r/arrow • Felicity Queen • Oct 13 '16

Discussion [S5E02] "The Recruits" Post-Episode Discussion

243 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

453

u/Gbrisc Oct 13 '16

love the fact that oliver's first strategy to build teamwork is to use the same drill that gets everyone around him killed immediately the first time he does it

280

u/obsidianraindrop Oct 13 '16

well it was either that or strand them on an island for 5 years.

210

u/alisonstone Oct 13 '16

Should just make them slap water.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

73

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Eh, I think the point of the exercise still stands. It's just that the characters were written to be too dumb to realise what Oliver was trying to do.

I mean, if you're training to become part of a team, even someone with a tiny amount of intelligence could figure out that teamwork would be one of the early lessons.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/1C3M4Nz Oct 13 '16

It's kind of the same as Naruto to be honest. Naruto had the steal the bells and the more complex theme of causing distrust by saying only 2 folks who get the 2 bells move on and stuff. Ringing the bell using teamwork, I guessed it within a minute. They are not fit to be vigilantes if they can't figure it out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

428

u/Feeenay Oct 13 '16

Ok. Everyone let's make this clear. Ragman is not Prometheus. They have similar suits but they are two separate people

160

u/yamitcg Oct 13 '16

Prometheus had to be someone who was carefully watching or was directlyinvolved in the Arrow-Church fight since he knew Church was about to kill him. Since RagMan saved Arrow from Church as was there, he could be Prometheus and be trying to gain Arrow's trust as Rag Man

364

u/cmath89 Earth-X Arrow Oct 13 '16

So Prometheus is Jay Garrick? fuck

→ More replies (14)

77

u/RoseBladePhantom Oct 13 '16

Tommy's the only one that makes sense to me. Would've been awesome with the right set up, but oh well.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (15)

22

u/JayCaesar12 Hole-in-the-Wall Lawman Oct 13 '16

That is my biggest criticism so far of the show, its really hard to tell the difference between the two.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

343

u/amJLINN Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

The beginning of Digs storyline was so random, two of the soldiers just stood in front of the door in the middle of fire

116

u/GreenArrowCuz Earth-X Arrow Oct 13 '16

Also the end of it, dude is married to the head of argus, you think framing him is a good idea? Fuckin idiots

65

u/Titan897 Oct 14 '16

I didn't get this either.

How it should have went:

"You might not want to frame me"

"Why not?"

"Because my wife is the director of the largest intelligence agency on the planet"

"Oh shit he's right"

→ More replies (10)

180

u/Thatguy181991 Oct 13 '16

Ugh it's painful to watch people get "soldiering" right even in high budget things. Arrow has no chance haha

→ More replies (9)

41

u/whiskeybill Oct 13 '16

Right? And why on earth did the corrupt army commander keep diggle alive? He is literally the only loose end left from your attempt to steal the nuke.

→ More replies (10)

21

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Digs story line is a flash back? I thought that was happening in real time?

99

u/yamitcg Oct 13 '16

It's not a flash back. Dig left the team to join the military and this is real time. It will connect to the main plot eventually

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

282

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Baby Sara is obviously Prometheus

224

u/Drunk_Omar I'm The Justice You Can't Run From Oct 13 '16

Who?

248

u/Patrick_k32 Home grown organic bullshit Oct 13 '16

I think he meant john jr

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

457

u/ajdragoon Oct 13 '16

So...Raggedy Andy's gonna be pissed when he finds out that Felicity nuked his hometown.

391

u/RahvinDragand Oct 13 '16

Just look at all the easily avoidable drama they're setting up right before our very eyes. Felicity is hiding her boyfriend, and hiding her vigilante activities from her boyfriend. Rag Man will eventually find out Felicity nuked his town, which will inevitably jeopardize a mission. Thea just hired a drunk to be deputy mayor, which will definitely become a point of contention.

168

u/Theo67 Oct 13 '16

I wonder if the boyfriend will walk out her like she walked out on Oliver for hiding [to protect] his son.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (61)
→ More replies (13)

600

u/ezreads Oct 13 '16

"they're too green"

"some can say the same about you...I've been waiting 5 years to make that joke"

Oliver: ON THE LINE!

307

u/ItMayBeWrong Oct 13 '16

Can we just have this Felicity for the rest of the show? PLEASE??

293

u/ajdragoon Oct 13 '16

You mean, minus the relationship issues and unnecessary drama? I would like that too; it would be like old times again.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (11)

123

u/ThePerminator Wait is Arrow good again Oct 13 '16

Literally no one has ever accused him of being too green

→ More replies (6)

50

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

I legit thought that line was hilarious. Felicity works really well when she's written correctly.

→ More replies (6)

180

u/nwt123 HAIL VICTORY! Oct 13 '16

All I have to say about the "Ring the bell" flashbacks is:

RASH B NO STOP

7

u/ThornBird_116 Oct 13 '16

"ON THE LINE!"

"psst guys, I know how do dis. Is ancient russian tactic. Gimme AVP, then rash B no stop."

6

u/soeri27 Oct 16 '16

"We have to work together as a team!"

"shatap noob, faking americanski idi nahui" continues to play sandstorm in the background

→ More replies (2)

365

u/Napalmeon Oct 13 '16

I don't know dick about Ragman, but he's already way more useful than the recruits.

241

u/DRoyLinker Oct 13 '16

yeah what the fuck.
He's literally nuke/bullet proof and can move around using the rags.
that's op as fuck

→ More replies (4)

13

u/android151 Oct 14 '16

He's kind of like the Punisher or Ghost Rider in some senses, except he's a jew with magic clothes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

169

u/whiskeybill Oct 13 '16

Am I crazy or was Church trying to buy $100 Million dollars worth of guns? You can buy like 5 F-16s with $100 Million dollars, they couldn't have said something a little more realistic? And furthermore, if he has $100 Million why on earth is he still a criminal and not sitting on a beach somewhere?

129

u/ssdude101 Oct 13 '16

That's only plot money. You can't buy anything with it unless it's illegal.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/xipheon Oct 13 '16

He has goals besides having a boring life on a beach.

And this is the flarrowverse we're talking about. Many of those guns are probably high tech prototypes or even specially designed for taking out metas (when team Flash shows up, surely they want to prepare for that as well)

→ More replies (15)

372

u/Amyga17 Oct 13 '16

Continuing to love the Bratva flashbacks. I'm also looking forward to seeing Quentin and Thea's friendship develop. She seems to be taking on the role of 3rd Lance daughter so let's hope she makes it through the season...

120

u/NaijaBird Oct 13 '16

She's already died once (so as Sara), she'll will make it through

→ More replies (3)

84

u/DiceFestGames Oct 13 '16

She may yet be the third bearer of the title 'my baby girl'

→ More replies (1)

28

u/ItMayBeWrong Oct 13 '16

let's hope she makes it through the season...

As long as she doesn't die...again...

26

u/DarkKingx Earth-X Reverse Flash Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

Did you forget her father was Ra's Al Ghul?

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Rek07 Oct 13 '16

His 3rd daughter.
Her 3rd father.
Half-Life 3 confirmed?

7

u/TheFabledFamilyGuy Oct 13 '16

I too enjoy the dynamic between them.

→ More replies (2)

117

u/MeatTornado25 Bow Oct 13 '16

I love when they actually talk about the past. I thought Felicity actually had a really good scene when she talked about how much she respected Oliver for his dedication when they met. Oliver actually bringing up the Bratva and implying why he was so walled off in S1 and never wanted a team for self-preservation.

The icing on the cake however, was him pretty much admitting that he's better at being a vigilante than anyone else, because of his path to get there. I loved his comment about how his 5 years prepared him, which was a luxury that Laurel didn't have, and may be why she's dead.

→ More replies (6)

771

u/RahvinDragand Oct 13 '16

Felicity: "Hey new boyfriend, I'm going to repeatedly lie directly to your face while hiding a huge part of my life from you despite having just dumped my fiance for hiding something from me. Speaking of my ex-fiance, I do hang around with him all day and call him hot when he works out. Is that alright? Great."

136

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

i feel like i missed something with that scene, why did she need forensic run on ragdy man's cloth when he has superlab3000 where theyve definitely done analysis before

84

u/EvilAndPuissant Oct 13 '16

I think you did, she said something about her mass spectrometer being destroyed last season.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (4)

94

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

In all fairness, though, I was getting some pleasant vibes from way back in season 1 where it was a running joke to have Oliver tell Felicity ridiculous lies to get forensic work done. :)

→ More replies (2)

150

u/Napalmeon Oct 13 '16

Never change, Felicity.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

I got the vibe it's supposed to remind us (like a couple of things this season) of Arrow season 1, with Ollie's godawful lies to Felicity.

38

u/Theo67 Oct 13 '16

This is how we know this new relationship won't last. Makes me nervous that it's only a matter of time before dysfunctional Olicity is back in play. She's already undermining Oliver.

→ More replies (16)

347

u/MisterrAlex Green Arrow Oct 13 '16

Can we just consider Season 4 the gas leak year now?

95

u/ArachnoLad Oct 13 '16

It took Oliver a year and a half to recover from falling off a cliff. Now he's back. That other stuff was just him writing on his spare time or something.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Darhkest timeline confirmed

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

62

u/Ignis311 Oct 13 '16

Can we also give a shoutout to the return of not only the Salmon Ladder, but to Speed Weed!!

→ More replies (4)

249

u/Riggins_33 Oct 13 '16

Oh my god the fucking hypocrisy of Felicity calling Oliver emotionally abusive after how emotionally abusive she was to him last season.

Also, are they just...retconning everything about classic Team Arrow? Oliver didn't push people away...they left for their own reasons.

  • Sara left to deal with her bloodlust
  • Roy sacrificed his identity to protect Ollie's secret
  • Laurel...died.
  • Diggle left because of all the shit he was dealing with after killing Andy
  • Thea left because she didn't like who she was becoming as a person after the bloodlust and influence of Malcolm

NONE of this had to do with Oliver being abusive towards them. They all loved/love Ollie; that whole scene was absurd.

111

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Laurel...died

Some people will do anything to get out of a little work.

45

u/Kerrtheblurr Oct 13 '16

Ikr, for once I want Oliver to stand up for himself and be like "Hey wait a minute that's not true..." cause I agree with Oliver, and the lesson he was trying to teach was fairly obvious. They're talking about how Oliver doesn't trust them but I wouldn't trust anyone that doesn't know how and when to work as a team. I trust Ragman more than a guy who tripped off a buidling.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Theo67 Oct 13 '16

Makes me angry just reading about it.

→ More replies (8)

105

u/Trust_Me_Im_Right Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

I thought flash was Tuesday's? I've never been so disappointed in my life

Edit: apparently today is Wednesday. I've never been so happy in my life

75

u/Iamvihm Oct 13 '16

What a roller coaster.

→ More replies (2)

561

u/the_456_Ambassador Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

For fuck's sake, I'm tired of every episode being 'Oliver's in the wrong, it's time for Felicity to nag and insult him as much as possible!'

Also I fail to see how the way he's treating the recruits to be inappropriate.

It's unfair for everyone to be like 'Green Asshole, your friends left you, so you SUCK!'. Speedy left because of her own inner problems with the vigilante life. Spartan left because he killed his brother. They didn't leave because he bullied them and they couldn't take it. If anything, Felicity did that to Oliver!

Oliver's training makes sense! The Canary and Black Canary got murdered despite having training from the League of Assassins.

The life they live is not about being trusting, respectful to one another, and supportive, it's about becoming something that can survive the streets. In order to be a vigilante, you have to have to be trained in every form of combat imaginable, reflexes, intuition, and physical, emotional, and mental endurance.

Felicity and the recruits seem to be under the impression that this is team-building at the office, when they are supposed to be conditioning themselves to be physically capable of handling the enormous duty they have to take on.

How the fuck is trusting each other gonna improve Wild Dog's coordination so he doesn't trip off a building and kill himself?

208

u/Napalmeon Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

Glad somebody else said it. It's nice that they have been inspired by his prior acts and want to do something to help their city. But the simple fact of the matter is, they don't have the skill or the discipline so far.

At least Roy was willing to do what he was told and that's why he ended up being so valuable.

I dunno why the recruits thought he was going to be soft with him. Harsh training tends to produce the best results for those who can endure and stick it out. Just some guys off the street isn't good enough. Oliver can't hand them every answer, because at times maybe they'll need to know something on their own while he isn't there. This isn't a game out there.

63

u/hookahshikari Oct 13 '16

Well, to be fair, Roy got mad about slapping the bowl of water over and over with no explanation.

However, I will concede that Oliver didn't kick his teeth in every time he slapped it

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Agreed and the moral of the test was to teach them teamwork. Makes sense to me

24

u/the_cunt_muncher Oct 13 '16

Also I fail to see how the way he's treating the recruits to be inappropriate.

It's unfair for everyone to be like 'Green Asshole, your friends left you, so you SUCK!'. Speedy left because of her own inner problems with the vigilante life. Spartan left because he killed his brother. They didn't leave because he bullied them and they couldn't take it. If anything, Felicity did that to Oliver!

Oliver's training makes sense! The Canary and Black Canary got murdered despite having training from the League of Assassins.

Yes omg, this was bugging the shit out of me all episode. Like none of those people know what it takes to be a vigilante yet they all feel totally justified lecturing Oliver.

75

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Oliver is trying to turn them into heroes, Felicity is trying to turn them into CW characters.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/ItMayBeWrong Oct 13 '16

Oliver's reasoning made sense to me. I like how the flashbacks are set and even though his team members were shot, Oliver still uses it to teach a good lesson.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Jeffersonstarships Oct 13 '16

I was hoping Oliver would have ripped Felicity a new one, after she berated him in front of the new recruits. While she's been there since pretty much day 1, I can understand why she'd stand up to him. However, Oliver was 100% right when he said that none of them have had the same experiences and losses he has, especially since they were fresh vigilantes.

6

u/SawRub Oct 13 '16

How the fuck is trusting each other gonna improve Wild Dog's coordination so he doesn't trip off a building and kill himself?

I think what they meant is that until he starts trusting Oliver, he wouldn't be in the right head space to effectively learn how not to trip.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

90

u/Amyga17 Oct 13 '16

We hentai now, boys!

34

u/Econ01 Oct 13 '16

Seen enough tentacles to know where this is hoing

→ More replies (1)

185

u/epraider Oct 13 '16

Ragman will probably be this show's version of the Red Hood, get pissy with Oliver for not going far enough to avenge Havenrock, and probably try to kill Felicity.

Prometheus is probably Tommy due to Barry's dick in the timeline making it possible for him to still be alive, probably after Oliver for not saving Laurel.

144

u/MHath Oct 13 '16

Prometheus is probably Tommy due to Barry's dick in the timeline

I think you're overestimating how much Flashpoint will affect Arrow.

85

u/iMurd Welcome Home, Kid Oct 13 '16

Well honestly that might give them a reason to explain Flashpoint to the Arrow only viewers. Cause right now I have no clue how they're going to explain baby Sara gone.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (20)

49

u/svrtngr Oct 13 '16

I'm currently leaning more towards Prometheus being Felicity's cop boyfriend, but Tommy is suspect number 2.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/NoDiceSpringbing Oct 13 '16

Actually this makes me wonder. IF Black Siren is still in the pipeline... but was on Earth-1 when Barry went back in time... might she become a good Black Siren after Flashpoint?

Jay Garrick, Harry Wells, and Jesse Quick were not effected because they were on alternate Earths.

Dr. Light and Black Siren were still on Earth-1 for Flashpoint.

→ More replies (64)
→ More replies (15)

117

u/yamitcg Oct 13 '16

Important to note that Oliver revealed his true identity to Wild Dog, Sharpe and Curtis (who already knew) but didn't reveal himself to Ragman even though he added Ragman to his team

117

u/PainStorm14 I have and always shall love Laurel Lance Oct 13 '16

Why doesn't he just put it on billboards all over the fucking city?

After all, nobody can know his secret LMFAO

→ More replies (4)

43

u/MeatTornado25 Bow Oct 13 '16

And Ragman revealed himself first too

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

I got a bit annoyed with everybody going "well if I'm not going to train with the heroic legend if I don't get to know his secret identity, even though he has no real reason to trust me for the rest of my life."

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

178

u/Dethp00l Oct 13 '16

This entire new "team" is just full of wusses. For example, Curtis complains of Olie tearing people down. The purpose of doing that is to build the person again but as different person. Exactly what drill sergeants do in the military. If they quit so easily then Oliver truly did choose the wrong people

79

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

They're also incredibly dumb. It shouldn't take more than three or four tries to think "let's work together", let alone days of doing it.

Wasn't Curtis supposed to be super smart or something?

→ More replies (8)

19

u/Dievas39 Oct 13 '16

And the entire team is now useless. Those three idiots cant even ring the goddamn bell, and there are three of them! In Bratva challenge there were a ton of guys holding them back, but in this case its only Oliver! And bam, we have Ragman. Dude's op as fuck, he could probably kill those three idiots in a couple of seconds without breaking a sweat! I can already imagine how the next episodes of Arrow will try to make the three idioteers relevant when also having Ragman on the team. It is like having Goku, Yamcha, Krillin and Tien in the team, you kind of know that only one matters, but they are still there for the show!

8

u/Jeffersonstarships Oct 13 '16

I can see Wild Dog being the cancer on the team. He'll probably have some sort of disagreement with Oliver and turn against him or leave.

→ More replies (5)

151

u/Flying_Dogz07 Oct 13 '16

Arrow needs to make prometheus look more different ragman. They really look the same to me. How about you guys?

123

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Meh. Prometheus looks like Green Arrow with Ragman's mask.

70

u/NoDiceSpringbing Oct 13 '16

*Black Arrow.

His costume is 100% black. Or at least a dark enough green it looks black in dim light.

Nothing like Yao Fei's hood at all now.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

51

u/Hamton52 black canary Oct 13 '16

Yeah, I legit thought it was Prometheus for like half of the episode.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Vigilante_2277 Oct 13 '16

Definitely. When he joins the team maybe Cisco will redesign for him.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (10)

106

u/Hamton52 black canary Oct 13 '16

Not bad. Not as good as last week IMO, but still a decent episode overall.

69

u/svrtngr Oct 13 '16

As long as this is the low of the season, I can't be too disappointed.

Granted, we're only two episodes in but they've both been better than all of season four and season 3B.

69

u/linkman0596 Oct 13 '16

Probably won't be the low, but this will probably be the average, which is acceptable in my opinion.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

151

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

I was enjoying Ollie ripping apart the recruits after the event, but WHYYY does Felicity have to always interject as if she's some mother scared of her children being upset. It's not like she knows jackshite about training fighters

98

u/FortressAB Oct 13 '16

She is forced into every f#cking scene even if it makes zero sense

→ More replies (4)

36

u/Theo67 Oct 13 '16

Felicity should know better. She's seen Team Arrow come in injured, drugged, shot and dead from being out on the streets. She knows how high the stakes are, and how evil the villains.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/RatedR2O Oct 13 '16

This is what bothered me in this episode. Ollie was aggressive with the recruits, and having Felicity interrupt him during the training showed the recruits that his methods were too aggressive. They didn't trust him because one of his most trusted friends questioned his methods. I don't mind Felicity (the character) at all... but they need to tone her down a bit.

→ More replies (7)

25

u/Svetgm Oct 13 '16

-two episodes in and it's looking pretty good -Felicity is eventually going to get rag-fucked by Ragman -the veteran Characters seem to all have decent story arcs -Prometheus wants to make Oliver suffer slowly by the looks of it

→ More replies (2)

22

u/linkman0596 Oct 13 '16

That end scene was perfect.

This episode wasn't as great as last weeks but is probably the second best episode in the past year and a half so I'll call it a win. It's earned another week on my watch list, if it can keep this up (with only a little faltering in episode 5) until the crossover I'd be willing to recommend Arrow to people again.

→ More replies (8)

43

u/notathrowaway75 Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

I'm actually really enjoying the flashbacks. I especially like how their connecting to what's going on in the present.

"Some could say the same about you." I'll admit, I laughed.

Why doesn't Thea just become the deputy mayor?

Looks like they're addressing the nuke in Havenrock, thankfully.

32

u/MeatTornado25 Bow Oct 13 '16

I assumed Thea was his Chief of Staff, which is probably more important

→ More replies (2)

19

u/frankie_benjamin Oct 13 '16

Why doesn't Thea just become the deputy mayor?

Deputy Mayor is better off with someone with a reputation in the city. Gives the position some shine. Also would look weird, "Hey, I'm Mayor Queen, and this is my sister, Deputy Mayor Queen."

→ More replies (1)

18

u/TheSamehMagdy mAyBe iAm JuSt 10 sTePs AhEaD Of yOu Oct 14 '16

Ok, am I the only one who made the connection to Team 7's bell test from Naruto?

87

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Loving the action scenes and the brutality so far this year. Great job.

Felicity needs to STFU about Ollie being too mean. The most capable one of the three literally tripped trying to run off a roof and would've died if Ollie hadn't saved him. Tough love is exactly what they need.

Felicity is a complete hippocrit lying to her bf so she can run off and hang out with Oliver. Last season she got mad because he lied to her (because the mother of his child wanted him too btw) and now she's doing this. Typical terrible Felicity.

27

u/Jeffersonstarships Oct 13 '16

I thought having Felicity yell at/stand up to Green Arrow made him look weak in front of the new recruits.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Thought the Rag dude was Prometheus felt confused af

→ More replies (3)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

the actress that plays evelyn sharpe is pretty bad, they really should have recast her, i doubt anyone would have noticed i mean it worked for sara.

also is thea the only one with a job, felicity supposedly has one but her and curtis spend all their time in the cave. also did i miss something? why did felicity ask her boyfriend to do the lab analysis when she can look at something and tell you the field where the cotton was picked

also that Dig speech where he was talking about how the red white stripes give him courage was super weird

22

u/PsyJak Oct 13 '16

I snorted with laughter before I realised you meant Sara Lance not Sara Diggle.

It looks like they're dialling back on her omnipotent skillset after complaints of last season.

10

u/Theo67 Oct 13 '16

Didn't Felicity get fired? Does she have a new job now? I'm assuming she got millions from Roy and Oliver's former company...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/antigravitytapes Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

"When I was in the Bratva....." -ollie

"You never talk about that!" -felicity

the cringe is never ending. she immediately interrupts him as soon as he says bratva, and its like stepback bitch have some fucking manners you heathen let the man speak. dear god they just need to kill Felicity off and the show would get much better. its not shitposting when its honest to god truth. also when she explains things she does this weird deep monotone thing with her throat that sounds froggish.

6

u/Darth-Pimpin Oct 13 '16

Dear Grodd. If it was me, I probably would have just said "………and that's why." and gone silent again.

14

u/Marlinsoverdolphins Oct 14 '16

I didn't understand the part when felicity found out Oliver was going to be the only security for the free clinic. He then said no i wont be alone, I'll have the police and the task force with me as well. Then she says the dumbest thing... the police are out of their league, this will be a better job for the team... I don't know about you guys but I'm pretty sure by this point in the story the police will be 100% better for security than the useless team they have... all in all just a stupid line in a whole sea of shit. Just a little side note: felicity and curtis just needed to shut up this episode, seriously nothing productive came out of their mouths at all.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/yamitcg Oct 13 '16

Prometheus and Alchemy have very similiar masks

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Future_Vantas The Flash Oct 13 '16

A rehash, but the brutal fights give me hope. Not a huge fan of the recruits yet, but I'm willing to give them more time.

37

u/Ignis311 Oct 13 '16

We're 2 episodes in boys and everything is going good. A little too good. Fool me once...

19

u/itzjamez1215 Oct 13 '16

chill season 3 & 4 didnt go bad till after their winter breaks

→ More replies (8)

27

u/ItMayBeWrong Oct 13 '16

THIS STILL DOESNT EXPLAIN HOW Evelyn Sharp was able to imitate the Black Canary!!

23

u/PsychoLunaticX Oct 13 '16

Are you talking about with her power? She stole the sonic device from the hospital when Laurel was admitted. She was there due to I believe, drug problems.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/gensouj Oct 13 '16

why does arrow care if ragman kills ppl, he be killing everyone

7

u/Logiteck77 Oct 13 '16

That was last episode totally different.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/CorporalThornberry Oct 13 '16

Good episode. I have hope for this show yet

8

u/rovanz Corny McGuggie Oct 13 '16

Thank Grodd, Ragman revealed his identity straight away, if not we would be flooded with "ragman identity theory threads".

Is it me, or does he looks a lot like Brother Blood?

→ More replies (1)

22

u/remag117 Oct 13 '16

I liked it. Not as good as the premiere but still solid. The Ragman storyline is predictable (he'll eventually find out Felicity dropped the nuke and will try to kill her) and some of the training storyline was weak, but I'm liking it. And I'm glad they're doing multiple villians, Prometheus and Church are both awesome so far

17

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Don't think Church is gonna stick around

→ More replies (3)

33

u/fullforce098 Oct 13 '16

A solid "Meh" for me. Nothing awful but nothing great. I kinda like the idea of Oliver training a new team, it's a new direction to take the show at least, but it won't last long if it stays this boring. Church is really uninteresting too, but I feel like he wont last long.

13

u/TheFabledFamilyGuy Oct 13 '16

I disagree but I do agree about Church. I don't find him interesting.

16

u/ItMayBeWrong Oct 13 '16

Church is really uninteresting too

That's probably why he's not the big bad of the season

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/DarthJordan Deadshot Oct 13 '16

Good episode. However this bugged me: "No one in the Bratva knew each other's name... except mine.. everyone knew my name" lol

7

u/Hieillua Oct 13 '16

I'm seeing people saying on this sub how good episode 2 was. What show were these people watching? What happened to this sub and why are people so positive so suddenly? This episode was boring and so badly executed. Annoying new characters, rip-off Zoom, Felicity still annoying as fuck, poorly handled mayor plot, boring flashbacks, uninspired Diggle plot, ''Genesis day''.

And I guess Wild Hog can regenerate. Remember when wounds/injuries would have actual impact in season 1 and 2?

7

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

In comparison to seasons 3 and 4, it was a huge improvement. The first half of a season is always going to be a bit slow, this episode wasn't amazing but it was decent.

25

u/rmw6190 Oct 13 '16

It was alright. Which is going to make people think it was great.

Diggles storyline is borderline unwatchable. His wife is the head of argus, you think they cant find out who got paid extra for wmds. Give me a break.

Felicity still sucks, but she isnt killing the show this season so improvement.

The actions scenes are better, but they arent great and cut a lot to make it appear faster. And had some weird sequences to progress the plot(ragman appearing in the middle of the crowd, Olivers miraculous change of clothes)

Half the episode was done in the beginning of naruto.

The team is terrible. They arent able to grasp teamwork and than abandon him when they cant figure out the lesson they are supposed to learn. But felicity says oliver needs a team, despite him not needing one at all and not even struggling in the episode.

Ragman is obviously going to find out about felicity and betray oliver. Its so obvious, that it will barely qualify as a twist.

Overall it is a step in the right direction, but there is still a lot of problems and the next few episodes plot seem to be more of season 4 and not like season 5

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Megaman99M Oct 13 '16

Ollie may not be a meta or have any magic but with how fast he can switch costumes he's faster than Barry

6

u/mythical_legend Oct 13 '16

Isn't ragman way to overpowered to apart of team arrow? Who needs strategy when you have nuclear-bullet proof ragguy.

He seems like someone that'll end up on Legends or Flash if he doesn't turn out to be crazy.

6

u/Nerevaryjczyk Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 15 '16

One thing I noticed during the episode: how could Wild Dog tear a piece of Ragman's outfit since it's supposedly resistant to a nuclear explosion? I'm not familiar with this character, so I have no idea how those robes are supposed to work, but it seems really off.

Also, not sure what kind of analysis the police boyfriend did exactly, but why would he even go for determining the age? If he went with Felicity's story, it's supposed to be just a random scrap of material and police usually tries to find out the type, traces of other materials and so on, they don't strike me as ones to do archeology work with it.

Also, convenient coincidences are convenient. The only nuke to reach its target was obviously created by the company based in Star City. Obviously.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/GMack17 Can ya digg it? Oct 13 '16

The first two episodes this season weren't terrible. I guess ill keep watching

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

It bothered me when he told her she needs a mask and that its "not negotiable" and then the next scene she is all superior to him and goes "no chance". I really don't like the character. I watch the show for the fucking GREEN ARROW. Not for Felicity.

This was my favourite show for a time now I watch it mostly out of habit and to keep up with the Flash.

5

u/Dievas39 Oct 13 '16

Overall, good episode. Compared to the previous season, when I was on the phone for entire episodes browsing facebook, this one was actually interesting to watch.

Though to be fair, the entire team makes no sense. Curtis should be behind a computer. Other two idiots are complete trash, and with an attitude. And the fucking Ragman is the bomb. He is seriously hella strong, and so far seems to be a cool character that is quite reasonable, which is rare in Arrow. With Ragman in the team, other three idiots would just be foot soldiers, but of course, the show is going to go extreme lengths to make them appear useful, even though next to Ragman they are crap.

Ragman is definitely going to have a mental breakdown once Felicity fucks shit up by feeling too guilty and telling him she is the reason his town was destroyed.

Felicity is definitely going to get involved into a shitload of drama once the boyfriend emerges and/or finds out what she is doing in her spare time.

Finally, I goddamn hate Church guy. He is seriously useless, and yet he is probably going to bother Oliver for the rest of the season. And that typical "kinda crazy but in fact smart and knows how to fight" bad guy, COME ON, cant you come up with something more creative?

P.S. I loved how they explained Oliver losing to Church (if you missed it, Oliver lost on purpose, just so he could ask Ragman to help him, and recruit him later on). I hope the days where Oliver, the man who defeated Ras al Ghul, defeated Mirakuru soldiers, defeated early-day Flash, has a difficult 5 minute fight or even loses to a street thug.

P.P.S. Moderators stop that Arrow shaming. Yes, S4 was total crap, but so far S5 is pretty good, so you should stop calling the show shit. Give it a chance, maybe Arrow will become a great show it once was. I think that Prometheus dude has the potential to be an interesting villain.

5

u/Shinjukugarb Oct 13 '16

fuck felicity and her bullshit.

5

u/TheGreatRao Oct 14 '16

A quick question. Church was knocked out. How did he get away? It's good that they mention that Oliver basically dogged the fight to test Ragman's loyalties, but wouldn't they have secured Church after knocking him out?

5

u/Anna-asd Oct 14 '16

It took me about 80 minutes to watch the episode, i was taking breaks all the time :D

5

u/riptide747 Oct 15 '16 edited Oct 15 '16

Oliver back to not being able to beat some dude who learned how to fight in the streets despite being one of the best fighters in the DC universe.

Edit: Just finished the episode. He let him win to recruit someone...when he could've killed Church and stopped the entire reign of terror he had been causing. K.

5

u/GrimChronos Oct 15 '16

Honestly tho I dont think Felicity should be involved or be allowed to lecture Oliver about how he trains the recruits , batman (GR show version is like him) does the exact same thing with his robins only difference is they have the drive and dont Rebel , they do have some level of hate towards batman but they still train , which is why I can't agree with Curtis's point or Felicity's point of how he treats people

5

u/AHMilling Oct 15 '16 edited Oct 15 '16

Curtis, go eat a dick! and felicity you can eat one too.

Oliver was in the right to do what the fuck he wanted to do. You don't get to be a vigilante by sunshine and rainbows with cookies.

Roy and Thea didn't leave because of Oliver, they left because of themselves, Roy because he had to hide, and Thea because of her Bloodlust.

But it was nice to see Thea do some Parkour :)

12

u/DrJonesPHD62 Creative Lead: ARROW EXPANDED Oct 13 '16

Not a terrible episode. Not as good as last week's. Had its share of flaws and I didn't enjoy it nearly as much, as I saw it stepping dangerously close to S4 territory a few times. Pacing was FAR too fast. Flashbacks were FAR too short. Last fight was cool, minus the strobe effect. Oliver was ruthless with his arrows and kicked his team around sufficiently.

He got far too much flak for his treatment of the recruits, but to be fair, they were people he barely knew and unlike Oliver they didn't have four prior years of combat experience before "on the line" training. Still, they gave up after one or two sessions? What'd they think they were in for? Cookies and hugs and gentle encouragement to risk their lives and battle the unforgiving world with reckless abandon? They're the perfect example of why the writers can't give Felicity combat training. To be hardened to Oliver's extent requires at least five years of punishment and an incredible degree of endurance. It requires an iron will. Neither the new team nor Felicity have those traits.

At least I could tell where it was going and there was some logic behind the episode. As annoying as Felicity was, she did have an actual point in the episode. That may be why I enjoyed it more than S4 but less than last week's episode. Nothing felt extraneous except Fefe. Last week had minimal Fefe, whereas this week had about 40%-45% Fefe, 20% of which she spent being annoyed and making obnoxiously disrespectful demands.

11

u/MeatTornado25 Bow Oct 13 '16

Pretty sure Slade repeatedly beat the shit out of Oliver before he had any experience whatsoever. I think Oliver was mimicking that training as much as he was the Bratva technique.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/buzz3light Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

The placement of flashback and diggle scenes were mostly strange. Why is there this incessant need to pan the camera to Felicity? I really don't get that practice. She was a real focus this episode, still annoying with her snarkiness and I'm-right-you're-wrong attitude, but a little more tolerable; we could definitely use less of her. God, I'm afraid they're going to ramp up her presence at the expense of these new characters. They need to not have strobe lights going off during an action scene, literally can't comprehend what's going on

Also, these recruits are bitchmade, especially Curtis.

4

u/gusefalito Oct 13 '16

I propose a new theory: Prometheus is Detective Malone (Felicity's boyfriend)

4

u/FortressAB Oct 13 '16

Meh, best part was Prometheus

4

u/ALANJOESTAR Arsenal Oct 13 '16

To be honest oliver´s training methods make a lot of sense to me so all that felicty nagging and curtis being butt hurt to me was just plain straight up pathetic, also he doesnt need a team he did fairly well on his own for a really long time and he should have only gotten better since then. having him on his own would make for a more entraining show that its focused primarly on him and not this so called "team" (sometimes less its more crazy aint it? ) besides having felicty its tortute enough as it is. I liked the season premier mostly because we got a bit of what made the first two seasons great, but after this episode and as expected from the trailers we are all in just for another shitshow.

4

u/lolxddavid Ten Steps Ahead Oct 13 '16

Holy shit Oliver stabbed a dude with an arrow

4

u/Rydisx Oct 13 '16

I think Oliver's test of the recruits was perfectly reasonable. He gave them a test for them to overcome. He figured it out when it was done to him. They failed to do so. They couldn't work as a team, they never attempted too. Doesn't matter if they were or were not told how to do it.

Then when they failed because they couldn't do what they think was impossible, they all quit. They couldn't/didn't work as a team and this shows they can't do this job.

This team is a complete failure and they deserve to be benched. They aren't ready and they threw in the towel very early. Oliver should of let them walk away and stay away. Not bring them back.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Lyrixon Oct 13 '16

"Pretty boy Queen here thinks he's actually saving the city."

Lmao! 😂😂

4

u/dizzybala10 Oct 13 '16

I'm actually not sorry I gave the show another chance after season four. Been pretty decent episodes so far.

4

u/chinchillahorned Oct 13 '16

Top level comments. Felicity.

So the show sucks and the good first episode was a fluke?

4

u/Thejklay A Crisis Is Coming Oct 13 '16

Please keep this up arrow, That was good!

Pros

  • Badass training!
  • Cool Flashbacks
  • Great fight scenes
  • "Someone Else, Something Else!"
  • Ragman was really cool, love his meta powers
  • The Thea Quentin scene
  • Some very funny lines

Cons

  • Felicity being a hypocrite about the lying thing

Not as good as the premier but still good

4

u/gthv Oct 13 '16

I know it's late, but did they just redecorate Queen Consolidated's CEO office to be the Mayor's office? I know they reuse sets, but damn guys.

4

u/MeepMorper Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16

I really liked this episode, maybe more than last week's. My only gripes were Felicity lying to her boyfriend, and the dumb trust stuff; the old team left on their own accord/died, not because GA was mean to them.

4

u/blackfireproduction1 Black Canary (Laurel Lance) Oct 14 '16

You know what this new opening means? Oliver isn't going to lose his position as mayor this season and end up jobless for the entire back half of a season!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/nerfAvari Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16

'member when we said we weren't gona watch the shitshow that is Arrow? pepperidge farm 'members

I know we just can't look away, but you all know in the back of your minds that nothing has changed

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16

From this episode I learned that Oliver was a dick. Also why do both Flash and Arrow have villains with large dumb looking masks.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kingsky123 Oct 15 '16

Wasn't ragman a DC hero who dealt with magic? I remember reading about him in JL:Dark. He is always shown with Constantine and Zatana right?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '16

Just the fact that he uses his arrows and actually kills baddies and does cool shit makes arrow do much better

4

u/GrimChronos Oct 15 '16

anyone else miss Roy , he the best sidekick #cryforarsenal #BringHimHome

→ More replies (1)

7

u/gusefalito Oct 13 '16

I liked this more than last week (in the minority I guess) but really liked the focus on Diggle and his storyline, Oliver and Felicity had logical arguments where they both made good points, Oliver has a secret identity again (that kind of rly diminished in S3, but it made sense) the fight scenes are still on point (Bamford seriously needs to direct more episodes), Lance is still the MVP (shout-out to Blacthorne, guy never disappoints) and I'm rly digging his arc so far, Thea is showing some rly good character development and does a better job at running the City than the Mayor. These were just a few points but Arrow is shaping up to be a good season.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Ragman's hella cute.

13

u/Coolica1 Hi organic writing, I'm dad Oct 13 '16

7 arrows fired (1 wasn't really an arrow, whatever Chrurch had thrown in his back and excluding the 1st 5 minutes as I wasn't watching then).

If Thea had been the one to have run for mayor then Oliver could have stuck to being a vigilante and that would have made a lot more sense. I don't like this new team so I'd have much preferred it this way too.

Diggle sideplot just doesn't interest me. I was more invested in the Diggle developments in the Flash episode than tonight. How often does he run into corruption in the military? And where the fuck is Lyla?

Quentin is tragic but apart from that he doesn't really add anything to the show apart from occasional sadness and sarcastic comments. At least he's bonding with Thea and he's got a new job.

Now we're back to felicity being right as usual with her and everyone yelling at Oliver. Oliver is putting up more resistance against that this season but he still ends up caving.

I think it's slightly better than the start of last season but the only reason for that is better flashbacks. The Bratva is fucking ruthless although maybe a bit OTT on that front. It's clear that they have run out of ideas, the show is pretty boring at a time when we should be hyped. It shows how much damage has already been done, this won't be a quick fix.

15

u/ItMayBeWrong Oct 13 '16 edited Oct 13 '16

Diggle sideplot just doesn't interest me.

I think its there for a way to bring him back to Star City.

It just sucks that Diggle got back stabbed twice while in the military

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Pretty solid episode. Wasn't the greatest but still better than anything in S4

16

u/Hamton52 black canary Oct 13 '16

Except for the Constantine episode and the Vixen one. Those were pretty solid.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/dg07 Season 5 is good, kid Oct 13 '16

For those of us that can't watch live or don't watch, was it good?

8

u/linkman0596 Oct 13 '16

Second best episode in a year in a half.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Oh my god. Season 4 was gas leak year, hmm 4 seems like a bad number for tv.

But uh ... can I just say how happy I am that Flash is now morally obligated to no longer stick his dick in the time line. I have faith it will stay this way.

It's like Berlanti said "Flash: You guys do whatever as long as Barry dicks the timeline but give him a reason not to do it anymore. Arrow: Guggie sit the fuck down and do whatever Flash says."

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Vigilante_2277 Oct 13 '16

Well it looks promising so far but I won't get my hopes up too soon.

3

u/Tyron112 Oct 13 '16

Not quite to the levels of last week's, but still a good episode. Really hope Thea joins back sooner rather than later though, I don't want a half vigilante Thea who can't make up her mind all season.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

so has the main villain been revealed?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Clearly Prometheus. He has a vendetta against Green Arrow who he may or may not know is also Oliver Queen

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/AxiosImmortal Oct 13 '16

I already have a theory about who Prometheus is: [spoiler] (#s "the flashback with Oliver trying to ring the bell back in russia trying to join Bratva made it easier. The main guy with the hood and eye mask ordering the recruits to go to the line every time they failed is likely the one after Oliver from his past. As more flashbacks go on the more they will reveal the conflict between them" )

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gusefalito Oct 13 '16

Deputy Mayor Lance? I DIG IT. QUEEN/LANCE vs WELLS/RAMON for Presidential Elections 2016

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

There was quite a bit of writing I liked in this episode. I liked Quentin getting the job from Thea and I didn't think Ragman was gonna be recruited to the team.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Montythe Deathstroke Oct 13 '16

Love how no one ever pretends to be shocked that Oliver is the Green Arrow.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Five seasons in and Oliver's still getting talked down to by people that work under him. It's gotten annoying.

Besides that, I really enjoyed this episode, especially teaming up with Rag-man.

3

u/hellsbellltrudy Oct 13 '16

Hoodies are really popular this season. Dr. Alchemy, Prometheus and Ragman.

3

u/RifleGun Oct 13 '16

Anyone else thought he was scarecrow?

3

u/EchoLeader1 Oct 13 '16

Is it just me, or does Felicity now feel way more like the Felicity from seasons 1-2, almost like she just skipped seasons 3-4 (with a quick pitstop to nuke a town)? Not complaining, I love that she's back to being a good character. I just wondered if anyone else felt the same.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '16

Anyone else thinks that the team is too big?

3

u/Tsorovar Oct 13 '16

Not digging the flashbacks. They seemed slightly promising in the first episode, but now we're back to "random superficial connection to the present episode" like seasons 3 and 4. They really needed to get back to the Season 1 and 2 system, where the flashbacks had their own compelling story that stood on its own, but also connected to the present.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SmellyWeapon Oct 13 '16

a pretty solid " Meh " episode for arrow. Cant wait for next week's to eventually find out who is prometheus and what did barry fucked up.

3

u/CharlesNapalm Oct 14 '16

Did Felicity's new boyfriend used to be a woman? Something felt really weird.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TheHillsHavePis Oct 14 '16

Alright, who called it? I specifically remember someone calling that "Felicity having to nuke the city will be some forced point of drama this season"... I can already see it coming how it's going to play out... Ugh

3

u/Metroidman Oct 14 '16

Oliver lives a pretty predictable life having everything happening to him being an exact copy if what he was going through 5 years prior

3

u/somebody1993 Oct 14 '16 edited Oct 14 '16

So does the fact that we're getting Bratva flashbacks mean we'll finally know why they accepted a such a one sided relationship in Oliver's favor in the earlier seasons ?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Savletto Oct 15 '16

When you think that writing couldn't get any worse... it actually happens. I feel so sorry for this show and its actors - it started great, it was awesome, but now it's a TRAINWRECK. Yes, TRAINWRECK in caps, TRAINWRECK as in "US presidential election of 2016".

Where's all quality of Season 1 and 2?! Просрали все полимеры, блять!
I thought something will change for better in Season 5, but no, after two episodes i'm adamant that there's no remedying it now, which frustrates me a lot. I'm done with this show, i'm done.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/rovanz Corny McGuggie Oct 15 '16

Next time Curtis dares to talk shit, Kakashi Oliver should just use one thousand years of death.

3

u/AlexHD Oct 16 '16 edited Oct 16 '16

I'm actually pretty happy with season 5 so far. Having a metahuman(?) on the team with a mystical "holy vengeance" mindset and personality is a nice contrast to the more realistic characters. The fights and stunts are nicely done and the editing and camera work shows off more of the choreography instead of being lost in choppy editing.

People (read: Reddit) whine about how the show is going backwards with Felicity's dominance in the story and Oliver killing again, but it's not nearly as bad as the Olicity soap opera stuff. I kind of like that Oliver is being a tough bastard who kills and it goes to show that a no-kill rule is really really hard to keep. Unfortunately the only "voice of reason" character the show has is Felicity (and maybe Thea, but she's out of Team Arrow right now and Diggle is away), so Felicity has to take that role, but we get annoyed with her because of all her previous baggage. Like, if it was Diggle telling Oliver what to do, we'd be totally fine with it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DualDier Oct 13 '16

What a great episode. Good plot lines, good transitions into the flashbacks. For the love of god, the flashbacks are actually interesting again!

The only thing is, I think people forget that Oliver used to do this for nearly 2 years all alone..