r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Nov 14 '14
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 3 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E03 "Something Wicked This Way Comes"
The designers have access to Broadway's "Wicked" to fashion couture-inspired styles. Guest judges: Ariel Winter ("Modern Family") and Betsey Johnson.
14
Upvotes
58
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '14
That sequin dress did not deserve to be in the top... It was so incredibly unfinished and if this was on Project Runway it would've been slated.
45
u/yatcho Nov 14 '14
Chris seemed so over it by the end of the episode.
28
u/BatenicYork Nov 14 '14
The thing that pissed me off, besides disagreeing on almost every winner/loser decision, was that they said Fabio didn't meet the challenge. Fabio presented something that he saw as a gown. It was an interpretation. That's what artists do. They present their own interpretation. And it's not like he made a men's suit and said "this is a gown," there were plenty of similarities to a standard gown. So it's not like it was even that far out of the box. I mean, do they want the designers to bring their own unique voices to the work they're doing, or just make slightly fancier versions of stuff that's already in stores?
Now whether you like the dress itself or not is a whole different story, (personally I like it a lot, but I can see why people might hate it) but don't say he didn't do the challenge.
And holy crap that doily dress.
27
u/konfetkak Nov 14 '14
Today Alyssa is wearing my mother's antique lace tablecloth.
27
u/konfetkak Nov 14 '14
All these "couture" gowns seem so boring. The dress that Chris March and Christian Siriano did in their season STILL sticks out in my mind, but these just seem so...blaaaaaaah
24
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '14
Nooo, Chris :'(
I wanted to hear that glorious laugh before he left.
21
u/Empress929 Nov 14 '14
Does Alyssa Milano's stylist get high on paint thinner before she styles her? Terrible!
39
u/konfetkak Nov 14 '14
Dmitry reminds me of Gru from Despicable Me.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '14
Aww....He just wasn't into it this time. Kinda seemed depressed.
33
u/shelbeebuzz Nov 14 '14
Kate makes me roll my eyes, every episode, without fail.
Also, I just want Justin to will all the challenges. (But maybe I'm biased as a North Carolinian lol)
16
u/fragilehearted Nov 14 '14
I really liked Chris's, except his choice of fabric for the shredded part. It did look cheap. I just hated to see him go, since I enjoy him so much. I'd rather see more of his designs than Helen's or Fabio's.
I liked Dmitry's, except that I feel like he coasted a bit. Sam's looked a bit messy, so I guess I'm ok with the choice for the win. Overall, I was a bit underwhelmed, but it's hard to do couture in 2 days.
13
u/konfetkak Nov 14 '14
wtf is zanna wearing? ARE THOSE SHOULDER PADS?
12
u/agorby00 Nov 14 '14
Every season I say I'm done with this show, but I keep coming back.
I wouldn't be so disheartened, but I see designs I think the judges are gonna gush over, or something I know they'll all verbally tear to shreds... And I'm dead wrong every time. The winning look for this week, I swore that Isaac was going to call it a cocktail dress with aspirations.
11
u/meldolphin Nov 14 '14
Alyssa, what are you wearing why are you doing this...
I don't get why everyone fixates on gowns so much. I didn't love the front of Fabio's but I liked the pants. Couture doesn't necessarily have to mean dresses. Chris' dress reminded me of those clubbing outfits that have slits all down the side. The guest judge was spot on calling it Hot Topic.
25
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '14
OH GOD.....I would not want to see Alyssa in that dress in that bubble! You could see the baby crowning!!
17
u/gofurthernorth Nov 14 '14
I.... kind of like Fabio's the best.
8
u/pajamasinbananas Nov 15 '14
I'm sorry I'm a jerk but what is with Alyssa's laugh
7
u/234and1 Nov 14 '14
Fabio seems less sure of himself this season than previous seasons but idk if he's just trying to be more humble. Michelle and Dmitri could take a leaf out of his book. Chris March and Sanjay are likeable as ever, and I love kate even though I would like her to make something new and exciting. also predict they're keeping her around so at least someone knows how to do bridal in the foreshadowed bridal challenge!
