r/WritingPrompts • u/muffinprincess13 • May 27 '14
Off Topic [OT] Some suggestions for new budding writers
First off, let me say that I am not a professional writer, and that if someone came up with the perfect writing technique, it would become so successful that everyone would know about it and do it; therefore there isn't (to my knowledge) a perfect way to write.
That being said, here are some things I've noticed in my early forays into writing:
- Read. Read. Read. Not just to be a pompous know-it-all. Studies have shown that people who regularly read literature understand emotions better.
- Write. Write. Write. That is part of why this sub is here; you have a great venue to practice quick two-four paragraph fiction. Like any other talent, skill, or hobby, you need to practice to get better.
- Do Find what is admirable in an amateur-written story. I cannot stress this enough. It is very easy to pick out what went wrong with writing, but people who have written and read a lot know good writing and know what to look for. This is another reason why this sub is here: you are exposed to a variety of writers responding to a variety of prompts, critique them! Tell your opinion, it is helpful not only for you but also for them to get better at writing, and perhaps share and discuss a certain point either one of you made!
- Do Use a thesaurus. Dictionaries give you the denotation of a word, but a thesaurus gives you the connotation, and you can often figure out their meaning by context clues. For you windows users, this is "Shift+F7" when you open up Microsoft Word. This has also personally helped me expand my vocabulary.
- Do Make your characters weak and/or flawed. For more action oriented stories, you want your character weak, for narrative/psychological driven stories, you want flawed characters. If your character is an awesome muscle-man killing people with his well-aimed punches and his poorly phrased puns, your character can quickly get boring. Stories are about struggle and conflict, whether physical or emotional. Making your character unprepared for the conflict makes the story more tense and exciting. Let them get hurt, let them feel loss, not just as a narrative device so that the character can start on a quest for revenge, but for them to lose an integral and necessary member of their cast.
- Do listen to critiques. Even if you are dead-set on believing that someone's interpretation of what you wrote is wrong, the fact is that someone interpreted what you wrote in that way. This gives you an important insight on how people read and understand what you write.
- Don't take critiques personally. True, some people are out there just to ruin your day, but just because you wrote something that someone didn't agree with doesn't mean that no one agrees with what you wrote. There are many theories on writing because there are many writers and many more readers out there, and I'm sure you'll find someone who'll appreciate your work.
- Don't tell me what happened, show me. Saying:
"He was angry at Sam."
Isn't as provocative as:
"He tried taking, slow, deep breaths. He moved away from anything that was expensive or fragile. He tried picking up a crossword puzzle, but all he ended up doing was imagining breaking off his pencil and jamming it into Sam's throat."
Not only did I describe an emotion, but I also showed that the character was actively trying to calm himself down. This shows emotion, how the character was trying to deal with the emotion, and that he wanted stay in control of his feelings. Use action to describe emotion!
- Don't start a sentence with "one word+a comma". Example:
"However, the thoughts didn't stop there; he imagined how his fingers would feel awash in Sam's hot blood gushing from that puncture wound in his neck."
When writing in prose, many of your sentences can be a lot stronger if you drop that first/first few words. Example:
"The thoughts didn't stop there; he imagined how his fingers would feel awash in Sam's hot blood gushing from that puncture wound in his neck."
Take something I said earlier:
"That being said, here are some things I've noticed in my early forays into writing:"
Now drop the first few words:
"Here are some things I've notice in my early forays into writing:"
Words like "However", "But", "Also", "Then", "Therefore" and others can usually be dropped to make a sentence have more impact. Realize that this is also a stylistic choice, but know that you can add this to your toolbox when you write to give your prose a little more "punch".
- Don't repeat the same words too often. This goes back to using your thesaurus; people get bored when writing, add some variety to the words you are using! You'll get exposed to a plethora of words that you can add for later use. That being said:
- Don't get too liberal with the thesaurus. Sometimes you need to use repetition to emphasize a point. Finding the correct amount of fancy words + concision takes a bit of practice, but I think Faulkner and Hemingway's interchange pretty much sums it up:
Faulkner on Hemingway:
“He has never been known to use a word that might send a reader to the dictionary.”
Hemingway on Faulkner:
“Poor Faulkner. Does he really think big emotions come from big words?”
- Don't be a afraid to rewrite. Got a really cool idea, and have it in your story, and then you realize that it doesn't really add to the story? Does it slow your prose down and you spend more time dealing with your cool idea than allowing the narrative to progress forward? I'm sorry, sometimes you have to cut the idea or that really well-phrased sentence because it just doesn't fit with everything else.
Now, i've got to be on campus in less than nine hours, so i'm going to leave this here. If i think of anything else, or if someone points out something that i missed or is particularly useful, be sure to point it out.
Thanks!
EDIT 1: woo-hoo i'm on the wiki now! also, some other points people brought up:
On dialogue by /u/StoryboardThis
On using the "to be" verb by /u/jp_in_nj
11
u/[deleted] May 27 '14
Agreed with all of this, particularly the 'show, don't tell' angle.
Only thing I'd add is that I once had the privilege of attending a Q&A session with Iain Banks (a well-regarded British author), and he said that you have to write a million words of shit before you can get to the good stuff.
So yeah. If everything comes out shit then just remember that everyone started that way.
5
u/SurvivorType Co-Lead Mod | /r/SurvivorTyper May 27 '14
I added this to our wiki, thanks for posting!
4
u/mo-reeseCEO1 May 27 '14
some thoughts...
firstly, it doesn't really matter if you are professional or not in terms of giving advice. a professional writer does not denote a good writer (take any second rate news publication, for example, and you'll see what mean). secondly, profession does not indicate expertise. your fifth grade English teacher was not a professional writer. she was an expert in grammar and composition, however, and her advice was eminently useful. sharing observations about what makes strong writing is good for the community. no one should qualify that statement, though you should be able to defend your assertions.
that said, you character should be flawed, not weak. the muscle bound macho cleaving through mobs of mooks with nary a weakness is the actual weak character. a guy like Macbeth is pretty flawed, suffers from human weaknesses and all, but is in fact a strong character. strength and weakness of characters isn't based on the attributes of their stat sheets but whether or not they can carry a narrative and build an empathetic rapport with the reader.
lastly, the point about avoiding one word than comma sentences is more stylistic than substantive. that's absolutely the right construction in some contexts. this appears to be a variation of Vonnegut's 'i hate semi-colons' rule, which he then goes on to break because it's more of a guideline/personal conceit than a trick to being a good writer. my counter advice would be:
2
u/cilice May 28 '14
Oh. My. God.
You used "concision". I have been telling this to people for years. "Conciseness" is absurd!
2
u/marbledog May 27 '14
I would only add that why we write is every bit as important as how.
Excerpt from a letter Kurt Vonnegut wrote to a high school class:
Every word you set to paper, shared or unshared, adds to the pool of human achievement, helps you grow as a person, and makes the world a marginally better place. Don't write because you want to be a writer. Write because you want everyone to live in a better world.
29
u/StoryboardThis /r/TheStoryboard May 27 '14
Some Thoughts On The Spoken Word in Writing
Dialogue is difficult.
You're probably rereading that first sentence and thinking, "Quit being a pessimist, SbT! I could write conversational circles around my characters for days!" And you might be right. For all I know, you could be the next Dickens of dialogue. But let's suspend disbelief for a moment and say you're not a wizard of verbal communication.
What can you do to make your dialogue more believable?
Those are the three big ones for me, but I'm sure there are many, many others.
8
u/Tornspirit May 27 '14
Something I've noticed that a lot of inexperienced writers do is follow this to an extreme; they try to use heaps of fancy words that don't really help your story at all. Sometimes, a simple 'he asked' or 'he replied' will do.
7
u/jp_in_nj May 27 '14 edited May 27 '14
This could be strengthened further:
Because "to be" is static, for me it can keep sentences dead on the page. I find that rewriting to avoid its use (within practical limits) almost inevitably improves prose.
Here's an example:
Not bad, a little poetic. While there's a visual, there's no sense of place to him, though.
Rewritten:
We make him "tall" by having him look down, and "gaunt" by giving him a "narrow posterior".
It doesn't have the same poesy to it that the original does, but for me it's more immersive, and it lets the reader do their 50%.
(That said, sometimes the voice requires the original sentence.)
Here's another:
Okay, that's vivid enough. But can we get rid of the "were"?
Or, y'know, whatever.
Point being that working without the static safety net of to be forces the writer to consider more active phrasing. Sometimes a good "were" is exactly what's called for... but often it's just the quickest tool to hand, rather than the best one.
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '14
Agreed also, but on that last point I thought I might impart a little experience. I wrote the first draft of my first novel two years ago. I always love quoting Hemingway who imparted a multitude of gems on how to write - one relevant to this was, 'The first draft of anything is shit.'
Now I'm not saying that your first draft is shit, but mine certainly was. Be proud of it regardless - to write a draft of any novel is no small feat. But while you may want to take a scalpel to it to refine and hone it, because you cling to what you've done, never be afraid of an axe. My novel started with a first person perspective. Now I'm on the third draft and having to be very brave in throwing whole chapters out of the window and starting from scratch in places. You may love a character, but because they don't add enough to the story you either remove them entirely or merge some of their qualities into another character. In rewriting you have to be brutally honest with yourself. There was a time when I would endlessly tweak sections to get them to work with the novel and I was unable to see some of the flaws. I now have entire pages where I've written in the margins, 'This is shit, write better.' And on the second re-write things pan out better.
And a final tip for all of you budding writers - persist. I learned a lot writing that first couple drafts and I hope to learn a lot more writing subsequent drafts and subsequent novels. Talent goes a long way of course but no one wakes up and has an inate ability to rattle off brilliant prose, so never underestimate how much you have to learn nor how much you can learn. Your first attempts may make you baulk, but persist and your attempts have the potential to go as far as your imagination.
Good luck!
1
u/PacoDamorte May 27 '14
Thank you for this!
1
u/Dhz_4 May 27 '14
Thank you :)
1
u/[deleted] May 27 '14
Thank you for writing this. Especially the Shift + F7 one, I mean seriously, I never knew that.
1
u/falsevillain May 27 '14
Personally, I think as long as you're a creative person, you understand emotions with or without reading, despite what studies say. But that's not to say reading won't help you, and it's always helpful to expose yourself to writing from different authors.
-1
u/Rukenau May 27 '14
Please correct the typo: it's amateur, not amatuer.
0
u/[deleted] May 27 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment