r/soccer • • Mar 08 '14

Your clubs best homegrown player ever

Who would you say is the best player your club has had come through your system? You can only pick one although I'd understand if you had trouble picking between two.

We don't get many through but undoubtedly the best and biggest we had was Laurie Cunningham, he wasn't with us for long but this is the only time a player has gone from playing for Leyton Orient to playing for Real Madrid!

141 Upvotes

634 comments sorted by

146

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

The King of Rome, Francesco Totti.

292

u/galaad09 Mar 08 '14

C. Ronaldo...

88

u/ChezMan44 Mar 08 '14

There there

67

u/ofap Mar 08 '14

No contest. Runner ups: Nani, Moutinho, Figo, Futre, Patrício, Damas...

19

u/theeolivetree Mar 08 '14

Nani ahead of Figo, Futre and Damas in the order you remember them?!

93

u/ofap Mar 08 '14

No order in particular, just named the first ones that came to my mind

→ More replies (1)

135

u/Ikestar Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Cruijff.

24

u/ajax96 Mar 08 '14

Pretty easy choice. In many ways he is why modern football is played the way it is

7

u/Ikestar Mar 08 '14

Yeah there's a ton of honorable mentions but there's no way to justify any of them over 14.

63

u/arron77 Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

TIL: how Cruyff is spelt by the dutch

Edit: til not tl dr

15

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

they spell it Ruud van Nistelrooij not Nistelrooy either

7

u/Jarik42 Mar 08 '14

It's the same with Kuyt

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

103

u/marauding_forward Mar 08 '14

Tony Adams, definitely.

He signed for Arsenal as a schoolboy in 1980, made his debut aged 16 in 1983, went on to win ten major honours with the club (some whilst as club captain) and retired in 2002. His entire 22 year career was with us and now he has a statue outside the Emirates.

Proper Roy of the Rovers stuff.

29

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Tony Adams would tell you it was Liam Brady.

3

u/Plecboy Mar 08 '14

He joined Arsenal at 15 and made his debut at 17. I'm not sure if that constitutes "homegrown". He spent most of his formative years in Dublin. I'd give Adams the shout ahead of Brady.

23

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Tony Adams put through by Steve Bould, WOULD YOU BELIEEVVVVE IIIIITTTT?!?!??!?!

That... sums it all up.

11

u/PenguinKenny Mar 08 '14

YouTube - gives me goosebumps every time.

14

u/TheDrunkITBloke Mar 08 '14

Proper Arsenal man through and through. Shame his management career didn't go particularly well.

4

u/supersy Mar 08 '14

Have you listened to his Desert Island Discs? It'll make you love him even more.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00st439

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/TheCheesemongere Mar 08 '14

Billy Wright.

Most caps as England captain, led the team to three First Divisions titles and an FA Cup.

15

u/Psychowolf87 Mar 08 '14

And despite being a Centre half and playing over 600 games for club and country, he was never once cautioned or sent off.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/StoriesToBeTold Mar 08 '14

Steve Bull though...

3

u/Jerglingz Mar 08 '14

Steve Bull was a legend but Billy Wright takes the edge IMO.

→ More replies (3)

52

u/SeeminglyTomC Mar 08 '14

In terms of importance to the club, as well as ability, it's probably either Liam Brady or Tony Adams.

Would also give an honourable mention to David O'Leary. Very talented player and has the most Arsenal appearances.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Fun fact: David O'Leary got his first and only red card in his last game for telling the ref he'd lost control of the game.

→ More replies (17)

95

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Paolo Maldini

16

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Baresi surely!

24

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Baresi was a fantastic CB, but all things considered, I think Maldini is the greatest all around defender ever. Not only is he the best fullback the world has ever seen, but he could play CB better than almost all natural CBs.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Personal preference. I grew up with Maldini as the captain and he was always the captain in my eyes. I can understand if people think Baresi is better, but from my personal view our best homegrown player is Maldini

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

23

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Choose one of the Benders

61

u/Emmanuell89 Mar 08 '14

i choose you then

34

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Says the All Boys fan.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/minminsaur Mar 08 '14

TIL Lars & Sven Bender came from Cezero Osaka.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

245

u/doberlae Mar 08 '14

Don't ask...

345

u/TheKanyeCompass Mar 08 '14

Bayern is browsing this thread.

27

u/brazijl Mar 08 '14

It rhymes on Möpse

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Chimpville Mar 08 '14

hahaha hugs

10

u/Xian244 Mar 08 '14

Susi Zorc for 36 years of great service.

Probably not the best in terms of ability though. :/

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Peter Beardsley.

comment from /u/mulhuzz summing him up:

"Amazing that he was just constantly in space. Testament to his ability of course but I do wonder if team's just thought 'fuck it, we'll never get the ball off him anyway, leave him in space' Some of my favourite goals in that collection are when he is almost walking with the ball and opposition just can't take it off him. Other favourites are the patented 'well this cross isn't absolutely inch perfect and I don't want to move if I don't have to....I wonder if a bicycle kick might do the trick?' and the equally delicious 'oh...keeper looks a millimetre off his line here, I can definitely lob him from here.' Neither before nor since has a player of such grace, intelligence or charm graced the shirt. Not to mention outright skill. He is probably the finest footballer England has ever produced with the ball at his feet. Certainly in my lifetime."

8

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Twinkletoes. Such a good player, good looking too.

Wtf was that song all about though?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Disinformasiya Mar 08 '14

That first touch at 1:58 man!

2

u/sjtnufc Mar 08 '14

Pedro is a legend, was an absolute magician and a true gentleman aswell, but I would have to give my vote to the most naturally gifted Englishman of all time: Paul Gascoigne. Similar type of player to Zidane, but better. Had Alex Ferguson signed him for Utd he might've managed to help him sort out his issues, and he would've gone down as one of the greatest ever with the amount of accolades he would've won.

English football's most tragic figure of the last 25 years.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheScarletPimpernel Mar 08 '14

Part of one of the best footballing sides that has ever existed. He was magic.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/TheKingMonkey Mar 08 '14

Gazza was better!

→ More replies (2)

336

u/Morizar Mar 08 '14

Steven Gerrard

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Fun fact: I met Ronnie Moran at an ESPN event and asked him who he thought was the best Liverpool player (it was a bet, i won). He said Dalglish.

yeah i know he wasn't home grown but i though scousers might like to hear this opinion.

→ More replies (12)

40

u/lance16k Mar 08 '14

Bobby Moore

3

u/greg19735 Mar 08 '14

It's kind of boring that there's no debate. But it's true. Moore is one of the best defenders ever so it's an easy choice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

38

u/Executioner_Smough Mar 08 '14

Emile Heskey.

ͼ(ݓ_ݓ)ͽ

12

u/Owner_of_GoalDotCom Mar 08 '14

? Heskey was a great player, better than a lot of names mentioned on here.

4

u/Executioner_Smough Mar 08 '14

He was. Liverpool ruined him though, he was never as good as he was when he was at Leicester.

33

u/DerDummeMann Mar 08 '14

Gary Linekar surely.

18

u/Executioner_Smough Mar 08 '14

Yes, you're right (at least, during my life-time). But I just wanted an excuse to use that face.

That being said, Heskey has been our best talent during the Premier League era, which is quite depressing really.

21

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

That's not depressing, he was awesome once.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

55

u/Sodapopa Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14
  1. Johan Cruyff
  2. Dennis Bergkamp
  3. Marco van Basten
    Favorite: Clarence Seedorf.

Never saw Cruyff play himself but not putting him first would simply be dead wrong. Then between Bergkamp and van Basten it's close, both in a league of their own. My all time favorite though is Clarence Seedorf, the rolemodel of rolemodels when it comes to football.

EDIT: We need an Ajax flair! It's here, found it! Actually, the amount of crests is extremely impressive. For a brief moments I actually believed my local neighborhood paint-drawn five-a-side team logo would appear somewhere.

11

u/Minnesotaugust Mar 08 '14

Van Basten? I feel like he wasn't homegrown because of his stint at UVV and Elinkwijk. 15 is a little late for to be called a homegrown player IMO

8

u/Sodapopa Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Yeah well it's the neverending discussion. I agree with you, although 15 years old (especially back then) is on the edge.

Props to Elinkwijk as deserved, love those stories about the local club where the player grew up. My dad for instance was part of several coaching teams of Ruud van Nistelrooy back home at this small little club called RKSV Margriet, if only he knew in advance right ;)

4

u/apotre Mar 08 '14

Aside for the personal views on the matter, doesn't the current rule state that he has to spend at least 3 years before his 21st birthday at the club for him to be considered homegrown?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/rxh339 Mar 08 '14

Man the players Ajax came/comes up with never ceases to amaze me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/attackisbestdefense Mar 08 '14
  1. Johan Cruijff
  2. Piet Keizer
  3. Dennis Bergkamp
  4. Frank Rijkaard
  5. Clarence Seedorf

Van Basten is not home grown. as pointed out by Minnesotaugust he came from Elinkwijk (and UVV before that).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/ersanb Mar 08 '14

Arda Turan

4

u/apotre Mar 08 '14

Tugay Kerimoğlu and Bülent Korkmaz should get honourable mentions as well.

79

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Raul

42

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Tough choice between him and Casillas.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Omar Bravo.

5

u/Ikestar Mar 08 '14

How's Carlos Fierro doing, he still looking good? He was amazing in FM2013.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/drubi305 Mar 08 '14

I want to go with Salcido. I just love that damned dinosaur.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

I remember the season Bravo played in the MLS with SKC a couple years ago. He was definitely entertaining to watch. Shame it was only a season.

165

u/xMGMT Mar 08 '14

Paul Scholes.

132

u/NIgooner Mar 08 '14

George Best is rolling in his grave. Not just United's best ever player, but one of the best of all time anywhere.

151

u/DerDummeMann Mar 08 '14

I think it's a bit disingenuous to talk about players you never really watched.

So, whenever these things come up, I do mention the greats I never watched, but I find it odd when people put such lush praise on players they have maybe only seen youtube clips of.

→ More replies (11)

19

u/Ailez Mar 08 '14

Most people from the Busby Babes era would say Duncan Edwards. Scholes and Best are both great shouts also.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

24

u/arron77 Mar 08 '14

Never will we see such a unique player like Paul Scholes again.

(By this I mean unwavering loyalty and his disregard for the media. Just want to play football.)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

his greatest qualities

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/Jackson9Martinez Mar 08 '14

there are various,what about the Busby babes? Best? Charlton? Beckham? Giggs?

but I would say Cleverley.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Sir_Bryan Mar 08 '14

Beckham and Giggs deserve a shout. I'd go with Scholes too though.

41

u/The96thPoet Mar 08 '14

Are you guys serious? Beckham doesn't come close to Giggs and Scholes.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

only in shirt sales!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

40

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

John Stones

94

u/marauding_forward Mar 08 '14

You know nothing, John Stones.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/PeppercornMedley Mar 08 '14

Thank You!

5

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Yo....you're welcome.... :( Can't we just have him back for just.. just one game?

→ More replies (1)

131

u/Rummenigge Mar 08 '14

If you submit a name, can you at least give an explanation as to why you think he is the best among all homegrown players? What has this subreddit come to? Gifs, shitty discussions without any depth and downvoting based on disagreement.

21

u/PureDarkness93 Mar 08 '14

There's lots of discussion beneath most answers once people suggest other people for that club and they discuss which is better. The ones that don't have those are the ones where it's obvious why they are the best at their club, like Cristiano Ronaldo and Gerrard.

5

u/The_Shandy_Man Mar 08 '14

Gerrard is by no means obvious for Liverpool, Liverpool have have had quite a few great home-grown players e.g Fowler and Macca. Personally I think Gerrard is the best but you can easily make an argument for the man they call God at Anfield.

→ More replies (16)

19

u/GreenMoonRising Mar 08 '14

Trouble picking between two?

McNeill, Johnstone, Dalglish, Murdoch, McStay, McGrain, etc. - there are almost too many to choose from!

If I was pushed, my choice would be Jimmy Johnstone.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Billy McNeill - The first man to captain a British football club to European Cup success, played over 800 games at Celtic.

Jimmy McGrory - 538 goals in 534 games, record goal-scorer in British football, the 8th greatest striker of all time according to the International Federation of Football History & Statistics.

Jimmy Johnstone - One of the best right wingers of all time, not as well known as he should be as there were better players around that time that have taken the spotlight. George Best, Bobby Charlton, Gerd Müller, Beckenbauer, Cruyff, Dragan Džajić, Eusébio and Flórián Albert.

Kenny Dalglish - Not as good as the others but above but played more recently, still a great player.

7

u/GreenMoonRising Mar 08 '14

Any Liverpool fan would vehemently disagree about King Kenny. Indeed, some older Celtic fans put him on a par with Larsson for his time with us.

Don't forget Danny McGrain (thought to have been one of the best right-backs in the world at the time), Bobby Murdoch (lauded by Jock Stein and many of the Lisbon Lions themselves to have been the best of them, and called the 'complete footballer' by Helenio Herrera) and Paul McStay (Celtic's most capped Scotland international who could have played anywhere in the world - indeed he was linked with many English sides and Inter were rumoured to be in for him in 1992).

33

u/eVolution91 Mar 08 '14

Aaron Ramsey.

21

u/like_a_baws Mar 08 '14

My dad would probably say John Toshack, but I'd agree with you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

52

u/AhoyDaniel Mar 08 '14

Messi.

And if people feel like that part of his childhood and his whole teenx year arent enough to be considered our youth, then Xavi.

6

u/BlameTibor Mar 08 '14

Messi, half homegrown? What age do the kids have to be to claim him? 13/14 or younger?

6

u/Jorlung Mar 08 '14

As a fetus.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Tom Finney (Preston)

For more recent years I'd probably say either Paul McKenna or Andy Lonergan.

McKenna came through while Moyes was taking over and got us into the Championship, he became one of the best midfielders in there and when we lost our way he moved on for £1mil to Forest and proceeded to score a beaut in his first ever game against us :( I think he now plays under Grezza (Graham Alexander) at Fleetwood Town.

Lonergan was our first choice goalkeeper for about.. 6 years, maybe more, I'm not gonna wiki that. Probably wasn't as influential as McKenna but it was nice to see him get the odd game as a teenager and then to break through. He scored a goal against Leicester which was hilarious, then we sold him on to Leeds around the same time McKenna left. I don't think he did much else.

One for the future, Bailey Wright!

16

u/PalacePete Mar 08 '14

Wilfried Zaha probably has the most potential (which sadly seems to be going to waste), but based on achievements so far it would probably be Victor Moses, as he has won the Europa League and the African Cup of Nations. Don't think Ian Wright counts because he was scouted from a non-league team.

17

u/TheKingMonkey Mar 08 '14

Palace signed him from Sunday league football. He was almost 22 by the time they picked him up too. Wright's story about how he became a pro is one of the best and most inspiring I've ever heard.

6

u/Vibot Mar 08 '14

So there's still a chance for me?...

3

u/Jangles Mar 08 '14

Imagine being that Sunday league CB who heard a few years down the line that that sod bagging hat tricks against him every time was starting for Arsenal.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/stats94 Mar 08 '14

Gylfi Sigurdsson :( my boy.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

I hate how wasted he with us at the moment, he's a very solid player

3

u/stats94 Mar 08 '14

We'll have him back. please give him back

8

u/EFCLuke Mar 08 '14

Joe Royle or Wayne Rooney recently.

15

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Let's hope it ends up being Barkley

51

u/mappsy91 Mar 08 '14

The mighty Ledley King

This tackle on Robben as proof

23

u/Postalservic Mar 08 '14

Why not Hoddle? I'm not deriding your nomination but Hoddle, the technique that man had would have people drooling. I feel a bit like how Totti doesnt quite get the recognition he deserves for staying with Roma and not winning as much as he could goes for the same with Hoddle. I mean look at the difference in how people recognised his ability after going to Monaco compared to when he played for us.

Edit: Spelling

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Got to be Hoddle

28

u/godismanen Mar 08 '14

I've only read about and seen highlights of Hoddle but he seems to have been a midfielder for the ages, he might edge King for me.

16

u/ron_manager Mar 08 '14

If it wasn't for his bizarre views on the disabled I think he would have been a great England manager too, we played some great stuff under him.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Man, King was a boss back in the day

16

u/ChezMan44 Mar 08 '14

If only he had knees that matched his ability...

21

u/DerDummeMann Mar 08 '14

Glenn Hoddle mate.

8

u/Dooey123 Mar 08 '14

No doubt King was a great defender but players like Hoddle come along once in a generation and he was admired throughout Europe.

4

u/Piemonade Mar 08 '14

Gah fuck I miss Ledley so much :'(

2

u/failem Mar 08 '14

Such an amazing player. I feel like if his legs weren't mate of glass he could become one of the best defenders ever.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/rogeedodge Mar 08 '14

Jackie Milburn, Chris Waddle and Paul Gascoigne all started out their careers with Newcastle.

Add Alan Shearer and Peter Beardsley as local boys that eventually made their way back to the club.

