r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Mar 11 '18
Map Thread #86 Top Maps Thread
Welcome one and all to the top map feedback thread for Map Thread 86! The following maps have made it through to the final stage. The goal of this staged testing is to give maps more time to sink in. It also allows the community and committee members to give feedback to promising maps in the same testing cycle.
Maps
Zungguzungguguzungguzeng - Beast Mode
Neunundneunzig Luftballons - Fronj
Mapmakers whose maps have advanced have the next few days to make alterations to their maps. Any edits should be posted as comments responding to the appropriate top-level map comment made from this account.
Feel free to give constructive criticism on the maps put through to top maps in their respective parent comments! YOU could influence the next map in rotation!
Notes will be published in the results thread.
MTC applications are coming!
6
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
Tint - Fronj
4
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
Veil - Nym
4
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
Sugar Hill - alchemist
4
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
Zungguzungguguzungguzeng - Beast Mode
23
u/yespadrille Dove Mar 11 '18 edited Mar 11 '18
You guys broke my heart tonight. Past threads have disappointed me, but tonight I was ghoulishly teased. I've been hoping to see Fetish 4v4'd for a while because I just don't know how it will play. The perfunctory test began, preceding gameplay, with a deluge of disparaging comments that set the tone for rest of the test and fueled a proposal to end the test 50 seconds in. Met without demur, the test summarily ended exactly a minute later without ever shifting pitch from the opening salvo. I understand not voting for a map after a candid test, but to cut one short under the pretense of unplayability while playing through and even appointing inferior maps is, to me, valueless and untenable. The test was so unsuccessful as to reveal to me nothing about the map (highlighted by the first 40 seconds), or how to improve it. There is nothing I can glean that I didn't already know because only after an actual test can a map be adequately described, yet the sole commentary throughout is a mere a priori construction, guaranteeing the test was a waste of everyone's time. It leaves me enervated. Was it really such a slog to play for the two minutes y'all gave it, or was the slog fabricated, imported, and regurgitated, creating a sullen aura during the test? While testing, how aware are the MTC of the transfer of opinion, especially directing from the most opinionated to the ambivalent or feckless? After testing, I can't be sure how much influence genuinely remains to inform the votes, but if even the nominator is convinced to end the test early...
Maybe I'm being uncharitable by alleging MTC opinions are easily or frequently swayed during initial testing, but in observing the process for a while, at the minimum, the existence of a pessimistic motif seems to be irrefutable. The incremental atrophy of TagPro no doubt carries memetic resonance; as it nears the nadir, saturnine attitudes become fraught and ambient among those that remain involved in the game. Symptomatically, the MTC is approaching a similar measure. If we are to continue along this trajectory then all we have to do is exactly what we are doing now. To expect something to change, we must act, and for it to be meaningful it must be a group effort in solidarity with one another. This applies broadly to any movement, but it is here apropos of the MTC. How far the MTC still is from being primed to accept their impotence is strikingly proven by their aversion to any serious discussion about alternatives to the incumbent system with the wider audience of TagPro. The MTC is already loosely congealed; how many members just resigned, and how many potentials are on deck to replace them? How many incumbent MTC still enjoy what they do? It seems to me that the growing discontent presages more dissatisfaction for those remaining members and more feelings of disconnection between the MTC and the community which is bound to give rise to growing antagonism overall. To focus on finding recruits to fill the empty positions is to perpetuate the problems of the current system. I believe that involving the community by opening up discussion is the current best course of action. If you proffer the topic using this account and make obvious and comprehensive the issues we face, the community will be willing to talk about it. The prospect of a new arrangement may just become a cynosure and a boon to the whole of TagPro. But first, the MTC must agree that the map selection process needs revision. Please, have compassion on the words of this suppliant. ♫ ♥
8
u/PIZZAspartan442 naga///MTC Mar 11 '18
what happened
9
u/cfcnotbummer Mar 11 '18
Hi'yall GG Allin here I have not played in a long time due to having to get a degree, I have now finished. See you on Chord soon. Glad to be back
1
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
Neunundneunzig Luftballons - Fronj
0
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
They laughed at Louis Armstrong when he said he was gonna go to the moon. Now he's up there laughing down at them. - FINDADMAGUS
0
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Mar 11 '18
Allegory - Narumii
6
u/LinuxDootTP black magic Mar 11 '18
haha nj mtc
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18
I VOTE FOR LUFTBALLOONS BY FRONJ
1
u/girmluhk Gramps Mar 20 '18
is Saigon in the throwback or something? I keep getting it and it's cancer in pubs.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18
uh so yeah we should definitely just put all of these in rotation
they all look like fun and the more maps we have in the less likely to get wormy or ricochet
0
u/Tyler1986 Trapsin Mar 12 '18
imo, a pretty strong top maps thread. I'd be happy to play any of these but the nf one, that's not based on its merits, I just don't like nf.
-1
u/TheBestNarcissist exit triks Mar 21 '18
They're all so similar.