r/TheNightOf • u/NicholasCajun • Jul 17 '16
The Night Of - Episode 2 "Subtle Beast" - Episode Discussion
Episode 2: Subtle Beast
Aired: July 17th, 2016
Episode Synopsis: As attorney John Stone counsels Naz, lead detective Dennis Box investigates the crime.
Directed by: Steven Zaillian
Written by: Richard Price
Keep in mind that discussion concerning episode previews, IMDB casting information, the BBC series Criminal Justice and other future information needs to be inside a spoiler tag.
Use this spoiler tag format:
[SPOILER](#s "Night") which will appear as SPOILER
234
Upvotes
371
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
hahaha Jew Time do a Jew Crime is best line ever
239
u/mydarkmeatrises Jul 18 '16
Criminals are even stunned. Funniest moment of the episode
258
u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Jul 18 '16
This show is a master class on what not to do if you are detained by the police
126
u/shortymoscato Jul 18 '16
the acting in this show is phenomenal
119
u/MikeyMadness83 Jul 18 '16
I know they are painting Stone like he is out of his league, but something tells me he knows the deal. He knew they didn't have enough to bring the charges immediately and he handled himself great during the arraignment. Him wanting his son to do the paper on Thurgood and the degrees on his wall makes me think he used to be a bit more prominent but something happened. Maybe im reaching.
As of right now, it looks like this is just a payday for him, but I hope at some point he shows he's got what it takes. Even the ADA knows this isn't a slam dunk.
118
u/daddylikedat Jul 18 '16
The van loading/transport scene was terrific and terrifying.
95
u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Jul 18 '16
Love how HBO re-uses actors from other series, first we get Bodie and now Little Carmine from the Sopranos
91
u/losterps Jul 18 '16
God damn it this show has been on for one week and I'm already planning my entire day around it.
87
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
One thing stuck out to me tonight. Box said "Harris got the blade to within half an inch." There is a very strong chance that that knife on Naz is not the same knife used for the crime. It may have just been the knife from downstairs that he cut Andrea with on the hand. We'll see! I wouldn't be surprised if this pops back up with more testing.
86
u/scottfiab Jul 18 '16
That awkward moment when mom finds condoms in your backpack.
153
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
I can't get over how well-shot this show is. That scene in the autopsy room was so well done.
72
u/darkknight915 Jul 18 '16
Box really doesn't seem so sure of this case, he's trying to goad a confession out of Naz.
127
u/MostlyPurple Jul 18 '16
Was I the only one thinking that the opening sequence was indicating some kind of other presence in the house while they were there?
44
u/Puddy1 Jul 19 '16
Don't think anyone has mentioned it but I love the futile attempt Naz's parents have at trying to learn about the court system through NYCourts.gov
127
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
The stepdad is really suspicious.
43
u/mydarkmeatrises Jul 18 '16
The theme of the night is
Shut up
113
u/scottfiab Jul 18 '16
I like how the writer from House of Cards is in this.
78
u/darkknight915 Jul 18 '16
His parents are handling this extraordinarily well.
197
u/MrRedTRex Jul 18 '16
I was arrested for a pretty minor crime (in comparison to homicide) that I didn't commit in NYC, in 2014. My experience was very similar to Nasir's, so far. In fact, I love this show so far but it's been legitimately hard for me to watch at times. It's that accurate.
37
u/naterrrrrrr Jul 18 '16
Okay maybe I'm reading too much into it, but here's something I noticed. In the car ride to the Naz's taxi that's being sweeped for evidence, Box is listening to a song from an opera. The song is Au Fond Du Temple Saint. I looked it up to see when it's used and what it's about, and this is wikipedia described it as:
"A key moment in the opera, this duet is the clearest depiction of the triangular relationships between the protagonists. The obvious situation at this point is that males will value their friendship higher than a heterosexual relationship.[1] Peter Weir uses this duet in his 1981 film Gallipoli without the heterosexual aspect, purely to express male mateship and loyalty between a pair of doomed soldiers.[2] A different view is possible by a reading of the duet as a "pair of parallel monologues",[3] emphasizing the rivalry and deceit between the men."
So maybe Naz's brother/cousin (the other guy living with him) or his friend that ditched the party is involved. Also, in the jail, why did they decide to specifically point out that the officers didn't know who the guy sitting next to Naz's parents are?
164
u/PhinsPhan89 Jul 18 '16
Accepting the inhaler found at the crime scene means it's his. Another less-than-smart move, Nas.
81
u/MarionCotesworthHaye Jul 18 '16
Did Box put Naz in a Harvard t-shirt because he's a BEAST who wants Naz to be targeted at Rikers, or because he's SUBTLE and doesn't think Naz did it and thought Harvard would present well in front of the judge?
172
u/scottfiab Jul 18 '16
I think John Turturro's foot condition is a little overstated and irrelevant.
25
u/Tha_HNIC Jul 18 '16
Don't fuck with Hightower.
46
u/cy1763 Jul 18 '16
"Now Remember, don't talk to anyone."
5 mins later...
"Hi Mom and Dad, so here's what happened while I'm being recorded." Facepalm
45
u/rnon Jul 18 '16
Michael K. Williams next episode!
20
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
Been looking forward to this for weeks.
67
u/Lane95 Jul 18 '16
That fucking deer head has a camera in it's eye or something.
18
u/Vindictus7 Jul 18 '16
What would have to happen for the step father to receive Andrea's inheritance?
I posted last week that a small pet theory of mine was that she was offed because someone was chasing her inheritance. Now that we've confirmed both of her biological parents are dead, what would it take for the step father to be next in line? He mentioned that he and her mother were only married a short time. But by calling himself her step father, that would mean that he took over as a legal guardian right?
18
u/MarionCotesworthHaye Jul 18 '16
That prosecutor is gonna be an awesome character. She's like Judge Jeanine Pirro on too much Ativan.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
I really liked the subtle beast speech. So true of the system.
17
u/Jakem5686 Jul 18 '16
Why so much emphasis on Stone's eczema/feet?
16
u/youngmermaid Jul 18 '16
Fuuuuuuck Rikers!? This show makes me one big stress ball
15
u/JOJOtookyoHOHO Jul 18 '16
When Naz is first getting transported to jail and then how he looks around when he is just entering is exactly how it feels the first time . Just a feeling of " is this really happening? " and how long will i have to play this out. Its not a good feeling. Have to adjust to a whole new lifestyle fast.
30
u/MikeKrombopulos Jul 18 '16
Turturro said the name of the ep
64
u/12millercs Jul 18 '16
Man this show just shows how, in our judicial system, you're guilty until proven innocent.
I'm 75% sure he didn't do it, but either way, he; like many others, is being treated unjustly.
13
u/darkknight915 Jul 18 '16
There's gotta be a wrench thrown in this episode in this case, some kind of break for Naz.
24
u/Rastagaryenxx Jul 18 '16
Either I've watched too much SVU, or the stepfather did it.
...or Bodie.
12
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
I'm just hoping this doesn't turn into 'How To Get Away With Murder' quality.
12
u/jarkmames Jul 18 '16
Anyone else in the legal field want to play spot the constitutional violations for the next episodes?
Been having fun thus far.
21
u/SleepingAntz Jul 18 '16
Something that I'm not sure anyone else has mentioned...when they did the muffled flashback to the night of the murder, they showed the exchange that goes
"Do you have a girlfriend?"
"No, do you?"
"Would that turn you on?"
Which just seemed like a natural, inconsequential conversational dialogue but it was interesting that they showed it again. Also of note is that Naz wakes up in the kitchen with ZERO blood on him. Unless he took a 45 minute shower and did a full wash/dry of the clothes he woke up in there's no way he was in the room when Andrea got stabbed. There was blood everywhere.
I am thinking that maybe a third party (based on the dialogue, a girl, but a guy would work too) was brought in at some point after Naz blacked out. Maybe it gets a little weird and Naz goes downstairs to get some water for a break, and then he passes out while things get out of hand without him.
I understand this is a big leap to take off of one dialogue exchange but I just thought it was interesting. Other thoughts:
9
u/scottfiab Jul 18 '16
Wow, it's a very different perspective from the beginning of this ep
9
u/IamDa5id Jul 18 '16
The junkie in the holding cell is Phreak from Hackers... cannot unsee!
15
u/Enders_Sack Jul 18 '16
Someone inside the jail knows something about the crime
20
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
Everyone ready for some Ballers?
7
u/zsreport A Subtle Beast Jul 18 '16
A real life version of the bus that transported Naz from The Tombs to Rikers Island.
7
u/CommanderSnow Jul 18 '16
I thought the directing was excellent this episode.
Think we will be seeing Michael K Williams next week?
13
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
HBO gonna go avant-garde and reveal the killer(s) in episode 2.
36
u/badoosh123 Jul 18 '16
Great acting, directing, and cinematography, but this episode was a bit slow. It's ok as I understand the show is going for a slower burn and you need the episodes that do the setup like this one. However, I do hope they pick up the pace in the future episodes. Still, though, the production quality is great.
18
u/darkknight915 Jul 18 '16
Shut up Naz shut up shut up shut up shut up shut up!
18
u/chezzie11 Jul 18 '16
the cinematography is just insanely good
6
u/MikeKrombopulos Jul 18 '16
Box gettin on the parents' good side
10
u/sporkintheroad Jul 18 '16
Naz must be innocent, and here's why; there's blood spatter all around the victim, but not a drop on him. Other than his hand of course, but we know that story.
19
u/MikeyMadness83 Jul 18 '16
One thing not adding up is his lack of emotion. I know we can attribute it to shock, but at some point all of this needs to sink in. I've been in central booking in NYC and it is HORRIFYING. And now he's on his way to Rikers without a single tear or any excrement in his pants?! I get that it's all a whirlwind, but I need some more anxiety if I want to believe he is truly innocent. He didn't even blink at the possibility of life. Great show either way.
8
u/flyingblackpig Jul 18 '16 edited Jul 19 '16
I think the step father is the killer. Andrea was stabbed brutally. This means that the murder was not done by any random guy like the hearse driver or the racist guy or so. And the money is not the cause of such brutality. The step father probably was her lover. They were in relationship and they just broke up at his place in Queens. He followed her to the apartment and came into the apartment before Andrea and Naz came in. He was waiting inside for Andrea. Then he watched the play by Andrea and Naz. He became furious so he murdered her and left through the backdoor. The black guy who was living in the street knew this. So when he saw Andrea getting in with a stranger man (Naz), he stared at them.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
Deer head - Chekhov's gun or red herring? Last week it reminded me of the weird animal heads on the wall in True Detective S2 and I didn't think anything of it until I saw it pointed out here that the camera definitely showed it deliberately several times. Tonight it is almost overly obvious that it is there for a reason. Or they're just fucking with us.
3
u/catfashion Jul 18 '16
Was that judge a lawyer on Law & Order SVU? If so, maybe it's a crossover and he finally got his judgeship.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
After Nas leaves, why would the judge congratulate Stone on getting the case?
3
u/doocurly Jul 18 '16
I know that the reason we are discussing the murder in this series is because we all know there is more to the story than what meets they eye. I have a feeling though, that as episode two has shown, that IRL, that all of this circumstantial evidence would be more than enough to convict Nasir and no one would ever look back on it. I guess what I'm saying is that no matter how this unfolds, my guess is that short of someone else confessing, that a jury would still say it was the guy in her house that stabbed her hand and had sex with her. I think that it's fun to go on a journey, but juries are not comprised of people who really want to get to the bottom of murders. Juries are comprised of people who have been selected by attorneys because they can't relate, never heard of something, aren't familiar with, et cetera, and they want someone to give them something easy so they can go home. Nas would still be convicted by a jury in this country no matter how the rest of this plays out.
3
u/junior40 Jul 18 '16
Naz is so idiotic.
3
u/jarvik7 Jul 19 '16
Man the title sequence for this show sucks. It's like they bought the GENERIC MOODY TITLE SEQUENCE template from the same production company as True Detective (which had better music anyway).
6
u/MikeKrombopulos Jul 18 '16
deer head again
7
u/hotsauzz69 Jul 18 '16
I'm buying into the too obvious giveaway from the episode 3 preview that Michael K. Williams will be coming out of that ominous jail cell. (OMAR COMIN' Y'ALL!) I'm also thinking the Hightower character will be his second-in-command or something of that ilk. He was acknowledged twice in this ep as someone who consistently is being tried by the courts (the cops checking for paraphernalia and the judge denying Naz's bail.) and also the perpetrator of the jail cell beatdown. He seems too important to just let go of in the story.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
Remember the inhaler, folks.
4
u/NPTVN Jul 18 '16
Was it just me or was there blood on the stepfather's fingers when he signed that form at the morgue?
2
u/MikeKrombopulos Jul 18 '16
Here we go
2
u/MarionCotesworthHaye Jul 18 '16 edited Jul 18 '16
Something I noticed: The actress who plays Andrea is named in the show's opening credit sequence. Normally wouldn't a one-off appearance be credited as a guest star? Does this mean she'll be back?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
I thought the ending of this episode was so great I remained firm in my decision not to watch previews of next week. Rikers looked like "all kinds of wait until you see what goes on in here".
2
u/atlStylez Jul 23 '16
I honestly believe the killer was shown during the first episode. Maybe the friend of Trevor who stares back at Andrea and Nazir as they walk into her house or maybe the guy driving a hearse who threatens that Andrea might be the next one he drives.