I really think they did a great job developing a connection between Nasir and the audience. I can honestly say that I feel bad for him. The final scene when Nasir's father runs out to get in his cab, but finds it is gone, really got to me.
Really liked this first episode and I can't wait to see this story unfold.
I'm not convinced Naz didn't do it. I don't think he did, but I'm not sure.
It's his dad who I really feel sorry for. When I saw him hang up the phone and sprint to go help his son only to find his cab gone, it put a wrench in my stomach.
I feel the same way. Those final scenes of Nas' dad really left me feeling for him.
I also am not convinced Nas didn't do it. He seems like a good guy, but I really can't think of a situation where some one else came into the apartment just to kill the girl, and do no harm at all to Nasir.
Nonetheless, I'm really excited to see where this series goes. The story seems solid and it's built enough mystery for me to want to keep watching.
it was hard for me to feel bad for him. he did so many stupid things that didn't help his own case. and i gradually lost most of my sympathy for him by the end of the episode.
running from the crime scene when your DNA is everywhere
drove recklessly enough to get pulled over
tried to run away from the police station as they were detaining him
had a knife with her blood in his pocket
- left her visible blood on his hand
didn't ask for his lawyer right away
didn't really present his case or alibi or innocence to the detective besides repeating "i didn't do it"
not keeping his mouth shut when he got pulled over and in the back of the police car
maybe some of those things can be excused by him being in a traumatic or emotional situation or him being on different substances, but damn that was one frustrating series of events and i feel like he didn't put any effort into establishing that it was a misunderstanding.
shit even before he met the girl, that one scene where he was aimlessly driving around nyc with his off duty light off was frustrating. he's just a frustratingly hopeless character
The dude was in psychological shock. You try waking up after your first time rolling on E, doing a couple lines of coke and getting drunk, only to find that the girl you hooked up with has been butchered. On top of that everyone thinks you did it and you don't know if you did or not. See if you can think straight.
Yeah! If it was me I would have called 911 as soon as I woke up and been like: "Yo you gotta get over here because a girl I just had sex with is now lying in a pool of blood with what appears to be multiple stab wounds. We did some stabby barroom games with a knife a while ago but that was just on her hand and I totally didn't kill her."
It was like he made the worst possible decision every choice he had. Like, "how can I make this any easier on the cops?" His lawyer is going to have his hands full dealing with that. Fortunately the cops seemed to make a crucial mistake by breaking chain of custody on the knife. He can definitely use that.
I'm kind of in the middle. I agree with the people that say Naz would do some stupid things being in psychological shock, but he didn't have to literally pick the worst choice in every decision.
Besides stealing his dad's car and not being able to turn off the light, the cops pulled him over and kicked out his passengers and then let Naz go. He was lucky they didn't realize he was shady and not a cab driver. But then he stops them as they're leaving to ask for directions? WTF??? That is just sheer stupidity. You're trying to fake a cab driver to the police and then stop them for directions when they let you go. Okay.....I realized then that he must not be very bright.
From what we need see, he seemed like a really good guy. Going to school, tutoring classmates, helping his family out, etc. I'm sure there's more to him that we'll find out throughout the season.
Loved it! Interested to see why that guy told the detective he was alone when really he was with a friend that gave Nas and the girl a creepy ass stare.
Good pick up. I assumed that it was because he was with his drug dealer or someone he was selling to and didn't want to be a narc and get him involved, but there could definitely be more to it.
The cop told Box that there was a camera on the street/block but wasn't sure if it worked or not. Obviously if it does work, they'll be able to see that Bodie's character is lying.
I had to pause this show SO MANY times because it was just completely overwhelming. Their use of suspense, ominous lighting, strong/convincing acting and not to mention, a really well-cast premiere made me love this show.
I am absolutely thrilled that I have a new show to watch after Game of Thrones ends this Sunday.
They really love the dark and surreal tone of the whole thing. Its like you're watching a nightmare. The suspense is crazy, like when they were searching for the knife and the detective was describing the weapon. I think that was my favorite scene from the first episode
It was even better because the cop didn't even think she would find anything on the guy. And the timing with the description as she pulls it out was so good.
Yeah I completely agree. I've seen this show getting compared to The Wire, Oz, and the first season of True Detective and while, I can see the similarity to all 3, what the pilot really reminded me of was The Leftovers. The constant feeling of dread and just being overwhelmed in general. It was hard to watch, but in the absolute best way.
I got three quarters of the way through the show before realizing my mouth was hanging open and a bit of drool was building up in the corner. I was 100% immersed in what was going on. Its been forever since I felt that from a show.
It felt similar to the feeling I get when I watch overwhelmingly awkward shows (like The Increasingly Poor Decisions of Todd Margaret), except it was unnerving suspense.
Small pickup I noticed. Andrea has her motorcycle licence. This is indicated on her licence with the "DM" on the left side. Might be significant considering the motorcycle scene.
He asked her if she had a girlfriend and she said would that turn you on. So what if the person on the motorcycle is her girlfriend and she found them together - stab stab.
My favorite part of the episode was how they built that feeling of tension when Naz was thinking about just walking out of the police station. Loved how they got him halfway there, then he sits down and thinks about it, heightening that tension further.
Also, did anyone notice how Andrea didn't fully close the back gate after she let the cat out? I think that might come into play later on.
Andrea not closing that back gate caught my eye as well. I didn't really think about it much until the last scene with the dad in the road, a cat that looked similar to Andrea's cat passed behind him and meowed....
He totally could have just walked out if he had committed to it. Also, I don't get why the cops had to search him when they weren't charging him with anything and Naz knows he has a knife on him--shouldn't he have protested?
Nah man, doesnt matter. I know this is a show and all, but you get searched if you go in the back of my car and unless you are a witness, you go in handcuffs. Then, you get searched coming out of the car and the car gets search as well, to make sure you didnt dump any drugs or weapons I may of missed or you might of had up your ass. Then, when I bring you infront of the desk you get searched again and your shoelaces come out of your shoes and your belt comes off, this is all so you cannot try to kill yourself in the cells.
Again, this is for all non witness, you may be suspects of a crime. We can detain you and place you in a cell if we have probable cause and they said they were gonna charge him with reckless driving(which would never go down like that in real life, but it is TV)
It was such great writing--think about being in that situation yourself, feeling completely helpless and almost willing to take that risk and book it out of there.
I really enjoyed the first episode. Thing that sticks out for me the most is that Naz didn't have any blood on him when he woke up in the kitchen and the knife he got her hand with was still on the table downstairs.
I didn't pick up on the blood until I watched the episode a second time.
Also noticed the first shot of Naz in class pretty clearly shows him as a left handed writer which I can see being used as a defense if the knife wounds are consistent with a right handed person.
I got that too but don't you think it was suspicious he woke up from sleeping on the table? And not like on the bed beside her. It might seem like a stretch but the opening credits had a shower still on it. The pilot definitely did pile up on evidences against Naz but at the same time had enough foreshadowing to throw away his case (breaking the chain of custody, overworked officers, the reason why he was pulled over in the first place, racial profiling).
It also reminds me of Rectify, and though it might hint at a similar direction I really hope it doesn't.
That's a great list. Another thing that I think will count in his favor is that both witnesses saw him in the station. I think this could be considered witness contamination. They didn't use the photo lineup until after the witnesses had already seen Naz.
don't think so. he had a lot of blood on his naked body. you see it in the strip search. enough from that deep stab wound? I don't know maybe not. Enough for that murder? def not. But the point is why clean up some and not all?
I couldn't help but think the whole time that this show was born from Serial's success. That in the hysteria bred from Season 1 of Serial, HBO execs sat down and said "Fuck, with True Detective and Serial, there's definitely a thirst out there for complex, dark and mysterious cases". I think they took elements from Serial (Pakistani suspect, claiming innocence, smart kid with an interest in sports, young girl whom suspect was romantic with ends up dead, police misconduct, evidence handling, racial profiling, and complex narratives that have tons of cogs and gears that can spin the point of view of the truth a dozen ways) and wove them into a fictional story that hits a lot of the high points of serial that drew a lot of people in, but also spun this story in a way to maximize the Neo-noir mystery and modernized it in the context of the recent racial crisis in America across a backdrop of a post 911 NYC police state.
Season 1 of Serial debuted in October 2014. James Gandolfini -- who has an Executive Producer credit for this show -- died in June 2013. So, this must have been in the works long before Serial took off.
Perhaps the popularity of the podcast caused HBO to make some changes, such as the suspect's ethnicity, but that's about it.
A few thoughts and observations I feel like I should bring to everyone's attention.
