r/soccer • u/TheDreaminArmenian • Feb 17 '14
Who is the most underrated or unappreciated defender?
For me, it's Ivanovic. The man's a tank and can do no wrong. He could easily become a chelsea legend, but still in overshadowed by the whole Cahill/Terry partnership in the back. But for me, the whole back 4 of chelsea is solid.
100
Upvotes
57
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
De Sciglio
8
u/TheDreaminArmenian Feb 17 '14
OH! one criticism i have of Ivanovic! if he watch him play, he really likes to cross the ball, and he should because he knows when to cross it! but he shouldnt... He's so bad as crossing, oh lord, just so bad. I rarely see one of his crosses making it to anyones head or foot.
218
u/Tomato_Chetkup Feb 17 '14
Sylvain Distin.
88
u/grelch Feb 17 '14
I don't think Ivanovic is underrated at all. If I could choose one defender from another club in the league it would definitely be Ivanovic. He's a beast in all phases of the game. And he's got a nasty side to him. Under appreciated? We've got one. Winston Reid. We may be fighting to stay in this league, but it's not down to Winston. We just can't score. 13 clean sheets, and he's marshaled the back 4 throughout most of the season. He's composed, he's a leader, he has great positional sense, he's an excellent tackler. I'm surprised one of the larger clubs hasn't come knocking. He'd improve many of them.
82
u/Kovet Feb 17 '14
i would say barzagli because hes never mentioned among the best in the world when in reality he is one of the main reasons for Juve's recent success.
145
u/devineman Feb 17 '14
Ivanovic is a very good shout. Extremely good defender at both right and centre back and never mentioned in the conversation as one of the top defenders.
I've always thought Winston Reid to be an exceptional talent for where he is (with all due respect to West Ham), and he'd fit well in a team challenging for the CL places. Surprised nobody has gone after him to be honest.
55
u/bambinoquinn Feb 17 '14
Ron Vlaar, I know people will think 'Villas defense is shocking' but if you look at our record with and without him you will see how much of a difference he makes. Since last December he has missed 13 games and we haven't won any of them. Most of his game is sweeping up terrible mistakes made by Baker
31
u/badguysenator Feb 17 '14
Fabian Schar at Basel. Man City fans, he's who you want to replace Demichelis.
46
u/egran Feb 17 '14
Gary Cahill, maybe? I know I might be little biased, but Cahill has been solid this season. I don't see his name mentioned a lot despite his massive influence on Chelsea games.
50
u/bricebru22 Feb 17 '14
From my club it has to be Adriano. The guy can play RB, LB, CB, and you could even throw him at wing or in midfield. He also is 100% ambidextrous and is one of the only players on Barca that can score amazing long shots. He offensive and defensive skills are both excellent and although he is not one of the world's best, I do believe he is one of the most well rounded footballers.
I believe that he should be included on Brazil's WC squad as an ultimate versatile squad player. If anyone gets hurt then Adriano will be able to fill in. I also would like him to start against Man City tomorrow instead of Alba because he has the best defensive qualities of any of our fullbacks.
63
u/Jaroken Feb 17 '14
Medhi Benatia, maybe? i don't hear much about him, but he's one of the biggest reasons Roma are second in serie A, not to mention that he has 5 goals as well. arguably the best centerback in serie a atm.
17
u/JuAnVasqz Feb 17 '14
Curtis Davies.
6
u/CaporalViolet Feb 17 '14
The Atleti centre-backs Miranda and Godin have been wonderful this season.
16
u/lolinai Feb 17 '14
Jonas Olsson who plays for West Brom
96
u/DerDummeMann Feb 17 '14
I think Evans is a lot better than he is given credit for.
45
u/futbaltonight Feb 17 '14
Lovren, Gibbs, Distin and Azpilicueta.
36
u/DerKenz Feb 17 '14
Boateng, at least here at Bayern. I think he's one of the best in the world and only gets shit on for that one mistake in 25 games he makes.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
I'd say there is a case for Aaron Hughes. Over 450 Premier League games, never been sent off, had an absolutely fantastic partnership with Hangeland. Helped Fulham to a European final (he played over 60 games in that season) and is still captain of Northern Ireland. Sad to see his ability decline but guess it was inevitable with age.
10
u/rough_outline Feb 17 '14
Underrated =/= Players I don't watch very much
5
u/cvillano Feb 17 '14
Nenad Tomovic at Fiorentina
5
u/fcburdman Feb 17 '14
Domenico Criscito if you ask me - such a versatile left-back and the guy runs for days. He fell off the radar for a while suspended from the national team due to his involvement in the Italy match-fixing scandal awhile back but he's getting called back up again. Technically, he hasn't missed a beat. I honestly would say he's the number 2 or 3 left-back out there behind Marcelo and maybe Jordi Alba.
5
u/timmeh38 Feb 17 '14
I'd say Virgil van Dijk is a bit underrated ! Should be selected for the Dutch 'Oranje' in my opinion. Very strong, calm, fast, with a pretty good shot and capable of good long balls forward.
5
u/kerbyage Feb 17 '14
Gary Cahill is constantly underrated. A solid defender who can block shots and score goals with the head. I hope he continues to flourish with JT at the back for the rest of the season.
80
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Jozy Altidore. Always the best defender for the opposing team.
19
u/Jimi187 Feb 17 '14
Pepe. Some people can't see past his crazy antics, but he's one of the best center backs in the world. Strong defender who isn't afraid to go hard.
11
u/Fuglylol Feb 17 '14
Heike Westermann ofc ¯_(ツ)_/¯
4
u/kdoubledogg Feb 17 '14
Leandro Castan. Benatia is finally getting the recognition that he needs, but Castan remains unappreciated in my mind. Roma's legendary defense this season would not be the same without him. He's consistent but not flashy and does not have the same scoring prowess as Benatia.
4
u/platoiscool Feb 17 '14
Sebastien Bassong at Norwich is superb on his day.
7
u/mczbot Feb 17 '14
joel matip. weirdly enough even doesnt get enough credit among our own fanbase, let alone the bundesliga. i actually believe if he decided to play for germany instead of cameroon he would have a way higher standing here.
9
u/PineappleBagel Feb 17 '14
Diego Godín is a solid CB
In the games I've seen him play he typically does a good job, and his partnership with Miranda is great. It could be me, but I don't see him get a lot of attention in the spotlight around here when defenders are talked about.
10
u/moklboy Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14
I feel like Pepe is still seen as a defender who gets away with way too many dirty fouls and doesn't do much else in a game, while he was actually our best defender this season and commits a really low amount of fouls.
Edit: of course there are defenders who are more underrated, but he was to first to come to my mind, I don't know why...
21
u/dude8498 Feb 17 '14
Cesar Azpilicueta.
11
u/FullyWoodenUsername Feb 17 '14 edited Dec 05 '24
profit disarm elderly bake uppity future nine adjoining snow wistful
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
All the Hammers here are saying Winston Reid and I agree but let's not forget the other half of our regular CB partnership, James Tomkins. Still maturing but he's a bloody good defender already and on his way to hopefully become a West Ham legend.
3
u/Pedrinho21 Feb 18 '14
Miranda and Godin are constantly overlooked as world class defenders. They somehow think that having the most clean sheets in La Liga is purely Courtois (which he does deserve a large amount of the credit) but Miranda and Godin are great defenders and compliment each other perfectly
3
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
Godin too
3
u/GunnerNYC Feb 18 '14
Per Mertesacker. People don't rate him because he's slow, but his reading of the game and organization are second to none. He's arguably been Arsenal's best player this season.
3
u/perrydap Feb 18 '14
Sakho
3
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
Bacary Sanga..
Fantastic workhorse, very rarely gives free kicks away, and can whip in a cross better than most.. It really shows when he isn't on the field..
13
u/fronteir Feb 17 '14
Subotic. He's not horribly underrated, but is often overshadowed by Hummels
17
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14
ITT: Rated and appreciated defenders (mostly)
EDIT - the threads a bit better now than when I posted this...
4
u/Shaqiriiii Feb 17 '14
Diego Godin, Adriano. Cahill, Ivanovic, Subotic, Benatia, Barzaghlilili (can't spell his name)
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Maza Rodriguez, ex Stuttgart player who currently plays for Club America. He has talent to be in Europe, I feel like the German club didn't appreciate his talent, sold him back to his home country.
2
u/rookie999 Feb 17 '14
Rene Adler, unappreciated defender of Hamburg's losing streak.
2
u/thekidfromthegutter Feb 17 '14
Mehdi Ben Atia of Rome. that dude is a beast
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 18 '14
Meza has made neymar his bitch many many times.
2
u/FutureAlcoholic Feb 18 '14
Here with the Rapids we've got Shane O'Neill. The world of soccer is going to know that name real well real soon.
2
u/adismalscientist Feb 18 '14
This might be too late but i think that Varane is quite an underrated defender.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
everyone is always all over hummels but subotic is absolutely nasty and provides a lot of cover for him and makes up for his mistakes.
Rami who just left Valencia for Milan (i think?) is sneaky good too.
Iraiola and Inigo Martinez are two very underappreciated Basque defenders.
2
u/ivanfca Feb 18 '14
Laurent Koscienly
2
u/perrydap Feb 18 '14
Varane
2
u/theKinkypeanut Feb 18 '14
Benatia or Barzagli, both absolutely top class defenders who are rarely mentioned.
