r/WritingPrompts • u/TrueKnot • Apr 22 '15
Off Topic [META] Wednesday Writing Workshop
Welcome to the new, weekly Writing Prompts writing workshop! This workshop, part of the new schedule on /r/WritingPrompts, will be held each Wednesday, at 9:00 AM EST. There will be a bit of information about the rest of the schedule at the end of this post.
The purpose of this workshop is to get more people writing well. We’ll cover a variety of topics, including some of the dos and don’ts, the editing and publishing processes, avoiding tropes and cliches (or intentionally following them) as well as many other topics. This week’s topic is short and sweet: Reasons for Writing, or Knowing your Audience.
Writing has many different purposes. We write to entertain, or to inform. We tell stories or speak to the human condition. We might write a one-page essay, or a 100 thousand word novel. Each piece of writing has its own unique purpose, and is (whether we intend it or not) directed at a very specific target audience.
Exercise
For this week’s exercise, you’ll be writing a timed, unedited short story. You can pick any prompt you like, but from the moment you choose it, you have only 20 minutes to write. Try to wrap the story up within those 20 minutes.
For bonus experience, read a few of the other stories posted here, and try to identify at least 3 features of your target audience. These could be age, gender, location, genre… anything that separates the group you’re writing for from any other group.
I’ll be going through any posts all the way up to next week, offering feedback, answering questions, and trying to identify the target audience for each story.
What is a Target Audience
I frequently see people complain that their writing, raved about in one place, is criticized in another. The reason is often that the piece spoke more strongly to one audience.
/r/WritingPrompts is a great example of this. The purpose of this sub is simple: Get people writing. Because the purpose is simple, this sub is more lenient regarding spelling mistakes, grammatical errors, and so on. And because the story supply moves so quickly, we see a lot of “trends”, which rapidly become cliche. And that’s okay. There are times and audiences for whom this is acceptable. It’s okay to cliche. This audience loves a cliche. We love your powerful conclusions, your twist endings that we see coming a mile away. We love your sardonic heroes and your grandfather paradoxes.
Other sites and subs (and definitely publishers) may be less open.
This audience loves a quick punch, a reply that lets us post “feels” gifs and memes. We love the shortest of stories, and most of all, we love stories we can read right now.
This is why a 5000 word, finely-crafted masterpiece which takes two days to craft properly might get less attention here than two paragraphs dashed off within ten minutes of the prompt hitting “new”. Those quick stories, even when riddled with errors, are written with this audience in mind.
That’s not to say that your finely crafted novella won’t succeed here, but it will find a smaller market, which means it will require more work to succeed.
The subreddit or site you submit to is part of your target audience. Whether you’re looking to publish or not, you have other target markets, based on genre, age, gender, or culture.
Writing for your audience
When writing you have two very basic options. You can write for your audience, or you can write for yourself. Writing for yourself, we’ll address in a moment. Writing for your audience is a bit more complicated.
Things that will leave one audience drooling will often turn another audience off. /r/nosleep loves creepy stories where the narrator involves the audience. Subscribers to /r/DarkTales are also horror fans but they tend to prefer darker stories, and with much less audience involvement.
Persons who purchase a novel, or even a book of short stories are hoping for a longer, more engaging read than those who search for short stories on a website. It’s important to connect with your audience--more important than any “hook” or first line, more important than a powerful ending--and you do this by finding ways to make your writing resonate with them.
If you want to make a connection with your readers--your target audience--you first need to know who they are. Usually, (at least on this sub) we begin with an idea. “Hitler invades Hogwarts,” for example. At some point during the writing process, it can become beneficial to think about what sort of audience wants to read a story like this.
Because the “Potterverse” is followed, primarily, by the Middle Grade and YA audiences, this is the group that would likely be most interested in your story as well.
How can this help you, as a writer? Well first of all, even though Hitler is also in the prompt, a middle grade/YA audience would probably not catch on to obscure references to minor events of the 1940s. If we were writing to 70 year old veterans, it would be a different story.
Different audiences are looking for different things. It's important to know who you're writing for, and what they want and expect. If you don't want to write for someone else, write for yourself!
Writing for yourself
Of course sometimes we write, not to please anyone else, but simply for ourselves. When writing for yourself there are no real restrictions other than those you place on yourself. There is still, however, a purpose for the writing, and it can be beneficial to know what the purpose is. For example, you might write to relieve stress, or to brainstorm a new idea.
Knowing why you are writing, and who you are writing for gives direction to the writing. It also helps to organize your thoughts, and gives a starting point for self-editing, later.
New Writing Prompts weekly schedule:
Next week, we’ll be touching on writing basics with /u/lexilogical. Until then, the mods of /r/writingprompts have a new weekly line-up for you. Hope to see you all there.
SUNDAY: Sunday Free Write (all day) - The Free Write will allow you to share any piece of writing you’ve been working on, even if it’s not prompt-inspired!
MONDAY: Writing Prompts Showcase brought to you by /u/Pmomma and /u/Nate_Parker (all day) - Nate_Parker will be featuring one writer each week, and Pmomma has a line up of prompts and stories enjoyed by our moderators, which you may have missed.
TUESDAY: [CC] and [PI] posts - Tuesdays, we’ll be looking for your CC and PI posts which might not have gotten much attention.
WEDNESDAY: WritingPrompts Workshop with /u/Trueknot (9:00 AM EST, accepting assignments and questions throughout the week.) - The workshop will cover a wide variety of topics designed to help you become a better writer. The posts will be helpful on their own, but the workshop is most beneficial if you do the exercises and interact with each other!
THURSDAY: Thursday Theme Day, beginning April 30, 2015 - Each Thursday a new Theme will be posted in the side bar. Themed prompts will be randomly stickied and possibly gilded! Stay tuned. ;)
FRIDAY: Ask Lexi (writing advice Q&A) - /u/Lexilogical will be posting answers and advice based on frequently asked questions from the /r/writingprompts chatroom! If you have questions that aren’t answered, feel free to post in the comments. If your question isn’t answered right away, maybe it will be featured in another column.
SATURDAY: Question of the week/Meet and greet with /u/SamtheSnowman - Sam’s looking to foster a sense of community, and bonding in the community. Each week, he’ll be asking a writing-related question. Drop in and share your opinions. Meet your fellow writers and talk with your peers!
We hope you'll join us as we bring these new features to life. If you notice any issues or have suggestions please feel free to post that here as well!
7
u/Insert_delete Apr 22 '15 edited Apr 22 '15
Hi /u/Trueknot, thanks for organizing this, I wrote the following reply in 20 minutes (timed) and the prompt was [WP] You have never lied or mislead anyone in your entire life. However, everyone you have ever met does not trust you.
Dastardly Honest
Part One
He had never lied to anyone about anything in his life. His earliest memory was of being yelled at for something he hadn't done. He hadn't taken the toy car. He was telling the truth. He always told the truth. He was a good boy.
Part Two
"It's not you, Linus, it's me."
"What did I do? Just tell me what I did."
"I don't want to get into this, goodbye Linus."
She stood up and left the restaurant. He didn't even get a chance to say goodbye. the following week, his professor asked him to come in for a meeting where he was lectured on the penalties for academic fraud and officially cautioned.
"I didn't plagiarise my paper." "Look, I know you didn't write this, If you want to turn in something else I'll accept it late but if you insist you wrote this the best I can do is a pass, just don't take any of my classes next semester."
He'd really liked that professor, his classes were interesting and there was always something to do in them.
Part Three
"I understand." "Look, I'd like to give you a shot but the others just don't see it happening." "I've been searching for over a year, I'm a good worker, I've got all the qualifications you asked for in your advert." "Yeah, that's part of it, nobody can have all those qualifications, he'd have to have worked his ass off and frankly, it just doesn't seem possible in the timeframe indicated in your CV." "You saw the certificates, what more proof do you need?" "Yeah, about that, if you can hook me up, we might do something."
He left the office. His lips downcast in a grimace. This was the third place. Why had he hustled all those extra credit hours? Why bother?
He'd pushed it down, pushed it away, but he couldn't keep trying to prove himself. It wasn't working, it was never going to work.
"I am perfectly trustworthy and nobody has ever trusted me in my entire life," he said to the pale blue sky of late spring. "I have always told the truth as I saw it but no one has ever taken my word at face value." He spread his hands in supplication. "I studied, I graduated, is there anywhere for me to go? Is there any job out there for someone like me? Where do I start? Where do I begin?"
Then he had it, finally he'd asked the right question. There was a place for someone who everyone automatically assumed was lying.
The following week he walked into his first audition for a local play. He read the part of the villain.
He walked out with a job.
6 weeks later, the audience held the production over. The theatre had claimed another lost son.
3
u/Anonymouse79 Apr 22 '15
I already posted this here in response to the prompt: You're driving alone on an empty highway when you come across a body. It fits the requirements and I'd love to get some feedback on the (albeit very short) piece.
I was staring straight ahead, my eyes fixated on the double yellow lines ahead of me, willing my eyes to stay open. The rhythmic tick, tick, tick of my turn signal further lulling me to sleep. I rolled down all four of my windows in the hope the fresh air would help me stay awake.The adrenaline from the concert had long since left me, and I found myself wishing I lived closer to the city.
Route 245. So close to home I could taste it. As I rounded the bend, my high-beams caught a reflection something in the shoulder of the road. Something in the back of my mind snapped to attention. Was that a pair of sneakers?
Suddenly my heart was beating quicker than the dubstep I'd been listening to earlier. My palms were sweaty as I spun the car around as quickly as I could and headed back in that general direction. It was like my hands had a mind of their own and my brain had left the building.
As I pulled onto the shoulder, I could definitively see a pair of sneakers poking out into the roadway. And they were absolutely still attached to a body, lying face down in the ditch. I swallowed the rest of my dinner down, and fumbled, hands trembling, to open the door.
The night was so silent, it was stifling. There wasn't even a breeze from the bay, and there certainly weren't any other cars driving by at this time of night. Everyone civilized was ensconced in their air-conditioned houses, snoring away.
Speaking of snoring. . . My brain snapped back to attention. The body was snoring. Definitely snoring.
"Sir?" I yelled. The pile of clothes shuffled, grunted, and sat up.
"Give me a ride home?" he slurred.
3
u/Kaycin writingbynick.com Apr 22 '15
I wrote this for a prompt posted here. I only had about a minute for editing, so sorry if there's a couple of mistakes. These types of prompts are my favorite: very ambiguous. It leave it open for anything, really. You can tell from the responses, a couple (including mine) have to deal with death and the end of things, while another deals with a drunk.
Any, here's my 19 minute story:
Day light breaks through the rearview mirror, behind him he sees the sun begin to break the horizon; still nothing more than a hint of curvature. Already dusk’s pale hue is being flooded with the warm colors of the rising sun. Gold, red and orange floods the landscape, the view alone is enough to warm him, Goosebumps rise on his forearms, standing his hairs on end.
Through the mirror he spies her as well. She lay curled up in a ball, clutching blankets tightly to her chest. She asked him to turn up the heat, but he gave her that horse blanket instead, not telling her why he needed to save fuel. He watched the fuel gauge with resigned distress, carefully guarding his face but knowing in his heart it would run out… and what then?
What worried him most were the inevitable questions. What was he going to tell her, once she woke up? How could he make her understand? Can one make a ten year old understand the end of things? Why?
Why?
He turned the car left, then right. Weaving around the debris in the highway. The car moved to a crawl, the speedometer never going past 15mph. Fuel efficiency. And even if he did want to drive faster than 30mph he’d have to precariously weave amid cars and belongings.
The car jostles as he pulls off onto the grass median separating the northbound and southbound highways. The bumps and jumps wake her in the back seat, he silently curses to himself.
“Good morning, sunshine.”
She rubs her eyes and stretches, as if waking from a deep sleep. For half a moment, she make the world look normal.
“Morning.”
Rowen looks out the window with sleep heavy eyes, blinking away lingering dreams.
“Where are we?
“We’re on the I-5, heading north.”
“Are we going to Grandma’s?”
“And Grandpa’s, yes.”
“Mm” she grunts, still blinking to clear her eyes.
What does he say to her?
He pulls back onto the road and traverses the maze of junk once more. She’s looking out the passenger side window, searching the seemingly endless forest for something to catch her eye.
“Will Grandpa have the pool filled?” She asks, still looking into the treeline.
“I think so.”
“I didn’t bring my swimsuit.”
“I’ll buy you a new one.”
They don’t say anything for a long time. He eyes the needle of the fuel gauge.
Then he sees a heap of something on the side of the road. At first, he thinks it’s a pile of clothing, laying just behind a car. It wasn’t far from the truth. As the car putters forward, he realizes it’s a man. Or was a man. His arms are splayed outward, as if reaching north for something just beyond his reach. He is face down, his legs are twisted at impossible angles and a pool of coagulated mess circles his head like a halo.
His chest constricts, “Did you see the sunrise, love?”
“I’ve seen plenty of sunrises, Dad.”
“Ah,” he says with emphasis, “but not this one. Every dawning day is different. Turn around, take a look.”
He feels his muscles relax when she turns around. She’s not wearing her seatbelt, but at this point he doesn’t think it matters. She’s on her knees, resting her arms on the back seat and her chin on her hands.
“You’re right,” she admits. “This one is nice.”
He presses the peddle lightly, speeding the car past the man.
“Take a picture.”
She holds up her hands to create a rectangle, the presses an imaginary button.
“Click,” she whispers.
“How’d it turn out?”
She looks at the imaginary picture, “Pretty good, want to see?”
“Do I ever.”
She hands him the photo. He regards it with a smile. “Beautiful, how’d you become such a talented photographer?”
“Definitely not from you.”
He feigns exasperation through the rearview mirror, then slowly rises his hand, mimicking a pincer.
“No!” She cries with a smile and a giggle, shifting up the seat, “I was just kidding!”
He reaches back, “THE CLAW DEMANDS A SACRIFICE!” He’s had a decade to perfect a monster voice.
His claw gets a hold of her leg and squeezes mercilessly. She shouts and laughs, the car is filled with their joined laughter. He cackles maniacally as any good monster would.
“THE CLAW HAS BEEN SATED.”
She’s breaths heavy, still grinning. "I still think you're a bad photographer."
He makes his eyes wide once more and resumes the tickle attack.
For half a moment—a split second, for a blip in the span of eternity— the world feels normal. There is nothing but the two of them: a loving father and his only daughter, driving north on a highway to anywhere but here, laughing as they would any day before this day. As if the world hadn't turned.
He doesn’t know what they’re going to eat after a few days, he doesn’t know where they’ll sleep or if they’ll be in danger, but that’s not what worries him.
He dreads the inevitable “why?” How can he protect her from knowing?
3
u/nazna Apr 22 '15
"Peter," the girl whispers.
She is any girl. She is all girls. Wheat blonde hair and brilliant blue eyes. She has come to the tent carrying an offering.
Aniya wonders if it is enough. Gold, she has no use for. Relics can be handy. Payment must be made in more than just things.
There are only so many names she can carve on her skin. The thin pale canvas is not limitless nor is it easy to cut and bleed for each sin.
The lower half of her face is covered in a purple scarf. It doesn't hide any names. She hasn't had to do that yet.
"What do you offer?" Aniya asks.
The girl offers the gold. Aniya shakes her head. She offers the sharp tooth of a massive animal. Something born before the seas dried out. Aniya shakes her head. The beads at the ends of her braids knock against each another.
The girl takes a breath. She holds out her last offering. Her hand is empty.
"This Peter, he must have done something very wicked indeed," Aniya murmurs to herself.
She could take the whole hand. Sacrifice brought such delicious power. Enough to remove two names at least. Two memories of blood and horror.
The girl does not cry or beg. Her hand is steady as she holds it up.
She is wearing a cheap dress. A farm girl's dress. The hand she holds up is already callused from hard work. Her eyes are hard as blue stone.
"I shall take two fingers," Aniya decides. Two is generous. Perhaps too generous. But Aniya likes that the girl's hand does not shake. The girl is young enough not to miss those fingers too much and the sacrifice might be enough for part of one name. It is enough.
Aniya brings out the stone tablet. There are more than three dozen runes etched on the surface. Aniya knows only how to speak two of them.
"Come," she says.
The girl puts her hand on the tablet. Aniya takes out the curved knife, sharp and gleaming.
"Are you sure?" she asks.
The girl thins her mouth. She nods.
Aniya cuts the two first fingers in one swift blow. The girl gasps but makes no other sound. Blood gushes from the wounds, falling into the runes. They glow blue for a brief moment.
Though there is blood left on the girl's hand the fingers are gone. The wounds are healed.
Part of Houk is gone from Aniya's shoulder. Good. He'd beaten his wife in front of his son. Beaten her so her face was nothing but pulp. Aniya would dream less of him now.
She takes out a different knife for the next part. Small and thin. Sharply pointed. The hilt is made of ebony and warms in her hand.
Aniya pulls up her skirt, exposing soft brown skin. From her ankles to her thighs are ugly pink scars. Names of men. Names of women. One especially deep scar is the name of a town that no longer exists.
"Peter?" Aniya asks.
The girl nods.
"Think on him. Think on Peter and what he deserves. What he has done."
The girl closes her eyes.
Aniya carves the name onto her upper thigh. She bites her lower lip as images fill her mind.
A man in shadows. A man throwing a torch onto a house, taking a screaming girl away while her parents scream. Chaining her to his home. Chaining her to his bed. Peter.
Once the black clears, Aniya opens her eyes.
"He will suffer. Fire and pain and sorrow such as no man has suffered."
"Good," the girl says. She looks down at her missing fingers.
"It was worth it."
3
u/VapingWriter Apr 22 '15
TL;DR: Trying to write a story for an hour before deciding to write a poem in 15 minutes.
IDK if this counts. Full story:
Saw that post a few weeks back about how writing time travel and demon prompts was bad for WP reddit. (“WP: You are the devil and want to ruin WP by posting nothing but time travel and demon prompts.” or something like that.) Fucked with my writing chi on a lot of the prompts.
Trying to do the assignment. Looking at the rising prompts (for max internet point potential of course). Couple on AI sentience kinda grab me. Think about them for about three minutes a piece and decide that a comment on the nature of sentience is not something I’d figure out in the next five so I can pound the keyboard for ten and edit/post for two.
Space tourism was too fifties retro-future for my need for realism. Didn’t want to do the revenge stolen WP, also couldn’t make it realistic and interesting, IRL=boring lawsuit. Couldn’t get around that. Severed leg and body on the side of the road just didn’t speak to me too much.
Saw the wish one and thought about it for a bit. Considered a legal drama, drown them in paperwork kinda thing. Decided Celestial wish courts would probably not be susceptible to that kind of thing. Idea of wishing that all women were attractive occurred here in the three to five minutes considering this.
Clicking around more. Maybe an hour trying to pre-prep some ideas that I could throw into a WP and clicking WP to see if something just comes flying out. Nothing.
12:56ish Occurs to me that poems are an option. I always thought I’d do a limerick if I ever did poems. They express my comedic side more easily than a story. I felt a light treatment of these topics was appropriate and limerick helped me put aside concerns about painting realistically detailed narratives. 12:57 check time. Decide on the wish prompt I had thought about before. And the last word in the poem. Reverse engineered it from there:
[WP] You are a wish-lawyer, and your job is to help clients phrase their wishes to prevent unexpected consequences when a genie grants them. One day you forget to include something in a client's wish. What happens?
A frustrated young man sent a note
Requesting one wish that I wrote
Unfortunately, he loved a goat
3
u/desireewhitehall Apr 22 '15
NSFW Response to the equally-NSFW prompt regarding sexual favors as currency.
Took roughly twenty minutes. Give or take a half-minute or so as I lack a credible timer.
Hard to pull off on a Kindle. I hate onscreen keyboards...
1
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15 edited Apr 23 '15
It does me good to remain optimistic in this world. In hindsight I should have followed my fellow gods example, create a world that pleases me. Yet I had to rebel, be unique. So I drew a portrait of a flawed world, and a flawed world I created.
Everywhere I go, everywhere I see, there is something hidden, buried. Outwardly they express their lies in an attempt to forge their image towards other wounded who cower behind their unseen masks; it makes my stomach knot and I cover my mouth to stop my gag.
Am I capable of such a thing, have bile force its way up my throat, and out my mouth with a gut wrenching heave? Perhaps, but I will have to force something down first. That would be an impressive feat for me, for a god who created this wretched place.
See that knight clopping over the hill with his tired mount? His entire company is wiped out by the brigands, yet on he trots, standing upright and tall as the people in the village hail him for ending the endless raids plaguing them.
I mourn the wasted life, more so for those who survive such travesty; their candles go out, yet they continue to melt in the unforgiving world, decaying into nothing.
The world starts to blur and I tremble. The screams of those being rattled and washed away snaps me out of my sorrowful daze.
Gone, because of my misery, they are gone... Bring them back, they did not deserve such a terrible demise!
Please...
Yet no matter how much I plead, this flawed world refuses to obey. There is no choice but to coap with this meager existence.
And so I smile, trying wear my mask as proudly as they.
1
u/narrpip May 21 '15
This seems pretty cool, I'll be coming back each week for sure! This took just under 20 minutes to write and the prompt was a photo of a guy in the back of a coffee shop.
He sat in the corner of the coffee shop, his face ghostly white from the early morning light of the window. How long had he been there exactly? Cassie had only just started her shift but if she had been there a few hours ago she would have seen his bright eyes and warm smile as he ordered a cappuccino and double checking the opening times.
As she pulled on her apron and took over the counter as Brice waving goodbye with a sleepy smile. Poor guy, Cassie was glad she didn't have his shift. The shop was empty, which wasn't unusual at this time on a Tuesday. The tables were all clean, the floors had been mopped and the machines after a night of apparently no use were spotless.
It made no sense having this place as a twenty four spot.
With nothing else left to do, she crossed the room to where the guy was sitting. His shirt was creased and dark rings round his eyes revealed his lack of sleep. If he hadn't been so tired, she would have had him down for being twenty, maybe even nineteen. His table was buried beneath scribblings, notes he was still working away on whilst she stood beside him. She cleared her throat to catch his attention.
"Can I get you another drink?" perfect smile and open body language, the art of being a barista. This place was going to help pay for her degree and if she could get a few tips from simply being polite then why the hell not.
"No I..." he seemed to only now notice his coffee had gone cold, a look of disappointment crossing his features "Oh, sure okay"
"Another cappuccino?"
The guy seemed distracted, looking out the window and blinking a few times. He seemed to have been pulled out of a world of his own. Curiosity - or perhaps plain damn nosiness - made Cassie look over what he had been working on. His handwriting was far too messy to understand but there were drawings all over the place. Some looked like nothing more than scribbles and doodles but some of them were a lot more intricate; a pocket watch, someone’s eye and rather grim looking doodle of a snarling dog.
"What's the time?" He asked, and Cassie averted her eyes so she wouldn't look so rude. He turned and looked at her and she now got to properly see his face. His eyes were a warm chestnut and his dark hair looked unwashed. If he had taken better care of himself, she would have called him attractive.
"Err...seven am?"
"Hmm...They’ll be coming soon" the guy leaned back in his chair and stretched backwards. Every muscle in his arms tensed and he ran his fingers through his hair. He grabbed a few notes, throwing them in his pocket before rising from his seat "Scratch that coffee"
Cassie watched him leave the shop, the little bell over the door ringing to declare his exit. His table had been left a mess, a mess which Cassie would have to clean up. Great.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment