r/fairytail • u/AstonishingSpiderMan Gramps • Apr 27 '17
Mod Post [Mod Post] Reddit Changes | Thoughts & How it'll affect /r/fairytail
Hi everyone, I have been asked and will continue to be asked about Reddit's changes that are incoming. I WILL PROVIDE MY OWN PERSONAL OPINION. Why? I'm the one who does most of the changes. Below is the following:
- Chapter 777: /r/FairyTail's Love for CSS
- Initial Reaction
- Reaction: Follow Up
Chapter 777: /r/FairyTail's Love for CSS
As mentioned above the following is my view on our love for CSS. So when I became a moderator the CSS:
- This is the look of the subreddit before March 2016
- This is how it looked in 2016
- To see how we look now, just use a non-mobile browser.
- To see how the subreddit looked before at any point click here
- Personally, the Christmas one last year with the snow effect was one of my favorites.
This subreddit is very dependent on the CSS and the way it looks. We are constantly making sure we don't over do it in the front page. Which is why worked on removing flairs from the front page to reducing the size of them. So what exactly in the subreddit is a result of the CSS:
- The Overall Look of the Web Page. May Vary from screen to screen.
- The Red Crimson Color Scheme
- Spoilers and Tagging them
- Means we can color code spoilers manga is red, preview is black.
- The Side Bar, this includes:
- Renaming the Users Online/Subscribers
- Side Bar Image
- Character Side Tabs 1. Guidelines, Sticky Threads, Resources, etc..
- Hiding Spoilers & Tweeting Mashima
- Above the User/Sticky Threads
- The Scrolling Banner
- Choose your theme 1. 3 Selections Available: Chibi, FT, Spriggan (Manga Villains)
- Weekly & Mod Thread Display 1. Depending on Screen Size you can get 3 to 5.
- Announcement Bar 1. Where, you know, we make announcements.
- Snoo & Logo
- User Bar 1. Let's us change the color scheme, the displayed pages (hot, new, etc...)
- The Submit Page
- Includes the Background Image
- The Color Scheme
- How the page actually looks.
- Bottom Aspect of the Page
- Bottom Image
- Scroll Bar 1. Click here to get to the top of the page or any page that it lets you.
- Submission Display
- The Color Scheme to the Link Flair.
- The Color Scheme on the left hand side of each thread.
- The Submission Thumbnail
- The over 250 User Flairs we have
- 253 to be exact. One of the Flair is in the mod/heavy contributor flair sheet. 1. That's a lot of fucking flairs. More to come
hopefullySeries 3 of Fairy Tail. - This does not include the moderator or heavy contributor flairs.
- Flair: Part I
- Flair: Part II
- Flair: Part III
- Flair: Part IV
So, what does this mean? It means we love our fucking CSS. It means I love the changes we have done, to help make the subreddit accessible and very much oriented into looking adorable like Best Girl Lucy. It means that I will continue trying, along with the other moderators, the hardest possible to make sure we look amazing and the users have a great experience on here. So yes, in case you weren't aware
Initial Reaction | No CSS in the Future
Custom community styles are a key component in allowing communities to express their identity, and we want to preserve this in the site redesign. For a long time, we’ve used CSS as the mechanism for subreddit customization, but we’ll be deprecating CSS during the redesign in favor of a new system over the coming months.
- This is fucking stupid. Like stupider than a certain wizard in Chapter
- shameless plug see the rant thread I did
While CSS has provided a wonderful creative canvas to many communities, it is not without flaws:
- It’s web-only. Increasing users are viewing Reddit on mobile (over 50%), where CSS is not supported. We’d love for you to be able to bring your spice to phones as well.
Then why not just bring those features to mobile instead of just some bumass banner and snoo?
- CSS is a pain in the ass: it’s difficult to learn; it’s error-prone; and it’s time consuming.
Yes, it is a pain in the ass. No, it's not difficult to learn this is the most bullshit thing I've seen so far.
- Some changes cause confusion (such as changing the subscription numbers).
- CSS causes us to move slow. We’d like to make changes more quickly. You’ve asked us to improve things, and one of the things that slows us down is the risk of breaking subreddit CSS (and third-party mod tools).
Why fix what's not broken? Why not ask for actual mod feedback instead of saying yeah, this is going to happen. Deal with it.
We’re designing a new set of tools to address the challenges with CSS but continue to allow communities to express their identities. These tools will allow moderators to select customization options for key areas of their subreddit across platforms. For example, header images and flair colors will be rendered correctly on desktop and mobile.
Sounds like more bullshit that I'm not buying in any capacity.
We know great things happen when we give users as much flexibility as possible. The menu of options we’ll provide for customization is still being determined. Our starting point is to replicate as many of the existing uses that already exist, and to expand beyond as we evolve.
See above.
We will also natively supporting a lot of the functionality that subreddits currently build into the sidebar via a widget system. For instance, a calendar widget will allow subreddits to easily display upcoming events. We’d like this feature and many like it to be accessible to all communities.
Oh that's great, oh wait i can already add a calendar via css and even have it displayed on the side bar. Oh...
How are we going to get there? We’ll be working closely with as many of you as possible to design these features. The process will span the next few months. We have a lot of ideas already and are hoping you’ll help us add and refine even more. The transition isn’t going to be easy for everyone, so we’ll assist communities that want help (i.e. we’ll do it for you).
How about you just don't do it.
Reaction: Follow Up
I have many thoughts on the matter, I'm still baffled and amazed at the level of stupidity shown by the Admins. I simply just don't get it, why on God's Green Earth would you change from CSS when majority over 90% of all websites use CSS. Look at all the subreddit you (users reading this) visit, look how amazing they look. Do you really think going away from that is the best thing? Now let's talk about this claim that CSS is so hard. What's so hard about it exactly? There are dedicated subreddits where users are willing to help you with any issue you have. Why remove our/ or any a subreddit's personality and style just to give us some half ass basic features? Now, yes I should give them the benefit of the doubt. I won't, for the simple reason this change isn't needed and is just in my opinion being done to pander to the mobile/app only users. How hard is it to open up the web page on a smart phone or any phone post 2010? To those who believe it isn't just to pander to mobile or the app it has out for it reassess the situation. It literally says GET REDDIT MOBILE when I open the web page on my smart phone. They also mention in the thread about how more mobile users currently than before. So they want to make sure they are pandered to. Now how will this ultimately affect this subreddit. All the spoilers in threads of the past will be revealed when this change occurs, which I guarantee will be during Fall 2017. All the fun changes and content we've had on reddit will be replaced. I will promise you this, regardless of how laughably basic these features are you can best believe I'll find a way to try and make this subreddit look as kawaii as it looks now.
The main problem I have is that Reddit seems to think it's a social media the likes of Facebook, MySpace, Twitter. It's not. It should really stop trying to be that, you're not that. Cut the bullshit and just be what you are. Be happy with the model you currently have. Now, again I'm sure people think I'm speaking out my ass but let's take a look. Oh, reddit user profiles what are they exactly?
What is it?
A new profile page experience that allows you to follow other redditors Selected redditors will be able to post directly to their profile. We worked with some moderators to pick a handful of redditors to test this feature and will slowly roll this out to more users over the next few months.
Who is this for?
We want to build this feature for all users but we’re starting with a small group of alpha testers.
How does it work?
You will start to see some user profile pages with new designs.
If you like what they post, you can start to follow them, much as you subscribe to communities. This does not impact our “friends” feature.
You can comment on their profile posts
Once you follow a user, their profile posts will start to show up on your front-page. Posts they make in communities will only show up on your frontpage if you subscribe to that community.
I hope this answers the stance this subreddit has on this whole issue. The other mods, agree with me that this change is bogus but they aren't as hotheaded or as annoyed as I am. Which is understandable and I can appreciate. So yes, I personally am all for /r/ProCSS I think it's a worthy cause, just look how much of CSS we use. I'll END with this, I just don't get it Reddit and I don't think I ever will. I have never been a fan of pandering to anyone and this very much seems like you're pandering to mobile/reddit app users. It means you will ignore and disregard to the non mobile/reddit app users regardless whether you'd like to admit it or not. You are a great platform, you are able to deliver so much content to various locations, unify people in their common interest. So why are you trying your hardest to go away from what you are and have been? To quote the Director of Marvel's The Avengers, Joss Whedon:
9
u/ChronoDeus Apr 27 '17
I'm surprised how angry I am about the CSS thing. What the admin propose is completely ridiculous to put it mildly.
•
u/AstonishingSpiderMan Gramps Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Side Note: GOLDEN WEEK FESTIVITIES BEGIN APRIL 29 EST!
4
u/WithYouInSpirit99 Apr 27 '17
I can't say I agree with you on much but this is 100% correct. The Admins are about to wipe away 11 years of our hard work... CSS is too hard they say... It's bullshit. Sorry for anyone who's offended but I can't find enough places to vent :(((
4
u/TeamAcno Apr 27 '17
The amount of salt over this is just delicious. So much salt everywhere! People all across reddit are up in arms, and I'm just sitting here thinking that it could end up being an amazing idea.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
I use reddit on my mobile a lot. But the reason for that is, I read a lot of stuff while on the commute to work. What this means is I don't need the fancy stuff I am already using the pure basics because that's all I need. I guarentee that's what a lot of people using reddit are doing, they got the app (because their mobile website essentially forced you too) so they can read and comment on the go.
People using it on mobile I highly doubt care about all the stuff the admins are saying and aren't wanting to be pandered too. Just because numbers say more users are using mobile doesn't mean anything unless you know WHY they are using it, if they surveyed people I feel it would be safe to say most who say they use the mobile app is because it's good for on the go and can use it on the shitter. As long as I can comment and read comments on my mobile I'm all good.
Seems like the admins saw this big increase and were like oh shit we better make sure it works well for these users as they are the majority now. When that majority likely couldn't care less, and are just happy to have something to check out while waiting for the bus. Definitely not something that needs such an overhaul that could possibly create more problems than it solves.
4
u/twx_95 Apr 27 '17
You go, Spidey/Natsu!
2
u/11thDoctr Apr 28 '17
No CSS? Guess I'm out of a job then