r/spacex • u/zlsa Art • Aug 19 '16
Modpost August 2016 Modpost: Recovery threads, SpaceX merchandise, and Mars/IAC 2016!
Hello, everyone! As we approach IAC 2016, which is likely to be the largest event the subreddit has ever seen, we wanted to bring up some topics and collect feedback on the subreddit as a whole.
Booster recovery threads
SpaceX are getting really good at landing boosters now, faster than we’ve been able to mature our concept of what a recovery thread should be! Here are the links to the recovery threads for past launches: CRS-8, JCSAT-14, Thaicom 8, Eutelsat 117W B & ABS 2A, and JCSAT-16.
We've had selfposts which were run and updated live by volunteers from the community, and we've had link posts which were not. Based on the scattered selection of feedback we've had surrounding the last launch, it seems the community generally prefers selfposts. Are we correct in assuming that is the case? If so, we’d like to make a formal call for volunteers to run recovery threads. We feel that recovery threads are one thing too many to add to the list of duties, so we’re giving the community the chance to run the threads themselves!
We’ll support whoever runs the thread by providing a template to work from; this will be designed for maximum readability of the information, and will help standardise around a sensible format. We’re proposing that the recovery selfpost gets stickied, and all further recovery updates belong in this thread. If you’re interested, and are someone we can trust (i.e. your account is >6 months old with >1000 total karma - same criteria as used for wiki editing), let us know in the comments below!
SpaceX merchandise
So far, we’ve been deciding these on a case-by-case basis, but as SpaceX expands their merchandise selection, we feel that having a new post for each new product becomes unwieldy and clutters up the subreddit. We’d like to hear your thoughts on this.
Mars and MCT/BFR
And finally, Mars and MCT/BFR speculation. Understandingly, there have been a number of recent posts speculating on the MCT/BFR vehicle and on Mars colonization in general. We’ll be posting a predictions thread soon, so you can comment with your predictions of various aspects of the vehicle and architecture. We’ll also have weekly Mars/MCT/BFR discussion threads, up until IAC; these will start in just under a week.
We will put the subreddit into restricted mode before Elon Musk’s talk, just like during a launch. There will be a Mars announcement thread, just like a launch thread, where the rules are relaxed and nearly anything goes. There will also be a media thread to go with the Mars announcement thread.
General feedback and wrap-up
If there’s anything you’d like to see us improve on or do differently as IAC approaches, please tell us about it here. This is a new process for all of us, and we’re somewhat feeling our way as we go, so any feedback (positive or negative) that you want to share can help guide us through IAC and beyond.
Cheers,
The r/SpaceX moderation team.
8
u/ticklestuff SpaceX Patch List Aug 20 '16
You missed one :)
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4ee2zy/crs8_ocisly_returning_to_port_canaveral/
+1 on keeping the merchandise posts, it goes hand in hand with being a SpaceX fan.
38
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Aug 19 '16
Transparency report: here's the modlog for the last 3 months.
16
u/randomstonerfromaus Aug 19 '16
I'm happy to volunteer to run further recovery threads when I can.
As always, Thanks to you guys for the long hours you put in to run this sub!
16
u/Kona314 Aug 20 '16
Regarding merch threads... I'm thinking the title of the Ask Anything thread should be altered. Something like "General Discussion and Questions"? It's already used for small updates that don't deserve a thread (right now, the most recent post in there is a statement that F9-021 will be vertical tonight). If we embrace it as such with a minor rebranding, we can continue to funnel that information in there—including things like new merchandise.
Another alternative would be to make Ask Anything exclusively for questions and create a second monthly thread for the minor updates etc. I think that's a bit excessive though...no reason they can't go together.
Also, I'm sure there are plenty others more qualified, but I'd be happy to host a recovery thread. (I'm in Pacific time, if it helps to know.)
Thanks for everything, you guys—you clearly put a lot of time into /r/spacex and it shows!
11
u/still-at-work Aug 19 '16
Can one of those MCT weekly threads focus on all the many technologies designed to keep a few humans alive and sane for at least 3 months and more for the round trip with no backup and no more supplies then what they were launched with.
Most of our discussions have been about getting tons of cargo (be that people or not) from Earth to Mars. They have been great but if the MCT is really going to take people then it will need little things like a way to launder clothes in space. Those small technologies as well as big ideas like radiation protection, simulated gravity, food, and water all need to be part of the MCT's 'payload'. Thankfully there has beend decades of research on this area so there is lots of information out there to hypothesise on.
So a thread that talked about the habitable area of the MCT, be it new ideas or describing some technology that nasa or someone elese has already developed to solve an aspect of the problem of keeping those humans on board happy and healthy.
9
u/iberichard Aug 20 '16
I do love how well run this sub is and that threads like this are run.
With regards to booster recovery threads community involvement is always going to help make the sub even better. And it is always nice to have the information all in one place, was a wee bit scattered for JCSAT, but I was impressed how well it worked.
As many others have said below the occasional piece of merchandise advertising is nice for those of us who do not peruse the shop website often. But yes we could reach saturation if they release too much.
Finally thanks mods for controlling/banning some members. Particularly the inflammatory ones who feel the need to send personal mail to push their personal agenda.
Off topic but any indication Echo on when mission control will be ^up?
7
u/MoscowMeow Aug 20 '16
Merch posts: Mission shirts usually come out 1-2 days after mission success. Those can be added in the stickied mission post. This would cut down on the new posts drastically. This includes mission patches. There can be a link to both added in the mission post once they become available.
10
u/deruch Aug 20 '16
The /r/SpaceX donation solicitation for IAC attendance has raised close to 400% of the original goal, but is still up and touted in the header. It's great that the community has been so awesomely generous but at this point I think there needs to be some discussion of how the superfluous funds are going to be spent (beyond what's in the original campaign page). I would recommend repurposing to support attendance at other future events (as partial refunding would likely be very difficult). Or maybe asking if there's anyone who'd like a partial refund? Also, at this point, IMO it really isn't right to continue to solicit/accept donations when they clearly aren't going to be going to the purpose originally stated. I don't know if it's possible to "halt/stop" the campaign on the generosity.com site or what other options they provide. But at the very least, the link should be taken off the subreddit header announcements.
4
u/aureliiien Aug 20 '16
I'm good for recovery thread. Are you planning to add more mods in order to match the needs of a growing membership ?
4
u/vaporcobra Space Reporter - Teslarati Aug 20 '16
If you ever need help with a recovery thread or need a host, I would be willing to help out/host one myself. I am generally quite busy but am always happy to help if I am able.
As always, keep up the fantastic work :)
1
u/kmccoy Aug 21 '16
You guys do a generally good job here. Thanks for that. It's unfortunate that the IRC channel isn't nearly as well run or transparent.
3
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Aug 20 '16
I would definitely like to volunteer for the recovery threads!
3
u/OrangeredStilton Aug 20 '16
You seem to have a number of takers for "host of a recovery thread", but I'll throw my hat in the ring too. As long as people shout at the host to keep the selftext updated, I won't have a problem; won't have much of a chance to keep an eye on events myself.
3
u/Darkben Spacecraft Electronics Aug 20 '16
@mods:
I'd like to volunteer for helping with recovery threads :)
3
u/MarcysVonEylau rocket.watch Aug 20 '16 edited Aug 20 '16
I don't feel like i'm able to mantain a self.post recovery thread (mostly because of the timezone situation), but I have direct contact to the /u/surfgurufl, owner of the surfguru.com cameras, so if anyone wants to recieve instant notification when Falcon is visible on the horizon - just pm me ;)
6
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '16 edited Aug 21 '16
I'd say keep the merch threads, but maybe not for the obvious merch like mission patch t-shirts, which you just assume exist.
I'm not checking the store frequently so if there's something new it's nice to know, also as the catalogue grows it'll get harder to spot new things.
2
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Aug 20 '16 edited Aug 30 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketbargeshipDecronym is a community product of /r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
I'm a bot, and I first saw this thread at 20th Aug 2016, 01:13 UTC.
[Acronym ^lists] [Contact ^creator] [PHP source ^code]
2
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '16
I'm fine with having booster recovery threads be community-driven rather than mod-made. Although, I'd still like to see the more popular (with 100+ upvotes) posts that revolve around booster recovery be stickied until the booster is back in port.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '16
SES-9 had OCISLY arrival thread too
Maybe add page in Wiki for SpaceX merchandise, and update it?
P.S. I'm ready to help with recovery threads!
2
u/astrotechnical Aug 20 '16
Well aware that my account is not yet in the "trust-able zone" yet to host a recovery thread, but I do just want to throw in my two cents and say that I prefer the selfpost method you describe for recovery threads. It's worked well and I anticipate that it would continue to.
Additionally, a new post for every piece SpaceX merchandise is a bit cumbersome. I'd probably prefer either a monthly update on merchandise (although I realize that's more work and you already have a ton on your metaphorical plates) or no notification at all - although it's certainly not the end of the world if that does not become the case.
Lastly, a massive thanks to you all. Fantastic work guys. Can't wait until IAC!
2
u/cpushack Aug 20 '16
RE: SpaceX Merchandise: These threads come and go fast enough that I don't really see a problem with them. They don't (at least for me) interfere with my consumption of other SpaceX Reddit material (and I am always tempted to buy more SpaceX loot)
RE: Recovery thread. Much prefer a standardized self post type format. Matches the launch thread better that way and eventually someone (on the wiki maybe ?) can make a pairing of each (launch + recovery) for each mission for a historical archive.
1
u/dgkimpton Aug 20 '16 edited Aug 20 '16
Do we really need separate 'recovery' threads? Can't it all just go in the launch thread? We could just adjust the flair like happens for the 'happening now', but have it with 'recovering now' ?
1
u/BrandonMarc Aug 22 '16
What are the chances this subreddit passes 100,000 dragon-riders by October 1?
1
u/Ericabneri Aug 20 '16
keep merch posts pls. Nice mod post. As always thanks for all you guys do.
1
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Aug 20 '16
I don't think that would really hurt, the advantage of Reddit compared to simple forums is the upvote system based of opinions of the masses. There is some self moderation because of that, you don't need to manually remove threads based on rules.
If there is a lot of other stuff happening that +1 thread will quickly disappear, if there isn't much other content, it will stay longer based on how interesting that new merch is. If it fits, it sits
O shit... /me runs back to the crafting table [#]
1
u/BattleRushGaming Aug 20 '16
Are there any rules should there be any leaks regarding MCT/BFR before the talk in September?
I would love to see some kind or restriction on possible leaks or the post should be taged as "SPOILER" and the titles shouldnt reveal the content much or at all. I dont know about the preview image but it could be maybe set that spoilers are text only allowed or something without a dirrect imgur link to the spoiler (which would lead to reddit showing a preview image), but with the link inside the post. This is not dirrected towards the speculation threads only for spoilers from "trusted" sources.
But maybe thats just me not wanting to get spoiled before the talk but still browse /r/spacex
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment