r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Nov 06 '14
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 2 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E02 "The Art of Construction"
A construction site inspires the designers to create feminine styles from masculine materials. Appearing: Nicole "Snooki" Polizzi and Jenni "JWoww" Farley.
20
Upvotes
43
u/konfetkak Nov 07 '14
You know what this season is really lacking? Fringe. Not seeing nearly enough fringe.
36
u/comababy Nov 07 '14
Zanna's critiques are so bland and unhelpful. "I don't want to see rope." "Be careful with trash bags." "This is feminine." "It's ... goth."
At least she told Kate to stop making Cinderella wedding gowns.
35
u/konfetkak Nov 07 '14
Mizrahi was throwing all sorts of shade at Jwoww and Snooki. Loved it.
32
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '14
Who told Alyssa that denim coveralls were a good pregnancy look? Because they lied to her...
21
u/roadwarrior1 Nov 07 '14
snow fence and zip ties...who knew?
38
u/Dulciferous Nov 07 '14
I really like Elie Tahari as a judge
32
u/aelizabeth0623 Nov 07 '14
"alexandria's look - i think it's atrocious, and i think it's missing a bird. in the cage." oh, dimitri ❤️
15
u/meldolphin Nov 07 '14
At the judging Michelle had some eyeliner smeared up into her socket and as someone with hooded eyes I sympathized so hard. Anyway...
Michelle's look was blah but I would have put Samantha's in the bottom instead. What was that thing? As far as the Dmitry/Chris situation, that was just silly. When no one is doing what you're doing, you have to compete against all of them. When someone is doing the same thing as you, all you have to do is beat that one person to stay in the competition.
26
u/neopolitancake Nov 07 '14
It bothers me a lot that they shoved down our throats the "coming up this season" clip because once it got down to the last two standing, I knew Michelle wasn't going home because I remember her freaking out when they announced they were going to London. I want it to be a surprise when I watch.
10
u/legalbeagle05 Nov 07 '14
Jungle chic Dmitry???
19
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Nov 07 '14
I expected Alexandra to last a lot longer than she did.
23
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '14
Chris should've spent less time bitching about Dmitri and more time actually making a garment. The skirt he ended up with was cool but Dmitri's top was infinitely better than his.
8
u/peaceandkim Nov 07 '14
The opening credits... no Alyssa. Just no.
28
u/SeptimaRiffic Nov 07 '14
I posted something similar in another sub, but I think that it deserves inclusion in this one too: I cannot stand Snooki and JWoww! They are blatantly ignorant, homophobic, and misogynistic. They can try all they want to re-brand themselves away from "slutty reality TV mess," but their clear lack of class and general stink of desperation makes their efforts completely transparent. I find it in poor taste that Project Runway, a show which has historically represented both strong women and gay men in a positive manner, would book these two as guest judges. Sadly, it is yet another example of how Project Runway is leaning more towards "reality TV" than towards substance.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '14
Kate irritates the shit out of me, but her dress fit the challenge best. And Alexandria's looks like a construction site accident.
6
u/blogginglife Nov 08 '14
I find it ridiculous that Alexandria went home. This is Kate's third season and she's now been in the bottom 2/2 times. She's received the same critique every season and she's not listening. Why are they giving her third and fourth and fifth chances while some designers haven't received second chances?
Same with Michelle...She's a winner, she has to be held to a higher standard. She's been in the bottom 2/2 times as well. I'm sure she'll step it up, but I wish they could have gotten her out now because I find her so annoying.
3
u/BatenicYork Nov 09 '14
The Snooki and JWoww thing was super annoying. Although knowing the television industry, it was probably an idea from an executive who never watches the show and just thought it would be good ratings.
I also thought a lot of the dresses that ended up safe were really nice, I liked Helen and Gunnar's a lot.
10
u/Spinfo Nov 09 '14
I am so annoyed with the sexist gender roles this season has going on. First the first challenge, putting them in groups according to their gender, then this episode, make FEMININE clothing out of MANLY stuff, look at this construction site, who would think a woman could walk around here, PUH-LEASE, construction sites are only for manly men, look at these two manly men in their construction clothing (ps. you are allowed to undress them). This is bad, this isn't feminine. This is good, every woman would love to look like a fairy princess, while they avoid every construction site on the planet.
WTF Project Runway.
2
u/PinkPirate27 Nov 10 '14
Snooki and JWoww?!?!
-2
u/blogginglife Nov 08 '14
I did not like Justin's look...I like him, of course, but I didn't get the appeal of that dress. It made his skinny model look huge, and there was no innovation whatsoever. The work it took to create is impressive, but I just didn't like how it looked. It was a strapless dress...