2
u/md_abboudi Feb 18 '14
Caulker for Cardif He is solid and young Totemham realy didn't appreciate him and I'm surprised that no big team actualy tried to sign him up
4
u/lgf92 Feb 17 '14
Mike Williamson, if you're rating from an "American football field goal kicker" point of view.
5
u/FAT_HAIRY_COCK Feb 17 '14
Evans and Koscielny are definitely the most solid CBs of their respective teams, and have a decent shout to be considered among the best CBs in the Prem.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14
No underrated but Kaboul has had so many injuries and problem keeping his form/place because of those injuries that many people forget how good a defender he is. Hopefully he can stay fit for us and for France.
For those who disagree: why? I think he's under-appreciated not underrated.
3
u/wwxxyyzz Feb 17 '14
Ivanovic is a good shout, scores a fair few goals as well.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Is Coloccini underrated or can we count him? Lost a bit of pace, but still is brilliant whenever he plays
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Godin
1
u/envague Feb 17 '14
For all the Gunnercentrism here, I'm surprised that Bacary Sagna doesn't get much love. I'm always impressed by him in the Arsenal games I watch.
1
u/TheRoyalTenenThom Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14
Filipe Luís.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Jose Angel for us, he's been really good at left back in my opinion. he just had a great game against malaga
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Dave
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
Cannot believe no one has said Hugo Campagnaro.
1
u/willavilla2 Feb 18 '14
Vlaar.
1
u/B0M85H311 Feb 18 '14
I think Lovren is under appreciated at Saints
1
u/river49 Feb 18 '14
Bayern with less than a 1/3 seems a little odd, considering last year's result and the form of the two clubs right now.
1
u/yoMush Feb 18 '14
Okore
1
u/futballfanman Feb 18 '14
Arbeloa, Abidal, Yepes, and Ballesteros.
1
u/DrCrazyFishMan1 Feb 18 '14
Dave
1
u/TheDica Feb 18 '14
Wes brown. Last year sunderland had mignolet saving their arse defensively now its brown. Always calm and has a 100% tackle success rate. Amazing for a man who had previously been injured for almost 2 years
1
u/Incaahhh Feb 18 '14
Distin, Koscielny, or Macherano
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
Varane
1
u/T0mmyTsunami Feb 18 '14
Jérémy Mathieu
1
u/ertant Feb 18 '14
I'm not sure if Ivanovic is considered underrated, but if he is then I would put him right up there in the top 2-3
1
u/Ploxyy Feb 18 '14
Virgil van Dijk
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
Chris Smalling.
1
u/XlPoLaR04 Feb 18 '14
Jan Vertonghen maybe? I would like to see him in the conversation with Kompany for best CB in the PL. When we don't have him on an island at LB he truly is something else.
1
u/DellMB Feb 18 '14
Sokratis Papastathopoulos .
1
u/KingOfCopenhagen Feb 18 '14
It would be interesting if people chose a player who is NOT in there own team.
The question isn't who's the most under appreciated in YOUR team.
1
u/Ausrufepunkt Feb 17 '14
Großkreuz
He's been stellar for Dortmund this season
People always quickly disregard him because he's not as flashy and shiny in his moves as other players...but yknow, work hard - play hard.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Ranocchia.
In an organised defence, he'd be top class.
1
u/An_Eloquent_Turtle Feb 18 '14
Might be a bit late to the party, but Ryan Shawcross. I'd rather him get picked for England than jagielka or Dawson.
1
u/maroon_sky Feb 17 '14
Zabaleta, up until recently. This guy works his ass off in every game and everyone was talking about how good Kompany was. I honestly think that he got appreciated this season only because Kompany was injured a lot.
1
u/nashvillepicker Feb 17 '14
Sebastian Bassong. No-nonsense CB always looking to close down his man and tackle. Great in the air and the only reason we're not bottom this season.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Adriano. Can play everywhere along the backline, and is very disciplined defensively. Has a rocket shot from outside the box as well. He's a very important contributor to Barcelona.
1
u/So1ar Feb 17 '14
I really rate Jose Enrique for Liverpool. I don't know if he's underrated but I don't hear him mentioned much and I don't think he's ever gotten an call up to the senior Spain squad. He got a few at U21 level.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
I'll give Hector Moreno a shout. Rock for Espanyol, he really has no holes in his game.
1
u/HuYuHaiDing Feb 17 '14
I'm surprised by a lot of the defenders mentioned here. I thought most of them got appreciated quite well actually. I mean players like Distin, Barzagli, Subotic, Di Sciglio, Koscielny, Ivanovic, Benatia, Cahill, Boateng, Criscito, Lovren, Pepe, Azpilicueta, Vlaar and Evans are more known to me as good defenders than bad. I actually had a very hard time naming an unappreciated defender.