Sir Bobby Robson, Bobby Charlton and Jack Charlton were also local boys but never played for the club. Newcastle have a pretty atrocious record when it comes to spotting and developing youth players.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Bryan Robson too, if memory serves me. Agent brucie as well.

5

u/BeastOfBritish Mar 08 '14

Chris Waddle actually started in non-league and didn't come through Newcastle's youth setup.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/dayumgurl1 Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Guðni Bergsson

edit: Atli Eðvaldsson also a strong contender

7

u/reece0n Mar 08 '14

Jay Rodriguez, at least from the last 40 years or so. (Not in the same class as the other players listed here, but we love him)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Agree with J-Rod for the time i've been following since the late 80's but my Dad would cuff me over the head repeatedly saying "Dobbo, Dobbo, Dobbo" for uttering such sentiments.

Then regale me with stories of how our youth system was the envy of men and gods alike during the 60s. Yes Dad, I know, you've mentioned it before.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/nacho78 Mar 08 '14

Luis Suarez. I am from Uruguay and fan of Club Nacional de Futbol.

17

u/EJR94 Mar 08 '14

Steven Gerrard has to be top of the list for us

12

u/Killspender Mar 08 '14

Per Mertesacker

21

u/gonzo20 Mar 08 '14

Maradona. Although you could argue that would be Argentinos Juniors'.

Personally, I would say Riquelme. At his prime he was an absolute spectacle to watch.

3

u/matumdq Mar 08 '14

Like fully homegrown and developed at Boca, I'd say Tevez

→ More replies (5)

6

u/ujussab Mar 08 '14

Depends, can we claim Heskey?

8

u/pix1985 Mar 08 '14

Instead of Lineker?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lazenbooby Mar 08 '14

Either Phil Jagielka or Kyle Walker.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

boateng brothers maybe

11

u/voiceofreason9 Mar 08 '14

Dwight Yorke

5

u/rdzzl Mar 08 '14

One of my favorite players ever. I can not express how impressed I was with his midfield performances in the 2006 WC. What an intelligent, lovely player. Always had a smile in him too.

4

u/TheKingMonkey Mar 08 '14

Dunno if Dwight counts as home grown, we signed him as a schoolboy but we did import him from the Caribbean based on ability he already had.

I think it's difficult to argue against Sid Cowans.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/random_german_guy Mar 08 '14

Big Fucking German

14

u/Ochinko Mar 08 '14

Vincent Kompany (RSCA fan here)

3

u/BrotherSams Mar 08 '14

Oh Captain. My Captain.

I'ld give a kidney to see Kompany end his carreer at RSCA with Vandeborre & Tielemans.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

With your flair, i'd have thought Ezno Scifo

→ More replies (4)

42

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Gareth Bale

27

u/TheKingMonkey Mar 08 '14

Alan Shearer wasn't bad either. Another Southampton youth team graduate who went for a world record fee, but surely as a Saints fan there is only one answer you are morally allowed to give?

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Le God, surely!

27

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Yep. Shearer would also be a candidate.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

27

u/DerDummeMann Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Paul Scholes, Ryan Giggs, maybe even Charlton depending on your definition.

You have chosen an interesting choice of words, because using the FA's current definition of a homegrown player, Cristiano Ronaldo would be one for us. But, that's clearly not what you meant.

Edit:- Can't believe I forgot George Best.

5

u/barlingbackbable Mar 08 '14

Ben Davies, not because hes probably the only proper homegrown player we have but because of his merit as a footballer. Plays defensive rolls on either flank, not afraid to have a run with the ball, decent pace and crossing abilty, can shoot (scored a belter earlier in the season against palace) and the boy isn't even 25 yet! He was given a chance by Laudrup after Taylor broke his leg last season and now hes a key player in our starting 11. This boy is going places!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Robbie James or Cliff Jones.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/atreyaaswin1234 Mar 08 '14

Iker Casillas or Raul

11

u/Jerzy_Letz Mar 08 '14

Toni Kroos

8

u/adityaseth Mar 08 '14

Our Honorary President and one of the greatest Italian footballers of all time, Giampiero Boniperti, who played alongside two of the other greatest players Juventus ever had: Omar Sivori and John Charles. The man scored 182 goals for Juve, and his record was only beaten by the boy he signed for us in 1993: Alessandro Del Piero, Juventus' favorite son.

It's really a beautiful story.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/caks Mar 08 '14

Pelé

4

u/mattz0r98 Mar 08 '14

Sir Tom Finney, without a doubt. Rest in peace, you legend.

4

u/JustBuyAnotherTen Mar 08 '14

Puyol! He has been incredible for barca!

4

u/Carthradge Mar 08 '14

Ronaldinho

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Ashley Young or David James.

1

u/Grantus86 Mar 08 '14

Did John Barnes come through your academy?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/hreiedv Mar 08 '14

George Best

3

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Cliff Bastin.

In my lifetime, it's hard to look beyond Dean Moxey.

3

u/madden27 Mar 08 '14

Easy one, Kevin Keegan.

3

u/TheDynamo55 Mar 08 '14

Carles Puyol.

3

u/ianwilson1997 Mar 08 '14

Anichebe wins hands down

3

u/abbygunner Mar 08 '14

Without a doubt in my mind, Tony Adams. The guy bled Arsenal. I sometimes feel saddened that I only got to see the end of his career but looking back I know he was just immense. Liam Brady is a shout as well, but I haven't seen enough of him but from what I've seen he was a God.

3

u/emreuysaler Mar 08 '14

Arda Turan

3

u/BCFC92 Mar 08 '14

Tom Cleverly...

4

u/plooney Mar 08 '14

Wayne Rooney

4

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

I want to say Michael Laudrup, but that would be stretching it a little, so Ill settle for Brian Laudrup.

2

u/Wombatsarecool Mar 08 '14

Carlos Vela never made a 1st team apperance and doesn't consider himself a Chivas product but it's him. Cheech a close 2nd.

2

u/mrtaway Mar 08 '14

In recent times I'd say Dean Moxie. Jamie Mackie is an ex player aswell, but he wasn't homegrown

2

u/mesor Mar 08 '14

I didn't see either play, but Facchetti and Meazza are absolute legends.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MrBathroom Mar 08 '14

Luka Modrić

2

u/matumdq Mar 08 '14

Historically, definitely Alfredo Di Stefano, but then the club doesn't identify or love him as much as Norberto "Beto" Alonso, he's more of a symbol to the club, too bad he's now too much into criticizing the club than supporting it

2

u/IlCattivo91 Mar 08 '14

Totti & De Rossi.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Thibaut Courtois.

Honorable mentions for Kevin de Bruyne and Christian Benteke.

2

u/shotputprince Mar 08 '14

giggs or scholes

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '14

Paul Gascoigne

2

u/Aspley_Heath Mar 08 '14

Southampton fan here.

Toss up between Shearer, Bale and Matt Le Tissier.

So probably Shearer. Bale still has time to change that.

2

u/Kaiserkotska Mar 08 '14

Mike Summerbee!

2

u/thelix Mar 08 '14

Rafa Marquez - Atlas FC from Mexico

2

u/Theninjapirate Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

United have an incredible list of candidates:

  • George Best
  • Paul Scholes
  • Ryan Giggs
  • Bobby Charlton
  • Duncan Edwards

14

u/Roland1405 Mar 08 '14

Philipp Lahm.

111

u/Ikestar Mar 08 '14

I'd think Beckenbauer, actually.

14

u/dYYYb Mar 08 '14

Maybe his club is FC Gern and he just supports Bayern...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

13

u/jprsnth Mar 08 '14

Well there's this short little guy, apparently from Argentina.

29

u/gonzo20 Mar 08 '14

Newell's fans incoming...

20

u/oldaccount Mar 08 '14

I don't think where you play U10 really counts.

11

u/svefnpurka Mar 08 '14

Fine, Xavi or Iniesta.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/TheLeoMessiah Mar 08 '14

He moved there when he was thirteen, he's purely a Barca talent now

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jason_in_sd Mar 08 '14 edited Mar 08 '14

Jon Flanagan

1

u/pubey_tampon Mar 08 '14

Trevor Francis

1

u/bamsaron Mar 08 '14

Not sure if George Best counts because he joined during his early teens, but he would be my choice hands down.

1

u/JeanneHusse Mar 08 '14

Laurent Blanc from Montpellier

1

u/therealmacoy Mar 08 '14

Kyle Walker

2

u/lazenbooby Mar 08 '14

Blades fan? I was thinking Jagielka!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/BeastOfBritish Mar 08 '14

Lawrie Cunningham