r/arrow • u/amadoamata Tom, Eat a dick • Jan 26 '17
[Spoilers] [S05E10] Who Are You? Post Episode Discussion Spoiler
Worried that Prometheus is right and he is truly a killer at heart, Oliver (Stephen Amell) looks for any ray of hope and finds it in what seems to be the miraculous return of Laurel Lance (guest star Katie Cassidy). However, Felicity (Emily Bett Rickards), still reeling from Detective Malone’s murder, is bent on revenge – she wants to stop Prometheus at any cost. While in prison, Diggle (David Ramsey) fights for his life. Gregory Smith directed the episode written by Ben Sokolowski & Brian Ford Sullivan.
This is for post episode discussion of the new episode of Arrow. Did you love it? Hate it? Saw something cool? Post it below!
200
u/amadoamata Tom, Eat a dick Jan 26 '17
Alright this episode was okay. It wasn't great but it was okay.
Highlights of the episode include:
+Adrian Chase in general
+Moments between Black Siren/Oliver
+Mr Terrific becoming more of who he is supposed to be as a hero
+Some character development for Felicity. I know she's not great but the do anything to avenge Billy attitude makes sense.
Some low points include:
-Black Siren getting a sever power down
-Felicity overriding Oliver on the team
-The flashback wasn't too good this episode except for her showing up
-The implication that a new person is going to be Black Canary as opposed to showing Black Siren can be rehabilitated which would make more sense as we know how Earth-2 is in comparison to Earth-1
-Weak motivations for Black Siren to actually attack team Arrow
2
u/amadoamata Tom, Eat a dick Jan 26 '17
Hey mods can this thread at least get a sticky for discussion's sake?
/u/venn177
/u/stock_character
568
u/FKDotFitzgerald Jan 26 '17
The Adrian Chase scenes made the episode for me. Such a cool character.
743
u/captainjenkins Jan 26 '17
You can't put up the idea of a black siren redemption and then immediately make the next episode about trying to recruit a person with similar powers to be black canary....
327
u/ezreads Jan 26 '17
"YOU REALLY NEED TO SHUT YOUR DAMN MOUTH!"
well okay Curtis
586
u/niffirgmason Jan 26 '17
Laurel: "Once you let the darkness inside, you can't stop it"
Oliver: "Are you telling me... you can't lock it up?"
251
u/UltralightFiends Jan 26 '17
Raw Dog is really starting to grow on me.
230
u/Flashwing21 Jan 26 '17
At least they blasted the shit out of that fugly Black Canary statue. +1 for that.
591
u/anthonyongg Jan 26 '17
For a second I thought Oliver was going to ask Felicity to be the next BC. I would never watch the show again if that ever happened
273
u/niffirgmason Jan 26 '17
I forgot they had a female president, just like-
Oh...
271
u/ezreads Jan 26 '17
"hello Mr. Queen my name is Talia I've been looking for you"
oh okay...WAIT WHAT??
545
u/niffirgmason Jan 26 '17
And just like that... Laurel has been demoted to villain of the week status.
Sad times.
103
u/PlasticCocktailSword Jan 26 '17
Well, they were on track to turn things around for like the first 45 minutes.... Then decided "nah, fuck BC and fuck the fans"
447
u/Toahpt Jan 26 '17
Can Felicity actually get any worse? I said in Discord that it's a shame that Black Siren can destroy buildings, but not explode Felicity's head. Obviously it's because Felicity's head is made of the densest material in the multiverse.
First she undermines Oliver's leadership repeatedly, then she runs into the fight right next to Mr. Terrific. If she wasn't the main character, I would think she's actively asking to be killed.
63
u/ManOfIronAnSteel Jan 26 '17
Prometheus: Its Felicity or Me
Oliver: (continues fighting Prometheus)
Me: Good choice let her die
Writers: JK we are going to have her punch Laurel and have some bullshit lame oneliner.
156
u/ajdragoon Jan 26 '17
I feel like the point of that episode was to make it clear that Katie Cassidy's Laurel Lance will never be Laurel or Black Canary ever again. I have mixed feelings. On one hand, the new Black Canary seems to be more like the streetwise metahuman screamer from the comics. But on the other, Dinah Laurel Lance is Black Canary, and just giving the title to a new person is one hell of an annoying bandaid.
103
u/UncleIroh626 Jan 26 '17
The sad thing is that Tina seemed just like Dinah Laurel Lance. That kills me. Because I know she'll be an enjoyable presence, but her very existence is a reminder of the writer s' past and current failures. Why couldn't they just get it right once? Why throw Kassidy to the side?
It's frustrating and I'd absolutely understand anyone jumping ship (though, come on, you made it through Season 4).
92
u/Joker_CP *Angry Helicopter Noises* Jan 26 '17
It hasn't descended to Season 4's level yet, but I thought this episode was pretty weak. The character of Black Canary was shat on in so many ways. I still don't understand why she wouldn't just use her powers on Prometheus and escape unless Prometheus has powers too...I can't believe the plot with Chase and Diggle was actually the better part of the episode.
88
u/remag117 Jan 26 '17
They really nerfed Black Siren. Like it was already dumb that she'd be scared of Prometheus at all after fighting metas (including a speedster) but she gets a one hit KO from some tech geek who just started any sort of training? This is worse than what they did to Deathstroke
218
u/DrJonesPHD62 Creative Lead: ARROW EXPANDED Jan 26 '17
That wasn't great. Definitely the weakest episode of the season by far. Had moments of cool (Siren's reveal, the fight with Prometheus, scenes with Curtis and Rene, Rory being Rory, etc) that made it still enjoyable but GOOD HEAVENS. Seeing Felicity knock Siren out was the worst thing I've seen since she got up and walked out on Oliver. In fact I even did an impression of her by getting up and walking out of the room after that happened. The rest of the episode was highly flawed but enjoyable. That... that one scene was terrible.
41
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
Not sure if it's only me but the 'Laurel is back from the dead' arc was wasted potential. Should have gone the route of having her in at least 2 episodes making everybody trust her and all that other shit. Instead they just throw you in the action like 5 mins into the show starting.
38
u/domokl3 Jan 26 '17
Ragman had that Worf Effect hit him hard.
292
u/iamduh Nyssa al Ghul Jan 26 '17
I did not watch this episode to see Felicity punch out Laurel.
89
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
I think people need to remember that Cassidy is signed up on a multi-show deal --- this isn't the last of her.
162
u/arielle17 Jan 26 '17
Calm down guys.
Did you guys really think they'd turn a major, sadistic villain from the Flash into a heroic character, and the new Black Canary, within the span of one episode? We don't know where the story is going (yet) but Laurel will clearly appear again. I'd imagine Tina's Canary will be used as a part of her redemption arc, but there's no reason to think she's been reduced to a "villain of the week" just because her redemption wasn't rushed in 30-40 minutes.
52
u/gusefalito Jan 26 '17
MVP goes to Josh Segarra's portrayal of Adrian Chase. Definitely most badass character on the show.
The Black Siren stuff was alright. It did serve its purpose in the sense that it advanced both Oliver 's and Felicity's storylines in a logical, somewhat mature way.
Rene and Curtis dialogue was nice. Good to see Curtis begin to grow into his Mr. Terrific role. Much needed character development there.
Cool continuity nods to the rest of the DCTV Canon. Great to see that the writers acknowledge the other shows with ease and that these other shows do have an effect on Arrow and vice-versa.
Flashbacks served their purpose. Talia HYPE. Hope they flesh out that storyline soon (Episode 12 is titled Bratva so maybe then?). Maybe Talia can conjure some of that LoA training to perfect Oliver's archery skills over the next 5 months.
Overall, low-key excited for the rest of 5B. Hope to see Thea and Lance soon!
25
u/JontheFiddler Jan 26 '17
The actor playing Adrian Chase is fantastic, dude has that simmering anger vibe down. If I hadn't seen the preview, I thought he was going to snap and kill the general. Really hope this leads to bigger roles for the guy.
And now for the elephant in the room. This episode made me realize I hate Felicity as a character. She really didn't anything that bad but I just want to fastforward whenever she talks for more than thirty seconds. And it really has nothing to do with the romance but the fact she makes Oliver worse as a character because he will always be wrong when it comes to any conflict involving them. The episode wasn't terrible but it could have been so much better had Siren actually been conflicted. Have her working with Prometheus but once she starts spending time with Oliver it begins to bring out the person she was. And once the revealation about who she really was came out it should have been a huge emotional moment for both of them. But I knew the moment that Felicity had her suspicions she'd be right and all nuance would be thrown away.
21
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
I was kinda hoping Felicity overstepping her role would be a bigger plot point. There's been a lot of hints at it and tonight looked like it finally bugged Oliver.
51
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
This new Random Canary is just a walking Cliche.
I don't like it, especially since they had a Damn good redemption story with Siren.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
Do the writers know that the Attorney General can't disbar people? They are the 'General' attorney of the US, not the General of US attorneys. That's why the plural is 'Attorneys General) and not 'Attorney Generals'. He's the lawyer of the US and runs the DoJ, he doesn't get to order all of the other attorneys around.
27
u/MetaMarc Earth-X Reverse Flash Jan 26 '17
In my opinion this was the worst mid-season premiere out of Gotham, Flash, Legends, and Arrow. Lets do the run down shall we?
Gotham- Return of the Joker and the possibility of the Gotham crime war started by Falcone.
Flash- The team begins to solve how they will save Iris and Wally West begins.
Legends- The return of Captain Rip Hunter, George Lucas, and some great moments between the heroes and villains.
Arrow- Felicity bossing around Oliver once again, a fake Laurel that we saw coming from a mile away, and a new black canary is coming.
I am just so let down by this episode. I thought Arrow season 5 was great so far, but this episode I was just board and worst of all this episode was so predictable even if it wasn't ruined by the teasers.
36
u/wesnotwes Jan 26 '17
Total meh on that last scene.
12
u/mh40sw Jan 26 '17
Fucking Felcity takes over again. Wtf.
10
u/tabman16 Jan 26 '17
They aren't doing Prometheus justice right now. He should really be a menacing force but they have him in for like 50 seconds. His punch on Ragman made since he creeped on him. We need a full Prometheus episode. Very much so
10
u/Ember408 I'm a reminder Jan 26 '17
Who else is excited for Iron Fist, The Defenders, Jessica Jones, and The Punisher?
9
u/Ajax_Da_Great Jan 26 '17
Have to admit though the Adrian Chase and Diggle scenes probably were the highlight of the episode. Definitely a surprise since I was excited about the Laurel/Black Siren story
9
u/lolxddavid Ten Steps Ahead Jan 26 '17
The Adrian Chase and Diggle scenes were awesome. That is all
9
u/Psymon_Armour Jan 26 '17
Positive side, Adrian Chase has been awesome. The "hit me" scene and his overall attitude, would be nice to ditch the recruits and get that version of Vigilante some more screen time.
Wild Dog being a bro while still being an asshole.
New girl's attitude at the end seemed VERY Dinah-esq. Maybe in a few episodes we find out she's the Dinah Lance Black Canary doppleganger from Earth 71 or something. Still all seems remarkably unnecessary though.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17 edited Jan 26 '17
Good things
The Bad
In Summation: The show has regressed after the midseason finale, as has been tradition since Season 3. At this point they are pretty much just trolling us. Fuck you Guggie/Mericle and Olicity shippers.
16
u/xymandopex Jan 26 '17
This episode just left me gutted. I stopped watching halfway through season 4 once it was revealed Laurel was biting the bullet (plus the overall quality took a massive dip). Then I decided to give the show another shot after hearing how good season 5 was. I thought the powers that be were repenting for the shitfest they gave us seasons 3 and 4 but this episode was more of the same aka Felicity being pushed to the forefront. This show will never respect Laurel. Black Siren should've at least been a multi-episode arc, not a random villain of the week. I'm probably just being overdramatic but I really care about Laurel and really like Katie and neither deserve this.
8
u/ACmilanRgood Jan 26 '17
in my opinion it was the weakest episode in S5, wild dog and Curtis were good outside of the fight scenes, and KC/BS was amazing outside of the fight scenes. Why would Prometheus ask Oliver to make a choice between him and felicity and then vanish immediatly? felt way too forced to set up the felecity punching BS moment
8
u/theaveragejoe_1 Jan 26 '17
I have nothing against this new Tuna Bologna, she might be fun. It's just...annoying that we're going to have a Black Canary that's not Dinah Laurel Lance. Even worse, it seems like her being Black Canary will just be an excuse for Olicity to come back...
8
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
I was rooting for Felicity to die. Why does Guggie tease us like that.
7
u/SockPenguin I got tired, Frank. Jan 26 '17
This episode was basically proof that the writers only care about Felicity. Oliver's character barely moves forward, Thea and Quentin- people who actually spent time with Laurel and had relationships with her- are completely out of the picture, Black Siren does little outside of shit on Laurel as a character (Seriously, that whole 'finally' spiel when she was randomly in the Quiver to attack Felicity just felt like the writers bashing their own character.) and spam the Canary Cry, the team randomly listens to Felicity because of course they would, and Black Siren is taken out by a sucker punch from Felicity instead of Oliver being forced to accept he can't save this Laurel or Curtis actually getting to win a fight (you know, things that would resolve stories going on in this episode).
The plot does not actually make sense. How the actual fuck does Prometheus know about the Wave Rider or Sara or the pipeline or Black Siren? The recruits barely even knew details of Oliver and Team Arrow's exploits- as conveniently proven in-episode by Rene not knowing about Sara's returns from alleged and actual death- so he's not getting this information from Evelyn. Hell, Barry didn't even know anything about the Legends until Oliver told him about it. Is Prometheus secretly Nate's colleague and put together the existence of the Legends and worked from there? Does he have every place Team Arrow (and possibly Team Flash as well) might conceivably hang out bugged so he can piece together all these little details? The entire episode is built on the premise that Prometheus could know the existence of the pipeline and Laurel's doppleganger, free Black Siren from a prison that seems to require a hand print to enter without tripping a single alarm and get her to a point she could believably pass as Laurel to the people that knew her best then drop her off in the Quiver all before Team Flash notices one of their prisoners is gone, and the purpose of all that is... what, exactly? It's possible I missed a line somewhere, but from what I could tell it seemed like the only point of that was Prometheus trolling Oliver.
Also the Prospective Canary seems wack as fuck. There admittedly wasn't much to go on there, but the line delivery was bad.
tl;dr: I'm extremely salty that I gave this season a go and will only get saltier as I continue to watch because I am not a smart man. I hope the writers step on a Lego every day for the rest of their lives.
13
u/Gryffinwhore64 Jan 26 '17
I actually really like the Felicity/Rory friendship.
13
u/PlasticCocktailSword Jan 26 '17
Booooooo
18
u/Foolsgil Jan 26 '17
First, let's be honest if Siren fought Team Arrow the way she fought Flash, there'd be nothing of Team Arrow left. It's ridiculous that Prometheus and Felicity slapped her around like that. She took on Flash alone!
But overall, good episode. Ollie feels episode, I felt really bad. Wild Dog helping Mr. Terrific was good, we need to see his altruism more often, being such an acquired taste and all. Diggle's B Plot was good too.
12
u/poopslayer69 Jan 26 '17
felicity felt so forced in this episode i get shes mad about her boyfriend being dead but some something still bothered me but i cant find the word for it. Overall this episode felt weak compared to the past episodes of this season
6
u/cdRAGE Jan 26 '17
And then there were riots.
6
u/jonathot12 Jan 26 '17
I knew the Black Siren redemption arc was over the second she didn't tell Oliver that Zoom forced her to come to this earth. Then it would've seemed like every bad act she did was under duress and she truly may have been rehabilitated. After that didn't happen I figured they'd fuck it up and, well, they did.
6
u/DevoutJoJo Jan 26 '17
I'm just glad Curtis is finally moving back to an inventor/engineer role. I will never understand what his role was supposed to be in combat.
Seriously, Wild Dog has his guns and military training, Rory has his magic rags, Artemis had her bow, Felicity hacked things as long as the plot demanded, meanwhile Curtis had what? The ability to get his ass kicked?
6
u/WordToMyTimbs Jan 26 '17 edited Jul 01 '24
voracious grab amusing tender innocent tie touch north sloppy encourage
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/ojdhaze Jan 26 '17 edited Jan 26 '17
Too. Much. Felicity.
Talia finally introduced though.
64
u/TheAlexHunter Jan 26 '17 edited Jan 26 '17
Imma say it before I have to deal with Laurel fans or Felecity fans all week. Yes, Felicity punched earth 2 Laurel in the face, but yes it did work in context of the scene. It was a nice moment between Oliver and her, not some bullshit Olicity bait or Guggy returning to form, it was just an honest character moment. The episode was good, not great, but still miles better than 3b or 4. Edit: Also gonna say Tina acted more like comic Canary in tone than Laurel did for most of the show in a few moments, so I'm hopeful so far.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
Bad stuff aside Josh Segarra killed it today.
5
u/deanssocks Jan 26 '17
Damn Diggs arc was the best thing about this ep.
5
u/FireFlashX32 Jan 26 '17
More felicity drama, can we just get rid of her already?
9
u/DeoGame The Punisher Jan 26 '17
I'm conflicted. .. on the one hand, this episode was filled with tons of stupidity from a gullible Oliver, another black canary and Felicity punching Black Siren to convoluted logic leaps and massive questions such as whether Prometheus knows Ollie's number and location. On the other hand, Cassidy killed it, the door is still open for more siren, the new BC looks better than Evelyn at least, there was some good material for Diggle, Chase, Wild Dog and Curtis, and they got rid of the chocolate Laurel statue. But... the Felicity punch, ugh.
21
u/Ajax_Da_Great Jan 26 '17
Hopefully the Black Siren storyline continues and doesn't end with that awful, forced Felicity moment
33
u/simsim28 Jan 26 '17
Anyone else not really care that Felicity punched Black Siren? It was lame but if shit like this happened on the flash no one would care that much.
28
u/Fksnfiwoj1 Jan 26 '17
Fuck this show and fuck me for letting it burn me once more. WE HAD A BLACK CANARY BUT YOU KILLED FOR BECAUSE YOU "HAD NO STORIES LEFT". And now, after just 15 episodes, we get a fucking new random chick as our Black Canary. That's just TERRIBLE writing. Fuck this I'm never watching this live again
17
u/UncleIroh626 Jan 26 '17
A good episode (that isn't actually over as of right now), which will never outshine the fact that it has Felicity punching Laurel in it. That's going to damn it.
4
u/SpikeRosered Jan 26 '17
I'm glad the show is finally addressing how useless Mr. Terrific in fights. However I'm just starting to think that Renee is just as bad. I mean he's a guy with a "shoot first ask questions later" attitude, but his guns are just never effective.
4
u/TryHarderNow Jan 26 '17
I've said this since season 3. It's now a comedy show about the struggles of being Felicity with your side kicks Oliver Queen and the gang. You'll enjoy the show much more, if see the writers are pushing ridiculous stories that make no sense.
4
u/ContinuumGuy Long Live The Fastest Man Alive Jan 27 '17
Y'know, the punch actually does make a certain amount of sense when you consider that Black Siren probably never had to learn how to truly fight because she probably grew dependent on the metahuman gift, unlike E1 Laurel who first didn't have powers.
I mean, that doesn't make the punch right, but it does make a certain amount of sense.
4
u/domrayn Jan 27 '17
Unlike zoom who is OP'ed as f. There is no suspense in finding out the identity of prometheus (guessing it's some guy in the flashbacks). Does Prometheus watch legends of tomorrow on his breaks? There is no way he would be knowledgeable enough to sell a story that would fool oliver.
4
u/crushcastles23 Jan 28 '17
Well, at least this episode finally kills the Adrian Chase is Prometheus theory.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '17
..They're giving us a fourth (Black) Canary (Siren)? Honestly I was happy with Sara. Still am.
4
u/Isketam Jan 28 '17
Watching E2 Laurel with nose piercing kinda feel cringey, a half assed attempt to make Black Siren look badass?
13
u/DarkSaiyanKnight Jan 26 '17
so lets get this straight so they want a new BC but ignore a perfectly set up redemption arc for another new cringey recruit
10
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
Even not-Laurel gets shit on by Felicity. Useless Curtis shuts down her cry and then she gets 1 punch KO'd by Felicity? Wtf!?!
7
u/samsaBEAR Black Canary (Laurel Lance) Jan 26 '17 edited Jan 26 '17
I'm personally fine with Black Siren having a slow redemption and I still hope that's the case, I really do think her speech with Oliver while she was locked up came from her heart rather than her acting.
What continues to piss me off is how the higher ups at DC/Warner are allowing Guggenheim, and by extension The CW, to destroy the legacy of one of their strongest female characters just because there are a subsection of fans that really do see this as the Oliver and Felicity Relationship Show, and not a show about Green Arrow.
Imagine if Justice League this year kills off WW and replaces her with someone with the exact same powerset, there would be a fucking uproar. I'm done with Guggenheim because he's a fucking hack and it's to be expected from him, but not from DC themselves.
6
u/PhenomsServant Jan 26 '17
Seriously. Why has Katie sued these assholes? She was never given what they promised her, they kill her off for the sole reason being that she was a threat to a bunch of fantards' fantasies, she's been cyberbullied by said fantards. These people need to pay.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
Seriously fuck this show. Fefe punched a powerful meta human and she went down... Just like that? What's fefe's superpower? Organic shitstrength?
Fuck Gugg's hard in the ass.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
The thing I hate the most about this episode is that Oliver WAS reaching Black Siren... until Felicity opened her GODDAMNED MOUTH. And that's not even counting the fact she undermined him, what, three times? Four?
When Oliver asked for the room, I actually sat forward, excited to see him FINALLY tear her a new one. But NOOO, he was WORRIED about her putting her LIFE on the line. Oliver QUeen has NO FUCKING BALLS.
I loved Oliver and Black SIren and every time they got interrupted I wanted to scream.
Funny thing: Black Siren can bring down buildings. Humans are far more vulnerable. So I am betting she was lashing out because of what Felicity said, and if you think about it, Felicity is the ONLY one she wanted to actually kill. Everyone else? She just put them out of the fight.
6
u/xipheon Jan 27 '17
Yikes, a lot of hate for what I thought was a really good episode. This was the first time I felt Felicity was justified in her actions and well written. Oliver wasn't the usual wounded puppy letting the abusive woman talk down to him, they had a real argument where they discussed their opinions.
I'm still on alert for any of the old felicity bullshit but I'm very happy with how she was in this episode. She had a smart plan with the water, she didn't Mary Sue and save the day, and her skepticism of Laurel was justified right away and carried throughout the entire episode while Oliver played the opposite side choosing to believe in Laurel.
8
u/LocoComa Jan 26 '17
That episode just left me numb inside.
Just... goddamnit.
3
u/1033149 The Punisher Jan 26 '17
I'll say this. It does not compare to the mid-season finale. But it was good. They planted a seed so that Black Siren can return when Katie Cassidy's schedule opens back up. Felicity's arc was pretty dumb in my opinion but it worked for the story. I was slightly pissed off that Felicity punched Laurel but I'm pretty sure Felicity has permanent ear damage now so the scales are kind of balanced. Flashback stuff was cool. Diggle arc was cool. Not the best episode ever but got me back in. But the promo for next episode has me hyped. Oliver trying to honor Laurel's legacy and failing looks to be the right set up for BS to come back in.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
I just want Laurel to have a part in the show but like Amell said, "You can't always get what you want", I guess it goes both ways :/
3
u/peanutbutteroreos Jan 26 '17
Talia = Prometheus.
3
u/CopperCactus Still unsure about what game we played Jan 26 '17
So... let me get this straight, Black Siren, who brunted several hits from the flash at several hundred m/h, got knocked out in one normal speed punch from Felicity? Why am I not surprised
3
u/ChaosMagician777 Prometheus Jan 26 '17
This episode sucked cock. I went to the episode expecting awesomeness. Everything the episode featured had potential that was wasted for another Canary. Another Canary that would suck like Evelyn trying to become one last season. Guggy, you can't turn every main female character into the Black Canary. This episode gets a D. I am still sticking around. I survived Season 4.
3
u/ChaosMagician777 Prometheus Jan 26 '17
Damn I have not been so angry at DC since Suicide Squad. At least I will still watch the show. I made it this far.
3
u/laughinglord Jan 26 '17
This episode felt like a step back. Or maybe few steps back. They teased us something and went all 180. The promos from next episode as well.
3
u/is-an-ant Jan 26 '17
Soo.. basically fuck everything even remotely related to Black Canary, right?
3
u/WadeTheWilson Jan 26 '17
I have never once ACTUALLY hated Felicity until the end of this episode. That punch, solidified that instead of fixing their mistakes, and bringing back a great character, they decided to ruin TWO characters and double down on the bad. I've never stopped watching these shit CW shows yet, but I may have to actually give up on this slog.
3
u/TheChrisDV Evil Sexy Laurel Jan 26 '17
Do I need to change my flair?
-Reads discussion thread for 5x10-
Guess not.
3
u/Lym2222 Arsenal Jan 26 '17
Ehhh, it was okay... I was disappointed by a lot of things, but I think they can be fixed in a short span of episodes. I just want to know HOW THE FUCK Zoom's lieutenant was scared of Prometheus and how Felicity or Oliver survive a scream that could shatter buildings.
IMO this episode can be redeemed as long as they do Black Siren redemption arc. Hopefully they didn't bring her back just for one episode to have Felicity punch her.
Other than that, Prometheus fight scene was great, Chase and Diggle plotline was really interesting, Curtis seems to have found his place on the team and the new Black Canary doesn't seem too bad?pleasedon'tmakeherBCthanks.
Also: Talia seems awesome.
3
u/melonwoo Jan 26 '17
I am definitely more frustrated at Felicity undermining Oliver's authority. She literally could've gotten them all killed because she (not in the field and thus not in the danger zone) made a stupid assumption. Dig would've never done this, neither would've Laurel/Roy/Thea back in the day. Who does dis bitch think she is??? I'm 200% for strong female characters, but this ain't strength - this is arrogance and acting impulsively. I can't believe Oliver didn't chew her out more. Just because she's a lady or because they used to sleep together? Give me a damn break. Feminism/equality means you should be able to shit on a girl just as hard as you shit on a guy. And this is coming from a female feminist btw. Ugh, this show. shakes fist
3
u/sharkweek247 Jan 27 '17
If I could never see Laurel again I'd be so happy
3
u/DullBlade0 Nyssa al Ghul (Hooded) Jan 27 '17
Ok. They have to explain WTF is up with Prometheus.
My biggest complaints of this episode are:
3
u/Gdeathe Jan 27 '17
Any chance of Damian Queen being the new red arrow
3
u/TienNhan Jan 27 '17
The only GREAT part was Black Siren destroying that shitty fucking chocolate statue
3
u/thatoneguy889 Jan 27 '17
I'm really liking this trend of mysteries and drama getting solved in one or two episodes rather than getting dragged out over an entire season.
3
u/gotoucanario Jan 28 '17
And we are back to terrible (xcept for Adrian Chase)... Some higher up has a real hard on for felicity, I just wish he didn't have to ruin the whole show for it.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17
This episode started what has been an otherwise great season down a dark path.
Thus far, Felicity has been repeatedly put in her place and her role in the plot was greatly reduced, along with her abilities being severely nerfed. Consequently, the season has become about Oliver again and fans rejoiced.
But, in this episode, they channeled some of S4 with Felicity being a jealous irrational bitch who jumped the chain of command, and Oliver just letting it happen. They also trashed Laurel's legacy by pulling a huge bait-and-switch, then offering the prospect of redemption for Black Siren and yanking it away with "haha just kidding, I was evil the whole time." Also they severely nerfed her abilities (Remember S2 Flash, where Black Siren nearly killed Barry and he was bleeding out of his ears?) and then the cherry on top was having FeFe knock her out with a single punch.
Not a good sign at all. Not a good way to begin the second half of the season. They better get this shit in line quickly because if the next few episodes continue to feature S4 Fefe I will just tune out and not bother with the rest.
9
u/OLKv3 Jan 26 '17
Felicity wasn't bad this episode. I feel like people are so burned by the last 2 seasons that they just hate everything about her regardless if it fits the plot or not. Oliver has ALWAYS had blinders when it came to damaged women he believes he can save. Felicity made great points and was mostly behaving like Oliver usually does when he's not distracted by a Huntress or Evil Laurel or some woman he believe he could save
Also, weird how some parts of the spoiler posted here were correct but a lot of it wasn't.
5
u/LeakeeReigns Jan 26 '17
I think I can punch a trained fighter and knock them out. right?
5
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '17
I don't want to be a circle jerking diva and write off the rest of the season, but it just seems like the writers refused to listen to a pretty big portion of the fans. Credit to them for having some great ideas and delivering some fun moments; I still think there were a lot of moments in the ep that were awesome, but damn I just feel so sour now.
5
u/Davidleilam Green Arrow (Unmasked) Jan 26 '17
How about the fact that Black Siren's screams didn't shatter Felicity's glasses after attacking her multiple times
8
u/seanmac46 Laurel Lance always lives on Jan 26 '17
First off I was optimistic about Tina now I'm not she seems terrible but they are still teasing a black siren redemption arc and fuck that felicity punching black siren bull shit