r/WritingPrompts • u/202halffound • May 06 '15
Media Prompt [OT] /r/WritingPrompts new feature in testing: seperate areas for off-topic prompt discussion
A rule has been in place on /r/WritingPrompts since the beginning of the subreddit: all top-level replies must be stories or poems. Due to subscriber requests, the /r/WritingPrompts moderation team is considering relaxing this rule to allow non-story off-topic comments to be posted in specific areas designated as off-topic comment areas. This change is currently being tested on /r/WritingPrompts.
On every prompt posted during the testing period, there will be a comment posted by /u/WritingPromptsRobot, which will read as follows:
All non-story replies should only be made as a reply to this post rather than a top-level comment.
This comment identifies the off-topic comment area for the prompt. You are requested to post any non-story comments as a reply to /u/WritingPromptsRobot's comment. Any non-story comments posted as top-level replies will still be removed.
We hope that this feature will improve your experience on /r/WritingPrompts.
-The /r/WritingPrompts moderation team.
=
In the interests of transparency, the source code for /u/WritingPromptsRobot is available here.
5
u/Khajiit-ify May 07 '15
Is it just me or does the bot just post a blank comment?
3
u/JBaloney May 07 '15
The deleted post strategy doesn't seem to work, on new prompts with stories that haven't been upvoted yet, the botpost is still listed first.
5
u/Luna_LoveWell /r/Luna_LoveWell May 06 '15
I'm confused. It looks like the bot deletes a top level comment and replies to it, instead of posting its own top level comment. Why is that?
45
u/wqzu May 06 '15
Good idea. A lot of bad prompts have similar traits, and being able to say this without the comment being removed will hopefully boost the quality of prompts - and stories - in this sub.
16
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
I think it's a bad idea to have the bot do the [deleted] post thing. The client's I use hide deleted posts. I'm sure we can handle having the discussion be a normal post without this extra complication. It's not like we'll see the discussion and then not read the stories. I don't see what problem this is supposed to solve.
10
u/Zalgryth May 06 '15
This is awesome. Often I see a good prompt and I'm reminded of a good book that I'd like to recommend, but that could only be done as a reply to a story and that didn't feel like a good place to put it. Now we can make recommendations!
7
u/yunker81 May 06 '15
I got it now. I posted a WP earlier today and then saw that the first reply got deleted and responded to by the bot.
Here I was thinking that the first person didn't like their story after they submitted it or something.
1
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books May 06 '15
202, need to add the [TT] prompts too...
3
u/yukichigai May 06 '15
Great idea. I often see prompts where I want to give the OP feedback or suggestions but there's no real easy way to do that. This will help a lot
3
u/Sg_Lurker Jul 30 '15
I personally dislike this bot.
Almost every post has a comment by the bot and that does not make things neater or more organised.
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
I like this. Please leave it up.
2
u/fringly /r/fringly May 07 '15
I think this is a good idea and I've seen it working very well in other subs. Fingers crossed it's used to give nice positive feedback and discussion and it makes mod's lives easier.
2
u/Crushgaunt May 11 '15
I really like this idea but man is it surprising the number of people who don't know what's going on with it. I don't expect the mods have a way of helping with that that hasn't already been addressed but I figured I'd go ahead and point out the sentiment.
2
u/Taco49 Jul 30 '15
Another reason to stay a Lurker....
2
u/deeppit Aug 01 '15
Great idea. Sometimes I want to post something but doesn't quite fit as a reply to a particular story.
2
u/buchanandoug Sep 20 '15
Something I'm curious about. Does the OP get a message when a comment is posted in this section, or do they have to check manually?
1
u/RedDyeNumber4 May 11 '15
Thank you for implementing this. Hopefully it works for allowing OT discussion without harming the existing WP structure.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
I like this feature. Thanks.
1
u/bigshammy Oct 14 '15
What is the penalty for losing in the fight???
1
u/tcon025 Oct 21 '15
I really like this idea. Sometimes I want to discuss the idea behind a prompt, but I don't actually have time to write.
However, there is a risk of abuse if it just encourages people to bag out the prompt writer. Possibly the rules could be tailored to target this kind of abuse: "No disparaging comments about the prompt. Downvote and don't answer if it doesn't interest you."
1
u/ixfd64 May 06 '15
I was just thinking about suggesting a similar thing. Great minds think alike!
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '15
I thought the bot was broken, because on every post was a deleted comment with the bot's automated message as a reply.
1
u/TenNinetythree /r/TenninetythreeWrites May 16 '15
This is a bad idea and should be removed preferably today. It made the subreddit worse and attracted OT like shit attracts flies. It alsso means that clarification questions are no longer visible by OP, believe me, I tried.
In addition it doesn't even work and occasionally deletes the wrong comments.
In short: please kill the bot!
0
u/liehon Jul 28 '15
Could Writing bot be adapted to always invoke RemindMe Bot (time 1 day)?
-2
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
[removed] — view removed comment