r/soccer • • Apr 08 '14

Change My View: r/soccer edition (from r/nfl)

Pretty simple, post an opinion you have on a player, team, coach, whatever and others will try to change your mind.

Try to back up your claims.

EDIT: For the sake of fostering discussion please don't downvote comments. Instead, upvote, reply, and state your argument.

Also, people may want to sort by "controversial".

142 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

247

u/Yarik32 Apr 08 '14

If Pedro played the same number of games,had the same number of assists and goals that Neymar had this year nobody would give a shit .

126

u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14

Pedro has only played 4 less games than Neymar and their goal and assist tallies are similar. I disagree however that ''nobody would give a shit'', there has been quite a lot of hate on Neymar recently.

344

u/Yarik32 Apr 08 '14

Dude look at my username we are like relatives or something

124

u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14

lol that's awesome

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/Internetcoitus Apr 08 '14

The point is, Pedro wouldn't even be getting the shit that Neymar has gotten this year but he wouldn't get positive attention either. Everyone would simply not care.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

49

u/anticancer_agent Apr 08 '14

I don't think Pedro gets enough recognition honestly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/poipoiop Apr 08 '14

I think the Scandinavian league system of playing Jan-Dec ultimately ruins their chances of ever being properly competitive in Europe.

Putting aside the fact that they don't have the same monetary power as Russia, who can afford to buy quality Europe-level players season-in-season-out.

If they were to ever manage to get into Europe, their Group Stage games begin at the end of their season when they're starting to show signs of fatigue and slowing down. They've just played the whole season to be domestically-competitive and then, towards the end, they have to try and compete in Europe against teams who are fresh off a pre-season.

Adding into the mix that countries like Norway and Sweden have extremely high taxes. A Danish club can offer the same wages to a Nor/Swe player and the player could earn more due to Denmark having a lucrative tax-scheme for athlete's, which in turn causes the top-finishing clubs in Nor/Swe every year to sell off their best players and start from scratch.

So if we assume (dream) that a Norwegian/Swedish club can get past the group stage in the EL/UCL, the next Knockout Round would be in February, which means that the Nor/Swe clubs would need to compete with a whole different team to the one who progressed in the first place.

Lose/Lose.

TL/DR; Taxes and winter is ruining Norwegian and Swedish football.

19

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

I agree and I can't change your view. But you have to understand that it's 100% impossible to play football during the winter here. Even in Mars most pitches would be unplayable. Especially considering the fact that most clubs here don't even have close the money necessery to keep the grass relatively good under bad conditions.

45

u/woonderbear Apr 08 '14

Yeah, I hear the Martian Winter can be pretty brutal.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/trophy_hunter Apr 08 '14

To be fair there's an advantage during the qualifications for EL/UCL because at the time Scandinavian teams are are in the middle of the season but other teams have just started theirs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

208

u/cypher-raige Apr 08 '14

Americans need to stop comparing European football with the NFL, MLB etc.

It's a lot more like the NCAA. Historic teams rooted in local communities, rivalries that go back hundreds of years and teams of all different sizes.

47

u/ncocca Apr 08 '14

Even the atmospheres are similar. I went to a HUGE ncaa football game, I saw Penn State play Michigan at Beaver Stadium. Full crowd of ~100,000 people. You have your supporter section where all the college kids are drunk and going crazy with body paint and the likes. This is what I imagine professional football games are like in Europe and South America, at least that's what I see on TV.

This is a stark contrast to professional sports in the US, which are much more sterile. Much more a family environment, where everyone is almost always sitting down and there's no specific section dedicated to an opposing team's fans.

52

u/TheYetiCaptain1993 Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Much more a family environment

This is a point that is often overlooked when discussing American pro sports and the stadium atmospheres. American culture has this really obnoxious habit of placing a huge emphasis on family values and family friendliness. It's why network TV and terrestrial radio, pro sports venues, and really anything that has to do with mainstream culture feels so sterilized.

Sidebar: People wonder why Americans act like children well into their 20s, and honestly it is because we treat them like children for such a long part of their lives. I don't want to turn this into an anti-USA circlejerk, I love this country, but if there is one thing I would change it would be that.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

15

u/Hcapade Apr 08 '14

This is best comparison I have ever seen, and I am so glad to have it well put as you did. Thank you!

I will be using your statement to anyone who does not understand the allure of European football.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

63

u/the_crooner Apr 08 '14

Balotelli is a great striker and he's going to show it in Brazil.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

I completely agree and believe his main flaws are his temperament and selfishness. If he is able to turn it into a more team attitude, he can be great.

3

u/river49 Apr 09 '14

A better word to use is brilliant. He is as good a player as any and shows what he is capable of at times. He already showed it against Germany in Euro 2012 and this summer, but to be truly great you have to lead your team. Time after time he has hurt his team by getting disciplined or caused tension with others in the club. A great striker would be somebody like Lewandowski, who is both brilliant and clutch (think his 4 goals against RM last year).

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

He could be even better if he tried his hardest every game. He seems quite lazy now.

2

u/swamp_th1ng Apr 08 '14

that's exactly the point, aside from the occasional game he only really puts 100% in the big games - I still think he will become something of a fantastic striker but the problem is he doesn't have the effort in some essential games. He can score two in a Manchester derby but do nothing in a home game against Birmingham city. Same for scoring two again Germany but do nothing against Livorno.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/buckweed_the_African Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Selling RvP in the summer would be the daftest thing Moyes could do. Just because Mata, Kagawa and Rooney have played very well together towards the end of the season doesnt mean you go and sell your best striker. That just limits your options and style of play.

edit: removed the ever part.

21

u/mcfrattington Apr 08 '14

Here's a few reasons I wouldn't be against the idea:

  1. He's nearing the end of his prime. He's 30 and historically injury prone. He can't get much better but can get a lot worse.
  2. Danny Welbeck is finally coming into his own. Given both players form in 2014 (without injury) I'd rather Welbeck start over RVP.
  3. Chicharito. My favorite player and doesn't get enough time to get any consistent form. Although I believe he'll leave this summer, he's a great sub that has had time limited because of RVP.

Of course I can also think of millions of reasons why I'd keep RVP too. At 30 it's a bit like rolling the dice. He could drop off completely next season or play at a top level for the next three years. All in all, I'd keep him unless we bring in another high profile striker like Lukaku.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Danny Welbeck is finally coming into his own. Given both players form in 2014 (without injury) I'd rather Welbeck start over RVP.

Not to mention we could possibly promote James Wilson or Angelo Henriquez to take Welbeck's current 3rd/4th choice striker slot, which would be good.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/SteelKeeper Apr 08 '14

Best striker ever? Seriously?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

your best striker ever.

Wow, you really think that?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/tikky30 Apr 08 '14

He will be turning 31 at the start of next season. Seeing as he's an injury prone player, selling might be the best option. Then you bring on a new striker that has the luxury of playing more minutes and you hope that you made a good purchase.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

29

u/TheTrotters Apr 08 '14

Most of football writing and discussion (whether in The Guardian or any other newspaper or on forums like this one) is just the male-equivalent of celebrity gossips. "Who will be fired next?"; "Will X step up?"; "He doesn't want it hard enough!"; "He's selfish/lazy"; endless memes.

There's very little discussion about actual football and very little trying to understand the game better.

16

u/swamp_th1ng Apr 08 '14

It is impossible to change your view as it is fact.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/royalewithcheese94 Apr 08 '14

Eden Hazard is overrated, not the second best player in the league like so many people seem to think. I would put him on a par with Theo Walcott.

3

u/gypsybear Apr 08 '14

Who do you think is the second best? Who would you say are the top 5 players in the Premier League?

→ More replies (4)

47

u/Ritzen Apr 08 '14

Hazard blows hot and cold quite often and for a player of his ability he is surprisingly easy to mark out of a game when facing an organised team but comparing him to Walcott is a bit extreme. Not to say Walcott is bad but I think Hazard is more talented, he just needs to show some consistency.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/salfordred Apr 08 '14

Good god. Walcott is the best example of a player's quality getting inflated when he's injured.

Hazard is a much better player than Walcott.

25

u/AfricanRain Apr 08 '14

Walcott had the most goals as a winger last year. I don't think his quality getting inflated, I'd say he's earned it.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/HazardIsCute Apr 08 '14

Carries Chelsea on his back going forward. Easily the best winger in the EPL but behind Suarez, Y Toure and some others in overall quality right now. Potential to be one of the top 10 players in the world.

→ More replies (8)

28

u/poipoiop Apr 08 '14

I like how a Change My View thread generates more discussion that a Controversial Opinion thread.

I'm noticing they're essentially the same thing. Just worded differently.

9

u/drinktusker Apr 08 '14

One invites discussion, the other invites controversy. In the context of Change my view we are being encouraged to engage and persuade people who we disagree with to out views. In a controversial opinion thread we are being encouraged to overstate unpopular claims and defend them as though they were statements of fact.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/Sean88888 Apr 08 '14

Arturo Vidal is the best box-to-box midfielder in the world

7

u/AlGamaty Apr 08 '14

I agree. The only other player with a shout would be Yaya imo.

2

u/Definetly_not_batman Apr 09 '14

Yaya's not far behind but i'd agree with you on that one, doubt many people would dispute that

→ More replies (7)

55

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

I would rather Newcastle get relegated and be sold than continue to 'be financially stable' with Mike Ashley

70

u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14

So we can welcome the Newcastle Cougars to the EPL for the 2015/'16 season?

If you go for the Newcastle Pandas you can even keep your black/white kit.

14

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

i don't even mean 'bought by a wealthy arab/russian/whatever'. Nor do I mean return to the prem necessarily, just want an owner who cares about the club

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

236

u/MrSqueegee95 Apr 08 '14 edited Feb 25 '15

Raheem Sterling is better than Januzaj and has more potential.

EDIT: Thought so.

154

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Sterling suffers from the fact he's English, black, and small which means he gets written off as a Shaun Wright-Phillips type player. Kind of like how any French, black, big midfielder is likened to Patrick Vieira.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

SWP was a hell of a player in his own right

→ More replies (19)

59

u/Ritzen Apr 08 '14

Too early to say who has more potential but I think saying Sterling is better is a pretty fair comment.

29

u/thierry90 Apr 08 '14

I'm honestly surprised that so many people have got such comprehensive views on the ability and potential levels of two 19 year olds, particularly Januzaj who has played less than 30 games for United. I've got no qualms with Liverpool fans claiming Sterling is better at the moment or that he's had a season or whatever, but half the comments i'm seeing on them are just random statements that can't be proved/disproved.

→ More replies (4)

87

u/platoiscool Apr 08 '14

Different players.

Sterling is a hard working player who makes a lot of intelligent runs in order to score/cross or create space for the best strike pairing in the world right now in Suárez/Sturridge. Januzaj, on the other hand, is a player who prefers the ball played to feet so he can commit defenders out of position as well as link up with other creative players like Rooney/Mata/van Persie.

I personally believe that if their roles were reversed i.e. Sterling @ United and Januzaj @ Liverpool, Januzaj would continue to flourish whereas Sterling would be perceived as average. In other words, Sterling is benefitting more from the players around him and the fluid system Liverpool play, whereas Januzaj possesses more technical ability making him shine during a poor United season.

Overall, I think it's hard to compare their different styles, but if we're going to judge on individual talent alone and not their team's overall success, I believe Januzaj is the better player.

14

u/ChristheGreek Apr 08 '14

Rodgers has been playing Sterling in the #10 role more recently and he has adapted quite well. I didn't think he had the passing skills or awareness around him to excel as a #10, but he proved me wrong. You are underrating his passing ability and vision, and he's quite good at making space for himself when he has the ball.

14

u/leytonstoneb Apr 08 '14

you can also argue that becuase Januzaj is playing in a UTD squad that isn't playing to their usual standard and that's why he's standing out more.

52

u/Ritzen Apr 08 '14

That's what makes Sterling so good in my view, he can play that traditional run down the wing style or he can play passes to feet and split defences. He's actually quite creative and his passing is very good, it's why he's been playing in the middle as of late.

→ More replies (3)

43

u/postdaemon Apr 08 '14

You are doing Sterling a great disservice here. He is very good at getting past his man. He is also faster than Januzaj and ten times better defensively. Sterling is the better player at the moment, but Januzaj has the potential to be better.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Ten matches ago I'd have agreed with you. But they're actually incredibly similar when Sterling plays more centrally. He picks the ball up with his head up and makes such good decisions it's hard to believe he's 19. For him to basically usurp Coutinho in the 10 role in a Brendan Rodgers team tells you know what you need to know.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/donttaxmyfatstacks Apr 09 '14

Sterling has already had a full season in the PL and is excelling in his second season in a side that is playing great football. Januzaj is in his debut season, playing for a side that is struggling for cohesion, and has made a bigger impact than Sterling did in his first season. Sterling has formed a great partnership with Suarez and Sturridge, Januzaj has had to be a one-man team at times. Reverse the roles and I think Sterling stuggles, Januzaj flourishes

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

There was a period of the game this last weekend that Sterling switched to playing centrally, and looked very good. I was really impressed, he fed a nice through ball to someone on a counter attack.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (27)

48

u/ining Apr 08 '14

Thiago Silva is not the best Centreback in the world. A defender like Benatia who is able to turn up every week and play at a high standard is worth far more to a team than a player who on his day is incredible.

Similar reason for why Barzagli is more invaluable than Chiellini for Juventus.

7

u/CalcioMilan Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

I think that's unfair considering Roma have no European competitions, playing in Europe is such a toll physically and mentally. But because of that I feel "best" or "GOAT" is a silly thing in sports because of all the different factors.

4

u/AlGamaty Apr 08 '14

I agree on the Benatia statement. This guy has arguably been the best centre back in Europe this season.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '14

Can you really judge centerback on only one season? T. Silva has been top defender for years. In 11/12 he had exactly as good season as Benatia is having now. He organized our whole defense and was fixing mistakes made by his partners, without making any on his own.

Benatia is really really great and I think he can be better than Thiago, but CB is the position that requires stability. I think it will be fair to compare those two after another season, just like it will be fair to compare Suarez to Ronaldo after one or more seasons.

→ More replies (5)

176

u/Natniss Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Jack wilshere is overrated and should not be considered a starter for England.

Edit: I think fans and journalists have hyped him up even more than they usually do for any English player that can tie his own laces. I don't see him as one of englands best players or most important players as some journos have said. I think his last performances for England were very poor and there are plenty of other options. I also find he is very prone to losing the ball in the middle, and sitting down on his arse slapping the floor like a child waiting for a freekick as play goes on and he is nowhere to help.

128

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Why must people insist on writing off young players off so early?

Jack Wilshere only turned 22 in January and has had an injury hit career so far. He's clearly very talented. You support Liverpool and need only look at the case of Jordan Henderson to see the foolishness of writing off a young, talented player so early. Henderson's 18 months older and yet less than 12 months ago few would believe he'd be going to the world cup, yet alone as a likely starter.

38

u/Natniss Apr 08 '14

I'm not writing him off, I just don't think he should be a "first on the team sheet" for England type of player. I think he has potential to be that but not now. And England should be about now, especially at a world cup.

33

u/Sulphur32 Apr 08 '14

He isn't one of the first names on the team sheet. The reality is, however, if Hodgson does want to play in a certain type of way Jack is one of a rather limited number of options for England at the moment.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/postdaemon Apr 08 '14

You must not have watched his games against Brazil.

48

u/suchaslowroll Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Or against Bayern last year, or lots of games this season..

It really is bizarre, it's like people stopped watching Wilshere, then assumed because they haven't been watching him that he's been shit..

He's a phenomenal talent who's been at the heart of Arsenal's great results at the beginning of the season. He's also only 22 years old and had 17 months out with injury..

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

57

u/Ritzen Apr 08 '14

I know he's seen as a bit of a joke on here but I actually think Demichelis has been fantastic for Man City. A few high profile mistakes/bad games are tarnishing what has been a very good season for him.

45

u/badguysenator Apr 08 '14

I don't think he's been fantastic by any means, but there's been some speculation as to what's going on with his bad form and it's all to do with being the leader.

Gary Cahill is a good example. Great alongside Terry at Chelsea. Great alongside Jagielka for England. Terry and Jagielka are leaders; barking orders and taking charge. Cahill likes to be told what to do on the pitch. He's much shakier and error prone when alongside Luiz or Smalling.

It's been suggested Demichelis is a leader. He gets confused by Kompany running the show as their defensive instincts don't match up. When Kompany's not around, he basically plays how he wants and has looked far better.

14

u/Ritzen Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Bad form? He's been playing very well lately. He had a bit of a rough patch for like 3/4 games in a row a while back but he's been solid for the majority of the season.

I agree with all that and it makes sense, I've always said he looks better without Kompany. When he paired up with Garcia against (Hull?), that was the best City defensive performance I have seen all season. It was incredible, entire defence was organised, not one person made a single mistake.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/devineman Apr 08 '14

This is true. You don't get gifs of his last minute goal saving challenges on /r/soccer but do for his tackle against Messi.

It's a very good example of how players can be defined by one or two incidents in the mind of many. Zidane actually is helped by this as are other players. The biggest ever beneficiary in my book was Solskjaer; a pretty run of the mill player who had good runs of form now and again but was propelled by his CL Final goal. He didn't score anywhere near what people think he did off the bench but they all remember that goal and the time he scored 4.

I think people like Titus Bramble - a very good defender over his career who made one or two high profile mistakes have been hurt by this. Gareth Barry is remembered for being outpaced by Ozil but not for being the lynchpin of City's title winning team who played almost every game. Baggio is remembered as a guy who missed a penalty rather than possibly the greatest forward that Italy has ever produced.

It's just the way that the football media works and in particularly how it shapes perceptions of almost all fans. This is a very interesting topic that I'd like to discuss with somebody who has really looked into it but I tend to think that most opinions in football; of fans, pundits and even some coaches are a result of confirmation bias after hearing the opinion of somebody else and the stereotypes that they have learnt throughout their lives. The football media acts sort of as an echo chamber within itself and it seeps into the fans

I think that if we "deleted" our football opinions and stereotypes and all started from scratch we would come to hold very different opinions from what we did before. It's a process which you go through as part of coaching education to a degree. There's a brief moment where you wake up and realise to yourself that all of those tenets which you hung your hat on were just wrong and you don't actually know anywhere near what you think you did.

This is a process that I'd very much like every fan in the world to do as once you dismiss everything you think you know or the opinions that you parrot of others, you begin to see errors that you made.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/forbacher Apr 08 '14

It has always been like this with him.

On a good day he can stop anybody, Suarez, Ibra, van Persie, you name it.

On a bad day he singlehandedly can give the game to Freiburg by doing stupid shit.

When he had the most success at Bayern and was for 2 seasons a starter ('07-'09) he managed to have constant good days with just one or two bad days the whole season. This ratio went downhill until he left.

→ More replies (5)

98

u/Bob_Swarleymann Apr 08 '14

On an unrelated note to the topic, it kind of destroys this post when people downvote every comment they don't agree with. Try to actually change his view, instead of simply down voting.

60

u/ibpants Apr 08 '14

Maybe they think enough downvotes will change their view?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

48

u/themanguydude Apr 08 '14

Ribery should be voted the sexiest man alive in 2013

26

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Not an opinion I ever want you to change.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

72

u/chickenMcNugs Apr 08 '14

Luis Suarez is the best striker in the world at the moment.

19

u/rick_rolled_you Apr 09 '14

Good discussion guys! Everyone can go home.

→ More replies (29)

85

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

r/soccer is a boring BPL and CL circlejerk

21

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Mar 14 '24

vase provide lip rob capable aware uppity deer quarrelsome materialistic

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

28

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

It's not the big leagues, it's only the BPL. The vast majority of posts here are related to the BPL and English clubs. Every statistic about the BPL will be upvoted no matter how stupid or useless it is. I like the BPL very much and I follow it closely, but I do think this subreddit needs more variety.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (21)

76

u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14

I think that you shouldn't hate on a player because he dives. It's no worse than a player making a foul to prevent a counterattack. However, For the first many say that the player is a disgrace and for the second ''it's part of the game.'' Makes no sense to me.

262

u/TheyDidItFirst Apr 08 '14

Professional fouls designed to prevent a counterattack are done with full knowledge that they will be punished - the defender isn't hiding anything, he's making a calculated decision to take the punishment (often a yellow or even red card) in order to help his team. Diving, on the other hand, is an underhanded act with the sole intention of being undeservedly rewarded, with no accompanying punishment (and often with the intent of inflicting punishment on a fellow professional). I can understand why players do it, but it's dirty and unpleasant and I don't like it.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/SecularMantis Apr 08 '14

I think for many (and for me, at least) the difference is that diving is disingenuous, trying to create a foul out of nothing, while fouling to prevent a counterattack is overt and aims to use the rules of the game to gain an advantage. Simply put, diving seeks to exploit weaknesses in the enforcement of rules (imperfect refs). It's "lying". Fouling for an advantage isn't lying; it might be cynical, but it's open (no attempt to fool the ref) and has a clear cost and a clear benefit that are outlined in the rulebook.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/RainbowBarfingToastr Apr 08 '14

hence the term "forcing the foul".

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

If a player makes a foul they take a punishment set out by the rules, diving is specifically trying to gain an advantage whilst avoiding being punished. Secondly a dive will likely lead to the opponent being punished for something they didn't do, so not only is the diver gaining an advantage through the dive they're also leading to their opponent being directly punished a lot of the time. Thirdly diving tends to be a lot more obviously game changing, someone diving to get a penalty or get someone sent off is going to unfairly change the game more obviously than stopping a counter attack.

This sub is fairly weird in its love of diving though.

2

u/Rainen Apr 08 '14

I think it greatly depends on the manner of the dive. If it is simply "oh I can't control the ball / I have made a mistake, let me dive to see if I can get lucky and fool the ref", then it seems motivated by a desire to win at all costs, which is somewhat unseemly.

Diving should be permitted if it is truly making the most of something that does exist in an attempt to highlight it - and leaving the rest up to the ref. I feel like anyone can bring cases to mind which are somewhat hilarious and also embarrassing, and other cases where perhaps an added flop sold the foul.

It is a fine line, but to simply give a full-on pass to all divers seems a bit much, as there are some serious actors out there.

One of many videos out there.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

I like to refer people to this video I saw a while ago on here. Its Gary* Neville talking about how the game has changed so much that if no one were to dive anymore, less fouls would be called until an evolution of the game happens again. I believe this too an extent. I feel that football has made the transition to little dives being more accepted and that has changed how fouls are given in the refs mind.

here is the video

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

34

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Pep Guardiola strives on an already built core and a huge hefty bank roll. He wouldn't have the reputation he has if Barcelona and Munich didn't have such prestige.

37

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Yeah, I guess you could say he hasn't proved himself as a great manager (encompassing the arguably outdated role of doing pretty much everything (like in Football Manager). However, when you watch a Guardiola team, you can say to yourself "fuck me, these lot are extremely well coached". The way they have a system, with every player knowing their role, and every player being utilized to the absolute maximum of their ability is a sight to behold. It's the same with watching Liverpool this season. You can watch them for just a minute and tell they are extremely well coached.

I don't know what he does at the training ground, but after watching his teams for 6 years, in my opinion Guardiola is the best coach I have seen for a long time.

→ More replies (2)

75

u/StpMpls Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

MLS has as much to teach the rest of the world as the rest of the world has to teach it.

Few leagues anywhere in the world have faced as much apathy as MLS has experienced. Most leagues take their position for granted. But the way that MLS has experienced success by emphasizing parity and the fan experience should be learned by leagues globally.

The fact that the league is not dominated by one super team and the use of a playoff system keep fans of all teams excited and engaged every year, throughout the season.

The fact that the league is relatively free of fan violence and racism is a huge benefit that helps attract players and casual fans.

