r/formula1 • u/StatsSean Sean Kelly ✅ • Oct 20 '15
AMA I am F1 Statistician Sean Kelly: Ask Me Anything
Hi everyone,
Sean Kelly here…. F1 statistician to the stars… or something like that. Yes, if you’ve watched a Formula 1 race on virtually any TV network in the past decade (especially NBC or SPEED), or even bought an official program at the track, those statistics were all my fault. I’m now here to entertain and inform ahead of the US Grand Prix weekend, so feel free to ask me anything you’d like, be it stats, F1 TV production, general opinion, or just casual insults. Fire away :)
382
Upvotes
49
u/StatsSean Sean Kelly ✅ Oct 21 '15
Okay folks, i'm out of here. It's been a fun three hours and I really enjoyed answering your questions :) I hopefully will see some of you in Austin this weekend, and you can follow me on Twitter @virtualstatman. In the words of Bob Varsha "we'll see ya 'round the web" :)
23
u/StatsSean Sean Kelly ✅ Oct 21 '15
I think I've worn everybody out here.....
53
u/kakashi150 Lando Norris Oct 20 '15
What's your favourite little piece of trivia?
35
u/showstopperNL Jordan Oct 20 '15
What has been the most suprising statistic you have ever uncovered ? ( I dont know what the correct term is for finding out statistics )
28
u/ut15uf08 Kimi Räikkönen Oct 20 '15
Thanks for doing this!
I was wondering how you landed your current position, and what advice you would give for anyone interested in statistics but self-studying the subject.
63
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '15
Pastor Maldonado: Highest pole/conversion of all time. Williams' only winner for 10 years.
What is a stat that makes a great driver from history seem poor?
20
u/ceribus_peribus Oct 21 '15
I just saw this; thanks for taking the time to talk to us.
18
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '15
In your opinion, what was the biggest ever surprise in F1?
18
u/ranab1r Sir Lewis Hamilton Oct 21 '15
How do you feel about FOM not embracing online streaming memberships like MLB TV? I'd rather give my money directly to the sport than to a consumer-unfriendly cable provider here in Australia. I feel guilty watching illegal streams when the races aren't shown on free-to-air TV, but can't justify paying hundreds of dollars a year on current legal solutions. :(
15
u/Mulsanne Obliterate All Chicanes Oct 20 '15
From /u/fart_leviathan
Firing the questions early, as I won't be here in an hour :(
So, with every statistical bit factored in, who do you think is the most underrated F1 driver?
Of either or both kinds. I mean one like Luigi Fagioli who was a legend, but many don't know him and one like Bernd Schneider who has tremendous talent and had to put up with useless machinery for all his F1 career resulting in abysmal stats.
Also on a totally personal note; Who is your all-time favorite driver?
Edit: And surprise me with a nice bit of statistics if you don't mind. I'm not easily impressed in that field though :D
22
u/401vs401 I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 20 '15
What's your go-to statistic when trying to impress someone?
11
u/ceribus_peribus Oct 21 '15
Do you or have you considered maintaining stats for any of the feeder series? I wonder if it would be useful for scouting the most likely future F1 drivers.
10
u/withersoul Mika Häkkinen Oct 21 '15
Hey, thanks a lot for doing this. Do you think there is a difference between a successful and a talented driver? Stats are usually a representation to measure a drivers success and we assume the most successful ones are the most talented ones. Also a follow up question, is there any statistical data on who has the most total overtakes?
17
u/adams008 Daniel Ricciardo Oct 20 '15
What does a typical race weekend consist of for you? Is there a certain place you are during Free Practice, Qualifying and the Race?
17
u/AndyBstyles Kevin Magnussen Oct 20 '15
Hi Sean! Thanks so much for your time :)
My question: How do you go about deciding upon/formulating/researching your stats, specifically how you choose them and how they come to be?
Imagine I give you a blank piece of paper, pen and laptop, what makes you choose the criteria you focus on? Do you think up a stat first then research it, or choose a team/driver first?or just do what's topical or basically where on earth do you start!!??!!??
Many thanks :)
8
u/moment9 Minardi Oct 21 '15
Going through the questions you're stressing to keep it simple and I can't help but notice watching all sports that commentators are using more and more adjectives to make each accomplishment seem more significant.
Do you think there are many true firsts left for stats in F1 or in general? Or are more nuanced stats the inevitable future as the audience becomes more conditioned to hearing them?
14
u/Mulsanne Obliterate All Chicanes Oct 21 '15
Baseball has Wins Above Replacement - an aggregate stat that attempts to weigh every aspect of a player's game and boil it down to one number representative of their value. Do you think it would be feasible to come up with something similar for F1?
Something that takes into account wins, podiums, poles, fastest laps, consistency. And normalizes for poor reliability while penalizing for driver errors and things of that nature.
I'm a big baseball nerd, so it's something I've wondered about.
7
u/MightJustPostToday Oct 21 '15
Would you recommend an f1 stats related job for someone very interested in both? And related to that is it a big industry, with many jobs available?
30
u/whatthefat Ayrton Senna Oct 20 '15
Hey Sean, author of the f1metrics blog here. Thanks for your valuable work!
Why do you think F1 fans are still so resistant to taking a statistical view of their sport (e.g., in assessing drivers) when compared to many other sports that are highly statistically driven and analyzed? In F1, even basic performance parameters are rarely calculated. This is especially surprising given F1 is such a quantitative sport. My own guess is that it's due to the number of hidden variables and intrinsic difficulties comparing drivers between teams, but I'd love to hear your view.
21
u/kimiquokka Kimi Räikkönen Oct 20 '15
Statistically, how many drivers have won from 17th or lower on the grid?
11
u/jiroe I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 21 '15
Hello Sean thanks for doing the AMA already seen some interesting Q&A.
With the USGP on this weekend Do you have any interesting Facts about GP's in the US?
also being that you are from the US (i think) do you think the US can support a second GP?
10
u/HeyFlo Ferrari Oct 20 '15
I love you Seanus, thanks for doing this. My question, what physical feature on any driver was more iconic than the Nigel Mansell stach?
5
u/20tokens4abuck Oct 21 '15
Sean! Just made it home and saw your AMA. I've been and F1 fan since the late 80's and the current production and announcers are the best we've had.
Thanks for the great work and congrats on your seemingly badass life path.
Uh.. for a question... In your opinion, will we see refueling again?
5
u/tejasX Sebastian Vettel Oct 21 '15
I always wonder, how do you calculate all the possibilities when the championship is getting to a close. Last year would have been simple, but what about a closer WDC fight between 3 or more drivers? How do you take into account all the combinations?
9
u/roissy_37 Sebastian Vettel Oct 21 '15
It seems like F1 has afforded you some "once in a lifetime" opportunities... Monaco; fabulous parties; beautiful girlfriends and invites to the Playboy Mansion. As a stats guy, what percentage of your life is the rockstar, and what percentage is the hard working guy behind a Mac? And why did you turn down the invite to the Mansion?
8
u/kyrambo Cadillac Oct 20 '15
Do you work for NBCSN or are you an independent reporter?
8
u/whataguy Oct 20 '15
What are the odds?! I am a motogp fan, and just started having interest in formula 1 last week. I look forward to watching my first F1 race this weekend. Earlier today I was browsing this subreddit and realized that although I enjoy my profession currently, I wish I was involved in a profession that allowed me an outlet for some of my passions.
Hence my question - how did you become an F1 statistician?
I am currently an actuary, so statistics is my field. Any insight on potential career paths for statisticians or data analyst type professions within F1, or any motorsport for that matter? Where would one get started? Any major barriers to entry?
Thanks!
20
u/oh84s Sir Lewis Hamilton Oct 20 '15
Is it true that Sebastian Vettel is the only reigning champion in history to fail to win a race while his team mate has?
4
u/rustyiesty I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 21 '15
OT question - in your twitter display picture, it looks like you are in triathlon kit. Have you ever done one? Could anyone in F1 beat Jenson..
7
u/SE94 Ferrari Oct 21 '15
Mr. Kelly, are there any particularly unusual statistics you keep track of? E.g. Things other than wins, poles, streaks etc.
6
u/SharkSugarr I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 20 '15
Have you been to COTA yet? If so how did you like it? What's the longest amount of time between a single driver winning one race and then another?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '15
Do you bet on f1? Do you work with betting sites to help derive their odds?
6
u/racun12 Williams Oct 20 '15
What do you think will (continue to) be the longest record in F1?
6
u/reddishknight Jules Bianchi Oct 20 '15
Best and worst moments of F1 in the last 5 years?
6
u/baronvonkleist Nico Hülkenberg Oct 21 '15
when was the last time qualifying was pushed to Sunday due to rain...?
8
u/Coji5gt Sir Lewis Hamilton Oct 21 '15
How many drivers have won a wet race while starting 5th or lower, making it to the front, then falling back to some position equal to or lower than their starting position?
7
u/RIPop Mika Häkkinen Oct 20 '15
As a statistician, Mayo or Ketchup?
7
u/Gribbz Haas Oct 21 '15
Kind of a selfish question but: I have a statistics research paper this year that I plan to write on Formula 1. What interesting models would you recommend I look into running with the mostly public information available?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
So I am looking for a interesting stat. I want to see the most recent f1 car( by that I mean most recent year) times vs Indy car of the same year at the same track.
I know Indy never tests at COTA, I would love to see them have a test day at Austin to see how much slower Indy cars are compared to F1. I would guess around 3-4 seconds per lap but I have also heard that the Indy car spec tire is better in terms of mechanical grip compared to pirelli.
2
u/BaffledPlato Ferrari Oct 21 '15
Damn. I live in the wrong time zone and missed this totally.
In the off chance you might see this: Pastor Maldonado has the reputation of having a lot of crashes. Statistically, is this fair? Does he really have more crashes than his peers?
2
u/Acurus_Cow I was here for the Hulkenpodium Oct 21 '15
Who has the lowest standard deviation for finishing position?
2
u/Heikkie Fernando Alonso Oct 21 '15
Just wanted to thank you for all the precious information you shared! You've got yourself a new fan, and I'll make sure to mention you whenever I get the chance to share these statistics with my friends.
1
u/Southofsouth Juan Pablo Montoya Oct 21 '15
Give me a cool stat about Montoya please
1
u/jayaykaee Alfa Romeo Oct 21 '15
If youre still answering, if put in all identical cars, who do you think would be the fastest around a track? say Spa for example. (drivers from the last 5 years)
1
u/pumbucka Daniel Ricciardo Oct 21 '15
What differences are there in terms of track side attendance and TV viewers when comparing the dominance of Ferrari in the early 2000s, Red Bull's dominance and finally Mercedes recent dominance.
1
u/PlayerXz Sebastian Vettel Oct 21 '15
How many drivers have there been in formula 1 from each continent in total?
1
u/techiebabe Ferrari Oct 21 '15
If you and Karun Chandhok were put head to head in an F1 fact quiz, who would win?
1
u/GagLV Oct 21 '15
I thought you worked at Sea World as a dolphin trainer?
1
u/cmtedouglas Emerson Fittipaldi Oct 21 '15
what tracks do you want to see back on f1? imo i would love to see imola back
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
Was there ever a race won, or lost, when somone was in the pits? ( like a punctue on the last lap, and crossed the line in the pits)
1
u/NoahthePorscheGuy Valtteri Bottas Oct 22 '15
Do you keep stats on the amount of trolls you dispatch on twitter? You crack me the fuck up on the regular.
Noah (PorscheFanatic) (The one kid you ran into after the Montreal GP)
1
u/bclautz McLaren Oct 25 '15
first you guys have done a great job this weekend. second Question is Who holds the record for most front row starts of all-time.
1
u/johnnygrant Sir Lewis Hamilton Oct 21 '15 edited Oct 21 '15
Who was 7th in the 33rd lap of the Malaysian GP in 2007?
It is a question that has been nagging my soul