This trial is wholly unrealistic time wise. It takes longer to prosecute a DUI than this case. But obviously it's not very compelling to have a 90 day trial.
It really bugged me how the defense wasn't piecing things together for the jury like they should have during Dr. Katz's portion of the testimony. Sure, the jury probably understands that someone wouldn't be able to see Naz if they went in the back and immediately up the stairs, but a decent attorney would specifically ask the question to clarify it, and make it stick in the jurors' minds.
"So based on the angle of your photograph, which was taken on the stairs, someone coming from the back gate and traveling up the stairs wouldn't have been able to see the defendant unconscious in the kitchen, is that correct?"
I think that's my favorite thing conceptually about the series: how life can change in completely radical and unforeseen ways with something mundane as the catalyst. Ever since the show started I think about that in my own life--how seemingly innocuous events can ripple in unexpected ways.
yes, he was an amazing expert witness. his reaction when she tried to call him out for saying those great things about the M.E. was perfect. "oh! you caught me! i said nice things to be polite."
I think this may be a reference to the amazing true crime documentary series The Staircase. They had the exact same thing happen in the real trial. Edit: grammar
Naz is gonna be found not guilty. We'll find out it was the step dad but he goes free and gets money from the house. Naz and his family are still screwed and sold everything to prove his innocence not to mention backlash they've received from the community. Screwed by the criminal justice system under the "veil of presumed innocence".
I agree Naz will be found not guilty, and we will discover who the killer is as viewers. The main theme of the show will be that our criminal justice system turned an innocent kid with some bullying and temper issues into a hardened criminal who is helping commit murders and smuggle drugs. The system turned a kid who should've been able to have a fun night out blowing steam off, into a true jailhouse thug. In order to survive his fight to prove his innocence, he became guilty.
I hope this is how it ends. I'm too invested in Naz's innocence to believe that he's going to stay in jail for what happened with Freddy's minion. But I doubt the showrunners spent THAT much time on what was happening in the jail to just let it slide at the end. Freddy's storyline and Naz's downward spiral HAS to come into play.
Although cheesy, is it possible that the kiss, which was caught on camera, could be used to force a mistrial? Nas could claim that his lawyer didn't properly defend him because she had been in love with him, therefore forcing a mistrial and maybe being retried or not. Maybe a little far fetched, but possible.
This was by far the strangest part of the series for me. I thought for sure it was going to cut to Nas daydreaming. When it didn't, I was like wtf... A couple episodes before it seemed like she had feelings for Stone. Maybe it'll make more sense on a re-watch or after next episode, but I was scratching my head.
I thought it was sick for a minute and became extremely worried. But then it managed to open the door and you knew it, leisurely skipping its way straight onto the bed!
The one objection Chandra did give kinda just felt like it was thrown in for the sake of it. Even Weiss was like "uh, objection to what?" and the judge overruled.
Another lawyer here: If every objection in a courtroom scene was made as it would be in real-life, you would be watching an 8-hour-long episode as the attorneys repeatedly approach the bench to consult with the Judge about what to strike and how to rephrase questions.
His entire countenance bothers me. Something's up. I think he's been the best of the best for 33 years, and this last case - despite "the mountain of evidence" just doesn't add up. If I were in his place, I wouldn't want my last case to be something that didn't feel right.
I've seen a few people comment that Box will ultimately help unveil the true killer - seems that may be what's happening.
He's been repeatedly asked what he's going to do after retiring and golf seems to be the only thing anyone jokes about, and he seems completely uninterested. So I think that tells us he doesn't know what to do with himself. Then the line of questioning this episode made it sound like he left the job unfinished. Put those together and I think he wants to do some more digging to make sure his work is done, and because he has nothing better to do anyway.
The stare at the clubs was depressing. I don't think he finds the joke about golf funny anymore.
It's been clear that this entire case has had Box feeling uneasy. His detective roots tell him Nas committed the crime but at the same time he doesn't see the logic in the murder. With his upcoming retirement his colleagues have asked him what his plans are on several occasions (golfing, moving to a beach, etc..) and each time Box shrugs the question off suggesting he wants nothing to do with any of the typical retirement possibilities. I think in the next episode we see Nas convicted early, being sentenced to life in prison, and then we see Box (and possibly Stone) working to find/confirm who the real killer is.
I'm still at a loss as to why no one has asked how it is Naz could have done this and not ended up soaked in blood. I know this has been mentioned before but now that we're seeing the machinations in the courtroom, it seems absurd that this hasn't been brought up, particularly since we're getting into the minutiae of missing knives and what this guy said about this other guy years ago.
Remember the pilot? After Naz gets arrested for the DUI they take him to the precinct and he just sits there, unguarded, with a knife in his pocket, for a long time. He even thinks about walking away. The point is, cops do the bare minimum and miss all kinds of things. Box is the same way... why didn't he follow up about the stepfather, or Trevor's companion? The system is designed to pick the one to accuse, and then start the wheels turning. They rarely look back.
Stone, you may recall, had no idea Andrea had been stabbed 22 times until right around the middle of the show. That's the real criminal justice system. It ain't "Dexter".
I posted some of this in the live discussion but wanted to share:
Did anybody else notice that the cat opened the door by itself in Stone's apartment and jumped into bed with him? As soon as this happened I immediately thought about how Andrea let her cat outside in the first episode.
Someone else mentioned the tiger documentary Naz and Freddy were watching this episode and how the narrator said something about cats not taking well to water. I was thinking that if it rained that night after Andrea let the cat out, the cat would have been encouraged to return home. So I went back and watched parts of the first episode, and while it didn't appear to be raining when Andrea let the cat outside, it definitely did rain that night, as evidenced by the wet pavement and puddles we see in the very last scene of episode 1 when Naz's father runs outside and discovers his cab is gone. It's also worth noting that in this scene, a cat runs across the street behind Naz's father.
Another image from tonight's episode that stuck with me was that of a waving cat figurine that appears in a shop window that Stone passes by after seeing Dr. Lee. It looked familiar with me so I ran a Google search and learned that it's called a Maneki-neko: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maneki-neko
"The maneki-neko (Japanese: 招き猫?, literally "beckoning cat") is a common Japanese figurine (lucky charm, talisman) which is often believed to bring good luck to the owner."
It goes without saying that the cat is going to help Stone find the answers. The one thing I can't put my finger on is the blood that was found on the back patio. I have a gut feeling that the cat has something to do with this, especially now that we know there was an open window on the second floor that could have been accessed by climbing the tree below.
Now we know how or why Naz had such big red scratches on his back....its from his allergic reaction to the cat. i might be late on this, but it didnt register to me until they showed the red scratch on Johns neck.
The kiss would not be protected by the privilege. It protects communications between attorney and client. There's either no audio on the tape or it could simply be muted to protect the privilege. It's just a recording of her being grossly unprofessional. It's irrelevant to Naz's case, but it could destroy her career.
Dr. Katz should have his own spin off show, he would rock and roll every courtroom in NYC. Anybody else find it interesting that his name is Katz, cats, CATS. Andreas cat for sure is the killer, damn feline smelled the blood from the knife game and went to town when she was pass out.
Honestly, I think that might be more impactful. Kind of saying that had Box done any investigation into any other possible suspect, he would have found that the step-dad was just as likely as Naz.
Ohhh man, you might have a point-- the way Naz told her that everything was OK will probably rub her the wrong way once she realizes that her son committed suicide.
She was only doing all of this to help her son out :/
Unless NY has weird evidence rules, prior bad acts are generally not admissible (unless to impeach or the defense opens the door on character or something). So how the hell was the stuff about him throwing someone down the stairs as a kid admissible?
Why didn't the pathologist discuss the fact he found blood in the backyard. I don't know about everyone else but I dont believe I have bloody leaves in my yard.
That scene between Chandra and Naz's mother in the bathroom was terrific. The way that Chandra tried to comfort her and the way that Safar rebuffed her... there was so much going on in that moment with so few words.
Something I missed the first time was that Chandra gave Safar a head's up about Naz calling her. I thought perhaps she didn't answer because she didn't know who it was. But Safar knew who it was and refused to pick it up. And Naz knew it as well.
In this context, with Naz despairing that his mother doesn't believe him, Chandra's instinct to comfort him kicked in. Just as she tried to hug Safar to reassure her that Naz was innocent, the kiss was her way to reassure Naz that she believed him.
It's also going to come back to bite her when someone looks at that video that captured it. I predict the kiss will end up in the tabloids.
Stone should have nailed the old rich white lady, she was begging for a threesome. All he had to do was take off his shoes and let the fungi take over, she would have been tripping balls and sucking them as well.
In the first episode they casually mention that they broke chain of evidence Infront of stone. He clearly hears it. I don't understand how it hasn't come up yet.
In the first episode when Nas is sitting in the precinct for however many hours, the forensics guys come up to the desk to ask for the evidence removed from Nas. The officer at the desk says, "Oh, we sent it out, I thought you got it" to which the forensics guys say, "Where did you send it? You know it's supposed to come to us, you can't break the chain of custody like that."
(This isn't actual dialogue, but that's basically a TL,DR version of what happened.)
Anyway this literally happens a few feet from where Nas is sitting and he could obviously listen if he wanted to.
I think the ending is obvious, Chandra obviously struck a nerve with box. He was unaware of the other suspects...He went to his retirement party or whatever with a great deal of guilt. He's clearly going to dig deeper, figure out that Naz was not guilty and he won't get any rest until that happens.
And just as the court decides he is innocent, he will do something stupid in prison and end up staying in there for other reasons. Completely a product of the environment that he shouldn't even be in, in the first place. After all, it seems that the show is trying to point out how fucked up our criminal justice system is.
Box is an interesting mix of a character. He's an asshole, and an antagonist. But his motives appear genuine, that is to solve crimes and catch criminals. He's clearly not racist, and extremely intelligent and well-read. And I think when confronted with the idea having done something wrong, as he did with the inhaler, he has a guilty conscience. Now he's retiring and free of his duties to solve crime and his last sloppy rush to judgement might put someone behind bars.
With the lighting I thought it was a fantasy of Naz's initially. I'm glad it isn't a fantasy since I find those a bit hacky, but I also don't know if the ground work was really laid there effectively.
Maybe because he may be the one to prove Nas's innocence in the end. He doesn't seem like a bad guy, he seems like he would want the right thing done in the end. And it's clear now that he doesn't think Nas did it.
I don't like how they kind of skimmed over the fact that Andrea had other similar scars on her hands and body.
Also I think the fact that Chandra brought up Duane Reade and the hearse guy in court indicates that we haven't seen the last of those two (hopefully). Feeling the same way about the step-dad. I don't think Stone has given up on that lead at all, despite him dropping it for the rest of the ep.
Seems that some people here believe that the show will end with Naz's verdict being guilty to make a point about how flawed the justice system is. But I feel that's cheap, and it would be a pretty frustrating ending. What would be better imo is that Naz ends up being freed at the cost of him being fully corrupted; him turning towards a life of crime after prison. The message here is that the "rehabilitation system" is also flawed — how it took a mostly good man, and amplified the bad that already existed in him. I think that makes for a much more interesting ending anyway.
Agreed. The writers have developed the characters way way too much to end him with a guilty verdict and he just sits in jail. I'm predicting that he is found not guilty and they spend some time ending the show where they highlight the new dynamics between Naz and the free world. Naz and his family are forever changed by the events that have conspired and it would be really interesting to see the conversations between the new Naz and his family.
That's been my take for awhile, especially with the head-shaving and tattoos, and that got stronger with the Coke can incident. I think the Ep 8 title suggests that angle, too.
I don't expect Naz to be convicted - I expect him to get out but be a changed man due to his time in prison. Think "Making a Murderer": how many people think Avery is in fact guilty of murder due to his time previously spent in prison on a wrongful conviction? Prison changes people, especially if they feel like they shouldn't be there and must fight to survive.
This show is about so many different things: inefficiencies in the justice system, wrongful convictions, poor conditions in prisons, good people needing to do bad things to survive, et al. I hope we DO find out who murdered Andrea (no matter who that person may be) because I love the "whodunnit" genre. However, this show clearly is not about that. No matter what the outcome of the trial is, the message is clear: the whole system is messed up.
I don't think Naz did it, Andrea said herself, something's gonna happen tonight in the 1st episode. Can't remember the exact quote. Like she was expecting something bad to happen and figured fuck it.
Even as a "bad girl", how often do you think she hops in cabs and tells the driver she wants to go to the beach, give away drugs and have sex then fall asleep... That's why the stepfather is the strongest suspect, but it could still be someone else.. not Naz tho
Motha fucking freddie is gonna fuck this all up. Naz is going to be found innocent but Freddie is gonna convince him to do some fucked up shit where he ends up staying in prison anyways.
UNTIL they started cutting in Nas with the victim (forgot the name). The way it was cut tells us Nas was thinking about kissing the girl. I think this is a hint that he really remembers. Whether he knows it or not. (See convo with Box about subconscious (unconscious) and conscious mind)
Did Box take the specific inhaler from the scene or from a bag in the station? If he took it from the scene how would he know Naz would need it at the time he left when Naz wasn't even in custody for the murder?
Box took it from the scene after meeting with Naz for the first time in the interrogation room, so it does leave the question of whether he actually did it to help Naz, knowing he'd eventually need it and felt bad for him, or because it wouldn't fit the prosecution's case.
A lot of comments here in disapproval to the kiss.
Anyone else ok with it from a storytelling point?
I didn't see this as a "forced" romantic ploy at all. To me, this was yet another stumble by the defense. Chandra had been near perfect up to this point, but now all three on that side of the courtroom have done things that make you scream at the TV.
It fit the characters. It had been building up. It's not like they're "meant" for each other, but they sympathize with each other and they work close. It was realistic and it hurt to watch. I'm glad it was included.
I wish the defense's expert witness would've went a little further with his thinking in regards to the knife set. On cross-examination, while referring to the knives, he conceded that the 4th knife could have "been lost at some point or broke in the garbage disposal" (paraphrasing with quotes, I know), but I feel like he should've added "or another person could have entered the house and used it to stab the victim and took it with them. They're all possibilities." With juries everything needs to be spelled out and this would've been a haymaker.
at this point, i really don't think we are going to find out who killed andrea. the most likely scenario seems to be that Nas is found guilty and we see in a flashback that he was sleeping when andrea was murdered. i think it's unlikely that they'll show the face of andrea's real killer though. it's pretty clear at this point that the show is not a whodunnit but a critique of our criminal justice system
I think there's room in the show to reveal the real killer while still remaining a critique of our criminal justice system. I'd like to think that Detective Box ends up dying at the hands of the real killer, when he gives into that feeling that he's wrong about Nas and actually investigates.
Anyone feel like Naz is gonna fuck it up and either get killed in prison, or commit a crime in prison where he actually gets caught and gets sentenced for that?
I feel like him getting off free would just be too easy.
This has possibly already been said elsewhere, so my apologies to anyone who has already stated this, but I found the kiss scene quite interesting. When Chandra goes to hold Naz's hand, she ends up covering up his "SIN" tattoo. Then almost immediately after he covers her hand up with his other hand with the "BAD" tattoo. It was almost as if Chandra covering up the "SIN" tattoo was like her covering and trusting him for his sin that he may or may not have committed (the murder). Then right away covering her hand with the "BAD" displays how he has changed/transformed from someone who may or may not have committed a sin, which can be forgiven, to someone who is just genuinely bad now.
I noticed that too. I think that there are a lot of neat stylistic and symbolic choices going on in the show like the one you mentioned, and it might be worth a rewatch someday to try and catch them all.
So, one thing no one has mentioned is that the opening scene of this episode Box is surveying a murder scene and he comments that it reminds him of Andrea Cornish's murder. I think this was to inform the audience that Naz is in fact innocent in the murder of Andrea.
i think it was merely to point out no one in the media cares about the violent murder of a young african american woman, but when a young white woman is killed and the suspect is a minority, its the trial of the century.
Why are you talking about the kiss? The most important moments of the episode were the first and the last.
The episode begins with Box and another detective looking at another murder victim. Box says, "What we have here is the same scenario as Andrea Cornish, would you agree?" This is a serial killer and it can't be Naz.
The episode ends with Box sitting alone drinking after his retirement party trying to decide if he will let the defense know about this other murder or not.
I don't think that's the case at all. The murder at the beginning and his comment was to show the little attention paid when it's a black woman murdered vs a rich white girl. Him sitting alone at the end is because we just found out this episode that he sacrificed his ethics for an easy last conviction. Everything we've heard about him so far is that he'll do everything by the book. He's sitting alone in atonement because he knows he failed himself by personally interfering with the case.
so we are going to learn about a serial killer in the very last episode of the mini series? Doubt it. The reason for that first scene is just to show the difference in how we react to the same exact crime based on who it happens to. Everyone lost their minds over the Andrea Cornish murder because she was a well off , attractive, young, white woman from a rich part of the city. Add to that a Muslim suspect and boom, you have news headlines for months. It is all over national news, Wolf Blitzer, Nancy Grace etc. and all that media coverage crying for justice doesn't help the suspect one bit. That is what they are trying to show, that society is super quick to grab the pitchforks when the narrative fits our ideals. The murder at the beginning of the episode of the black girl is there to show that things like that happen to lots of people, and that the majority of them don't get the Andrea Cornish treatment because to be honest, who cares? I doubt they even mention that murder again in the last episode, it is there just to show a disparity in how we react to things.
as for what Box was thinking while sitting there alone after his party, it is all speculation with zero evidence.
I think you guys may be right, or possibly that we are both right. The words I missed were "So where's the news trucks?" Box is making a point that the media doesn't care about similar murders when the victim is a young black girl instead of a white girl.
So the one dude killed himself because he didn't want to suck dick anymore? And then Freddy killed the other dude because he was making his drug connect suck his dick and that made him want to kill himself so Freddy can't get more drugs?
In the first episode, when Nas gets taken back to the precinct, there are two guys sitting in one of the cell's talking about NBA basketball. One of the men is Pete who is acting normal, not concerned about being in jail, not asking for his one phone call, shooting the sh*t. Once the knife is found on Nas and he is taken down and arrested, we see Pete and his 'friend' being escorted out of the cell. Pete no longer seems calm and says to the officer, worriedly, that he needs to call his 'mom'. My theory is that Andrea's step father went to Freddy to get Andrea killed to collect the money from the estate. When Pete, who didn't murder Andrea but knew the hit was going down, found out that there was someone in the house during the murder, he needed to pass that information on to 'mom' aka Freddy. This explains why Freddy is willing to take Nas under his wing. He knows he is innocent.
Stone must absolutely check to see if the stepfather's ex actually filed charges for the alleged assault. Her story seemed off, he had his hands around her throat and the she was somehow able to contact the police and they arrived in time? Theory: Some of what the Cpa is saying is true. The stepfather really is a gold digger and has filed for bankruptcy etc. But Ray coached the stepfather's ex to bring up a violent incident and then pointed Stone directly to her.
Stone must absolutely check to see if the stepfather's ex actually filed charges for the alleged assault. Her story seemed off, he had his hands around her throat and the she was somehow able to contact the police and they arrived in time?
Domestic assault strangulations happen all the time. You call the police either before or after they strangle you. Putting enough force on someone's throat to give them trouble breathing, even for a few seconds, often leaves terrible bruising. Most domestic abusers aren't aiming to kill their victims -- they're unleashing anger in an extremely short-sighted and harmful manner. Most people survive these incidents, and when the defendant is found out it makes for a fairly easy case of domestic abuse for the prosecutor.
What's the deal with Stone's self-imposed-while-asleep scratches that he blames on the cat? I've never seen someone scratch themselves up that hard while asleep.
Am I the only one who absolutely cannot stand the actor who plays the prosecutor Helen Weiss? She is totally monotone and her acting takes me out of every scene she's in.
A lot of people think that for some reason. I think she's fantastic. A lot of people think that too. On Reddit the sentiments are generally against her; and on web reviews she's very popular. I wonder if this is an age bracket thing. Jeannie Berlin is the daughter of Elaine May.
I almost feel like the past couple episodes have been a little rushed. There's eight episodes as part of the limited series but it could easily be ten. Either that or the episodes should all be 75-90 minutes long. I enjoyed last night's as we got significant developments in the case findings and witnesses. I feel like it's trying to close every loose end and plot point.
I think this was my favorite episode so far, since we get to see Chandra on the offensive and make some headway in court.
I suspected this from the beginning, but I think they're going to leave us on a cliff hanger, without a verdict.
There's so much more to explore and so many questions that I want answered that I don't think is possible to cover in 1.5 hours.
I'm a fan of the actress that plays Chandra. That scene in the bathroom between Chandra and Naz's mom, who's very good as well, was heartbreaking.
That kiss was stupid though. It would have been forgivable if it was a daydream or if it stopped before anything happened, but that's life. Can that video be released, even though it's between an attorney and client?
I read an article with the producers/creators of the show saying they're open for another season to tell another story, so I guess Naz's story ends with the 8th and final episode.
Otherwise, I'm excited and sad this series is ending. It has a lot of potential and I can see them exploring other stories with new characters each season, kind of like what they did with In Treatment, another very good adapted HBO show.
Can that video be released, even though it's between an attorney and client?
Yes, I believe so. The audio would have to be excluded. Both my parents are attorneys - their take is that the only person who could potentially be hurt by the kiss is Chandra, whose professionalism is clearly compromised.
Conversely, it could potentially help Naz on appeal, as it could be argued that the kiss shows that Chandra's emotional involvement rendered her ineffective as counsel.
I'm annoyed with the pacing of this show. I would assume many months have passed, but it would appear everything has happened in weeks. I'm guessing the time line based on how long stone has had his cat.
If only weeks have passed, I can't imagine Nas would have had such a big transformation in prison nor do I believe the justice system works that quickly. Please someone correct me if I'm wrong.
Yeah - the show undoubtedly suggests that racism is prevalent in courtrooms, and that incarceration is an ineffective means of "rehabilitation." Naz being denied bail and being placed on the no fly list despite having no criminal record and no passport says it all. Such a critical moment that ultimately changes the course of his life. He was assumed to be a terror threat because he's of Pakistani descent. Had he been granted bail, he would have awaited trial on the outside and wouldn't have turned into a monster - a monster that was ironically created by the system that is supposed to help him become a better person and ultimately return and contribute to society. At this point, regardless of the verdict, his life is shot.
If Nas is found not guilty and leaves prison, wouldn't Freddy still have leverage on him? As in, could Freddy force Nas (via threats to him and his family) to get him drugs or other contraband?
I was curious what people make of how race is treated in this show. It's clearly a major theme, but it's subtle. It just occurred to me in this last episode that Naz, in the beginning, really wanted to fit in with the cool black kids on the basketball team (that was why he was going to the party in Manhattan in the first place), and now -- in this horrible twisted way -- he's found his place in an "in-crowd" of the alpha male black guys around Freddy. The tattoos seemed so out of character and reckless but then it made sense if we see it as a quest for belonging that's been part of his life for a while. All of which could be part of the show's commentary on race, i.e., being South Asian, and Pakistani particularly, in the American racial context, trying to find your place, or whatnot.
Andreas stepfather is a massive creep, pulling moves in the gym on hungry and tired clientele. If I was stone I would plant a hooker in the gym, and get her to give the stepfather aids. Then he would be a gym trainer who can't sweat without worrying that he is spreading his cooties. Pootie Tang.
How the hell are they gonna wrap all this up in one episode? Really didnt like how at the end they expanded upon the jailhouse drama rather than closing in on a storyline....I really dont care about the inmates.
The jailhouse drama is crucial to the entire story. The story is what happens to Naz as a result of this one night of fuckery and how his entire world has been shaken up, and how his character develops as a result of being put in jail for a crime he (presumably) didn't commit. Or didn't remember committing. Whatever floats your boat.
Freddie's (can't help but at least think of him as Omar) whole system is built on being able to sling dope. The guy raping the kid who was ultimately the supply screwed that up.
Nas is living a comfy life in jail because of Freddie and it is all because Nas can help Freddie with the business.
Well, the business is fucked. So all of this is very relevant for our boy Nas. This wasn't just petty jail drama, this will have an impact on our main character.
With one episode left, I feel it points to a ending that isn't too happy for naz. I see him either fucking up in prison or getting convicted. As the episode ends we get a some kind of answer that he didn't kill her but will do life in prison anyway.
Loved this episode! For me, this one really drove home the point that the criminal justice system works how it works, regardless of the story. We've been given so many different angles, and they've all been so heavy handed: Nasir is good and innocent (see first few episodes), Nasir is bad (see "sin" and "bad" knuckle tats; his cold, remorseless behavior when helping Freddie kill that dude in the end), the stepdad did it (so many red flags with him), Duane Reade did it, the creepy herse driver did it, etc etc. Obviously these all aren't options. I think the whole point is, it doesn't matter what we think, or it doesn't even matter who really killed her. The point is that the story from a legal standpoint has already been written. The Justice system doesnt serve everyone equally, and our prejudices/stereotypes are the reason why. (See Box's line at the beginning, when he points out that the media cared about Andrea's murder, but was nowhere to be found when a black girl showed up murdered in the same manner).
I think those chumbalones are all red herrings. whoever stabbed that lady at the beginning of ep 7 did it, and box will find some link to the andrea killer. My guess is its a militant PETA member who saw the deer head and RAGED.
Box regrets getting caught in a mistake, not that he did it. He isn't doubting his work or Nas' guilt; he feels conflicted about his retirement. Even if he somehow proved Nas' innocence, the prosecutor isn't going to put the brakes on the trial. She's got too much riding on it. The PD would have to find a more compelling suspect to charge and drop charges against Nas. The PD ain't looking for anyone else.
I wish the show had done less focus on jail and answered some of the many questions that need to be answered now in one episode in some of the time used for jail. While I still love this show I don't see how all of this can be wrapped up in one episode. Many questions will simply have to go unanswered but I am hopeful that we will at least find out who killed her.
Anyone else feel like Naz signing the inhaler release form took him forever? To me it felt like he was furiously writing something for far longer than it takes to sign your name.
Isn't it possible that he had to write more than his name? Name, DOB, SSN, inmate number, cell number, medicine type, sign... any combo of these things?
I think Box mishandled the evidence intentionally. He knows the Naz didn't do it from the beginning. He took a long time thinking about when to charge him, so he decides to take his inhaler out of evidence when he's made his mind up. He's about to retire so makes a minor error in order to help Naz in the "end" (Naz's trial), but also, to help his own conscience. Now he's just meddling with the fact the real killer is out there, and if he can live/golf with that.
If Box really and truly thought Naz was innocent, he would have been continuing the investigation into other potential suspects. Giving the inhaler to Naz was more of a way to be Officer Friendly, part of Box's effort to get Naz to confess. Despite Box's protestations on the stand, he really, really, really wanted a confession.
I sincerely doubt this. If Box thought Naz was innocent he would either a) pursue other leads or b) not care. Why would he risk being caught out on a major evidence handling error, potentially risking his pension if it were seen to be intentional (fraud)?
69
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
9
u/youngmermaid Aug 22 '16
The kiss didn't really bother me because it's been building up. But it did annoy me because it's just like COME ON GUYS HOW COULD YOU BE SO STUPID?
14
u/TheClassyRifleman Aug 22 '16
It really bugged me how the defense wasn't piecing things together for the jury like they should have during Dr. Katz's portion of the testimony. Sure, the jury probably understands that someone wouldn't be able to see Naz if they went in the back and immediately up the stairs, but a decent attorney would specifically ask the question to clarify it, and make it stick in the jurors' minds.
"So based on the angle of your photograph, which was taken on the stairs, someone coming from the back gate and traveling up the stairs wouldn't have been able to see the defendant unconscious in the kitchen, is that correct?"
11
u/callmebatman14 Aug 22 '16
Kiss between Chandra and naz was out of no where.
385
u/mi_piace Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
All I can think is... none of this shit would have happened if Naz's friend just picked him up for the party like he said he would.
271
u/cogollento We'll never know Aug 22 '16
Dr. Katz is super awesome.
144
u/Ferggzilla Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
Naz is gonna be found not guilty. We'll find out it was the step dad but he goes free and gets money from the house. Naz and his family are still screwed and sold everything to prove his innocence not to mention backlash they've received from the community. Screwed by the criminal justice system under the "veil of presumed innocence".
198
u/Jimbob929 Aug 22 '16
the kiss was cheesy otherwise great episode
253
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
The cat was solid like always. Hope it gets its own spinoff.
77
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
I felt like there were a lot of moments either lawyer could have objected in court but didn't do so. Some of the legal scenes are very inaccurate.
74
u/EarthNoMore Aug 22 '16
So is Box thinking he messed up?
58
u/taward Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
I'm still at a loss as to why no one has asked how it is Naz could have done this and not ended up soaked in blood. I know this has been mentioned before but now that we're seeing the machinations in the courtroom, it seems absurd that this hasn't been brought up, particularly since we're getting into the minutiae of missing knives and what this guy said about this other guy years ago.
48
u/moonshoeslol Aug 22 '16
You have to feel bad for the Khan family.
Whether Naz did it or not, they had nothing to do with the events that transpired and yet they are dead broke, shunned and constantly harassed.
88
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
I posted some of this in the live discussion but wanted to share:
Did anybody else notice that the cat opened the door by itself in Stone's apartment and jumped into bed with him? As soon as this happened I immediately thought about how Andrea let her cat outside in the first episode.
Someone else mentioned the tiger documentary Naz and Freddy were watching this episode and how the narrator said something about cats not taking well to water. I was thinking that if it rained that night after Andrea let the cat out, the cat would have been encouraged to return home. So I went back and watched parts of the first episode, and while it didn't appear to be raining when Andrea let the cat outside, it definitely did rain that night, as evidenced by the wet pavement and puddles we see in the very last scene of episode 1 when Naz's father runs outside and discovers his cab is gone. It's also worth noting that in this scene, a cat runs across the street behind Naz's father.
Another image from tonight's episode that stuck with me was that of a waving cat figurine that appears in a shop window that Stone passes by after seeing Dr. Lee. It looked familiar with me so I ran a Google search and learned that it's called a Maneki-neko: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maneki-neko
"The maneki-neko (Japanese: 招き猫?, literally "beckoning cat") is a common Japanese figurine (lucky charm, talisman) which is often believed to bring good luck to the owner."
It goes without saying that the cat is going to help Stone find the answers. The one thing I can't put my finger on is the blood that was found on the back patio. I have a gut feeling that the cat has something to do with this, especially now that we know there was an open window on the second floor that could have been accessed by climbing the tree below.
5
u/theverdictsin Aug 22 '16
Now we know how or why Naz had such big red scratches on his back....its from his allergic reaction to the cat. i might be late on this, but it didnt register to me until they showed the red scratch on Johns neck.
41
u/Jean-Paul_Sartre We'll never know Aug 22 '16
Katz 2016
109
u/dingleberry6996 Aug 22 '16
that kiss will end up haunting naz and his defense team, camera caught it, they should have went all in and boned right then and there
35
u/MickeyBronson Aug 22 '16
it would be crazy if he was found "not guilty" and he ended up doing it.... i don't think he did..... but that'd be crazy.
70
u/dingleberry6996 Aug 22 '16
Dr. Katz should have his own spin off show, he would rock and roll every courtroom in NYC. Anybody else find it interesting that his name is Katz, cats, CATS. Andreas cat for sure is the killer, damn feline smelled the blood from the knife game and went to town when she was pass out.
118
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
I honestly do not think we are going to find out who killed andrea.
58
u/rekirts Aug 22 '16
I can't see a way everything gets wrapped up in an hour next week...
28
u/MobbDeepFan Aug 22 '16
I have a feeling Naz will get exonerated but Petey's mother will end up flipping on Naz, either for the drug smuggling thing or for murder conspiracy.
26
u/br0ct00n Aug 22 '16
Unless NY has weird evidence rules, prior bad acts are generally not admissible (unless to impeach or the defense opens the door on character or something). So how the hell was the stuff about him throwing someone down the stairs as a kid admissible?
49
u/Irishalbert37 Aug 22 '16
Why didn't the pathologist discuss the fact he found blood in the backyard. I don't know about everyone else but I dont believe I have bloody leaves in my yard.
66
u/ircmullaney Aug 22 '16
That scene between Chandra and Naz's mother in the bathroom was terrific. The way that Chandra tried to comfort her and the way that Safar rebuffed her... there was so much going on in that moment with so few words.
Something I missed the first time was that Chandra gave Safar a head's up about Naz calling her. I thought perhaps she didn't answer because she didn't know who it was. But Safar knew who it was and refused to pick it up. And Naz knew it as well.
In this context, with Naz despairing that his mother doesn't believe him, Chandra's instinct to comfort him kicked in. Just as she tried to hug Safar to reassure her that Naz was innocent, the kiss was her way to reassure Naz that she believed him.
It's also going to come back to bite her when someone looks at that video that captured it. I predict the kiss will end up in the tabloids.
266
u/dingleberry6996 Aug 22 '16
Stone should have nailed the old rich white lady, she was begging for a threesome. All he had to do was take off his shoes and let the fungi take over, she would have been tripping balls and sucking them as well.
21
u/Golden_Jiggy Aug 22 '16
In the first episode they casually mention that they broke chain of evidence Infront of stone. He clearly hears it. I don't understand how it hasn't come up yet.
21
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
I think the ending is obvious, Chandra obviously struck a nerve with box. He was unaware of the other suspects...He went to his retirement party or whatever with a great deal of guilt. He's clearly going to dig deeper, figure out that Naz was not guilty and he won't get any rest until that happens.
84
u/dinero2180 Aug 22 '16
Was anybody else bothered by the kiss? I just don't know why it was necessary, maybe I'm missing something
17
u/BaconIsGodsGift Aug 22 '16
Significance of Box choosing the episode title on his insurance?
29
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
Katz owning the DA was my favorite part of this episode
14
u/j-3000 Aug 22 '16
I don't like how they kind of skimmed over the fact that Andrea had other similar scars on her hands and body.
Also I think the fact that Chandra brought up Duane Reade and the hearse guy in court indicates that we haven't seen the last of those two (hopefully). Feeling the same way about the step-dad. I don't think Stone has given up on that lead at all, despite him dropping it for the rest of the ep.
Very excited about next weeks episode.
25
u/mormanbear Aug 22 '16
I got really worried at the end their with Naz.
24
u/j-3000 Aug 22 '16
"Do you think you're invisible?"
Someone finally said what we've all been thinking for weeks.
55
u/xitzengyigglz Aug 23 '16
I want Nas to stand up in court and say" the only thing I murdered was that pussy!" And then fist bump stone.
30
u/SomebodyImportant101 Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
Seems that some people here believe that the show will end with Naz's verdict being guilty to make a point about how flawed the justice system is. But I feel that's cheap, and it would be a pretty frustrating ending. What would be better imo is that Naz ends up being freed at the cost of him being fully corrupted; him turning towards a life of crime after prison. The message here is that the "rehabilitation system" is also flawed — how it took a mostly good man, and amplified the bad that already existed in him. I think that makes for a much more interesting ending anyway.
20
u/am5465 Aug 22 '16
I don't expect Naz to be convicted - I expect him to get out but be a changed man due to his time in prison. Think "Making a Murderer": how many people think Avery is in fact guilty of murder due to his time previously spent in prison on a wrongful conviction? Prison changes people, especially if they feel like they shouldn't be there and must fight to survive.
This show is about so many different things: inefficiencies in the justice system, wrongful convictions, poor conditions in prisons, good people needing to do bad things to survive, et al. I hope we DO find out who murdered Andrea (no matter who that person may be) because I love the "whodunnit" genre. However, this show clearly is not about that. No matter what the outcome of the trial is, the message is clear: the whole system is messed up.
10
u/mrnoor Aug 22 '16
I don't think Naz did it, Andrea said herself, something's gonna happen tonight in the 1st episode. Can't remember the exact quote. Like she was expecting something bad to happen and figured fuck it.
Even as a "bad girl", how often do you think she hops in cabs and tells the driver she wants to go to the beach, give away drugs and have sex then fall asleep... That's why the stepfather is the strongest suspect, but it could still be someone else.. not Naz tho
9
u/offjerk Aug 22 '16
Motha fucking freddie is gonna fuck this all up. Naz is going to be found innocent but Freddie is gonna convince him to do some fucked up shit where he ends up staying in prison anyways.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
I thought the kiss was weird, too.
UNTIL they started cutting in Nas with the victim (forgot the name). The way it was cut tells us Nas was thinking about kissing the girl. I think this is a hint that he really remembers. Whether he knows it or not. (See convo with Box about subconscious (unconscious) and conscious mind)
9
u/toxicbrew Aug 24 '16
Who would buy 1/3 of a medallion for $250k when Uber is around?
8
u/CWSwapigans Aug 22 '16
With just one episode left there's no way they're gonna tie up all the open questions here. I'm curious to see what mysteries they leave.
8
u/ChicagoIL Aug 22 '16
Did Box take the specific inhaler from the scene or from a bag in the station? If he took it from the scene how would he know Naz would need it at the time he left when Naz wasn't even in custody for the murder?
15
u/PM_Me_Your_Schnoz A Subtle Beast Aug 22 '16
How has the CPA known so much about Don this whole time?? And he seems almost giddy to help the case against him
39
u/jvotto19 Aug 22 '16
A lot of comments here in disapproval to the kiss.
Anyone else ok with it from a storytelling point?
I didn't see this as a "forced" romantic ploy at all. To me, this was yet another stumble by the defense. Chandra had been near perfect up to this point, but now all three on that side of the courtroom have done things that make you scream at the TV.
It fit the characters. It had been building up. It's not like they're "meant" for each other, but they sympathize with each other and they work close. It was realistic and it hurt to watch. I'm glad it was included.
7
u/12millercs Aug 22 '16
Katz reminded me of the Asian guy that the defense from "The staircase" brought in to cross examine , if anyone has seen that.
19
u/rjstang Aug 22 '16
Wasn't there a dead girl all stabbed up in the street at the beginning of the episode? Haven't seen anyone mention this.
13
u/bigjoe65 Aug 22 '16
Did the preview for the finale leave anyone else worried? I was kinda confused but it seemed like Freddy tried to put the murder in jail on Naz.
13
u/Mbenner40 Aug 22 '16
I wish the defense's expert witness would've went a little further with his thinking in regards to the knife set. On cross-examination, while referring to the knives, he conceded that the 4th knife could have "been lost at some point or broke in the garbage disposal" (paraphrasing with quotes, I know), but I feel like he should've added "or another person could have entered the house and used it to stab the victim and took it with them. They're all possibilities." With juries everything needs to be spelled out and this would've been a haymaker.
18
u/heybrother13 Aug 22 '16
at this point, i really don't think we are going to find out who killed andrea. the most likely scenario seems to be that Nas is found guilty and we see in a flashback that he was sleeping when andrea was murdered. i think it's unlikely that they'll show the face of andrea's real killer though. it's pretty clear at this point that the show is not a whodunnit but a critique of our criminal justice system
6
u/jarkmames Aug 22 '16
Shitty Prediction: he gets acquitted of the murder of Andrea then gets a 187 hung on him on accomplice liability for freddy killing the other guy.
Do people not realize everything in Jail is taped?
16
u/themariokarters 1.5" wide, 5" long Aug 22 '16
What an amazing episode man.
2
u/Steve4444 Aug 22 '16
who was that actor who was working in the copy shop - i can't place him but i know him from something else
11
u/WaterChemistry Aug 22 '16
Anyone feel like Naz is gonna fuck it up and either get killed in prison, or commit a crime in prison where he actually gets caught and gets sentenced for that?
I feel like him getting off free would just be too easy.
15
u/boomerifical Aug 22 '16
This has possibly already been said elsewhere, so my apologies to anyone who has already stated this, but I found the kiss scene quite interesting. When Chandra goes to hold Naz's hand, she ends up covering up his "SIN" tattoo. Then almost immediately after he covers her hand up with his other hand with the "BAD" tattoo. It was almost as if Chandra covering up the "SIN" tattoo was like her covering and trusting him for his sin that he may or may not have committed (the murder). Then right away covering her hand with the "BAD" displays how he has changed/transformed from someone who may or may not have committed a sin, which can be forgiven, to someone who is just genuinely bad now.
15
u/juiceimortal Omar Comin' Aug 22 '16
So, one thing no one has mentioned is that the opening scene of this episode Box is surveying a murder scene and he comments that it reminds him of Andrea Cornish's murder. I think this was to inform the audience that Naz is in fact innocent in the murder of Andrea.
77
u/ircmullaney Aug 22 '16
Why are you talking about the kiss? The most important moments of the episode were the first and the last.
The episode begins with Box and another detective looking at another murder victim. Box says, "What we have here is the same scenario as Andrea Cornish, would you agree?" This is a serial killer and it can't be Naz.
The episode ends with Box sitting alone drinking after his retirement party trying to decide if he will let the defense know about this other murder or not.
18
u/TheNewJack89 Aug 22 '16
So the one dude killed himself because he didn't want to suck dick anymore? And then Freddy killed the other dude because he was making his drug connect suck his dick and that made him want to kill himself so Freddy can't get more drugs?
14
u/KingxRomox9 Aug 23 '16
In the first episode, when Nas gets taken back to the precinct, there are two guys sitting in one of the cell's talking about NBA basketball. One of the men is Pete who is acting normal, not concerned about being in jail, not asking for his one phone call, shooting the sh*t. Once the knife is found on Nas and he is taken down and arrested, we see Pete and his 'friend' being escorted out of the cell. Pete no longer seems calm and says to the officer, worriedly, that he needs to call his 'mom'. My theory is that Andrea's step father went to Freddy to get Andrea killed to collect the money from the estate. When Pete, who didn't murder Andrea but knew the hit was going down, found out that there was someone in the house during the murder, he needed to pass that information on to 'mom' aka Freddy. This explains why Freddy is willing to take Nas under his wing. He knows he is innocent.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
Stone must absolutely check to see if the stepfather's ex actually filed charges for the alleged assault. Her story seemed off, he had his hands around her throat and the she was somehow able to contact the police and they arrived in time? Theory: Some of what the Cpa is saying is true. The stepfather really is a gold digger and has filed for bankruptcy etc. But Ray coached the stepfather's ex to bring up a violent incident and then pointed Stone directly to her.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
What's the deal with Stone's self-imposed-while-asleep scratches that he blames on the cat? I've never seen someone scratch themselves up that hard while asleep.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '16
Everybody seems to be reading into the kiss, I thought she was just trying to keep him going after his mom stopped talking to him.
2
u/doughansen Aug 22 '16
Am I the only one who absolutely cannot stand the actor who plays the prosecutor Helen Weiss? She is totally monotone and her acting takes me out of every scene she's in.
9
u/Cakes2015 Aug 22 '16
I almost feel like the past couple episodes have been a little rushed. There's eight episodes as part of the limited series but it could easily be ten. Either that or the episodes should all be 75-90 minutes long. I enjoyed last night's as we got significant developments in the case findings and witnesses. I feel like it's trying to close every loose end and plot point.
12
u/wipny Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
I think this was my favorite episode so far, since we get to see Chandra on the offensive and make some headway in court.
I suspected this from the beginning, but I think they're going to leave us on a cliff hanger, without a verdict.
There's so much more to explore and so many questions that I want answered that I don't think is possible to cover in 1.5 hours.
I'm a fan of the actress that plays Chandra. That scene in the bathroom between Chandra and Naz's mom, who's very good as well, was heartbreaking.
That kiss was stupid though. It would have been forgivable if it was a daydream or if it stopped before anything happened, but that's life. Can that video be released, even though it's between an attorney and client?
I read an article with the producers/creators of the show saying they're open for another season to tell another story, so I guess Naz's story ends with the 8th and final episode.
Otherwise, I'm excited and sad this series is ending. It has a lot of potential and I can see them exploring other stories with new characters each season, kind of like what they did with In Treatment, another very good adapted HBO show.
8
u/Kurtronic Aug 22 '16
I'm annoyed with the pacing of this show. I would assume many months have passed, but it would appear everything has happened in weeks. I'm guessing the time line based on how long stone has had his cat.
If only weeks have passed, I can't imagine Nas would have had such a big transformation in prison nor do I believe the justice system works that quickly. Please someone correct me if I'm wrong.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '16
Yeah - the show undoubtedly suggests that racism is prevalent in courtrooms, and that incarceration is an ineffective means of "rehabilitation." Naz being denied bail and being placed on the no fly list despite having no criminal record and no passport says it all. Such a critical moment that ultimately changes the course of his life. He was assumed to be a terror threat because he's of Pakistani descent. Had he been granted bail, he would have awaited trial on the outside and wouldn't have turned into a monster - a monster that was ironically created by the system that is supposed to help him become a better person and ultimately return and contribute to society. At this point, regardless of the verdict, his life is shot.
4
u/impekkable706 Aug 22 '16
If Nas is found not guilty and leaves prison, wouldn't Freddy still have leverage on him? As in, could Freddy force Nas (via threats to him and his family) to get him drugs or other contraband?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '16
I was curious what people make of how race is treated in this show. It's clearly a major theme, but it's subtle. It just occurred to me in this last episode that Naz, in the beginning, really wanted to fit in with the cool black kids on the basketball team (that was why he was going to the party in Manhattan in the first place), and now -- in this horrible twisted way -- he's found his place in an "in-crowd" of the alpha male black guys around Freddy. The tattoos seemed so out of character and reckless but then it made sense if we see it as a quest for belonging that's been part of his life for a while. All of which could be part of the show's commentary on race, i.e., being South Asian, and Pakistani particularly, in the American racial context, trying to find your place, or whatnot.
Thoughts?
31
u/dingleberry6996 Aug 22 '16
Andreas stepfather is a massive creep, pulling moves in the gym on hungry and tired clientele. If I was stone I would plant a hooker in the gym, and get her to give the stepfather aids. Then he would be a gym trainer who can't sweat without worrying that he is spreading his cooties. Pootie Tang.
15
u/Eforestation Aug 22 '16
"Six mollys"
lol
9
u/IamCGI Aug 22 '16
It's the hearse guy
9
u/claydavisismyhero Aug 22 '16
im on the fence whether the kiss was a misstep by the writers.
10
u/sanfrancisco69er Aug 22 '16
How the hell are they gonna wrap all this up in one episode? Really didnt like how at the end they expanded upon the jailhouse drama rather than closing in on a storyline....I really dont care about the inmates.
6
u/Realniggafasho Aug 22 '16
With one episode left, I feel it points to a ending that isn't too happy for naz. I see him either fucking up in prison or getting convicted. As the episode ends we get a some kind of answer that he didn't kill her but will do life in prison anyway.
8
u/TooMama Aug 22 '16
Loved this episode! For me, this one really drove home the point that the criminal justice system works how it works, regardless of the story. We've been given so many different angles, and they've all been so heavy handed: Nasir is good and innocent (see first few episodes), Nasir is bad (see "sin" and "bad" knuckle tats; his cold, remorseless behavior when helping Freddie kill that dude in the end), the stepdad did it (so many red flags with him), Duane Reade did it, the creepy herse driver did it, etc etc. Obviously these all aren't options. I think the whole point is, it doesn't matter what we think, or it doesn't even matter who really killed her. The point is that the story from a legal standpoint has already been written. The Justice system doesnt serve everyone equally, and our prejudices/stereotypes are the reason why. (See Box's line at the beginning, when he points out that the media cared about Andrea's murder, but was nowhere to be found when a black girl showed up murdered in the same manner).
8
u/reddituser165 Aug 22 '16
step dad paid duane reed to kill andrea. promised him some of the insurance money. that's my theory
3
u/boo_prime_numbers We'll never know Aug 22 '16
Box regrets getting caught in a mistake, not that he did it. He isn't doubting his work or Nas' guilt; he feels conflicted about his retirement. Even if he somehow proved Nas' innocence, the prosecutor isn't going to put the brakes on the trial. She's got too much riding on it. The PD would have to find a more compelling suspect to charge and drop charges against Nas. The PD ain't looking for anyone else.
3
u/GoingMachFive Aug 22 '16
Is the finale going to be 58 minutes like the others or longer?
5
u/harbaughskhakis17 Aug 22 '16
I wish the show had done less focus on jail and answered some of the many questions that need to be answered now in one episode in some of the time used for jail. While I still love this show I don't see how all of this can be wrapped up in one episode. Many questions will simply have to go unanswered but I am hopeful that we will at least find out who killed her.
5
u/Colonel_Angus_ Aug 22 '16
Anyone else feel like Naz signing the inhaler release form took him forever? To me it felt like he was furiously writing something for far longer than it takes to sign your name.
5
u/TheLadyEve Aug 23 '16
I had that stepfather pegged from the beginning, so I hope it's not that simple.
The cross examination with Dr. Katz was simply a delight to watch. This show is stellar, and I think this is the best episode so far.
8
u/lookingtothefuture94 Aug 22 '16
i hope peteys mom didn't have an std otherwise naz is fuckeddddd
10
u/DabblesALot Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
I think Box mishandled the evidence intentionally. He knows the Naz didn't do it from the beginning. He took a long time thinking about when to charge him, so he decides to take his inhaler out of evidence when he's made his mind up. He's about to retire so makes a minor error in order to help Naz in the "end" (Naz's trial), but also, to help his own conscience. Now he's just meddling with the fact the real killer is out there, and if he can live/golf with that.