r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Feb 05 '15
Project Runway All Stars Season 4 Episode 12 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S04E12 "Some Like It Hot Dog"
Red-carpet gowns are fashioned as inspired by the beauty of Marilyn Monroe. Also: A Hollywood legend visits the workroom.
20
Upvotes
56
u/leokat Feb 06 '15
"I'm allergic to dogs...but I'm more allergic to losing." I love Dimitry!
48
u/freelantzer Feb 06 '15
That was the most predictable outcome; the judges haven't really liked anything Michelle has made all season, but they've raved over Helen and Sonji's repetitive designs. I can't believe no one even mentioned the fact that Sonji has made that exact skirt multiple times this season.
And WTF was the point of that Lassie challenge? Let's give them only one day to create a red carpet look, but let's also just waste their time on a pointless exercise to get more promotional dollars. Lifetime has taken a good show and run it into the ground. It's one big advertisement now, with designers raving about the accessory wall and what an AMAZING opportunity it is to design for dogs! There's always been an element of that, but now it's so heavy handed. The designs seem secondary to the network, and that's a shame because that's why we watch.
33
u/meldolphin Feb 06 '15
Ugh Michelle only went out on a technicality. I get that rules are rules but her dress was clearly better than Helen's. I think it might have been my favorite of the night actually. Then in that final challenge her look was interesting and unique while Helen just made another boring schoolgirl dress. Regardless, it should have been Sonjia in the bottom two. When I think timeless, I do not think midriff with a mini skirt under lace. Both of those are very on trend but it is just that: on trend. These things come and go.
30
u/lilyew Feb 06 '15
28
u/Sudenveri Feb 06 '15
THE FRINGE IS BACK.
53
u/whyowhyoholic Feb 06 '15
Michelle's dress was a thousand times better than Helen's.
20
u/KansasCity12 Feb 06 '15
The wedding scene and now the dog scene.... They were painful and pointless, respectively.
19
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Feb 06 '15
Wtf was the point of the dog-costume challenge. That was just embarrassing.
19
u/starkey2 Feb 06 '15
Michelle did my favorite finale collection. I loved that Lone Wolf stuff. The sweaters, the coats, the dress.... definitely memorable. I'm disappointed that she is out. I remember Helen's collection being cool but one note.
33
u/leokat Feb 06 '15
"Timeless doesn't mean that you could see it in any decade." Uh, that's exactly what it means Zanna. Also, that neckline is Victorian? Victorian dresses often showed lots of cleavage, so idk what she's talking about. Zanna's advice is worthless!
16
u/aznboi508 Feb 06 '15
How great would it be for Sonjia to win in the finale against two previous winners.
12
u/squonge Feb 07 '15
Can we talk about that airhead playing Marilyn Monroe who called her "one of Hollywood's first screen icons"? An actress whose career began in the 1950s!?
11
u/pineyfusion Feb 06 '15
Wow, somebody REALLY wanted Helen in the finals...
I feel like they really want her to win. Like it was with Anthony Ryan (oh my god was that one so orchestrated) and Mondo (which was pretty much spoiled before the show even aired). Which makes little sense because I don't think anybody really liked Helen.
I think they also had the decision made for them a lot easier by the fact that Michelle only used 2 looks rather than the 3 they asked for.
Sonjia's was a great idea with shoddy execution. Then again, when you have only 1 day to do a challenge which included an intermission with dogs, it's kind of hard to be at your top shape.
Dmitri's was great. Just straight up great.
Michelle's needed something else to go with it. And the chain was kind of tacky. I think with a better chain or something more sparkly, it would've worked better. Oh and if the fabric wasn't so see through at some points.
Helen's...ugh. The color was awful and the design was too simple. At least Michelle's had some ambition to it.
As for the Lassie mini-challenge, what the hell? Did they think that the contestants were stressed out so they brought along dogs? Or was Isaac dangerously close to a deadline so he decided to ask the PR contestants for help/ideas by disguising it as a mini challenge? It really made little sense. That being said, the dogs were kind of cute but man I wish they used larger dogs. Or maybe if they made it a challenge in itself to design for a dogwalker and their dog. Though I feel like they did that in Season 1 or something like that...
7
u/Dantesfireplace Feb 08 '15
Has anyone else noticed that they've shown a lot more of Dmitry's personality in the last two or three episodes? He went from being stoic (still loved him) to pleasant and even silly at times. I wonder if he has changed, or the selection of clips has changed.
7
u/no_shant Feb 08 '15
I am only watching for Dmitry and his snark at this point. I don't love everything he does, and he does recycle ideas, but he is a great designer. This episode's dresses weren't amazing, but I did like all of them besides Helen's. It's so obvious that they wanted her in the finale, it's ridiculous.
Lassie challenge? Wow. I sure do hope this season is the last PR:AS season (haven't they ran out of designers now anyway?)
11
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '15
That "bow". gag
15
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Feb 06 '15
No. Just no. That is some BULLSHIT. Sonjia & Helen should've been bottom two, and I wouldn't care which of them got sent home.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '15
That chain on Michelle's looks suuuuuper tacky.
7
u/TheNobullman Feb 06 '15
Imagine that the All Star season has rigged bullshit
Dmitry just snark this shitshow into oblivion this episode is embarrassing
3
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Feb 06 '15
After watching the episode last night, I occurred to me that Dmitry reminds me of Sheldon from Big Bang Theory.
3
u/legalbeagle05 Feb 06 '15
Wrong choice!!!!
2
u/aznboi508 Feb 06 '15
I didn't mind Michelle's from the front....