r/formula1 • u/PatSymonds Pat Symonds ✅ • May 06 '15
AMA I'm Pat Symonds - Williams F1 Chief Technical Officer - Ask me Anything! Questions answered Friday May 8, 1600 BST / 1100 EDT
Post your questions in this thread and I'll be back on Friday to take a break from our Spanish GP preparations to answer them.
Looking forward to it!
EDIT: Thank you for all of your questions. I now have to return to the data from Free Practice in Barcelona.
1.2k
Upvotes
85
u/PatSymonds Pat Symonds ✅ May 08 '15
Thank you for all of your questions. I now have to return to the data from Free Practice in Barcelona.
262
u/YouOverRotated McLaren May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hello Pat,
Can you explain a bit about how the in-season development process works? The team shows up at the first race of the year with the best car you can muster, so where do you go from there? When the team comes to Spain with a big upgrade package, where did those ideas come from? Are there just flashes of brilliance while you're sitting back in your office, or do you have a laundry list of tweaks that you would like to test out but just haven't had time?
Good luck in Spain! The resurgence of Williams has been one of the most exciting stories to watch these last two seasons.
96
u/Dubakoor Michael Schumacher May 06 '15
Hello Mr. Pat, my question -
30
u/FootmanFrenzy Formula 1 May 07 '15
Hi mr Symonds,
I was wondering, how accurate do you find Finite Element software force/strength calculations to be when compared to how the designed components behave in real life? Is there a large difference? Do you need a big safety factor or can you pretty much design a component to behave 95+% to it's real physical specs?
23
u/Pwoo Williams May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
Thanks for taking the time out of your busy schedule, we've all been quite excited to talk to you! I'll cut to the chase:
Thanks again!
22
u/stampmanF1 Benetton May 06 '15
Who's the best driver you've ever worked with?
21
u/Mantikos6 Michael Schumacher May 07 '15
Pat, Could you explain the job of a TD? Do you come up with ideas, do you pick between ideas your design team comes up with? What does your day look like?
Also, can you explain why certain cars are easier on tires versus others? Is it common knowledge on what to do to make a car easier in its tires? Is it part science and part art?
Do you think banning FRIC and F-ducts was the right direction? What direction would you like to Formula 1 to head in?
You've worked with Ross, what one quality you think made him successful? Was he hands on technical or just a very good people manager?
19
u/itshonestwork #StandWithUkraine May 06 '15
What are you opinions on the WEC, and the close fight currently between entirely different approaches?
151
u/Sir_Skelly I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hey, thanks for taking the time to do this.
I've a personal question relating to Engineering at Williams: Is it even worth applying for any position if you have no industrial experience in motorsport? What is the lowest qualification you'd expect to see on a CV?
As a young(ish) engineer, with only 2.5 years industrial experience, it's almost impossible to get noticed!
What advice could you give for someone looking to get the most from their career?
31
u/LP886 Michael Schumacher May 06 '15
Dear Mr. Symonds,
I will make these simple so please answer. It's regarding the usefulness of the new formula that you defend so much.
If you removed all the batteries and recovery systems from the car, how much weight would it save? Would the car run faster on a qualifying lap in that configuration? Would it use less or more fuel? Can you answer the same questions, but for race trim instead of qualifying?
Thank you, good luck in the race and good job bringing back Williams where they belong.
26
u/olliekart Sir Lewis Hamilton May 06 '15
Hi Pat!
I've secured work at Williams this July though the 'Taster Week' and wanted to know what key characteristics you look in people to employ at Williams?
10
u/MikuruRS Michael Schumacher May 07 '15
Hi Pat, I'd like to echo everyone else & thank you for taking the time to come on here & answer our questions.
I'd like to ask how different was it working alongside a smaller team like Virgin/Marussia compared to the larger teams like Renault/Williams?
Good luck for the weekend & the rest of the season!
10
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
First of all, thanks Pat for doing this, really appreciated.
A few of questions:
10
u/HeratioReggaton Williams May 07 '15
Hello Pat,
You have had a long and successful career in Formula 1, what motivates you to keep pushing on after achieving all that there is to achieve as an engineer in this sport? Can you recall a time when you have questioned your desire to continue and what was it that encouraged you to stick at it?
Thank you for taking the time to answer these questions even if you don't see mine! Good luck to yourself and everyone at Williams this weekend.
26
u/Travelling_Turnip McLaren May 06 '15
Hey, Pat!
We are in year two with the new regulations, in what area do you see the most potential to gain lap time over the next few years?
Do you agree with Adrian Newey that there isn't enough flexibility in the chassis regulations? Does it stifle innovation?
Does Rob Smedley still call Massa Felipe Baby?
Thanks for the AMA!
18
u/beoheed Phil Hill May 07 '15
Hi Pat! Weather questions as always from me:
9
u/ThePiedPiper27 May 06 '15
Thank you Pat for this AMA 1.Given the amount of time you have been involved in Formula 1 what do you think is the best looking F1 car? 2. Which driver in your career has been the best to work with(feedback, work ethic e.t.c) ? 3. Finally what inspired you to get involved into formula 1 was it a long term ambition or did you get involved by chance? Thank you very much for your time as I am sure you are very busy
9
u/rafabr4 Sir Lewis Hamilton May 07 '15
Do you think there is room for improvement on CFD? To the point where using wind tunnels is not strictly necessary anymore?
8
u/SecretApe I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
Hi Pat. Very excited to read all your answers tomorrow.
7
u/chuckstig I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hey Pat, welcome to /r/formula1!
Where is your favourite place to visit during the year?
7
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Jean Todt had to wear plasters on all his fingers to stop him biting his nails. Christian Horner has his foot tapping. Do you have any nervous habits, or have you seen any other strange ones in the pit lane?
Also, what do you do to unwind in the summer break and the (very short) off season?
7
u/boomboombalatty I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
Pat - thanks for doing this AMA!
If you could poach any technical person from another team (or from another point in F1 history), who would it be?
6
u/mikeyd85 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
Hi Pat,
What's your favourite non-Formula 1 related activity?
Thanks for coming in here!
Mike
10
u/me_llamo_greg Max Verstappen May 06 '15
Thank you for taking the time to answer some questions!
A lot of people are of the opinion that tyre wear is holding Williams back from being in the fight with Ferrari and Mercedes. Do you agree that this is a limiting factor in Williams' performance at the moment? If so, how much potential do you see to improve in that facet throughout the season?
10
u/theruley Gilles Villeneuve May 06 '15
How do the logistics get handled for getting the crew to a race?
Do they each get their own plane ticket to the venue provided, or is it a private flight? Then are they individually assigned a hotel room at the same hotel or do they get to pick which ever one and send the team the bill?
Then will some of them occasionally opt to arrive earlier to mess around in which ever country the gp is held at?
56
u/Sir_Skelly I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Would you rather fight 100 Duck-sized Bernies, or 1 Bernie-sized duck?
11
u/Imonavirgin Sir Lewis Hamilton May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
If you could re-live any year of your formula one career, what year would it be and why?
8
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Hi Pat, Thanks so much for taking the time do this AMA. This is one of the most Die-Hard F1 Forums with knowledgeable individuals, so I feel safe in saying we all appreciate taking the time out of your day.
A.) A lot of people have talked about making the cars faster by raising the fuel flow limit above it's current 100kg/hr. What would performance increases can be realistically achieved by increasing the fuel flow rate?
B.) A general consensus among many in the F1 Fan community is that while the cars are massively complex and state of the art. They just don't draw the casual fan due to the fact they don't "look" as impressive as they once did both visually and from a speed perspective. What are ways you would increase the spectacle in terms of car performance and visual cues for the "casual fan".
C.) Are there any chances we will start seeing lap records being broken on tracks that were on schedule in 2004?
D.) In terms of tires and fuel... many in the F1 paddock argue that Formula 1 is no longer racing and instead a strategy game. Do you feel that's accurate and that something needs to be done to put things "more in the drivers hands"
Thanks so much again!
7
u/SmokeDayEveryWeed BMW Sauber May 06 '15
Hi Mr. Symonds, what's your favourite food?
4
u/BowtiesAndF1 Sebastian Vettel May 06 '15
What do you feel is YOUR biggest achievement in the F1 since you've been a part of it?
124
u/davidb23 May 06 '15
Hi Pat, here's a two part question:
52
u/RomanCessna May 06 '15 edited May 08 '15
Hi Pat!
Newey drove two of his cars I think last summer in Silverstone for the first time. Do you actually get to drive the cars that you design? I find it sad that all these people are involved in a car project and never get to drive the cars, besides the drivers.
Another question: how does a driver know the car is good when first test driving it? I mean it might feel a certain way, but what if all the other cars are better? I guess they just compare it to the previous year.
Thanks!
90
u/Riesig19 I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 06 '15
If you could go back in time and create a permanent rule in F1, what would it be?
24
u/Jam71 Patrick Depailler May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
Thanks for doing this AMA!
I know you have worked with many incredible drivers, and no doubt will be inundated with questions about Senna etc, but I am fascinated by Teo Fabi, who I know you worked with in 85 through to 87
He seemed so good on fast circuits but not as good elsewhere, and a really enigmatic character....what was he like to work with and why was he apparently inconsistent from one circuit to another?
Thanks.
69
u/Mulsanne Obliterate All Chicanes May 06 '15
Can you share an interesting anecdote from your time as Michael Schumacher's race engineer in the mid 90s at Benetton?
Thanks for taking your time to be here!
55
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Hey Mr. Symonds. Of all the eras of Formula 1 you've found yourself being a part of professionally, which has been the most interesting from a technical standpoint in your view?
The push towards computerized systems such as suspension in the 90s? The hybrid technologies of the past 5 year or so? etc.
50
u/RobGlass Romain Grosjean May 06 '15
My last question:
Having worked with Frank Williams, Flavio Briatore, and Ross Brawn what are the biggest differences between the three of them?
Also, if you were going to start a brand new F1 team and had to pick one of them as your partner who would it be?
17
u/vprakhov I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hello Pat,
First of all, as a long-time Williams supporter I would like to thank you for being a big part of the team's revival. Keep up the good work, I want that beautiful white car to win one day.
My question is what's in in your opinion the right direction for Formula 1 in terms of technical and budget regulations to keep the sport competitive and affordable for private teams, without losing interest of the big budget factory teams?
32
u/RobGlass Romain Grosjean May 06 '15 edited May 08 '15
How thorough is the FIA in checking cars for banned technology? And are there self-reporting processes for personnel inside teams to report things to the FIA?
Edit: As it hasn't been asked elsewhere but it has been talked about when the AMA was announced and is regularly talked about, I suppose I should ask it here. There have long been rumors that the B194 had active Launch Control and Traction Control in the '94 season. Was there any truth to this beyond what the FIA found? Do you know of any cases where similar systems were successfully hidden from the FIA?
28
u/22Actual Sir Lewis Hamilton May 06 '15
I have 3 questions if I may,
Thanks!
118
u/liberummentis Nico Hülkenberg May 06 '15
If you could tell Bernie one thing without consequences, what would it be?
89
u/Mrf1fan787 McLaren May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hi Pat, thankyou for doing this AMA.
24
u/falcongsr I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hello sir,
34
u/zeronemi Sir Lewis Hamilton May 06 '15
Hi Pat, You've worked with some of the best in the business, who would you say has been your biggest influence during your time in F1?
18
u/finedisregard Jenson Button May 06 '15 edited May 08 '15
Do you think F1 can learn from the WEC in how it's run and regulated? In terms of technical regulations, LMP1 features Audi, Porsche and Toyota who are all fighting close battles with three completely different drivetrains and design concepts that push engineering boundaries, and Nissan is coming soon with something completely different again. Could F1 benefit from trying to achieve something similar?
16
u/Oliveriver I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hi, thanks for doing this! It's a great opportunity for everyone to get a personal insight into the professional side of F1.
I've been wondering about F1 personnel opinions on this for a while: when watching parts of a race not involving your team, do you tend to support other teams/drivers in particular? Is it mostly about which result would indirectly support your team's best interests, or is there some scope for personal bias?
25
u/nottakumasato May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hi Mr. Symonds, are any parts (can be related to aero/chassis, doesn't matter) discarded after the design process, just because the Return on Investment (ROI) is low?
For example, assuming there is a part that would improve the car 0.015 seconds per lap costs 1500k (ROI = 0.01 ms/1k) theoretically, and another part 0.005 but with a cost of 100k (ROI = 0.05), would the cost of 1500k prevent the part from proceeding to production?
14
u/sprulz Aston Martin May 06 '15
Hi Pat, Where exactly does Williams stand with regards to cost control? Do you stand with Force India, Sauber and Lotus? Or does the team believe nothing is wrong with the sport?
14
u/rocketlauncher5 Ferrari May 06 '15
What do you consider the greatest engineering achievement by Williams?
13
u/longhornjeeplover Mercedes May 06 '15
Hi Pat, and thank you for taking the time to join us and conduct this AMA.
Have you been notified by Mercedes HPP when you can expect a revised power unit that utilizes the remaining tokens, and if so, by which grand prix?
In light of the well defined 2015 pecking order, is the new goal for Williams to concentrate on defending third in the WCC while causing trouble for Ferrari or Mercedes when possible?
13
u/Dr-M-van-Nostrand May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
Thanks for doing this!
I was at the Monaco GP in 2013, sitting at Tabac. Pastor crashed right in front of me & I came into possession of a piece of his car.
Here are some images: http://imgur.com/a/Pb5fG
To me it looks like a small part of the front wing assembly. It is probably a relatively unimportant part, however I've always been curious what it was & what it's purpose was. It's been carefully designed to perform a specific role, and I'd love to know what that was.
I know it was just before your time at Williams, but if you have any inklings on what this could be I'd really love to know! The part now lives in Australia with me. :)
Good luck in Spain!
16
u/random_runner I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
As a Mercedes customer team, how much help do you get from Mercedes to set up the engine?
14
u/Monkey_Economist Formula 1 May 06 '15
Thank you so much for doing this AMA!
5
u/tristancliffe May 07 '15
Hello Mr Symonds,
Congratulations on a fantastic career in motorsport, and I hope you continue to have success and satisfaction within motorsport for many more years.
I am at the other end of the motorsport world - I run a tiny club-level team with a 2011 F3 Dallara. I find it a struggle to decide what setup options to pursue, how much downforce is optimum, and how to calculate what each parameter's influence is on lap time. It's clearly an aero-dominated car, but with only 215hp and on UK circuits, chassis control is still important.
Wondering if you had any general advice on how to approach running a modern slicks and wings F3 car with very little track time or budget? Leave everything alone apart from wings and gear ratios? Spend money testing (which might mean skipping races) and try changing every parameter in isolation?
I'd love to have the facilities to develop aero parts or create clever things like inerters, but I'd happily settle for being able to ascertain what the tyres want to get best lap times for example.
In short - if you had zero money and only one full time member of staff, what would you prioritise for making a race car faster?
Not a very specific question, but I hope you won't scroll on by too quickly. Thanks, Tristan
9
u/RobGlass Romain Grosjean May 06 '15
Who is the most innovative engineer you've worked with? And can you give an example of why?
4
u/missiletest James Hunt May 06 '15
Hello Pat,
Do you think technology has advanced enough in the past 30 years to allow for the safe application of some ground effects in cars, in order to promote better following in corners?
4
u/Roozle10 Haas May 06 '15
What do you think about Haas's strategy of sourcing as much of the technical bits of their car as they can? Do you think it's only a valid strategy for a new entrant, or could we see a mostly outsourced Constructor's Champion that is more than the sum of its (variably sourced) parts?
7
u/Spam78 Felipe Massa May 06 '15
What technology would you want to see added to/removed from F1?
9
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Hey Pat, thanks for taking the time to do this AMA.
What's something interesting/ funny about a driver that most fans wouldn't know about?
6
u/gsurfer04 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
What aspects of other motorsports would you think would be successful in F1?
What banned technology do you think will eventually be re-allowed?
Which rookie drivers have impressed you the most? Are Williams eyeing any of them up?
Your cars seem to be struggling to keep up with Mercedes so far; how well is development going and do you think you could catch up within this season?
3
u/BenAlexanders I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Do you believe the formula 1 will embrace the internet in the near future?
It has always surprised me. With the amount of live stats and video feeds available, an online platform seems the ideal methods to engage with fans. Other sports, even motor sports (WEC) do a good job in this regard, and seem to be able to make money from it at the same time.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Hi Pat, may thanks for the AMA!!
A few questions:
3
u/shopkeeper56 Sir Jack Brabham May 07 '15
Hi Pat.
Having worked with both Fernando and Michael at very similar stages of their careers you have a very unique perspective. I'm interested to hear your opinion on how they both operated in the team on their rise to success, and how they contrasted in your eyes. Alot has been said recently about how difficult Fernando is in a team. Conversely Michael is viewed as someone who would galvanize a team. Who impressed you more?
Also I'd love to hear the inside scoop on the deteriation of the relationship with Jarno in 2004. And how close you were to signing Mark for 05. But Ill understand if you can't answer these.
