r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Jan 09 '15
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 8 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E08 "Making a Splash"
The designers create elegant resort wear with swimsuits. Before that, they plunge into a major challenge when they must collect their fabric from under the water. Fashion figure Nigel Barker is the guest judge.
19
Upvotes
24
u/juluj Jan 09 '15 edited Jan 09 '15
Weird challenge. I loved Michelle's suit but hated the dress. Thought Fabio should have been in the bottom
24
u/pineyfusion Jan 09 '15
I feel like there's some sort of inside joke with the contestants where they're trying to out-mediocre each other to see just how far they could get.
20
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Jan 10 '15
Sexy, noted, fashion photographer--Nigel Barker!
19
u/Dantesfireplace Jan 10 '15
Okay... What was up with Zanna and Issac's outfits? Issac looks like my dad, and Zanna's combo is reminiscent of Claudia from the Babysitters Club.
Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't they accuse Justin of making an outfit that could be purchased at Banana Republic? I know this is meant as an insult to his creativity, but Justin mentions that they said his outfit could be purchased from a cheap retail store. Please don't tell me that Banana Republic is considered cheap... because it's too expensive for me. :P
15
u/Earth_Intruders Jan 09 '15
I dont get why michelle was on the bottom if they kept saying her swimsuit was one of the best ones I laughed when Sam said "sorry" though...
10
u/shoensandal Jan 09 '15
I actually LOVE Alyssa Milano's runway dress this week. I am shocked..
9
u/LakeMaldemere Jan 09 '15
I loved both of Justin's looks. I liked Dimitri's and Michele's swimsuits but hated both of their dresses. I loved Sanje's swimsuit and pants - hated the top. Loved Jay's dress but didn't like swim suit. Didn't care for either of Sam's looks.
9
u/mmcleod24 Jan 10 '15
When they called Fabio and Helen's names, I thought they were just going to send them both home without a critique. Both of their looks were so boring and uninspired. Incredibly shocked that neither were actually in the bottom.
I feel like Sam saw Nicki Minaj's "Anaconda" music video and thought that somehow that swimsuit style was back in. I didn't think it was completely terrible, it just wasn't right for that model at all. Really shocked she went home over Jay as well.
8
u/IronBearicade Jan 09 '15
In addition to low budgets for shopping, and short time frames, let's add a change in the models on top of that?
How does that really help the designers show off their construction and creativity?
32
u/PoeGhost Jan 09 '15
Unnecessary, gratuitous swimming models. I would have rather seen the designers have to dive for their own fabrics.
5
u/Spinfo Jan 09 '15
I was really surprised that the designers was so uncreative with their bathing suits. Dmitri, Michelle, Sonjia and Justin really did something great and unexpected, but the rest was so bland! Jay's, Fabio's and Helen's couldn't have been any plainer!
5
u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Jan 12 '15
It's like they're picking episode ideas from Whose Line's 'scenes from a hat' hat. This week: fabric swatches pulled from the bottom of a pool by nearly naked men while designers hoot and holler. Next week: Sketch in a shark tank!
4
u/Holly_Tyler Jan 09 '15
It's up to episode 8? Sweet, I have like 4 episodes to catch up on. Guess I know what I'm doing this weekend!
4
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 09 '15
I feel asleep before it ended, who won and who went home?
3
u/mualphatautau Jan 11 '15
Nigel judges in the same voice as ANTM (and everything else he does). So cheesy, based on one-liners, I love it.
3
u/konfetkak Jan 11 '15
The only I could think of every time Jay brought up Ibiza
4
u/aelizabeth0623 Jan 10 '15
i have the top sonjia wears in her talking heads, and i love that it's from target. work that target brand, gurl.
10
u/Spinfo Jan 09 '15 edited Jan 09 '15
Those half-naked men in the beginning were really unnecessary. What's up with PR these days? I don't know if it's because I'm from Europe and stuff like that is quite frowned upon where I live, but making groups according to gender, creating feminine clothing out of manly construction site stuff (ps. undress the manly construction workers if you like, contestants) and ordering around pool boys in speedos is pretty sexist and inappropriate.