r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Jan 22 '15
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 10 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E10 "Versatile Tops and Bottoms"
New York City's Times Square is the backdrop when the designers learn about the business of fashion and style combinations. Guest Judges: Lisa Robertson & George Kotsiopoulos
15
Upvotes
45
u/ecokitty Jan 23 '15
oh look, Helen made a cape
43
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '15
Can we just appreciate the title of the episode for one second.
32
u/EmptyStar12 Jan 23 '15
"But is it QVC enough...?"
Do you really WANT it to be?
24
u/flowerpencup Jan 23 '15
when they all 'rang the bell' together. what a fail LOL
23
u/binnyzhan Jan 23 '15
Was it just me or did this episode seem way more catty than usual with the contestants critiquing the other people's stuff?
21
u/Spinfo Jan 24 '15
"Look at the time! I need to go ring the bell"
Honey, that requires wearing a watch.
17
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Jan 24 '15
SO late on this but Zanna's critiques are utterly useless. She just gives warnings about what the designers shouldn't do ("don't go Morticia on me;" "this doesn't look like the sketch;" "no butt cheeks on the runway!") So it's either a terrible edit and the producers remove her advice/feedback, or her feedback is just terrible. She couldn't talk less about the designs or technique if she tried.
16
u/meldolphin Jan 23 '15
Jay has never worked with red before? Whatever you say man... I'm really disappointed he went home. His RTW look was modern and unlike a lot of those other whackadoo pieces up there, could actually be worn by a woman in every day life. I loved Fabio his season and thought he should have won then, but the stuff he's making now is just so bad. I think what annoyed me the most was how he was kind of on the right track. I liked that print he made. I liked the leather. I liked that he made a skort because I'm super unladylike and hate having to keep my legs from sprawling out when I wear a skirt. And then he went and made those two lousy outfits.
QVC lady doesn't like prints? Jesus what is wrong with you. What an oddly close-minded way to approach fashion.
EDIT: Also who on earth wears neoprene on a day to day basis, much less in a long sleeve crop top form with lace on it. I'm getting tired of this neoprene business.
25
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Jan 23 '15
I'm glad Fabio finally got called out for how his designs are out of step with where fashion is right now. My jaw dropped when Isaac called his outfit irrelevant to fashion, but I totally agree.
12
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 24 '15
I miss Michael Kors.
27
u/queerblackgirl Jan 23 '15
Both of Michelle's pieces were ugly as shit. It kinda made me angry.
9
u/pbrooks19 Jan 23 '15
I just don't like any of these pieces today - so much so I'm questioning my bitchiness about them. The only one who did anything for a QVC audience was Sonjie, and I thought it was a bit too frou-frou. :P
5
u/the_cucumber Jan 23 '15
That QVC lady has been chewed up by valentine's day