118

u/littleboylover123 Apr 08 '14

the use of a playoff system keep fans of all teams excited and engaged every year, throughout the season.

i can say that this actually has the opposite effect as after about 2/3 of the way through the season most teams have no chance of making the playoffs and no threat of relegation and therefore just kind of mess around until the next season

what the mls needs is a relegation system (even if it is just two tiers) to keep the pace throughout the season -- look at leagues now (at this point in the season) were some of the most intense games are between relegation candidates!

25

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

It goes both ways though. In MLS the last 5-6 games of the season you have teams positioned 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th in their conference fighting for the last couple playoff spots. And also the top teams are fighting to get better seeding for home-field advantage. More than half the teams in MLS get into the playoffs (10 of 19), so it takes a while for most teams to get fully eliminated from contention, unless the team is god awful.

Take for example this year in the EPL. Newcastle stopped caring a few weeks back because they don't want to win (they want to avoid Europa league) and they're all but safe from relegation. The same thing with Stoke this past weekend, they didn't really show up because they are basically safe now. At the end of the season in the EPL usually teams positioned 6-15 have no reason to play. It's a parallel to what you see of teams positioned at the bottom of the table in MLS, or even the NBA, NFL, MLB, NHL.

So in MLS you have teams in the middle of the pack fighting for the playoffs and the bottom teams slacking off. In the EPL or other European leagues you have teams in the middle slacking off and teams at the bottom fighting it out.

Relegation isn't the answer for MLS right now, for the reasons /u/smokey815 has stated.

→ More replies (3)

49

u/smokey815 Apr 08 '14

MLS does not need a relegation system. Not right now, at least. It would not be good for the league.

32

u/kingaardvark Apr 08 '14

Why? Legitamite question

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/soccerfreak2332 Apr 08 '14

Have you watched the mls? Last year the only teams out off playoff contention with a few weeks to go were tfc, DC unites and chivas USA.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

37

u/envirosani Apr 08 '14

I don't know what you want to hear. The MLS does the right things, for the position they are in. The US has a tradition in the style their sports are played out. You got playoffs, drafts and so on. This is not the case in Europe. They are just two different styled to run something. Each style has advantages and disadvantages. I like that European leagues don't have a salary cap, that teams can't be sure of their position in a certain league because they can get demoted and of course that the clubs have tradition.

I played in the same club as my father and my grandfather. When my Grandfather played in the youth the team were champions of west Germany. So even teams in the lower leagues still can have glorious pasts.

Fan violence for sure is a topic, but not as big as you make it seam. Tickets are cheap and rivalries are serious. Add to that beer that doesn't cost 15 $ per glas and you sometimes get a few fights here and there. It may be a bigger problem in leagues which are more in the east of Europe, I can't comment on that.

The fact that one team doesn't dominate in the MLS is only contributed to the financial restrictions teams have and their not so long history. Borussia Mönchengladbach dominated the german league when no one thought about the MLS. Just as an example. The combination of the two make it hard for any team in the MLS to dominate and I personally don't think that that is a good thing.

I can't comment on fan violence and racism in the US, but I guess you got incidents all over the world.

And sure most leagues in Europe take their position for granted, the same does the NFL in the US. When you are the biggest sport of a nation, why should you fear for your position?

I don't want to downplay what the MLS has achieved, but I don't think other leagues can learn much and that's just because the mentalities are so different.

30

u/Yurilovescats Apr 08 '14

the way that MLS has experienced success by emphasizing parity

No league in the world would ever dream of initiating this, and why would they? I like my politics socialist and my sports Darwinian, Americans like their politics to be Darwinian and their sports Socialist... weird.

→ More replies (8)

23

u/Nokel Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

The Japanese League has relatively no fan violence, virtually no racism, and Imo has set itself up for long term success better than mls. While MLS has no relegation and keeps adding teams to the mix (which I think is watering down the strength of the individual teams), Japan has a healthy 3 - tier professional League system that insures that teams fight throughout the season to remain above the relegation line, fight for promotion in the lower leagues, and feel an overall need to get better due to how unpredictable the league is (yes, parity exists in leagues outside the mls too).

While I am proud of what the mls has accomplished, the way the league is doing things is by no means the best nor the only way to run a league.

Personally I like the system in Japan better than the current system we have here in America. It allows the most talented teams to inhabit the league, it insures that every team has an awesome youth setup and stable finances before entering the league, and it's plain to see that teams are getting stronger and stronger as a whole each year.

Japan went from not being nobodies in world soccer for decades before the j. League came around until they finally reached their first world cup in 1998. The future looks bright for Japanese soccer but due to the constant expansion of the mls I have a hard time believing that the quality of the league won't stagnate at some point.

Each League is relatively the same age, so I guess we will where they both end up a decade from now.

Tl;dr: just because the mls is finding success doesn't mean the way it's doing things is the best way

I wrote this on my phone so sorry if there are any mistakes.

→ More replies (15)

10

u/Zelrak Apr 08 '14

The fact that there is so much parity means that every team is gunning for the top every year. (Well ok, maybe not every year since there are development cycles, etc, but every team hopes to win in the next few years.) Whereas the league systems in Europe tend to be much more stable, with more to play for, so you can be fighting for a champions league spot, fighting to stay away from relegation, fighting to hold on to your mid-table spot so that relegation isn't a worry, fighting for Europa league, fighting for separate cup competitions. In the MLS, the only thing that matters is the winning the whole thing, if you can't do that you basically have nothing to play for.

And the playoffs, rather than keeping people engaged all year, mean that the only part of the season that actually matters is the playoffs. Admittedly, this is good for grabbing the casual fan's attention for at least a little while, but it makes the position in the league less important.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Except that MLS is also fighting for champions league spots, with the US Open Cup scheduling to worry about.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/myrpou Apr 08 '14

Well I think all leagues have a lot to teach each other, all national football federations have unique ways of running their leagues, not one is perfect and they all have different values and philosophies.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/Samperalejo Apr 08 '14

Messi>Ronaldo

Not only in paper (all the records he has broken) but as a team player Messi is much better than Ronaldo. However, I admire Ronaldo's attitude and athleticism. He is the definition of a modern day athlete.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '14

The way I see it, Messi is Superman. Born with his abilities that no mere mortal could replicate.

Ronaldo is batman. A human being chiseled to the epitome of what a human being can be.

2

u/Des_Eagle Apr 09 '14

While it is anyone's right to believe any player is the best in the world, I think it would be very, very difficult to provide any sort of objective evidence to Change Your View. Numbers can be cherry picked for Ronny but a comprehensive look can only lead to the conclusion you've already come to.

Subjective reasoning would only lead more in Messi's favor. What he regularly does on a pitch is not remotely like what anyone else on Earth is doing.

It's like comparing Jordan to Lebron for me. Lebron plays the game with a power, pace, and intensity that sets him on another level from current competition, aided significantly by his physical presence. He dominates by overpowering other players and just forcing the ball through the lines and into the hoop. Not unlike Ronny. Success at any cost. Impeccable work ethic, studying, training, and dedication.

But Jordan was always just playing a different game. That's what it feels like to me to watch Messi play. The two of them, in their respective sports, basically operate on another level.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/TheDreaminArmenian Apr 08 '14

This is a breeding ground for reddit arguments. I like it ;)

→ More replies (2)

11

u/captainbergs Apr 08 '14

These thread never achieve anything. Opinions and rebuttal are downvoted, people spout bias and ridiculous opinions which they clearly have zero intention of changing. Some popular sentiment will reach the top.

How many people do you see saying "Jack Wilshere is world class take him to the world cup right away"? compared to "DAE THINK JACK WILSHERE IS OVERATED?!?!?!".

63

u/Bob_Swarleymann Apr 08 '14

The Spanish league is by far the best league in the world. The wealth of talent both born in Spain and emigrated from South America is unrivaled. Take a look at Man City; most of their stars are players from outside the top two La Liga teams who are supposedly shit. Take a look at UCL/Euro League. The Premier League has money and marketing, whereas La Liga has talent and incompetent leadership.

98

u/StonedCrow Apr 08 '14

Best is a pretty broad term. You seem to be restricting the term to player talent (other notions of "best" might be the competitiveness of the league - in which case the Prem would certainly be better than La Liga - or fan base, league revenue - again prem - or a number of other criteria).

So what you are arguing is that La Liga has the most talented players in the world. In the case of Barca and Real this is pretty hard to contest.

look at Man City; most of their stars are players from outside the top two La Liga teams who are supposedly shit.

This point has another side to it. La Liga does produce and import some very talented players but the best are skimmed off by "larger" (read: richer) clubs like Real and Barca within Spain and the biggest clubs through out Europe (like City). So yes Spain may be talented but the league suffers because teams have to sell (in no small part due to the poor revenue sharing system which favours Barca and Real so heavily)

The wealth of talent both born in Spain and emigrated from South America is unrivaled

If this refers to players who emigrate while already professionals then surely the Prem can make a similar boast - the wealth of talen born in England and emigrated from Europe is unrivaled. Spain has a much easier time recruiting South americans due to lax visa regulations but England imports the best players from all over Europe and the world.

Take a look at UCL/Euro League

I'm looking at it. Since 1999 three English teams, Man U, Chelsea and Liverpool have all won - with United winning twice - and Arsenal finished runners up once. Barca and Real are the only Spanish teams to win ever. Over all two teams have won from spain in 60 years while 5 from britain have (adding Villa and Forest to the previous list).

English teams perform poorly in the Euro league for a number of reasons. First, the huge revenue of the Prem usually means that domestic league position is more valuable than Euro league success. Second, because the FA and League cup's result in euro league spots you get teams like Birmingham and Wigan competing against Champions league drop outs. The English league also has more fixtures, closer together than some European leagues (including la liga) which results in greater player fatigue. This combined with the more physical nature of the English games means greater numbers of injured and tired players.

The Premier League has money and marketing, whereas La Liga has talent and incompetent leadership.

La Liga doesn't have incompetent leadership. Its leadership is doing a great job of diverting as much revenue to Real and Barca as possible. The Spanish league could be much greater than what it is but not until revenue is split in a manner more similar to the Prem. Until that happens Spain may continue to produce talented players but they will be sucked up by richer teams like Barca and Real and by the biggest Prem teams.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/Lisbian Apr 08 '14

The wealth of talent both born in Spain and emigrated from South America is unrivaled.

They have far less stringent work permit rules for South American players than other top European leagues. It all goes in cycles. Serie A was the best from the mid 90's-mid 2000's. Then the Premier League from the mid 2000's-late 2000's. Now it's La Liga's turn.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/nowitasshole Apr 08 '14

If the leagues were movies La Liga would clean up at the oscars and the Premiership would be a box office hit. La Liga would be 12 years a slave and the Premiership would be Iron Man 3.

Now ask yourself which is better; 12 years a slave or Iron Man 3 without setting a criteria of what constitutes "better". At the end of the day you can only pick which you enjoy more because it's subjective.

45

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

a bit of a top heavy league imo, the top teams are some of the mid-table/ lower teams are arguably worse than the BPL.

19

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

I think that the difference is that Real Madrid and Barcelona are vastly superior to most teams in Europe. They would dominate Premier League if they played there too.

→ More replies (5)

60

u/anticancer_agent Apr 08 '14

Bilbao beat United home and away in 2012, Valencia, Sevilla, and Atletico have all won the Europa league in the last 10 years. The talent outside the top two is still quite good.

→ More replies (14)

7

u/Bob_Swarleymann Apr 08 '14

Yeah the money makes a huge difference there.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

While I want to agree with you, it's hard to see La Liga continue to compete as a whole with the EPL in the coming years. While La Liga has wisened up to collective bargaining for their TV rights, the EPL recently signed a deal which will make it the 3rd highest grossing league in the world (behind the NFL and MLB). If I recall correctly we're talking in the coming years of the EPL bringing in over $6B in revenue a year (total, including all forms of revenue) compared to La Liga bringing in just under $2B. That revenue gap will be hard to close, and it's coming soon. Talent development and tactical innovation is miles better in the continent, but what good does that do if even midtable EPL clubs will soon be able to pay much better than most of La Liga, Serie A and the Bundesliga?

23

u/william701 Apr 08 '14

The way I see it:

Average la Liga team is slighty better than average Premier League team but the difference between the top teams and the bottom teams in the Premier League is less than that in la Liga (making it seem more competitive and hence 'better'). It's of course all subjective to what you are looking for in football.

11

u/Bob_Swarleymann Apr 08 '14

I agree with that. However, I feel like that is down to the fact that Madrid and Barcelona have only become stronger in recent years whereas most elite clubs in England has seen their fortune come and go.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Rainen Apr 08 '14

Okay, I'll have a go.

The Spanish league probably has the finest farm system in the world. I'm not sure anyone can really argue with that, considering the talent that comes through their system, especially if you go down to players that transfer out when they are 16 to 18.

However, from top to bottom, the English Premier league is by far and away a league of greater quality. The regularity with which teams at the bottom compete with teams at the top is unrivaled in the world, and the parity, at least from a team perspective, is greater there than anywhere else. This makes the league both more competitive and more fun to watch. A team like Swansea, a bottom half team in England, can make a run in the Europa league. Simply having Real, Barcelona, and Atletico don't make the whole league that great, just as having Bayern Munich doesn't make the German league the best.

The style in England is arguably a more difficult style to play, as there are many players who do 'make it' in Spain who do not 'make it' in England. It is faster paced and can involve a much more physical approach than in the Spanish league, coupled with the tactical and spacial awareness necessary at the highest level in both leagues.

Interesting blog here. Article 1 Article 2 Article 3 Article 4

14

u/firechaox Apr 08 '14

Ok- as mentioned by another guy earlier, if your just basing the league by parity, the brazilian league is definitely better- there, any team can claim they have a shot of winning the league at the beginning of the year. None of the teams are slouches really. But that's not what makes a league better is it? The spanish league seems to have better teams than the english league imo- it's just that the disparity between the top and bottom in spanish league is greater then in the EPL, which makes the spanish league look weak. But when you look at international competitions, you see spanish teams playing much better then english teams.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

11

u/devineman Apr 08 '14

most of their stars are players from outside the top two La Liga teams who are supposedly shit

Hart, Pantimilion, Clichy, Kolarov, Kompany, Lescott, Nastasic, Richards, Yaya, Fernandinho, Garcia, Rodwell, Nasri, Jovetic, Dzeko

vs

Demichelis, Zabaleta, Navas, Silva, Negredo, Aguero

I think this is the classic case of seeing a disconnected list and assuming a trend. And I'm arguing with Zab as he's 10 times the player he was in Spain

→ More replies (3)

7

u/salfordred Apr 08 '14

It's the best league but not 'by far the best league'.

6

u/SecularMantis Apr 08 '14

The Spanish league is by far the best league in the world. The wealth of talent both born in Spain and emigrated from South America is unrivaled. Take a look at Man City; most of their stars are players from outside the top two La Liga teams who are supposedly shit.

Well, you started out talking about the Spanish league, but then moved on to talking about how those star players left for the premiereship. Do you mean that the Spanish league produces the best talent, or that the talent currently in the league is the best in the world?

→ More replies (17)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

I reckon that English being the global business language, most people's 1st or 2nd language and usually the coaches universal language is the main reason why the Premier League is the most marketable and therefore has the most money in it.

2

u/Nungie Apr 08 '14

I think this opinion of Liga being shit stems from the massive points gap and very often two-horse race scenario that goes on at the top while the prem has top sides like Chelsea,City,Liverpool,Arsenal and your lower sides like United,Everton and Spurs who can all drift in and out of CL and Europa League spots very quickly.

In terms of actual players a Liga XI vs BPL XI would be in favour of Liga so if you meant as in people think the teams/players are shit then I don't know where people get these opinions

→ More replies (20)

23

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

A neutral hating Young and calling him a cunt while loving Suarez and Sturridge is extremely hypocritical.

And Gerrard's current(!) ability is overrated. He's still great offensively but when he plays as a holding midfielder he leaves way too much space between himself and the back line which has been a large factor why Liverpools' defence has been suspect at times and why they have let in more goals than anyone in the top 7 except Spurs. I find it laughable that so many are putting him in their team of the year.

23

u/tigerpk Apr 08 '14

So you're saying Gerrard is not.... a top, top player?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/YouSeemSuspicious Apr 08 '14

Liverpool's defending was just as bad when the holding midfielder wasn't Gerrard.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Simon_Riley Apr 08 '14

in the last 4-5 games Gerrard has been immense, offensively and defensively. Now if Kolo wanna fuck shit up and give goals away, nobody can stop that, but Gerrard's holding performance has gotten much better.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

So you're saying there aren't united fans that have ever liked Young, but hated Suarez?

Sturridge has had one incident this year of going down easy though. This "reputation" he's getting isn't validated yet.

Edit: Mistakes were made

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

The current way of choosing the best player in the world (especially the Ballon d'Or) is flawed.

4

u/SweetMojaveRain Apr 09 '14

captains, coaches and journalists voting?

who should vote then

→ More replies (2)

2

u/f_mene Apr 09 '14

Awarding one single player heavily based on that player's team's performance is a questionable thing in a purely team-based game like football. The fact that it's a title awarded based on democratic vote instead of athletic competition just shows that the game of football itself doesn't work as a measure of an individual player's skill.

Furthermore, the purpose of the ballon d'Or is mostly just to increase the market value of the players and clubs involved and more importantly the competitions the judgement is based on. For that reason, awarding it by actual skill would be counterproductive anyway. Players have to bring other qualities as well, mostly related to their advertising potential and media exposure. That automatically creates a preoccupation towards some players. Attacking players usually get more media exposure than defending ones or goalkeepers. They are more easily declared mvp even despite not necessarily being the most skilled ones. Players from big football nations with lots of media exposure have it easier than those from smaller ones that might not do as well at world/continental championships, completely independent of individual player skill.

To wrap it up, I don't think the modus ia flawed because it fits the purpose very well. Sadly, people actually buy into awards like the Ballon d'Or and interpret an importance into it that's just not justified. Which in turn shows how well it achieves its purpose to begin with.

13

u/cas757 Apr 08 '14

The Champions League is more exciting to watch than the World Cup.

23

u/G3isme Apr 08 '14

That is probably because you are support Bayern. They are serious competitors for these Champions League. The World Cup is more exciting because once every 4 years all of the country is putting aside the rivalries, and supporting thier country together. If you are not live in a country that has a World Cup team then it is hard to watch. Even once my team gets elimanated, Portugal, me still get nervous, hoping that the team that knocked us out will get elimenated. That passion is just not compare for the Champions League.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/justthisones Apr 08 '14

Nothing beats the World Cup feeling. There is no "rich teams", it's all down to what your country has to offer. Only team that has a home advantage is the host and even they don't play in the stadium every other weekend... The whole world is watching while these players give everything they got for their countries. Can't get much more exciting than that IMO.

Champions league is great but the WC is just something really special.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/cheftlp1221 Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

A Euro Super League is inevitable and will be a reality in the next 10 years.

Clubs will sever ties with their local FA's and form their own transnational league that will replace the current UCL.

EDIT:

Here is how I think it would look.

Money. Money is what makes modern soccer go. Especially TV rights fees. When the European Super League happens it will because someone will come along with a solution and offer more money then the clubs will be able to turn down. Playing in the Champions League is already the goal and ambition of most teams because of the money involved. It will be doubly so once a real ESL is put forth.

Competitive Balance. Most European League are already segregated into haves and have nots. Of the top 8 Leagues, 90% of the clubs have zero chance to win their League when the season starts. This 90% are playing not to lose and be relegated. Not exactly the most sporting of intentions.

  • The EPL offers the greatest diversity with a whooping 20% of Clubs with an honest shot winning.
  • Followed by Italy with 3-4 teams in any given season.
  • The fiscally responsible Bundesliga has Bayern Munich and 17 other clubs that struggle to consistently challenge Bayern. See Wolfsburg and Dortmond for recent examples.
  • Spain is self evident.
  • Portugal and France, Belgium and The Netherlands are approaching duopoly status.
  • I already ordered my 2018 Celtic Championship Banner.
  • Turkey has their Big 3
  • PSG is following the Russian Oligarch and Oil Shiek plan

Having such a competitive imbalance in leagues will ultimately lead to dwindling interest of casual and regular fans. Additionally big clubs are often patronizing to lesser teams in the league and play just hard enough to get the result and not get hurt further deteriorating the product.

Travel. Travel for both the clubs and supporters is a red herring. Travel is part of the game already. One only has to look to the US and their sports leagues to study travel. I am not suggesting that it is not a factor but to dismiss a Super-League because travel is to onerous is patently false. Firstly the travel distances in western Europe are ridiculously close where most of the Super League clubs would be located. Secondly these are highly tuned professional athletes with some of the best bio-mechanical trainers at their disposal. I am pretty sure they can fly 3-4 hours to play a game. I also don't think it would be a problem for 3-5000 supporters a normal away allotment to make their way to Milan, Paris, or Madrid. It is not like they are being asked to travel to an out of the way Eastern European village.

Teams and Format. The European Club Assc was formed in 2008 and represents the biggest clubs in Europe. It was formed to protect the interests of the big clubs and a warning to UEFA that they could take the proverbial ball and go somewhere else. The foundation of a Super League will come from here.

I imagine two 16 team leagues, ESL1 & ESL2.

  • Playing a standard home/away schedule.
  • Initial Season leagues will be divided by UEFA coefficient
  • Top 4 in ESL1 go to playoff. Semifinals being a 2 legged playoff and a single game final for all the marbles
  • Bottom 3 of ESL1 relegated to ESL2.
  • ESL2 has promotion playoff similar to Championship.
  • Bottom 4 of ESL2 are relegated back to their homeland league.
  • Semi Finalists of Europa League are promoted to ESL2
  • Championship homeland teams can challenge the lowest ranking ESL team from their country for their spot in a 2 legged playoff prior the next season starting.
  • Early season knock out cup competition similar the League Cup, can be played with a early March final.

The First 32

Eng: ManU, ManCity, Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool

France: PSG, Lyon, Monoco, Marseille

Spain: Barca, Real Madrid, Atletico Madrid, Valencia

Italy: Juventus, AC Milan, Inter, Roma

Portugal: Benfica, Porto

Netherlands: Ajax, PSV

Germany: Bayern Munich, BvD, Shalke 04, Wolfsburg

Belgium: Anderlect, Standard Liege

Greece: Olympiacos, Panathinaikos

Turkey: Galatarsaray, Fenerbache, Besikitas

Scotland: Celtic

A set up like this would literally change nothing about the ambitions for the clubs involved; Arsenal could still aim to comfortably finish 4th. I don't think it would have the adverse effect on the homeland leagues like people say. In England, top to bottom would be a wide open exciting race for the title. 10 teams could have title hopes at the start of the season. Winners still get to play for European spots and a chance to qualify for the ESL.

The big clubs get to make a metric fuckton of money and play against world class teams every week. The fans would have a field day. Every week there would be a 6-8 delicious matchups. Neutrals would flock to their TV's. Worldwide interest would spike.

56

u/joy_divison Apr 08 '14

Really doubt this one. Nationalism, ability for lower clubs to compete, too many issues.

17

u/envirosani Apr 08 '14

The UCL is the biggest football event of the year. It is exciting because you have a chance to enter when you are good enough. When you are the Belgian champions and you play well in the CL you have the chance of winning it. Making a consistent league will take a lot of excitement away, players from smaller clubs won't have the chance to show themselves on the european stage and I think seeing the same teams year in year out won't be as exciting as the current system.

14

u/TheTrotters Apr 08 '14

Here's why it wouldn't work:

  • Europe doesn't and won't have a college farm system which selects and trains players. Big teams need mid-table Dutch teams, Championship teams or decent Portuguese teams to scout and develop players. If you make a league like this, it'd cut off most of financing to most of the clubs and thus they'd lose resources to do what they do.
  • I don't think there would be that much extra money from advertising, sponsorship etc. All games take place during the weekends, so they'd compete for attention with each other. No matter how many great games there'd be, I'm unlikely to watch more than one or two, just as I do now.
  • I think you underestimate the role of local rivalry (that is, rivalry within country or region). I'd wager that for many, say, Arsenal fans a game against Tottenham is more exciting and meaningful than a game against most of the teams listed there. There's blood between the clubs, there's history, fans know each other and can feel smug about that. Galatasaray might play better football, but people are in it to a large extent for drama and "narrative," not for the best football possible.
  • A team like PSV, Anderlecht or Standard Liege (?!?!) is reputable only because it's among the best in its domestic league. In the new SuperLeague they are basically Fulham, Newcastle, and Cardiff.

Here's what I think is viable and should happen: regional mergers of league. Great Britain + Scotland should be one league. Scandinavia should be one league. Benelux should be one league. Spain + Portugal. Balkans. Eastern Europe could probably create two leagues. Ukraine and Russia are large enough and politically distant enough to remain as separate leagues.

This way you keep most of existing funding and rivalries in place, but also make each league stronger and more interesting. Ajax, PSV, Feyenoord, AZ, Vitesse, Anderlecht, CB etc. would make a good league. Adding Porto, Sporting, Boavista and Benfica (among others) to Spain would be fascinating. Celtic and Rangers should play against Arsenal, United and others.

It is also the only way for a football team from, say, Czech Republic, Sweden or Hungary to ever be relevant again. Sparta Prague makes into group stage of CL every now and then, but they'll never be more than that if they play most of their games against teams from small Czech towns. But I playing against teams from Warsaw, Kraków, Gdańsk etc. would make everyone much better off.

28

u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14

Why would clubs want to do that?

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ICritMyPants Apr 08 '14

Why would successful clubs want to leave a league where they have a huge chance of winning to a league where they have much less chance of winning?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

This will never happend. You have to realize that Europe is fundamentally different from the US. The cultural difference between different countries is way too big for it to happend. There is way too much tradition for it to happend. Money and advertising isn't everything here.

Unlike American sports, there is no one who "owns" the sport. There is no centralized ownership and that's why it will never happend. FIFA and UEFA can say whatever they want, but they don't own nor decide over leagues. Yes, all FIFA and UEFA care about is money but as mentioned, they have little say in the matter.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

What makes you think that the rest of the league would be a title race from top to bottom? The way I see it Everton and Tottenham would just race for the title and the rest of the teams would try and close the gap and we'd end up with a situation to the one were in now.

2

u/wishwellPT Apr 08 '14

How come Turkey gets 3 clubs yet Portugal and the Netherlands only get 2? Last time I checked Portugal was 5th, the Netherlands 8th and Turkey 11th.

Edit: and France gets 4.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/gwaksl Apr 08 '14

Munich's centre-back situation is wholly unsustainable and Boateng is grossly overrated.

2

u/kbradley27 Apr 08 '14

David Moyes was brought in to never succeed at Manchester United. He is an average manager, who did slightly above average, with an average Everton squad. However, he is, and most likely never will be, close to Alex Ferguson, in terms of managing ability. I don't think he was the best manager to replace SAF, in terms of continuing his legacy, and is being used as a scapegoat and to further the legacy of SAF by comparison. I am a long time United supporter, and fully support any manager in charge, but I think Moyes was brought in to fail. Change my views

2

u/donttaxmyfatstacks Apr 09 '14

Because SAF is a shareholder in MU. MU doing poorly is directly hitting him in the pocket, just like all their other financial backers. Since when do people purposefully try to lose money?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/meiuqer Apr 08 '14

these are the kind of threads you need to sort by "controversial"

2

u/EpoxyD Apr 08 '14

Play offs at the end of a season are a horrible idea.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/MR777 Apr 08 '14

Steven Gerrard is not a top, top player.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sheikmat Apr 08 '14

France will win the world cup

2

u/amediocregatsby Apr 09 '14
  1. They bombed out of 2010, and only barely qualified for 2014 WC.
  2. Still, they got the easiest group, with two decent teams and Honduras.
  3. I find Benzema to be a pretty overrated striker, and since France's #2 option is Giroud (and not Remy), their attack doesn't really quake boots.
  4. France's defense is a mix of old guards and promising youngsters; that's a dangerous combination to have on a big stage.
  5. They have a fantastic midfielders (and wingers!), but I'm not sure they've found the best way to balance them yet. They seem to fall into two categories: aggressive and energetic box-to-box players (Capoue, Pogba, Sissoko) and creative types who like to come in from the wingers (Ribery, Griezmann, Nasri).
→ More replies (1)

8

u/1mdelightful Apr 08 '14

With the exception of keeper you can compare any two players regardless of position. It is simple laziness to say "their completely different players." For example. Arturo Vidal and Dani Alves. Vidal is physical, can score and assist he can be used anywhere in the midfield. Dani Alves is can basically cover a whole side of the pitch by himself. Few other midfielders have shown the ability to score and assist as well as Vidal there are a few Eriksen, Goetze, Iniesta and de Maria come to mind. Unlike the others mentioned he has high defensive work rate. This is why Vidal is superior (to Alves) because it is much more difficult to place such a versatile midfielder than it is to find a RB would will bomb forward - you may not want him to go forward anyway. Vidal compared to Benatia. With Benatia you do not need to cover him as well that means you can create an overload some place on the pitch or simple field more attackers. It is like playing with 11.2 people. This is more valuable than a midfielder who scores.

10

u/Jarik42 Apr 08 '14

I'm not actually disagreeing with you CMV, I am disagreeing with your assessment of Dani Alves.

find a RB would will bomb forward

Alves has an 87.4% passing accuracy, a player like Zabaleta, only has 84.6%. Alves also wins more aerial duels per game, scores goals and he gets less cards. He has more key passes (1.3 compared to 0.8 per game), dribbles (1.2 compared to 0.2) and crosses (1.1 compared to 0.3)

Barcelona would not have an easy time replacing Alves

5

u/Sean88888 Apr 08 '14

A few years ago when Alves was at Sevilla the team tactic was built around him going forward. He was a wing back who had the tactical liberty and creative freedom of an attacking winger. I wouldn't be surprised if he can play in Ronaldo's or Bale's position, which would increase his value but he plays FB for Barca because no one does it better.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/HazardIsCute Apr 08 '14

Frank Lampard is the best midfielder in the premier league era. No one has done anything close to what he has from midfield. Ronaldinho in his prime is the only reason Lampard doesn't have a Ballon D'or

17

u/ICritMyPants Apr 08 '14

Just curious what you mean by "No one has done anything close to what he has from midfield". Can you expand on it a bit, please?

35

u/thierry90 Apr 08 '14

He can only mean goal output surely. I don't think he's got the all-round game of Keane and Vieira, or the ability to impact on a game like Gerrard, or the ability to dictate a game like Scholes. He's got longevity on his side like Giggs but I don't think Lampard can be described as the best in anything outside of consistently banging goals in.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

33

u/omegaxLoL Apr 08 '14

In goal scoring, sure Lampard is very highly ranked when it comes to midfielders. Overall, players like Scholes, Keane, Gerrard and Vieira have been consistently better than Lampard. It's a massive exaggeration to say 'no one has done anything close to what he has'.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/The_British_One Apr 08 '14

Steven Gerrard springs to mind as his main rival. Although equally Beckham, Keane, Giggs, Scholes, and arguably Mata & David Silva more recently.

While none of them have matched his goals scored, and that may depend on playing style as well as the fact that some like Beckham, Mata & Silva didn't/haven't played their whole career in the BPL, they are all at least as good as him in terms of passing, vision, leadership etc.

For me Gerrard comes out on top. While he's scored 61 goals less, he's 2 years younger for a start. He's also not always been the main free-kick taker like Lampard was. But more than that, look at the teams Lampard has played in...alongside Drogba, Zola, Joe Cole in his prime, Hasselbaink, Gudjohnson, Anelka, Ballack, Hazard, etc. Apart from Zola, all of them were at their peak when he played with them.

He played in some dominant teams and has won 3 premierships, and never finished outside the top 4.

