r/TheNightOf • • Aug 08 '16

The Night Of - Episode 5 "The Season of the Witch" - Episode Discussion

Episode 5: The Season of the Witch

Aired: August 7th, 2016


Episode Synopsis: Detective Box reconstructs Naz’s whereabouts on “the night of.”


Directed by: Steven Zaillian

Written by: Richard Price & Steven Zaillian


Keep in mind that discussion concerning episode previews, IMDB casting information, the BBC series Criminal Justice and other future information needs to be inside a spoiler tag. Use this spoiler tag format: [SPOILER](#s "Night") which will appear as SPOILER

341 Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

465

u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Aug 08 '16

"Guess what, his name really is Duane Reade." This episode has been excellent haha

40

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 08 '16

Somebody hunted down IMDb a few weeks ago and mentioned that name. I had to stop for a moment to assess why I had a reaction when that name was spoken.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (27)

382

u/MarionCotesworthHaye Aug 08 '16

Excuse me while I casually retrieve these bags of coke from my vagina

→ More replies (23)

380

u/Cuse88 Aug 08 '16

Was not expecting a shot of a deceased man's penis.

96

u/Halo2isbetter Aug 08 '16

My mom happened to walk in and I was telling her about how good this show was and then BAM dead guys penis.

149

u/FKDotFitzgerald Aug 08 '16

HBO has had a thing for gross cock close-ups this year.

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (15)

359

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

I want to hire Michael K. Williams to look at me with stern approval while I work out like he does with Nas. I'd be so fucking motivated and jacked.

52

u/DPool34 Aug 08 '16

That's a good idea for a work out video. Just cut the scene with MKW, and run it on a loop...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

321

u/MarionCotesworthHaye Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16

The actress playing the DA is a fantastic representation of the tired, overworked, put-upon, but still-diligent-as-hell New Yorker archetype.

117

u/CammmJ Aug 08 '16

I still can't tell if she's a real person.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '16

Agree 100. She's a great character actress. And she is the epitome of the female working class New Yorker over the age of 50. I've known a few of her. Actually, I think I AM one of her (head slap... God, help me).

→ More replies (23)

315

u/PinkHK5213 Aug 08 '16

Ok I bust out laughing when he bombed the cat with a shit ton of cat toys and they landed all around him lol

110

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 08 '16

I started laughing when he was shopping for those things. Very well chosen assortment.

He rolled the individual playballs to the cashier....

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (10)

303

u/losterps Aug 08 '16

My mom: "oh no he has beautiful hair"

120

u/daybowbowchica Aug 08 '16

I was kinda bummed when he shaved it. But he actually looks pretty good with a buzzed head!

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (47)

240

u/CARNIesada6 Aug 08 '16

Detective box, just look on reddit, someone already mapped it out for ya

→ More replies (11)

232

u/norvnotdumb Aug 08 '16

His plan is to chase the potential murderer into a dark alley and then...

228

u/tonyjefferson Aug 08 '16

....So he can kill me and I can finally not have to deal with my eczema anymore.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (20)

228

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

How thoughtful of Freddy to not let the kid swallow his mom's vagina eightballs.

118

u/MCShereKhan I miss the Old Nasir. Aug 08 '16

Hahaha. This was a rite of passage for Nas and looks like he passed it. Well. Three out of four.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (10)

218

u/TheChicagoMethod Aug 08 '16

That shadiness of the morgue employee/ specialist is appalling. That...and the unnecessary zombie cock shots.

84

u/NurRauch Aug 08 '16

Yeah that was pretty sad. The medical examiner in my county prides himself on his impartiality and the fact that his office is not connected with a police agency or the prosecutors.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

183

u/MikeKrombopulos Aug 08 '16

The gate failing to close is now officially relevant

106

u/mm825 Aug 08 '16

That inspector guy was awesome, great guest character

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

518

u/FKDotFitzgerald Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16

I'm so glad Stone knew what Naz was doing the entire time. That scene was played so intelligently.

159

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Same here. It was so obvious.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Which scene?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

174

u/I_am_Nobody_Special Aug 08 '16

Trevor's a dead man.

152

u/Jovial_2k Aug 08 '16

Stone screwed Trevor real bad. First name he mentioned.

→ More replies (6)

59

u/Coop_the_Poop_Scoop Jew Time, Jew Crime Aug 08 '16

I feel like Stone did that on purpose, and maybe has a plan. Maybe convincing Trevor to testify truthfully and try to get a witness protection deal or something.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

160

u/Toberoni Aug 08 '16

LA DRO

34

u/MikeKrombopulos Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16

What could it mean??

edit: guys pls I was kidding

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (13)

151

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Ok.... now i'm torn between the hilarious judge and the hilarious pharmacist for favorite (comedic) character. "VIAGRA."

119

u/FKDotFitzgerald Aug 08 '16

Everyone in this show is so savage.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (14)

300

u/Sykotik Aug 08 '16

Did he take a picture of a blind spot? Where you can't see into the kitchen from the stairs?

131

u/PinkHK5213 Aug 08 '16

Ohhhh thank you! I was trying to make sense of that shot...totally nailed it.

→ More replies (48)

43

u/mr_chiller Aug 08 '16

Interesting. I guess so. I also noticed when Naz was describing his account of the night we were shown fuzzy flashbacks. The last lingering flashback was from the vantage that guy took the picture from (going up the stairs).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

136

u/norvnotdumb Aug 08 '16

"You could have worn shoes though." We were all thinking it.

106

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

"I'm afraid those days are gone." Poor John :(

→ More replies (5)

123

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Damn this whole thing where Nasir's father is being asked to charge his son with grand theft auto is heart wrenching. (But i think its gonna play out in some fashion at the end.)

52

u/thegouch Aug 08 '16

I know the dad is completely distraught, but he seems to be acting like a real douche about the taxi to his two partners, who are quite polite about the whole thing. I'm not saying the father should be willing to charge his son, but acting a little more interested in helping his friends/business partners out would probably be prudent.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (4)

220

u/MarionCotesworthHaye Aug 08 '16

The actor playing Naz continues to age 3-4 years each episode.

67

u/Willy_B_Hardigan Aug 08 '16

That's what shaving your head and growing stubble will do for you.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

305

u/obeythed Aug 08 '16

The coroner basically implying he'd lie on the stand pissed me off to no end. It's really hard to have faith in our justice system when people like that exist.

114

u/blockem Aug 08 '16

I think it's showing that so many things can be 50/50 and depending on who's asking the questions, a bunch of 50/50s can lead to a conviction.

→ More replies (1)

120

u/creesa The deer did it Aug 08 '16

Yeah, that annoyed the hell out of me, because you just KNOW the show isn't stretching the truth very much. I'm sure that kinda shit happens all the time.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

200

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Was that scene showing an inner temper in Naz (that could've been released when he possibly killed Andrea) or was it showing the criminal justice system turn an innocent man into a criminal? I have a feeling we won't know which until the smoke clears.

46

u/MarionCotesworthHaye Aug 08 '16

Both, which is what makes it so good

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

98

u/mylo8912 Aug 08 '16

someone needs to compile the Stone cat adoption scenes and put them to a good song and have it be the next SPCA commerical

→ More replies (4)

93

u/hammyhands Aug 08 '16

Did Jerry Gurgich just steal Stone's girl?

63

u/TheCenci Aug 08 '16

Hahaha well if that was Jerry then that woman is going to be satisfied.

→ More replies (5)

266

u/MarionCotesworthHaye Aug 08 '16

How much time are we supposed to believe has passed? Naz looks like The Rock.

97

u/karthenon Aug 08 '16

The produce in Andrea's refrigerator don't seem to have gone bad yet.

→ More replies (7)

55

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

The security tape from Box standing on the street corner said 11/24/2014 so it was exactly a month after "the night of"

→ More replies (1)

128

u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Aug 08 '16

No kidding, he got freaking swole in since last week's episode

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

261

u/BlueHighwindz Aug 08 '16

Bodie knows not to be snitching. Last time he talked to the cops... didn't end too well for him.

22

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 08 '16

Milk and cookies can't get what a heart to heart discussion (and the fear of being contacted with eczema) in La Dro gets you.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

82

u/POPNWAFFLES Aug 08 '16

Still not buying Nas having done it, the back door being broke seems to kill that theory imo.

25

u/goalstopper28 Aug 08 '16

I think we all know that Nas didn't do it. It's just trying to figure out who did it. Whatever it is I think the step-father is involved.

→ More replies (5)

158

u/R-Lu Aug 08 '16

totally thought stone was oblivious when naz was swallowing coke, that dude is so damn sharp and doesn't miss a beat. shame he has a bad rap as a scum lawyer

57

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

When Nas shit them out he said he took 4 and one hadn't come out yet. But I thought he only swallowed 3. Did I miss one or is Nas lying?

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (5)

332

u/Sykotik Aug 08 '16

This cat is such a metaphor for Nas it's not even funny. Out of the shit hole and into better digs with plenty of toys but still in a cell at the end of the day.

84

u/reegstah Aug 08 '16

Had me real worried tonight when Stone kept trying to help the cat despite the allergies "killing him."

34

u/Thewideout4 Aug 08 '16

Good observation

→ More replies (5)

72

u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Aug 08 '16

Chandra is sitting there thinking, "what the hell did i get myself into"

→ More replies (8)

71

u/ayebreh Aug 08 '16

Really love how Freddy's motive for protecting Nas turned out to be that he just needed a new desperate guy to do his dirty work for him. Lots of viewers really liked Freddy's 'care package for my brain" shtick, but I'm kind of happy they kept it realistic and turned him into the ultimate bad guy with amazing manipulation skills that even had us fooled for an episode or two. Nothing's sweet up at Rikers.

45

u/Toberoni Aug 08 '16

I think it goes both ways. Freddy appreciates that he has "an intelligent equal". But on the other hand he has to establish his superiority.

Hope Naz isn't getting a little too cocky for his own good.

→ More replies (9)

70

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

We all know what comes next. The swastika tatoo.

→ More replies (5)

137

u/Bravely_Default Guilty Aug 08 '16

Shaving his head was a mistake, makes him look like much more of a hardened criminal and much less of a babe in the woods; bad for the defense. The DA coaching the corner was also sickening, but I'm sure that exactly how things are done.

Nas might not have entered rikers as a criminal but he's going to leave a completely changed man, shaped by being around criminals 24/7. And that is the point the show is making, there's no presumption of innocence anymore, even if Nas gets aquitted his name will never be cleared and he will be forever changed by his time at rikers; presumably for nothing.

→ More replies (5)

67

u/AgalychnisCallidryas Aug 08 '16

They hinted and hinted that Box has the slightest doubt, but his 33 years of experience tells him Naz is the guy. But there's this itch he can't quite scratch… picked up perfectly in the camera shot after the DA said "this is premeditation" and the shot panned to him, thinking, "hmmm…"

45

u/Dubbys Aug 08 '16

Yes. He has found his victim yet he sits in the cab with her and doesn't drive off. He's seeing things differently than the DA for sure.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/skratchx Aug 08 '16

How many more criminal justice professionals have to see a Jackson Pollock blood painting on the wall before wondering why Nas wasn't covered in blood? Now Chandra and Stone's photographer buddy (who by the way found, what, a bloody leaf in the back of the house?) have also been brought into the fold and no one's mentioned it yet.

→ More replies (9)

57

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Coroner: Don't mind me! Just pullin' out some eye juice over here. FUCK ME i nearly lost it when I thought they were gonna show the whole thing.

→ More replies (4)

115

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

That dude in Freddy's cell apparently rolled and was lighting a joint in approximately 4 seconds. Like fucking whoa man... props.

→ More replies (3)

53

u/CARNIesada6 Aug 08 '16

What was the blue

81

u/ReducedToRubble Aug 08 '16

The UV lamps from the beginning. It's meant to suggest that Stone is desperate to exonerate Naz which is why he chased down Dwayne by drawing a parallel to the stupid things he does (Crisco, UV lamps) in attempting to cure his eczema.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

48

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Ok.... ummm.... did anyone else immediately think that was Giovanni Rabisi's cousin or some shit in the bar scene when Stone asked for special k? In line with our recent Steve Buscemi cousin revelations... i was like wtf?

→ More replies (9)

93

u/izzystardust12 Aug 08 '16

I liked the part where Stone lowkey points out that the shit Nas is doing (swallowing drugs) is going to fuck his whole situation up. His sharpness is so underrated. I can't wait what they dig up for him, in defense of.

70

u/PinkZeppelins Aug 08 '16

That was my favorite part. I love Stone. I love that he seems like such a genuine character. He understands why Naz is doing it, but is letting him know the consequences of getting caught. He isn't actively trying to dissuade him, just being realistic about it.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

45

u/PuffsPlusArmada Aug 08 '16

In a perfect world prison would be smoking weed and playing chess while watching boxing.

→ More replies (6)

44

u/TheCenci Aug 08 '16

God damn the lack of communication between characters on this show is aggravating.

40

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

yes. Naz not revealing every single thing he could remember to his lawyers, which makes him suspicious.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

87

u/MarionCotesworthHaye Aug 08 '16

Why don't you go, and take your cookie with you

63

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

And your milk

→ More replies (1)

87

u/WhackAMoleE Aug 08 '16

By far best epi of series so far. Loved the scene with his hooker girlfriend, it was classic. I doubt there's ever been a Viagra shortage, it's a hugely popular drug in plentiful supply at every pharmacy.

44

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 08 '16

Must have been season of the witch.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

123

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Prediction: Detective Box uncovers some incontrovertible new evidence which clearly exonerates Nasir but decides not to reveal it 'cause... you know... LOL.

100

u/Sheeps Aug 08 '16

Don't think we've been shown anything to suggest he's that dirty. That would be a serious Brady violation.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (6)

155

u/DrRad Aug 08 '16

Lol are high school kids actually this fucking stupid? They don't know what a lawyer is?

113

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Hitler killed my grandparents you fucking monster! Like she doesn't understand that she just asked a hypothetical question.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

119

u/KEYSER_SOZ3 Aug 08 '16

How the fuck do you spin pre-meditation out of that haha

57

u/maassizzle Doesn't Matter, Had Sex Aug 08 '16

I think it's somewhat logical for her to be able to spin pre-meditated out of that, but have they talked to the two cops that had their lights on next to him?

→ More replies (1)

97

u/Quinn_tEskimo Aug 08 '16

Had the same thought. One guy on that jury and Stone flashes Andrea's picture and asks "would you kick her out of your cab?" Murder 1 gone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

41

u/travis- Aug 08 '16

ohhhhhh shitttt. went to jail innocent but became a criminal.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/DFSPete Aug 08 '16

Freddy runs Rikers. He was smoking s joint in his cell as the guard came in. He couldn't pull some strings to let Naz back to his cell without having him swallow the coke?

87

u/thecarlosdanger1 Aug 08 '16

I think Freddy just runs that block. I think the guards in the front are out of his control.

45

u/Lardarius Aug 08 '16

He just wants to be able to control Naz

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

41

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Despite the eczema... Stone's fence hop game is STILL on point!

40

u/MikeKrombopulos Aug 08 '16

don't push it Naz

47

u/soourcream Aug 08 '16

Oh boy, here he goes killing again

→ More replies (1)

22

u/PM_Me_Your_Schnoz A Subtle Beast Aug 08 '16

LOL Ellen

→ More replies (1)

39

u/thatweirdmusicguy Aug 08 '16

Naz went from 0-100 real quick in like his first scene of the episode

→ More replies (8)

39

u/walkmanJ Aug 08 '16

Loved the moment with Stone and the waiter who sold her the drugs. Stone worked him quickly and skillfully, but was also subtle about it. I definitely chuckled when he ordered a beer and turned to the guy next to him. Such well written scene.

28

u/detlef_shrimp Aug 08 '16

he also folded up his unsigned warrant and used it as a drink coaster.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/BlueBelleBlues Aug 08 '16

Theory....the eczema gnawing at Jon's body represent the corruption he feels in his soul, because he is a criminal defense attorney (and a 2-bit one at that) always representing guilty-as-sin people. So he sees Naz as both someone whose case benefits his career, as well as someone who is actually innocent. So he will find some evidence indicating Naz is, in fact, not guilty and he will get Naz freed. During which time his eczema will clear up substantially (increasing his confidence and overall wellbeing). Only, after its all over and the innocent have prevailed, freedom rings, yada yada....Jon inadvertently discovers something ...that makes him certain that Naz IS in fact the murderer and has sociopathic tendencies. At which time, we also see just the tiniest return of a spot of his eczema.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/typocorrecto Aug 08 '16

Damn, they ain't your friends dude.

→ More replies (2)

194

u/TheCenci Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16

Freddy has a drug operation outside of prison, the dude that sold the X and special K to Andrea got his supply from Freddy's guy. So that dealer owes Freddy's guy, he sends them to Andrea, then she gets murdered. Freddy knows all this so he's trying to make sure Naz gets involved in stupid shit while in prison awaiting trial. (TIN FOIL HAT KINDA DRUNK THEORY, PROBABLY TOTAL SHIT)

EDIT: Though I feel like if Freddy was somehow connected he would have just let Nazir get killed in prison, which it kind of seems like it was heading down that route. Who knows man.

133

u/DaB0mb0 Aug 08 '16

i think you underestimate the amount of drugs done in new york, and overestimate the extent of freddy's network

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (22)

64

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Did anyone else watch the beat down scene with some really mixed emotions? I wanted Nasir to get his revenge and I could clearly see the rage of someone who has been bullied come out in full form... But i was also saying NASIR NOOOO the whole time. Gahhh.

→ More replies (9)

31

u/FKDotFitzgerald Aug 08 '16

I feel like the cat and eczema scenes are more enjoyable for me than they should be, considering they're currently irrelevant to the main plot. That will obviously change for both though.

56

u/BlueHighwindz Aug 08 '16

Irrelevant nothing. The cat is the killer.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

30

u/golfer74 Aug 08 '16

When confronting a possible murder suspect you may want to bring the cops.

33

u/surlystudent Aug 08 '16

When confronting a possible murder suspect you may want to wear sneakers

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

30

u/akkveto09 Aug 08 '16

Great episode overall. Still waiting for some more information on the step dad...and I'm not sure if the hearse driver in episode 1 is important but that dude looked pretty sketchy.

Lastly. The cat has been some type of focal point in every episode. It sounds dumb but I think it's going to play a large role in this case.

22

u/SirLuciousL Aug 08 '16

Don't know how useful it would be, but the cat was put outside on purpose. That would at least prove that Nas was welcome in the house, since he's allergic to cats.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

29

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Were there really 4 bags? I could sworn there were only 3.

→ More replies (8)

129

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Chandra's questions about ketamine made her sound like a real square.

→ More replies (31)

27

u/PM_Me_Your_Schnoz A Subtle Beast Aug 08 '16

was Freddy's master plan to figure out if Nas was capable of the murder??

→ More replies (2)

77

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Question: Did anybody else for a second see a creepy figure in the surveillance footage and get all excited... only seconds later to realize it was Box standing there in the present taking in the scene? LOL.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/_CharlesInCharge_ Aug 08 '16

The cat really is a perfect metaphor for Naz. He feels comfortable with the perks/toys Freddy offers, but at the end of the day he's still locked up in a room. Man after last episode I hoped things would get better for Naz.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/depan_ Aug 08 '16

That scene with the medical examiner was shady and unprofessional as all fuck. Going from he doesn't know how the wound was made to it was from the knife slipping and asking how likely only 1 slip would be with 20+ stab wounds. Holy Fuck. Is NYC really THAT corrupt or was the show just using artistic license?

→ More replies (18)

41

u/Jovial_2k Aug 08 '16

Alternate Theory for the murder: Duane Reade, violent offender. Jackpot for the defense.

55

u/room23 A Subtle Beast Aug 08 '16

Now if he had called the cops to have him arrested for his warrant instead of tipping him off.. would have been nice.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/berotec93 Aug 08 '16

Stone is way worthier than what he charges... risking his life for this case

→ More replies (7)

57

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

I think the UV light at the end is actually from Dwayne Reed using it for HIS foot condition. The two form an unlikely bond. Also this episode was good but there wasn't enough dead guy dick.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/MCShereKhan I miss the Old Nasir. Aug 08 '16

I don't think my heart has raced faster than when Nas was swallowing the coke.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/dantonizzomsu Aug 08 '16

Does anyone think that Box is going to find some key evidence that Naz didn't do it and then give a tip or two to Stone? It is interesting that this is Box's last case that he is working on so at this point his relationship with the DA doesn't really matter. I also think that while he was mapping out Naz and Andrea's journey he notices that what he was saying was the truth. She wanted to go to the "Beach" and then he follows the cell pings to where the river is located. I also think as he maps out the journey he is starting to realize that this is not a kidnapping but it looks like Andrea was in control of he situation.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/Gyroballer Aug 08 '16

They finally addressed the vial of drugs. I thought it was coke, not ketamine tho

34

u/LiBrizzi Aug 08 '16

Such a good episode, minus that little fake out cliffhanger ending, SPOILER

I believe Naz's "transformation" tonight gives us a lot of backstory. We'll definitely find out a lot more next episode.

SPOILER

→ More replies (6)

31

u/oatsoatsoatsoats Aug 08 '16

Ballers probably gets a lot more viewers being right after The Night Of

→ More replies (20)

14

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Whoop! We got some investigating going down finally! Time to take screenshots and wonder aloud to myself on Monday morning why it is that I have allowed myself to destroy my life on Sunday nights! Can't Wait!

28

u/Xelath Aug 08 '16

Am I the only one who saw that there was a green leaf among the dead leaves on Andrea's balcony? I'm guessing someone climbed a tree.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Someone should issue tickets to Box and the ADA for smoking in a public building in NYC.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/spate42 Aug 08 '16

anyone else think the ending of the episode (Stone hunting down Duane) was very True Detective Season 1 esque?

got a very similar vibe

→ More replies (15)

47

u/Dirty_Dale Aug 08 '16

This has been bugging me all season: Naz's inhaler is a Ventolin inhaler, which is albuterol sulfate (a short-acting beta agonist) but they keep incorrectly calling it a steroid. Also, where I'm from, I've never seen a pharmacist act like the one they are portraying in the show.

→ More replies (16)

63

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16

I am a Police Officer in the NYPD, can check my history from /r/nyc for cred. Would anyone be interested if I did an AMA to how it pertains to the show?

EDIT: Getting some pretty positive responses, I have messaged the mods to set up a formal AMA, lets do this!

→ More replies (12)

12

u/Curseofthorn Aug 08 '16

Oh my jesus, anxiety to the max

12

u/izzystardust12 Aug 08 '16

We're already done with the 5th episode and I feel like there are still way too many loose ends that need to be tied up. I hope they address everything without falling into the trap of deux ex machina. I mean. I doubt it (and I'm really hoping they won't) seeing the brilliant people behind the show but JUST. THREE. MORE. EPISODES. LEFT.

12

u/danijay1 Aug 09 '16

Every time I start to settle on a killer, I hear the echo of Andrea saying, "I can't be alone tonight." in episode one. She was definitely spooked over the prospect of someone looking for her, so that's why I think it rules out someone random - like the two guys they encounter in front of the apartment in episode one.

The other reason I can almost guarantee that it's not Duane, is that these type of self-contained series - such as True Detective - like to throw out a red herring suspect right around episode three or four.

My gut feeling is that Andrea was sleeping with her stepfather, and while I don't think that he was the perpetrator - someone close to him was - like a new girlfriend of his. (He states in episode one that Andrea's mother is deceased).

Of the seemingly countless male suspects they could throw at us for seven episodes, I think it would be such a great twist to see a lady at the other end of the knife.

Maybe?

→ More replies (2)

42

u/MCShereKhan I miss the Old Nasir. Aug 08 '16

THIS WAS THE BEST EPISODE YET.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/travis- Aug 08 '16

rub these raw eggs on your feet and then drink a cup of dog sweat. trust me.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/juiceimortal Omar Comin' Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16

A few thoughts 1) John Stone is whip smart, for him to notice and understand what Naz was doing and going through at Rikers was further proof that Jack Stone is also a subtle beast. 2) The idea or that Naz' behavior in beating a man that literally burned him somehow equating to Naz being any more culpable in murdering someone than he was before is short sighted and doesn't follow. There were a ton of reasons behind the murderous rage and why he reacted the way he did with homeboy who literally burned him. Firstly, he didn't have much say in the matter as he was gifted to him, and second it must have cathartic for him to let out all of the frustration and anger against someone who actually did him harm. How this calls into doubt wether or not Naz committed a murder of the second girl he had ever slept with is beyond me.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/MikeKrombopulos Aug 08 '16

That's his actual name? The fuck?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/mattty_pg Aug 08 '16

What was that flickering light right at the end?

→ More replies (11)

10

u/trenaer Aug 08 '16

I think it's very telling that Nas has not once tried to remember what happened. If you were accused of murdering someone, wouldn't you rerun the events that night in your head over and over again until you got answers or at least enough to convince yourself you did not do it.

We know why Stone didn't ask him what happened, but what is Chandra's reason for not asking what happened. Why are they attempting to piece together facts without asking him questions. For example, after they found out another person was with Trevor, they should have come back (after Nas got rid of the dope) and asked him to walk them through the events of that night. If this convo doesn't happen in the next episode, I'm over it.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Nas talking about the fourth 8 ball had me worried about a leakage situation

→ More replies (2)

19

u/typocorrecto Aug 08 '16

...Why the "justice" system is trash...

→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Watch Naz become an actual murderer in jail, but then get off for the murder of the girl.

→ More replies (11)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Wearing headphones while Nas wailed on that dude in the shower was not a good idea. The sound editing is great in that scene but so brutal. Yeesh.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/CARNIesada6 Aug 08 '16

Box will discover the motorcycle person was following Andrea and maybe even get a plate number

→ More replies (2)

9

u/typocorrecto Aug 08 '16

Naz's balls are wrecking ball size atm.

9

u/Cuse88 Aug 08 '16

And that's how he has to pay for his protection. Nothing is free.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/Pax_Soprana Aug 08 '16

What a fucking episode probably the best one besides maybe the pilot, those last couple of minutes were intense as hell.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Poppinlikeballoons Aug 08 '16

What if that Dwayne guy is related to Freddy?! and Naz is pressured into making his lawyers toss Dwayne out as a suspect otherwise he is killed in jail by Freddy. Either way, Naz is screwed

→ More replies (3)

9

u/iamda5h Doesn't Matter, Had Sex Aug 08 '16 edited Jun 03 '25

oatmeal offbeat dazzling stupendous vanish tease coordinated attraction exultant cats

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

17

u/PinkHK5213 Aug 08 '16

Re: the fridge. The investigator opened the door, got cat food out and left it wide open. Maybe that's also why the fridge was left open behind Naz when he passed out/woke up. Someone cared enough to feed the cat before they left/after they killed her?

→ More replies (7)

16

u/Bub1023 Aug 08 '16

Chandra's the best

→ More replies (4)

8

u/sheckie9 Aug 08 '16

I'm thinking Stone's Clorox and black light prescriptions for his eczema come in handy for some crime scene investigation.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/chezzie11 Aug 08 '16

wouldnt the autopsy show that the sex between Nas and Andrea was consensual? why do they keep trying to nail him down on a sexual assault charge when I would think the DNA evidence would show that the sex was clearly not forced

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ExamineTheExczeman Aug 08 '16

Detective Box checking out the police patrol dashboard cam together with the bald cop ('either subway time or overtime, I could use the money') from episode one. Later checking that spot IRL and noticing different cameras on buildings around the spot. Most probably not Duane Reade on that footage, but really wondering who it is that made her get into the cab and want to drive off in a hurry. We might get a glimpse of Andrea's actions before she got into the cab.

8

u/slcjosh Aug 08 '16

Naz is gone. Rikers has cooked him.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/futuredestiny Aug 08 '16

This show is truly amazing and fun to watch, keep it up HBO as usual.

8

u/coopdaloop123 Aug 08 '16

I feel like this show is going to end with Naz getting off, but then going back to jail for an assault charge or another murder after all the changing he's done in prison.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Jovial_2k Aug 08 '16

Who gave Naz the message: "Take the deal"? I figured it was Freddy who wants the case closed. But if Freddy wants Naz to take the deal, why make jail time easier for him?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

This is stressful.

7

u/Bub1023 Aug 08 '16

I really hope someone, especially John, keeps the cat. Weird that I'm so concerned about it.

7

u/Cuse88 Aug 08 '16

What a scene. Felt tense the entire time.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/tonyjefferson Aug 08 '16

I like how last episode ended with Freddy saying alliances are everything, and this episode began with Chandra and Stone forming a new alliance.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

Box definitely has doubts about Naz. You could see it when him and the prosecutor were talking about the video of Andrea getting into the cab, and the prosecutor jumps on the video as evidence of "premeditation," while Box looks less convinced.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/SlyKlyde Aug 08 '16

The Night Of healthcare professionals would all kill it on the comedy circuit

7

u/Chutzvah Aug 08 '16

"Doing Keto makes you wanna fuck." Uhhhh what kind of Keto have you done Stone? That shit makes you a friggin zombie!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/travis- Aug 08 '16

ohhh i wonder how his foot is doing this episode.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Liftology Aug 08 '16

That fucking cliffhanger... Wow.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

I LOVE how Stone picked up on Naz swallowing the 8balls.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/depan_ Aug 08 '16

So Petey (the kid that needed protection from Freddy and passed the 8 balls to Naz) was credited in the pilot on IMDB. So tonight is the 2nd episode he is credited for that has aired. A simple mistake or was he actually somewhere in episode 1? That could be pretty huge if all this has to do with some sort of Freddy drug ring.

→ More replies (18)

6

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

Kid: "You just made it. Scheduled for 8:00 AM"... John: "This is a stay, not a pardon." What in the actual fuck man. This show is making me think about legal concepts in some weird ass ways.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16

So much happened this episode. Bring on your crazy theories.

6

u/catapolana Aug 08 '16

Was that 3 confirmed dick shots?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/sheckie9 Aug 08 '16

Anyone else find Stone trying to seduce the prostitute totally endearing? It was a weird conundrum feeling.

6

u/throwliterally Aug 08 '16

Love the humor. Stone explains K to the young lawyer and later we get to see him walking around with a raging hard on from Viagra. Love the music when he's shopping for kitty toys, the way he rolls the balls at the clerk and how he throws them in the room.

11

u/travis- Aug 08 '16

swallow that snatch coke.

→ More replies (2)

100

u/Conchking Aug 08 '16

Dicks out for harambe

→ More replies (2)

10

u/badoosh123 Aug 08 '16

This show is sooo fuckin good. I loved that scene of Box going through the map and going through the paper trail of Naz to retrace his night. It was really well edited. The cinematography in this show is amazing too, that shot from outside of the laundromat of Bodie from the Wire and Stones was amazing. This show is probably the best I've seen since Fargo.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Cuse88 Aug 08 '16

He's going to spend the next few hours on XVideos.

5

u/MikeKrombopulos Aug 08 '16

what a tense scene

5

u/LlamaTony Aug 08 '16

I was so sure Stone was gonna get attacked.

5

u/level202 Aug 08 '16

Even Duane Reade is sold out of Viagra.

5

u/MrBillyLotion Aug 08 '16

Question here - did Naz admit to Stone that he had taken Adderall or is the amphetamine in his system still a mystery?

→ More replies (8)

5

u/creesa The deer did it Aug 08 '16

Though possibly squirrel blood, the blood found outside is really exciting. Could prove a lot.

5

u/MariSnow Aug 08 '16

When Nas just kept kicking and kicking first time I thought, its just possible, that he did do it. It's like he's got better at prison life but still can't do the right thing to help himself, his creepy new bald head bug eyed convict look for example.

5

u/thetalentedoppressor Way too psychological Aug 08 '16

I honestly just thought about how funny it is that mcdonalds and weed got a solid cameo in this ep. What a fucking really funny and really tough episode to watch. Damn.

5

u/krazygraphics Aug 08 '16

One scene that stuck out to me was when Stone's "forensic specialist" was going through the house looking for clues. He takes a picture of the drawer that contains a knife. Maybe I am mistaken, but I saw blood in that drawer.

Why would there be blood in that drawer? Didn't Andrea take out the knife before she was bleeding? And once she was bleeding, that knife stayed on the coffee table.

Could that be a sign that someone else (who had blood on them) was either taking a knife out (or putting one back in). Could the knife in that scene have been the murder weapon?

Just some thoughts...

→ More replies (9)

5

u/miles197 Aug 08 '16

Why did it end the same way it began? With the blue flickering lights? Was that just artsy stuff or did it mean something?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/trenaer Aug 10 '16 edited Aug 10 '16

Nas did it...Nas is the Subtle Beast the parents and brother gave it away... Why did Nas' brother wake his parents to let them know Nas was not in his room? Why rat him out unless... Nas may have a history of doing crazy violent shit (that he later claims not to remember) before passing out.

Did you notice how quick the parents were to call the hospital. I have a 23 year old but would not get too worried until daybreak. It was a Friday night and they knew he was going to a party because they called the guy Nas was supposed to be with.

The dialog when the dad was calling the hospital(s) stood out to me too. The mother said something similar to 'Which one are you calling?' I can't remember the father's exact reply, but his response was strange. I'll have to rewatch episode 2 because I don't remember the exact words.

It was strange how the mother searched Nas' room. Was she making sure there w no signs of his last murder or last psychotic break?

And finally, before pissing off the plea deal Nas said 'my parent will never know I didn't do it". Stone's reply was 'they don't know that now?' To me, Stone was saying his parent have known him all his life and Stone was surprised they'd think he is capable of committing such a horrible crime.

→ More replies (5)