Andrea said "I can't be alone tonight". I don't think she was talking about rolling alone, I'm pretty sure she pissed someone off and seems like she is running from something. She says to go uptown and she seemed like she was in a little bit of a rush. Then later she says "do you ever just wish you could transport yourself? Something bad happens here and suddenly you're over there" Something is bothering her for sure. We know that her dad died but we don't know how or how long ago it happened. It might have been recent and this might be how she is dealing with it. Mabye she
I don't think the hearse guy is involved because he just seemed angry about the cigarette but when Naz and Andrea left the gas station it was all caught on surveillance so if he actually did start following them it would be caught on camera.
Trevor lying about being alone seems too obvious, him and his friend are most likely just a red herring.
In case you missed it, when Andrea let the cat out she didn't close the door all the way. Then at the end of the episode the same cat crossed the street. Naz has an allergy to cats so I feel like this is going to somehow come in to play later.
Andrea might be dating someone when she dodges the question Andrea: "do you have a girlfriend?" Naz: "no, do you?" Andrea: "would that turn you on?"
There's a really small detail that I don't think anyone else has pointed out but when they go upstairs Andrea puts her hand on the end of the railing and gets blood on it. This might help Naz later but he also put his hand on the railing as he rushes down the stairs so it might not matter at all.
Clearly the deer has some significance but if you look at the first and last time we see it there is no noticeable difference
So far I'm really confident that we haven't seen the killer yet. Out of all of the characters we've seen so far I think the most likely culprit is the motorcycle guy at this point since we know so little about him. The blood on the railing is going to be important, I just know it.
I don't think it's the same cat. I think it's meant to tie the two scenes together aesthetically, from the murder scene to Naz's parents house. Even alluding to where the whole night began, with the stealing of the cab, to where it ended: Andrea's apartment with the cat. Kinda just wraps it all up full circle. But, the reason it's not the same cat is because it's only been maybe 6-8 hours. Maybe 9-10, since she let the cat out the back until we see a cat run behind Naz's dad. That would mean that cat went all the way from the upper west side in Manhattan to Jackson Heights queens which would be hard for a human to do in that amount of time with knowledge of directions and such. You have to cross a bridge. It's a long way. So I just don't believe it's the same cat. Maybe I'll be shown to be wrong but that would be a huge stretch for me. The only way it could be is if somehow the murderer scooped the cat after the murder and brought it near Naz's parents house for some reason, maybe being someone Naz knows or something. But that would also be a bit hard to fathom. Maps on my phone says from 87th and Broadway to Jackson Heights Queens is 7.1 miles and walking would take 2.5 hours which I think is somewhat generous. That's walking with conviction knowing where you're going. Cats meander and wander. Plus, a loose cat, of all places to go to in the vast metropolis of NYC, goes directly to the parents house of the boy the cats owner just met in another borough of NYC. Just pushes the boundaries of belief for me.
The deer is important I think. I don't think the Deer is meant to show anything that changed with it, like evidence or anything. Instead I think it fits more into the shots of security camera footage at the bridge and convenience store and the witness sightings like the hearse driver and the black guy and the neighbor and the motorcycle driver and the two young guys in the back of the cab before Andrea. The Deer stumped me at first but I think what it's meant to be, with all the lingering shots of it (like 4-5?), lingering shots that are very similar in presentation to the shots of the security cameras and witnesses, is a symbol of being observed. For one, I don't know that I've ever known a girl who lives in a house or apartment by herself and has a Deer head on the wall. Have any of you? Generally a deer head is a masculine trophy. And implies that the home has a male presence that lives there. Her dad (he's dead) so not him. Step Dad as someone else mentioned from reviews of episodes 2-3? Boyfriend? Ex-Boyfriend? Either way I think it's clear it's meant to convey a male presence in the house. And the shots of it, like I mentioned, are similar to the security cam footage, and really give a very direct sense of being watched in the house. So to me the deer is indicating a male who either owns the house/apartment or lives in the house/apartment is there and watching. I think the murderer may have been in the house the whole time Andrea and Naz were there. Unseen, but watching. Striking once they were passed out. And since the show doesn't wanna give that away too soon, or ruin one of the big suspects for us so quickly, it uses the deer as a proxy observer to imply the things mentioned above. That's my take on the deer.
I haven't seen any comments on that yet, but I find that there is a lot of emphasis on Naz being left handed in the show (at the very beginning, when he's writing in his book at school, when they do the knife stuff drunk, etc). I feel like if a left handed person stabs someone, the wound will be very much different than if a right handed person does it, regarding angles of penetration (that sounds weird) and such. I'm sure it's gonna come into play at some point and could even discredit Naz from being the murderer.
I'm loving this already but my god, come on Nasir! this guy has to have the worst luck, don't amplify it by being an idiot, leave the knife, clean it dammit man!
I just figured he was planning to toss it out on the bridge on the way home. Yeah his DNA was everywhere but in that moment of panic he saw a possible murder weapon with her blood on it (from finger knife game) and his prints. Figured it's best not to leave that there for the inevitable discovery. Didn't really think he was gonna be pulled over on the way home and then searched in a police station with the lead detective of the murder right next to him when it's found in his jacket.
So here's my problem it's 2014 and the two brothers are arguing about who's gonna do the majority of the scoring Melo or Amare??????? What the fuck is Amare gonna do? He hasn't been good since 2011!
Did anyone else notice that the refrigerator door was wide open behind him when he woke up asleep on the island in the kitchen and that he was fully clothed after previously having been naked?
Maybe he got up, got dressed, then went downstairs to leave, but then why would he have stopped in the kitchen? Was he that hungry? Maybe he was talking to somebody in the kitchen and they left the fridge open?
It's creeping me out knowing there was probably a third person there but nobody knowing who it was.
Blow and molly, mixed with tequila will make you very thirsty. I believe there was a glass of water next to him. He probably stumbled downstairs to get water and passed out, not realizing the door was left open, just like leaving the lights on when you are drunk.
Great start, I'm hooked already. I haven't seen it mentioned yet, but what's up with the hearse driver?
After he told her she would be his next passenger or whatever, he left the same time they did. Did he follow them? And I do think the guy Trevor was with will come into play somehow. Trevor was telling box he was alone for a reason...
My girlfriend said the hearse driver only asked her if she wanted to be his "next passenger" because she had thrown out a lit cigarette at the gas station. Hence the reason he smashed it out on her window.
Anybody else notice the Jesus pose he struck when the cops were photographing him? That + the wound on his hand. Dude didn't do it, but he's going to be convicted. The innocent guy dying for the guilty one.
A few stabs in the dark about what's coming in future episodes...
The medical examiner who took the pictures of the body knows her.
She was stabbed with a surrated knife, not the shun that was in his pocket.
The male hooker getting booked in the precinct knows her.
Naz got roofied. Andrea either wanted to die (unlikely) or someone needed a scapegoat for something else that was happening at the time, and Andrea owed this person a favor.
It's possible that the two officers who rolled up on Naz before Andrea got in the cab are the ones who killed her. They obviously know the area and are ok with not doing things by the book.
The detective is going to try to railroad Naz via the media.
I noticed the medical examiner's reaction as well. You wouldn't think someone so used to seeing brutal death would have that kind of reaction, but who knows. As soon as he winced I said "oh, he knows her." I noticed the male hooker, "Pauline," is credited in future episodes as well--I think that's a pretty solid guess there. Can you clarify what you mean by #4?
Probably doesn't mean anything, but very random thing I noticed is that when they parked his cab in front of her house when they first arrived, they very clearly parked in front of a hydrant. It seems there is a ticket on his windshield when he gets back in the car but the hydrant was in plain view for what seemed to be a slightly extended period of time initially, so I'm wondering how something like that could play into the plot or maybe an alibi.
Yeah, it's becoming clear that the whole progression of events with Nas being pulled over, then left in the car, then brought to the station, then the knife being found while there, rather than just being arrested, may have been plot machinations for his Miranda rights to be forgotten/skipped.
Just thought about how money will play part of the plot.
First is the lawyer. We know the lawyer isnt a public defender, so he'll want to be paid somehow and Nas' family doesn't have a lot of money. His dad's a cab driver, and not a "rich" one who owns cabs and rents them out. he co-owns and that's been emphasized. his mom works at a clothing store. she might co-own it.
The second is family income. The dad relies on the cab, which is now gone and not coming back for a while since it's evidence. Nas even says "my dad needs the car for work" and they show the dramatic scene of the dad going out to find his car missing. Unless the mom is a part owner of that store they're going to have a really rough time during the trial.
He's obviously not a very powerful lawyer if he is out late at night doing work for a transgender dude. I think he's probably just a good guy who sees someone in need and wants to help out. I doubt that how Naz's family gets money to pay the lawyer will be a big plotline, or even mentioned at all.
I think the cat in the background of the final shot of the father is a hint that letting the cat out and leaving the door open is a key detail. Not saying that they are the same cat obviously, but I don't see any reason to go through the effort of putting a cat in that last scene other than the director sort of poking the viewer and winking.
Or maybe my heart rate is just elevated to the point that I'm overthinking everything...
I can't believe they were able to breathe new life into TV depictions of police procedure. The way the various officers spoke and acted, the general demeanor of the precinct, the cataloging of evidence...it was all written and directed in such a unique, realistic way I almost forgot I've seen this stuff 10,000 times on Law & Order.
Do we even know who's apartment they were in? There was a hat hanging on the wall by the deer head, and it looked like a men's hat. Actually I'm not even sure if it was there after he woke up. It was definitely there when they first went upstairs.
--What about the kid who was talking about basketball in the station and as they are about to release Naz they take the kid away and he asks a female cop if he can call his mom? I get that the kids talking about basketball in the station mirrors Nas and his brother talking about basketball at dinner, but why did the kid get another couple of lines to ask for his phone call? This show seems to do everything deliberately, so are they deliberately highlighting Naz's naivete and family connection with the kid, or will we see the kid again later somehow intwined with the death?
--I have a wild theory that the neighbor who saw Naz leave did it. Maybe Andrea is the neighbor's sugar baby. She pissed him off so when he saw the opportunity to kill her and frame Naz he took it. This theory has many holes (such as why did he have access to the neighbor's property to be in when he sees Naz, unless it is also his and he is renting the sugar apartment under a different name) but is building off the theme of watching and someone being in the apartment, and the hat that is on the deer.
The neighbor theory holds some weight. I could see that being why she didn't want to be alone that night; she incorrectly thought that, if she brought a guy back with her, her neighbor wouldn't try to do anything.
If they just had sex and there was all that blood and stab wounds, I would think he would have much more blood on him or his clothes. I've watched enough Dexter to know that much. It's clear he didn't take a shower since his hands and back had some blood on it. All of that said, the other plausible theory that someone else broke in while he was passed out and stabbed her is seemingly far fetched. There was also the second black dude during that first encounter but I have a feeling it's a red herring because it is too obvious.
Black man who did not utter slur STARES down Naz…EMPHASIS ON STARING
First thing shown inside is mounted deer head followed by near-endless pink Christmas lights
Andrea pulls out knife and pours tequila. Naz mentions he's allergic to cats, Andrea lets cat out.
Dramatic music cues, Andrea asks about Naz's racist experiences, then each drink shot,begin 'knife game'
Andrea seduces Naz, offers cocaine, gets him to stab between her hand—hits her
Andrea finds it erotic and they 'go at it,' smearing blood on Naz--deer again shown as they go upstairs
Naz does more blow, fucks, wakes up in kitchen--deer shown as he goes up toward crime scene
Naz runs in shock--deer again shown--but forgets keys, runs back--neighbor sees break in
Naz drives off in taxi, honked at, and is then stared down by helmeted motorcyclist (with a light out)
Naz takes illegal left seemingly out of fear of cyclist--cops pull over and take him to crime scene i.e. Andrea's
Note before taking Naz to crime scene, black female cop is aggressive--more than white male—he wants to let Naz go
Black female—not white male—is also the driver. Naz asks what street they're going to. Black cop stares down from rear view mirror.
Cops and Naz arrive at crime scene. Neighbor says he saw criminal get in cab. Officers don’t connect dots
Other officers see Naz in car--ask why?? Black female cop says he was in car when they got call. White cop says not drunk.
Neighbor/witness stares down Naz as cops see crime scene and tell neighbor to step back. Officer says to other officer don’t puke here--again ‘nice neighborhood.’
CSU guys are black, pull up with loud rap. Detective Box appears at scene, also in an unmarked navy police car. Note every other police car is heavily marked.
Box sees crime scene and says nice looking girl. That’s it--Cuts to white officers driving Naz to station.
Officers ask what Naz what he saw at the scene, as a witness--Naz says ‘nothing.’ Then he asks white officers “is SHE dead?”
Naz is booked for the time-being.
A bald man enters the police station enraged--mirrors man from just after girl picked up--and a black officer stares at him intensely, from aside
Black inmate asks Naz what the fuck he’s looking at--scene cuts to Box asking about knife used
Black racist guy appears back at crime scene, asks “what he do, kill her”
At jail cops keep noting Naz as a witness bc no one knows why he was brought to murder scene
Close to letting him go, then black female cop pats him down--earlier black officer stares at him
Find knife
Naz runs--black racist witness is suddenly there to confirm he saw Naz, but was before unaccounted in the station
After interrogation black cop--who stares--knocks Naz around as he disrobes and consents to bodily exams
Cop at desk tell CSU knife given to Mathis, which broke code of evidence conduct
Front desk guy tells new lawyer of Naz that Box got case, lawyer initially is ?!?!—then seems to recognize that’s just bad
A cat mirroring Andrea;s cat crosses street the morning after, as the father realizes Naz had taken his taxi\
Note: AMAZING SHOT. When Naz left the house the night before, the shot of him exiting and going towards the taxi is the exact same as the following morning, when the father extits the home and goes toward the taxi.
Points #30 and #40 i didn't think anything of until i read your comment.
30 - What would be the purpose of showing the shot of CSU rolling up deliberately playing loud rap music? Seemed out of place to me.
40 - If i remember correctly did Box ask where Trevor was when he came in and there was some back and forth banter about who brought him in? Then all of a sudden he is there and points out Naz? Also seems odd
The only other thing I've seen Riz Ahmed in before was Nightcrawler and I really liked him in that too. I think he will make a really good lead for this show, and hopefully gain some notoriety after its over
If you look at the scratches on his back, they seem to be too close together to be human. They kind of look like cat scratches (close together, parallel lines,) Her cat was put outside due to his asthma, but could have been let back in when someone opened the door. And I highly doubt either of them would let the cat in.
no blood was covering him for a Rob Zombie directed murder
knife that they cut the limes with was clean besides the accidental foreplay stab.
Thoughts:
Key witness lied and said he was walking the skreets alone and is racist, won't hold up in court? 2a. Who the fuck was the hearse driver? 2b. Who the fuck was the guy on the crotchrocket?
It's possible the knife they found on him isn't the murder weapon but iirc it had blood much farther up on the blade then it would have had from her stabbing her hand.
I don't think Bodie is even that necessary to the state's case. Nas admitted he was with her and Bodie couldn't even give an exact time he saw them.
Just got done, WOW. I don't remember the last time I've been on the edge of my seat like that. The movie "Apocalyptyo", probably. This show is excellent.
Watched this a couple of weeks ago and wanted to say how absolutely incredible the cinematography was within the first episode. The whole "eerie & dreary" grayscale NYC setting felt like a separate character to the whole plot and was what initially grabbed me.
That being said, I loved Riz Ahmed in "Nightcrawler" and I have a feeling this series is going to set his career off if each episode keeps delivering the same quality of "The Beach." You could truly feel his sense of panic and anxiety throughout the whole latter half of the episode and he really does amazing work with his eyes. I love the "nice guy, bad choice, wrong place, wrong time" characterization, as he exuded enough humbleness and quiet innocence to pull it off.
There was no clear cut suspect (as of now) and I'm sure there were a million clues that I missed, but I cannot wait for the next episode. I'm also in the boat where I think the "Miranda Rights" issue might come into play even though Naz said they were read to him. I love how worried his parents were about him and hope they become great secondary characters as well.
Early suspects: Drug dealer guy & Neighbor who made the call. Really hoping this is even better than True Detective S1.
-The girls mood is beyond strange, lives in the brownstones, when naz says you know do what everyone else wants you to do she responds "no I really dont". The transporting somewhere else when something bad happens makes me think she is somewhat sucidal. Seems like a girl with everything wealthy, attractive, but never is happy/smiles very somber mood, obv involved somewhat heavily with drugs.
-I think she was suicidal, saw naz liked her so he could be easily manipulated, obv liked pain it turned her on, convinced naz to stab her in bed and he just listened like before/wasn't at full mental capacity.
-I believe the show will show how people like to believe someone is innocent even when their is overwhelming evidence is stacked against them. Every person right now are playing detective thinking of who else could have done it, when the answer is actually right in front of you.
-I also believe it will play on the stereotype that all cops are corrupt/shady. When his lawyer hears Box is on the case he is visibly upset more upset then when he finds out the girl was murdered, I believe this is because he knows Box plays by the rules follows proper protocol. Everyone automatically assume cops are shady/do unethical things, but are willing to take far bigger leaps of faith to believe naz is innocent.
When Naz retrieved the knife, it was on the coffee table, pretty much right where he left it after playing the knife game with Andrea.
I have a feeling that will be important later. I'm going to go home and see if we can see where the knife is when they run upstairs to bone, and compare that to where it is when Naz grabs it on the way out.
There's faint evidence that someone was fleeing the murder scene. When Naz wakes up on the kitchen counter with his water, you can hear a car outside speeding away. The engine revs loudly, indicating it was starting from a dead stop and accelerating away quickly. You hear a car honk, possibly implying that the fleeing car pulled out quickly in front of the other car, who in turn, honked at him. Later, when Naz get back into his Dad's cab to flee the scene himself, he pulls out into the street so quickly that another car honks at him in an ironically similar manner.
This episode was great, such great detail and story telling. I'm going to go back and watch it again because I want to make sure I don't miss a ounce of detail. Cannot wait for EP. 2
The motorcyclist in all black who pulled up next to Nassir, then stared at the knife on the dash of the cab.. His headlight was out on the bike, he/she will probably get pulled over by the cops and not contribute positively to Nassir's situation.
Because driving someone else's totally unfamiliar car while you are black/brown at 3-4am when you are carrying a bloody knife from a crime scene is RISK FREE.
just watched the first episode finally and WOW, then I rewatched it an hour later because I couldn't stop thinking about all the scenarios. late to the discussion party unfortunately but a few things I'll mention that really stuck out to me.
Why did the witness say he was alone when he was with a "friend" that was staring at Nas
what was the pill Nas and the girl took, based on his reactions and staring I was thinking something similar to/or Molly? or was it something that caused him to "blackout"
that hearse driver really left a mark on me, I feel he had a strong connection based on his staring. Could go on and on but these are the things I am super hung up on.
I have a feeling his knife is not going to match all the wounds that killed her. She mentioned she couldn't be alone that night so maybe she was caught up in some shit already.
Part of me wonders about the guy Trevor was with, his lingering look at the brownstone - but, I know that could also be misdirection on the part of the director and writers.
It is still unclear (and mentioned several times) if the knife is serrated or not. The knife on Naz (which he picks up downstairs) is NOT serrated. I would think the ME's report will be clear about the type of knife used. It would be an interesting story arc to have the report come back 'serrated' but have the police ignore this detail and try to make everything stick to Naz.
Anyone who's ever watched or written a series like this will expect the killer to make their first innocuous appearance in episode one, not episode six- that would be lame. So we've probably seen him already, and we can restrict our analysis to the relevant 20 minute interval (from 10 to 30 minutes into episode one).
So let's eliminate some suspects right away:
NAZ: I've never stabbed anyone 22 times, but if I did, I can't imagine explaining to a dead body, "Well, it's been fun killing you, but I'd better get home before my parents find out..." Plus, who would kill a goose that laid golden eggs like that? Free illegal pills, freshly cut limes, sex with Mazzy Star in the background, nice apartment... The guy has only gotten laid once before in his life! And he's tutoring vector calculus! He's a bumbling fool around cops but he isn't a complete nimrod.
ANDREA: People have pointed the finger at her, but try stabbing yourself 22 times in the back and let us know how that turned out.
TREVOR, who was the first witness to identify Naz, but who also says this immediately after their initial encounter with Naz and Andrea: "Anyway, look, I'm going to Shiranda's, man. I know that her cousin's there and she's got some fat ass. I know they got some weed over there too." If the killer turns out to be Trevor, then that's some seriously bad writing. It's not Trevor.
THE CAT: Exonerated for not being able to hold a knife.
There are at least 4 likely suspects at this point:
HEARSE GUY, for obvious literary reasons. He's driving a hearse, and asks her if she wants to be his next customer (since she tossed a lit cigarette toward him at a gas station). But Andrea doesn't seem to know him. ("What's his problem?" asks Naz. "Who cares?" she replied.) HOWEVER, notice how Hearse Guy is done refueling, but is still leaning against his hearse as Naz comes back to his cab. He only gets back into the hearse when Naz has gotten back into the cab. AND there is a closed-circuit TV catching all this. To me, that looks like the fuse of a plot line, at least several episodes long, just waiting to be lit. Even if Hearse-Guy gets exonerated, expect to see that CC-TV footage in a later episode. I can't wait to meet Hearse Guy again later on.
TREVOR'S FRIEND, whose existence is not disclosed to the police by Trevor, and who also gave that scary-look-that-must-mean-something. But the scary look could easily be explained away: he's going be a witness in a future episode, so he's shown prominently giving them a good look over. Once he's in the show again, we're going to find out why Trevor lied about being alone- probably something underwhelming like drugs.
NOSY NEIGHBOR across the street- he's the only one so far who you would suspect to have known the victim previously. Was he alerted by breaking glass, or does he always stare at her through the window like a perv? He seemed pretty suspicious to me.
MOTORCYCLE GUY, who certainly seems interested in that knife on the dashboard. You can't see who he is. He may actually be Trevor's Friend or Hearse Guy. (Presumably Nosy Neighbor is talking to the cops at that moment, so it isn't him.)
Some obviously big clues spill out of Andrea's mouth when she gets in the cab, indicating danger nearby:
"Are you going to make me get out?"
"I would really like to get going."
"A river would be fine. Not here though, go uptown." (How far?) "Far."
"I can't be alone tonight." (Is she scared, or just horny?)
Her dad "was OK". (Does that mean he's dead? She doesn't correct Naz when he infers that.)
A lot of people watching this have expressed incredulity that this girl can afford to live in an apartment in that area. Where did she get the deer head- did she shoot it herself? Maybe she's living off a dead father's inheritance? That's the most trivial explanation- but this is a murder mystery, after all, so I'm thinking she might have been blackmailing somebody.
The biggest clue is the second entrance which she uses to deposits the cat outside. Neither the wrought iron gate nor the door behind it seem to latch as she goes back in, and they made sure to film it not latching, so chances are 100% that the killer entered through there. (Naz clearly doesn't know that it exists or he wouldn't have smashed the glass at the main door to get back inside.) Now who else might have known about the second entrance? There's no clear reason why Trevor's Friend or Hearse Guy would have known of its existence. But Nosy Neighbor would certainly have been aware of it.
If this were real life, I'd say the second entrance makes Nosy Neighbor the prime suspect (after Naz of course). But since it's fiction, the CC-TV at the gas station points strongly toward Hearse Guy. (The only alternatives are Trevor's Friend, and- if he turns out to be a separate character- Motorcycle Guy.)
I know some people have written up some great analysis on the deer scene. Seeing the mount made me feel very uneasy. Definitely a feeling of being watched.
Another point a wanted to make, coincidence or not, was the hearse driver scene
Driver wearing all black
Driver: You wanna be my next passenger?
Andrea: No
Puts out cigarette on the window
It's almost symbolic to me that the hearse driver represented the Reaper. Dressed in all black and driving a hearse. He asked her if she wanted to be his next passenger. She said no. He didn't like that answer too much. And put out the cigarette on the window and left an ash mark, almost as if she was marked for death.
Amazing scene change right after they have nasir strip down to nothing. detective box is sitting right at the exact level where nas' exposed penis would be and then bam! There is a phallic shaped finger (nas' finger) being inked for prints. Love little things like that.
Naz (sp?) doesn't do drugs on the reg. He did cocaine and ex for probably the first time of his life. How the fuck does he go to sleep? The first time I did either of those drugs I was up all night. Not to mention the adrenaline from meeting a new girl, stabbing her, and fucking her. How the fuck did he fall asleep soundly enough to not wake up to her being stabbed in the same house.
I think he did it. They showed us everything except when he actually killed her.
Already rewatched once to see if i missed anything. And the hearse driver seemed sketchy and so did the black guys friends . anyone else get the vibe? Just the way both of them stared at him made them seem off to me
Amazing construct, acting and production value. Thought the portrayal of the girl (affluent, careless, dark and mysterious) was a bit clichéd. But so far, fantastic show!
Shit. Cliches come from somewhere. Go hang out in Manhattan or at NYU or The New School for a bit. You'll see how, though cliché, it can be pretty fucking spot on.
Given how many times she was stabbed and how much blood was on the bed/surrounding area, wouldn't Nasir have WAY more blood on him if he did it? Seems like a simple thing the lawyer can bring up, he clearly never changed clothes.
I honestly want to reach into the TV and shake Naz tell him to STFU and ask for a lawyer. Just please Naz stop talking to the police. They are Not there to help you. I can see the train wreck hurling a thousand miles an hour about to crash into huge mess. Cant wait till 17th!!!
Couldn't help but notice that the girl's front door locked on it's own when Nas left the house after finding her body. For that reason, I believe whoever ended up murdering her had obviously entered through the backdoor when she let out the cat. Not sure if that points in any specific direction, just was thinking about the entry point.
I think we can all say on how the director shot the scene. That whoever is riding the motorcycle is the murderer. I don't think we've met him/her yet and will probably meet this person soon in the upcoming episodes.
I'm not sure what to think yet. There's a handful of suspects and Nas has some unanswered questions to.
Some people I find suspicious:
The two guys that jumped in the taxi - Just seemed like a weird scene that didn't go anywhere. It didn't add anything to the story and the show runners could've easily just skipped to the girl getting in the car.
The guy from the gas station - He had a strange look as Nas was driving off but that's about it besides for being annoyed about the cig. Probably nothing.
The racist black guy - I don't think he had anything to do with it. Just seems like an asshole. He did lie to the cop about being alone, though.
Racist black guy's friend - I don't think it's him but that creepy stare after the confrontation was strange. I did notice that when she let the cat out she didn't close the gate properly so if it is one of these two than they had a way inside.
That's it for suspects besides Nas himself. I did think it was weird that Nas woke up at the table and was fully dressed with no blood on him except for his hand. You would think someone who stabbed a girl to death and covered the bed blood would have a stain or two. The knife ending up in his pocket is also weird.
Then as I was typing this out I was thinking about everything the girl said to Nas, about how she wanted to go to the beach and didn't want to be alone that night. What if she was contemplating suicide? We saw how easily it was for her to talk him into the drugs and the knife game. What if she asked him to mercy kill her and he was so high that he agreed and doesn't remember? It's a far fetched theory but who knows.
All I can say is that I'm intrigued and can't wait for the next episode.
It would look fishy to an outside observer (cop/juror/whatever) that Naz threw those guys out of the cab but then immediately let in an unaccompanied young woman. Hmm...was he looking for a target? That will probably come up.
They had the two guys get in the taxi and him refuse to drive them to make it clear that Naz was making a decision to abandon his plans and drive this girl for whatever his internal reason was: a good time? she was intriguing? Help a girl in need? He refused to change his plans for two guys to the extent of getting the cops involved, but immediately gave up on them and went with her when she asked. Also shows his ability to be persuaded by her.
The gas station guy was driving a hearse and told her she would be his next passenger for smoking carelessly at a gas station. It was a joke but served as foreshadowing (she would die that night).
Racist guy's friend stared a bit too long afterwards and based on the racist guy's claim that he was alone when talking to police, I would imagine that this guy is a bad dude that does not cooperate with cops/scares the racist guy. This one has legs to me, but I think random black gangster murders her is a bit too low for this show.
Personally my theory is that she had trouble in her life outside of what we know, she could not be alone because she was a little scared but mostly depressed, and I would imagine some ex lover came back to kill her that night. She was targeted and killed maliciously.
Well I have seen "How to Get Away with Murder" upto such extent that Naz reminded me of Wes.. and I have been taking mental notes of what's happening, could happen, who could be a suspect, the witnesses, murder weapon, his mistakes.. not asking for a lawyer before speaking up...etc. etc. I guess they have developed an excellent pilot episode, and this can become one of the amazing mini series (at least of this particular genre)
I've only seen it once but for some reason what keeps sticking with me is when the cat was let out the back door, wasn't there another screen door directly next to hers into another building??? Seems plausiable that a "third person" could come in and out of there pretty quickly and efficiently to muder Andrea if so. Could have walked right past Naz just conked out on the island and getting a tan from the refrigerator light...
Reading theories about the hearse driver is giving me True Detective Season 1 theory vibes. I'd bet a lot of money that his main significance will be that he is called in as a witness to testify to the fact that he saw Nas with the girl. Other than some foreshadowing ("You trying to be my next passenger?") that's likely to be his role.
Is it true that if Naz did not consent to dna and blood samples, the court order would take 45 minutes in the middle of the night? Or was this BS on the detective to convince him to concent?
Why has nobody mentioned the dude on the motorbike that pulls up alongside Nas when Nas is leaving the crime scene? Or have we all just assumed that the mystery rider was a red herring too?
Damn better than True Detective as far as I'm concerned. The first ep of True Detective definitely wasn't as consistent in quality as this, in my opinion. Really wish I waited for the rest of it to be released is all, considering it's hard to watch the first episode and get much more than set up. But then again, the is how HBO keeps viewership up.. So yeah, I'll be there in 2 weeks to watch the next episode, that's for sure.
Way too early to make that call. I had to watch the first two episodes of TD 2-3 times before I got the narrative style and how it was working.
TNO, so far, is linear. It did an excellent job of giving a sense of place and time. Where it will go from here is way up in the air. We've briefly been introduced to many characters by name already, and with the use of surveillance footage as pov, we can see what the detectives might be looking at in the future.
There's so many avenues to take it. I think it's going the be at least 3 episodes before anyone can say where it's going.
I can't decide if all of Nas's poor decisions was lazy writing or showing the reality of someone panicking. I mean, come on. You take the knife with you in your jacket? Forget the fact that that's the murder weapon, who puts a long knife like that in their coat pocket?
Forgetting his keys, breaking the window, not obeying traffic laws, trying to run. Am I being too harsh in thinking his actions were a little ridiculous?
I don't think it was lazy writing - I think it was brilliant. Naz was overwhelmed, in a state of shock, strung out on all sorts of substances, and just generally not thinking clearly. Combine that with the fact that he's naturally clean-cut and naïve, and he probably feels guilty as hell for stealing his dad's cab and doing all sorts of things over the course of the night that go against his upbringing (drinking, drugs, sex with a total stranger, stabbing her hand). His fear and confusion gave way to contradictory actions: he calls his parents and they don't pick up, they call him and he doesn't pick up; he talks to the police without having a lawyer present because he doesn't want to seem guilty, later he decides he needs a lawyer because he doesn't want to seem guilty. The guy is in TOTAL PANIC mode. He is grasping at straws to keep from drowning. All of us who watched it had to have been shouting at our tvs for Naz to do something different, something that would make himself seem less suspicious, to behave in a way that was less incriminating. But all of that was by design. His poor decisions are supposed to leave us feeling frustrated and angry. This show seems to be all about snap judgments, the moments when we act without truly thinking. We see this reflected again and again in the cops who fail to communicate and send evidence to the wrong people out of convenience, the lawyer who decides to defend Naz because of a gut feeling, and of course in Naz himself.
As somebody who has made some pretty serious mistakes while high/drunk, it's actually realistic. When you're all fucked up and in a state of panic at the same time, you'll only make your situation worse with the rash decisions you make. And needless to say, mine never involved a dead chick that I just slept with, so turn it up to 11.
You should research some old court cases. Generation Why is a good podcast for it. Innocent people make themselves look guilty all the time out of stupidity and ignorance. The system doesn't care because it gives the public the illusion of justice even though it is intrinsically flawed.
I don't think it was lazy writing at all, I just think he was confused/panicked/high/drunk and just made some poor decisions. This guy is a pretty straight kid, its not like he has experience with dealing with crime scenes
Not every smart person is a genius when it comes to crime, and not every criminal mastermind is a genius.
I think they purposefully contrasted his intelligence (college tutor) and his bumbling (knife, window, not knowing how to drive) to show that he's far, far out of his element.
You're being too harsh. He's paniced, and everything about the mise en scene and writing was pointing to that fact.
I love the series so far. Was screaming during the revelation scene. Yelling, going to be a long wait. Wish they just released all the episodes but I guess this will build the suspense even more.
One thing I'm wondering about...Why would she start trying to stab her hand and then ask him to do it. Its like if she wanted his fingerprint on the knife. Idk I could be far reaching but its a little suspicious or coincidental to me.
Something that's been bothering me about the front door of her house is when it locks/doesn't lock...when they first arrive at the apartment she uses a key to get in. Then he runs out to his cab, forgets his keys, and runs back in only the door is locked again so he has to break in. But then when the cops get there, they open the door no problem. Why didn't it lock again? This is important because if the door auto-locks, how did anyone else get in there to commit the murder? If it doesn't auto-lock, then why did Naz have to break in to get his keys?
Isn't the Deer mount completely hung differently from the moment before they sleep together to the scene where he wakes up in the kitchen and walks upstairs? Also it had a hat on it before they slept together?? Or does she have multiple deer mounts in this ridiculously sweet apartment?
Smoking is brought up twice in this episode. The first time was Andrea flicking out the lit cig from the cab and the second was the detective smoking at the crime scene.
This is too random for it to be nothing. It was put in for a reason, I think.
And if this was written with Serial, Season 1 in mind, I would not be shocked if Naz is the killer and we see glimpses of his anger as the season moves forward.
This could also morph into something similiar to the old Richard Gere/Edward Norton movie where Norton does a very abrupt character change after the trial.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned, and I don't particularly think they had anything to do with the murder itself, but those two guys who got in the cab before Andrea got in. Like I wonder if they could know who or what Andrea was involved with, what she was kind of running from, even if they were just random witnesses and saw something before Naz showed up.
Plus, they seemed kinda high IMO, seemed like the type of dudes who could've possibly been hanging out with or around her that night.
Expository device to show that a NYC cab driver HAS to take a passenger anywhere they want to go within the 5 boroughs if he is "on duty". Hence all the discussion of "well why isn't your light on??".
223
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '16
I really think they did a great job developing a connection between Nasir and the audience. I can honestly say that I feel bad for him. The final scene when Nasir's father runs out to get in his cab, but finds it is gone, really got to me.
Really liked this first episode and I can't wait to see this story unfold.
194
u/Azrael_ Jun 29 '16
So glad to see my mainest man Bodie putting up some hours. True Soldier.
166
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '16
Loved it! Interested to see why that guy told the detective he was alone when really he was with a friend that gave Nas and the girl a creepy ass stare.
336
u/t3hdownz Jun 25 '16
I had to pause this show SO MANY times because it was just completely overwhelming. Their use of suspense, ominous lighting, strong/convincing acting and not to mention, a really well-cast premiere made me love this show.
I am absolutely thrilled that I have a new show to watch after Game of Thrones ends this Sunday.
152
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '16
What if all of this leads to him meeting Jake Gyllenhaal!?
138
u/Toilet_Spiders Jun 29 '16
Small pickup I noticed. Andrea has her motorcycle licence. This is indicated on her licence with the "DM" on the left side. Might be significant considering the motorcycle scene.
125
u/ehhhhhhfuckit Jun 26 '16
My favorite part of the episode was how they built that feeling of tension when Naz was thinking about just walking out of the police station. Loved how they got him halfway there, then he sits down and thinks about it, heightening that tension further.
Also, did anyone notice how Andrea didn't fully close the back gate after she let the cat out? I think that might come into play later on.
107
u/thegouch Jun 27 '16
I really enjoyed the first episode. Thing that sticks out for me the most is that Naz didn't have any blood on him when he woke up in the kitchen and the knife he got her hand with was still on the table downstairs.
75
u/Iseecircles Jun 27 '16
This show is like the Serial Podcast on screen. Fantastic first episode.
75
u/TheMightyHash Jun 28 '16 edited Jun 28 '16
A few thoughts and observations I feel like I should bring to everyone's attention.
65
u/quiggleton Jun 25 '16
I'm loving this already but my god, come on Nasir! this guy has to have the worst luck, don't amplify it by being an idiot, leave the knife, clean it dammit man!
108
u/CallMe_DeaconBlues Jul 06 '16
So here's my problem it's 2014 and the two brothers are arguing about who's gonna do the majority of the scoring Melo or Amare??????? What the fuck is Amare gonna do? He hasn't been good since 2011!
42
u/cometparty The deer did it Jul 03 '16
Did anyone else notice that the refrigerator door was wide open behind him when he woke up asleep on the island in the kitchen and that he was fully clothed after previously having been naked?
Maybe he got up, got dressed, then went downstairs to leave, but then why would he have stopped in the kitchen? Was he that hungry? Maybe he was talking to somebody in the kitchen and they left the fridge open?
It's creeping me out knowing there was probably a third person there but nobody knowing who it was.
39
u/Ufookinwatm8 Jun 26 '16
Great start, I'm hooked already. I haven't seen it mentioned yet, but what's up with the hearse driver?
After he told her she would be his next passenger or whatever, he left the same time they did. Did he follow them? And I do think the guy Trevor was with will come into play somehow. Trevor was telling box he was alone for a reason...
33
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '16
He just kept digging his own grave!
Great show so far, well-casted and well-shot. It's going to be a long three weeks.
31
u/Milo_and_Tock Jul 14 '16
Anybody else notice the Jesus pose he struck when the cops were photographing him? That + the wound on his hand. Dude didn't do it, but he's going to be convicted. The innocent guy dying for the guilty one.
27
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '16
Jesus, this episode made me so anxious, more than maybe any other show I've watched. It was almost too overwhelming.
26
u/waltpsu Jun 26 '16
Just watched it, really enjoyed this first episode...but man all I could think of the whole time was Don't Talk To Police!!
26
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '16
A few stabs in the dark about what's coming in future episodes...
25
u/jk7724 Jun 29 '16
Probably doesn't mean anything, but very random thing I noticed is that when they parked his cab in front of her house when they first arrived, they very clearly parked in front of a hydrant. It seems there is a ticket on his windshield when he gets back in the car but the hydrant was in plain view for what seemed to be a slightly extended period of time initially, so I'm wondering how something like that could play into the plot or maybe an alibi.
20
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '16
LPT: DO NOT EVER TALK TO THE POLICE
20
u/TheOneWhoKnocks3 Jul 08 '16
I never heard anyone read Nas his Miranda rights, I was waiting for that. Also the consent he gave was for the search not for waiving Miranda warning.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '16
I think it's funny that we are calling bodie, bodie. Like what is his name in the show? I forgot lol all I see is bodie!!
18
u/azima143 Jul 03 '16
Just thought about how money will play part of the plot.
First is the lawyer. We know the lawyer isnt a public defender, so he'll want to be paid somehow and Nas' family doesn't have a lot of money. His dad's a cab driver, and not a "rich" one who owns cabs and rents them out. he co-owns and that's been emphasized. his mom works at a clothing store. she might co-own it.
The second is family income. The dad relies on the cab, which is now gone and not coming back for a while since it's evidence. Nas even says "my dad needs the car for work" and they show the dramatic scene of the dad going out to find his car missing. Unless the mom is a part owner of that store they're going to have a really rough time during the trial.
17
u/GetShwifty69 Jul 11 '16
I think the cat in the background of the final shot of the father is a hint that letting the cat out and leaving the door open is a key detail. Not saying that they are the same cat obviously, but I don't see any reason to go through the effort of putting a cat in that last scene other than the director sort of poking the viewer and winking.
Or maybe my heart rate is just elevated to the point that I'm overthinking everything...
17
u/chrismarshall Jul 13 '16
whoever surfaces later wearing the tan-brown hat that was hanging by the reindeer head…. is the killer
46
u/SevenwithaT Jul 11 '16
It's too bad Andrea is dead because I think I'm in love with her
16
u/MarionCotesworthHaye Jul 13 '16 edited Jul 16 '16
I can't believe they were able to breathe new life into TV depictions of police procedure. The way the various officers spoke and acted, the general demeanor of the precinct, the cataloging of evidence...it was all written and directed in such a unique, realistic way I almost forgot I've seen this stuff 10,000 times on Law & Order.
15
u/navjot94 Jun 26 '16
Do we even know who's apartment they were in? There was a hat hanging on the wall by the deer head, and it looked like a men's hat. Actually I'm not even sure if it was there after he woke up. It was definitely there when they first went upstairs.
14
u/kayzaaaaay Jul 01 '16
I wonder two things.
--What about the kid who was talking about basketball in the station and as they are about to release Naz they take the kid away and he asks a female cop if he can call his mom? I get that the kids talking about basketball in the station mirrors Nas and his brother talking about basketball at dinner, but why did the kid get another couple of lines to ask for his phone call? This show seems to do everything deliberately, so are they deliberately highlighting Naz's naivete and family connection with the kid, or will we see the kid again later somehow intwined with the death?
--I have a wild theory that the neighbor who saw Naz leave did it. Maybe Andrea is the neighbor's sugar baby. She pissed him off so when he saw the opportunity to kill her and frame Naz he took it. This theory has many holes (such as why did he have access to the neighbor's property to be in when he sees Naz, unless it is also his and he is renting the sugar apartment under a different name) but is building off the theme of watching and someone being in the apartment, and the hat that is on the deer.
14
u/andyznyc Jul 03 '16
If they just had sex and there was all that blood and stab wounds, I would think he would have much more blood on him or his clothes. I've watched enough Dexter to know that much. It's clear he didn't take a shower since his hands and back had some blood on it. All of that said, the other plausible theory that someone else broke in while he was passed out and stabbed her is seemingly far fetched. There was also the second black dude during that first encounter but I have a feeling it's a red herring because it is too obvious.
28
u/SwoopJones Jun 28 '16 edited Jul 17 '16
Here's what I caught, start to finish. Anyone connecting dots?
13
u/Garmana1 Jun 25 '16
I just finished it and I feel it is a strong start. Great acting all around.
13
u/Jbuckle3 Jul 14 '16
If you look at the scratches on his back, they seem to be too close together to be human. They kind of look like cat scratches (close together, parallel lines,) Her cat was put outside due to his asthma, but could have been let back in when someone opened the door. And I highly doubt either of them would let the cat in.
11
u/dr__lis Jun 29 '16
Evidence helping Naz's case:
Thoughts:
11
u/SevenwithaT Jul 11 '16 edited Jul 11 '16
Just got done, WOW. I don't remember the last time I've been on the edge of my seat like that. The movie "Apocalyptyo", probably. This show is excellent.
11
u/Moonboys_MoonDoor #FreeNasir Jul 14 '16
Can you imagine how awkward it would have been if Mustafa didn't leave his bombs at home? Endless possibilities.
20
u/jrsmusicman Jul 10 '16 edited Jul 11 '16
Watched this a couple of weeks ago and wanted to say how absolutely incredible the cinematography was within the first episode. The whole "eerie & dreary" grayscale NYC setting felt like a separate character to the whole plot and was what initially grabbed me.
That being said, I loved Riz Ahmed in "Nightcrawler" and I have a feeling this series is going to set his career off if each episode keeps delivering the same quality of "The Beach." You could truly feel his sense of panic and anxiety throughout the whole latter half of the episode and he really does amazing work with his eyes. I love the "nice guy, bad choice, wrong place, wrong time" characterization, as he exuded enough humbleness and quiet innocence to pull it off.
There was no clear cut suspect (as of now) and I'm sure there were a million clues that I missed, but I cannot wait for the next episode. I'm also in the boat where I think the "Miranda Rights" issue might come into play even though Naz said they were read to him. I love how worried his parents were about him and hope they become great secondary characters as well.
Early suspects: Drug dealer guy & Neighbor who made the call. Really hoping this is even better than True Detective S1.
20
u/Atmoze Jul 11 '16
I think Naz killed her.
-The girls mood is beyond strange, lives in the brownstones, when naz says you know do what everyone else wants you to do she responds "no I really dont". The transporting somewhere else when something bad happens makes me think she is somewhat sucidal. Seems like a girl with everything wealthy, attractive, but never is happy/smiles very somber mood, obv involved somewhat heavily with drugs.
-I think she was suicidal, saw naz liked her so he could be easily manipulated, obv liked pain it turned her on, convinced naz to stab her in bed and he just listened like before/wasn't at full mental capacity.
-I believe the show will show how people like to believe someone is innocent even when their is overwhelming evidence is stacked against them. Every person right now are playing detective thinking of who else could have done it, when the answer is actually right in front of you.
-I also believe it will play on the stereotype that all cops are corrupt/shady. When his lawyer hears Box is on the case he is visibly upset more upset then when he finds out the girl was murdered, I believe this is because he knows Box plays by the rules follows proper protocol. Everyone automatically assume cops are shady/do unethical things, but are willing to take far bigger leaps of faith to believe naz is innocent.
10
u/severaltons Jul 13 '16
When Naz retrieved the knife, it was on the coffee table, pretty much right where he left it after playing the knife game with Andrea.
I have a feeling that will be important later. I'm going to go home and see if we can see where the knife is when they run upstairs to bone, and compare that to where it is when Naz grabs it on the way out.
10
u/LaMirage131 Jul 13 '16
There's faint evidence that someone was fleeing the murder scene. When Naz wakes up on the kitchen counter with his water, you can hear a car outside speeding away. The engine revs loudly, indicating it was starting from a dead stop and accelerating away quickly. You hear a car honk, possibly implying that the fleeing car pulled out quickly in front of the other car, who in turn, honked at him. Later, when Naz get back into his Dad's cab to flee the scene himself, he pulls out into the street so quickly that another car honks at him in an ironically similar manner.
9
u/AvocadoAndBacon Jun 27 '16
This episode was great, such great detail and story telling. I'm going to go back and watch it again because I want to make sure I don't miss a ounce of detail. Cannot wait for EP. 2
9
u/VermontPizza Jul 01 '16
The motorcyclist in all black who pulled up next to Nassir, then stared at the knife on the dash of the cab.. His headlight was out on the bike, he/she will probably get pulled over by the cops and not contribute positively to Nassir's situation.
edit: words
9
u/amisoz Jul 14 '16
But why didn't he just take the F train to downtown...
17
u/JM2845 Jul 11 '16
Just watched the premiere high and it was intense af
8
u/HotKarll Jun 30 '16
just watched the first episode finally and WOW, then I rewatched it an hour later because I couldn't stop thinking about all the scenarios. late to the discussion party unfortunately but a few things I'll mention that really stuck out to me.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '16
Anyone think Bodie's friend had a role?
8
u/Aaronimoe Jul 11 '16
I have a feeling his knife is not going to match all the wounds that killed her. She mentioned she couldn't be alone that night so maybe she was caught up in some shit already.
8
u/sbvballer Jul 13 '16
It is still unclear (and mentioned several times) if the knife is serrated or not. The knife on Naz (which he picks up downstairs) is NOT serrated. I would think the ME's report will be clear about the type of knife used. It would be an interesting story arc to have the report come back 'serrated' but have the police ignore this detail and try to make everything stick to Naz.
15
u/axionic Jul 13 '16
Anyone who's ever watched or written a series like this will expect the killer to make their first innocuous appearance in episode one, not episode six- that would be lame. So we've probably seen him already, and we can restrict our analysis to the relevant 20 minute interval (from 10 to 30 minutes into episode one).
So let's eliminate some suspects right away:
There are at least 4 likely suspects at this point:
Some obviously big clues spill out of Andrea's mouth when she gets in the cab, indicating danger nearby:
A lot of people watching this have expressed incredulity that this girl can afford to live in an apartment in that area. Where did she get the deer head- did she shoot it herself? Maybe she's living off a dead father's inheritance? That's the most trivial explanation- but this is a murder mystery, after all, so I'm thinking she might have been blackmailing somebody.
The biggest clue is the second entrance which she uses to deposits the cat outside. Neither the wrought iron gate nor the door behind it seem to latch as she goes back in, and they made sure to film it not latching, so chances are 100% that the killer entered through there. (Naz clearly doesn't know that it exists or he wouldn't have smashed the glass at the main door to get back inside.) Now who else might have known about the second entrance? There's no clear reason why Trevor's Friend or Hearse Guy would have known of its existence. But Nosy Neighbor would certainly have been aware of it.
If this were real life, I'd say the second entrance makes Nosy Neighbor the prime suspect (after Naz of course). But since it's fiction, the CC-TV at the gas station points strongly toward Hearse Guy. (The only alternatives are Trevor's Friend, and- if he turns out to be a separate character- Motorcycle Guy.)
20
u/Buckeyes2010 Jul 12 '16
I know some people have written up some great analysis on the deer scene. Seeing the mount made me feel very uneasy. Definitely a feeling of being watched.
Another point a wanted to make, coincidence or not, was the hearse driver scene
It's almost symbolic to me that the hearse driver represented the Reaper. Dressed in all black and driving a hearse. He asked her if she wanted to be his next passenger. She said no. He didn't like that answer too much. And put out the cigarette on the window and left an ash mark, almost as if she was marked for death.
14
u/coldancer Jul 11 '16
Amazing scene change right after they have nasir strip down to nothing. detective box is sitting right at the exact level where nas' exposed penis would be and then bam! There is a phallic shaped finger (nas' finger) being inked for prints. Love little things like that.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '16
The suspense of him helplessly sitting in the back of the car is excellent.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '16
Naz (sp?) doesn't do drugs on the reg. He did cocaine and ex for probably the first time of his life. How the fuck does he go to sleep? The first time I did either of those drugs I was up all night. Not to mention the adrenaline from meeting a new girl, stabbing her, and fucking her. How the fuck did he fall asleep soundly enough to not wake up to her being stabbed in the same house.
I think he did it. They showed us everything except when he actually killed her.
7
u/JOJOtookyoHOHO Jul 11 '16
Already rewatched once to see if i missed anything. And the hearse driver seemed sketchy and so did the black guys friends . anyone else get the vibe? Just the way both of them stared at him made them seem off to me
7
u/nfleite Jul 14 '16
Does anyone else thought it was super weird the amount of focus they gave to that deer head? It made me think that maybe there's a camera there.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '16
Amazing construct, acting and production value. Thought the portrayal of the girl (affluent, careless, dark and mysterious) was a bit clichéd. But so far, fantastic show!
6
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '16
Given how many times she was stabbed and how much blood was on the bed/surrounding area, wouldn't Nasir have WAY more blood on him if he did it? Seems like a simple thing the lawyer can bring up, he clearly never changed clothes.
6
u/Halo909 Jul 03 '16
I only have one question after watching the first episode. How can someone be so stupid?
6
u/openandreal Jul 06 '16
I honestly want to reach into the TV and shake Naz tell him to STFU and ask for a lawyer. Just please Naz stop talking to the police. They are Not there to help you. I can see the train wreck hurling a thousand miles an hour about to crash into huge mess. Cant wait till 17th!!!
5
u/z0okie Jul 05 '16
Couldn't help but notice that the girl's front door locked on it's own when Nas left the house after finding her body. For that reason, I believe whoever ended up murdering her had obviously entered through the backdoor when she let out the cat. Not sure if that points in any specific direction, just was thinking about the entry point.
5
u/Burrrat Jul 12 '16
I think we can all say on how the director shot the scene. That whoever is riding the motorcycle is the murderer. I don't think we've met him/her yet and will probably meet this person soon in the upcoming episodes.
5
u/MarionCotesworthHaye Jul 13 '16
I can't believe the entire series (except for the final episode) has already been screened by critics. Interesting tactic.
5
u/Classic1990 Jew Time, Jew Crime Jul 13 '16
I'm not sure what to think yet. There's a handful of suspects and Nas has some unanswered questions to.
Some people I find suspicious:
The two guys that jumped in the taxi - Just seemed like a weird scene that didn't go anywhere. It didn't add anything to the story and the show runners could've easily just skipped to the girl getting in the car.
The guy from the gas station - He had a strange look as Nas was driving off but that's about it besides for being annoyed about the cig. Probably nothing.
The racist black guy - I don't think he had anything to do with it. Just seems like an asshole. He did lie to the cop about being alone, though.
Racist black guy's friend - I don't think it's him but that creepy stare after the confrontation was strange. I did notice that when she let the cat out she didn't close the gate properly so if it is one of these two than they had a way inside.
That's it for suspects besides Nas himself. I did think it was weird that Nas woke up at the table and was fully dressed with no blood on him except for his hand. You would think someone who stabbed a girl to death and covered the bed blood would have a stain or two. The knife ending up in his pocket is also weird.
Then as I was typing this out I was thinking about everything the girl said to Nas, about how she wanted to go to the beach and didn't want to be alone that night. What if she was contemplating suicide? We saw how easily it was for her to talk him into the drugs and the knife game. What if she asked him to mercy kill her and he was so high that he agreed and doesn't remember? It's a far fetched theory but who knows.
All I can say is that I'm intrigued and can't wait for the next episode.
8
u/droninglocust Jul 12 '16
First of all, I wish every episode was out because I would binge this show all night right now.
Secondly, I am loving Box. Such a good character, he is a massive asshole.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '16
Does anyone else think the hearse driver did it?
4
u/fmkhan213 Jun 30 '16
Well I have seen "How to Get Away with Murder" upto such extent that Naz reminded me of Wes.. and I have been taking mental notes of what's happening, could happen, who could be a suspect, the witnesses, murder weapon, his mistakes.. not asking for a lawyer before speaking up...etc. etc. I guess they have developed an excellent pilot episode, and this can become one of the amazing mini series (at least of this particular genre)
4
u/Sk81099 Jul 04 '16
So did anyone else see the dead girls cat pass behind his dad at the very end?
4
u/golfer74 Jul 11 '16
Will the mishandling of the evidence mean anything?
4
u/MasterPL25 Jul 11 '16
I've only seen it once but for some reason what keeps sticking with me is when the cat was let out the back door, wasn't there another screen door directly next to hers into another building??? Seems plausiable that a "third person" could come in and out of there pretty quickly and efficiently to muder Andrea if so. Could have walked right past Naz just conked out on the island and getting a tan from the refrigerator light...
4
u/duh_metrius Jul 13 '16
Reading theories about the hearse driver is giving me True Detective Season 1 theory vibes. I'd bet a lot of money that his main significance will be that he is called in as a witness to testify to the fact that he saw Nas with the girl. Other than some foreshadowing ("You trying to be my next passenger?") that's likely to be his role.
4
u/lobster777 Jul 13 '16
Is it true that if Naz did not consent to dna and blood samples, the court order would take 45 minutes in the middle of the night? Or was this BS on the detective to convince him to concent?
4
u/SpanishK Jul 13 '16
Why has nobody mentioned the dude on the motorbike that pulls up alongside Nas when Nas is leaving the crime scene? Or have we all just assumed that the mystery rider was a red herring too?
9
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '16
Damn better than True Detective as far as I'm concerned. The first ep of True Detective definitely wasn't as consistent in quality as this, in my opinion. Really wish I waited for the rest of it to be released is all, considering it's hard to watch the first episode and get much more than set up. But then again, the is how HBO keeps viewership up.. So yeah, I'll be there in 2 weeks to watch the next episode, that's for sure.
11
u/newmellofox Jul 11 '16
Kinda confused what the big deal is with this alleged "crime scene"? How do yall have sex? Everything seemed normal to me.
11
u/gobackclark Jun 25 '16
I can't decide if all of Nas's poor decisions was lazy writing or showing the reality of someone panicking. I mean, come on. You take the knife with you in your jacket? Forget the fact that that's the murder weapon, who puts a long knife like that in their coat pocket?
Forgetting his keys, breaking the window, not obeying traffic laws, trying to run. Am I being too harsh in thinking his actions were a little ridiculous?
3
u/branflora Jun 26 '16 edited Jun 26 '16
I love the series so far. Was screaming during the revelation scene. Yelling, going to be a long wait. Wish they just released all the episodes but I guess this will build the suspense even more.
3
u/wooble89 Jun 28 '16
The direction in this was so on point. Every quiet moment had me on the edge.
The authenticity to the actions and characters is something else. Really riveting stuff.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '16
I was floored by this show. Amazing acting.
3
u/PaintedBird22 Jew Time, Jew Crime Jul 05 '16
Why wasn't Naz Mirandized?
3
u/suxela_mart Jul 06 '16
One thing I'm wondering about...Why would she start trying to stab her hand and then ask him to do it. Its like if she wanted his fingerprint on the knife. Idk I could be far reaching but its a little suspicious or coincidental to me.
3
u/unclebatts Jul 07 '16
Something that's been bothering me about the front door of her house is when it locks/doesn't lock...when they first arrive at the apartment she uses a key to get in. Then he runs out to his cab, forgets his keys, and runs back in only the door is locked again so he has to break in. But then when the cops get there, they open the door no problem. Why didn't it lock again? This is important because if the door auto-locks, how did anyone else get in there to commit the murder? If it doesn't auto-lock, then why did Naz have to break in to get his keys?
3
u/tonyjefferson Jul 11 '16
Isn't the Deer mount completely hung differently from the moment before they sleep together to the scene where he wakes up in the kitchen and walks upstairs? Also it had a hat on it before they slept together?? Or does she have multiple deer mounts in this ridiculously sweet apartment?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '16
Who saw the stairs leading up outside of the bedroom as Nasir was walking in to put on his clothes? Is there a third floor?
3
u/93devil Jul 13 '16
Smoking is brought up twice in this episode. The first time was Andrea flicking out the lit cig from the cab and the second was the detective smoking at the crime scene.
This is too random for it to be nothing. It was put in for a reason, I think.
3
u/93devil Jul 13 '16
And if this was written with Serial, Season 1 in mind, I would not be shocked if Naz is the killer and we see glimpses of his anger as the season moves forward.
This could also morph into something similiar to the old Richard Gere/Edward Norton movie where Norton does a very abrupt character change after the trial.
5
u/Fisticuffs111 Jul 11 '16 edited Jul 11 '16
One thing I haven't seen mentioned, and I don't particularly think they had anything to do with the murder itself, but those two guys who got in the cab before Andrea got in. Like I wonder if they could know who or what Andrea was involved with, what she was kind of running from, even if they were just random witnesses and saw something before Naz showed up.
Plus, they seemed kinda high IMO, seemed like the type of dudes who could've possibly been hanging out with or around her that night.
5
u/TomisUnice Jul 12 '16
Every little thing that happened with Andrea felt like a clue. Brilliant.