic Feb 17 '14

There was an announcer during the last villa and arsenal game that was literally cumming every time Vlaar did anything.

6

u/CheeseMeUp Feb 17 '14

Came here to say Vlaar! So solid. concrete Ron such an apt nickname. Our record with him is much better across the park. Also commits so few fouls, which sort of balances things out as Clark and Baker just give them away for free. Did you see the whoscored article about him?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

I can't fucking wait for Okore to get back from injury, really hope he can step up and prove himself.

7

u/Schele_Sjakie Feb 17 '14

I think he has a good chance to start at the WC. He seems the only older and experienced defender we have that also plays well.

→ More replies (4)

31

u/badguysenator Feb 17 '14

Fabian Schar at Basel. Man City fans, he's who you want to replace Demichelis.

→ More replies (14)

46

u/egran Feb 17 '14

Gary Cahill, maybe? I know I might be little biased, but Cahill has been solid this season. I don't see his name mentioned a lot despite his massive influence on Chelsea games.

11

u/copinglemon Feb 17 '14

Cahill is great, I am upset that Arsenal did not try to sign him. He is an absolute warrior, he was flying in front of everything at the Emirates! Good technique for a CB as well.

2

u/SciFiRef_UpvoteMe Feb 17 '14

Would've been kind of a weird buy for Arsenal at the time, right? I don't think they really had a need at CB then.

5

u/prayfordiaby Feb 17 '14

They did need him and they did bid. Coyle said the bid was derisory and they wouldn't deal with dick law again.

10

u/iamveryharsh Feb 17 '14

Then they sold him to Chelsea for a similar figure

→ More replies (7)

4

u/lomoeffect Feb 17 '14

It's only been in the past few weeks/months that you see his name popping up more and more often. Any Chelsea fan who's been watching him since we signed him can tell you just how good he has been, especially in terms of how relatively little was paid.

6

u/msbr_ Feb 17 '14

played 120 mins of cl final and the first leg of semi final, and that was before he started to get credit.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/I_Love_Lamps8 Feb 18 '14

I fucking love Cahill

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

I have no idea why. In my honest opinion he won the CL for you at least as decisively as Drogba did, if not moreso. I was quite impressed.

50

u/bricebru22 Feb 17 '14

From my club it has to be Adriano. The guy can play RB, LB, CB, and you could even throw him at wing or in midfield. He also is 100% ambidextrous and is one of the only players on Barca that can score amazing long shots. He offensive and defensive skills are both excellent and although he is not one of the world's best, I do believe he is one of the most well rounded footballers.

I believe that he should be included on Brazil's WC squad as an ultimate versatile squad player. If anyone gets hurt then Adriano will be able to fill in. I also would like him to start against Man City tomorrow instead of Alba because he has the best defensive qualities of any of our fullbacks.

7

u/SkyInfernal Feb 17 '14

Pitty injuries hit him as hard as they did, I have only heard positive comments about him from barça fans.

6

u/DivineVibrations Feb 18 '14

WAS JUST ABOUT TO POST THIS!!

Seriously i'd rather have Adriano over Alba 9 times out of 10. The guy is a better defender, almost equal attacker, and overall feels a better fit than Alba for barcelona's style. Anytime i see Alba begin to drift out of position i bite my nails.

Not to mention that longshot

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

He scores some truly breathtaking goals cutting in from the wing.

1

u/helloo25 Feb 18 '14

His last few games have been simply amazing, definetly worthy of a call up for wc

63

u/Jaroken Feb 17 '14

Medhi Benatia, maybe? i don't hear much about him, but he's one of the biggest reasons Roma are second in serie A, not to mention that he has 5 goals as well. arguably the best centerback in serie a atm.

29

u/lakupiippu Feb 17 '14

Arguably the best centerback in the world

FTFY. There hasn't been any as dominant in the world throughout this season (except maybe if Ramos keeps his current form)

22

u/emreuysaler Feb 17 '14

Pepe has been better than Ramos IMO.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/TotallyNotAVirgin Feb 17 '14

I hate to do this but it's Mehdi*. I'll show myself out

→ More replies (3)

17

u/JuAnVasqz Feb 17 '14

Curtis Davies.

6

u/CaporalViolet Feb 17 '14

The Atleti centre-backs Miranda and Godin have been wonderful this season.

3

u/Pedrinho21 Feb 18 '14

Season before as well

16

u/lolinai Feb 17 '14

Jonas Olsson who plays for West Brom

6

u/nuclearjudas Feb 17 '14

Shame doesn't show it when playing for the national team, but I agree he's a really good CB.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

A good defender, but McAuley is our real unappreciated defender, crazy he didn't play in the prem until he was 31.

3

u/NotQuite_ThereYet Feb 18 '14

McAuley and Billy Jones chose Brom over coming to Bristol (don't blame them to be honest). Such quality players. Think that was the season we had Rose and Caulker on loan from Spurs too. How different things would been now, eh?

96

u/DerDummeMann Feb 17 '14

I think Evans is a lot better than he is given credit for.

28

u/SlappyBagg Feb 17 '14

Our best defender for the past two seasons.

23

u/Yannak Feb 17 '14

Not like he's had much competition with Vidic being Perma-injured and Ferdinand stopping to tweet mid game half the time.

40

u/SlappyBagg Feb 17 '14

The same Ferdinand who got in the pfa team of the year last season? Been shite this season but was quality last year.

22

u/grein Feb 17 '14

Ferdinand was amazing last year. But, it seems that people have a very short memory.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/wh11 Feb 17 '14

I think never really having a solid partnership has hurt him and us in general, especially this season.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bamsaron Feb 17 '14

People used to shit on him because Fergie chose him over Pique, in the past 2 years he has proven them all wrong.

18

u/SleepingJustice Feb 17 '14

How? He isn't better than Pique.

8

u/betterbutterbeater Feb 17 '14

United can pay him less than they would have had to pay Pique to make him stay. Evans is also a homegrown player, something you can't under estimate surely.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (7)

1

u/mellvins059 Feb 17 '14

That is understandable though. He was really bad a few years back.

→ More replies (7)

45

u/futbaltonight Feb 17 '14

Lovren, Gibbs, Distin and Azpilicueta.

27

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Lovren is pretty highly rated. If you want an underrated Saints defender, it's Jose Fonte.

3

u/jdosbo5 Feb 17 '14

He didn't do so well at Lyon though, so I think he lost some stock while he was there. I've heard he's doing great at Southampton though, which is wonderful for him

3

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I liked him at Lyon personally.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/LovinLampard Feb 17 '14

I wouldn't call Gibbs or Dave underrated.

10

u/duckman273 Feb 17 '14

Azpiliceuta's been incredible this season despite playing in an unfamiliar position and hasn't received nearly enough credit for it.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I thought everyone knew Gibbs was really good?

4

u/bellend1234 Feb 18 '14

There's a popular school of thought that Shaw should go to Brazil in place of Gibbs. That shows you how over and under rated each player is respectively.

4

u/suchaslowroll Feb 18 '14 edited Feb 18 '14

Meh, I definitely think Gibbs is underrated, because he's fantastic but unfortunately in the shadow of the best LB of the past few years in the world - Cole, and one of the current best in the world - Baines.

But I don't think Shaw is overrated, he has been one of the best players in a side 8th in the PL with one of the best defensive records in the PL, and is only 18 years old...And on top of that being an incredible attacking threat.

On top of the way he's performing, the potential he has for the future is huge, so it wouldn't be a mistake to get him into the squad at a young age so by the time he hits his prime he has World Cup experience.

A lot of people say that forcing Walcott into the squad so young was was wrong because he played bad in 2009/10 & 11... But in 2012 Euros he kept us in by scoring 2 against Sweden, then went on to the be the highest scoring winger in the PL in the 12/13 season... So now at just age 24 he's approaching (if not already) world class, which is just like any top Spanish player.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

All them are pretty accurately rated, at least by people who watch matches.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

You think Distin's been accurately rated?

7

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I do actually, at least by my friends and I and what I've read, so that's all I can speak too. Everton's back pair has been praised all season, rightfully so, they've been terrific, especially at the beginning.

36

u/DerKenz Feb 17 '14

Boateng, at least here at Bayern. I think he's one of the best in the world and only gets shit on for that one mistake in 25 games he makes.

3

u/ShittyTeam Feb 18 '14

He was really prone to panicking when he played for us and wasn't a great tackler.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

It's easier to remember the mistakes that Boateng used to make than recognize everything he does right.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I'd say there is a case for Aaron Hughes. Over 450 Premier League games, never been sent off, had an absolutely fantastic partnership with Hangeland. Helped Fulham to a European final (he played over 60 games in that season) and is still captain of Northern Ireland. Sad to see his ability decline but guess it was inevitable with age.

2

u/elevan11 Feb 18 '14

Have to agree with you there. Aaron Hughes has been brilliant throughout his career.

10

u/rough_outline Feb 17 '14

Underrated =/= Players I don't watch very much

5

u/cvillano Feb 17 '14

Nenad Tomovic at Fiorentina

5

u/fcburdman Feb 17 '14

Domenico Criscito if you ask me - such a versatile left-back and the guy runs for days. He fell off the radar for a while suspended from the national team due to his involvement in the Italy match-fixing scandal awhile back but he's getting called back up again. Technically, he hasn't missed a beat. I honestly would say he's the number 2 or 3 left-back out there behind Marcelo and maybe Jordi Alba.

2

u/cvillano Feb 18 '14

Great shout, I thought for sure he had that spot locked down but his move away from Italy really hurt his chances as Prandelli never calls up players outside Serie A. I dont think he watches enough players playing outside Italy, which is why I was against Giac going to Sunderland.

2

u/fcburdman Feb 18 '14

Yeah you're right, Cesare really doesn't keep an eye on them unless they're practicing their trade in the motherland. But man, do I really hope that Domenico gets a World Cup spot. I think his chances are good. Forza Azzurri!

5

u/timmeh38 Feb 17 '14

I'd say Virgil van Dijk is a bit underrated ! Should be selected for the Dutch 'Oranje' in my opinion. Very strong, calm, fast, with a pretty good shot and capable of good long balls forward.

2

u/JonnyBhoy Feb 18 '14

He is definitely the next player who will get a big move from Celtic. Him and Forster are our primary assets at the moment.

It's no coincidence that we are breaking all sorts of clean sheet records with those two in the side.

5

u/kerbyage Feb 17 '14

Gary Cahill is constantly underrated. A solid defender who can block shots and score goals with the head. I hope he continues to flourish with JT at the back for the rest of the season.

80

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Jozy Altidore. Always the best defender for the opposing team.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Jimi187 Feb 17 '14

Pepe. Some people can't see past his crazy antics, but he's one of the best center backs in the world. Strong defender who isn't afraid to go hard.

10

u/Adziboy Feb 17 '14

Was it him that hadn't had a yellow card for like over a year?

6

u/Jimi187 Feb 17 '14

Haha yeah, opposite of Ramos

11

u/Fuglylol Feb 17 '14

Heike Westermann ofc ¯_(ツ)_/¯

4

u/Re1nForce Feb 18 '14

¯_(ツ)_/¯ FTFY

4

u/kdoubledogg Feb 17 '14

Leandro Castan. Benatia is finally getting the recognition that he needs, but Castan remains unappreciated in my mind. Roma's legendary defense this season would not be the same without him. He's consistent but not flashy and does not have the same scoring prowess as Benatia.

4

u/platoiscool Feb 17 '14

Sebastien Bassong at Norwich is superb on his day.

2

u/GuiltyPassionfruit Feb 17 '14

He always showed good potential at Spurs

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

He showed even more potential at Newcastle. Was sad when he left

7

u/mczbot Feb 17 '14

joel matip. weirdly enough even doesnt get enough credit among our own fanbase, let alone the bundesliga. i actually believe if he decided to play for germany instead of cameroon he would have a way higher standing here.

2

u/derSteiger Feb 17 '14

Matip in top is the best CB of Schalke I guess...(not to mention Papa because of his injuries)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PineappleBagel Feb 17 '14

Diego Godín is a solid CB

In the games I've seen him play he typically does a good job, and his partnership with Miranda is great. It could be me, but I don't see him get a lot of attention in the spotlight around here when defenders are talked about.

3

u/fjperez12 Feb 17 '14

He's brilliant. Seems like a solid leader too.

10

u/moklboy Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14

I feel like Pepe is still seen as a defender who gets away with way too many dirty fouls and doesn't do much else in a game, while he was actually our best defender this season and commits a really low amount of fouls.

Edit: of course there are defenders who are more underrated, but he was to first to come to my mind, I don't know why...

11

u/FullyWoodenUsername Feb 17 '14 edited Dec 05 '24

profit disarm elderly bake uppity future nine adjoining snow wistful

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/TheJediJew Feb 18 '14

He's been broken a lot, sadly, and he's got a lot of competition for his place from vice-captain Agger.

But he's only 23. He'll be a first team regular soon enough. He's certainly good enough!

Our first choice pair would probably be Agger and Sakho if they weren't both left footed - which seems to be a problem for some reason.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/paddyduke Feb 18 '14

He's been good the few times he's played, but he's been out quite a lot with injuries. He's my first choice CB for Liverpool. I'd have him at LB over Cissokho too.

Not really underrated though.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

All the Hammers here are saying Winston Reid and I agree but let's not forget the other half of our regular CB partnership, James Tomkins. Still maturing but he's a bloody good defender already and on his way to hopefully become a West Ham legend.

3

u/Pedrinho21 Feb 18 '14

Miranda and Godin are constantly overlooked as world class defenders. They somehow think that having the most clean sheets in La Liga is purely Courtois (which he does deserve a large amount of the credit) but Miranda and Godin are great defenders and compliment each other perfectly

3

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

Godin too

3

u/GunnerNYC Feb 18 '14

Per Mertesacker. People don't rate him because he's slow, but his reading of the game and organization are second to none. He's arguably been Arsenal's best player this season.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

Bacary Sanga..

Fantastic workhorse, very rarely gives free kicks away, and can whip in a cross better than most.. It really shows when he isn't on the field..

13

u/fronteir Feb 17 '14

Subotic. He's not horribly underrated, but is often overshadowed by Hummels

17

u/ColdFrost Feb 17 '14

Nowadays people rate Subotic higher than Hummels. It's actually gotten to the point that Hummels is underrated. Hummels is improving defensively again and he also provides great distribution. Subotic may still have the edge on Hummels though. The defender that is highly underrated however is Sokratis. That guy has been a wall at the back and kept our defense together single handedly while our first team players were injured.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I'm not sure Neven is underrated anymore. I've actually played with his dad though.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14

ITT: Rated and appreciated defenders (mostly)

EDIT - the threads a bit better now than when I posted this...

3

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Who play for top teams

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Shaqiriiii Feb 17 '14

Diego Godin, Adriano. Cahill, Ivanovic, Subotic, Benatia, Barzaghlilili (can't spell his name)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Maza Rodriguez, ex Stuttgart player who currently plays for Club America. He has talent to be in Europe, I feel like the German club didn't appreciate his talent, sold him back to his home country.

2

u/rookie999 Feb 17 '14

Rene Adler, unappreciated defender of Hamburg's losing streak.

2

u/thekidfromthegutter Feb 17 '14

Mehdi Ben Atia of Rome. that dude is a beast

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 18 '14

Meza has made neymar his bitch many many times.

2

u/FutureAlcoholic Feb 18 '14

Here with the Rapids we've got Shane O'Neill. The world of soccer is going to know that name real well real soon.

2

u/adismalscientist Feb 18 '14

This might be too late but i think that Varane is quite an underrated defender.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

everyone is always all over hummels but subotic is absolutely nasty and provides a lot of cover for him and makes up for his mistakes.

Rami who just left Valencia for Milan (i think?) is sneaky good too.

Iraiola and Inigo Martinez are two very underappreciated Basque defenders.

2

u/ivanfca Feb 18 '14

Laurent Koscienly

2

u/theKinkypeanut Feb 18 '14

Benatia or Barzagli, both absolutely top class defenders who are rarely mentioned.

2

u/md_abboudi Feb 18 '14

Caulker for Cardif He is solid and young Totemham realy didn't appreciate him and I'm surprised that no big team actualy tried to sign him up

4

u/lgf92 Feb 17 '14

Mike Williamson, if you're rating from an "American football field goal kicker" point of view.

5

u/FAT_HAIRY_COCK Feb 17 '14

Evans and Koscielny are definitely the most solid CBs of their respective teams, and have a decent shout to be considered among the best CBs in the Prem.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14

No underrated but Kaboul has had so many injuries and problem keeping his form/place because of those injuries that many people forget how good a defender he is. Hopefully he can stay fit for us and for France.

For those who disagree: why? I think he's under-appreciated not underrated.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/wwxxyyzz Feb 17 '14

Ivanovic is a good shout, scores a fair few goals as well.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Is Coloccini underrated or can we count him? Lost a bit of pace, but still is brilliant whenever he plays

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Godin

1

u/envague Feb 17 '14

For all the Gunnercentrism here, I'm surprised that Bacary Sagna doesn't get much love. I'm always impressed by him in the Arsenal games I watch.

1

u/Jokeslayer123 Feb 17 '14

He gets a lot of love over on /r/Gunners

1

u/TheRoyalTenenThom Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14

Filipe Luís.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Jose Angel for us, he's been really good at left back in my opinion. he just had a great game against malaga

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Dave

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

Cannot believe no one has said Hugo Campagnaro.

1

u/B0M85H311 Feb 18 '14

I think Lovren is under appreciated at Saints

1

u/river49 Feb 18 '14

Bayern with less than a 1/3 seems a little odd, considering last year's result and the form of the two clubs right now.

1

u/futballfanman Feb 18 '14

Arbeloa, Abidal, Yepes, and Ballesteros.

1

u/TheDica Feb 18 '14

Wes brown. Last year sunderland had mignolet saving their arse defensively now its brown. Always calm and has a 100% tackle success rate. Amazing for a man who had previously been injured for almost 2 years

1

u/Incaahhh Feb 18 '14

Distin, Koscielny, or Macherano

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

Varane

1

u/T0mmyTsunami Feb 18 '14

Jérémy Mathieu

1

u/ertant Feb 18 '14

I'm not sure if Ivanovic is considered underrated, but if he is then I would put him right up there in the top 2-3

1

u/Ploxyy Feb 18 '14

Virgil van Dijk

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14

Chris Smalling.

1

u/XlPoLaR04 Feb 18 '14

Jan Vertonghen maybe? I would like to see him in the conversation with Kompany for best CB in the PL. When we don't have him on an island at LB he truly is something else.

1

u/DellMB Feb 18 '14

Sokratis Papastathopoulos .

1

u/KingOfCopenhagen Feb 18 '14

It would be interesting if people chose a player who is NOT in there own team.

The question isn't who's the most under appreciated in YOUR team.

1

u/Ausrufepunkt Feb 17 '14

Großkreuz
He's been stellar for Dortmund this season
People always quickly disregard him because he's not as flashy and shiny in his moves as other players...but yknow, work hard - play hard.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Ranocchia.

In an organised defence, he'd be top class.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Eh, he's arguable the weakest link in our defence for the past 2-3 years.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/An_Eloquent_Turtle Feb 18 '14

Might be a bit late to the party, but Ryan Shawcross. I'd rather him get picked for England than jagielka or Dawson.

1

u/maroon_sky Feb 17 '14

Zabaleta, up until recently. This guy works his ass off in every game and everyone was talking about how good Kompany was. I honestly think that he got appreciated this season only because Kompany was injured a lot.

1

u/nashvillepicker Feb 17 '14

Sebastian Bassong. No-nonsense CB always looking to close down his man and tackle. Great in the air and the only reason we're not bottom this season.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

Adriano. Can play everywhere along the backline, and is very disciplined defensively. Has a rocket shot from outside the box as well. He's a very important contributor to Barcelona.

1

u/So1ar Feb 17 '14

I really rate Jose Enrique for Liverpool. I don't know if he's underrated but I don't hear him mentioned much and I don't think he's ever gotten an call up to the senior Spain squad. He got a few at U21 level.

1

u/imasssssssssssssnake Feb 18 '14

When Clichy was leaving I had hoped Arsenal would go for him. He's had a fair few injuries hasn't he?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TheScarletPimpernel Feb 18 '14

I think he's rated entirely correctly because whilst he has his assets he also has a few major issues with his game. Consistency, for one.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14

I'll give Hector Moreno a shout. Rock for Espanyol, he really has no holes in his game.

1

u/HuYuHaiDing Feb 17 '14

I'm surprised by a lot of the defenders mentioned here. I thought most of them got appreciated quite well actually. I mean players like Distin, Barzagli, Subotic, Di Sciglio, Koscielny, Ivanovic, Benatia, Cahill, Boateng, Criscito, Lovren, Pepe, Azpilicueta, Vlaar and Evans are more known to me as good defenders than bad. I actually had a very hard time naming an unappreciated defender.