r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • u/NicholasCajun • Mar 17 '20
Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x01 "Part 1" - Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 1: Part 1
Aired: March 16, 2020
Synopsis: Herman Levin, anticipating a promotion at work, takes his family to look at a house in an upwardly mobile neighborhood, though Bess is wary of leaving the safety of their tight-knit Jewish community and raising a family amid growing anti-Semitism sparked by Lindbergh's ascendancy. As the family spinster, her sister Evelyn has a disappointing rendezvous with a married lover, but later, finds herself charmed by a distinguished local clergyman, Rabbi Lionel Bengelsdorf. Meanwhile, getting an earful from Herman for being fired from his job, his orphaned nephew, Alvin Levin seeks retaliation for an aggrieved friend.
Directed by: Minkie Spiro
Written by: Ed Burns & David Simon
Please use spoiler tags when discussing elements from the book and any episode previews.
Use this format: >!Spoiler!< - it will show as Spoiler.
21
u/WestboundPachyderm Mar 17 '20
God, I’m looking forward to this. I’ve wanted to read the book for more than a decade, now. You know how it is, too many books, too little time and I just never got around to this one, but I was thrilled to learn about this limited series just last week. Anxiously awaiting and I’ll see y’all on the other side!
17
u/facu_draper Mar 17 '20
Awesome first episode. If I look at the story objectively it just looks like far-fetched fictional dystopia. But thinking that all that stuff really happened ( i know FDR won , I mean the war, Nazis , the context) makes the show super disturbing. Cant wait for the next episode!
12
u/spiker311 Mar 17 '20
Don't know anything about the book but I'm really looking forward to this one.
9
u/daniddr Mar 17 '20
Great Start, Simon doesn't dissapont
7
u/vid00d Mar 20 '20
Sports goof, in case anyone cares:
As the family sits down to dinner, one character asks another about the Yankee game, mentioning that "Brooklyn beat them again," or something to that effect.
For those who aren't aware, the Yankees played in the American League during 1940 (and still do), while Brooklyn played in the National League. Unlike today, teams in the American League and the National League don't play each other, except in the World Series. The World Series takes place in October, and the show takes place in the summer. Thus, there was no way that Brooklyn could have faced the Yankees on that day.
Quite a big mistake for a show that's supposed to capture the essence of life in the 1940s.
5
u/datniggymanaj Mar 19 '20
I personally thought the first episode was a little slow.
4
u/stefantalpalaru Mar 27 '20
This modern history rewriting trend is weird. Why would anyone in 1940s America call Nazis "Fascists"? It would have been like calling Germans "Italians".
Also, the "Fascists hate Jews" line is anachronistic. The Italian "racial laws" from '38 were a requirement for the "Steel Pact" alliance with Germany in '39.
The actual Fascists rose to power in Italy in 1922 and they were obsessed with regaining the former glory of the Roman Empire, not with persecuting Jews like German National Socialists.
Fun fact: guess who else was dreaming about recreating the Roman Empire, recycling the same symbols? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces#United_States
3
u/MookieMoo17 Mar 18 '20
Very strong first episode, I’d never heard of the book so I came into this blind. Found all the characters really intriguing and was convinced Alvin was going to get killed when they went to beat up the two Nazi’s. We’ve been so spoiled in the age of binging that I don’t wanna wait 5 days, damn it. I’m in, I’m hooked.
3
u/Droolings Mar 19 '20
Loved the episode. Kind of chilling seeing the overlaps in politics from 1940 to today.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '20
Gee, I wonder if this can be viewed as an allegory to anything.
2
u/MarcusBrutus2000 Mar 17 '20
This has been an excellent start. Was waiting for it and it seems to be delivering
2
u/MyChanceToDrive Mar 17 '20
Finally, I’m about to watch. So, I will be back here in 57 minutes.
2
u/MyChanceToDrive Mar 18 '20
The angles that this series will take are going to be thought provoking. From the rabbi to the young stamp collector are characters that will have me waiting for the next episode. Does Turturro’s character have a southern drawl?
2
u/KingJeffreyJoffa Mar 18 '20
I never read the book, but as a person from Newark I find this show very interesting; how the rhetoric of a prominent person can awaken prejudices that were simmering just below the surface.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
Bit mixed on this start, to be honest. What I love about Simon's work is that he tends to look at issues from all levels, but it looks like the focus here will be on the Jewish community. As long as it gets going quickly, that will be fine, but right now there feels like there's some distance between the family and the threat.
I'm interested in the two boys. The older one liking Limburgh is a strong angle, and they're setting up something with the younger one. We know he's a snitch, and he clearly has some kind of strange perspective on women. I wonder if we'll see the two align down the road.
2
u/Moezot Mar 20 '20
Excellent first episode, uncannily true to the book down to the smallest details & fascinating how well the tv version translates the first person narrative of the book into something far better (in my estimation). However, I fear Winona Ryder is badly miscast, not only because she's not a very actor and projects a kind of stunned shrillness that always makes it impossible for me to forget that she's *ACTING* but also, because they've basically rewritten her character. However, I think writing her as an older woman would have worked with a different actor - any number come to mind.
1
u/MyChanceToDrive Mar 18 '20 edited Mar 18 '20
SpoilerDiid anyone notice the rabbi Turtourro is portraying has a Southern drawl? I know that will be addressed in future episodes, but maybe I overlooked a hint.
1
u/ItsBobDoleYo Mar 18 '20
had fun spending half the episode trying to figure out who the sister character was (Winona Ryder)
1
u/IWW4 Mar 19 '20
That was a great first episode. The cast was excellent. It did a great job of fleshing out the characters and planting the seeds of where the story might go.
I have never read the book and I am loving what I am seeing thus far.
1
u/Porn_Steal Mar 21 '20
EDIT: I don't know what I'm doing wrong w.r.t. spoilers. Caution. If anyone can advise please do!
Question about perceived (on my part) difference between book and show:
>!I read the book several years ago. My recollection was the anti-semitism portrayed in the book was a lot more implicit than in the show so far. For example I remember Lindbergh's administration came up with a program that basically separate Jewish kids from their families to make them live with non-Jewish families, but they talked about it like, "We're giving urban children a chance to see what it's like to live in America's heartland and do real work," not explicitly saying it was targeting Jewish people.!<
Am I just remembering the book wrong though?
1
u/SawRub Apr 16 '20
I was unsure about starting this because a lot of reviews said it was "good but slow", and in quarantine I was looking for something more fast paced, but I thought this was a great start!
-19
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '20
The whole show is basically liberal fantasy victimhood fetish material. The show will fail bc it’s just so tired and worn out at this point. They should’ve done the show on Amazon, where the other bullshit in this genre belongs. HBO taking one step forward and three steps back with shows like this.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment