r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Jan 16 '15
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 9 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E09 "Sketching With Sharks"
The designers must use marine life as inspiration for avant-garde fashion. One designer doubles the budget by swimming with sharks. Guest Judge: Nicole Scherzinger
19
Upvotes
25
u/RobotDevil80 Jan 16 '15
If I were a designer on this show, I'd ask to refuse Zanna's help. She's like the opposite of Tim Gunn.
49
u/FalseGoddess Jan 16 '15
As an avant-garde challenge this was pretty disappointing overall. Dmitry's recycled look was boring. Fabio's look was "Pretty in Pink" if a guy had the lead role.
I felt so bad watching Justin stress out over the challenge. It was really sweet when Helen gave him the extra fabric. I just wanted to hug both of them.
24
u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Jan 18 '15
Best Dimitry quote of the episode: "I'm inspired by the sea-whores."
44
u/pineyfusion Jan 16 '15
Sonjia's dress was the best and it just gets a "you're safe" result?! Seriously!? That should've been the winner. Helen's, IMO, was the worst. It didn't really scream shark to me at all. She should've went with something sleeker looking.
I love Fabio, but man that was awful. Dude needs to shape up and fast. Kind of bummed about Justin leaving but it made sense.
Dmitri made a pretty dress but it wasn't avant garde in the slightest.
37
u/meldolphin Jan 16 '15
Did Dmitry seriously win for an outfit that looked nearly identical to several others he's been praised for in the past, on an avant garde challenge? Really now? I don't think any of them looked super fashion forward bar maybe Michelle's. I kind of loved the weird sideways lips she put on her model. It didn't make a lick of sense and would have been more fitting if her fish was a flounder but something about it was super whimsical.
Speaking of those lips, there was some seriously misleading editing in the previews. I was preparing for a Helen smackdown but they were just being tricky.
And finally, nail art! I wish they'd incorporate that more often into their designs.
35
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Jan 16 '15
Man, Zanna was so rude to Dmitry D:. Or maybe I'm just biased because I hated her pants.
22
u/TheNobullman Jan 16 '15
Maybe PRAS' first two seasons have made me cynical to the show itself but is anyone else getting a feeling that this season is soooooooo slanted in favor of Fabio? He's gotten praised or spared for some reeeeeeeally underwhelming looks.
20
u/gofurthernorth Jan 16 '15
Dmitry was in a good mood today.
Helens dress was the worst.
Michelle showing concern towards Justin almost made me like her.
Alyssa's hair and make-up continue to look like I was in charge of her appearance.
14
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 16 '15
Wow, some of those dresses were butt ugly.
14
u/no_shant Jan 16 '15
This must be one of the most boring and disappointing seasons. Dmitry, I love you. But why do the same thing you've done multiple times in the past? Hell, he even stuck light eyebrows on his model - something that he did in his finale show on his season. Yeah, it was a beautiful piece, but it was hardly avantgarde. The win should have gone to Michelle, in my opinion. I also quite liked Jay's, I didn't expect the judges to hate it as much.
5
u/septemus Jan 18 '15
I'm gonna miss Justin. Honestly he was probably the biggest reason as to why I've kept watching this train-wreck of a season.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '15
I liked Alyssa's aquarium outfit. I thought it was pretty :)