r/soccer • u/gypsybear • Apr 08 '14
Change My View: r/soccer edition (from r/nfl)
Pretty simple, post an opinion you have on a player, team, coach, whatever and others will try to change your mind.
Try to back up your claims.
EDIT: For the sake of fostering discussion please don't downvote comments. Instead, upvote, reply, and state your argument.
Also, people may want to sort by "controversial".
142
Upvotes
247
u/Yarik32 Apr 08 '14
If Pedro played the same number of games,had the same number of assists and goals that Neymar had this year nobody would give a shit .
32
u/poipoiop Apr 08 '14
I think the Scandinavian league system of playing Jan-Dec ultimately ruins their chances of ever being properly competitive in Europe.
Putting aside the fact that they don't have the same monetary power as Russia, who can afford to buy quality Europe-level players season-in-season-out.
If they were to ever manage to get into Europe, their Group Stage games begin at the end of their season when they're starting to show signs of fatigue and slowing down. They've just played the whole season to be domestically-competitive and then, towards the end, they have to try and compete in Europe against teams who are fresh off a pre-season.
Adding into the mix that countries like Norway and Sweden have extremely high taxes. A Danish club can offer the same wages to a Nor/Swe player and the player could earn more due to Denmark having a lucrative tax-scheme for athlete's, which in turn causes the top-finishing clubs in Nor/Swe every year to sell off their best players and start from scratch.
So if we assume (dream) that a Norwegian/Swedish club can get past the group stage in the EL/UCL, the next Knockout Round would be in February, which means that the Nor/Swe clubs would need to compete with a whole different team to the one who progressed in the first place.
Lose/Lose.
TL/DR; Taxes and winter is ruining Norwegian and Swedish football.
208
u/cypher-raige Apr 08 '14
Americans need to stop comparing European football with the NFL, MLB etc.
It's a lot more like the NCAA. Historic teams rooted in local communities, rivalries that go back hundreds of years and teams of all different sizes.
63
u/the_crooner Apr 08 '14
Balotelli is a great striker and he's going to show it in Brazil.
11
u/buckweed_the_African Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
Selling RvP in the summer would be the daftest thing Moyes could do. Just because Mata, Kagawa and Rooney have played very well together towards the end of the season doesnt mean you go and sell your best striker. That just limits your options and style of play.
edit: removed the ever part.
29
u/TheTrotters Apr 08 '14
Most of football writing and discussion (whether in The Guardian or any other newspaper or on forums like this one) is just the male-equivalent of celebrity gossips. "Who will be fired next?"; "Will X step up?"; "He doesn't want it hard enough!"; "He's selfish/lazy"; endless memes.
There's very little discussion about actual football and very little trying to understand the game better.
13
u/royalewithcheese94 Apr 08 '14
Eden Hazard is overrated, not the second best player in the league like so many people seem to think. I would put him on a par with Theo Walcott.
28
u/poipoiop Apr 08 '14
I like how a Change My View thread generates more discussion that a Controversial Opinion thread.
I'm noticing they're essentially the same thing. Just worded differently.
35
u/Sean88888 Apr 08 '14
Arturo Vidal is the best box-to-box midfielder in the world
55
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
I would rather Newcastle get relegated and be sold than continue to 'be financially stable' with Mike Ashley
236
u/MrSqueegee95 Apr 08 '14 edited Feb 25 '15
Raheem Sterling is better than Januzaj and has more potential.
EDIT: Thought so.
48
u/ining Apr 08 '14
Thiago Silva is not the best Centreback in the world. A defender like Benatia who is able to turn up every week and play at a high standard is worth far more to a team than a player who on his day is incredible.
Similar reason for why Barzagli is more invaluable than Chiellini for Juventus.
176
u/Natniss Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
Jack wilshere is overrated and should not be considered a starter for England.
Edit: I think fans and journalists have hyped him up even more than they usually do for any English player that can tie his own laces. I don't see him as one of englands best players or most important players as some journos have said. I think his last performances for England were very poor and there are plenty of other options. I also find he is very prone to losing the ball in the middle, and sitting down on his arse slapping the floor like a child waiting for a freekick as play goes on and he is nowhere to help.
57
u/Ritzen Apr 08 '14
I know he's seen as a bit of a joke on here but I actually think Demichelis has been fantastic for Man City. A few high profile mistakes/bad games are tarnishing what has been a very good season for him.
98
u/Bob_Swarleymann Apr 08 '14
On an unrelated note to the topic, it kind of destroys this post when people downvote every comment they don't agree with. Try to actually change his view, instead of simply down voting.
48
u/themanguydude Apr 08 '14
Ribery should be voted the sexiest man alive in 2013
72
u/chickenMcNugs Apr 08 '14
Luis Suarez is the best striker in the world at the moment.
85
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
r/soccer is a boring BPL and CL circlejerk
76
u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14
I think that you shouldn't hate on a player because he dives. It's no worse than a player making a foul to prevent a counterattack. However, For the first many say that the player is a disgrace and for the second ''it's part of the game.'' Makes no sense to me.
34
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
Pep Guardiola strives on an already built core and a huge hefty bank roll. He wouldn't have the reputation he has if Barcelona and Munich didn't have such prestige.
75
u/StpMpls Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
MLS has as much to teach the rest of the world as the rest of the world has to teach it.
Few leagues anywhere in the world have faced as much apathy as MLS has experienced. Most leagues take their position for granted. But the way that MLS has experienced success by emphasizing parity and the fan experience should be learned by leagues globally.
The fact that the league is not dominated by one super team and the use of a playoff system keep fans of all teams excited and engaged every year, throughout the season.
The fact that the league is relatively free of fan violence and racism is a huge benefit that helps attract players and casual fans.
8
u/Samperalejo Apr 08 '14
Messi>Ronaldo
Not only in paper (all the records he has broken) but as a team player Messi is much better than Ronaldo. However, I admire Ronaldo's attitude and athleticism. He is the definition of a modern day athlete.
12
u/TheDreaminArmenian Apr 08 '14
This is a breeding ground for reddit arguments. I like it ;)
11
u/captainbergs Apr 08 '14
These thread never achieve anything. Opinions and rebuttal are downvoted, people spout bias and ridiculous opinions which they clearly have zero intention of changing. Some popular sentiment will reach the top.
How many people do you see saying "Jack Wilshere is world class take him to the world cup right away"? compared to "DAE THINK JACK WILSHERE IS OVERATED?!?!?!".
63
u/Bob_Swarleymann Apr 08 '14
The Spanish league is by far the best league in the world. The wealth of talent both born in Spain and emigrated from South America is unrivaled. Take a look at Man City; most of their stars are players from outside the top two La Liga teams who are supposedly shit. Take a look at UCL/Euro League. The Premier League has money and marketing, whereas La Liga has talent and incompetent leadership.
23
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
A neutral hating Young and calling him a cunt while loving Suarez and Sturridge is extremely hypocritical.
And Gerrard's current(!) ability is overrated. He's still great offensively but when he plays as a holding midfielder he leaves way too much space between himself and the back line which has been a large factor why Liverpools' defence has been suspect at times and why they have let in more goals than anyone in the top 7 except Spurs. I find it laughable that so many are putting him in their team of the year.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
The current way of choosing the best player in the world (especially the Ballon d'Or) is flawed.
13
u/cas757 Apr 08 '14
The Champions League is more exciting to watch than the World Cup.
21
u/cheftlp1221 Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
A Euro Super League is inevitable and will be a reality in the next 10 years.
Clubs will sever ties with their local FA's and form their own transnational league that will replace the current UCL.
EDIT:
Here is how I think it would look.
Money. Money is what makes modern soccer go. Especially TV rights fees. When the European Super League happens it will because someone will come along with a solution and offer more money then the clubs will be able to turn down. Playing in the Champions League is already the goal and ambition of most teams because of the money involved. It will be doubly so once a real ESL is put forth.
Competitive Balance. Most European League are already segregated into haves and have nots. Of the top 8 Leagues, 90% of the clubs have zero chance to win their League when the season starts. This 90% are playing not to lose and be relegated. Not exactly the most sporting of intentions.
Having such a competitive imbalance in leagues will ultimately lead to dwindling interest of casual and regular fans. Additionally big clubs are often patronizing to lesser teams in the league and play just hard enough to get the result and not get hurt further deteriorating the product.
Travel. Travel for both the clubs and supporters is a red herring. Travel is part of the game already. One only has to look to the US and their sports leagues to study travel. I am not suggesting that it is not a factor but to dismiss a Super-League because travel is to onerous is patently false. Firstly the travel distances in western Europe are ridiculously close where most of the Super League clubs would be located. Secondly these are highly tuned professional athletes with some of the best bio-mechanical trainers at their disposal. I am pretty sure they can fly 3-4 hours to play a game. I also don't think it would be a problem for 3-5000 supporters a normal away allotment to make their way to Milan, Paris, or Madrid. It is not like they are being asked to travel to an out of the way Eastern European village.
Teams and Format. The European Club Assc was formed in 2008 and represents the biggest clubs in Europe. It was formed to protect the interests of the big clubs and a warning to UEFA that they could take the proverbial ball and go somewhere else. The foundation of a Super League will come from here.
I imagine two 16 team leagues, ESL1 & ESL2.
The First 32
Eng: ManU, ManCity, Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool
France: PSG, Lyon, Monoco, Marseille
Spain: Barca, Real Madrid, Atletico Madrid, Valencia
Italy: Juventus, AC Milan, Inter, Roma
Portugal: Benfica, Porto
Netherlands: Ajax, PSV
Germany: Bayern Munich, BvD, Shalke 04, Wolfsburg
Belgium: Anderlect, Standard Liege
Greece: Olympiacos, Panathinaikos
Turkey: Galatarsaray, Fenerbache, Besikitas
Scotland: Celtic
A set up like this would literally change nothing about the ambitions for the clubs involved; Arsenal could still aim to comfortably finish 4th. I don't think it would have the adverse effect on the homeland leagues like people say. In England, top to bottom would be a wide open exciting race for the title. 10 teams could have title hopes at the start of the season. Winners still get to play for European spots and a chance to qualify for the ESL.
The big clubs get to make a metric fuckton of money and play against world class teams every week. The fans would have a field day. Every week there would be a 6-8 delicious matchups. Neutrals would flock to their TV's. Worldwide interest would spike.
2
u/gwaksl Apr 08 '14
Munich's centre-back situation is wholly unsustainable and Boateng is grossly overrated.
2
u/kbradley27 Apr 08 '14
David Moyes was brought in to never succeed at Manchester United. He is an average manager, who did slightly above average, with an average Everton squad. However, he is, and most likely never will be, close to Alex Ferguson, in terms of managing ability. I don't think he was the best manager to replace SAF, in terms of continuing his legacy, and is being used as a scapegoat and to further the legacy of SAF by comparison. I am a long time United supporter, and fully support any manager in charge, but I think Moyes was brought in to fail. Change my views
2
u/meiuqer Apr 08 '14
these are the kind of threads you need to sort by "controversial"
2
u/EpoxyD Apr 08 '14
Play offs at the end of a season are a horrible idea.
2
u/MR777 Apr 08 '14
Steven Gerrard is not a top, top player.
2
u/Sheikmat Apr 08 '14
France will win the world cup
8
u/1mdelightful Apr 08 '14
With the exception of keeper you can compare any two players regardless of position. It is simple laziness to say "their completely different players." For example. Arturo Vidal and Dani Alves. Vidal is physical, can score and assist he can be used anywhere in the midfield. Dani Alves is can basically cover a whole side of the pitch by himself. Few other midfielders have shown the ability to score and assist as well as Vidal there are a few Eriksen, Goetze, Iniesta and de Maria come to mind. Unlike the others mentioned he has high defensive work rate. This is why Vidal is superior (to Alves) because it is much more difficult to place such a versatile midfielder than it is to find a RB would will bomb forward - you may not want him to go forward anyway. Vidal compared to Benatia. With Benatia you do not need to cover him as well that means you can create an overload some place on the pitch or simple field more attackers. It is like playing with 11.2 people. This is more valuable than a midfielder who scores.
24
u/HazardIsCute Apr 08 '14
Frank Lampard is the best midfielder in the premier league era. No one has done anything close to what he has from midfield. Ronaldinho in his prime is the only reason Lampard doesn't have a Ballon D'or
3
u/Simon_Riley Apr 08 '14
Based on the goal-line technology decisions in the EPL this season, I think the Hawkeye or similar goal-line tech should be used in all leagues and international football. FIFA should also help with the cost.
3
u/croutonZA Apr 08 '14
Goal line technology, or any other form of technology to help the referees, has no place in football unless the FA or the Premier League pays to have it implemented in all Football League grounds at the very least.
3
u/Colonel_Hapablap Apr 08 '14
Pirlo didn't magically appear in 2012. He had a very successful time at AC Milan for a number of years. I hear way too many people talk about Andrea Pirlo as a late bloomer.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
I think Suarez is the best player in the World at the moment
5
u/Sean88888 Apr 08 '14
Rooney looks like Shrek. Change my view.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
La Liga has better quality teams all around compared to the BPL.
4
u/Redbullsnation Apr 08 '14
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain is Theo Walcott's son. Pacey but overrated and overhyped by the British media. I don't see what's the difference between the two. Just one is younger than the other
6
u/JKohlerFussballgott Apr 08 '14
Ribery should have won the Ballon D'or because he was just outstanding AND won titles with his team.
Even in a team that won the treble (and features only world class players) he managed to stand out
Everytime he played he was on fire, creating chances like there is no tomorrow, backtracking and overall tried everything to help the team
Hit me, change my view
3
u/NFeKPo Apr 08 '14
La Liga will never have a consistent title contender not named Barca and Real until they institute a TV revenue sharing system that resembles the EPL.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
Alex Ferguson is overrated. His fame stems from him not being sacked because Manchester United lack European ambition.
He won the Champion's League twice in 18 attempts. At most clubs, when domestic success does not translate into European success you get fired.
4
u/Thapricorn Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
Obviously heavy bias, but I'll do my best to be open minded and consider counter-arguments.
Steven Gerrard in his prime was the most complete midfielder, in terms of ability in different aspects of the game, in the Premier League era.
Edit: Nobody has replied yet, so I'll stretch it a bit more (even though I myself don't buy it): Gerrard in his prime was the most complete/well-rounded midfielder in the last 30 years.
4
u/CapMurphySeason Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
Pele isn't that great
EDIT:I could have worded this better
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14
Steven Gerrard was the best midfielder in the world from 05 till 09.