r/westworld • u/NicholasCajun Mr. Robot • May 14 '18
Discussion Westworld - 2x04 "The Riddle of the Sphinx" - Post-Episode Discussion
Season 2 Episode 4: The Riddle of the Sphinx
Aired: May 13th, 2018
Synopsis: Is this now? If you're looking forward, you're looking in the wrong direction.
Directed by: Lisa Joy
Written by: Gina Atwater & Jonathan Nolan
2.7k
Upvotes
1.9k
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
I absolutely LOVE the parallel between Ford and William. Before Ford made Bernard shoot himself last season, he said
Which is very similar to what just happened between William and Jim
3.4k
u/dreadfuldiego May 14 '18
At first, I called bullshit at Elsie surviving so long only eating protein bars
Then it came to me. She was there for days, only days. So much happens in Westworld that I thought Elsie was missing for months, but holy shit, it was just a couple of days.
1.8k
u/Blazemuffins May 14 '18
Did anyone else notice that the confederado (I think his name is Craddock?) Treated Lawrence's wife exactly the same as MiB did when he was looking for the maze? They both danced with her and held the gun to her the same way. Could it be even this was programmed by Ford to taunt William? Especially Craddock's line about looking so stylish while committing acts of violence?
2.7k
u/Kendallwithak May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
"someone took a chunk out of you boys, what happened to the rest of you?"
"double crossed by some bitch named of Wyatt"
"good for her"
4.6k
u/JhonnyWongStockings May 14 '18
So the last shot of Jim pedaling on the exercise bike was possibly the most horrifying thing I've ever seen.
2.4k
u/BigJoeJS May 14 '18
So this was the episode they will submit for Ed Harris' Emmy nomination I guess.
2.7k
u/svrtngr May 14 '18
Of course she has a gray hat.
3.0k
u/galaxyfudge May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Elsie: Promise me to never hurt me again.
Bernard: Ok. Also, FYI, I murdered everyone in this room, that cool?
6.1k
u/jsun31 May 14 '18
"You think you know death? You didn't recognize him sitting right in front of you"
Absolutely badass
1.3k
u/joliedame May 14 '18
Holy fuck, Delos, that was some Event Horizon shit.
3.4k
u/may-again May 14 '18
“Promise me you’ll NEVER hurt me again” “....Of course”
Oh, so Bernard is gonna kill Elsie this year, word
2.2k
u/SkylineSith May 14 '18
"If you can't tell, does it matter?"
Goddamn.
1.4k
u/FenBlacach May 14 '18
Alright, so last week we were convinced Elsie was running Ghost Nation remotely to scoop up humans - Turns out she's been eating protein bars and shitting in a bucket. So who's running Ghost Nation?
My money's on either eFord on a mainframe, or Ford 2.0 in a shiny new body.
2.4k
u/hodorito Stable Boy Sizemore May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Elsie was locked away by Bernard, to later be Bernard’s personal healer. He had this all planned out.
699
u/JJLong5 May 14 '18
Loved the visuals at the end with Delos.
He was literally in Hell.
695
u/StuartGT We will disappoint you May 14 '18
"It was just his reflection, laughing back down at you"
2.1k
u/tinycroissant May 14 '18
Maybe the game is the man in blacks Turing test.
1.8k
u/DJ_Doza May 14 '18
The red velvet cupcakes are cortices designed to hold a human mind in a host, but they haven't perfected it yet.
So are they just collecting guest DNA with the hope of being able to replace them some day?
1.8k
u/AmericanIdiom Bulk Apperception: 2 May 14 '18
Next week:
The Gang Goes to Shogunworld
828
u/sIoot full of splendor May 14 '18
Mr. Delos stylin on some yeezys.
His consciousness inside of a host body is something straight out of Black Mirror, it was disturbing.
1.7k
u/lunchboxg4 May 14 '18
That could have been a season finale, but was only episode 4. Dammit I love this show.
280
u/Ness_Bilius_Mellark May 14 '18
Watching this episode realized how lucky we are to have such a skilled cast. I mean Ed Harris was amazing but even the actor that played Delos was great too.
1.7k
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
The number of secret facilities in this park is TOO DAMM HIGH!
Also:
Is ford controlling you Bernard?
Ford is dead Elsie.
THAT IS NOT RELEVANT TO THE QUESTION BERNARD!
802
u/[deleted] May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
"I'm all the way down now. I can see all the way to the bottom. Would you like to see what I see?.....They said there were two fathers one above, one below. They lied. There was only ever the devil. And when you look up from the bottom, it was just his reflection...laughing back down at you." Damn!
734
u/Thomas_Sedgwick May 14 '18
Ed Harris on the road to redemption is all I ever wanted that I never knew I needed
2.5k
u/Eeyores_Prozac May 14 '18
The least surprising thing in this show is finding out Logan died of an overdose. Like, that's actually refreshing.
926
u/hodorito Stable Boy Sizemore May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
The best parts of this episode was Lawrence’s reunion with his daughter and Lawrence blowing up Craddok.
2.1k
u/ME24601 Why?! Why was I programmed to feel pain! May 14 '18
"You think you know Death? Name three of her albums."
1.3k
u/Blazemuffins May 14 '18
'you want to see what I see?'
Yeah that's gonna be a no from me dawg
898
u/aselectionofcheeses May 14 '18
Liked the touch of the goldfish in Delos's cabin. Memory of a goldfish.
2.0k
u/ME24601 Why?! Why was I programmed to feel pain! May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
I want a malfunctioning robot-off between Abernathy (Louis Herthum) and Delos (Peter Mullan). Which actor can play a broken bot better?
3.6k
u/pokupokupoku May 14 '18
this was probably the single best episode of the show so far, focusing on bernard/william is a great choice because they're probably the two best/most developed characters on the show, and bringing elsie back (my favorite character) is awesome
1.6k
u/TheGabrielCorleone May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Best episode of the series in my opinion! Lisa Joy’s debut as a director was brilliant! I hope she’ll direct way more episodes from now on!! WOW!!!
1.4k
u/VictorBlimpmuscle May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
”Then you still don’t understand the real game we’re playing here - if you’re looking forward you’re looking in the wrong direction.”
I like how Ford uses different child hosts to deliver cryptic messages to troll William.
2.2k
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
Anyone still doubt that Ford transferred his consciousness into a new body before being killed?
393
u/HollowWaif May 14 '18
Ed Harris gets better with every word.
1.3k
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
The Jim Delos scenes remind anyone else of Black Mirror? Shot similarly too.
370
u/UltramemesX May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
I loved the part with Senior Dellos living a cycle forever inside his house, and constantly having his mind copied into a new body. Some horror shit right there.
I'm guessing the balls or cupcake looking things we saw likely are the minds of guests. And they couldn't transfer your mind, only make a copy of it. And so far it wasn't successfull with Dellos senior.
900
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
“Hi dad.”
Man if the writers dropped that reveal straight away I really can’t wait for the rest of this season.
So much to do! Too much time! (before the next episode)
728
u/KanesWill May 14 '18
“You didn’t realize you were sitting across from him” such a badass line in a badass scene.
1.3k
u/SuccessfulUmpire May 14 '18
Best episode yet?
667
u/cornholiogringo May 14 '18
The way ford is still following William leads me to believe that Ford uploaded his consciousness into a host and somehow got it into the host network so he is like a virus jumping in and out of any hosts he wants.
663
u/TheDornishSun May 14 '18
Our boy William is gonna go grey hat and I couldn't be happier about it
475
u/Nantoone May 14 '18
This is probably my favorite episode of the entire series. So many insanely fucking cool scenes. The rain scene and the Delos scenes namely. And the reveal at the end to tie it up. Damn I love this show.
354
u/I_AM_PEAKSBRAH May 14 '18
“Hi, Dad”
Eff me sideways that episode was sick!!
640
u/SofaKing_24 May 14 '18
OH MY FUCK, THATS WILLIAM’S DAUGHTER.
1.6k
u/HandRailSuicide1 May 14 '18
Elsie’s back! Also, raise your hand if you’re confused
407
u/MisquotedSource Craig & Lori's Travel Agent. Team Ned May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Elsie Not knowing what the fuck is going on!
Delos secret project revealed!
William redemption Arc(ish)!
Ford fucking with William!
Grace is Williams daughter!!!
219
u/Mycareer Djawadi is king May 14 '18
I swear to god, every time this show answers one questions it raises like 12 more. Fucking love Westworld, I can’t get enough of this damn show.
Also, that tease for next week has me even more hyped for Samurai World than ever.
208
u/Mr_Face May 14 '18
Is Ford trying to teach William to become the hero again, like when he first started in Westworld?
293
u/Jorgeragula05 May 14 '18
Elsie is alive, and I was always on edge that she would just die.
100
u/slayer991 May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
This episode was amazing...mind blown...wow....probably the best episode yet.
More about William/MiB, his family, James Delos, Bernard, Elsie...just wow.
The scene with old William and James Delos was pretty sad. Logan ODed, his wife died, and his daughter (William's wife) killed herself. William was at least partially responsible for Logan and his wife (Delos' daughter) and damn if you can't see it weigh on William (mind-blowing job by Ed Harris here).
In terms of William/MiB redemption. What could he possibly do (and the little girl alludes to it...one good deed doesn't make up for who he is) to find redemption?
He has to go back...I'm guessing to Dolores since that's where his journey began.
200
u/Patriots80 May 14 '18
That was my favorite episode yet. William saving Lawrence and taking down the Confederados was Denzel Washington in 'Equalizer' esque. Got so hyped during that. This is the best show on television.
361
u/frenchee1 May 14 '18
REDEMPTION-ARC! REDEMPTION-ARC! REDEMPTION ARC!
92
u/Harekicker May 14 '18
Was there any particular reason as to why they had to incinerate every time they were finished testing with Delos? Wouldn't it be easier just to replace Delos and leave the room intact
753
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
By far the best episode in the series, ironically the Dolores narrative was absent.
167
u/cornholiogringo May 14 '18
Beautiful, I felt like I just watched a movie
2.0k
u/TheDuckHunt3r May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
That might have been the best produced/directed episode of any series ever.
Just wow. Old man Delos can fucking act.
And holy fuck Bernard with the Rollins Curb Stomp!
152
u/tribe47 May 14 '18
So this is what I thought for time periods:
~20 years ago is original Jimmi and Daddy Delos scene-Emily being about ten years old and it being half a decade since the retirement party would be the right age for her to start being called "whip smart"
~10 to ~15 years ago for the second scene with William and Daddy Delos where William terminates Host Daddy D-William’s hair here seems to match the scene where he undresses Dolores and mocks her, but that could just be me
-1 year ago: Juliet kills herself by taking pills in a bathtub
-immediately before season 1 events: Ed Harris and Daddy D scene talking about reset #149
-nebulously post massacre time period:
`*Grace and Stubbs and Ghost Nation seems to be immediately post massacre, potentially within a day or two
*MIB and lawrence connecting with Confederados right after Dolores betrays them
*Elsie and Bernard’s excellent adventure with Ghost Daddy D starts after he deals with Abernathy and Dolores
-current time period:
*Bernard is glitching his way through his trip with Elsie just like Dolores did last season for her trip with William
667
u/Labubs Of man's urge to take a thing of beauty and...strike the match. May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Ed Harris and Jimmi Simpson are both amazing and this episode's Host James Delos scenes showed how good they are getting at really picking up each other's little behaviors, facial expressions and quirks.
Also.
Holy. Fuck.
EDIT: "If you're looking forward you're looking in the wrong direction"
Cue beautiful shot of riding off into the sunrise. Amazing. This episode was by far the best of the season so far. Seasons 4 Breaking Bad/The Wire good. All members of the past week's Grace=Emily club stand up with me! Lawrence and William are the dynamic-ist of duos. Although with William and Emily together, it's like the two top ranked players who know all the Easter eggs just joined the server. Admin turned on perma-death/hardcore/survival mode though haha.
Although now I'm scared, every tight situation they end up in together my heart will be racing. Knowing the history, I couldn't bear one of them dying. Also find it slightly funny that most likely Ford is a marble in Bernard's pocket(at one point at least). Also found it slightly terrifying when William left Delos v.149 unwiped for a year(and would have been longer had the park not gone haywire). That shit was Absolute Zero cold. Also, reverse Ex Machina vibe there, anyone?
Kind of worried that Elsie wasn't on the beach :-\ So glad she's back though!
EDIT 2- I missed the date on the terminal, so Delos seems to have been there for 2 weeks instead of a year. William's beard threw me off too...still, William intended to just leave him there, so I stand by the point that it was ruthless haha
71
u/KanesWill May 14 '18
Oh man, ending the episode with William seeing his daughter, it just ended and I already can’t wait for next week.
417
u/thegreenbell May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
"Hi, dad."
124
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
William going Keyser Soze was probably one of the coolest scenes in the show.
Also, I doubt they’re super connected, but Delos’ line about, “if you want to deceive the devil” vs William’s “you didn’t recognize death right in front of you” was a cool parallel. Did the MiB become what he hated?
59
u/casualdarings May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Hands down best episode so far, just incredible from start to finish.
Who else thinks the last control unit printed is totally William? One last fuck you from Ford cause MIB wanted the project shut down and now there's going to be a clone of him running around. Or maybe I just want more screen time for Jimmi, I don't know.
57
u/suhhhduuude May 14 '18
What a dope ass hour of television wow
57
u/ColesHole May 14 '18
Anyone else lose their shit when they saw older William close the same door Bernard and Elsie were about to go through? I enjoyed that a lot
211
u/Kelvyn May 14 '18
You think Abernathy is a clone of a human? He looks like he's dealing with the symptoms of cognitive plateau. He also broke down after seeing that picture of William's wife in a city. Like he was rejecting reality.
53
u/chris5129 May 14 '18
Knew that was Will's daughter as soon as she said she's not looking to get rescued. The apple definitely didn't fall far from the tree
106
u/JMonty21 May 14 '18
Soooo we were totally wrong about Elise controlling the Indians, but right about putting Delos brain in new body. Alright Reddit 50%!
52
u/azmitex May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Crazy theory. Ford had Bernard make a copy of Arnold in the lab. Scene of "bernard" waking up on the beach is actually arnold placed in his/"bernards" body... Scene at the lake with the dead hosts, he says, "i killed them all", he isn't referencing the hosts in the water, but his last real life memory when he had all the original hosts kill themselves and have Dolores kill him.
151
u/OkNose May 14 '18
Okay but can we talk about the title of the episode for a sec? I think it refers to this original riddle from Greek myth: Which creature has one voice and yet becomes four-footed and two-footed and three-footed? The answer to which is man, who crawls, walks, and uses a cane throughout his life. A lifespan which the robots of Westworld could never understand.
50
u/wryoung May 14 '18
Lawrence is beginning to remember past lives - He remembered William telling him about his daughter
99
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
So did Bernard pocket Ford’s consciousness?
542
u/AttackoftheMuffins May 14 '18
The show writers are actively trolling us at this point. I know less now than I did last week.
46
u/gayjewtrombone May 14 '18
Did anyone understand the point of the Ghost Nation stuff with Stubbs, and also what happened to the other people they captured? I was really confused when they did that reveal shot and everyone was gone.
46
u/emikoala May 14 '18
MiB encountering his daughter gives us a pretty solid post-massacre timeline.
Gala and Mesa massacres take place at night.
Following the initial carnage (Night 0), Wyatt rides for the Confederados, executing folks along the way. MIB rides off to find Lawrence early in his loop.
Maeve and her men enter the park to find her daughter, and cross paths with Wyatt and his men that first night.
Bernard is initially with a group of execs and Charlotte but is separated from them by the next morning or afternoon (Day 1) and captured by Wyatt's men.
Emily flees Raj world the morning after the gala and washes up on shore the same day (Day 1), and is immediately captured by ghost nation.
It's not long before Maeve and her men are chased underground by Ghost Nation and link up with Armistice and the cats, and they all head back above ground.
Late in Day 1, Dolores has her skirmish with Delos security, who capture Abernathy but not until after Bernard has downloaded his data to himself. Clementine promptly abducts him and drags him to Elsie in the cave. Bernard finds Elsie fewer than 24 hours since the massacre. It's probably night outside by the time their encounter with Jimbot happens given how late it was getting when Clem dropped Bernard off.
Following the skirmish, Teddy lets what's left of the Confederados head back to their town, where they encounter MIB and Lawrence, who kill the rest of them by the end of Night 1*.
Maeve & Co reach Shogun World by nightfall (Night 1)*.
The ghost nation prisoners are taken to "the first one" at night, which is almost certainly still Night 1 because Emily doesn't seem like she would have waited more than a day in captivity like Stubbs was content to do. She escapes and sets out in her own.
The next morning after defeating the Confederados, MIB and his men ride out and encounter Emily on Day 2*.
*It's possible that Emily did stuff in between ghost nation, and that MIB took more than a day to reach the Confederados and they'd been chilling there for a few days since Wyatt betrayed them, which could put the Daddy-daughter meeting later than Day 2. It's also possible that it took Maeve & Co more than a day to reach Shogun World.
But thanks to Maeve encountering Wyatt before the skirmish with security, the Confederados interacting with Wyatt before MIB, MIB interacting with Confederados before running across Emily, the near certainty that security raided the fort the very next day after the massacre and that Emily did not allow herself to be held prisoner for more than half a day, and the audience seeing Bernard dragged directly from the skirmish to the cave by Clem and immediately discovering Elsie, it seems most probable that we have seen what each of the main narrative leaders (Dolores, MIB, Bernard, Maeve) did on Night 0 and Day 1.
Which means we still have at least 11 days until the events of the season premiere to get through! We haven't yet seen Wyatt kill the Ghost Nation member, which is time stamped 11 days before the events of episode 1 and doesn't seem to have happened until after Day 1.
132
u/higgon May 14 '18
GRACE IS MIB DAUGHTER oh yeah
88
u/Dongalor2 May 14 '18
Not sure why Elsie was so nonchalant and not all HOLY FUCK BERNARD IS A HOST... HOLY FUCK BERNARD IS A SENTIENT HOST, but still awesome episode.
42
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
That episode was my favorite of Season 2, so far. Reminded me of LOST at the beginning, and Red Dead Redemption in the end. Such a video game way to meet-up with his daughter.
That James Delos stuff was straight-up horror movie-esque. I loved the way he was peddling backwards when Elsie found him.
41
u/riptusk331 May 14 '18
That was a seriously amazing episode. So much backstory and motivation for what’s been driving everything revealed.
Did anyone else think for a second at the end that it was Dolores?
40
u/cineVette May 14 '18
Oh my. What a powerhouse episode of acting this was.
I've so bought into this transition of young to old William, what a brilliantly developed fucking character arc.
39
u/KatPiss_NeverCleen May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
So does the pyrotechnic "special effects" rule just not exist more? Is the nitro actually flammable instead of just a harmless prop that the control center manually ignites when a guest wants to use it?
Example: MiB breaking Hector out of jail in season 1.
38
u/TheLadyEve May 14 '18
I knew it. They're copying people.
And I love where it's going.
38
u/abstergofkurslf May 14 '18
This episode made me realize I don't care about Delores' storyline at all and just want to see whatever the Man in Black is up to.
196
u/cornholiogringo May 14 '18
The game for William is figuring out that the host are just as viable as humans. He wants William to treat them as equal and care for them, just like he did with Dolores in the past. It will come down to William and Dolores both coming to the same conclusion that both humans and host deserve to live
138
u/DJ_Doza May 14 '18
Emily = Grace confirmed!
75
u/wryoung May 14 '18
Elsie: "Is Ford in control of you now?"
Bernard: "Ford's dead"
That's not a no!
290
u/dondeestaelpotato Angsty Teen Ford May 14 '18
Holy shit that was the best 75 minutes of my entire life.
204
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
The show is better with less Wyatt/Dolores and this episode proved it. Give me more Elsie!
67
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
The Grace is Theresa theories are dead. And death is always true.
261
u/emmerick May 14 '18
James Delos was smoking a cigarette! He is clearly young Theresa!
/s
31
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
I love how they scripted a legit explanation for the memory jumps that Bernard is having. As a logic programmer,
I love this, “Your memories aren’t addressed. They’re just kind of drifting around in there, So when you’re experiencing one you don’t know if it comes before or after the others”
Seems like this tactic has been used before. (Maeve, Dolores, Abernathy)
Love this show.
119
u/ClunkiestSquid Definitely Human May 14 '18
“This game is for you William.”
William is dead, and they put his consciousness in a host. Thats why hes so good at shooting and such a badass. He’s been in Westworld trying to find his consciousness this whole time.
53
u/Sayain_Prince May 14 '18
James delos scene was very tragic, whole scene reminded me of a vault story from fallout
53
u/withaniel May 14 '18
My name is Elsie Hughes, and I clearly haven't learned my lesson about running headlong into creepy situations.
26
u/PudgyBonestld May 14 '18
RIP to the guy that got impaled in secret lab #354
52
u/neverdox May 14 '18
whether the clones created from humans work well or not is irrelevant, they could have created copies of every host Dolores wants to take into the real world, then put the shitty clones into the sea and killed them.
having everyone let their guard down and letting the actually working hosts escape, with nobody suspecting this since only high ranking Delos people know and they seem to have been slaughtered en masse at the party
Bernard may be one of these shitty clones, which would explain his shitty functionality better than the gunshot wound that hosts suffer all the time
93
u/Plainchant They simply became music. May 14 '18
There must be multiple timeframes IRL. I'm watching this live on HBO and the show's not even done yet.
25
u/DerpyNerdy Redditor in Black May 14 '18
One of the best episodes of the series. I just don't know how else to put it.
25
u/TaciturnWeirdo May 14 '18
If Elsie didn’t program Ghost Nation to save guests l, then who did? If it was Ford, did he only want board members killed and paying members seeking ‘fantasies’ saved?
25
u/faster_than_sound May 14 '18
Confirmations I feel have been made this episode:
MiB is on a path to some form of redemption.
Ford copied his brain before death and is now a part of the mesh network.
Elsie is just so cute. Glad to have her back.
25
u/Dongalor2 May 14 '18
Funny to see Ghost Nation had the human couple that shot Hector and Armistice at the end of the pilot.
24
u/itsyourdestini Host A Party May 14 '18
We called it. that was his daughter
24
u/ballpark_mustard May 14 '18
"Ford had me print another core."
The core is Ford.
24
u/atad2much May 14 '18
Notes They’re alluding to a shared memory host mind..... “you’re only alive as long as the last person that remembers you”, the cognitive plateau problem, Lawrence “remembering” that William mentioned having a daughter when it was Teddy that William mentioned that to. There have been other hints.
Also, I think the human host hybrid will turn out to be Grace.
48
u/Jas_God May 14 '18
That was far and away the best ep of the season so far.
202
u/mom-get-the-camera May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
ELSIE POGCHAMP
EDIT: BERNARD WITH THE AMERICAN HISTORY X CURBSTOMP HOLY SHIT
43
u/chillerguava May 14 '18
“Hi dad”
Lawrence: ohhhhh shit it’s about to go DOWN
41
u/Nightwing11 Why doesn't anyone just use noclip to escape? May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Anyone else getting the feeling that the real William died at at the gala when Dolores went on a rampage? In episode 1 when kid Ford first approached William with the game a fly can be seen landing on his hat, similarly to the role it played in season 1. That wolf also appeared to him almost like how it appeared to Teddy last season. The real William also had a broke arm and yet it seems fine throughout this season. Ford had Bernard print a controller for some mystery individual. The little back and forth that Ford had with William at the saloon in season 1 makes me think that Ford was getting a baseline reading of William's developed brain without him knowing it. Maybe the mystery host that Ford was printing last season was Williams body. " If you're looking forward, you're looking in the wrong direction. "The game begins where you end and ends where you began."
Also the whole line William says about seeing the men they could have been almost confirms in my mind that William is already dead. It would be surprising if Williams cognitive functions start breaking down at some point later in the season, similarly to Jim Delos.
20
u/Garandhero May 14 '18
Why is no one talking about how MIB got shot twice, and the bullets had no effect...... As if the saftey protocols were reengaged.
40
u/DJ_Doza May 14 '18
The new control unit is for MiB after he finishes Ford's quest.
56
u/skipperdog May 14 '18
So, how many INNOCENT goldfish boiled alive for this fiasco?
19
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
The idea of singularity is so evident in this episode. For those who don't know, here is a quote from a livescience.com:
" According to techno-futurists, the exponential development of technology in general and artificial intelligence (“AI”) in particular — including the complete digital replication of human brains — will radically transform humanity via two revolutions. The first is the "singularity," when artificial intelligence will redesign itself recursively and progressively, such that AI will become vastly more powerful than human intelligence ("superstrong AI"). The second revolution will be "virtual immortality," when the fullness of our mental selves can be uploaded perfectly to nonbiological media (such as silicon chips), and our mental selves will live on beyond the demise of our fleshy, physical bodies.
AI singularity and virtual immortality would mark a startling, transhuman world that techno-futurists envision as inevitable and perhaps just over the horizon. They do not question whether their vision can be actualized; they only debate when will it occur, with estimates ranging from 10 to 100 years."
19
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
The pieces of symbolism in the scenes with Jim Delos are awesome.
Living a repeating cycle inside of his holding room. Which happens to be circular in shape. He cycles for exercise. Which could also symbolize an effort to make progress but not moving anywhere... pedaling a cycle, but remaining stationary. The fishbowl. The records spinning in a repeating cycle on the record player. I'm sure I missed even more, but these little things make the scenes so much better.
51
u/mollzberg May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
"Hi Dad."
Saw that coming.
48
u/dragonman8001 The Only Good Synth Is A Dead One May 14 '18
That final Delos confrontation felt like a boss fight out of a horror game.
The way he was riding on his bike and just slowly got off to look in the mirror to see his damaged face?!
N I G H T M A R E M O D E
33
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
So, this was my mom’s first episode. She asked about William (during his “you’re sitting right across from him” moment), “so, is he good or bad?”
I don’t know anything anymore.
16
u/Rvictorromeo May 14 '18
Wow what a great episode! Here’s what I think:
William and Delos were logging guest DNA before they had perfected putting a human consciousness into a host. I’m hoping the idea was that they eventually wanted to offer the rich a way to live forever, and not to secretly replace powerful people with hosts in some weird world domination plot.
As we see with Jim, Delos wasn’t able to perfect the process. After 30 years, William calls off the project. When he earlier said something like: “it’s my greatest mistake”, he was probably referring to this program.
So they can’t put humans into hosts, but they still have a ton of data logged on rich and presumably important people. I guess this is what’s in abernathys head, and It makes sense that Delos corporate wants it badly (its both innately valuable, but also maybe incriminating). I feel pretty comfortable with this understanding.
The rest I am not sure of. Is this data trove the “weapon” Delores was referring to? Could she use the data to make human like copies of the rich and powerful in order to control the world and destroy humanity? Is Ford still behind all of this? Is ford alive and what Dolores shot in last episode of season one just a ford host that we saw Bernard making?
Suuch a good episode!!
80
u/AmericanIdiom Bulk Apperception: 2 May 14 '18
We're in Altered Carbon territory now.
67
u/K_U May 14 '18
Thank god the Grace = Theresa bullshit was curb-stomped to death this episode.
15
u/I_EDIT_PODCASTS May 14 '18
I don’t trust Bernard.
15
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
When Stubbs opened his eyes and the tribe was gone, what happened?
76
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
SHOGUNWORLD HYPE
14
u/XwingatAliciousnes May 14 '18
Listen: Bernard Lowe has come unstuck in time.
14
u/ef721 May 14 '18
I bet season 1 MiB was trying to solve the maze, as he thought it would be the key to breaking through the cognitive plateau that the control units hit. He wanted to figure out how hosts could attain sentience, so that he could implement the same strategy in his control units(?).
14
u/ziggurqt May 14 '18
Cracked up at the dude who killed Hector in the very first episode. You and your stupid fucking fantasy...
70
u/apple2gs May 14 '18
So Bernard totally printed a copy of Williams daughter right? That is part of Fords game for him. That has to be what ford sent Bernard there for.
39
u/kinkysnowman May 14 '18
FORD IS COMING BACK 100% MARK MY WORDS
26
u/TaciturnWeirdo May 14 '18
Does Shogun World have parallel versions of Westworld hosts?
13
u/kingofthemonsters May 14 '18
Best episode of the season by a wide margin.
54
u/RawScallop May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
What does Bernard keep whispering wtf....
Wtf Arnold
"Oh programmers dead so Im released"
Yeeeea
34
u/K_U May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
So this episode definitely strengthens and/or confirms a lot of the overarching theories that have been going since the start of the season. William's "greatest mistake" was a facility that was attempting to clone people, which stands to reason that Dolores sees this as a weapon as a way to get off the island, in host bodies that look like real people. Trojan Host Theory baby, get on board.
As i said in a comment earlier in the week:
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
Glad they didn't tease out the Grace daughter reveal for a long while
12
u/Porkins47 May 14 '18
Episode 5 "The Last Android": Maeve and Hector search for Tom Cruise's host body to defeat the evil Japanese imperialists controlling Shogunworld.
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '18 edited May 14 '18
Was talking with my wife about Delos Sr. and his dying lines before the conflagration. The writers did an incredible job of juxtaposing, potentially, Alzheimer's or another degenerative mental illness and how the hosts are wiped then endlessly repeat their loops.
This seems to characterize the fundamental flaw in trying to "immortalize" man in a host body. For the hosts, repetition and improvisation are the building blocks of consciousness. However, for man it appears that repetition deconstructs an existing framework for consciousness.
Management viewed hosts as a vehicle for immortality for exisiting people. Robert viewed them as the next stage of evolution, with the ability for them to selfdetermine their own destiny though I think it took him a while to get there.
Terrific food for thought and great episode.
12
u/theseyeahthese May 14 '18
This episode showed me how much I only really care about MiB’s story. It was actually nice not having Dolores and Maeve around. Ed Harris is badass.
40
u/SutterCane May 14 '18
Everybody, remember the pact we made.
If Elsie dies, we riot.
22
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
Shits getting all slicey dicey next week.
22
u/RekklesDriver May 14 '18
Bernard with the curbstomp. Jesus.
11
u/AnnieCheyenne May 14 '18
Every week the imagery in this show gets me hyped for Red Dead 2
11
u/machine_made Hell is Empty May 14 '18
So quick thoughts after tonight’s episode:
Ford knew about the secret labs.
Which means Ford knew they were bringing a copy of Delos online over and over to create a functional replacement consciousness (calling Lazarus from his cave—reinforced with that line appearing in the episode intro).
This makes me wonder about William’s line in Season 1: “You could say I was born here.”
Hmm.
30
u/digitchecker May 14 '18
Best episode of the series. Don’t @ me.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2.1k
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
1.2k
u/[deleted] May 14 '18 edited May 15 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
86
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment