r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Jul 24 '14
Map Thread #32 Results
Congratulations to Bowtie for getting his map Hurricane into rotation. The submission was pretty highly voted on the map thread, and we liked it as well. It's a slightly more defensive map, but offense still has a chance to make some clutch plays on it. The narrowness of the map makes it so that offense can't run around and hide forever, but still gives smart players the option to make fast getaways and keep defense on their toes.
On the less bright side of things, we've decided to take somewhat-beloved group favorite map SNES v2 by Ron Burgundy out of group rotation. Instead, it's now both in group and public rotation. It's a very fun, very balanced map that works for both competitive and non-competitive play, and I at least think it's going to at least become a pub favorite. Congratulations to Ron for being among the first to get a map from group to public rotation.
DaEvil1's Grail of Speed has been given a revision. It's been shortened a little around the edges and had a few reworks while still retaining the spirit of the map. The goal of the revision is to make it so that it's no longer as hard to catch up to a flag carrier and pop him, and to overall give defense an easier time to make the map more balanced. Look for the changes to be rolled out soon; bonus points if you take pictures of the maps on a disposable camera and take a red marker highlighting the difference between them.
Finally, Noobkin's Push will be making group rotation. The map has the form of a Neutral Flag map, but with the tug-of-war feel of a Mars Ball map. Despite the heartbreak that many Mars Ball maps have caused, this map has proven itself to be fun, whether it's for a smaller 3v3 or larger 6v6.
No maps will be taken out of rotation this time around.
15
u/crblanz Keekly | used to be good sorta Jul 25 '14
oh shit they liked my map!
oh okay...
6
u/bashar_al_assad pk || Roll into the base like what up I got a big block Jul 25 '14 edited Jul 25 '14
Hurricane
SNES
I couldn't find a map called "Push" submitted anywhere.
20
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Can we see pictures of all these maps?
13
u/BilldaCat10 Jul 25 '14
citizens demand to see the grail of speed revisions
our words are backed with nuclear weapons
11
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Can those maps that were considered but not selected get feedback in order to improve them?
9
u/SealedEnvelope Ron Burgundy | Blockburn Rovers Jul 25 '14
Oh wow I didn't even realise you guys were considering SNES any more, thanks so much! Now to wait for the hate to start rolling in :D
8
u/Cant_Quit_U Cant_Quit_U || Pi Jul 25 '14
Aww :(
Yay idk what this map even looks like :D
6
u/411connor caroline :3 Jul 25 '14
Good decisions this time by the map committee. The Hurricane map looks pretty good and SNES will be interesting for PUB rotation. I really wanna see what Push looks like.
6
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Jul 25 '14
Is there going to be a spreadsheet again with feedback? It was semi-useful to me last time but I know that mapmakers find it very useful
9
u/mmartinutk Macho | JuicyJuke Jul 25 '14
I've been among the crowd that has been critical of the map committee the last few threads- I loved Hyper Reactor and was not/still not a fan of a map or two that did make the cut. I voiced my opinion just like, as it seemed, a lot of other people.
That's why I think it's important to comment on how awesome these new maps look. I think Hurricane is the big map that everyone was wanting and it looks very balanced- I'm actually very eager to play it. And SNES's bases remind me of Whirlwind (bombs), and anything that reminds me of Whirlwind is okay in my book.
Well done guys.
4
u/quassus crosky Jul 25 '14
Feedback on Monarch, please?
http://i.imgur.com/fIdzhYv.jpg
4
u/UUD-40 Bome Sall || Wherever the ping takes me Jul 25 '14
I find it interesting that SuperDuperStamp had a big maptest organized, yet it remains unchanged, while Grail of Speed didn't, while large changes were made. I take this to mean the maptest committee is working hard behind the scenes to make maps balanced, good job guys!
Also, a short story: Yesterday in a pug we were playing snipers3, but after a few games we wanted to try other sniper maps. Since there was no snipers2 we played on, coincidentally enough, SNES 2. Shoutout to the group leader at that time Not actually out loud though he couldn't hear me...
Finally, Maptest committee, I know you get a lot of shit, but I think you are doing a really great job. Keep up the good work! :)
3
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Any feedback on Crazy 8? I'm not happy with it yet, but think it is really close to being a good map.
http://i.imgur.com/V7XyRlk.png
My main idea is it might be "too much", I'm hoping to simplify while keeping its integrity.
3
u/neckhickeys4u Tinker Creek // Pi Jul 25 '14
Please stop allowing revisions to maps already in rotation. I think it's generally a very bad idea.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Can I get feedback on Smooth 3?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Can I get feedback on Four Corners? (I renamed this map to "Pursuit" in the Map Thread due to another map having the same name)
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/360
Preview: http://i.imgur.com/h9Ba155.png
2
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Jul 25 '14
Feedback on Chalice2: http://cvps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/240.png
or Hug: http://cvps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/239.png ?
Also, I really like the changes on Grail of speed, the spikes are easier to maneuver and the side gates feel like they have purpose now
2
u/-Time- ツ Jul 25 '14
Feedback on Innoncence... please.
2
u/rndmwhitekid Rndm | Father of 21 Juke Street Jul 25 '14
Feedback on Tipi please?
2
u/Lysozyme_ Lysozyme Jul 25 '14
Are you guys doing that spreadsheet again with feedback? If not I would love if someone could give a quick word on mine, sorry!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Can I get feedback on my map Run?
http://maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/308.png
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
I made a map called Hurricane once. I think it's still in some-bots brain. Bowtie you totally stole my map. Theyre clearly very similar.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
wp mapcommittee gg
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
YES YES YES YOU GO BOWTIE
2
u/blakey88 PaulB // Origin Jul 25 '14
Hey where can I find Hurricane map and others?
I play on UK Origin server, didn't see them yet.
1
u/LawJik LawJik | Radius Jul 25 '14 edited Jul 25 '14
Bonus Points? Here are the changes for Grail Of Speed I noticed.
NOTE: The mid power up area on my "Old GOS" pic isn't correct. The current version of GOS on pubs has the gates around the PUP, just couldn't find a pic of that version.
Also OP forgot to link to SNES v2 and Push images?
Edit: Added the team boosts thanks BildaCat. Anyone have a real pic of the current Grail of Speed for comparison?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
is Push an inside joke or something? i don't really like inside jokes that 99% of the community does get in official posts.
1
u/SebastianTheHedgehog nip // chorbit // rbc Jul 25 '14
what did you think of 'the bear'? any good, or scrap it? :P
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Why was Reflex 2 removed? I kinda liked it...
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '14
really disliking grail of speed's changes. you can't hit the bottom boost the way you were able to before, you just get sent to the spike. the grail of speed puts you right up against a wall, which basically defeats the entire purpose of it. and the gates on either side force me to loop around them like a dumbass. i liked the previous version much more.
and as far as hurricane goes, i did enjoy it before, but i feel like it's different in PUBS. i feel forced to go one way when coming down the middle, and sometimes i have to snake through to get to base. as well, i really dislike the team tile and speed boost. at times it sends me fucking FLYING across the map and i usually hit a spike. yeah.
1
u/DizzerPilot Jul 25 '14
Colors and Star are on borrowed time by now I hope
-1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
Grail of Speed got worse.
-12
u/MultiMediaWill Juke King - MVP 90% of the time Jul 25 '14
SNES in. Hyper Reactor still out...? Let's overthrow this 'committee'
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment