r/BatwomanTV • u/IIIToxIII • Dec 10 '19
Crossover Discussion Batwoman [S01E09] "Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part Two" Post Episode Discussion Spoiler
Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part Two
Live Episode Discussion | Promo | Scene | Crisis Cast & Characters
The group uses Ray's invention to track new recruits to help save the universe. The Monitor sends Iris, Clark and Lois in search of a mysterious Kryptonian, while Kate and Kara head out to find Bruce Wayne. In addition, Mia challenges Sara, Rory discovers a hidden talent, and Lex Luthor returns. (Dec 9, 2019)
Crisis on Infinite Earths Schedule
| Part | Subreddit | Air Date and Time | Discussions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part 1: Supergirl | r/SupergirlTV | Sunday, December 8 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 2: Batwoman | r/BatwomanTV | Monday, December 9 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 3: The Flash | r/FlashTV | Tuesday, December 10 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 4: Arrow | r/arrow | Tuesday, January 14 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 5: Legends of Tomorrow | r/LegendsOfTomorrow | Tuesday, January 14 at 9pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
More Information about Crisis in this Subreddit
Please keep all discussion civil and about the episode. Mark comic and future spoilers. Report any rule breaking and enjoy!
Brought you to by the mods of r/Arrow, r/FlashTV, r/SupergirlTV, r/BatwomanTV, r/LegendsofTomorrow, r/SupermanandLois, r/StargirlTV, r/BlackLightning, r/ArrowAndTheCanaries, and r/DCTV!
9
u/DaGreatestMH Luke Fox Dec 10 '19
Yall are really impossible to please. People say they hated that Oliver was dead and he gets brought back and you mad. You say there's not enough character interaction so we get that but you still mad. You say the cameos are too short so we get essentially an episode full of extensive ones and you still mad. Smdh.
212
u/PeterQueen Dec 10 '19
Brandon’s supeerman mentioned his son Jason! From Superman returns.
2
u/Segal27 Dec 10 '19
Was that our Mick and Constantine on the alternate Waverider or the Earth-74's?
2
u/iitsWaVe Dec 10 '19
They have to bring Lucifer into this, imagine Lucifer and Constatine meeting
276
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Seeing a wonderful end to Smallville is something I will remember for the rest of my life. Clark has given up his powers, lives on farm and has girls with Lois. That's a good ending I can live with.
105
u/thingsandfluff Dec 10 '19
I really liked all the Kate and Kara scenes. Good pairing. They need to do a supergirl and Batwoman crossover
188
u/dragonman8001 Dec 10 '19
I loved it.
Smallville could care less about Luthor's bullshit
82
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Genuinely hoping Kevin Conroy returns as Bruce Wayne at some point. Maybe not modern day Earth-1 Bruce, but I would love to see him in a Beyond type role.
With that out of the way: Hoooo, so much more active than Part 1. Smallville’s Happy Ending, Returns Superman’s entire arc, Harbinger slowly being corrupted. Good stuff!
158
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I like Kevin Conroy as much as any Bat fan, but for the story at large, I like what they did with him here.
My only real criticism is the Lazarus Pit plot, because I just have a hard time believing Sara would entertain doing it. She's held the Spear of Destiny and still was able to understand it'd be a bad idea to revive her sister, she's EXPERIENCED the resurrection from the Pit, she's not new to this.
76
u/Sawalha_ Dec 10 '19
This episode makes the Spectre Theory plausible. I think the Monitor is going to use Oliver's body as a host for the Spectre to defeat the anti-monitor.
72
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I’ve honestly thought they’ve done a good job of balancing all the characters so far, but I think Lyla should’ve collected everyone in the episodes leading up to Crisis and saved cameos and earth jumping for these episodes.
69
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
I’m liking the crossover a lot so far. I figured Tom Welling would only have a small scene, but him giving up his powers (somehow) in order to have kids with Lois was sweet. Glad he gets a happy ending to his story.
Kevin Conroy as a Bruce Wayne who absolutely lost his way was fantastic. And he did the voice. Really glad he was in the bulk of the episode too, didn’t think we’d get that much of him. Was also happy to see that Luke got included. Didn’t think we’d get to see any of the Batwoman cast so that was a neat surprise.
Routh’s Superman is perfect as well and I’m looking forward to seeing more of him in the other parts. His fight against Tyler was really cool.
There’s also all the little extra tidbits, musical cues and themes that they had, bringing back Wentworth Miller so we could have Lenard as the Gideon of the Waverider, Jonah Hex on that Earth with the pit. Also loved seeing Constantine again, always enjoy seeing him on my screen.
I do feel like the story slowed down a bit, which is fine. Didn’t really expect 5 episodes of them trying to fight the Anti-Monitor. The character moments have been great though and I do appreciate them changing up the pairings. Can’t wait until tomorrows episode and I can’t wait to watch all five back to back.
68
u/AnnaK22 Batwoman I Dec 10 '19
When I started watching The Arrowverse in 2015 with Supergirl, I never ever thought I'd see a day where we get Brandon Routh and Tom Welling reprising their roles again. How have we come so far so fast.
That classic Superman tune mixed with TylerSuperman tune was incredible. Again, good job Blake Neely.
65
u/ChandlerForrestal Alice Dec 10 '19
I knew Kate would’ve taken the kryptonite!
188
u/_Elder_ Dec 10 '19
If I get Tom Ellis as Lucifer to save Oliver’s soul tomorrow, I will become the biggest hypebeast of all time.
61
u/Takemebacktomania Dec 10 '19
I didn’t realize how satisfying it was to watch retired Tom Welling punch Lex Luthor like it was nothing
51
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Someone else mentioned in the live thread about Injustice being a possible crossover event and I like that idea. Idk where you go post Crisis.
45
u/Rebornhunter Dec 10 '19
KC Superman made my night. They straight up reference Superman III, Returns, and used the exact scenario that pushed him to give up in Kingdom Come. Even used Alex Ross's art panel from the book! Even used the music from the original movies when Lois and Clark meet
The Smallville Coda was icing on the cake, As I remember watching the final episode live.
and Conroy's Bruce... while not exactly how I pictured it, hearing THAT voice coming down the stairs....I was a kid again tonight. And after a tough year, I needed it.
Im sure folks have issues with the episode... but i am throughly entertained and content
42
u/TirelessGuardian Mouse Dec 10 '19
The anti monitor talks and is not just a giants robot thing? He looks like darts vadar without a mask!
36
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Seeing Tom Welling in Crisis Of Infinite Earths is my high light of my life
33
u/theamatuer Dec 10 '19
I love how Lex Luthor finds out that Clark Kent is Superman from every reality he goes to and still refuses to believe that his own Clark Kent is Superman
32
u/SlashGames Dec 10 '19
Why was Nash shown after every episode last week if he had one scene so far and wasn’t even in the second episode? Does Pariah have a bigger role in the comics besides witnessing the deaths of Earths?
31
u/Edgelord420666 Dec 10 '19
Why was the Lazarus pit so small? Thing looked like a puddle
61
u/SaidTheTickTockMan Dec 10 '19
I posted this in the live thread, but for those who don't know, Smallville Clark's ending is almost certainly a reference to Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? written by Alan Moore. It was written as the figurative ending to the silver age Superman, just after the comics (i.e. original) crisis on infinite earths finished and superman's origin was due to be rebooted. Superman defeats all of his enemies in a final battle, but is forced to break his code and kill. In penance he depowers himself and disappears, secretly retiring to live with Lois.
58
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I've seen zero mention of it, but Johnathan interrupting The Monitor was hilarious, and then Mick reading him his saucy romance novel.
28
u/AnnaK22 Batwoman I Dec 10 '19
Baby Jon gives zero shits about The Monitor, his plans or the paragons. I love him already.
26
u/Oliverqueensharkbite Dec 10 '19
Oh so NOW we get to bring Oliver back with a Lazarus Pit. Tatsu would like a word.
Mia being not only tolerable but understandable?? And bonding with Sara?? Please please please don’t regress her. She is quickly growing on me and I hated her for most of the last two seasons.
Mick is the best babysitter and writer on any earth. I will not be taking questions at this time. And I am SO GLAD they got Snart back even as an AI.
“I kinda promised the team no more crossovers.”
Kate and Kara should team up all of the time. They are so good together. And I know a lot of people aren’t watching Batwoman but it’s a good show. I like how poor Kate has gone from “I can’t be Gotham’s hero” to a hero of the multiverse. She handles it well despite her misgivings.
Routh as Superman. Routh as Superman! That is all.
