r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Sep 14 '17
Project Runway Season 16 Episode 5 [Discussion]
Descending Into Good and Evil
Drawing inspiration from the film "Descendants 2", the designers visit Lyndhurst Castle and are tasked with creating a look that represents good or evil.
Guests: Dove Cameron, China Anne McClain
Β
Orginally broadcast on September 14, 2017
46
Upvotes
342
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Margarita: I design for the real woman.
Also Margarita: I have a plus-sized girl and it's nerve-racking.
279
u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 15 '17
Aww Kentaro and Brandon showmance!!
260
u/icouldseeformiles Sep 15 '17
Could do without the "I'm concerned about my model's size" soundbite every week
257
u/Queenofsorry14 Sep 15 '17
Aaron..wtf!???!? His garment has to be record worst of ALL TIME
218
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Samantha's reaction to being in: /thumbs up
Claire's reaction to being in: "I'm not going to grovel..." /cue egotism, showing she's learned nothing, instead
210
u/propoexctedly Sep 14 '17
Two challenges in a row based on random kids movies that I haven't heard of. That is oddly specific.
202
u/cornfeeden Sep 15 '17
Brantaro screentime is giving me everything
193
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
"Just tryina make a dollar out of fifteen CENTS!"
Okay I finally have a favorite
186
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
NEXT WEEK IS THE CHEATING WEEK!!! fhsdkfjdskfjsdlfjs YAAASSSSSSSSSSSSSS
179
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Swatch is looking spry today. At the beginning of the season, he looked like he was at death's door.
176
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
"Claire. You're also in."
entire sub screams and starts actual riots
318
u/pinkfroshie Sep 15 '17
WHY IS LIRIS SAYING THANK YOU??? SHE DIDN'T MAKE THE DRESS.
147
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Not only are the twins insufferable, they're mean. Not like they have the resume to back it up either.
140
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
Why does Aaron always look like his clothes came from a granny's closet after someone has taken all the good stuff though
131
u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 15 '17
I think Brandon's aesthetic is cut up straightjackets
124
u/pizza_on_a_stick Sep 15 '17
Wow what Aaron sent down the runway was so unacceptable. How can it be so bad. They even had two days
121
u/pinkfroshie Sep 15 '17
Did anyone else see Swatch running up the Mood stairs? I wanna squeeze his cute lil butt
121
u/nerathefinder Sep 15 '17
For the twins to interview and trash everyone else's looks when they are sending hot steaming piles of poo down the runway is getting on my last nerve
99
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
Amy made last weeks pajamas!
98
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
...and it shows.
90
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
She can't make it past the first ten minutes without being annoying.
178
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
At the risk of rudeness, I always have viewed the model as the canvas and the outfit as the artwork. I don't really want the canvas's input on the artwork O.o
87
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
2017's aesthetic being 'straightjacket' is really fitting actually.
84
u/bad_wolff Sep 15 '17
Margarita is getting the kiss-of-death call home
82
u/esquire22 Sep 15 '17
Fun fact: the costume designer for Descendants 2 was none other than Kara Saun!
78
u/PaladinGodfather1931 Sep 15 '17
Daaaamn Batani! You go girl! That's a fierce look
77
u/insubordinance Sep 15 '17
Plot twist: The cheating scandal will actually be Brandon and Kentaro.
76
u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 15 '17
I feel sorry for Aaron's model. She has to hold up her wrapping paper dress with her armpits.
74
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
What a surprise.
73
u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 15 '17
I'm so glad Sam was saved. She isn't my fave but she deffo deserved to be in
140
u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 15 '17
Why does the model keep saying Thank You?!? She didn't design the dress.
134
u/litladyloveshp Sep 15 '17
Kenya and Michael were sooo robbed!
59
u/throwawayacct472727 Sep 15 '17
Today was a rare episode where I agreed with the Top 3 and Bottom 3, and I would've been happy seeing any of the top 3 win.
58
u/insubordinance Sep 15 '17
I don't understand this meltdown. She designs for real women but she's getting tripped up with a plus sized model? She's worried about not being avant-garde enough for a straight eveningwear challenge? Is this just Killer Fatigue or a muddled edit to cover up something else going on?
58
u/PaladinGodfather1931 Sep 15 '17
The day that one of the twins goes home is a day I rejoice with a tall glass of Pinot.
58
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
sees dead-streamer-laden dress
girl bye
if none of the judges get on this i hope they are all fired
58
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Claire, girl, you are delusional.
58
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Liris is talking about someone "showing her body" again.
52
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Claire, you picked the fabrics!
51
u/potatothief24 Sep 15 '17
"Cinderella on her day off" A BIPITTY BOPITTY BOO...
47
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
Look at Claire's stink eye to everyone
43
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
Wow Claire someone is self centered
43
u/Livermush Sep 15 '17
I love you mom,
but I'm going to say you look horrible on national TV.
I hate the twins
40
u/ashiguana Sep 15 '17
Kenya's getting some daggers from Claire.
39
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Good to see Swatch can still do the stairs!
37
u/TheLadyEve Sep 15 '17
I'm glad they like Kenya's look. I was a wee worried they would think it's too costumey, but I liked the look. That color borders on too severe but she picked a brown enough red that it works.
34
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
But now who's personal clothes will I make fun of
67
u/Livermush Sep 15 '17
What is Aaron wearing?!
this is a weekly horror
33
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17 edited Sep 15 '17
I seriously didn't recognize Claire without the Crayola fuchsia lipstick.
ETA: And she's not ugly sans lipstick. In that one workroom shot, she looked a lot like Top Chef/Cutthroat Kitchen's Antonia Lofaso, who is a very pretty woman. So why is she wearing that dreck?
32
u/TheLadyEve Sep 15 '17
Claire did the big old step-in briefs under a shower curtain skirt. Yaaaawn.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Okay I always kinda was like "eh she's not so bad" with Shawn- but Claire bugs the shit out of me
30
u/pinkfroshie Sep 15 '17
Brandon's model looks like she escaped from a mental hospital and is still wearing her straight jacket
30
u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 15 '17
I feel like they may send Sam home over Aaron and that will be the biggest travesty of the season
30
u/cornfeeden Sep 15 '17
When the season started I didn't think I would vibe with Samantha as much as I do now, I'm really glad she got saved
86
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
I don't think Brandon deserved that win.
29
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
"A limited edition capsule collection as part of the Project Runway line, sold at select JC Penney's stores." I never actually noticed this before but, wow, they don't have a lot of confidence in this season, do they?
27
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
NINA HAS A SPACEMAN ON HER DRESS.
25
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Jasmine has been put in some really bad clothing, hasn't she?
50
u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 15 '17
Aaron dead ass just sent down the same look that got Kudzanai eliminated
24
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
π
23
u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 15 '17
Claire's dress colors would scare off a unicorn!! It's like toddler play clothes.
22
u/TheLadyEve Sep 15 '17
I actually thought most of the looks this episode were pretty sub par. Overall, I found it disappointing. I expect a little more joy and macabre in a fairy tale themed challenge. I think some of our past competitors like Ari (Andy) South and Christian Siriano and Jay Sario and Austin Scarlet would have come up with some crazy good stuff. Austin might have gone too costumey, but I would still rather see what he would make for this challenge than most of the snoozefest this week.
43
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Margarita, if you design for "real women," part of that is realizing they come in all sizes. If you "make women feel beautiful," you're going to be out of the market really quickly if they're only sizes 0-2. I'm 4'10" and a US size 4 and am HWP. Who the hell is your client?
43
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17 edited Sep 15 '17
If Aaron doesn't go home after an all time awful performance in this round and the game I will shoot myself. Not even kidding. I won't shoot myself anywhere fatal but like rip my leg if he stays
61
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
What's with the excessive praise Brandon gets every week?
21
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
I feel like it is harder to make "good" interesting. With "evil," the possibilities are much greater.
21
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
I love how Kenya subverted the OH NO I DIDN'T GET WHAT I WANT trope
21
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
I feel like this is the season we stop thinking of Wendy as the biggest villain of a season, it's Claire. SHES THE WORST
(Also wendy wasn't too bad it was just at the time being cutthroat wasn't cool)
21
u/Rachey56 Sep 15 '17
Anybody else wanna hug Kentaro cause he's so cute
20
u/insubordinance Sep 15 '17
I'm waiting for the day someone Heelys through the workroom. Or they have a challenge sponsored by hoverboards.
20
u/sebrahestur Sep 15 '17
How was it unexpected? It's a play on every single thing he's made during the competition
39
u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 15 '17
Aaron spent two days to make bloated parachute pants with streamers. And he had the nerve to say "Oh she's working it" when she walked the runway. Wtf.
37
u/insubordinance Sep 15 '17
What a boring runway as far as interpretation of the theme.
36
u/poppysand Sep 15 '17
I am so over the model input.
36
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Liris mentions her figure, yet again! Oh, and now she is BeyoncΓ© in concert. Girl...
17
u/ashiguana Sep 15 '17
Poor Jasmine, all of her designs were just awful.
17
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
Claires is so boring
62
u/itemri Sep 15 '17
Brandon's model looks like she was forcibly raised as a clown and has now accepted her fate and is just trying to make the best of it.
34
u/itemri Sep 15 '17
Buffoonery, riggery, and straight up tomfoolery.
16
u/insubordinance Sep 15 '17
Michael's model may have just redeemed herself by swatting Claire with the edge of her cape.
16
u/Shewasashowgirl7 Sep 15 '17
Can we discuss Brandon's Jesus smock/athliesure legs/gunslinger harness/braids look? I'm so intrigued. I feel like he would successfully run a cult.
15
u/Ufraudedme Sep 15 '17
I found Aaron's outfit on Pinterest:
https://i.pinimg.com/736x/1a/29/86/1a29860879204e2bd384ce2f3ea9101a--pink-white-yarns.jpg
28
u/no_shant Sep 15 '17
STOP. ASKING. MODELS. FOR. INPUT. THAT'S. NOT. THEIR. JOB. WHY. IS. TIM. CONDONING. THIS.
27
u/RCPB39 Sep 14 '17
I really hope we see more of Amy this week and she scores high or wins. She's so talented but I feel she's being slept on by the judges.
26
u/Rachey56 Sep 15 '17 edited Sep 15 '17
Observations
Claire cannot take criticism and is by far one of the worst people I've ever seen on this show (IM NOT GONNA GROVEL OH THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!!) Dove Cameron's lips were the third guest judge Margarita is annoying Nina Garcia is over this show. I don't think she'll be back for season 17 Swatches little bum running up the stairs at Mood was my highlight The model mirror is the worst idea since teams season
13
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
I am not understanding Brandon's outfit.
34
u/TheLadyEve Sep 15 '17
What? They like Brandon's outfit? What?
It's hideous. I hate it. Am I taking crazy pills?
12
u/ashiguana Sep 15 '17
I love Kentaro's wave.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Is this an incoming triple elimination??
11
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '17
Must every runway be inspired by a movie now? Lmao
11
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
When they showed Tim saying "beat back the costume" in the promo, I thought he was talking to Margarita.
11
u/potatothief24 Sep 15 '17
Oh just go full labyrinth amy. you're already halfway there
11
u/nerathefinder Sep 15 '17
They like Brandon's???
11
u/esquire22 Sep 15 '17
FFS
30
u/FastEddieMcclintock Sep 15 '17
First time in this sub.
-No way Brandon deserved to win. 3 of 3 IMO.
-I'd be fine if the guests judges were not allowed to speak. ever.
-Are the twins as bad as Korina from s13?
-Project kindergarden was peak Nina.
21
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
'One or more' is promising!
45
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
NO MICHAEL WAS ROBBED BRANDON IS THE NEW ERIN SDHJFLSKDJFSLKDJFSL
20
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Nina coming in clutch with the Ms. Frizzle chic.
Also, the guest judge pretending to dig Aaron being dressed as a schoolgirl made me cringe like hell.
10
u/TheTurdSmuggler Sep 14 '17
Get ready for some more twins fuckery
10
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
"I am so thrilled, we get two days to sew!"
I'm thrilled too!
10
u/pinkfroshie Sep 15 '17
I'm sorry but the models' makeup so far looks terrible.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
I hate the color Kenya chose, but it is beautifully constructed.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Nina, draaaaaaag her!
10
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
What is with the explosion of streamers?
10
u/testmonkey254 Sep 15 '17
Wow Claire...can't say I'm surprised
10
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
Oh man Shawn in the first look is just as egotistical as Claire
10
u/dangerboy55 Sep 15 '17
So glad Michael didn't win. I mean all draping and a few darts? Yes it was nice and well thought out but really the lace did all of the work and it was the most literal interpretation. I would have liked Kenya to win because she took so many risks but I'm good with Brandon winning. Sorry to see Aaron go but he never really delivered, did he?
19
u/Livermush Sep 15 '17
Yes honey, we know a voluptuous chest is foreign to you
π
these designers are part of the problem
19
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
Aaron's getting aufed calling it
26
u/salty_sam17 Sep 15 '17
Am I the only one that actually really liked Brandon's look? I was worried the judges wouldn't but I like the color palette and print a lot.
9
u/icouldseeformiles Sep 15 '17
Kind of weird that they're promoting Descendants 2 when it came out a month ago
9
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
I get the "crafty" comment, but I like that the colors of Sam's outfit match her hair!
9
u/potatothief24 Sep 15 '17
too bad. it's not like Shawn is Eleven and can telepathically make you talented
9
u/MinutesOnAScreen Sep 15 '17
That lip gloss grosses me out.
9
u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 15 '17
I never noticed how short Kenya is. She holds herself very well
9
u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 15 '17
And this thread will explode in 3...2...1...
9
u/ametron Sep 15 '17
When Claire came back and said that they didn't tear her to shreds, really?
All of the judges ripped her look apart, and it went on for so long that I actually felt bad for her.
9
u/craftybast Sep 16 '17
I was struck by Kentaro saying that black is the most emotional color. That concept fascinated me.
8
u/whoremongering Sep 15 '17
I'm worried about this runway.
8
u/ashiguana Sep 15 '17
Girl, just stop.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Aaron was my pre-season fave because anything androgynous draws my attention...this week was a let down for sure.
28
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Sep 15 '17
I HATE this obsession with Brandon! No way did his look deserve to be in the top for this challenge, let alone win. So frustrating.
27
u/throwawayacct472727 Sep 15 '17
Also people are complaining about Brandon winning so I'm just gonna throw it out there that his look today was my favorite thing anyone has made all season and I'm OBSESSED with it.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Kentaro's looks like this.
15
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
Brandon looks like he's wearing bondage PJs today. Also socks with those sandals???? Really bro??
20
u/Livermush Sep 15 '17
i make clothes for women to feel awesome in
but only if they're anorexic...
14
u/icouldseeformiles Sep 15 '17
I guess I'm not fashionable because I haven't liked anything Brandon has sent down the runway
7
u/Livermush Sep 15 '17
Brandon's look reminded me of a men's dress shirt oversized on a female
7
u/i-mhp1988 Sep 15 '17
Not upset Brandon won but I am upset he had to mention yet again he has only worked in menswear.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Getting sleepy, and I thought Margarita said she was making a "one-legged" pant (instead of "wide-legged"). Instant thought: wow, straitjacket chic is totally taking over.
7
u/iwasfeelingtwirly Sep 17 '17
I think the people who had good had a harder challenge. Evening wear plus "evil Disney" automatically makes you think of a black lacy/leather gown. "Good" is more of an abstract concept.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Brandon is the new designer the judges worship and the entire time I am like SHE LOOKS LIKE THE STILT WOMAN
12
u/nightmusic08 Sep 15 '17
So I LOVE Brandon but he's gonna have to make not a giant pants or not *** those *** sleeves again for me to be fully convinced.
12
u/regretflix Sep 15 '17
so next week the models are clients..... as if they haven't enough unnecessary input on the designs every single week thus farπ
6
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
"Don't use these three dozen accessories you're limited to to make a costume." Oh, Tim, whatever they designed, a random purse or shoes isn't going to save or doom it, short of putting gladiator sandals on some girl dressed as an angel or something.
PS: he missed adding "thoughtfully." Maybe that no longer applies.
6
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
Of course they would like Brandons. Though honestly that would be high fashion if it was executed a little better technically since some areas don't look fitted perfectly
6
u/Semicolon_Expected Sep 15 '17
the >we need a stronger voice thing makes it sound like shes gonna be in because they want to give her that chance
6
u/HeyJayHuggs Sep 15 '17
Claire just got that goddamn Korina save dammit!!
6
u/PhoenixorFlame Sep 15 '17
"Curry powder evil."
10
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '17
Who do these models think they are? They aren't the client. Who really gives a shit about their opinions?
5
u/DrunkKellyDodd Sep 15 '17
If I was on the evil team, I'd make the dress Zulema from S2 made that got Nick Verreos' model kicked off.
5
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
Sams outfit is crooked
5
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 15 '17
I want Nina's dress though. A+
5
u/ronscot Christian Sep 16 '17
I did like all the top 3 looks. It's a bit weird that Brandon got criticized by two judges and yet he still won. Did you know the models all have a crush on Brandon? You should, since this is the 2nd time they've told us. It's kinda getting annoying at this point.
Aaron's look was awful, but Claire was so rude when she referred to it at the end that at least her dress didn't look like that. I think Claire will be gone soon, she's not a great designer.