Meanwhile Gerrard has been playing in a team that has notoriously underperformed for the last 20 years, and only now is starting to really live up to expectations. He too has played alongside some world class players (Alonso, Torres, Suarez, Owen, Fowler) but the team he's been in has never, until this season, been as good.

If Chelsea had got Gerrard as they wanted in the mid 00's, Gerrard would have very similar, if not better statistics than Lampard. He's clearly more adaptable & versatile, has a better passing range, vision, awareness, defensive capabilities and penalties. He may not have scored as many goals, but he's not that far off, and the teams Lampard has played in, against the teams Gerrard has played in, would win most of the time. So obviously he'll have better stats.

There's a reason Gerrard was always chosen over Lampard for England. And that one is now national captain and the other doesn't make the squad.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Revise your statement to "Lampard is the best offensive minded midfielder." and I will agree. You cannot say he is better than the likes of say Scholes the way you did.

Lampard is a legend though.

6

u/thelenscleaner Apr 08 '14

Saying he is the best and saying no one has done anything close to what he has from midfield are two very, very different things. In terms of a midfielder who sets the tempo of the match and lets his team dominate while creating chances I don't think there is anyone better than Scholes in PL. I do however feel that Giggs is slightly over hyped and that's just because of him playing till this age. Overall I think in terms of consistency in PL Lampard takes the award.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (41)

3

u/Simon_Riley Apr 08 '14

Based on the goal-line technology decisions in the EPL this season, I think the Hawkeye or similar goal-line tech should be used in all leagues and international football. FIFA should also help with the cost.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/croutonZA Apr 08 '14

Goal line technology, or any other form of technology to help the referees, has no place in football unless the FA or the Premier League pays to have it implemented in all Football League grounds at the very least.

→ More replies (12)

3

u/Colonel_Hapablap Apr 08 '14

Pirlo didn't magically appear in 2012. He had a very successful time at AC Milan for a number of years. I hear way too many people talk about Andrea Pirlo as a late bloomer.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

I think Suarez is the best player in the World at the moment

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Sean88888 Apr 08 '14

Rooney looks like Shrek. Change my view.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

He's not green and his ears are human.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

La Liga has better quality teams all around compared to the BPL.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Redbullsnation Apr 08 '14

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain is Theo Walcott's son. Pacey but overrated and overhyped by the British media. I don't see what's the difference between the two. Just one is younger than the other

4

u/ShortSkrtLongJackett Apr 08 '14

I'd say the Ox is more technically gifted with the ball at his feet

3

u/AfricanRain Apr 08 '14

I'd say Walcott has been underhyped. He has gone relatively unoticed for the last few years depsite registering a very good goal:assist record last season.

5

u/Simon_Riley Apr 08 '14

OC has a slightly higher football IQ than Walcott.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Also much stronger

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NPHisKing Apr 08 '14

Ox is a lot smarter, stronger and more composed on the ball than Theo. Ox can play in central midfield and on the wings. Theo is a lot more direct (except shooting outside the area,) makes better runs and is faster than Ox. Theo can play on the wings and as a striker.

They aren't similar players at all, really.

2

u/MisterBlack8 Apr 08 '14

Change "pacey" to "athletic", and you've just described every young English player who has not embarrassed anyone yet. Since the statement applies to everyone, what makes you think Theo Walcott has fathered THAT many children?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/JKohlerFussballgott Apr 08 '14

Ribery should have won the Ballon D'or because he was just outstanding AND won titles with his team.
Even in a team that won the treble (and features only world class players) he managed to stand out
Everytime he played he was on fire, creating chances like there is no tomorrow, backtracking and overall tried everything to help the team

Hit me, change my view

42

u/HazardIsCute Apr 08 '14

It is not a team award. Bayern were the best but Messi and Ronaldo had better seasons. Ribery's stats were similar to Hazards in terms of production. Stats are misleading but as a forward you cannot put up those stats and win over the current versions of Messi and Ronaldo.

→ More replies (10)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

The ballon d'or goes to the best player in the world, Ribery's good but not even close to Ronaldo or Messi. Team achievements are mostly irrelevant.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/poipoiop Apr 08 '14

In my opinion, it's an individual award.

Individually, Ronaldo was better than Ribery.

Even though Ribery helped Bayern win those team titles, they're still team titles and awarded/credited to the team not individually to Ribery.

So yes, Ribery was outstanding. Just not, individually, as good as Ronaldo.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/owiseone23 Apr 08 '14

Well, I think it can be easier to perform well with a very strong team than without. With the wealth of talent around him, many teams don't think it's worth it to double mark him like Ronaldo and Messi constantly are. The Ballon D'or is for the best player and based purely on that, Ronaldo deserved it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/NFeKPo Apr 08 '14

La Liga will never have a consistent title contender not named Barca and Real until they institute a TV revenue sharing system that resembles the EPL.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Alex Ferguson is overrated. His fame stems from him not being sacked because Manchester United lack European ambition.

He won the Champion's League twice in 18 attempts. At most clubs, when domestic success does not translate into European success you get fired.

26

u/deepit6431 Apr 08 '14

I'm very obviously biased and emotional about this, but I'll still say this:

Sir Alex has absolutely nothing left to prove in the world of football. He has conquered everything there ever was. If you can't see his charisma, his tactical brilliance and adaptability (anyone who says Fergie wasn't tactically brilliant has absolutely zero idea about football), and his influence on English football and the Premiership, you're either wilfully ignorant or a complete dunce.

25

u/rkrish7 Apr 08 '14

He almost beat us with the squad that is currently sitting 7th in the premier league. If that doesn't speak to his abilities to think tactically and motivate his players, I don't know what does.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/salfordred Apr 08 '14

It's because he was in charge at a time when English football was not even close to their European counterparts.

If anything he put England back on the map in the CL.

The best players never came to England and they still don't. We still have to settle with the best of the rest and promising talents who can become world-class.

And it was much worse before the mid 00s than it is now. In the 90s only one English team won it all (United).

Younger fans don't realise how much of an after thought English teams used to be.

Ferguson for large parts of his career simply didn't have a squad that could win the CL. The one period he did 2007-2011, United were great in the CL. The 5 year period when English football was at it's strongest Ferguson got us a win, two finals and a semi-final. A great record.

To call him overrated is just foolish.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/DerDummeMann Apr 08 '14

For the majority of Ferguson's career, English teams were vastly inferior to the other teams.

There was never any expectation to really succeed in the CL (i.e you would never get sacked for not winning it).

You must be younger and have seen expectations shift. When English teams were expected to succeed in Europe, Ferguson has had a great record.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

4

u/Thapricorn Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Obviously heavy bias, but I'll do my best to be open minded and consider counter-arguments.

Steven Gerrard in his prime was the most complete midfielder, in terms of ability in different aspects of the game, in the Premier League era.

Edit: Nobody has replied yet, so I'll stretch it a bit more (even though I myself don't buy it): Gerrard in his prime was the most complete/well-rounded midfielder in the last 30 years.

4

u/CapMurphySeason Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Pele isn't that great

EDIT:I could have worded this better

61

u/ucd_pete Apr 08 '14

Well, he's not that great now, he's 73. But he was great.

15

u/salfordred Apr 08 '14

How can you say that without having watched him?

I'm 100% sure you haven't watched over 1 full match of his.

2

u/L__McL Apr 08 '14

Being the best player at and winning 3 World Cups says otherwise.

2

u/donttaxmyfatstacks Apr 09 '14

The only possible way to judge players across the ages is to judge them relative to their peers. Pele was ridiculously far ahead of his peers, even more so than Messi is now.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '14

Steven Gerrard was the best midfielder in the world from 05 till 09.

26

u/Panda_In_The_Box Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14

Ronaldinho, Xavi, Zidane, Totti and potentially Scholes/Lampard depending on what you look for in an English midfielder.

Gerrard was excellent though.

15

u/lakupiippu Apr 08 '14

Quite difficult to put Zizou in there since he retired in 2006 and Ronaldinho wasn't anywhere near Gerrard in 2008 and 2009.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/lakupiippu Apr 08 '14

On par with Kaka during that time period.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)