49
u/JakeM917 Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
“The end of the entire multiverse is imminent. The stakes have never been higher. We are running out of time and we need to make our stand. Now Kate, go to Earth-99 and talk to a future version of your cousin for an hour to figure out something I could tell you right now. Lois, Kal-El, and Iris, check every single universe with a Superman and see if he’s the paragon. They’re all pretty much the same but do your best. Lex, take the Book of Destiny and wreak havoc across the multiverse. Harbinger, take a nap, you must be tired. As for the rest of you, do whatever you want, I don’t give a fuck.”
— The Monitor
24
u/Queen_Raiden Dec 10 '19
I'd like to see a bigger reaction from Ray finding out he has a Superman doppelganger, but at least they interacted. Maybe there will be more in the other episodes.
24
u/BornAshes Luke Fox Dec 10 '19
I just wanted to point out how awesome Constantine was in this episode and just how powerful what he did was. This guy freakin cast a locator spell that scanned MULTIPLE universes across the multiverse in order to find what amounted to a needle in a haystack using a cigarette and juuuust the right set of words. How incredible is THAT!?!?! That is like some level 20 wizard stuff right there!
23
u/iornhide132 Dec 10 '19
I know some people are a bit split on this episode, but I gotta say, I liked this episode way more than yesterday's episode. I like that it was more character based and had a better pace. I know some people are complaining about the slower pace, and having less action, and feeling a bit less urgent, but what I love about the crossovers are the interactions between characters and the fanservice, which this episode has lots of.
18
u/cowboys5xsbs Dec 10 '19
RIP Batman he was great
18
u/VitaUser Dec 10 '19
"My parents taught me a different lesson. The world only makes sense if you force it to"
Straight out of Batman v Superman, right? Conroy was amazing!
17
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I’m thinking Cisco will be a paragon - that’s how he’ll get his powers back
15
u/atomic1fire Dec 10 '19
I can't believe they made Batman a bad guy.
14
u/Wizardplum Dec 10 '19
I was about to start laughing so hard because I thought the monitor was going to say Mick was a paragon
13
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Some people may be pissed about Kevin Conroy being evil but i really liked that twist. I did not see that coming. I thought he might be a kingdom come kind of batman... Broken but not beaten and still a good man... nope. The multiverse provided a batman who looked into the abyss and when it looked back... he blinked. He was more like a Frank Miller version. I do hope there is a massive fight where a good version shows up and utters that iconic I am batman line. They are clearly building things up for the finale in 2020 and I can't wait!!! Maybe Paragon of Truth superman will bring his friends into the fight and that's where kevin conroy will reappear along with wonder woman and others.
12
u/nomadic_stalwart Dec 10 '19
I wonder if Routh Superman is gonna fill the role of Earth 2 Superman from the comics. And with the introduction of Titans, maybe in a future crossover they’ll do Infinite Crisis.
22
u/stu_25 Dec 10 '19
Well the cameos were great, seeing all the universes is great fun... while they last.
Novu is a dick, killed Earth-90 last year, allowed Lex to murder Supermen just to lead them to Not-Ray and allowed them to kill Earth-99 mad Batman!
All the interactions, all the adventures within one big story is really fun and building up towards the final battle. Kinda like End Game with the different missions.
Not keen on having an AU Legends though.. since Constantine appears from Earth-1... hopefully it wasn't just to make another "crossover" joke. But Snart-Giedon is cool
Oliver in the Lazarus Pit is an interesting move, though his death yesterday was badass so a little disappointed but not surprised.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Kevin Conroy's Batman voice on a live action Bruce Wayne is amazing
11
u/NatAwsom1138 Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
Wow that was crazy. Let's see what I can keep track of:
I could go on, but those are the first things that come to mind. Wow I am loving this crossover so far. It's really entertaining, there's fan service galore, and I love how it's expanding the multiverse to include so many DC properties. I can't believe we're only two episodes in, with 3 more to go.
Al I know is that while we're waiting for the last two episodes in January, I'm going to be doing A LOT of catching up on the some of the shows that are now technically part of the Arrowverse.
11
u/butterball1 Dec 10 '19
Smallville. Worlds Finest. Mick Rorie with a Superbaby. Paragons. This was like the happiest episode of Batwoman ever!
9
u/DaJohnnyB23 Dec 10 '19
Was anyone else getting pseudo Injustice vibes with E-99 Bruce?
9
u/glitterydick Dec 10 '19
Can I just say how disappointed I was that Terry Mcginnis wasn't the batman of the future?
17
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Fan theory from me: based on all these paragons, and Kara resolving to use the book to bring back earth 38.....my prediction is at the end of all this, the heros will all use the book together to ensure all Earth's everywhere have the paragons on theirs. They start with earth 1 being a combo.of 1, 2, and 38.and then all Earth's based off that earth and beyond.
17
u/the_456_Ambassador Dec 10 '19
Gathering the paragons feel more like a pre crisis filler episode type thing. I would think the actual "Crisis on Infinite Earths" would be more like the Earth-X crossover with two powerful forces at war with each other.
Splitting the episode into these three subplots makes each of them feel pretty bare bones straightforward.
With all this talk about the crisis and how it's the end of everything, we still don't know why any of this is happening or who the Anti-Monitor and his shadow demons are.
And I really don't see the point in killing Oliver in the first part if they were just going to just immediately resurrect him. It feels like they just needed to fill in screen time. Death has felt really cheap and impermanent on Arrow particularly and this doesn't help.
On the other hand, it's cool seeing:
8
u/darknightgotham Dec 10 '19
This episode was interesting, I really liked it, especially loved everything related to Brandon Superman (and seeing him share the screen with Ray was great). But I have to admit, the pacing felt a bit off in some parts, mainly the Oliver-related scenes, felt like they were dragging it a bit so it happens in the Flash episode instead. I am however really curious about how itll turn out, wonder what they're gonna do to get his soul back if Constantine can't help. And I am not eager to get to the inevitable heartbreak where he has to sacrifice himself all over again ;-;
7
u/flintlock0 Dec 10 '19
The Brandon Routh Superman should’ve looked that baby right in the face and said “I’m your Daddy now.”
r/technicallythetruth
7
u/greyjackal Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
I made notes while watching it.
Leonard! And Mick!
"You had me at beer."
Oh Mick you cute bastard
"Bruce Wayne is the Dark Knight?" Oh Ray...
Oh don't put the guest stars on the screen before they turn up, dammit....
Fucking Lex....
KEVIN!!!
MATT!!
TOM!! (and damn he looks good) Nice twist too
Yay, Brandon Kent!
Fucking Lex....
Oh that tune
About time someone twatted that annoying Lex
Bloody hell, I wasn't expecting Jonah Hex
Lovely BvS (comic) references
Saw that Paragon of Courage coming a mile off😄
Ruby and Melissa have excellent chemistry
Oh, like cousin, like...cousin? Sneaky batses.
Aaand Anti-M looks like a scrotum.
Great episode :D
Edit - also, they seem to be more "general" episodes than previous crossovers. Sure, Kate was in this a bit, and the Bat story took up a chunk but it wasn't as focused on Bats as it would have been last year. Same with Supergirl yesterday. They're advancing the whole plot. And I like it. It means the final 3 hour, 45 minutes could easily be watched as a film.
7
u/JakeM917 Dec 10 '19
Now that Lex knows that Superman is Clark Kent on Earth-96 and Earth-167 do you think he might start putting 2 and 2 together?
7
u/Khalizabeth Dec 10 '19
Loved Snideon
7
u/Eternal_Density Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
Well that's certainly a way to get a Waverider without the rest of the Legends. (well, barring Constantine and Mick. So we've got 4 of the legends and all the surviving originals! (the hawks don't count since they're off being baristas or whatever)) I sure was not expecting the voice of Snart!
Ha, Tom Welling still isn't playing Superman :P Funny seeing Erica as Lois again. That was a nice little sendoff to Smallville :D
The other earths visited continue to be fascinating! Including alt-Luke and alt-Beth!
Supes vs. Supes was a fun use of Lex.
Supermen are dropping like flies, one to Lex and another to Batman!
I kept hoping Kara would bring up the Lena situation with Kate. Oh well.
Hmm, looks like Kara's gonna try getting E-38 back. On one hand I like the idea of her and her people sticking on Earth 1, on the other hand there's M'gann and Malefic on Mars-38 so... I'm kinda torn. But it seems weird to go through all that evacuation drama to just undo it. I feel it's more likely to fail with consequences, or just go weird.
edit: ooor Kate stops her with the kryptonite? (not my theory but I like it)
I had another comment to make and I've already forgotten it. I didn't keep notes like I did yesterday.
Oh yeah I remember now. It's hilarious that while Lex now knows about Supermans being Clark Kents, he absolutely does not believe that his own earth's Superman is Clark Kent :P
7
u/redloveone Dec 10 '19
Did anyone get a clear shot of that trophy case? I definetly saw the riddler's cane.
13
u/MrBubbles9039 Dec 10 '19
This seems to be going really slow. It's good but slow. I'm a little worried of how they will continue. In the comics all the paragons were already brought together in like the first issue. Not enough pariah and too many separate plot points
6
u/AnnaK22 Batwoman I Dec 10 '19
Noo Kate why!!! I'm wondering if Kate will use the kryptonite now , during this crossover, or save it for the next time we see them meet.
6
u/LightningLad2029 Dec 10 '19
I know it's really because of budget limitations but man... I'm so sick of these bs excuses for not bringing in more heroes to help. The fucking multiverse is getting wiped out, nobody cares about the Legends not wanting to do another crossover.
6
u/szeto326 Dec 10 '19
It would feel weird if Tom Welling got to put a suit on now I feel. Glad that’s how they executed his involvement in the crossover.
6
u/galkardm Dec 10 '19
I've got zero history on Smallville seeing only maybe a few episodes... But I enjoy how an unpowered farmboy just annoyed the absolute shit out of Lex Luthor and his magic book. It absolutely crushed Lex that he gave up his power... and he got to punch him in the face.
I loved Old Man Clark and Old Man Conroy.
There was so much to both of them in an extremely limited amount of time.
6
u/Barry_McKackiner Dec 10 '19
Glad smallville supes has a happy ending though it's kind of a bummer he's now powerless & unable to save anyone anymore. And i'm shocked he would do so with Lex still there as a threat.
6
u/TapatioPapi Dec 10 '19
I’m confused why did they use a whole different Mick, instead of our normal Mick?
And second Sara’s “I promised the team no more cross overs” had me dead.
6
u/ThaCrit Dec 10 '19
I know there was a lot of tidbits this episode but can we just take a moment to admire what an absolute treasure Mick is.
16
u/shadow_spinner0 Dec 10 '19
There were many things I liked about this episode but boy did Kara look mighty fine in this episode, like better than usual.
2
u/Denzema123 Dec 10 '19
Why has Barry been so sidelined in this two Crisis episodes? Barry is such an important character but has very little lines it amazes me. Batwoman, Mia, Lois, Clark, Kara, almost everybody has more lines than Barry. It’s like Grant pissed off someone in the writers room, Barry feels so left out in crisis. It originally way suppose to be about him so hopefully they fix that or I’m gonna be pissed. Back siding Barry is stupid.
11
u/Kbye80 Dec 10 '19
Two questions:
5
u/FinalForerunner Dec 10 '19
Wasn't it confirmed there was a scene with 3 Supermen? I'd say I'd want Tom to come back and wear a suit but honestly that ending was pretty perfect.
I really enjoyed Conroy's on-screen Batman performance, I don't mind that they went with this evil Batman route, it's a parallel earth.
Was also really happy they had Ray and Supes face to face, Kara looked so absolutely confused lmao.
5
u/WeiShenMotherFucker Dec 10 '19
Its a small thing, but I like how after a short MoS skirmish, a mind controlled and conflicted Reeve/Routh Superman still absolutely bodies E38 Superman. Really shows what kind of beast we're dealing with.
I love what they did with Conroy's Batman, but I wish he survived. Redemption could've been more interesting and his death was far too sudden.
5
u/FPX_NooGiN Dec 10 '19
I'm not going to lie. When they said batman of the future, I thought they were about to drop a batman beyond Terry McGinnis tie-in. Dreams are dreams though.
5
u/BigHaircutPrime Dec 10 '19
I hate to be pessimistic, but so far I feel like Crisis is a bit of a mess. For the monitor to go, "Oh I just found out about Paragons today," feels really random and shortsighted. I think my problem is that it feels like 90% of the team is just sitting on the bench right now, and what cool scenes we do get are rushed and half-baked. It's a little unfocused for me.
I know it'll get better. We'll get this third episode, and then I'm assuming the 2-hour finale in January will be mainly action and constant forward momentum. But seriously though, what the heck was Lex's plan? I get he hates Superman, but if Paragons are the only hope, he wouldn't have just have a Superman-less multiverse, but no multiverse at all. You'd think the smartest man in the world would be more clever.
5
u/WillboSwaggins Dec 10 '19
This is my favorite crossover episode of all time. Hands down. And it’s only gonna get better from here.
Some quick thoughts:
-Novelist-nanny Mick is best Mick.
-I fell off of Legends in season 4 and whatever Cold AI that’s in Gideon’s place now was a surprise. Just that voice reminded me of how much I miss Wentworth Miller. He made that show for me.
-I love Brandon’s Superman. I’m so happy he gets to don the cape again for a story worth his talent.
-The only Lex that comes anywhere close to Jon Cryer’s Lex for me is the one from the DC animated universe. Cryer’s version is the most honest adaptation of how I see that character. A genius sociopath with a little bit of theater gay in him. The way he said “Clarke” to Smallville and then flamboyantly opened the portal was just perfect.
-I’ve never watched Smallville, but that Supe getting the good life warmed my heart. I can’t imagine what it was like for fans of the show.
-Kevin Conroy was perfect as always. The way they wrote this Batman was fantastic, but I couldn’t help but be a little bummed he was just contained to this episode. Not saying he should’ve had a redemption arc, that would’ve taken the bite out of his villainy, but I just I just don’t care about Batwoman. Ruby Rose is awesome, but I just can’t get into a Gotham without Bruce. That’s just me though.
All I know is I’m gonna be pissed when the credits roll tomorrow night. Having a break in the middle of a crossover should be a goddamn crime.
5
u/MrTerrific2k15 Dec 10 '19
Old Bruce got Donna Troy'd
18
u/JakeM917 Dec 10 '19
So like, when they actually move the plot forward, this crossover is amazing. But there are so many slow moments. I only hope that by the last two episodes they cut all the fat and make this live up to the name Crisis on Infinite Earths.
15
u/DarkSaiyanKnight Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
I'm so confused and frustrated as to what they're doing with Oliver's character. It leaves a really sour taste in my mouth to see what they're doing with him. At this point I don't care if it was predicted by the entire internet I would have just had him been present across the crisis. I hold out hope and see if they can redeem themselves later on.
Also these past two episodes have been really low energy at least for me. I just feel like all the hype that we've had for about a year and the foreshadowing of crisis as this huge event it just feels very low scale. I just figured that there would be a little bit more state of panic, a little bit more dire pacing. Instead we just have a lot of downtime of just gathering people and doing pep talks.
I feel like this should feel like infinity war but it feels like end game.
11
u/snoogle20 Dec 10 '19
As crossovers go, Infinite Earths has been more Legends of Today/Tomorrow and Invasion! qualit than Earth-X or Elseworlds so far.
It’s always a thrill to see these characters together and I imagine there’s more fun to come, but the writing feels a bit haphazard, both in the plot realm and on character fronts. It’s all been fetch quests and fan service so far and it’s feeling a tad wheel-spinny.
Little A, B and C plot mini-quests have the scale feeling decidedly small despite me knowing the entire multiverse is at stake. I’m hoping it just means they’re saving budget for some sort of epic finale.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Clark and Lois being happy with kids Two Supermen fighting
4
u/OutsiderJediSam Dec 10 '19
I really liked this episode MORE than last nights bc it game me what I wanted, teamups b/t people you don't usually see together and especially CONVOS b/t said people that don't interact....but it did have two main issues
4
u/idontwanttobehere17 Dec 10 '19
Loved Kara’s reaction to Lex
4
u/indigofox83 Dec 10 '19
So most the cameo universes have some Easter egg with the number (earth 66 was Adam west batman, 90s flash is earth 90, etc).
Anyone know what earth 167 is a reference to for smallville? Could just be random but I feel like it's probably something.
4
u/Lithogen Dec 10 '19
Everybody's missing the detail that Superman 3 was re canonized in the Returns Universe, terrible movie but I do like its cheesiness.
4
u/Randothor Dec 10 '19
Man, what a bittersweet episode. Loved it though
It was really cool to see Kevin Conroy's Batman in live-action, even if he was evil, his voice gave me the chills.
Smallville Sups had a good cameo- I was kinda hoping to see him in the suit though. Brandon Routh's Superman was great. It is sad knowing that he lost his Lois, and Daily Planet friends (especially since Routh is supposedly Christopher Reeve's Superman, which I love) but it is great that unlike Injustice, it didn't break him. Also great bit of continuity that his son Jason is mentioned and fighting an evil doppleganger in Superman IV.
Jonah Hex and Leanard Snart, cameos were cool. Anti-monitor makes me hype.
Is Lyla/Harbinger going to kill Monitor like in the comics?
4
u/kamanitachi Dec 10 '19
In Doomsday Clock, Dr Manhattan says that Magic is “the discarded scraps of creation, wielded by those who society discarded.” So if most DC worlds follow this logic, it makes sense that Constantine lost his mojo. There’s no creation left to manipulate.
4
u/HiroJa Dec 10 '19
Just like a good little Bat always get the Kryptonite.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
For someone who is not as invested in this as various other people, I found that episode kind of slow. You have this crisis in which the entire multi-verse is being destroyed, and everyone is off on their own adventures. I did like the Welling Superman scene (Never saw Smallville), and I also liked seeing Routh's Superman again. Other than that, I found last night more gripping.
4
u/Sealwheeler9 Dec 10 '19
God, I absolutely loved the details with the different Supermen's in this episode. Brandon's Superman even had a different heat vision effect, which had just the right amount of old-timey-ness to it.
4
u/Thefeature Dec 10 '19
Tom Welling is my TV Superman. He was more Clark Kent and Superman in his scene, wearing flannel, than Tyler Hoechlin and Brandon Routh.
I hope he was using blue kryptonite and shows up to help make the save.
4
u/hoorahforsnakes Dec 10 '19
When it became clear bruce wasn't "the bat of tommorow", i was really hoping we'd see terry mcguiness show up.
4
u/The-Cod-Father Dec 10 '19
Potential plot hole:
Earth 38's Lex Luther told Smallville's Clark Kent/Superman and I quote "Clark Kent is Superman, where I come from that would be ridiculous, he can't see past is glasses".
Lex had only JUST then sent Iris West, and Earth 38's Lois Lane & Clark Kent back to the Wave Rider. So........................Is Lex actually an idiot?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I loved how bored SmallvilleClark looked at Lex's talk
10
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Can we lock this thread until a minute or two until the episodes done so idiots like those down below don’t spam the thread?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I guess he could come back into play but I think bringing Tom Welling back to not put him in a suit and utilise him as a bait and switch is insulting to anyone that watched and loved smallvile in the 10 years it's been on television. Who knows he may come back into it with powers but I'm starting to feel like DC doesn't quite get the potential they had with the crisis story
6
u/cardmasterdc Dec 10 '19
All the fan service made this episode really great for me and makes this crossover amazing
6
u/OmgItzAman Dec 10 '19
Holy shit you guys are judgmental as hell. The crossover was written to be collective, let's withhold our judgments till it's over you guys.
3
u/Skullripper675 Dec 10 '19
so how did smallville clark give up his powers? gold kryptonite pills or something?
3
u/nitua56 Dec 10 '19
Really good so far, can't wait for tomorrow. The long wait after that might kill me.
3
u/aflyingcrow Dec 10 '19
Is the dark matter spreading in two directions? Did it start at Earth X and then go both ways? I'm asking because I'm confused with them traveling to other Earths past the ones already destroyed
3
u/AnnaK22 Batwoman I Dec 10 '19
Something about the way The Monitor kept looking at the screen of paragon detector makes me think he's hiding something. Throughout the episode, I thought he was the anti monitor. But now we've actually seen him... but the again, we haven't seen them in the same room together so anything is possible.
The monitor has bee wrong about so much so far. Lex saving the world but he ends up stealing the book of destiny to destroy Supermen.
Kevin Conroy being a paragon.
3
u/Gateskp Dec 10 '19
I think I'm going to enjoy this episode more when I can watch it with all of them combined. I think the urgency of the multiverse about to be destroyed was lacking compared to yesterday. BUT. There were a lot of fantastic scenes, and I really enjoyed it overall even though it didn't always feel like they were in the middle of a crisis.
3
u/askthetruth1 Dec 10 '19
Does anyone know what was the thing that Lex stepped on in the Smallville universe?
3
u/Coffee_green Dec 10 '19
Dunno about Oliver in the Lazarus Pit. Seems like Sara should have fought against that more
3
u/ToneBone12345 Dec 10 '19
Ah was expecting Tom Welling to have a bigger role but I can live with a cameo! Also this felt just as if not more supergirl centric than supergirl last night I’m guessing part 3 three is going to end on cliff hanger of Kara sacrificing herself and vanishing instead of Barry!
Also was expecting earth 1 heat wave not earth 74 heatwave also love how he is the only one to stop Jonathan crying!
Also didn’t expect to see an alternate Jonah hex!
3
u/boringhistoryfan Dec 10 '19 edited Dec 10 '19
I have some trouble with the ending they gave Welling-Supes partly because it seems to break the continuity of Smallville itself, since it was repeatedly emphasized that Smallville Supes was a sort of eternal character there.
That said, its worth noting that Luthor is president in this universe so the potential for the apocalyptic outcomes envisaged by his presidency is very much on the horizon, so its not hard to imagine that soon after this intervention Superman somehow regains his powers. I'm imagining his version of Supergirl, the Manhunter, a Green Lantern or even Blue-Lantern Nightwing basically tossing him into the sun and reigniting his powers. Would certainly put the Smallville continuity back onto its rails and doesn't require too much bandaging to what the arrowverse creators did. And it did feel enormously respectful to Smallville. Especially the lazy sort of elder-parent attitude Welling had to all of them. He's really the grand-daddy to everyone in the Arrowverse.
PS: I will say that not having Welling be in a super suit is itself very respectful of the Smallville ethos. Welling being superman was fundamentally not the point of Smallville's story, so having him do a lot of supery stuff would kinda take away from it. It wasn't what I had expected from Smallville (I was kinda hoping he'd be a supes who doesn't intervene but gives them advice on the Anti-Monitor since he's dealt with the problem already, but I get that it would then take away from the "end is nigh" feeling of this story) but it was fairly satisfying.
3
u/BenjaminTalam Dec 10 '19
It is absolutely devastating to see Smallville conclude with Superman letting the multiverse be in peril and having no powers. Being Superman is about making personal sacrifices like not getting to gave a normal life. We spent 10 damn seasons learning this along with Clark. He finally accepted his destiny and this is how we end up?
I hope that was a fake out and Lex attacking him results in him finding a way to help in the crisis. Otherwise I'm pretty depressed.
Also I don't see what makes "kingdom come" Superman have anything to do with kingdom come so far. He's Donner Superman. Kingdom come involves Batman and other heroes and we found out Conroy wasn't Kingdom Come but some random earth where he went psycho.
3
u/admiralcinamon Dec 10 '19
If anything this makes me want a full live action show focusing on Conroy Batman.
3
u/smit1135 Dec 10 '19
I just want one of the paragons you be green lantern (diggle) . I feel like they are saving a suprise for us
3
u/myaltaccount333 Dec 10 '19
Taking bets: Oliver wakes up and is super pissed off and angry and tries to fight everyone. Except he has his soul and is just mad they used the pit on him
3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I liked what they did with Superman/Smallvile but I was not a fan of what they did with Batman. Initially I wasn't a huge fan of the dark/evil Batman twist but the more I sit on it the less I dislike it. I see the parallel between him and Dark Knight Returns Batman but this Batman is more of just a cold blooded killer than a the broken old man TDKR Bruce was. The thing I really didn't like was how they killed him off in five minutes to make BatWoman look good, I get the shows about BatWoman but you don't do that with Batman IMO. Maybe he'll come back or something but man that pissed me off.
3
u/gusefalito Dec 10 '19
Was that actually Wentworth Miller voicing the Earth-74 AI? They really went all out with this event
3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Lex's "On this earth, Clark Kent is Superman. Where I come from that would be stupid, he can't see past his glasses"
3
u/edd6pi Jacob Kane Dec 10 '19
I should have said this in the thread for part one but I think it’s pretty cool how whenever there’s a crossover, Oliver starts giving orders and everyone just obeys unquestioningly. They all just accept him as their military leader.
5
u/Ethosa3 Dec 10 '19
Great episode!!!
Satisfying happy ending for Smallville Clark, Brandon Routh's Superman was as majestic as I imagined, and Lois just being enamored by every version of Clark Kent. Loved that bit.
Really like how they're developing Kate and Kara's relationship, and the implications of Kate taking the kryptonite. She's probably gonna use it to stop Kara from using the Book to bring E-38 back, the Monitor did mention that it would "drive one to madness". It would be saving Kara from herself, but man it would be painful as hell.
6
u/emxlyy Dec 10 '19
Anyone else kinda like disappointed so far? Like I can see where it’s going but I feel like everything’s so slow burn and we’re nearly half way through now??? I’m hoping tomorrow is action filled and if lucifer turns up I will eat my words
7
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Idk why but this just seems super disappointing.. idk if it’s the pacing or what
4
u/Cptkiljoy Dec 10 '19
I'm sorry but why even put something like this up during the episode. I would just have one after it's done
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
God I wish they met Lucifer that episode. Well there’s still hope.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Bruce arc was kinda disappointing, feels like a disservice making Conroy evil. Other than that this was pretty solid
4
u/flintlock0 Dec 10 '19
Haha.
What if they had brought Oliver back and then he immediately drowned in the pool?