Thanks a lot for doing this :-)
15
u/whatthefat Ayrton Senna May 06 '15
Senna, Schumacher, and Alonso. At their respective peaks. Who wins?
5
u/Galwa I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
What is the most ridiculous problem to occur with a car on a race weekend?
5
u/iWish_is_taken Kimi Räikkönen May 06 '15
Not sure you'll see this question as I'm a bit late to the party...
Just wondering what your thoughts are on Formula E and what people are saying about it in the paddock?
6
u/jetshockeyfan Ferrari May 06 '15
Hi Pat, thanks for doing this! What are the challenges of competing with teams that have significantly larger budgets? How do you work around that obstacle?
4
u/marigoldandpatchwork HRT May 06 '15
Hi Pat, what would be your ultimate driver line up with past or present drivers?
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
What's your favorite burger?
4
u/lukehmuse Rubens Barrichello May 07 '15
Hi Pat,
If you could bring any driver back to Williams who would it be, and why would it be Rubens?
You should definitely bring back Rubens.
Thanks Pat.
6
u/Atticvs May 06 '15
Hi Pat, first of all, congratulations on your huge recovery from 2013 to last year. It was truly impressive. You sometimes said the FW36 was very aero efficient, but you also admitted to a certain lack of rear downforce, especially on corner exits. My question is have you really been able to gain more rear end grip with the FW37 without significantly compromising its aero efficiency and with maintaining reasonably good tyre usage? Your lack of top speed advantage and seemingly heavier tyre usage in 2015 suggests you weren’t, but I’ll ask anyway – you are certainly better qualified to answer this question. Thank you in advance and I wish you all the best.
5
u/lukalukaluka May 06 '15
Pat asked /u/willbuxton and I'm asking you - what are the ideal ingredients to your fry up?
2
u/tejoalvin Ferrari May 06 '15
Hi Pat, as you've been in F1 business for a long time, which F1 season is the best season according to you?
2
u/avoiceoftreason Default May 06 '15
What are your thoughts about the technical regulations in WEC, especially compared to F1?
2
u/CannedBullet Fernando Alonso May 06 '15 edited May 07 '15
What makes a good motorsport Engineer? Also, what should I do to become an Engineer in Formula One?
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
Do you think Flávio will ever return back to the sport?
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
I know you probably won't answer, but doesn't hurt to try.. after all, it's probably the most burning question in everyone's mind...
Did Alonso knew about the planned crash?
Thank you for doing this.
4
u/sailer99 Sebastian Vettel May 06 '15
What is the most difficult part of an F1 car to access for maintenance?
Are the cars designed with maintenance in mind?
How many checklists are used in the garage each weekend?
3
u/MrHedgehogMan Jim Clark May 06 '15
You have the power of the FIA. What regulations would you change?
3
u/__dirtydishes I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Do you have a pre-race rituals or traditions you do for good luck?
During a race weekend how many hours per day do you spend working?
3
u/DunnyKruger Mika Häkkinen May 06 '15 edited May 06 '15
Hello Mr. Symonds, I know Mexico is still 5 or so months away but what do you think about the layout and what are you expectations of the track?
3
u/dirtyhabit I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hi Pat, where do you stand on the current state of f1 (tyre and fuel management) and who would you like to take over from Bernie? Thanks!
2
u/JasonDilworth I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 06 '15
Thanks for doing this AMA Pat, much appreciated.
Tame, but always an interesting question I think:
If you weren't in a technical role (not just limited to F1), what do you think you'd have done with your life so far?
2
u/ZCtheBeast May 06 '15
How did you start out in Motorsport?
2
u/WilhelmSchmitt Sir Lewis Hamilton May 06 '15
Hello Pat, thanks for taking time out of your race weekend to answer questions from us, lowly peasants of the internet.
My question for you is this:
Do you think Formula 1 has evolved to the point that having one person at the helm of a management structure is outdated? It seems like more and more teams are moving towards having multiple executives running the ship (a la Mercedes).
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
What's the most accurate racing simulator that's publicly available?
Thanks for taking the time to do this, by the way.
2
u/felipebabystaycoo Jules Bianchi May 06 '15
Mr Symonds, I am very excited that you decided to take some time from your busy schedule to answer some questions, but What brought you to do this AMA? Thank you and I hope you enjoy your time here at reddit. also, be careful, time goes faster in this site (:
2
u/zhbrui I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
One question: How much do drivers have to conserve the car/tyres/fuel during an average 2015 race? i.e. how "on the limit" are they during the race? If 100% is a full-speed qualifying lap and 0% is driving to the mall to buy some groceries. How about in 2005? 1995? 1985?
2
u/SerTrollLord Nico Hülkenberg May 06 '15
What would be the best thing to study at college/university to get a job on a Formula 1 team?
2
u/iamclev Kimi Räikkönen May 06 '15 edited May 08 '15
Hi Pat! couple of questions.
1.what advice would you offer to a high school student hoping to end up in F1 engineering?
2.Is a Mechanical Engineering undergraduate degree enough to get into the field?
Thank you!!!
2
u/harbltron07 Max Verstappen May 06 '15
What race track aways had the best weather for racing?
2
u/InappropriateLaugher May 06 '15
Do you attribute Massa's improvement in form to an improvement in the car which suits his driving style, or has some intangible (e.g. hunger for victories) had a larger influence?
2
u/lonnonzzombies Daniil Kvyat May 06 '15
How do you think marussias original 2015 car would have faired?
2
u/gaslipstick Valtteri Bottas May 06 '15
What's the biggest difference between Bottas and Massa as drivers?
1
u/Tywnis I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 06 '15
How fast do you think you would go in this year's Williams ? (any track).
Faster than Claire ?
2
u/vfed6234 Fernando Alonso May 06 '15
Do you have any advice for a studying engineer participating in FSAE, it seems like designing your parts for your section is easy (relatively) but keeping it in context of everything else and getting a car that works in harmony seems to feel impossible as a first year team.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Do you think it's realistically possible for you guys to close the gap to Ferrari and keep ahead of the teams behind you (mainly RBR) through in season development despite being a non works team with a considerably smaller budget? Is it possible that Mercedes will give you some additional help in the form of better engine maps in hopes that you put a bit more pressure on the Ferraris, which would in turn stop them from attacking the works mercedes and having to focus on defending from you guys?
1
u/missiongiraffe I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Wow, thank you so much for getting involved in the community here like this!
I just wondered what a 'day in the life' is for you, on race day?
I've been a Williams fan since I was old enough to understand what Williams was. It's fantastic to see the team back up there, all the best for a win this season! :-)
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Hi Pat, thanks for doing this AMA.
Which race is the most memorable to you, and why?
1
u/FleshlightModel May 06 '15
Have you ever had a driver who is particularly difficult in helping you develop the car? How a substantially amazing driver helping?
1
u/daniel_ricciardo Daniel Ricciardo May 06 '15
Hey Pat,
What do you think of Daniel Ricciardo?
1
u/JacksterTO Sir Lewis Hamilton May 06 '15
What do you think is causing the performance difference between your cars this season in comparison to last? Do you think you will manage to return to the form of challenging at the front of the pack this season?
1
u/shivharia92 Kimi Räikkönen May 06 '15
Hi Pat! Felipe's pace has been great this year and was for a lot of last year too. Do you feel like he's driving better now than when he was at Ferrari and is he in a better place mentally?
1
u/CurvyVolvo I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hello Mr. Symonds, Back in 2010 Frank Dernie suggested that reverting to manual gearboxes and implementing harder tires would help overtaking in F1. Do you agree with this, or do you think downforce reduction is the way to go? Thanks for this AMA!
1
u/Frothyleet Kimi Räikkönen May 06 '15
Hey Pat,
From a car development standpoint, how much influence does the driving style of your drivers have on the technical side? Is there a big focus on trying to accommodate particular driving nuances, and are there issues with conflicts between the styles of the two drivers that have to be addressed on the technical side?
1
u/Velocirapture_Jesus I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
How do we, genuinely, get those at the top of F1 to see things from the fan's perspective and make the changes that the fan's really want, rather than the changes they think we want?
1
u/DD_Power May 06 '15
Hi Pat. What are the differences and similarities between Felipe and Valteri?
1
u/harmonep I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Hi Pat, thanks for doing this! What's been the hardest part about, or biggest challenge faced when bringing Williams back up to speed from previous poor performance?
1
u/Antares_ I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
What do you think about introducing spec-parts and maybe even satellite-factory teams (aka customer teams)? It works wonders in MotoGP, why do you think it would or wouldn't work in F1?
1
u/24Ours I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 06 '15
Mr. Symonds, thanks for taking the time out of your busy schedule to chat. Given your relationship with a privateer team, what are your thoughts on Gene Haas and his upcoming first year in F1? Even with his relationship with Ferrari and his considerable success in North American racing, can he compete in F1 in it's current technological and economical environment?
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '15
Hi Pat - you are the coolest technical officer on the grid. WE all appreciate your great honesty.
Would you say 1000hp turbo cars are on the horizon?
1
u/d1cey1 Daniel Ricciardo May 06 '15
Hi Pat,
First of, thanks for doing this. As a technical person in F1, do you find working on the cars more interesting now, with more rules but having to work to find loopholes and such, or when the rules were more open like the early 90s? Second, do you think the sport would be better off moving in a more technically free direction or a more road relelvant direction? Ex. The move to stronger hybrids.
Thanks for your time and good luck to Williams this weekend!
1
u/spatchbo Mario Andretti May 06 '15
The one day I don't check r/Formula1.
1
u/OnlyForF1 Mark Webber May 06 '15
G'day Pat, what is your opinion of the F1 Strategy Group, and if you could change the governance of the sport to any structure you would like, what would it be and why?
Cheers, best of luck for the weekend.
1
u/AdamMc66 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
Hello Pat,
How Involved is a Driver in the development of a car and it's upgrades during the season and who is the Driver that you could say is the "Engineer's Driver"?
1
u/jordan7741 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
What do you think the younger (<30) fans can do to support the sport? Bernie is right that we can't all afford a Rolex yet, but aside from attending races, what else can we do to stop the floundering of this sport that we all love?
1
u/amidoes Charlie Whiting May 07 '15
Thank you for doing this AMA! Now on to my question: How do you think Haas F1 will do next year? What do you think of the way they are doing things?
1
u/spateeter Fernando Alonso May 07 '15
Hey Pat,
What is your opinion on the ever growing pace of the McLaren Honda car? They are slowly catching up with Williams and Red Bull. Does this concern you at all? How much of a challenge do you think McLaren would have to face to get passed you once they have caught you?
1
u/ibhardwaj I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
Seeing that you have signed Sutil as a development driver, what do you think about the legal situation in Sauber at the beginning at the season?
1
u/Nootwerks Roscoe Hamilton May 07 '15
Hi Pat! Thank you for doing this.
What are your thoughts on some of the classic, European circuits (Imola, Magny-Cours, both tracks in Germany and, potentially, Monza) losing their races in favor of less "traditional" venues like Russia, Baku, and Korea?
1
u/ari_hess May 07 '15
When you were a boy, did you ever imagine you'd have as cool of a job as you have? Has it lived up to your expectations?
Also, in a typical race week, how much time do you have to explore the area/sightsee? I'd imagine very little.
1
u/DuckKnuckles Niki Lauda May 07 '15
Hello Pat,
Thank you for doing this. I just graduated with an aerospace engineering bachelor's degree earlier today. What would be the best way for someone like myself to find a job in the Formula 1 sphere of influence?
1
u/tapz63 May 07 '15
Do you think Bernie Ecclestone is an honourable man?
1
u/dpfagent Daniel Ricciardo May 07 '15
Hi, have you ever been on the simulator for curiosity? How did you do?
And a question about Bernie: do you think anybody can replace him? How do you feel F1 will be without him?
Thanks!
1
u/tjsr May 07 '15
Hi Pat, I have two complicated questions, the second of which I hope will be useful to aspiring students:
Are there development areas including this, or others, which could perhaps be better restricted for the overall benefit of Formula 1 financially in development costs, to benefit the show for the fans and to be more relevant to the industry?
2. For a person who might have a long-term future interest in being part of a team at this level, what would be the attributes teams could most benefit from or most look for in job-seekers? Are there particular areas of study, soft skills, or general deficiencies you frequently see in potential candidates that is an absolute must-have quality or skill that only a select few have?
1
u/seanm624 May 07 '15
Hi Pat
I'm graduating aeronautical engineering next year with aerodynamics. What is the best way to try and become involved with the formula 1 industry?
1
u/thenonfinisher May 07 '15
Hey Pat, first of all let me tell you I'm a big fan of how Williams has been built up from the ground! Go garagists! Second, what exactly is the difference that a driver can give to a lap time today? How would you know if the driver is actually pushing the limits or not. You could have two bad drivers not pushing the limit! How could you tell otherwise?
1
u/wild34bill Sir Lewis Hamilton May 07 '15
I'm starting graduate school in the fall, specializing in either computational aircraft design or in CFD. What are some cool engineering problems that need solutions in the Formula One world?
1
u/dropkinn Pirelli Intermediate May 07 '15
Hi Pat, huge fan, If the fia were to open up the rules in one area which area would give us the most diverse cars/most radical? Thanks!
1
u/bLububL I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 07 '15
As far as being an engine customer: there being a regulation stating Works teams' engines & Customer engine must be the same, where is there flexibility for Customer teams to be different? i.e. ECU tune, transmissions, etc.
1
u/pperca Ayrton Senna May 07 '15
Hello Pat,
Great work Williams is doing and I'm here rooting for my man Massa.
Felipe seems to have concerns about the power unit and parity with the works team.
How much engine data is shared across all the customer teams? Power and torque curves, etc. How can you benchmark against the others to understand where the aero package should be making a difference?
Thanks for taking the time to answer the questions here.
1
u/estebomb May 07 '15
Hello and thank you for doing this AMA!
What is your favorite racecar from your motorsports career, and what was it that made it so special to you? Is that car also your all-time favorite? If not, what car would that be?
1
u/LoudestHoward Daniel Ricciardo May 07 '15
Hi Pat, thanks for doing this!
Within the teams is there a firm idea that the overtaking situation we had up until 2008 is now resolved with DRS and the current tyre/aero regulations?
1
u/Cfkid94 Sebastian Vettel May 07 '15
Hey Pat, Howdy from Texas! This may not be in your area of work, but does Williams have an Advertising team? I'm an advertising major and was curious if the team even need them?
1
u/Mathiaaz Pirelli Wet May 07 '15
Are you close friends with people from other teams? If so, who would you say is your greatest friend in the sport at this time or any time before? I like to imagine there is a lot of friendship within Formula 1, just when it comes time to race those friendships get put on hold!
Also as an aspiring F1 engineer, what do you like to see in new candidates? Does the team have a "work your way up to the big leagues" attitude or a "you fit the job, we want you in this position now" type of response to newcomers in the team?
Thank you!
1
u/cooldude1991 Sebastian Vettel May 07 '15
Hello Pat! You discover overnight that Felipe and Bottas, along with Suzie, Sutil and Lynn have disappeared. If you had a free choice of drivers who are on the grid, whom would you put in your car?
1
u/flyboy2443 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
how does one become a Chief Technical Officer?
1
u/Kozeyekan_ Brabham May 07 '15
Hi Pat,
Where do you stand on F1 tech being representative of what can be used on the road? Do you think we'll see Energy Recovery Systems filter through to most vehicles, or do you think F1 technology should push boundarys without keeping it in line with general motoring technology?
1
u/TryTryTryTryAgain May 07 '15
Hi Pat,
Thanks for taking the time to sieve through all these questions. My question is, if you could be an Avenger, who would you be? How will that help in your current role in F1?
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Hi, thanks for this AMA! Is driver being somewhat important in car development (with his feedback) really a thing or it's just a myth?
1
u/johnson4253 Felipe Massa May 07 '15
We've seen grands prix be rotated between circuits like the German Grand Prix (Hockenheimring and Nurburgring). What would your opinion be in regards to doing this with more grands prix? For example, have an Asian Grand Prix rotate between Shanghai, Buddh and Yeongam.
In addition, are there any former grands prix that you would like to see return? (Germany, San Marino, etc.)
1
u/schumcho Michael Schumacher May 07 '15
Hello Mr Symonds,
You've worked with a great number of drivers over the years, who was in your opinion the best amongst them in terms of developing the car pre-season and in-season?
Thank you and good luck to you and the team!
1
u/barryoke I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 07 '15
Hello Pat! Thank you for being so giving of your time for the fans. My question is about just that.
The media gets a good level of access to you and the team. Sometimes they throw to you during a race. There was a recent piece showing you and the factory team working with the trackside team over the Albert Park weekend. And Crofty and Brundle often mention Williams gives them a briefing before each race.
My questions are: what's in it for you and the team, is it actually something you "have" to do (does FOM or similar require it), and does the media ever get in the way or get too time-consuming?
Thank you!