r/ProjectRunway • • Sep 08 '17

Project Runway Season 16 Episode 4 [Critique]

Below are images showing the different looks from this episode. Upvote if you like something, downvote if you hate it, or novote if it's just OK. Reply beneath the image to add your comments.

 

Orginally broadcast on September 7, 2017

29 Upvotes

375 comments sorted by

267

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

60

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

I had her pegged to be in the top this week, and I really did love this. I was surprised it was just safe. The back is smashing.

20

u/danny2787 Sep 11 '17

It's nice, but doesn't look 'Heidi' enough to me. Which is why Heidi challenges don't work well.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/sabia_sings_at_night Sep 10 '17

Absolutely! It's a gorgeous total look and I would have bought all three pieces in a heartbeat. Lounge in style! It would have been reasonably simple for Heidi to mass produce as well, given that Samantha used the same two colours for all three garments. Really surprised she wasn't in the top.

50

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

Looked the most modern and comfortable to me, how many women wear satin-y nighties to bed anymore?

15

u/_Pliny_ Sep 08 '17

Loved hers. It reminded me of the Modan Gaaru (Modern girls- basically flappers in 1920s) Japan. There was a pajama streetwear look. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_girl#/media/File%3AKagayama_mogas.jpg

6

u/HelperBot_ Sep 08 '17

Non-Mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_girl#/media/File%3AKagayama_mogas.jpg


HelperBot v1.1 /r/HelperBot_ I am a bot. Please message /u/swim1929 with any feedback and/or hate. Counter: 109443

12

u/Tina-Slay Sep 08 '17

This is cool.

12

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

I really loved this, and I'm glad to see she can make something besides a ballerina circle skirt.

42

u/TheKneesOfOurBees Sep 08 '17

IDK why but it kinda looks like something a mobster would wear on a vacation to Greece.

13

u/coconutnutcream Sep 08 '17

That made me laugh! very cool mobster with good taste!

6

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

This is something I would have never thought of on my own but now that you have said it, I know exactly what you mean! I 100% agree.

5

u/Hefaes Sep 09 '17

exactly the colours and the flow scream Greece

10

u/Jay-of-the-days Sep 09 '17

Very surprised this wasnt in the top

7

u/projectfunway Sep 08 '17

I would so wear this everywhere.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

i loved this and i thought it was way better than most of the other sleepwear looks

7

u/Zoethor2 Sep 08 '17

I loved this and it was the one look where I thought "I would maybe buy that." And since I am not terribly fashionable, particularly regarding sleepwear, that probably should've been my first hint it wouldn't be in the top. :)

4

u/Holly_Tyler Sep 11 '17

Lol thats a good point! I want those pants! But, I'm not so fashion forward in my own wardrobe either...

6

u/shinyteerex Sep 08 '17

I love it, but doesn't it looks almost too wearable outdoors?

17

u/Toke27 Sep 08 '17

Well Shawn's look was even more wearable outdoors and they loved that. I thought this was far superior. Samantha should have been in the top with Michael and Kentaro.

5

u/polkadotsrule Sep 08 '17

Love this one, looks like something Phryne would wear in Miss Fisher's

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

This was the only one I actually wanted to wear. I would buy this one.

4

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

OMG I want this SO bad!!! Michael's was great too, but I'm much more of a pants-sleeper than dress-sleeper. I loved all of these details, this is what the average woman would want, I think!

3

u/macabragoria Sep 08 '17

I would have expected her to make some frilly vintage negligee thing, this is actually kind of cool and unexpected.

3

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Sep 09 '17

Should have won

3

u/sarelai Sep 09 '17

THIS WAS THE BEST ONE

2

u/deftones518 Sep 08 '17

It's pretty but it's not casual

→ More replies (10)

243

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

50

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

I really liked this for how wearable it is for a wide variety of bodies. It's not particularly innovative, but it's very appealing and it looks comfortable. I loved the way he finished the neckline.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

i wanted this look to win because it looks really comfortable and the print is pretty, but michael's was a couple of steps ahead of kentaro design wise

17

u/sugarplumcow Sep 08 '17

I absolutely love this, but I think it would be a better dress than lingerie. I think this would be an absolutely stunning dress that I would want to wear and own every. single. day. I just wouldn't want to sleep in it. Still a big Kentaro fan! He is lovely. <3

4

u/SoMuchMoreEagle Sep 10 '17

I agree. It doesn't look like a nightgown. Lovely dress, though.

16

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

I really like the scalloped neckline but it felt like there was just so much extra fabric and unnecessary volume and length in the skirt. It made it read a bit too daytime.

50

u/throwawayacct472727 Sep 08 '17

This one was nice, but I feel like this sub wouldn't have loved it nearly as much as they did if it were made by anyone but Kentaro.

7

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

I absolutely love this look. The colour palette is divine and fits the feminine silhouette.

However, I see this more as a ready-to-wear dress if it was made in a more daytime-suitable fabric. This as a sundress with slightly thicker shoulder straps, would sell like hotcakes during summer.

18

u/Tina-Slay Sep 08 '17

I love Kentaro, but I actually didn't like this. At all.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

I love Kentaro, but this print looked really sloppy to me (granted, he made it in less than 2 hours ---- ps how did this dry???). I do love the dip-dye of this, but I'm not super crazy about it as a whole. I don't really get how the print and dye-job go together. The scalloping is nice, and I get that it's a ton of work, but it just sort of folded over on itself, which I didn't find super appealing. But, I think that's the thing with sleepwear, it's silk and folds over, so, yeah.

4

u/Hefaes Sep 09 '17

not my taste but I understand it and I'm glad he pulled it through

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

I really loved this, but from a practical standpoint for pj's, I feel like there's to much fabric in the bottom, and the defined waist wouldn't be comfortable for sleeping. But as a dress, it was beautiful.

13

u/PadishahEmperor Sep 08 '17

Should have won.

17

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

I wanted it to win because I wanted to buy it, but I thought it was pretty obvious that Michael's would win. It's definitely more unique, which would make it a standout piece for Heidi's collection. Plus, his is way more mass producible.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

235

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

58

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

I like it, it's just that those straps around the neck seem highly uncomfortable for sleep wear.

19

u/nancyaw Sep 09 '17

Agreed. And how do you get them on? They go over your head? Tie? I think this would be a gorgeous gown for not just the bedroom.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/themaknae Sep 09 '17

I agree, especially because they complained about the neckline of Aaron's.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/Tina-Slay Sep 08 '17

No question this was the best. The rose color is exquisite, the patterning is smartly placed and equally beautiful, and the cut of it all is divine.

13

u/Pheelibert Sep 09 '17

I simply loved that nightgown as well. I am actually surprised that the design on the hips got taken away for production though...https://www.heidiklumintimates.com/deco-doll-slip-chemise

21

u/maryloo7877 Sep 09 '17

$200???? This is for sleeping...

14

u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Sep 09 '17

Oh wow, I do not like the adaptation for mass production.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/CrumbsInMyBed Sep 08 '17

I feel he was so smart to have the hair and makeup resemble the Art Deco era to match his dress. IMO it made his look pop more and sealed his fate as a winner.

22

u/shinyteerex Sep 08 '17

Heidi should've just stood up and say: "No need for deliberation, Michael is the clear winner"

15

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

i don't like the neckline but besides that everything is so effortless and chic. i love his sexuality bending aesthetic too and i hope he goes far.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

The back was exquisite but something seemed a little off on the front.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

I feel the center straps were too high

18

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

It was obvious that this would win, but I would never want to sleep in it. I'm pretty sure I'd end up half strangled from that neck strap.

7

u/throwawayacct472727 Sep 08 '17

Love Michael, love this. The clear winner for me.

7

u/macabragoria Sep 08 '17

All the entries this week were a little rough around the edges due to the conditions of the challenge but this one will definitely look the best when actually put into production and not hastily thrown together out of hand-painted silk in a day.

6

u/Pineapplesmores Sep 09 '17

I think it's beautiful but the neck doesn't look too comfortable to me. I move a lot when I sleep and I feel I'd wake up in the middle of the night being strangled by the neck thing. But if I was classy sleeper I'd wear it.

5

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

One of or maybe the best look/s on the runway. Interesting neckline and textile treatment.

4

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Sep 09 '17

nothing special really

7

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

Easily the winner. So effortless yet so clearly inspired by art deco.

3

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

Incredibly elegant and by far the best look this week. Hopefully we will see more of him in the coming weeks.

→ More replies (3)

159

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

105

u/shinyteerex Sep 08 '17

I feel so bad about actually liking this. However, just like everyone else, I'm pissed about the fact that she didn't do this all by herself.

45

u/DLMeyer Sep 08 '17

This looked very pretty, but how much of the design was actually hers? The judges said themselves that they were shocked it was her look and I think it's because it WASN'T. I would've been pissed if I was one of the designers and she'd won the challenge. I'm also annoyed that they ripped Kenya for the lack of practicality in her design but completely blew past it in Shawn's.

11

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 08 '17

If she had won I imagine we'd get 9 people yelling about how she didn't make it alone and maybe they should play fair for once. In shocked she didn't get called out on the runway when she made the top three.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

Very pretty. Perfect color and great proportions. You're lucky your sister helped you, Shawn.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

so for a red carpet look shawn makes shorts and a shirt that you can probably take off in minutes but for sleepwear she makes this convoluted mess? interesting

22

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

As irritable as I find her, this was honestly my favorite

48

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

It's quite pretty, but it's not very practical for sleepwear. I was really annoyed that they called Kenya out on "how to pee" in a romper but said nothing about Shawn's jumpsuit. Heidi even told her in the workroom that it wasn't workable and she did nothing!

28

u/blurrylulu Sep 08 '17

Exactly. This felt like producer manipulation. Heidi said in the workroom that a jumper wasn't practical and yet they love it at judging? It's gorgeous (I hate myself for saying that bc I loathe Shawn) but as sleepwear it did not meet the challenge. Who the F is wearing a jumpsuit to bed? No one.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

Yeah, the judging here was inconsistent

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

I like it, but is it not almost the same design as last week?

16

u/CrumbsInMyBed Sep 08 '17

Shocker- another long ribbon/sash from Shawn.

13

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

This time it is thoughtful and really nice looking, though!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

The pattern is very pretty, but as sleepwear a jumpsuit is just not practical at all. She should have just made the look as separates and it would have easily solved the issue.

3

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

This was actually one of my favorites. Elegeant and pretty well tailored, though the pants look like they could use a quick steam.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

I almost didn't up vote because I dislike the Nose Ring Twins so much, but I have to give respect where it's due....even if I am salty AF about it.

2

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

I hate that I love this! It is so cute, but definitely not sleepwear. I don't get how you'd sleep in this, but that PRINT matched with that SASH!!! ugh. I wouldn't wear this to bed, but I'd sure as shit wear this to a party!

2

u/sarelai Sep 09 '17

We are learning a real important life lesson from the twins: people who's personalities suck can still do beautiful work.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

Had this won, it probably could have been made as a two-piece set, with an elastic waist pant covered by the sash. I'm thinking that's why it wasn't called out for impracticality.

→ More replies (3)

136

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

75

u/no_shant Sep 08 '17

The top sits a little too low which means one's boobies would be at too much risk of escaping (the straps need to be shorter), but overall this is actually rather pretty.

20

u/blurrylulu Sep 08 '17

Agree. The color/print and overall feel of this is stunning and romantic, but my boobs would be spilling out of this in .009 seconds and bc of that, I would never wear it. Even on her slim model, it was way too much skin on top.

31

u/CrumbsInMyBed Sep 08 '17

I have mixed feelings about this one. I go back and forth between criticizing the non-functionality of it and enjoying the look from a runway perspective.

Functionally, I feel claustrophobic just THINKING about trying to sleep in this- my boobs would be completely out of it as soon as I lied down and I would probably wake up tied inside of a satiny knot of a dress.

Model wore it beautifully though and I respect the artistry of the look.

22

u/FKAnugs91 Sep 08 '17

This is a night gown I see thrown on the floor before the nights over, then gets put on and thrown back on the floor in the morning, i give it a toot

8

u/nancyaw Sep 09 '17

I can see a boob making a run for it and getting caught between the fabric and the strap while I wake up confused at 4:25 AM wondering why my boob feels like it's being strangled.

7

u/throwawayacct472727 Sep 08 '17

My boobs probably wouldn't stay in this but I'd probably wear it anyway tbh

6

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

she deserved to be safe. it isn't horrible but it's not great either

5

u/sarelai Sep 09 '17

It's so boring. The paint is sad. She did so little and the hem is still shoddy.

4

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

I think that color is very tricky but I just love the way this looks and moves.

4

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

I love the impact of it but her breasts would fall out instantly. I'm also not crazy about the print, but love the color.

4

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

Really did not care for this print, but the style of dress for sleeping is something that I could really get behind. Nice and flow-y, it seems like it would be easy to sleep in.

3

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 08 '17

It looks like her nipples are bleeding.

5

u/shinyteerex Sep 08 '17

She got barely no screentime this time around. Mixed feelings about it, and I almost thought this was going to be at the bottom =/

10

u/PM_ME_DOGS_IN_SOCKS Sep 08 '17

She and Brandon didn't even get a critique segment -_-

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

I liked this. It just wasn't a WOW.

2

u/Rachey56 Sep 09 '17

Not a fan of wearing boob tape to bed so it's a no from me

→ More replies (4)

67

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

57

u/FKAnugs91 Sep 08 '17

Design is bleh, but this looks soooo expensive, toot

13

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

what's with you and toots!??! What's it mean? :)

24

u/Hefaes Sep 09 '17

this meme is for my gurls, my RPDR gurls

→ More replies (1)

29

u/themaknae Sep 09 '17

It's from the Fashion Photo Ruview series on youtube, where two famous drag queens who also appeared on Rupaul's Drag Race (Raja and Raven) discuss contestants' looks. if it's good, toot; if it's ugly, boot. They're really fun to watch, even if you don't like Drag Race!

13

u/chillaxicon Sep 11 '17

This looks like what a rich person on a Shonda TV drama would wear when they find out their husband's been murdered in the middle of the night.

10

u/FKAnugs91 Sep 11 '17

Bish yas, this has Viola Davis/Kerry Washington sprinting down a staircase written all over it. I give this comment a 2 toots.

50

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

Boring design, gorgeous colors and fabric

19

u/Tina-Slay Sep 08 '17

Gorgeous colors.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

i don't even remember this coming down the runway and i've watched this episode twice

18

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

It's good bed attire because boy did this put me to sleep.

5

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

this is something that I would actually wear to bed, I think I already have this. It looks so comfy, and doesn't push the envelope that much, but I still really like it

5

u/HBHT9 Sep 09 '17

Safe is exactly where it should have been.

4

u/FishnetSinner Sep 08 '17

Love the colors. The design is very 'meh' for me.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

BORING!

2

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Sep 09 '17

Lordt. Does this girl like cloth or what.

2

u/SoMuchMoreEagle Sep 10 '17

It needs something under, like a tank top or something. Who wants to sleep in a robe?

2

u/trickmind Team Bishme Sep 12 '17

Where is the pattern?

→ More replies (2)

41

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

82

u/Mimitori Sep 08 '17

What happened to "basically only her boobs are covered"? It looked a lot more revealing before the show. I don't dislike it, I just was very surprised by the finished look.

26

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

I wonder if part of Heidi's critique wasn't shown and she said something about the marketability of the design in the US. The sheer was definitely more interesting, but probably wouldn't sell well.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

If I remember correctly, the last time heidi klum had a "i'll add your outfit to my intimates collection" challenge, a super sexy-revealing piece one (i'm too lazy to google it!) so when i saw her critique i thought she might win - it looked pretty cool.

but i too am surprised by the end result, not as interesting looking.

43

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

the robe and the actual sleepwear don't really look great together. like i'm pretty sure if a sleepwear line like heidi's put this design into production the robe would not be sold with this look

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Tina-Slay Sep 08 '17

Looked a lot better in the workroom? Not a fan of those shorts.

6

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

What is on those shorts?? Kind of looks like a sand dollar. It's not enough to be able to tell what it is, though sand dollar PJ's would be cute :)

→ More replies (1)

22

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

This seemed overcomplicated to me, and the khaki color is just so utlitarian.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

The pink robe was completely superfluous. I like the rest though.

11

u/no_shant Sep 08 '17

I don't get the shorts. Plus it doesn't all seem to go together, although the shirt and gown separately are fab.

10

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

I actually really liked the shorts + shirt here, but HATED the robe. The robe doesn't go, and it just looks like it has stains on it, like I spilled my evening glass of wine on the bottom of it. The color of the shorts and shirt are really nice and I liked the color-blocking of it, that's attractive

7

u/DLMeyer Sep 08 '17

I hated the color. I also didn't really like the shape created. It didn't feel sexy to me. It's the first time I really disliked one of her looks, though, so hopefully next week will go better for her.

5

u/Hefaes Sep 09 '17

not a fan of the colour combo

4

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 08 '17

That top would get so bunched up as people rolled around in bed. The cover looks like a backwards snuggie.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/blurrylulu Sep 08 '17

I like the top, but the shorts are horrible and although the robe is well made and pretty, it doesn't go with the top/shorts. Ayana gets so much love on this sub, but she's very 'meh' to me so far.

4

u/ajkkjjk52 Sep 08 '17

Khaki? For intimates?

4

u/Pineapplesmores Sep 09 '17

This is such a muddled up look. The robe and pjs don't go together at all. I thought the top would be really cute as an actual top not pjs

7

u/CrumbsInMyBed Sep 08 '17

I really like this for some reason. It almost looks like street wear.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

Overdesigned. The multi-layered top and those art-project-ish shorts AND a floor-length robe? This looks like what a tamer Kudzanai would have came up with if he wasn't eliminated.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

88

u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 08 '17

Nina looks like she double fisted a muppet.

57

u/champagneflute Sep 08 '17

Zac looks like he's drunk at a wedding but trying to look sober for the photo.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/SoMuchMoreEagle Sep 10 '17

Seriously. For someone who works in the fashion industry, she wears some of the weirdestly ugly clothes.

Was it last week or the week before that she looked like she was attacked by a BeDazzler?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/DLMeyer Sep 08 '17

It was difficult to take anything Nina said seriously when she was wearing whatever the f&!@ that was supposed to be. Absolutely hideous.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

what the hell did nina put on her wrists

12

u/Zoethor2 Sep 08 '17

Oh my word, is that a CAT PRINT Demi is wearing? I now need that dress.

8

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

Nina looks like a Chinese restaurant hostess who tried to glue a piñata together for the first time for some kid's birthday party but failed.

6

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

Demi's subtle ombre is my new spirit hair.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

I don't know what has happened to Nina. I know she has young children. Are they dressing her now?

5

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

Nina, honey, no. Those blue sleeves with a really classy black top with red piping? Why!!

5

u/sabia_sings_at_night Sep 10 '17

I've seen that awful outfit on Sienna Miller before. I don't like it any better on Nina. It's Prada apparently. https://www.gofugyourself.com/what-the-fug-sienna-miller-in-prada-10-2016

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Hefaes Sep 09 '17

where's the muppets corpse Nina?

→ More replies (1)

23

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

57

u/puppetalk Sep 08 '17

another crop top?

45

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

Ashley's ghost continues to haunt us...

51

u/macabragoria Sep 08 '17

Does he know any colours other than "nicotine"?

14

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

Yeah they talked to Kentaro about his reliance on black, but I would love for them to say something about Brandon's use of this offwhite palette.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/TheLadyEve Sep 08 '17

It looks like he used the curtains from a octogenarian chainsmoker's house to make this outfit. Truly terrible, dingy look to it.

32

u/Tina-Slay Sep 08 '17

Pants are gorgeous, top is a little . . . gross colored. Would have been prettier in almost any other color.

7

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

Also it's the same top he's made a few times already.

7

u/Fake11Name Sep 08 '17

Isn't this the same design as his red carpet/camo look?

7

u/Pineapplesmores Sep 09 '17

I can't tell the difference between his pj look and his day clothes look

11

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

The top is hideous. It's a dingy, dishwater-colored, uneven-hemmed crop top. I wouldn't want my duvet cover to touch that, much less my partner.

11

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 08 '17

Another fucking crop top. Does this dude know fall and winter exist?

42

u/haikubot-1911 Sep 08 '17

Another fucking

Crop top. Does this dude know fall

And winter exist?

 

                  - blackbirdsongs


I'm a bot made by /u/Eight1911. I detect haiku.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DLMeyer Sep 08 '17

I didn't mind the silhouette but the color was NOT flattering.

3

u/ajkkjjk52 Sep 08 '17

I think it's pretty fashionable, but I can't imagine sleeping in a crop top would be comfortable.

3

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Sep 09 '17

Not ideal for sleepwear but I'm liking his aesthetic more and more, which surprises me.

3

u/Hefaes Sep 09 '17

not a fan of the colour

3

u/tyrelanas Sep 10 '17

My first reaction was that the top looks stained by pee...The pants are nice though!

5

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

Love the pants. The top is a bit messy and boring

4

u/Mimitori Sep 08 '17

There was one moment on the runway when the coloring and shadow made the pants look like she had a pretty bad menstrual accident and the stain didn't come out with the wash...

5

u/shinyteerex Sep 08 '17

Sleepwear? where?

2

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

Disappointing look from Brandon this week. The top looks like it's been left in a closet, accumulating dirt for decades. He could have made better use of his sporty aesthetic.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

It's not really looking sleepwear-ish.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '17

Can you imagine a final collection by this bitch? ugh, so boring!!! 12 pieces all made with lousy, off white fabric in oversized and crooked constructions. It's gonna be Jeezys all over again.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/runwaythreader Sep 08 '17

69

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

i'm surprised the other look got called out for being a hospital gown when this look existed??!! ironically this whole challenge was a snoozefest tbh

17

u/rowanbrierbrook Sep 08 '17

This at least had a print? Since part of the challenge was printmaking, that probably helped her. Also, while impractical, this was at least an attempt at a design, unlike Deyonte's.

→ More replies (3)

90

u/TheKneesOfOurBees Sep 08 '17 edited Sep 08 '17

Opening shot. A number of designers walk into an unfamiliar, well lit room with Tim Gunn and an unfamiliar lady standing in front of them.

Tim: Hello Designers!

Designers: Hi Tim!

Tim: Welcome to the 'name of hospital that agreed to actually pay Project Runway money'! Meet 'lady name', she is the head executive of this hospital.

Designer A, in confessional: Wow, I cannot believe we are actually in THE BEST hospital that has ever existed! I always wanted to go to this hospital!

Lady name, in a weird accent that seems to be a mix of midwestern and Belgian: Designers, in Hospital Name, we believe that style is not something you have to throw away when practicing medicine. Our Surgery rooms are fitted with vast closets for you to choose your outfits from while in surgery, and we are the first hospital to actually hire Style Nurses, who would help you in your healing journey.

Shot of designers nodding

Tim: Deigners, your challenge is to create a hospital gown for the everyday woman. It needs to be fashionable, comfortable, and it has to be able to be dressed down, or up, if needed.

Designer B, in confessional: I am actually very excited for this challenge, I love hospitals, and I feel like this is a challenge where I can shine!


Now if that had been the challenge, this would have been great. But it wasn't. So...

11

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

Laughcrying into my La Croix.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 08 '17

"You're beautiful," he murmured, stroking her soft, pale cheek.

Her heart thrummed as she reached for his muscular arms, smelling the scent of him: warm, like woods and leather.

"You're beautiful, too," she whispered.

He placed his arms around her waist, lifting her up onto the bed. Kissing her softly, hair, then face, then neck. Removing strap by strap -- "wait. Darling. I can't ... this thing doesn't come off ... can you ... no, try lifting it."

"Here, move over ... "

"No, I mean just like ... shimmy out of the bottom ... "

"I'm stuck on the waistband."

"What?"

"The waist thing is folded over ... here, wait, hold it ... stop ... if you pull the top, I can crawl out of it, I think."

"Ow!"

"Fuck, sorry, I didn't mean to kick you."

9

u/nancyaw Sep 09 '17

Brilliant! And also how sex really goes.

25

u/CrumbsInMyBed Sep 08 '17

This was hooooorrrible.

It immediately made me think of the Statue of Liberty, but in a hospital gown. That color and print choice was god awful.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 08 '17

That print looks like a fucking tire tread. She looks like she's been run over.

7

u/nancyaw Sep 09 '17

Hence the need for a hospital gown.

5

u/jelloisalive Sep 09 '17

Traffic victim in the ER

19

u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 08 '17

Amy has been underrated, but this was by far the worst shes done.. Still better than half of the other designers though

7

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

It's like a hospital gown mated with a sleeping bag. Just no.

14

u/shinyteerex Sep 08 '17

Isn't Amy being a little too underappreciated so far?

28

u/surgartits Sep 08 '17

I think overall she is being totally ignored, which either means she comes on like a house on fire at the end or gets booted in the next few weeks. Personally I really like her work, and I feel bad that she's being deployed by the editors as a Tim Gunn alternative.

10

u/the_cucumber Sep 08 '17

I find everything she does to be well made and executed, but I never quiiite like it. She seems to be making backward looking clothes to me. Like the trim on this nighty is very La Senza Girl 2001 chic to me. Nothing she does looks COOL. It's more like, cool techniques that make her looks interesting at least, but not something an It Girl would want to wear or a fashion blogger would hype.

10

u/puppetalk Sep 08 '17

no. it isn't practical enough, even though it's well made. this was very deserving of a safe position to me.

5

u/FKAnugs91 Sep 08 '17

Was thinking the whole episode "Amy hasn't had any screen time at all" then when I saw this walk out "ohhh..." love her and she's totally been under appreciated but this a big miss por moi

3

u/idontknowboutdat Sep 08 '17

"You're a mess, just standing!" - Michael Kors

Imagine sleeping in this mess and waking up looking even messier.

3

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 09 '17

I liked the print and the top half of this but the bottom half desperately needs some sexy. Short skirt? Wider slit in the skirt?

4

u/sabia_sings_at_night Sep 10 '17

Yup. Totally agree that a tweak to the design could have saved this. I like the slouchy relaxed look the top has at the front, but the back just feels so functional, and like a different garment. From the front it walked well.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '17

there is nothing edgy or cool or comfortable about this

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '17

J'adore the color and print on this.

2

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 09 '17

Hospital gown back. The entire back pisses me off, the sleeves are strangely uneven too.

→ More replies (5)