7
u/blogginglife Nov 16 '14
This was the first episode of Project Runway EVER that I wanted to stop watching (Lord knows I won't). I just don't get it...I mean do the judges have no style (well, actually, 2/4 of them don't)?
Fabio was clear winner to me. Beautiful, loved the juxtaposition of the soft front and the hard, BDSM-y back. And the only thing that was different. I mean how boring were all those floor-length, glittery gowns? I guess Sonji tried to make something a little different, but that type of skirt is so hideous to me (people have been trying to make it in for ages. Austin, Season 1, anyone?).
Chris's elimination is also ridiculous. His was far from the worst, plus most of the time designers who were super talented in their seasons aren't eliminated their first time in the Bottom 2. Kate's look, again, was the worst to me. Seeing her continue to float by on her third time on the show is so annoying. I think the past two eliminations have been stupid, and there are far worse designers (Benjamin, Michelle, Kate, Jay, Helen, Gunnar) left.
29
u/EmptyStar12 Nov 14 '14 edited Nov 14 '14
Wicked? Betsey Johnson as guest judge?
How could this possibly go wrong?!I'll report back in an hour because it obviously will...
Edit: Well they did it. They managed to screw it up somehow. I dunno, the runway just felt like such a letdown. I think this would've been better suited to another avant garde/ unconventional challenge were they designed a costume for one of the extras or something. This just seemed so devoid of fun. Even worse, it was devoid of sequins. =(
"This isn't a gown, but it's my interpretation of a gown". Shut up Fabio. At first I wanted Helen's weird brocade luffa dress to be out, but after seeing the back of Fabio's dress that needed to go. That girl from modern family was right. It was an apron. He has a clear POV, but he let that get in the way of the challenge tonight. It really wasn't couture.
Chris getting sent home was the killing blow to this episode of suck. I really don't wanna watch this series anymore...
12
u/imaginesomethinwitty Nov 15 '14
This judging was ridiculous! Isaac and Betsy Johnson, the two actual designers say this is good. A teenager, who apparently has no taste and Alyssa who we know has no taste say oh I disagree.
The three bottom looks were not worse than Jay's pregnancy pant ruffle monstrosity (safe) or Samantha's top look! "Raw" my ass, that was rough. Even Michelle and Gunnar's boring dresses deserved to be down there before Helen and Fabio (and I'm not a big fan of either).
When I'm thinking Snooki and JWow should come back as judges, it's time to take a look at yourselves, Lifetime.
6
u/bitchSpray Nov 14 '14
Another episode over... And I still feel completely indifferent. Dresses walking down the runway, people leaving, I still don't care.
Three episodes and still not a single dress that would get me excited. Everything is either strange or just okay. Nothing new, nothing daring.
I'm still keeping all my fucks and not giving any.
The only moments I feel anything is when I see what Alyssa's wearing. I'm always like, "Oh honeyyy...". Like that time on this episode when she just put on some leisure leggings, wrapped a felt rectancle around her torso with a belt, washed her hair and quickly dried it with a towel, and hopped on the runway. But that's just a comment on her (?) fashion choices, she's probably a nice person (guessing from her AMA).
17
u/gofurthernorth Nov 14 '14
Is Alyssa having quadruplets?
2
u/yogaliscious Nov 17 '22
How can they have sent Chris home???
3
u/yumslurpee Nov 15 '14
I wasn't with the judges at all in this episode, I feel like I'm taking crazy pills. I didn't like the top dresses (or at the very least thought they were not avant garde) and although I didn't love Chris's look, at least he was trying to do something! Uggh
1
u/Stunning-Tea5759 May 29 '26
No-o-o-o! My dear Chris! Your look was NOT the worst by far (Helen, I'm talking about you), but something was definitely lacking in his demeanor this season. Where was his booming laugh? He seemed depressed.
My favorites:
Dimitri - his gown looked like the night sky come alive.
Fabio - couture, shmouture. It was fabulouse and exciting.
Sonjia - I liked it a lot, but I didn't love it.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14
Can we talk about the phallus on Helen's gown?
Am I the only one that saw it?