r/electronics • u/badon_ • Jun 08 '19
General Chilean engineer Ricardo Salaverry chose AA batteries for the world's most popular pocket camera system - This is the story behind the design's success
https://www.electronicdesign.com/analog/picture-perfect-box-camera-system-design
213
Upvotes
33
u/badon_ Jun 08 '19 edited Jun 08 '19
Originally from my comment in r/AAMasterRace, brief excerpts:
That's fascinating. The profit margin on a successful $100 digital camera is only about $20. I did not know that, but it makes sense, since 20% profit is a common goal in many industries. Even more interesting is the fact the cameras only have $40 in parts. I did not know that either. It's fascinating to know what it costs to make something, and how much of your purchase price is profit for the company.
"A good problem to have" is a phrase I thought only I used. Was this article written by me?
I did a bunch more research on this camera system. It's true hundreds of millions of them were sold, which is amazing for any product. The MarketWire link in the article about the popularity of the design didn't work for me, but I found it in another location:
The article says the system is device is called Cammini, but Zoran refers to it as COACH (Camera On A CHip). I found the terms seem to be used interchangeably:
This article talks about COACH, but not Cammini:
I thought this article was especially interesting because it contrasted the good engineering of the AA battery design with the author's own experience with a failed product that chose to use a non-replaceable lithium battery design.
If you don't include the chargers, you're not fully accounting for the size and weight of the product. That's why the sidebar of r/AAMasterRace is specific about including the chargers:
Since you can't have spares with a non-replaceable battery, you're forced to carry around the charger (and stay close to walls with power outlets). With AA batteries, spares weigh about as much as a charger, so I usually don't need the charger. What does that mean? NO WAITING! NO WALLS! NO POWER OUTLETS! NO WIRES!
I'm truly wireless with AA batteries. "Mobile phone" is a bit of an oxymoron if it doesn't take AA batteries, haha.
17
u/slartibartfist Jun 08 '19
Oooo... Thanks for posting this. Fascinating. And the lessons: modularity, zillions of test pads, and the "don't take shortcuts just because it's a prototype" stuff - that applies across just about any industry. Great article.
8
u/superwester Jun 08 '19
Wow. Im a chilean ee student. Electronics is my passion and this gives me a boost of hope that i will have the chance to build interesting stuff for a living.
3
u/mrwillbill Jun 10 '19
Holy cow! Ricardo Salaverry interviewed me for an internship position almost 10 years ago! I didn't really know who he was or that he was so accomplished until right now. I ended up interning at a different group at the same company but probably would have learned more working with him.
4
u/TheBlueShovel Jun 08 '19
God I love those guys, LT is always my first choice because they will actually come out and help, and ltspice.
Probably because they dont have field app engineers, frickin dinks.
This guy is like a god to me, he advanced out of his LT position to TI who I hate, but they usually make good chips. I liked reading about his designs, all the test points and connectors for extra signals. I'm the only one at my company who regularly does this, it's a pet peeve.
4
u/EkriirkE anticonductor Jun 08 '19
For the longest time I would only buy a digital camera if it used standard batteries so I wasn't locked into manufacturer proprietary expensive packs
1
u/tomoldbury Jun 16 '19
This is fantastic! Very good advice for an EE.
1
u/JCDU Jun 08 '19
Oh jeebus if only all dev boards were designed by this guy.
0
u/Hsker1989 Jun 08 '19
,,,,,, x ?