r/TheNightOf • • Aug 29 '16

The Night Of - Episode 8 "The Call of the Wild" - Post-Episode Discussion

Episode 8: The Call of the Wild

Aired: August 28th, 2016


Episode Synopsis: Stone is thrust into the spotlight as a controversy involving the defense emerges.


Directed by: Steven Zaillian

Written by: Richard Price & Steven Zaillian

779 Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

710

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Aug 29 '16

To me, the real hero is the dad. After all the family went through with the cab, the trial, the media speculation, and the racist harassment, he still stuck by his son. I love the embrace with the two of them after Nas is freed.

341

u/fangsby Aug 29 '16

When he asked Naz if he wanted to go out and hang with his friends, I was kind of hoping Naz would ask if he could borrow the cab. Then punch his father in the shoulder and say, "Just fuckin' with you, Dad."

→ More replies (21)

56

u/Forgottensoul89 Aug 31 '16

Nas's dad is the epitome of what ever father should be. Never once questioned his son, stood by him, didn't sell him out even though it was the easy thing to do. Great father and a great actor.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/stanley_twobrick Aug 30 '16

I can't believe the mom didn't even come to pick him up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

1.0k

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

Because of this show I'm not sure if I'm more terrified of going to prison for a crime I didn't commit, or developing eczema.

503

u/suarezj9 Aug 29 '16

What if you developed eczema while in prison?!?!

→ More replies (17)

78

u/niravana21 Aug 29 '16

when else would you get a sick sin bad tat

→ More replies (36)

840

u/didjerid00d Aug 29 '16

Tragic story. Less tragic then Nas going away for life when he is innocent. But left mangled by the criminal justice system. I was so relieved when he was free to go. But that last shot of him sitting at the beach broke my fucking heart.

286

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Also Chandra's career is completely ruined.

→ More replies (100)

454

u/VRomero32 Aug 29 '16

Especially him remembering Andrea, he clearly had feelings for her though she was the unintentional catalyst for the ruining of his life... even more heartbreaking

→ More replies (20)

283

u/JonSnow33 Aug 29 '16

Honestly, I reached a point in episode 7 where I kind of felt like he may just be better off in prison at this point. He's not who he was before he took that cab, this new version of Nas is far better off living out his days with Freddie. His drug addiction and issues with the community around him are the perfect recipe for him ending back up in jail anyway. The finale confirmed that for me

→ More replies (32)

10

u/OneReportersOpinion Aug 29 '16

I think the saddest thing is that he really doesn't know if he killed her or not.

→ More replies (37)

383

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

ughhh Stone's closing argument was awesome

134

u/BleedingFish Aug 29 '16

I honestly think that alone made Nas a free man. That arguement caused the deadlock

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

998

u/moneymoneymoneymonay Aug 29 '16

"What do you want to do tonight, Nas?? Do you want to go out with your friends?"

YEAH LETS NOT DAD

797

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

For some reason I found this heartbreaking. It's almost like the dad blames himself for being too strict and is somehow trying to make up for it, even though it's too late.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (8)

974

u/ProfessorWeeto Aug 29 '16

There's something poetic about the fact that Freddy ended up being a man of his word. He genuinely saw the innocence in Nas and tried to help him. It wasn't a ruse, there wasn't any ulterior motive (even though he still used him for jobs) and he even did his best to get him out. They could have easily made him turn on Nas, or have him plant some of the evidence he clearly had access to that could have hurt Nas. He just wanted a cool dude to hang with that wasn't like the rest of the filth in prison

507

u/mw8912a Aug 29 '16

I enjoyed this part of the story as well. At the end, when we see Nas leave Rikers once and for all, I felt for Freddy. He was clearly taking his frustration out on the punching bag because he just "lost" his closest companion and someone who's presence he genuinely enjoyed. It makes sense that Nas would also go right back to the heroin as well because he probably never connected with anyone on such an emotional level like he did with Freddy.

→ More replies (57)

272

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

We saw three people with the same character: Freddie, Stone, and his Dad. All genuinely believed he was innocent throughout the whole trial. It's interesting that they all represent one part of the justice system: the public, the courts, the prisons.

→ More replies (22)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

It was the most poetic and ironic thing that the hardened criminal boss in prison was the one to offer Naz protection and presume his innocence, versus the criminal justice system.

→ More replies (37)

2.0k

u/jcoop93 Aug 29 '16

Who else thought Naz was gonna get murdered as he was leaving prison?

642

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Totally. I was terrified

→ More replies (9)

440

u/midnitetoker87 Aug 29 '16

I thought Nas would get killed leaving prison and Stone later would call about the cat only to hear it was put down

→ More replies (14)

242

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

That was more intense than the jury scene. As he's packing his things up I couldn't help but think, you have to go back to jail after you're free? Dude just burn all my shit I'm not going back in there.

And how many small dark rooms do you need to go through on the way out?? I was clenching everything

→ More replies (15)

173

u/MrRyszard Aug 29 '16

I was positive that someone was going to die... until the credits rolled.

→ More replies (9)

127

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Every time the camera was viewing him from that window I was waiting for him to get it! Thought maybe if Freddy couldn't have Naz he wasn't going to let him walk free.

→ More replies (18)

9

u/MiamiFootball Aug 29 '16

I thought Omar was going to kill him right when we saw that the cell was empty. I think the show kinda faked that move when they had kind of a 'bang' when they transitioned to the next scene

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (46)

521

u/skatingee Aug 29 '16

My favorite character the whole series was Box. He couldn't have played the part more perfectly. Deep down it just didn't sit right with him, and when he left the court room, it just solidified his innocence.

288

u/Thepappas Aug 29 '16

Box and Stone were the best characters in the series.

→ More replies (29)

12

u/PinnedWrists A Proper Convict Aug 29 '16

He went in there that day intending to make a big show of walking out. The scene where Naz's mom walks out explained it all to us.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Honestly I was shocked at how much him leaving the court room affected the prosecutor. You would think that she would be able to continue through minor distractions like that. Though I guess it was to show that she was starting to realize she might be wrong.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

237

u/beef_boloney Aug 29 '16

The cat and Naz made it - we good

→ More replies (2)

224

u/The_La_Jollan Doesn't Matter, Had Sex Aug 29 '16

All I know is, that cat got away with murder.

60

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Don't be surprised if Stone turns up dead in his bed, stabbed 22 times.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/oliviapostisfakename Aug 30 '16 edited Aug 30 '16

Let's not forget the cat also tried to kill Stone by sneaking into his room and snuggling him almost to death

→ More replies (2)

620

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Great show about a man's battle with eczema

92

u/EddieKruger Aug 29 '16

i think perhaps it was metaphor for the damaged and disgusting legal system. Everyone has "the cure" but it is really broken and will take a long time to heal and probably won't they way politics work. So learning to live with it as uncomfortable as it is in the mean time.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/Abacap Aug 29 '16

Dude I have eczema (Was much worse when I was growing up, not Stone level though) and halfway through this season I started to give less fucks about Naz and more about Johns battle. Fuck eczema

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

1.2k

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Cat lived. Show 10/10.

214

u/TheLadyEve Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

I was more relieved to see that cat than I should have been.

It was his love for that cat (and for doing actually good work instead of his standard shtick) that cured his eczema.

→ More replies (8)

102

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

We should all take the time to thank Sarah McLachlan.

→ More replies (5)

77

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

Sobs commercials work. I can't believe this.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/MiamiFootball Aug 29 '16

the whole show is about that cat. we just don't watch it sleep. but if it's awake, the show is about the cat.

→ More replies (25)

531

u/bjorn2reddit Aug 29 '16

More closure than I was expecting, but I could have watched another 8 episodes happily.

440

u/SevenwithaT Aug 29 '16

Box spinoff plz. Title it "Get the fuck outta here, I'm retired."

→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (13)

136

u/kajun-ss Aug 29 '16

Freddy "I got me a unicorn" deserves an Oscar for the best line this year.

53

u/CreamyDingleberry Aug 29 '16

Kind of reminded me of his role in The Wire. Ridiculously badass, but also gay.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

453

u/lilparra77 Aug 29 '16

Totally thought that Naz was gonna go do something stupid and we'd see him back in prison, hence the "Call of the Wild". Instead he's just a free drug addict with trust issues :(

397

u/nick-halden Aug 29 '16

Yeah but that's the point. Naz will most likely be back in prison for some other crime. Even if he wasn't a criminal before hand, he for sure is now.

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (6)

952

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

I really thought Nas was going to be having flashbacks to stabbing her several times when he was sitting alone at the river.

398

u/darkknight915 Aug 29 '16 edited May 03 '26

I thought it would have been cool if they filled in the blanks in the last 8 minutes with what actually happened that night.

→ More replies (35)

90

u/EdgarCayce Aug 29 '16

No way. They made it pretty obvious it was the CPA

→ More replies (45)
→ More replies (11)

356

u/kfjsport24 Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

Nas is ruined

198

u/FedaykinII Aug 29 '16

His own mom thinks he is a murderer...

→ More replies (52)

74

u/berotec93 Aug 29 '16

I think one of the main points of the series was to show that bad side of the criminal system. Although he's not accused anymore, his life may never be the same again. Even if the person is not in jail while waiting for the trial, in many cases their life just pauses, since people don't want to be near a suspect and the media doesn't help either... Situations like that really suck

→ More replies (9)

225

u/bored007 Aug 29 '16

Yeah, but the cat is doing great. So it was a good ending lol.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)

189

u/darkknight915 Aug 29 '16

That little sad smile Andrea gave Naz in that flashback was gut wrenching.

34

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Man, poor Nas though.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

I sat in silence for about a half hour after the credits ended just thinking about that scene. Naz sees himself as an outsider no matter where he is now (home, public, etc.) so in his mind he goes back to the last person who he felt a legitimate connection to before his life turned upside down. Unfortunately, she was also the person who indirectly caused his life to be ruined and she's dead now so his life is essentially meaningless aside from his freedom. It was so heartbreaking.

Edit: clarification

→ More replies (5)

893

u/I_Enjoy_Taffy Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

Fantastic ending. Although, I gotta be honest until the very end I was waiting for the final second to make sure Naz wasn't going to die.

451

u/Bubbashanx Aug 29 '16

The entire time he was walking out of the prison I was clenching everything.

→ More replies (46)

311

u/johnnyjj14 Aug 29 '16

Isn't he dead though. The Naz that his family knew and loved is long gone. He's a shell of his former self.

→ More replies (135)

112

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

Or remembers that he stabbed her 22 times

→ More replies (21)

29

u/Vincent__Adultman Aug 29 '16

I totally thought that last shot of him was on a bridge he was about to jump off.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/BurnerForJustOnce Aug 29 '16

Ditto! I was screaming OH SHIT FREDDIE'S GONNA HAVE A TAPE OF HIM SMUGGLING DRUGS AND GET HIM IN THERE

→ More replies (22)

391

u/nlp7s Aug 29 '16

A+++. BTW only the poor father never questioned his son's innocence. He sold his licence, did the delivery guy, and eventually was the one waiting for him at the exit of the prison.

137

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

The unsung hero. He even told Naz to go out with his friends like Naz didn't just go to hell and back.

→ More replies (3)

94

u/oh_nice_marmot Aug 29 '16

They get the taxi back now right? I honestly cared more about Khan senior than Naz by the end

→ More replies (18)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

did the delivery guy

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

→ More replies (9)

497

u/Mailstoop Aug 29 '16

Gotta be honest.... They didnt think to look deeper into where exactly she was coming from before she got in the cab in the beginning of the investigation?

595

u/Ritchey92 Aug 29 '16

That was the point and that's why Box felt so guilty. He knew he rushed it and just wanted to get it over with before he retired, but them his conscious kicked in.

→ More replies (7)

189

u/niravana21 Aug 29 '16

like stone said, they were sold they got their guy when he had the murder weapon on him and he decided to run.

→ More replies (20)

46

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

That was kind of the point the defense made. They didn't investigate anything before charging Nas.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (27)

225

u/wheezymustafa Aug 29 '16

It was a great story and a great ride. Glad to be apart of it with you all. See you in r/westworld.

→ More replies (2)

209

u/Coo_coo_ca_choo Aug 29 '16

I guess the prosecution did the right thing in the end but I definitely wanted to punch her in the face for still going through with it when she was presented with clear evidence of the actual killer. Box came through like we knew he would. Great series.

Nas is screwed though. His life is forever changed.

216

u/Mutch Aug 29 '16

You could definitely see her pull back and actually stop completely during her closing arguments. I think Box's evidence slowly ate away at her belief Naz was guilty .

→ More replies (29)

52

u/lilith480 Aug 29 '16

Yeah, also I believe that would be a Brady violation because it's potentially exculpatory evidence that she didn't then disclose to the defense.

→ More replies (14)

24

u/Solid_Waste Aug 29 '16

Looking at that knife like "where's the rest of the blood after 22 stabs?"

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (25)

669

u/VRomero32 Aug 29 '16

Can't we just clear all the red tape and just hand John Tuturro his emmy... also the cat

436

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Seriously. The closing speech was awesome.

→ More replies (18)

62

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

Damn cat already got an Emmy in my heart.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (42)

176

u/johnnyjj14 Aug 29 '16

Great series. I can't help but be fascinated by the character that is Sgt. Box. I would have loved to see him more incorporated in the development of the post-crime storyline and the trial. His old-school and hard-ass approach was phenomenal.

Love the storytelling; from beginning to end.

141

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

HBO excecs, if you are reading this, stop scratching your damn heads and develop True Detective 3 around Box. You've got everything you need.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (8)

221

u/peoplebotherme Aug 29 '16

BUT THE DEER HEAD! Was waiting for it to play a crucial role because of the blood/cut on the eye or something

385

u/mik14b Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

I think when Box said in the casino "he forgot his hat" it was a sly reference to the deer head having contradicting shots with and without a hat on its head in earlier episodes, implying someone else was in the house at some point and forgot the hat.

That line all but cemented Ray is the real killer imo

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (5)

53

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Loved when John dropped "The night of" in his closing statement.

11

u/Chutzvah Sep 01 '16

Always think of family guy when they say the title

→ More replies (1)

377

u/29a Aug 29 '16

I couldn't me more satisfied with that finale. The eczema and kiss storylines came full circle, we see a side of the criminal justice system that's not often portrayed in media (a deadlock and the prosecution saying they won't proceed), we have a new suspect, we see some of the impact the trial had on Naz's and his family's life when he got out. Box was vindicated, there was no dumb twist. It was great. The no music over credits was perfect too.

48

u/HairlessSnatch Aug 29 '16

Okay I'm sorry this might sound stupid, but I was a little confused about the eczema thing in this episode? How did it come full circle?

→ More replies (64)
→ More replies (17)

202

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

In case people didn't notice this camera image that shows the CPA throwing away the murder weapon

http://imgur.com/je7zLIJ

67

u/meepsicle A Subtle Beast Aug 29 '16

OH awkward I thought it was just clips of him walking

→ More replies (2)

20

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

It's a garbage bag... we don't know what is inside.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

111

u/jbob2011 Aug 29 '16

The ending leaves you feeling pretty hollow. Spot on ending to this kind of story which happens way too often (although usually with a guilty verdict)

→ More replies (1)

108

u/catapultation Aug 29 '16

I honestly don't understand how the lack of blood wasn't mentioned. Based on the crime scene, it'd really answer the question definitively - if he's covered in blood, he did it, if he isn't, he didn't. The only reason they didn't mention it is because it would essentially ruin the story.

18

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

The writer read this subreddit and decided to take out all mentions of the lack of blood and the deer head out of spite.

9

u/Mor315 Aug 29 '16

True. He would have been covered in it. Also Nas is left handed, and the cut from when the "knife slipped" is on his right hand. Surprised they didn't address that

→ More replies (34)

36

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

As Nas was slowly walking out of jail, i thought someone was going to slit his throat.

→ More replies (4)

35

u/leirbag23 Aug 29 '16

Absolutely fantastic ending. Loved the whole show, and I felt like the ending was extremely satisfying. I'm kind of sad to see that so many people would rather have closure on the whodunnit aspect of it, than on what concerns the characters and their developments over the series.

I mean, yeah, Chandra went off the rails, but I didn't feel at all like that ruined anything for me, like it seemingly did for some people. She is young, vulnerable after a presumably bad breakup, she developed a very ill-advised sentimental attachment to her client, got overconfident and made a very stupid mistake, one that cost her her career. I'm not saying that it's nitpicking to have one's suspension of disbelief ruined by that, or by the apparently shoddy handling of the courtroom scenes. In fact, it's a legit reason, if that's what you're most interested in.

But, like Naz, she simply made stupid decisions. Like him, she acted on a reckless impulse and, while her life was not completely ruined like Naz's, she's going to, at the very least, have a hard time picking up the pieces. Mistakes were made, because people make mistakes. And so what ruined the show for some people, actually made it all the more remarkable to me.

That is why I don't really care that we didn't get a 100% reliable answer as to who is the killer. To me, that's not what the show is about. I can watch a hundred murder mysteries if that's what I'm looking for, and 99 times out of 100, I'll have closure for that.

This time, I prefer to have closure about the characters. Naz is a mess. Chandra is a mess. Naz's family is forever changed. Stone learned something about himself, and perhaps his future will be different, maybe he'll end up seeing himself as less of a leper. Box got some closure by seeing his efforts bring some semblant of justice to Naz. Weiss is also changed, as we can see by her quitting smoking. Freddy met his unicorn. And, most importantly, the cat survived.

To me, this show was a heartbreaking story of lives being chewed up and spat out by an unfeeling, faceless system, one that, understandably, would always rather choose the least contrived path, the one that leads to a conviction and "closure" after a crime. It's a story about how people are always doing a balancing act, trying not to screw up and, when they do, it's a long way to the bottom.

→ More replies (3)

65

u/thatweirdmusicguy Aug 29 '16

But in the end, did Naz really win? Also need an explanation on why Freddy sent the tape to Stone

174

u/Coo_coo_ca_choo Aug 29 '16

Freddy knew he was an innocent unicorn and did what he could to try to help Nas.

→ More replies (7)

73

u/nick-halden Aug 29 '16

He sent the tape to help Naz. It seems in the end Freddy was always looking out for Naz. Even though in the end he's upset when Naz leaves him.

→ More replies (7)

30

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

I think Freddy was just trying to help Naz just like he did with the jump suit and the shirt and tie. He knew that tape could help Naz win a mistrial, even though it didn't happen.

17

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Freddy was his true blue friend... you kind of assumed he was a shithead who had some sort of ulterior motive the whole time, giving him the right jump suit, the right dress clothes... What to make of that... why would he want to see him aquitted?

Freddy, and his father, were the only 2 people that really believed he was innocent from start to finish.

→ More replies (3)

79

u/anilehcim Aug 29 '16

To throw the case. Freddy was critical of Chandra. If you remember, in a previous episode Freddy told Nas that Chandra seemed inexperienced and made it sound like he didn't trust her with the case. It looks like they're implying that the kiss was a calculated move and that Nas (and Freddy) manipulated Chandra purposely in an effort to throw the case. They also got her to smuggle drugs for them.

→ More replies (16)

9

u/solobolotrolo Aug 29 '16

I think he sent the tape to Stone because he believed, as did Stone, that it would be grounds for a mistrial.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

32

u/TheSubtleSaiyan Aug 30 '16 edited Aug 30 '16

Riz Ahmed's eyes deserve an Emmy.

He had a silent and subtle screen presence that spoke volumes. When appropriate his eyes could exude a naive innocence, a sudden resounding fury, earnest gratitude, or a truly broken spirit. Riz consistently gave breathtakingly emotive performance every episode and did it all without delivering an impassioned monologue, often without saying a word, or even making an obvious facial expression.

→ More replies (2)

87

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Thought for sure Naz was a goner leaving Rikers. What an ending though. Wow.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/ivaguelyremember Aug 29 '16 edited Sep 03 '16

Out of the entire season, the shot that went right through the heart for me was when Naz saw his dad and hugged him/Dad covers him with jacket. I cried like a bitch.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Hennashan Aug 29 '16

So there's no explanation on that really weird ending of episode five I believe when Dwayne Reed was being chased ?

13

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

I think that last shot of Stone (when he turned around) was when he kind of snapped out of it I guess, and he realized he was taking this lead way too far, putting himself in way too much danger, and just went home to his UV lights (the flashing blue light at the end). I don't know, really.

If not that, maybe Stone found something big on Dwayne, and called the police (that could've been the flashing blue lights), and Stone was the reason he got put back in jail... which helped his defense of Nas.

At any rate, I wish we had a real explanation for that episode's ending so I didn't have to wildly speculate like this!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

27

u/Drumitar Aug 29 '16

Anyone else feel bad for Freddy losing out on nas as friend ?

14

u/CountPanda Aug 29 '16

My optimist theory is that eventually Naz gets the metaphor/message Freddy was saying by giving him the book The Call of the Wild and Naz gets over his grief for Andrea (which I thought was nice that the showed) and over his H addiction and eventually starts writing Freddy letters which means a lot to Freddy.

It'll be Freddy's reward for not using and throwing away Naz, and it will be a way for Naz to get back to normalcy.

→ More replies (4)

91

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Stone's closing argument couldn't have been better.

10

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

Tears and everything. I thought his face would look worse but the director was kind enough

→ More replies (2)

43

u/MikeKrombopulos Aug 29 '16

Great show but man was that depressing.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/shutyourgob Aug 29 '16

Out of everyone in the entire series, the blonde lawyer who quit on Naz was the most unlikable. I really fucking hated her.

10

u/autenboot Aug 29 '16

Hey man. Clean out your fucking desk.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/JohnBagley33 Aug 29 '16

I was really happy that there was nothing more sinister to Freddie's interest in Naz (other than using him as a drug mule, getting him hooked on crack and having serve as an accessory to murder, of course.) In his way, Freddie was actually just trying to look out for him, and Naz likely would have ended up far worse without him.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/ea212 Aug 29 '16

I rewatched the first episode last night and realized ray was the guy with the beanie on next to the witness when the cops were in front of andreas house. This combined with all of the evidence that came out this episode def shows ray is the murderer

→ More replies (6)

13

u/BenjenGrimes Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

That scene of Nas going to the "Beach" by the Bridge is fantastic. It was the first time he truly got to be alone, as a free man since the incident. And it was also the first time he truly got to grieve for Andrea. He really did like her, and I think she really liked him to. The music, flashbacks of her smiling on the rock at him and seeing him doing drugs as he thinks back really got to me. A beautiful yet very crushing moment and I think it was done incredibly.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/rodsarethrown Aug 29 '16

the cctv footage of the cpa watching andrea walk away, then deciding to follow her, was fucking chilling

→ More replies (6)

64

u/jwrightzz1234 Aug 29 '16

If you want Jew time do a Jew crime.

17

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Does the stabbing of Andrea count as a Jew crime if the CPA did it?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Doctor_Crunchwrap Aug 29 '16

Johns ex wife and kid just inconsequentially dissapeared from the entire show

→ More replies (12)

12

u/DirtyDizzil Aug 30 '16

I shit you not..... I fist pumped so many times when the cat appeared at the end.

→ More replies (1)

76

u/velmaish Aug 29 '16

Did they really ask us to believe she smuggled drugs in for him in her vagina? So ridiculous.

25

u/FundleBundle Aug 29 '16

It left a wet spot on the bench after she set it down lol.

19

u/j_accuse Aug 29 '16

Along with Bodie's courtroom outbursts, this was unbelievably stupid. And the way she pulled out the drugs was not correct positionally--unless she tied a balloon string to it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

23

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

The eczema was brilliant. it showed us exactly how Nasir will be looked at for the rest of his life, like he has a skin ailment that is destroying his body. Eczema is genetics, it isnt because of diet or whatever. And Nasir isn't being looked at anything he did but yet he will always have the remnants of the case and rikers following him around

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Foppful Aug 29 '16

I loved Freddy's monologue about Naz smelling of innocence. Apparently, half the jury felt the same way.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought Nas was gonna die leaving prison. The whole finale just became really unrealistic for me. The drug smuggling from his lawyer?

Also, I just feel sad for Nas. He came out of there basically a drug addict and feeling out of place. It was a good progression for the story but other than that, I just feel underwhelmed with the finale.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/notroy Aug 29 '16

One of the most high profile murder cases in one of the world's largest cities and nobody is checking the victim's cell records until after the jury is already deliberating?

→ More replies (1)

69

u/RecursiveSubroutine Aug 29 '16

It's just too hard for me to suspend disbelief that a lawyer will smuggle drugs into prison for their client.

All the stories you hear about law school. The first day, they tell you to look left and look right, only one of you will graduate.

So you have the degree and a good, secure job at what seems to be a prosperous firm.

You risk all that to commit how many crimes?

→ More replies (24)

25

u/jim732 Aug 29 '16

So all through a four month investigation and trial, nobody from either side had the idea to track Andrea via cameras until the very end? Come on son.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Andrea looked at him and her eyes told the whole story: she knew that by meeting him that night, she ruined his life forever. Heartbreaking.

30

u/BeastHastings Aug 29 '16

I don't think it lived up to what I thought it was going to be after the 1st episode, but it was still really good. Better than 95% of what's on TV these days, if not more. Just my opinion though.

→ More replies (8)

30

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Why is there so much uncertainty among viewers regarding Ray's (the CPA's) guilt?

Ray and Andrea get in an argument and break up that night, which is on camera. He called her multiple times in a row afterwards and she didn't answer. This is why he went to her house. Box made a comment to Ray about how he knows Ray didn't go home immediately afterwards because his cell phone pinged. Read between the lines: Ray went to Andrea's that night. Then Box says "...and I'll find the knife." aka "I know you did it, motherfucker."

→ More replies (15)

173

u/Gyshall669 Aug 29 '16

Why are people acting like we don't know who did it? The CPA. They made that very clear.

63

u/KP3889 Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

I want to see him punished for his crime. Denzel Washington style.

They soothed my anger by giving the cat a catmeo at the end there though. Love it.

→ More replies (5)

58

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

We all know he did it.

I personally wanted to see what the fuck happened though, and basically see what was inside of that large black box.

I wanted to see what Nas couldn't remember.

→ More replies (16)

36

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

The ending was actually less ambiguous than I thought it would be. I was kind of expecting them to convict the financial advisor and then the step dad makes a comment like "I got away with it..." law and order theme plays

→ More replies (1)

196

u/junkit33 Aug 29 '16

Did people learn nothing from this show?

We have zero proof that the CPA did it. We just spent 8 episodes watching what happens when you infer too much.

Maybe he did it and maybe he didn't. It's intentionally ambiguous.

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (45)

8

u/maverickps Aug 29 '16

Anyone else notice the dogs barking in the background as he walked out the door? Call of the wild?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Poppinlikeballoons Aug 30 '16

All of naz's flashbacks/memories of Andrea paint her in a positive light. if he had really murdered her out of rage or even bad trip, i wouldn't think his memories of her would be so innocent.

14

u/ivaguelyremember Aug 29 '16

Really loved the parallel of the orange cat walking across in final moments of the first episode and Andrea's cat walking across in the very last. Oddly satisfying. Anyone else?

7

u/Dlinc23 Aug 29 '16

Listen all I'm saying is we just watched an entire series where the whole point was to show that jumping to conclusions and making up your mind based on circumstantial evidence can fuck a lot of people over and people are gunna take their word for it that the financial planner did it based off of a quick convo in a casino and a tollbooth picture. That's it, that's all I have to say. I'm out

9

u/mikeyrocks202 Aug 29 '16

The difference is motive. The police and prosecution were trying Naz based on circumstantial evidence but they could not come up with a believable motive which is what ate at them through the entire ordeal. With the financial planner not only do they have circumstantial evidence around which to build a case but also a clear motive.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

So, tonight we saw--when dealing with the financial adviser in the casino--a decidedly different version of Box than what we saw 'the night of' in the precinct.

He was aggressive, handsy, and not worried about staying within the law.

So does this mean Box actually was being kind to Nas, the shell-shocked kid, even though he fingered him for the crime? Or is it just confirmation that Box is a subtle beast, and he knows just how to play suspects? Nice buddy Box for those like Naz, and tough guy when dealing with more volatile situations?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/myth1n Aug 29 '16

I dont know why it took me until tonight to realize the judge is errol, the main baddy from the first season of true detective, once he started talking some he was easily recognizable.

7

u/_CharlesInCharge_ Aug 29 '16

After last week's episode, I felt compelled to check out Call of the Wild from the library since its a quick read and I saw it was the finale's episode title. The parallels between Buck and Naz are strong, but it hit me hard when Naz returned to the beach and thought of Andrea the same way Buck returns to the place where his master (John Thornton) died. It just made that scene even more heartbreaking.

7

u/kriggles Aug 29 '16

I felt like he was reflecting on how different they were back then, how she was unlike his friends with conservative upbringings. He lived with his parents back then, "a good Muslim boy". But he doesn't trust his mother now, and he needs the drug, he's not just trying it. He's not just sitting with his memories of Andrea, he belongs with her now. Andrea is gone, and so is the boy she knew

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '16

John's Turturro's closing speech almost brought me to tears. Such a great scene.

72

u/PinkHK5213 Aug 29 '16

I'm so torn. Some the scenes and storylines in this series was so compelling. But I did not care at ALL for the way the courtroom scenes were written. Super corny and not realistic. And Chandra's storyline just went off the rails to Unbelievable Land towards the end. I'm not usually one to complain about ending of shows, but I felt that was pretty weak af. Just my opinion. 😏 I'm leaving kinda disappointed.

→ More replies (31)

13

u/Methodoman Aug 29 '16

When Naz sees the "friend" that told the court he sold him Adderall in that restaraunt, i could've bet money that he was gonna get up the beat the holy living hell out of him...

→ More replies (3)

83

u/ninjapoop7 Aug 29 '16

I'm reading all this praise about the ending, and I'm sitting here thinking that was the most anticlimactic ending I've seen. Maybe it was purposeful but that ending was so blah to me. Am I the only one?

Edit: also, I feel like Chandra's decisions with the kiss and the smuggling of drugs was so out of character?

AND HOW DID THE DEFENSE NEVER BRING UP THAT THERE WASNT A SPOT OF BLOOD ON HIM

→ More replies (29)

26

u/caseythelegend Aug 29 '16

Should have re-played the murder.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/jewishbrick Aug 29 '16

I loved the show, but the writing for Chandra really bothered me sometimes. Her cross examination was pretty awful at times and the fact she would kiss Naz or smuggle him drugs and have him on the stand just baffled me. I loved the show for its realistic take on the justice system but I feel like they totally broke her character in those moments and it took me out of the show's world.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Scranton_Strangler5 Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 30 '16

Beautiful finale. The more I think it over the more I love it. Something really poetic about the fact that Nas was "found" neither guilty or innocent.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/boilernos Aug 29 '16

Decent show. Court room scenes were so unrealistic. No cross examinations and bodie dropping f bombs. Also, the state not retrying with all the evidence. Definitely not a show for anyone that knows anything about litigation. Wanted to love it but it is so far outside the realm of possibility. In the end, forgettable.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Rastagaryenxx Aug 29 '16

10/10 because of the cat.

When that mofucka' scurried across the room, I fist bumped so hard.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Overall, pretty solid ending. The story is told more through the characters than through what actually happened, and I feel like I don't really need the closure so many are asking for. We got to see the true underlying intentions and standpoints each character has underneath:

Freddy genuinely caring about his unicorn, despite all the suspicion. He cared so much, he may as well have snuffed out the 'scent of innocence' with his own embrace. He must know he also changed Naz's life--for better or worse.

Box being notably disturbed by the idea of the 'cop who doesn't give a shit' show, and that being something people can enjoy...it awakens something in him. He can't NOT see this through the way his reputation precedes him to.

Stone (serious applause for Torturro) realizing he won't get by on the eczema with BS medications this guy or that guy says, but that when he has a friend around, like the cat, or when he genuinely believes in himself, the stress goes down enough that the eczema eases down.

Hell, even Weis is noticeably undone by her own judgment on the case mid closing argument. You can sense disbelief in her voice, her body language, even her face.

Chandra fucking sucks and that's about all I have to say about her. She got what she deserved, and she would've worsened Naz's situation way more had Freddy decided it to be so (he definitely had the tape footage). You have to ask yourself where the writers drew the line between her being a character vs. her being an arrogant, dumbfuck plot device that serves only to get Stone that beautiful speech at the end. Dumb.

The last scenes were fantastic, especially the eye to eye between Naz and Andrea in the past. Really worked in more ways than one, felt like a painting if anything. There's a lot of substance there--good show, probably a 6-7/10 in my book

→ More replies (1)

6

u/razzlefrazzled Aug 29 '16

I'm glad Naz is free or whatever, but good christ am I relieved the cat is ok. I swear to god I was invested in that cat too much, I thought it had some kind of bigger connection.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

I keep thinking how incredible Box was in that last episode. Both the casino scene and in the courtroom when he walked out was beautiful.

6

u/jpmama77 Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

The DA's decision not to retry the case wasn't about altruism, it was that she realized she had a 0% chance of ever convicting him. He would have much better attorneys next time, who will not allow Naz to testify. If your defendant answers the question "Did you kill her" with "I don't know" and you can't get a conviction, you're never getting one.

OTOH, I felt like Stone could have spun Naz saying "I don't know." The DA was saying to him that not calling 911 could have been the reason she died. So in that respect, Naz in a way killed her by not helping her. So not knowing if she was alive or dead when he left, he didn't know if he killed her in some way.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ivaguelyremember Aug 29 '16

Bam Bam the Cat finally gets credit.

http://imgur.com/ISc5jrC

6

u/rollypt Aug 31 '16

What a great fucking show. Oh indeed.

10

u/oh_nice_marmot Aug 29 '16

I'm glad they took a quick minute to remind us how big of a bitch that blonde lawyer is.

9

u/youngmermaid Aug 29 '16

She's definitely a total bitch, but what Chandra did was unprofessional, unethical, and could've ruined the whole case. She deserved to be fired

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Tragically beautiful.

5

u/The_La_Jollan Doesn't Matter, Had Sex Aug 29 '16

As far as the Chandra drug smuggling goes, I think Freddy had Naz set her up to get him a mistrial while helping his business out a little. It was stupid on her part, but Freddy is a great manipulator, and Naz wouldn't have gone to Chandra on his own to get the drugs.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/desperado3005 Aug 29 '16

Can't wait for season 2: NYU COPS

5

u/drbhrb Aug 29 '16

Anyone else feel the cat metaphor was waaaay to overt the entire season?

5

u/Y0y0y000 Aug 29 '16

Aha the financial advisor guy went full psycho Dennis Reynolds in the casino

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Gilb3rt23 Aug 29 '16

I'm still very rattled that nobody points out that Naz has no blood splatter on his clothes while the room looked like it just hosted The Red Wedding.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/TheRoyalMarlboro Aug 29 '16

No one forces a mistrial in Remus's court.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/badwolf1202 Aug 29 '16

I sobbed during Stone's closing arguments. Perfectly done.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '16

Box saved Nas when he walked out of the courtroom.

5

u/Swimfan10 Aug 30 '16

The scene at the casino bar was one of my favorites in the finale. Box is exceptional in his abilities as a detective and seems so satisfied after he tells Ray to get the fuck out of there. It's the only time we see him satisfied since his retirement. So glad to see his character finally get to the bottom of the case, he knew all along something was not right and finally made it as right as right can be.

55

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

To be honest I thought the first episode was amazing and everything since then has been kinda meh.

14

u/Hennashan Aug 29 '16

Second and third episodes were pretty strong. But the season deff stagnated. What the fuck was the ending of episode five about ? Strangest ending /cliffhanger I have ever witnessed.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

The first episode was one of the most gripping hours of television I've ever watched. The rest was just waiting for the end.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/johnnyjj14 Aug 29 '16

John Turturro's closing arguments gave me chills...

Stands as one of the greatest I've ever seen.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

DA stepping out her kicks. She was so over that shit.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/EdgarCayce Aug 29 '16

Can't believe the ending wasn't devastating. Props to Box for hanging in there, the DA for doing the right thing, and the Reddit sleuths that fingered the CPA.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/tpk-aok but who killed the deer? Aug 29 '16

We still don't know who killed the deer.

I really wanted closure and justice for the deer head.

4

u/dodadoof Aug 29 '16

People obsessed with the cat annoy me but this is reddit.

Also the DA's voice annoys me.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/vitorizzo Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

As he was leaving the prison I thought they were going to flashback to him actually killing the girl then he does the look back and smile like when he was in the elevator as he was leaving with his dad and it ends like that.

4

u/I-touched-the-butt Aug 29 '16

You're my unicorn. Freddy was such an amazing character. Him boxing as Naz is getting out was such an emotional moment.

4

u/FenwayK Ray's Cat Aug 29 '16

When I saw Freddy get the compact disc from the other guard, I thought he was going to make some weird prison shank out of it and stab Naz...

My paranoia level was all time high the whole episode.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/miserablemisanthrope Aug 30 '16 edited Aug 30 '16

When Freddy sends the video tape of Naz kissing Chandra to Stone, was it for Naz's benefit? Freddy had called Naz his unicorn, so there were several motives for wanting him to stay with him in prison. If there would have been a mistrial, which Freddy, I think, was hoping for, wouldn't that mean that there could be another trial, and Naz would have to stay in prison and wait AGAIN until the new trial starts?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/MG87 Nov 09 '16

Everyone's got a cross to bear, Naz, pardon the expression. Fuck 'em all. Live your life.

Thats a fantastic line.

13

u/BurnerForJustOnce Aug 29 '16

What pisses me off the most is that the DA decided to do the right thing ONLY after the jury was deadlocked.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

She was handed the opportunity to do the right thing without accountability. Typical and realistic

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

Nice chatting with all of you during this series!!! Thanks for clearing things up all the time, and being really friendly in general! See ya next time!!!!

7

u/he_saved_the_cat Aug 29 '16

The most unrealistic thing about the ending was the presumption that there exists the kind of monster who would take the Midtown tunnel at 2AM coming from the Upper West Side instead of the 59th st bridge (which of course has no toll), especially when trying to avoid detection. I MEAN C'MON GET REAL

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Fafman Aug 29 '16

They made an innocent guy a comvict

→ More replies (2)

55

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16 edited Aug 29 '16

I have to say this is easily the best series I have ever watched. Thanks for everything HBO and this sub. It was a great ride.

Edit: one of the best series

81

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16

You should watch the sopranos and the wire then

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (23)