r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Oct 31 '14
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 1 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E01 "Made in Manhattan"
All-star designers create fashions inspired by New York's uptown or downtown scene in the Season 4 premiere. Appearing: Ivanka Trump.
16
Upvotes
37
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '14
Is that Kate again??
34
u/fileg Oct 31 '14
Can we please never ever have "the boys vrs the girls" again...
25
u/neopolitancake Nov 01 '14
Does it bother anybody else that literally only two designers aren't from seasons 10/11/12. Seriously.
15
u/aznboi508 Oct 31 '14
This first episode was a bit of a mess. I have to say I love Alexandria's haircut. I also don't think I can tolerate Michelle's voice or Helen's crying so they might get the mute button from time to time.
12
u/nancyaw Oct 31 '14
I'm so psyched to see Justin, Sonjia and Fabio back. I don't think it's particularly fair to bring back previous winners but we'll see.
12
u/genericke Nov 02 '14
Chris, Dmitry, Fabio, and Michelle top 4 please.
11
u/birdablaze Nov 01 '14
LMAO. My mom and I were watching the "next on..." and when Alyssa Milano came down on that green circle thing my mom got so excited and said "ooooooo I love Bette Midler!!!"
8
u/allieFOUR20 Nov 04 '14
Benjamin should have won that first challenge. Fabio's jumpsuit was nice, but so basic looking. And noooooooo, Patricia!! Should have been Kate getting the boot, that dress was so cheesy.
15
u/Chinasun04 Nov 01 '14
Im glad Michelle is back. I was rooting for her on her season and dont find her nearly as annoying as everyone else. I dont even think she is smug. And I loved her winning collection in her season. I also liked amanda during that original season and during this last one too. There seemed to be a lot of amanda hate at the beginning of her 2nd season but by the end of it, many of this subreddit turned to liking her. Maybe the same will happen with Michelle....
5
u/theladyoctober Nov 02 '14
Fabio and Michelle, I'm excited to see more from both of them.
5
u/evixir Nov 02 '14
Surprised that Helen is still going with those ultra-pointy nails. I wonder if she's matured at all since her season. Maybe she has because she was at least polite and cordial to Alexandria.
Also, Kate has to go!
Nice to see that Jay Nicolas Sario is still going with those design elements he used in his (decoy) finale collection a few years back. I still love so many of those pieces, even if he was a total douchebag at the reunion special that season.
22
u/EmptyStar12 Oct 31 '14
This was terrible. All Stars consistently has better challenges (it gets into the camp that usual PR is afraid to handle), but that's about it. The judges are worse, Zana(?) adds nothing to the show, and the only guest judges I really recognized this season were Debra Messing and Snooki.
The waistband on Fabio's jumpsuit was horribly placed. Surely I wasn't the only one who thought that was super phallic. And the prize:
"Ivanka has agreed to wear the winning dress". Dude wtf does that even mean? That's so vague. Wear it where? Who's even gonna know?
Patricia undoubtedly cursing the judges in her native tongue was a nice end to the episode at least.
9
u/EmptyStar12 Oct 31 '14
Patricia yelling "Always the bridesmaid, never the bride!" was perfect haha. Guess I know who I'm rooting for.
9
u/legalbeagle05 Oct 31 '14
My favorite judge is Georgina Chapman.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '14
Anyone else excited to see Ivanka? Normally I'm not a fan of the elite borns (when they are there just because they're rich), but she is just so well spoken and classy!
4
u/SwatchVineyard Nov 04 '14
I have mixed feelings. On one end I want to see more from the designers, on the other hand, I want to see less of this show.
4
u/mielita Nov 08 '14
Totally surprised Kate wasn't the one to get cut, her dress was horrible, definitely agree it looked like something little mermaid would wear
8
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '14
DAMN....I've always been a massive Patricia fan. And I HATED the jumpsuit with the penis appendage on the front.
7
u/RobotDevil80 Oct 31 '14
Alexandria is my favorite. Her runway collection on her original season was amazing (& should have won!)
4
u/highwayunicorn Nov 02 '14
I JUST hit play on this episode and was reminded of how much I can't stand Alexandria. I don't remember why exactly, but I'm sure she will remind me. Ugh.
4
u/legalbeagle05 Oct 31 '14
I'm rooting for Kate and Benjamin!
2
u/Any_Neck5863 Jun 22 '24
Is it me, or does seeing I. V. 4. N. K. A. make anyone else skip this episode?
1
u/Stunning-Tea5759 May 29 '26
Uptown:
Michelle's dress was the only one that exuded "uptown", but only from the front. The back was not even downtown; it was just gratuitously exhibitionist, and the unnecessary color blocking and fabric switch gave it a low-rent vibe.
Loved Alexandria's slouchy, cool, expensive-looking outfit, but it was definitely not uptown; more of an elevated downtown.
Kate: So not uptown. Little mermaid in cheap fabric that was straining at the seams. An uptown woman could afford alterations. And better fabric. And better design.
Helen: Her gown was very well made, and fit like a liquid glove. But is it uptown? I think it's a little too naked for an uptown sophisticate, but it would garner positive attention in an artsy setting.
Poor Patricia. She is a genius fabric artist, but not a dress designer.
Downtown:
Chris March nailed it. Homeless dumpster turned chic and cool without seeming to try. It was so effortless and in-your-face individualist. I miss him.
Fabio from the back! So exciting.
The others: Just watched and already forgotten.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment