r/formula1 • u/willbuxton Will Buxton ✅ • Apr 29 '15
AMA Hi there! Will Buxton, NBCSN F1 Pitlane Reporter, F1 journalist, Dad, music lover, Stanley Kubrick and Beatles nerd. Ask Me ANYTHING! #AMA
As promised, with the first 4 races of the season behind us, thought I'd pop online and open myself up to questioning.
Fire away.
UPDATE: 24 hours on and still the questions are coming in! Thanks so much for taking the time. I've tried to answer as many as possible, but I'm afraid I've got to go and do some proper work! This was fun. Let's do another one in a few race's time, yeah?
1.6k
Upvotes
34
u/baldgye Apr 29 '15
Is Simon Lazenby a real person or just a manikin in a wig?
89
u/Happy-Pills Fernando Alonso Apr 29 '15
Hi Will!
68
u/WiredKiwi Jules Bianchi Apr 29 '15
That Sunday at Suzuka. Avoidable or not? By Jules or the FIA/FOM/Race Control? Thoughts on the outcome of the investigation? Feel free to not answer this if you prefer not to, as I understand this could be hard to express how you feel in this format.
65
u/Luvah Sir Frank Williams Apr 29 '15
If you could change current rules in F1, what would you change first?
20
u/gaslipstick Valtteri Bottas Apr 29 '15
What do you think about Ferraris new team dynamics? From easy to hate to fan favorite. Do you think Ferrari can actuallly catch Mercs this season and really bring it in raw pace?
61
u/atax1a Daniil Kvyat Apr 29 '15
If I gave you a bunch of CVs, would you consider carefully placing them in strange places within team hospitality areas at the next GP?
73
u/macdawg3312 Sir Lewis Hamilton Apr 29 '15
How much filtering do you apply to information you receive up and down the pit lane? Do you find that teams try to provide misinformation to throw other teams? Do you receive information that you cannot report on - ie. Do you ever receive confidential information? Thanks Will! Huge fan!!
47
u/argote Niki Lauda Apr 29 '15
Which recent driver do you think is / was most held back by their team?
Also, which team by their drivers?
46
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Hi Will, what is your opinion of Pastor Maldonado's driving with regards to safety. I read your article on that GP2 driver with a blatant disregard for others' safeties, and it seems at times that Pastor is not far away from committing some mad acts. Do you believe he is a danger to others?
31
u/jackshepard835 Apr 29 '15
Do you think the FIA were biased towards Ferrari in 2008?
42
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Which microphone screen manufacturer makes the best-smelling product?
41
u/RodriguezFaszanatas I was here for the Hulkenpodium Apr 29 '15
Hi Will,
I've always wondered how all the journos get along with each other. Is it more like a big family, or do they hate each other's guts because it's more like a rivalry?
I watch F1 mostly on German RTL, and from time to time they mention their colleague's from different tv networks and they seem to know each other pretty well. Also, did you ever get blinded by Kai Ebel's outifts?
40
u/marvinsuggs Karun Chandhok Apr 29 '15
What does your crystal ball say about how much longer Bernie will be running the circus?
28
u/raud83 Apr 29 '15
25
u/FW37 Williams Apr 29 '15
I've always wondered, which drivers are really different in private to their public/on-camera persona?
43
u/stampmanF1 Benetton Apr 29 '15
So many questions! :/
23
u/mxchris McLaren Apr 29 '15
Hi Will! If you could organize a Grand Prix at any track (assuming any track upgrades needed happened) in the world where would it be?
23
u/techietalk_ticktock Apr 29 '15
Ever hooked up with any of the grid girls?
22
u/fullautophx I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane Apr 29 '15
Hey Will,
I laughed my head off when you made the "...it's not unusual..." comment right after they showed Tom Jones. Was that pre-prepared or did you come up with that off the cuff?
31
u/voxquantum Apr 29 '15
Bux! I'm so glad you're doing this AMA, I've wanted to ask this for a while, but who do you think is your favourite up and coming driver? Someone that we've gotta keep our eye out for from the minor leagues? I know we've got people like Vandoorne knocking on the F1 door, but is there anyone else?
37
u/lessdothisshit Sir Lewis Hamilton Apr 29 '15 edited Apr 29 '15
Hey man! Glad you're so open with Reddit. First, wanted to say that I remember when you replaced Peter Windsor, and how iffy I was to the change (I grew up watching him); but by the very first race your enthusiasm had won me over. Thanks for all the work and insight!
My question: Favorite Beatles album, and why?
E: This made getting up at 5am worthwhile.
20
u/w197 Michael Schumacher Apr 29 '15
Which current non champion will win the championship first?
50
u/dl064 I was here for the Hulkenpodium Apr 29 '15 edited Apr 29 '15
10
u/TravisJLM Sir Lewis Hamilton Apr 29 '15
Someone once told me this: "Actually, due to the spygate in 2007, McLaren HAD to not win the championships as a hidden part of the deal for the light sanction they had (only 100m and disqualified, but could still run to the end). Hence China tyre strategy mistake and Brazil car going to neutral. No choice for them, or Lewis would probably have been champion..."
I'm guessing there is no truth to that, but what would be your reaction that paragraph?
27
u/Julien_F1 Max Verstappen Apr 29 '15
When us viewers see F1 races on TV it's all gliter, glamour and luxury. Everything runs smoothly and everything looks professional. Can you give us an insight which things in the paddock or circuit aren't as professional and glamourous as it looks like from the outside? Thanks in advance
24
u/f10101 Kamui Kobayashi Apr 29 '15
Hi Will!
Just an off topic question, seeing how much of an interest you take in the standard of driving in the lower formulas.
A few of us were discussing about Maldonado's tendencies last week and Monaco came up:
In the 2005 WSR race he drove straight into a marshal, and there were reports he was initially hit with a lifetime ban from racing at Monaco by the ACM, before it was downgraded to a fine. We couldn't verify it though.
Is the initial lifetime ban an urban legend or is there truth to it?
17
u/thephishfromvermont Haas Apr 29 '15
Hello, Will!
Do you think F1(FIA?) should remove restrictions that severely limit the size of the driver? I feel that right now they are to exclusive and we are missing out on a large amount of talent just because someone is a few kilos too heavy.
17
u/davidbla Ayrton Senna Apr 29 '15
Hey Will,
Thanks for doing AMA! You did a brilliant job with the podium interviews in GP2 / GP3 over recent years.
What are your thoughts on the celebrities which are rolled out every other week to do the podium interviews and ask daft questions to people they don't know about a sport they don't understand?
How long will we have to wait to get you up there to ask some properly intelligent questions that the F1 public actually want to hear answers for?
30
u/CausticCorner Apr 29 '15
Who would you nominate to succeed: a) Bernie Ecclestone b) Jean Todt
16
u/SoWhatComesNext I was here for the Hulkenpodium Apr 29 '15
Chiming in super late, but this is something that frustrates me and I want to know what you think.
Is there any way we can stop just adding "gate" to every controversial thing that happens within F1?
Watergate was in 1972. If you were born the year it happened, you would be 43. The average age of the fans on here is 24. So why are we using such an antiquated and stupid cliche reference?
"Tire-gate" could have just been the "tire testing controversy" and any other "gate" incident could have a proper name that we can refer to when we look back at formula 1 history. Hell, they weren't using the stupid "gate" bit in the 70s and 80s were they?
Anyway, that's a big rant. So I'm just wondering how you feel about that.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Big fan of your blog, love that you're doing an AMA :)
Herman Tilke is often criticized for creating tracks that are too flat and boring, what is your favourite Tilke track and what 3 things would you like to say to him when he designs his next track?
13
u/daGonz I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane Apr 29 '15
Hey will! In the pre-race show I always fast forward through everything that isn't your reporting. Thank you for keeping the reporting relevant and insightful. I'm based in Austin, your next drink here is on me.
18
u/Blanchimont Andrea Kimi Antonelli Apr 29 '15
Dear Will, What's your opinion on Bernie's stance towards young fans? I personally think it's better to invest in fans while they're young, and try to keep them hooked for the rest of their lives. They'd probably attract a different kind of sponsor, but at the same time increase the revenue of the expensive brands Bernie likes to associate with F1. After all, some of today's 'poor' youngsters will become those rich adults with money to buy a Rolex Bernie's gunning for. And those who don't become as rich as the Rolex-y type will still buy F1 merchandise or products made by other F1 related brands. It could be as easy as someone filling their car with Shell because they sponsor Ferrari, or someone wearing Puma shoes because they sponsor Mercedes. I think of young fans as long term investments with probably millions of euros/pounds/dollars worth of revenue. Bernie, on the other hand, thinks it's a waste of time to invest in younger fans and keeps aiming at adults who've already acquired the wealth to buy said Rolex or upen up an investment account at UBS bank.
22
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Hey Will, Would you like to be taller? J
12
u/MP4-23 Apr 29 '15
Hi Will The first question pops up is not actually about F1... Estaban Ocon was set to join Dams or at least join GP2. But we all know he ended up in GP3. Is it because Lotus does not have enough financial power to support his GP2 career? Since his deal with ART in GP3 also involves Pirelli. It will be such a sad story to see such a talent like him ended up not in F1 due to money issues. I hope to see him fighting with Verstappan in F1. They are the future.
Jim From Melbourne.
12
u/MrHedgehogMan Jim Clark Apr 29 '15
You suddenly have the power of Bernie and Jean Todt combined. What would you do to make the sport more exciting and reverse declining audiences.
Axe Spa, Monza and Silverstone at your peril!
16
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Senna or Prost?
14
u/3MATX Apr 29 '15
Morning Mr. Buxton,
When you talk to people at McLaren Honda what are their realistic hopes for this season? Do Jenson or Fernando stand a chance of winning a race this season or is this completely a building and research year in a long term plan for both drivers and team?
10
u/kakashi150 Lando Norris Apr 29 '15
Hey, Will! Did you enjoy the first GP2 races? Also, what's your opinion on Max Verstappen after the first four races?
10
u/551usersherenow Apr 29 '15
I recently ran a poll asking users to rate the attractiveness of the current F1 drivers. Although the results have already been published, I'm interested to know which drivers you think are most attractive?
10
u/wizzems Daniel Ricciardo Apr 29 '15
Hi Will!
13
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Did F1 get you into reporting, or did reporting get you into F1?
13
u/linkinstreet I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane Apr 29 '15
Does all the travelling takes a toll on you? And which circuit do you always looking forward to go every year? Do you think F1 would be more popular if it introduces a legal pay stream?
13
u/Perminisconious Sebastian Vettel Apr 29 '15
9
u/RobDeeJay Lando Norris Apr 29 '15
Hi Will! Thanks for doing this!
Of any tracks you have driven around the world, which has been your favourite to drive?
Any track you would love to drive around that you haven't done yet?
9
u/shiny_gengar I was here for the Hulkenpodium Apr 29 '15
What is your favorite foods to get when covering GPs overseas?
9
u/empw Sebastian Vettel Apr 29 '15
Will,
Do you race? Can you talk about your racing style?
12
u/Notpolitburo Mika Häkkinen Apr 29 '15
With Mark Webber's recent comments that F1 needs to become "awesome again" is the racing better now with Mercedes dominating in the current regulations or early 2000's regulations where a Ferrari would dominate?
Which do you prefer? What changes to the Formula would you like to see?
8
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Hi Will, thanks for doing this AMA. I was wondering what your thoughts are on the proliferation of F1 blogs and websites enabling fans to become ''FIA Accredited Journalists''?
8
u/Iceman741 I was here for the Hulkenpodium Apr 29 '15
Hey Will!
4
u/definethegreatline Mika Häkkinen Apr 29 '15 edited Apr 29 '15
Hi Will,
In theory, would F1 really have to 'burn down' and rebuild in order for it to return to a less worrying, chaotic state? Monetary issues aside are many of us whingers seeing F1 through rose-tinted glasses or is the crux that is the racing proving problematic?
Using cigarette sponsorship as an example, when it was banned to be placed on cars the funding dipped. In your view is there any other form of sustainable funding that could replace that hole and potentially help the funding problems that some teams face today?
F1/it's teams are embracing social media slowly, will it open up other avenues of fan engagement as time progresses or will F1 be limited to the elusive sport that everyone wants to know about? Is Bernie/FOM's reluctance to embrace change at a faster rate limited to their knowledge of current media trends or the desire for F1 to remain known as a high roller's sport?
Is there any thing that we the fans/consumers can do in order to help the state of the sport that we love or is this out of our control completely?
On average how many figures does the average journo spend on a season's worth of travel/hotels/etc and what can a young journo/photog expect to spend if freelance or with a wire/publication? This is something I would gladly sell my kidney for and something that I've thought about everyday for four years but I am the type who would really like to get glimpse in order to consider because I know how difficult it is to be in the circus.
How do we make the naysayers see that most grid girls are fans of motorsport and actually want to be doing their jobs?
Are you looking forward to the new Zedd album, and what is your favourite ice cream flavour?
I took a photo with you in Singapore last year, thanks for being awesome to a fan. Have a great season ahead.
4
u/ScuderiaSean Jules Bianchi Apr 30 '15
Hey Will, I know I'm a bit late to the party, as I'm in the U.S. and have been in class and studying all day, but I'll ask a couple questions just in case you check back again... :P
7
u/TommyWTF1 Max Verstappen Apr 29 '15
What is more important to you, F1 being the pinnacle of technology or F1 being the most entertaining form of motorsport?
7
u/theCraigLaw Eddie Irvine Apr 29 '15
Hi Will! I have huge respect for your blog and passion for motorsport.
What would be your advice for someone to get into F1 media, whether that be broadcasting, journalism etc? I'm writing an F1 blog that reviews every race and I've wrote for student newspapers and the like and really see a job like yours as my dream job.
Thanks!
6
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Does the FIA and Jean Todt for that matter have any say at all?
6
u/azisen Ferrari Apr 29 '15
Hey there Will!
What is your favorite dinosaur?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Thanks for the AMA!
How do you keep from laughing when Hobbs goes off on a tangent?
With all the commuting you do what helps pass airport and flight time?
6
u/Rillist Gilles Villeneuve Apr 29 '15
Hey Will, thanks for this mate. As a Canadian it can sometimes be tricky to get context of certain issues and rumors flying around. My 2 questions are as follows;
How bad a shape are Force India actually in? It always seems to be something with VJ. Now the Spirits board wants him gone.
and 2
With these rumored 1000hp engines seemingly in the pipe, how much technical shake-up can we expect? Thanks again for your time!
8
u/luxurytravelled Apr 29 '15
What do you think of the news of Australia moving to April. Good news, or a travelling nightmare if the season is condensed?
3
u/Seand0r Sir Lewis Hamilton Apr 29 '15
Hi Will! Why did you not cater completely to the US audience with this AMA, instead hosting it at 3am PST? =(
3
u/likeAdrug Eddie Irvine Apr 29 '15
Hi Will, Cheers for doing this!
I'm massively late to this so don't really expect a reply. I've seen a few questions about Jean Todt but what's his deal? Is he just taking the money and enjoying the cushy life while not giving a shit about the sport?
The WRC (something he was also involved with for years) hasn't been in a good state for a long time, (although it's getting better, but tv coverage is still shocking) and I haven't seen him do anything about it either. Say what you will about Max Mosley but at least he was an ever present figure.
If we get a new FIA President, can things change, or do the teams just have to much deciding power now and what can change that ? New Concorde agreement ?
PS I'll be in Monaco this year, (Wed - Sun) wheres a good place to catch drivers for a pic ?
3
u/djfil007 Williams Apr 29 '15
Might be too late on this one... but will try anyway.
Any thoughts about the start of Formula E? I've been finding the racing enjoyable overall, even though some of the tracks used are a bit "mickey mouse" and the speeds simply aren't there.
And say 20+ years down the road when the technology is able to produce the speeds, race distances, etc that is found in Formula 1, could that be the end of petrol based racing?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
After the first couple of races in Bahrain, what are your thoughts on the GP2 season so far, your successor in the comms box, and do you miss commentating on it?
3
u/jesterx7769 Nigel Mansell Apr 29 '15
If you were approached to be one of the three new hosts on Top Gear would you do it?
3
u/TheTedKravitz Apr 29 '15
Hi Will - Long time lurker, first time commenter here. Thought this would be an appropriate time to ask a question.
If drivers are principally compared to their teammate, how would you compare yourself to other pitlane reporters?
3
u/pzycho Nico Hülkenberg Apr 29 '15
Do you actually lurk this subreddit and upvote comments you like?
I'd be really curious if any of our comments have inspired any ideas that made it into more mainstream forms of journalism.
3
u/Nediadien Manor Apr 30 '15
hi will! what advice or directions would you give to an aspiring f1 journalist or PR officer? thanks for doing this mate
14
u/SkinnyBobZeta Jacky Ickx Apr 29 '15 edited Apr 29 '15
Sup Bux.
5
u/Rockableize Default Apr 29 '15 edited Apr 29 '15
Do teams complain to much about the rules and their engine partners, is it warranted, should it be kept private or should they be like Manor and just get on with racing?
Do you also think GP2 could come to Australia? With the season starting later and also the Australian Grand Prix held a survey after the event about potential categories coming to the future and GP2 was one of the suggest ones?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Thanks for doing an AMA Will. Love your reporting during the races, and I wish you all the best moving forward.
My question is a bit off the beaten path: What is your favorite Stanley Kubrick movie moment and why?
7
u/apelvisish Apr 29 '15
What do you think of this idea, Will? Formula 1: 2015 British Grand Prix to have 'festival' feel http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/31747695
8
u/ukonfire McLaren Apr 29 '15
When will we get to see you on UK television? I'm aware you work for the American NBCSN coverage but we're in dire need (mainly on sky) of someone of your caliber.
That being said: Who's your favourite pundit, expert or presenter to work with and why? and what subject area do you enjoy covering the most in the sport?
4
u/johnnygrant Sir Lewis Hamilton Apr 29 '15
What will be your suggestions for cost cutting, improving the show/sport, and increasing the profile of F1 around the world?
4
u/GiordySays Michael Schumacher Apr 29 '15
Do you think with all your years watching F1 and knowing what it takes to be a driver, you'd give it a shot? By the way money is also not an issue.
4
u/BlackCab Kimi Räikkönen Apr 29 '15
Dr. Strangelove or Full Metal Jacket?
4
u/randles_underwear Mark Webber Apr 29 '15
Hi Will, I think all of us here appreciate all the hard work you put into your job, so thank you for that.
My question is: Is there any plausible way that the junior formulas can be more streamlined to ensure the best drivers get to F1? For example, could you give the winner of GP2 an automatic F1 test, and so on and so forth? Or is the situation currently upon us just too messed up for it to ever happen.
4
u/KMagDriveTrainer Kevin Magnussen Apr 29 '15
Oh my sweet Jesus. You're still answering questions!
Okidoki then.
What are your thoughts on Magnussen? People keep saying that his season was terribly under par, and that Vandoorne would deserve a seat at McLaren more than K-Mag would. What would you say?
4
u/Olliedfox Default Apr 29 '15
Will...
Will you be driving in BRKC2016?
5
u/MeowtainThatRides Sebastian Vettel Apr 29 '15
Just a thank you for bringing many hours of amusement with your gp2 and gp3 commentary! As well as the 'guess what colour trousers Will is wearing today' game. (A surprisingly big hit in my house.)
5
u/Kookanoodles Formula 1 Apr 29 '15
Hi Will!
What are your thoughts on the FIA's plans to resurrect Formula 2? Do you think GP2 should just become F2?
5
u/Hand2HanSolo Apr 29 '15
Who do you consider the best network for F1 coverage? Who would you love to work for/with?
2
u/Yoshiman400 Daniel Ricciardo Apr 29 '15
Who do you think is F1's next first time winner?
2
u/attentionsurplus Apr 29 '15
Think anyone in F1 management realized that charging for live timing removes last reason for fans to actually watch races live while enduring the commercials?
2
u/thecluelessguy90 Ayrton Senna Apr 29 '15
Hey Will, what do you think of the Mexican GP, especially the last sector?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
In your opinion, which is the best Beatles album and why is it Abbey Road?
2
u/OnTheNuts Ferrari Apr 29 '15
Hi Will! My wife is absolutely in love with you, and I'm okay with that because it means we get to watch F1 together. We'll be at the US Gran Prix in October, we were hoping to catch up with you guys in Austin and buy you a pint! Do you ever get free time to enjoy yourself during race weekends? You seem like a busy fella.
2
u/blinkyxx Default Apr 29 '15
Hi Will. First time, long time.
2
u/Xorondras Sauber Apr 29 '15 edited Apr 29 '15
Terribly late, but maybe still worth it:
Who is the F1 savant within the TV crews (moderators, commentators, assistants, etc.) that is not known to a wide international audience?
2
u/Sen_Mithrarin Stoffel Vandoorne Apr 29 '15
Hi Will, what should I ask you?
2
u/TheDaan Sir Lewis Hamilton Apr 29 '15
Will, currently NBCSN broadcasts the premiere league games commercial free. Do you expect NBCSN to eventually broadcast a race commercial free? Or like the premiere league a break every 45 minutes? Also what does Coulthard smell like?
2
u/CarbonCyber Apr 29 '15
Do you on purpose wait until there's a car radio I really want to hear before you start talking?
2
u/ShootUpPot Nico Rosberg Apr 29 '15
Hey Will,
I don't have a question as I am typing this and I am very late to the party but I just wanted to take a moment to say just what a stand-up guy you are. You've answered so many questions and with such detail. You truly are a hero to the sport with your passion and your dedication to the fans. Keep doing what you are doing. You are truly one of the few people I find bearable on the NBCSN coverage. Thank you for all your thoughtful answers and for being an active participant in this sub. You do great work and we are all truly grateful.
In case you do come back round and see this I suppose I can throw in a couple questions.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Hey Will--no question here, just wanted to say thanks for doing what you do and keep up the great work! Always love your segments on race weekends here in the states
2
u/Deloox Kimi Räikkönen Apr 29 '15
How have you been Will?
How's your mini spring break going?
2
u/pzycho Nico Hülkenberg Apr 29 '15
I just wanted to say that I've always been a huge fan of your article about creating a series that is one step below F1, but not just for kids coming up through the ranks.
The more I think about it, the more I'd love to see a Formula 2 where every F1 team is required to have a "minor league" team where they could give experience and track time to their development drivers, and also experienced drivers waiting in the wings. Maybe they could use a standard model of a top F1 car from 3 seasons prior, make it a spec series, and then have a place for people like KMag, DiResta, Gutierrez, Sutil, Bird, Vandoorne, etc. to go. They could then still get track time, while also being on hand in case their reserve duties are needed. We could also see the resurgence of some drivers that perhaps faltered due to subpar equipment.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
Can we hang out in Montreal? I have grandstand seats.
2
u/Jam71 Patrick Depailler Apr 30 '15
I know you must have been asked the Senna or Prost question a few times, so instead : Jenks or Roebuck? (Or Saward perhaps?)
2
u/urbanglowcam Jenson Button Apr 30 '15
Hey Will. What do you think will happen with McLaren Honda this year? Which of the two drivers will finish higher in points?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
I don't know if you are still answering questions here but I was inspired by a question someone else asked so I have to ask.
Are you a Pink Floyd fan? If so, name your favorite album and favorite song overall. :D