I agree with this entirely. I think in the modern game fullbacks have become extremely important. I think this is because there aren't a lot of quality fullbacks compared to other position. I think it's the hardest position to fill currently. There are only a handful of really good fullbacks and then I think there is a large gap in quality beneath them.
Because the truly talented youngsters shudder at the thought of being a "defender". It isn't a glorious position and seldom scores any goals. I totally agree though that fullbacks are one of, if not the most important parts of a good squad
I think comparing players is pointless. Messi vs Ronaldo, Pelé vs Maradona or every "top 10 players of all time?" thread I see every week here. Football is beautiful because of the diversity of every player's abilities.
I think that some comparisons can be valid (funnily enough, the examples that you gave) if they're similar players. What I can't understand though, is comparisons like "Pogba is twice the player that Sterling is". How do you compare a midfielder with a winger!?
Football to me is 75% a social affair, and that I clues discussions and hypotheticals. It might not be accurate but it's a pleasant way to spend the hours before kickoff.
Plus, it's virtually impossible. If Ronaldo scores 30 against Barca exclusively, whereas Messi scores 40 against a variety of teams, which is more impressive? I 100% agree with your point, let's just appreciate them for what they are. I've seen Ronaldo live when he played for Utd and he was incredible. Easily the best player i've ever seen live.
I think Half-Scarves are for when you attend a game, but you don't support either team, then it would be cool to have a memory from the game to bring home with you.
Not necessarily a controversial opinion about soccer but more about the culture of /r/soccer that persists in the media too.
This sub tries way too hard to make some players happen. If the following players: Henrikh Mkhitaryan, Keisuke Honda, Adam Lallana, Mohamed Saleh, Michu, Ricardo Quaresma, Rickie Lambert, Adel Taarabt, Heung Min Son, and {insert any Belgian that has had one good year} do a single positive thing in their matches, they end up on the front page with captions like, "Whoa, this guy is total class and underrated."
No, they are not underrated. If anything, the massive amount of upvotes says the complete opposite. There are players this year having massively good years, like Ricardo Rodriguez, Layvin Kurzawa, Serge Aurier, Gabi, Arda Turan and many more that have not made the front page even once. But if Keisuke Honda attempts a free kick that hits the bar the dude gets 500 upvotes with comments like, "He's such class. Why didn't he go to a better team than Milan?" If anyone of you watch these players outside of 30 seconds YouTube highlight reels, you'd notice that they go missing in many matches and all have technical flaws in their games. That is not necessarily anything bad. Most players are like that. You'd have to be a true great to be completely consistent.
I understand that some fan-bases (countries and clubs alike) with a chip on their shoulders want to promote their players but the fact that you caption things with, "OMG, the dude is one of the best players in the world. Give him more love," is pretty darn lame and disingenuous in my opinion - your favoritism is blatantly obvious.
Well in r/soccer's defense; Adam Lallana is a pretty good player. I might be a bit biased because I'm a fan, but he deserves recognition and praise for the season he's having. Factor in that he's English and that explains the medias circlejerk over him.
Jesus Christ, any Pep managed team would turn it into some kind of hypnotizing passing vortex. It would literally be unwatchable without vomiting profusely.
I don't really care that much about football in general. I really only care about my team.
Besides big Champions League games and the national team, I mostly only watch other games when I'm bored.
I'm pretty sure a lot of supporters feel this way. Sports fans that happen to love football and club supporters are two different groups of football fans that have less in common than most people assume.
I think the red card is an over the top and unfair punishment in the majority of circumstances. A red card in the 10th minute is a massively different in comparison to a red card in the 80th minute, there shouldn't be a discrepancy like this.
In the vast majority of cases, a red card in the first half will ensure that the offending team cannot win the game (and will more than likely lose it). A sin bin, like in rugby/league would be more appropriate imo, it ensures that regardless of when the cardable offence happens, the punishment is equal.
I think for pretty much anything except violence, sin bins would be more appropriate.
It's just it sort of wouldn't work in football. What happens if the keeper takes out a player in a goal scoring opportunity, then gets sin-binned for 10 -15 minutes and the other team get a penalty. Do you sub on a new keeper? or have an outfield player play as the goal keeper? I think Rugby positions and players are much more interchangeable so it's not such an issue.
Individually they are better, like Usain Bolt is the fastest man ever or how records are broken every year. The development of techniques, diets, etc just makes them better athletes and players. An average player today is much better than an average player 30 years ago just like players 30 years from now will be much better than the ones today.
Not necessarily. We won't always be on an upward progressive trajectory of players physical (and mental) capability, there must be a point where sports science stagnates. So although in our lifetime we have seen massive improvements to things like diets, it does not mean in the future players will have even better capabilities
When people say Muhhamed Ali is the best boxer, they mean relative to his time period he is the best.
You are correct in the sense, that if Pele somehow time travelled to today, he wouldn't be as good as Messi or Ronaldo (he would still be a top 10 player, that's how good he was). Even then, the only differences are physical. Technique and mentally it has remained the same.
But, the question is how good they were relatively.
I think when they've both retired most people will agree on that. The game now is just much more intelligent, players have a much more diverse range of skills and physically are alot fitter. If you put a 25 year old Pele in the Madrid team now I think he'd seriously struggle against modern opposition.
Every time there is a thread about fights or something people come out with the same old 'These are not real fans'.
Most of them are definitely real fans, and I would even go as far as saying that they have been fans longer than a lot of the people on /r/soccer and go to more matches.
I don't really get this one. Are you trying to say that this season wouldn't have been exciting if they didn't fall apart? Chelsea, City, Liverpool and (maybe) Arsenal would have still done well anyway, right? They had strong teams coming into the season, and they've all played very well throughout. Wouldn't having another team (United) also playing well make this season even more exciting? Or are you trying to say that United would have cruised at the top of the league?
Okay, now imagine next year if United make some decent signings and get back to their old level. Arsenal, Chelsea, Man City, Man U and Liverpool all competing for 4 champions league spots.
I think the safe standing campaign in England is driven by nostalgic fans looking through rose-tinted glasses. Modern stadiums are superior in every way. Standing, even is specific standing areas, should not be brought back.
I kind of want to see a partnership, in Modern football it's all about the one striker supported by a play maker and two wingers, now it's even more, the striker BECAME a second playmaker, i don't know if it's the better progression and natural outcome of better tactics, I just want to see on last time a strong two headed classic offense where the two guys on top are equal and pay side by side.
Each to his own. I'd prefer modern football mixed with terracing; i.e., No fighting fans, safe standing, a lot of cameras, nice snacks, nice arenas. But there's no way I'd want an entire stadium of terracing, that's unfair on the fans who want to sit and watch the game.
When attending matches with kids or grandparents or something I completely agree. When going with mates and the usual mob the civility of it all can be a bit tedious though.
I don't think it's the ''flopping epidemic'' in football that makes it so unpopular with the average american. I think the average american's only exposure to football is that Simpson's bit. ''Flopping'' is just a bullshit excuse.
More importantly, it is not at all crucial that football becomes popular in America. Nobody outside of America cares whether or not football becomes as popular as basketball or handegg.
Any American that won't watch soccer because of flopping but watches the NBA is ignorant. Also, the mainstream fan watches what ESPN talks about. ESPN talks about soccer for like 9 minutes a week.
I honestly think that the sole reason Americans haven't adopted soccer is because big business can't advertise the same way as in a sport with timeouts and breaks. Those companies are more apt to sponsor American football, with its incredibly frequent stops and commercial pricing down to the local level. Less money = less glitz and no stars.
Soccer can sell the borders of the field, jerseys, and half time. Ford must be all "Wait, our commercial has to wait until 45 minutes into the game? Maybe more? Then it's in a 15 minute block? Can't they just change the channel? Sorry, not interested."
But what's changing now is companies realizing that a) whether or not soccer is adopted by the amer-football market, there will always be the built in audience of immigrants in America who will pay to see games, and b) soccer isn't as concussion prone as football so even more talented youngsters stateside are playing it than ever (Mark Cuban talked about this in his AMA, I would link but I'm on mobile, he called it the largest incoming shift in sports in the USA). Those kids are learning about Messi and Ronaldo and are driving consumption.
Vincent Kompany is the most overrated player in world football. He makes far too many mistakes and often gets caught high up the pitch.
I cannot understand the people who rate him with the best CB's in the game. Watch him closely in an average match and he will make mistakes which people just seem to completely ignore when they are judging his ability as a player.
I think Hatem Ben Arfa is and has been massively overrated by the Newcastle fans and other football fans for the last two seasons.
Whenever he plays, his teammates are reluctant to pass him the ball, because it always ends in him dribbling one too many opponents and losing the ball, or he shoots the ball way over. Yes, he scores some goals that way, but the amount of lost balls is way higher.
I for one completely understand why he doesn't play as much, and I certainly don't think any team above Newcastle in the table would benefit from having him either.
As an American Gooner, it makes me cringe when other non-English born Gooners go on about their hatred for Spurs. Unless you grew up in it, I don't think you can ever fully understand the rivalry and what it means. Drumming up this "hatred" for them seems fake and manufactured just to fit in.
Zidane is often overrated by people these days. Not saying he isn't an absolute legend. But, when I saw that Zidane was voted as the 2nd best player of all time by r/soccer, I was shocked.
Not just here. This is true everywhere. Most of the players from 30-40 years ago who have entered popular imagination are the ones who performed exceptionally in the world cup. Which is fair enough tbh, it's the biggest stage in the world. If either Messi or Ronaldo lead their team to world cup glory this summer then I can guarantee they will leapfrog Pele and maradona as unquestionably the greatest of all time, instead of being debatedly so.
Remember, most of the people in this sub would have grown up watching Zidane play. You need to go back and watch videos of him playing asap just to remind yourself how incredible he was, absolute legend.
It has to do with the age of most people here and the fact that Zidane had some incredible performances in big games. I don't think he was ever the best active player, and he certainly isn't the second best ever.
I don't want Liverpool to win the title. Their fans are already smug enough as it is. Can you imagine how unbearable they will be if they finally do it?
Genuinely hoping they have an outstanding fail and get 5th. Can't stand Liverpool fans. Constantly bragging about a history that 90% of them weren't alive to witness.
To be able to dive well is a skill in itself. Ashley Young gets roundly abused for being a diver but no one recognises just how good he is at it. Remember Andy Carroll's pathetic dive against Newcastle for LFC a few years ago? That's how not to dive. Ashley Young vs Villa two years ago. That's how to dive.
I feel that you're right, but if you take that stance, you should also accept the skill in getting away with a foul, like Fellaini not being punished for elbowing Zabaleta. Like diving, deliberate fouling with the intention of the referee not noticing is bad for the game, but advantages your team to the point where it can help to be good at it.
That Bergkamp goal against Newcastle (you know the one) is laughably overrated. I genuinely can't figure out if I'm missing something about that goal, because while it's clearly good, I don't see how people seem to consider it among the best goals ever. I saw someone here a few days ago call it the best ever, and I believe it was voted as the 2nd greatest goal in the Premier League's first 20 years (behind Rooney's bicycle kick, which shouldn't have been no. 1 imo but that's not what I'm here to talk about). I don't think it'd be in my top 50 Premier League goals, maybe not top 100 but that would take an awful lot of time to think of 100 other goals. It's certainly not the best goal Bergkamp has scored (that one against Leicester is). Yet, it gets put into a class with some absolutely unbelievable ones. Look at some of the goals it finished ahead of in that Premier League 20 seasons list: Le Tissier vs Newcastle, Di Canio vs Wimbledon, Matty Taylor vs Everton, Yeboah vs Wimbledon, Crouch vs City, Henry vs United - those goals are all so special, even conceding that I may be a little harsh on the Bergkamp goal because I'm tired of hearing it talked about so much that I've become irrational, I don't see how Bergkamp's can possibly be put on that level. Like I said, it's a good piece of skill,, but I don't feel that what he did was something otherworldly, it's just a nice flick. Unless I'm missing something about the exact way that he does it (I really think that I could be, because the consensus on this goal is so strong), it isn't all that unusual, difficult or special (when compared to other "legendary" goals, that is. I'm not saying it's easy, but it's easier than what Le Tissier did against Newcastle, Yeboah against Wimbledon or Bergkamp himself did against Leicester)
Edit: I feel that most people don't appreciate that the volley's I listed - Taylor's aside - weren't just people hitting the ball hard, they involved the kind of skill and control usually only apparent in closer-range goals like Bergkamp's (only Taylor's was a somewhat "normal" volley, and in that case, the distance alone is enough to make it really special. Every other shot was something pretty unusual), but they happened to be done from harder positions to score, and often controlling the ball and taking the shot all took place at once, or within one smooth move. Similarly, I probably don't appreciate what makes Bergkamp's goal as great as it is, because if it was as special as I believe, it wouldn't be talked about much at all. Also, although I think they're all magnificent goals, I picked those ones mostly because they're famous and often seen as other "Greatest Premier League Goal" contenders. It's not a list of my favourites specifically.
It's a flick that I don't think has ever been seen on a football pitch before or since.
Most players, if thinking of trying such a flick in that situation would stab the bottom of the ball with the outside of their right foot in order to send it to the defenders right, as well as giving it the spin to spin it back into the strikers path when he goes around the defender. This goal is a fantastic example of that. Edmundo vs Manchester United
But Bergkamp doesn't have this option, as the ball is fed in at an awkward height. He has to improvise and uses the inside of his left foot to generate the proper direction and spin. This is mindblowing. I genuinely can't think of how he even thought to do it. Let alone pull it off. It's genuinely a piece of skill we might not see replicated for a long long time.
Give me 100 attempts and there is a chance I could replicate some of the volleys and stuff you mentioned. I could spend years trying to pull off that Bergkamp goal and I don't think I ever could.
This is definitely controversial. Let me give you my bit.
All the goals you've listed, besides Le Tissier's, are essentially blooters. Having played soccer, I can tell you I have scored them. Having played soccer, I can tell you there's no fucking way I can ever score what Bergkamp or Le Tissier did. The amount of skill, control, improvisation, and creativity is outstanding.
I remember I was playing for my club team in high school and a ball fell towards my feet from about 30-35 yards out - and I crushed it. I mean I put every single fucking ounce of power into that ball that I could muster. I could have been arrested for assault and battery I kicked that bastard so hard you would not even believe. It was awesome. It swerved into the top of the net, the keeper couldn't do a damn thing. However, let this be known that my 16 year old self was capable of such a feat. I just don't think these "cracker" or "blooter" type goals should be held in such a high regard, because some of them are total flukes. Some are, some not, but you can never really tell. That Matty Taylor goal, for instance. That guy basically just hit it and hoped. I highly doubt he, in the moment, was able to control where that ball was going to go. Great goal, but I think that the intent behind the goal also attributes greatness. That's why I like Bergkamp's so much.
tl;dr Controlling the ball as Bergkamp did is far harder than it looks and some of the goals you listed are not as difficult as they look.
I disagree with your reasoning, but I do think that it isn't close to his greatest goal across all competition. I think we can all agree this should be considered Bergkamp's greatest goal, especially given the context.
The word soccer is stupid and shouldn't be used. But then that's probably because I've grown up with the word football and moving to Ireland and only hearing 'Soccer' is fucking annoying. Although all my friends say football now purely because of me.
That and Bayern Munich have absolutely ruined German football for the next 5+ years.
I don't like Bayern much but can you really blame them? They have been managed incredibly well to the point they have a squad of fantastic players. Financially they are sound and can afford to buy excellent players. They are also a club that most players would like to play for so if anything most clubs should aspire to be like Bayern because they are just that good off and on the field.
I'm from Ireland and everyone i know calls it football. I'm not saying some people don't call it soccer when trying to differenciate gaa and football, but the whole "all my friends call it football purely because of me" just makes you sound arrogant
Its because "football" started as a generic term referring to games played on foot. There was Association Football (soccer), Rugby Football, Gridiron Football (american football), Australian rules football, etc. What you call "football" has no more claim to the word than any of the others. Many places just started calling their regional version of adjective football simply "football", so in places that had a different regional game they have to distinguish Association Football somehow. Calling it Soccer is just easier than calling it Association Football all the time.
Also, the word 'soccer' started in England - so that one is on you.
I fucking hate the argument that "OH YEA! Well you Brits created the word soccer, it came from Associated Football!"
I don't care, it is literally never used here. If you call football soccer and you're English you're a bell end. Fair enough if that's your word in your country but don't try and say we started it. We come up with tons of words but we don't use them all.
You think he's better than Aguero? I would put him third (No bias, but a healthy Aguero is lethal, and Di Maria is one of my favourite players), definitely better than Lavezzi, Higuain etc.
I think that him being the second best player for us is more of a fact than an opinion, only modric could contest that but he hasn't been as bright for the last month as he was in the first half of the season.
The away goals rule is absolutely terrible. If a team ties 0-0 away and ties 1-1 at home, they're out. The system fails to reward teams for keeping a clean sheet in an away leg. This rule is outdated and should be done away with. Just go to extra time.
I think you're missing the point of the rule. It's purpose isn't to reward a team, it's to make games more attractive to watch by giving an incentive for the away team to play more attacking.
Controversial opinion more about this subreddit (and all of reddit).
I hate the scores of "fans" some users have. Some players on this subreddit will make a meaningless comment and tonnes of their friends will just upvote it almost regardless of the content. Meanwhile someone else will have made the same point and not receive any attention.
As a new user to Reddit it took me a while to realize this. I'd prefer if user names were removed from posts so that karma was less a popularity contest and more about content.
The English "golden generation" of the 2000s (Owen, Scholes, Beckham, Terry, Ferdinand, Gerrard etc.) were extremely overrated and realistically never had a chance of winning a major tournament.
Despite all the tabloid hype and jingoistic ads eg. Carlsberg Teamtalk. England never showed once that they were a world class team
And finally the amount of excuses each time they were knocked out was pathetic
He's been absolute dogshit at every international tournament since 2004. I'm dreading the prospect of watching him lumber around with the ball bouncing off him again.
Underdeveloped countries should not host a World Cup. They do not have the financial capability to host an event of this magnitude and have other issues to deal with.....looking at Brasil and S.A.
The modern game is based way too much on physical attributes such as speed and strength. I rarely see the footballing genius that really set apart the champions of earlier in the decade.
For penalty shootouts, the penalties should be taken from the top of the box. The way things are set up right now they might as well flip a coin. Even better, all major finals (champs league, WC, etc.) should have an additional 30 minutes of added time with an additional sub permitted to maximize the chances of deciding a game of football by playing, well, football.
I think an "injury" sub should be introduced. If a player is injured, a team could opt to use an "injury" sub, which would not count against their 3 subs, but would render that player unavailable for the next game.
Eden Hazard is overrated. He will never achieve the same standard as todays' worlds best players, and if he ever wins the ballon d'or, it's because a few players including Messi and Ronaldo would have deteriorated.
Last time one of these threads appeared, some one said that Steven Gerrard didn't deserve to play for England nor Liverpool. Opinions are opinions, but sometimes i feel like im watching a different sport.... i do agree that Hazard isnt ballon d'or worthy, but he is a phenomenal talent.
That football isn't and shouldn't become a 'gentleman's sport'. The amount of shit Jorge Jesus got for showing 3 fingers to Sheerwood is ridiculous. The amount of flame Mourinho gets anytime he says something just slightly controversial is ridiculous (not saying he doesn't say some shit, but most of it is very soft and he gets smashed for it for showing no 'respect'). I doubt Mou doesn't have any respect for any coach, but respect is one thing another is not speaking his mind because he should be 'respectable'.
that players treat the ref like they are 15 year old immature kids who dont get to go out this weekend and beg to their parents to change the decision.
That refs act like they are an untouchable force in the pitch and all their decisions are based on personal opinions most of the time.
I cant stand that. Hopefully you meant something along those lines.
I hate when people say "well there was contact" justifying a player falling on the ground as if they've been shot. Sure, fall over if forced to but unless you are actually hurt get up and carry on.
Barcelona are the greatest team ever. I have heard this a few times recently and I don't think they are. They are one the greatest teams but I think it goes in cycles, with great teams from different generations e.g. Liverpool team of the 80s, etc.
There are 2 freekick goals by Messi against Athletico de Madrid (in two different matches) where he scored before the referee's whistle, surprising both times Courtois and The Wall.
I think football fat-fishes tryes hard everytime to arrange football matches. sry bad ing.
The US has never produced even a mildly interesting footballer and won't for the next fifty years, at least.
It has nothing to do with numbers or popular appeal, it has to do with mentality, their basic conception of the game. Football, unlike their other sports, is essentially a game of wits, not athletics, which is why the English can sometimes struggle a bit (they emphasise the physicality ahead of the mental aspects of the game). But the US, witless drones that they are (in sporting terms of course), are so far behind that the mind boggles how they still manage to field a full USMNT roster.
They'll produce decent goalkeepers, fullbacks, and the odd midfield battler. Occasionally the world will wearily have to deal with an overrated attacker who will arrive in Europe with Nike tattooed on his arse and forehead and visibly snapping at the joints due to expectation, but he will only be interesting as a cultural phenomenon, not as a footballer.
No, the ultra competitive, run as fast as you can in a straight line before the commercial breaks, mentality that the US have is not at all conducive to producing talented footballers. And the dreary and utterly boring hysterics they get into over "flopping" and "class" and "statistics" (I think that is how it is spellt) shows how little they still understand.
There is a huge chasm of understanding there that they aren't even aware of.
Well, congratulations on being controversial. As an American football fan I have mixed feelings on this topic.
First, you have pinpointed an issue with the US youth system, it does value physicality over technicality which leads to the shabby (but improving) excuse for soccer/football that we call the "MLS," which for me borders on unwatchable. This boils over to the USMNT, which is also pretty hard to watch and can occasionally struggle to keep the ball in bounds.
Second, there is an absurd obsession with flopping (especially on this sub) which comes with common US media bullshit.
THAT SAID, you yourself seem to be incredibly pompous and ignorant yourself. Maybe throughout a lifetime of watching soccer my low birth has actually blinded me to the minutiae of the game which your observant eyes have scoped out but I have a feeling that your claim is just stupid.
The reason the US lacks technical ability is that soccer is taught by a bunch of dads until the junior high school level in a best case scenario.
And your idea that other US sports like basketball and football require little tactical knowledge is, as noted by others, ignorant as fuck.
Do you honestly think American football is not a game of wits? I understand this is an opinion thread but that might be one of the stupidest things I've seen in this sub. American football is literally two teams trying to outwit the other side by calling plays. Players read and predict other players before a play begins and adjust accordingly. The problem with American development is the horrible structure for developing youths compared to those in place for the other sports. Youth soccer at a high level is fucking incredibly expensive and the level of coaching is not comparable to the American sports at the same age brackets.
The thing about the WC is that it comes in summer, you see? in summer there is no highly competitive football, but then the WC comes, and which is football, I fail to see it as anything but good.
Substitutions in overtime should be forbidden. There should be an exception for serious injuries and of course an additional extra time if this happens, but substituting players to get time off the clock should be stopped at 90:00.
The rule change that allowed more than two teams per country to qualify for the champions league has effectively ruined the sport in europe.
Smaller leagues get shafted, all domestic cups have gone from prestigious competitions to hardly being worth anything at all, same goes for the Europa League.
Diving with no contact is cheating, should be treated as cheating, and if confirmed by video evidence should result in lengthy (10 games first offense, season long after that) suspensions.
Most would agree it's a problem, most would probably disagree with my draconian approach to stopping it.
The problem with football is that because it only lasts for 90 minutes a week, everyone feels the need to fill the whole of the other 166 1/2 hours with inane chat, waffle, speculation and bullshit, which is just so unbelievably tiresome.
I consider referee mistakes and dirty play to be part of the game. Diving, hand of god, ghost goals. It makes football more controversial and unpredictable.
And just to make it clear, this doesn't include bad tackles, fixing matches or aggressive fans. These just ruin the game in my opinion.
ITT: Americans think aloud on how they could 'improve the game'.
Now featuring: Making the pitches smaller, making the goals bigger, making 1/4 halves for more ad breaks, having two footballs on the pitch for added hilarity, half time cheerleaders, half time monster trucks, 'orange' cards, and many more..
I don't think rich teams ruin football, if anything it elevates the game and makes other teams want to win so they can afford big name players. I also don't give a fuck what's going on with human rights in Qatar I just want to watch a World Cup, think most of the reports on human rights abuse are bullshit and the people who are commentating on them don't really understand how the Middle East works.
That Manchester United's demise should be blamed wholeheartedly on their beloved Sir Alex Ferguson. He handed down a poor team (as we have come to find out) and he chose a manager whose greatest feat was finishing above Liverpool 3 times (once in the champions league spots).
It gathers far more than the Bradford fire because it is a bigger club.
As it was 25 years ago, the senior staff involved in the police cover up and Sun misreporting are all retired or dead so there is little Justice other then revenge.
The families who are opposing the move to reintroduction of standing have no good argument. The disaster happened due to overcrowding, not standing.
I like Man United. I am enjoying their downfall slightly, and I never want them to play well enough to hinder Liverpool, but English football needs a strong Man United. I also want Everton to get 4th spot.
I can see the everton point,great for the city of liverpool and liverpool should finish ahead anyways,'but the united point I hope they lose every game.
The thing is, in some circumstances, a penalty has a decently lower rate of conversion than the clear goalscoring opportunity, so it doesn't always restore the opportunity (although this could be countered by saying that there are occasions where a penalty has a higher conversion rate than the goalscoring opportunity that the foul took away).
Also, this rule is about player safety. If, as mentioned above, the penalty is less likely to be converted than the goalscoring opportunity, players will rush to foul before the shot can be taken. This is dangerous. Although they would obviously try to commit "just a foul" (as opposed to a yellow or red card worthy foul), their excitement and desperation might lead them to injure opponents if they mistime their foul. With the red card penalty, that's not as much of an issue: players know that any foul, hard or not, gets them sent off.
170
u/feedmecheesedoodles Mar 31 '14
I think full backs are incredibly underrated and can win games on their own. It is usually what separates Champions League teams and mid-table ones.
248
u/aDevastationPie Mar 31 '14
I think Cardiff look better in red than blue :(
265
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Professional managers are more tactically versed than armchair fans.
228
u/Vibot Mar 31 '14
I think comparing players is pointless. Messi vs Ronaldo, Pelé vs Maradona or every "top 10 players of all time?" thread I see every week here. Football is beautiful because of the diversity of every player's abilities.
226
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I actually like vuvuzelas.
50
u/PaulChewsOnMyPhone Mar 31 '14
bring back the snood.
63
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Half-scarves are OK but not meant to be worn.
134
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Not necessarily a controversial opinion about soccer but more about the culture of /r/soccer that persists in the media too.
This sub tries way too hard to make some players happen. If the following players: Henrikh Mkhitaryan, Keisuke Honda, Adam Lallana, Mohamed Saleh, Michu, Ricardo Quaresma, Rickie Lambert, Adel Taarabt, Heung Min Son, and {insert any Belgian that has had one good year} do a single positive thing in their matches, they end up on the front page with captions like, "Whoa, this guy is total class and underrated."
No, they are not underrated. If anything, the massive amount of upvotes says the complete opposite. There are players this year having massively good years, like Ricardo Rodriguez, Layvin Kurzawa, Serge Aurier, Gabi, Arda Turan and many more that have not made the front page even once. But if Keisuke Honda attempts a free kick that hits the bar the dude gets 500 upvotes with comments like, "He's such class. Why didn't he go to a better team than Milan?" If anyone of you watch these players outside of 30 seconds YouTube highlight reels, you'd notice that they go missing in many matches and all have technical flaws in their games. That is not necessarily anything bad. Most players are like that. You'd have to be a true great to be completely consistent.
I understand that some fan-bases (countries and clubs alike) with a chip on their shoulders want to promote their players but the fact that you caption things with, "OMG, the dude is one of the best players in the world. Give him more love," is pretty darn lame and disingenuous in my opinion - your favoritism is blatantly obvious.
279
u/NinjaDiscoJesus Mar 31 '14
Multi Ball is the way of the future
38
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I don't really care that much about football in general. I really only care about my team.
Besides big Champions League games and the national team, I mostly only watch other games when I'm bored.
I'm pretty sure a lot of supporters feel this way. Sports fans that happen to love football and club supporters are two different groups of football fans that have less in common than most people assume.
329
u/Jayesar Mar 31 '14
I think the red card is an over the top and unfair punishment in the majority of circumstances. A red card in the 10th minute is a massively different in comparison to a red card in the 80th minute, there shouldn't be a discrepancy like this.
In the vast majority of cases, a red card in the first half will ensure that the offending team cannot win the game (and will more than likely lose it). A sin bin, like in rugby/league would be more appropriate imo, it ensures that regardless of when the cardable offence happens, the punishment is equal.
148
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo are better than Maradona and Pele.
72
u/Red_Dog1880 Mar 31 '14
That hooligans are fans as well.
Every time there is a thread about fights or something people come out with the same old 'These are not real fans'.
Most of them are definitely real fans, and I would even go as far as saying that they have been fans longer than a lot of the people on /r/soccer and go to more matches.
301
u/TheArbitrageur Mar 31 '14
Man United falling apart has been the best thing for English Football, this has been the most exciting season in years.
11
u/jacob173 Mar 31 '14
I think the safe standing campaign in England is driven by nostalgic fans looking through rose-tinted glasses. Modern stadiums are superior in every way. Standing, even is specific standing areas, should not be brought back.
42
u/Potetost Mar 31 '14
I think players have too much freedom when it comes to changing what national team you'll play for.
48
u/Aspley_Heath Mar 31 '14
4-4-2 is a perfectly good formation in this day and age.
58
u/blackunderpants Mar 31 '14
I actually like Modern Football. No fighting fans, good seats, a lot of cameras, nice snacks, nice arenas etc.
78
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I don't think it's the ''flopping epidemic'' in football that makes it so unpopular with the average american. I think the average american's only exposure to football is that Simpson's bit. ''Flopping'' is just a bullshit excuse.
More importantly, it is not at all crucial that football becomes popular in America. Nobody outside of America cares whether or not football becomes as popular as basketball or handegg.
23
u/sandbag-1 Mar 31 '14
Vincent Kompany is the most overrated player in world football. He makes far too many mistakes and often gets caught high up the pitch.
I cannot understand the people who rate him with the best CB's in the game. Watch him closely in an average match and he will make mistakes which people just seem to completely ignore when they are judging his ability as a player.
8
u/LeoKhenir Mar 31 '14
I think Hatem Ben Arfa is and has been massively overrated by the Newcastle fans and other football fans for the last two seasons.
Whenever he plays, his teammates are reluctant to pass him the ball, because it always ends in him dribbling one too many opponents and losing the ball, or he shoots the ball way over. Yes, he scores some goals that way, but the amount of lost balls is way higher.
I for one completely understand why he doesn't play as much, and I certainly don't think any team above Newcastle in the table would benefit from having him either.
22
u/Mokoba Mar 31 '14
TV replays will spoil the game.
It's a game played by humans who make mistakes, if we remove any chance of the ref making a mistake then why not stop the game if a player does?
Also you can guarantee that it won't be a few seconds, it will be minimum 30 seconds so the TV companies can get an ad or two in.
92
u/otter_pop_n_lock Mar 31 '14
As an American Gooner, it makes me cringe when other non-English born Gooners go on about their hatred for Spurs. Unless you grew up in it, I don't think you can ever fully understand the rivalry and what it means. Drumming up this "hatred" for them seems fake and manufactured just to fit in.
184
u/salfordred Mar 31 '14
Zidane is often overrated by people these days. Not saying he isn't an absolute legend. But, when I saw that Zidane was voted as the 2nd best player of all time by r/soccer, I was shocked.
173
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I don't want Liverpool to win the title. Their fans are already smug enough as it is. Can you imagine how unbearable they will be if they finally do it?
74
u/FlickMyKeane Mar 31 '14
To be able to dive well is a skill in itself. Ashley Young gets roundly abused for being a diver but no one recognises just how good he is at it. Remember Andy Carroll's pathetic dive against Newcastle for LFC a few years ago? That's how not to dive. Ashley Young vs Villa two years ago. That's how to dive.
6
u/hanuta5 Mar 31 '14
Pyro looks cool
117
u/phatboisteez Mar 31 '14
It doesn't matter if you call it "football", "soccer" or whatever. All that matters is the game.
38
u/BoosterGoldGL Mar 31 '14
Liverpool will crumble next season with the weight of CL football and miss out on top 4.
57
u/socrModsBANbiasedly Mar 31 '14
Pele is over rated. Best juggler during game play of all time probably, but best player of all time I find laughable.
90
u/Dob-is-Hella-Rad Mar 31 '14 edited Mar 31 '14
That Bergkamp goal against Newcastle (you know the one) is laughably overrated. I genuinely can't figure out if I'm missing something about that goal, because while it's clearly good, I don't see how people seem to consider it among the best goals ever. I saw someone here a few days ago call it the best ever, and I believe it was voted as the 2nd greatest goal in the Premier League's first 20 years (behind Rooney's bicycle kick, which shouldn't have been no. 1 imo but that's not what I'm here to talk about). I don't think it'd be in my top 50 Premier League goals, maybe not top 100 but that would take an awful lot of time to think of 100 other goals. It's certainly not the best goal Bergkamp has scored (that one against Leicester is). Yet, it gets put into a class with some absolutely unbelievable ones. Look at some of the goals it finished ahead of in that Premier League 20 seasons list: Le Tissier vs Newcastle, Di Canio vs Wimbledon, Matty Taylor vs Everton, Yeboah vs Wimbledon, Crouch vs City, Henry vs United - those goals are all so special, even conceding that I may be a little harsh on the Bergkamp goal because I'm tired of hearing it talked about so much that I've become irrational, I don't see how Bergkamp's can possibly be put on that level. Like I said, it's a good piece of skill,, but I don't feel that what he did was something otherworldly, it's just a nice flick. Unless I'm missing something about the exact way that he does it (I really think that I could be, because the consensus on this goal is so strong), it isn't all that unusual, difficult or special (when compared to other "legendary" goals, that is. I'm not saying it's easy, but it's easier than what Le Tissier did against Newcastle, Yeboah against Wimbledon or Bergkamp himself did against Leicester)
TL;DR: meh
Edit: I feel that most people don't appreciate that the volley's I listed - Taylor's aside - weren't just people hitting the ball hard, they involved the kind of skill and control usually only apparent in closer-range goals like Bergkamp's (only Taylor's was a somewhat "normal" volley, and in that case, the distance alone is enough to make it really special. Every other shot was something pretty unusual), but they happened to be done from harder positions to score, and often controlling the ball and taking the shot all took place at once, or within one smooth move. Similarly, I probably don't appreciate what makes Bergkamp's goal as great as it is, because if it was as special as I believe, it wouldn't be talked about much at all. Also, although I think they're all magnificent goals, I picked those ones mostly because they're famous and often seen as other "Greatest Premier League Goal" contenders. It's not a list of my favourites specifically.
10
u/derscholl Mar 31 '14
The Bundesliga isn't boring. Anyone who thinks the Bundesliga is boring is a god damn glory hunter. Stop watching only the top 4.
41
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Sergio Ramos is a good CB but to be getting into the team of the year is a bit of a joke.
9
u/Shaqiriiii Mar 31 '14
This thread is giving me a heart attack.
192
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
The word soccer is stupid and shouldn't be used. But then that's probably because I've grown up with the word football and moving to Ireland and only hearing 'Soccer' is fucking annoying. Although all my friends say football now purely because of me.
That and Bayern Munich have absolutely ruined German football for the next 5+ years.
35
u/Golazzzo Mar 31 '14
Di maria is the second best player for Argentina and the second best player for Real Madrid.
8
u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Mar 31 '14
I hate Fullham
49
u/retrominge Mar 31 '14
Rule changes should be considered and tested. No sport is perfect.
Barkley isn't ready for a World Cup.
Man United fans are more annoyed about Liverpool's position in the than they are about their own.
Unless Walker comes back from injury and plays like a superstar, Flanagan should go to the World Cup. (assuming Walker was/is going to the World Cup).
Opinions. I'd rather discuss them civilly, if people can do so.
26
u/WackJilshere10 Mar 31 '14
The away goals rule is absolutely terrible. If a team ties 0-0 away and ties 1-1 at home, they're out. The system fails to reward teams for keeping a clean sheet in an away leg. This rule is outdated and should be done away with. Just go to extra time.
7
u/Footyphile Mar 31 '14
Controversial opinion more about this subreddit (and all of reddit).
I hate the scores of "fans" some users have. Some players on this subreddit will make a meaningless comment and tonnes of their friends will just upvote it almost regardless of the content. Meanwhile someone else will have made the same point and not receive any attention.
As a new user to Reddit it took me a while to realize this. I'd prefer if user names were removed from posts so that karma was less a popularity contest and more about content.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
The English "golden generation" of the 2000s (Owen, Scholes, Beckham, Terry, Ferdinand, Gerrard etc.) were extremely overrated and realistically never had a chance of winning a major tournament.
Despite all the tabloid hype and jingoistic ads eg. Carlsberg Teamtalk. England never showed once that they were a world class team
And finally the amount of excuses each time they were knocked out was pathetic
2002 - Seaman
2004 - The Linesman
2006 - C. Ronaldo
2010 - Capello + linesman again
7
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Vincent Kompany is the most overrated player in existence, he wouldn't get close to my top ten centre back list.
27
u/ThuggedOutNine Mar 31 '14 edited Mar 31 '14
England would've performed much better in the last 2 years if Rooney was left at home.
EDIT: Meant to say World Cups.
27
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Underdeveloped countries should not host a World Cup. They do not have the financial capability to host an event of this magnitude and have other issues to deal with.....looking at Brasil and S.A.
30
u/luks1910 Mar 31 '14
The modern game is based way too much on physical attributes such as speed and strength. I rarely see the footballing genius that really set apart the champions of earlier in the decade.
6
u/golasoo Mar 31 '14
For penalty shootouts, the penalties should be taken from the top of the box. The way things are set up right now they might as well flip a coin. Even better, all major finals (champs league, WC, etc.) should have an additional 30 minutes of added time with an additional sub permitted to maximize the chances of deciding a game of football by playing, well, football.
8
u/Lou3000 Mar 31 '14
I think an "injury" sub should be introduced. If a player is injured, a team could opt to use an "injury" sub, which would not count against their 3 subs, but would render that player unavailable for the next game.
68
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Eden Hazard is overrated. He will never achieve the same standard as todays' worlds best players, and if he ever wins the ballon d'or, it's because a few players including Messi and Ronaldo would have deteriorated.
3
u/wishwellPT Mar 31 '14
That football isn't and shouldn't become a 'gentleman's sport'. The amount of shit Jorge Jesus got for showing 3 fingers to Sheerwood is ridiculous. The amount of flame Mourinho gets anytime he says something just slightly controversial is ridiculous (not saying he doesn't say some shit, but most of it is very soft and he gets smashed for it for showing no 'respect'). I doubt Mou doesn't have any respect for any coach, but respect is one thing another is not speaking his mind because he should be 'respectable'.
3
u/Dugsalvador Apr 01 '14
Only the captain should be able to speak to the ref
20
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Nobody gives a fuck about the slave labor in Qatar. What they care about is the fact that its an Islamist regime in an Arab country that's doing it.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I don't think Kagawa has showed any reason to be played on a consistent basis.
7
u/DavideMontreal Mar 31 '14
that players treat the ref like they are 15 year old immature kids who dont get to go out this weekend and beg to their parents to change the decision.
That refs act like they are an untouchable force in the pitch and all their decisions are based on personal opinions most of the time.
I cant stand that. Hopefully you meant something along those lines.
17
u/BleedingGumsmurfy Mar 31 '14
I really really like John Terry. If he spent his career at United, he would be loved by the majority of people.
16
u/DoYouEvenShrift Mar 31 '14
I hate when people say "well there was contact" justifying a player falling on the ground as if they've been shot. Sure, fall over if forced to but unless you are actually hurt get up and carry on.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Barcelona are the greatest team ever. I have heard this a few times recently and I don't think they are. They are one the greatest teams but I think it goes in cycles, with great teams from different generations e.g. Liverpool team of the 80s, etc.
44
u/trowawayatwork Mar 31 '14
That its called football and not soccer.
16
u/NQsDiscoPants Mar 31 '14
Pavel Nedved was the best player of the last twenty years.
12
u/jammywalter0182 Mar 31 '14
Tom Cleverley is a decent player
4
u/cheq Mar 31 '14
There are 2 freekick goals by Messi against Athletico de Madrid (in two different matches) where he scored before the referee's whistle, surprising both times Courtois and The Wall.
I think football fat-fishes tryes hard everytime to arrange football matches. sry bad ing.
4
u/Meph1stopheles Mar 31 '14
I never liked Man United.No matter how good they were.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I don't care about MLS, the USMNT, how sawker is expanding in the US, etc, at all. Complete apathy.
76
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
The US has never produced even a mildly interesting footballer and won't for the next fifty years, at least.
It has nothing to do with numbers or popular appeal, it has to do with mentality, their basic conception of the game. Football, unlike their other sports, is essentially a game of wits, not athletics, which is why the English can sometimes struggle a bit (they emphasise the physicality ahead of the mental aspects of the game). But the US, witless drones that they are (in sporting terms of course), are so far behind that the mind boggles how they still manage to field a full USMNT roster.
They'll produce decent goalkeepers, fullbacks, and the odd midfield battler. Occasionally the world will wearily have to deal with an overrated attacker who will arrive in Europe with Nike tattooed on his arse and forehead and visibly snapping at the joints due to expectation, but he will only be interesting as a cultural phenomenon, not as a footballer.
No, the ultra competitive, run as fast as you can in a straight line before the commercial breaks, mentality that the US have is not at all conducive to producing talented footballers. And the dreary and utterly boring hysterics they get into over "flopping" and "class" and "statistics" (I think that is how it is spellt) shows how little they still understand.
There is a huge chasm of understanding there that they aren't even aware of.
11
u/scurvydog00 Mar 31 '14
I really don't care for the World Cup. It's the beautiful game at it's ugliest.
2
u/ssunburst Mar 31 '14
Corner and Penalty Kick goals aren't meritorious at all.
2
u/conuka Mar 31 '14
Substitutions in overtime should be forbidden. There should be an exception for serious injuries and of course an additional extra time if this happens, but substituting players to get time off the clock should be stopped at 90:00.
2
u/naaah_ Mar 31 '14
The rule change that allowed more than two teams per country to qualify for the champions league has effectively ruined the sport in europe.
Smaller leagues get shafted, all domestic cups have gone from prestigious competitions to hardly being worth anything at all, same goes for the Europa League.
2
u/HighburyOnStrand Mar 31 '14
Diving with no contact is cheating, should be treated as cheating, and if confirmed by video evidence should result in lengthy (10 games first offense, season long after that) suspensions.
Most would agree it's a problem, most would probably disagree with my draconian approach to stopping it.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
The problem with football is that because it only lasts for 90 minutes a week, everyone feels the need to fill the whole of the other 166 1/2 hours with inane chat, waffle, speculation and bullshit, which is just so unbelievably tiresome.
2
u/Sisyphuss Apr 01 '14
I consider referee mistakes and dirty play to be part of the game. Diving, hand of god, ghost goals. It makes football more controversial and unpredictable.
And just to make it clear, this doesn't include bad tackles, fixing matches or aggressive fans. These just ruin the game in my opinion.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '14
Offsides should be decided by technology.
2
u/xu85 Apr 01 '14
ITT: Americans think aloud on how they could 'improve the game'.
Now featuring: Making the pitches smaller, making the goals bigger, making 1/4 halves for more ad breaks, having two footballs on the pitch for added hilarity, half time cheerleaders, half time monster trucks, 'orange' cards, and many more..
2
u/TheMightyTreebeard Apr 01 '14
I don't think rich teams ruin football, if anything it elevates the game and makes other teams want to win so they can afford big name players. I also don't give a fuck what's going on with human rights in Qatar I just want to watch a World Cup, think most of the reports on human rights abuse are bullshit and the people who are commentating on them don't really understand how the Middle East works.
2
u/martin_italia Apr 01 '14
Mario Balotelli will never be a world class player, or considered one of the greats, due to his attitude and work rate.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '14
That Manchester United's demise should be blamed wholeheartedly on their beloved Sir Alex Ferguson. He handed down a poor team (as we have come to find out) and he chose a manager whose greatest feat was finishing above Liverpool 3 times (once in the champions league spots).
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '14
It's time to move on from Hillsborough.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
Mats Hummels is and always has been a great defender (even these past couple of years).
23
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
I like Man United. I am enjoying their downfall slightly, and I never want them to play well enough to hinder Liverpool, but English football needs a strong Man United. I also want Everton to get 4th spot.
I am a terrible Liverpool fan.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '14
If a foul in the area prevents a goalscoring opportunity it's a penalty but not a red, as the penalty restores the goalscoring opportunity.