r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • u/NicholasCajun • Apr 07 '20
Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x04 "Part 4" - Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 4: Part 4
Aired: April 6, 2020
Synopsis: Evelyn and Bengelsdorf receive an invitation from Mrs. Lindbergh to a state dinner for Nazi Germany's foreign minister, as Evelyn makes Sandy the face of the youth assimilation program. Back from war, Alvin takes a job at his uncle's warehouse. Philip is traumatized by a death in the neighborhood.
Directed by: Thomas Schlamme
Written by: David Simon & Reena Rexrode
Please use spoiler tags when discussing elements from the book and any episode previews.
Use this format: >!Spoiler!< - it will show as Spoiler.
89
u/facu_draper Apr 07 '20
I had such a relief when Bess struck Sandy. I know he is young, and influenceable, but he deserved it.
74
u/1bobbyperu Apr 07 '20
Phil kept it all the way 100. He didn’t tell that fed a damn thing.
63
u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 07 '20
Man, when Sandy called his parents "ghetto Jews," my heart just broke into pieces.
So thankfully, very glad to see Bess smack the shit out of that kid.
59
u/YouJabroni44 Apr 07 '20
Hmm can't say I feel so great about this "voluntary" Homestead Program.
36
u/rjacob95 Apr 07 '20
I loved the little scene where Lionel pushes the shrimp they’re serving at the dinner off his plate.... not the only thing that’s not kosher about this whole operation buddy!!!
57
u/YouJabroni44 Apr 07 '20
Evelyn is such a piece of shit. Trying to steal her sister's son away from her.
28
u/owen_core Apr 07 '20
I can’t believe there are only 2 episodes left!
28
u/ArcticRhombus Apr 07 '20
This was amazing. It blasted the show into a whole new level.
Phillip’s eyes when he sees the body. Sandy’s angst-filled rage at Herman. Herman almost losing his temper. Alvin’s determination to get to the bathroom. Alvin being fired. And of course, Evelyn at the ball.
What incredible scenes.
27
u/cappo40 Apr 07 '20
Been really enjoying this show. Excited to see how it goes.
24
u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20
Winona Ryder is just as beautiful today imo as she was in the 90s. She's looked beautiful throughout the series, but at the ball she just looked stunning. I don't think many actresses look like they could have been someone say pre 1960s, but she's so believable looking. She looked like she would have been an actress in the 40s.
22
u/GottaGoSeeAboutAGirl Apr 07 '20
Shoutout to my boy Earl! He was a weird guy, but he really did care in the end
43
u/maxlot13 Apr 07 '20
Crazy how the Nazi was the most polite to Evelyn. This show does a really good job of showing a slow decline into authoritarianism, I’m impressed.
20
u/RoboDodos Apr 07 '20
Sandy seems to really admire alvin. I think its weird that alvin doesnt talk to sandy and set him straight.
19
u/samspopguy Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20
Can someone give me a quick WW2 refresher were concentration camps a known thing that Germans were doing when this takes places? Or was that just something that was found out towards the end of the war?
18
u/leaffeon Apr 07 '20
Interesting shot of the circle in the glass of the door landing right on the Rabbi's forehead,,,
18
u/MickeyPineapple Apr 07 '20
I realized I had been holding my breath when the FBI agent finally drove away and left Phillip. So much anxiety in that scene! This show keeps getting better.
17
u/idle_wanderer Apr 07 '20
Can anyone translate what Evelyn retorted to the man who made that offensive remark to her and the rabbi in the state ball?
16
u/badguymaddox Apr 07 '20
One thing I like about the show over the book is Herman's relationship with Alvin during Alvin's time in the Canadian military. I always found it odd that though Herman is very obviously and very vocally against Lindbergh the novel never seemed to talk about Herman's view of Alvin when he left for the Canadian military.
Meanwhile, in the series, there are several moments in this episode where Herman outright declares Alvin as a hero and I always found that lack of admiration lacking or missing from the book.
14
u/allthenviousfeelings Apr 07 '20
That was the best episode yet. the slow build-up was well worth it. it's all paying off now and i can't wait to see what happens next.
37
u/couscous200 Apr 07 '20
This show truly is the definition of a slow burn
12
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20
We understand it's the beginning of American Internment Camps, but "officially" what is the reason for the relocation homes the Rabbi was pitching? Why would he say it's necessary?
11
u/JamesHRoss Apr 08 '20
The FBI following the Levins around made me so tense. Poor Philip, he's the purest of the bunch. My heart breaks for him. This show is amazing at making you feel for all the characters, except for the rabbi, for whom I feel absolutely nothing but contempt.
11
u/thatmillerkid Apr 09 '20
The most powerful moment in this episode, for me, was when Lindburgh snubbed Bengelsdorf. You could see a moment of understanding on the Rabbi's face for a second, the brief intrusion of reality into his fantasy world. But then he immediately gets over it and is back to acting as if everything is gravy.
That really affected me because I've seen that same reaction from the Trump supporting Jews I know. Something awful happens and they almost come to the truth, but then their brain goes into damage control mode to avoid cognitive dissonance and after a day or so they've rationalized it away.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20
Man I didn’t know Henry Ford was such a racist piece of shit.
8
u/pennylane8 Apr 07 '20
I'm not sure if this is significant, but did Alvin and the other soldier succeed in retrieving the German device they were sent to find in episode 3?
I can see why Alvin wanted to come back home instead of staying in Canada - as he said himself, war was over for him, in addittion the girl he fell in love with left him, he had no friends or family in Canada. But I can see him committing suicide, with how everyone except Herman seems to underestimate that he fought in an actual war, how his own country makes a lower class citizen out of him (communist because he fought against Germany) and doesn't let him work.
It's good to know that nowadays people who lost legs or even hands is close to normal, in the north-western part of the world of course.
7
u/Razorback121 Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 09 '20
What does it means when Ford says "If this were the South, you Jews would be out back, rilin' up the niggers"?
7
u/Grsz11 Apr 09 '20
How is Henry Ford being the most prominent anti-Semite in U.S. history not better know?
12
u/SJWagner Apr 07 '20
Herman continues to be the best character.
8
u/trimonkeys Apr 08 '20
Morgan Spector is a great actor he does a really good job.
8
u/ilovebowlsofpasta Apr 07 '20
I hate to be that guy...but Judah Benjamin was a senator from Louisiana, not South Carolina lol
3
u/habern Apr 07 '20
What was the thing with Phillip and the movie theater at the end of the episode? Did I miss something or are we going to find out about that on the next episode?
3
u/methmouthjuggalo Apr 10 '20
One of the songs the band played in the white house scene was "My Blue Heaven" which is so good.
5
u/mattyice522 Apr 07 '20
I like how everyone wore suits back then. When did that stop?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20
In this episode, Sandy maybe right for his behaviour, dude could some opportunity for his career but perspective of his parents ; Herman and Bess. He totally deserved the struck.
Also Evelyn such a ignorant person. She is a jew and although she next to Bengesldorf, Henry Ford and people like him hates them.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20
I keep catching myself saying “Evelyn..you dumb bitch”
1
u/keny427 Apr 11 '20
This episode is brilliant for patient viewers.
1
u/TheSpermWhoWon Apr 13 '20
So what exactly was the point of the Earl storyline?
1
u/Technical-Outside408 Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26
Kid really went "you're worse than Hitler."
I really thought Evelyn would eventually see the harm the rabbi was doing, but she's too far gone. Sad.
1
u/mattyice522 Apr 07 '20
Was there a big fast forward in the time line or did I miss something ? I don't remember seeing when Lindbergh became president...