r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • • Apr 07 '20

Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x04 "Part 4" - Episode Discussion

Season 1 Episode 4: Part 4

Aired: April 6, 2020


Synopsis: Evelyn and Bengelsdorf receive an invitation from Mrs. Lindbergh to a state dinner for Nazi Germany's foreign minister, as Evelyn makes Sandy the face of the youth assimilation program. Back from war, Alvin takes a job at his uncle's warehouse. Philip is traumatized by a death in the neighborhood.


Directed by: Thomas Schlamme

Written by: David Simon & Reena Rexrode


Please use spoiler tags when discussing elements from the book and any episode previews.

Use this format: >!Spoiler!< - it will show as Spoiler.

84 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

89

u/facu_draper Apr 07 '20

I had such a relief when Bess struck Sandy. I know he is young, and influenceable, but he deserved it.

50

u/nameisntapun Apr 07 '20

I was glad that Herman showed the restraint to hold back but also that Bess just smacked the living shit out of him

19

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

Classic parental tag-team action.

4

u/fede01_8 Apr 08 '20

Good cop/bad cop.

6

u/varro-reatinus Apr 08 '20

"I forgot which one I'm supposed to be!"

43

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

Sandy has become a little asshole.

12

u/youngpapiwhy Apr 07 '20

Sandy fucking sucks. Teenagers are horrible but this kid suckkkkkkkks

17

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

While the show doesn't really remind me of MITHC, Sandy getting indoctrinated reminds me slightly of the John Smith's youngest daughter being a good little Nazi, while the oldest daughter realized how it was all bullshit once she lived somewhere free.

4

u/LOnTheWayOut Apr 09 '20

That’s what happens when you hang out in Kentucky with the KKK

3

u/thatmillerkid Apr 09 '20

I just spat out matza crumbs lmao

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 07 '20

Yeah, Sandy was annoying before but he's become absolutely insufferable this week.

Bess even told Evelyn she didn't want him becoming a "know-it-all," but clearly that ship has sailed.

He's all the worst aspects of a teenager combined with the cultish admiration of a demagogue.

29

u/Tinkmama22 Apr 07 '20

I replayed it 5 times. It was so satisfying. But after juxtaposing it with her husbands restraint it reminded me that these are gullible and uninformed children doing what they think is okay. At the end of the day, hitting them isn’t going to make it better.

...That being said, I’m still glad she hit that boy and that I am not a parent.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

Might not change his mind but it’ll damn well change his tone lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/1bobbyperu Apr 07 '20

Dude I literally gasped

15

u/ArcticRhombus Apr 07 '20

Did you never burn like wildfire against your father’s dogmatic proclamations, regulations and restrictions and ”father knows best “ attitude? And all the while, Herman can start to make a plan, but he isn’t,

I think we’re supposed to feel the pain from both sides.

→ More replies (14)

74

u/1bobbyperu Apr 07 '20

Phil kept it all the way 100. He didn’t tell that fed a damn thing.

17

u/adamander Apr 07 '20

Phil is a thug in training!

9

u/zsreport Apr 07 '20

I think he pissed himself a little though.

13

u/adamander Apr 08 '20

Phil couldn’t blow his cover! Remember his friend kinda preconditioned him for this with the people following and watching

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MassH202 Jul 11 '20

Like cousin to cousin

7

u/arobot224 Apr 08 '20

Yeah really loved how Phil kept cool from an interrogation by Kellerman.

63

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 07 '20

Man, when Sandy called his parents "ghetto Jews," my heart just broke into pieces.

So thankfully, very glad to see Bess smack the shit out of that kid.

27

u/ArcticRhombus Apr 07 '20

It perfectly captured Sandy’s angst of wanting so badly to fit in in America, in a way his father does not, and the resentment that he feels from Herman laying down the law. Which of course Herman feels like he has a duty as a father, and a moral duty, to do.

So much of the core of Roth’s writing was about the inherent conflicts between parents and children and this scene captured it perfectly.

26

u/anthm17 Apr 07 '20

Ghetto jews is not something he would have just dropped for no reason.

I'm very curious about how he spent his summer.

22

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

Implicitly that came from Bengelsdorf/Evelyn-- which is exactly what Herman and Bess said when they heard it.

11

u/Sorge74 Apr 07 '20

It's not even something I've ever heard before, sounds like a very particular propaganda piece.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/anonyfool Apr 07 '20

Eating pork, among other things.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rasheedsunflowers Sep 13 '20

Yea I think Herman feels like his Jewish identity and culture is who he is and his proud of it. He also feels that because America promises “equality” and is considered to be or is sold as a “melting pot” that being Jewish within that “melting pot” is great. He’s finding it difficult to come to grips with that never really being true and that his whole idea of what the US is sold as is a lie. His fear of Sandy being indoctrinated came true. The way he speaks when he gives speeches When he says things like “real America” or “ghetto Jews”.

1

u/BenTVNerd21 Apr 28 '20

very glad to see Bess smack the shit out of that kid.

I need a gif of on a loop lol

59

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 07 '20

Hmm can't say I feel so great about this "voluntary" Homestead Program.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 09 '20

Yeah it made me feel even worse

36

u/rjacob95 Apr 07 '20

I loved the little scene where Lionel pushes the shrimp they’re serving at the dinner off his plate.... not the only thing that’s not kosher about this whole operation buddy!!!

9

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

I liked that too. They used the same gag in Mad Men to show WASPs ingnorance about Jewish culture.

1

u/ironmikeescobar Apr 09 '20

I can't remember this bit, when was it? I'm thinking it was with Rachel in s1?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ironmikeescobar Apr 09 '20

Yeah, it was a nice subtle touch. They'll never be accepted.

57

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 07 '20

Evelyn is such a piece of shit. Trying to steal her sister's son away from her.

20

u/pennylane8 Apr 07 '20

It seems to me she's just stupid. An opportunis, like Herman said. That was a powerful scene too, you could see how Lionel's face changed because he could be called an opportunist as well.

10

u/Lambchops_Legion Apr 10 '20

Evelyn represents the banality of evil. Not a fanatic or a sociopath, but instead an extremely average and mundane person who relied on cliché defenses rather than thinking for herself, and was motivated by professional promotion rather than ideology.

6

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

Desperate, being an unmarried woman of a certain age in the 40s. Wynona Ryder is a bit too pretty for the role.

14

u/Luberon Apr 08 '20

I don’t know if you read the book but Evelyn is supposed to be very pretty (and it also explains why Sandy et Philip adore her, she’s a bit like a movie star to them). But she had to take care of her mom and she’s a bit of a drama queen with big dreams, that’s why she hasn’t been able to settle with a man. And now she’s afraid it’s too late... till she catches the eye of Bengelsdorf.

But this is really the episode where you can’t find excuses for her behavior anymore, she should know better.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/GrapeTasteWizard Apr 07 '20

Yep, obviously the meet & greet with an actual nazi is fucked up, but even in less dire circumstances it would have been a bad thing regardless.

28

u/owen_core Apr 07 '20

I can’t believe there are only 2 episodes left!

2

u/ironmikeescobar Apr 09 '20

And it's a David Simon show. He often has the major dramatic incidents in the second to last episodes of his series and the last one is the characters dealing with the fall out. Not sure if that will happen here as it's a mini series. Can't remember if Generation Kill or Show Me A Hero (I'm pretty sure this one didn't) followed that formula, but if this does, having read the book, I can see how it might map out. If so, next week's episode should be action packed as there are a few major incidents still to come.

2

u/BenTVNerd21 Apr 28 '20

Show Me A Hero

The final parts of that fucked me up. What an excellent mini-series.

28

u/ArcticRhombus Apr 07 '20

This was amazing. It blasted the show into a whole new level.

Phillip’s eyes when he sees the body. Sandy’s angst-filled rage at Herman. Herman almost losing his temper. Alvin’s determination to get to the bathroom. Alvin being fired. And of course, Evelyn at the ball.

What incredible scenes.

27

u/cappo40 Apr 07 '20

Been really enjoying this show. Excited to see how it goes.

20

u/RahulBhatia10 Apr 07 '20

It's so great how it's this gradual descent, and framing it from the pov of a working-class family is the winning factor I feel. It offers this ground-level approach that really allows you to sympathize with the characters

24

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

Winona Ryder is just as beautiful today imo as she was in the 90s. She's looked beautiful throughout the series, but at the ball she just looked stunning. I don't think many actresses look like they could have been someone say pre 1960s, but she's so believable looking. She looked like she would have been an actress in the 40s.

5

u/zsreport Apr 07 '20

She’s a couple weeks younger than me, still have a crush on her.

4

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 08 '20

She's almost 50. Blows my mind!

→ More replies (9)

22

u/GottaGoSeeAboutAGirl Apr 07 '20

Shoutout to my boy Earl! He was a weird guy, but he really did care in the end

6

u/trimonkeys Apr 08 '20

What was the point of his character? He didn't seem all that relevant. Was it to expose Philip to the outside a bit?

15

u/GottaGoSeeAboutAGirl Apr 08 '20

I think his purpose was to teach Phillip how to navigate the city. That was highlighted at then end of the episode as well when the movie technician said he didn’t know how Phillip knew how to make it downtown. I’m guessing Phillip is going to have to be on the run by himself in the climax of the show, and he will use his skills of blending in and navigating the city to escape.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/maxlot13 Apr 07 '20

Crazy how the Nazi was the most polite to Evelyn. This show does a really good job of showing a slow decline into authoritarianism, I’m impressed.

47

u/devnulld2 Apr 07 '20

He only danced with her for the newsreel.

21

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

And she danced with Death.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/habern Apr 07 '20

What's crazy is how everyone is making excuses for the Nazis. I knew this happened historically but if I didn't see it with Trump in my own lifetime I don't know if I would buy it.

1

u/ThePantsThief Apr 10 '20

I've actually never seen it in real life, I almost want to see it so I can knock someone's teeth out

Sort of surprised I'm saying this because back when "punching nazis" was a thing online, I was disgusted by the thought of initiating violence against someone who is just expressing their opinion in a free country. I've literally been on both sides of the story here now.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/vadergeek Apr 10 '20

It's not like the US has ever been unwilling to deal with dictators. Trump is unusually overt about it, but Erdogan, el-Sisi, the house of Saud, cooperating with and arming murderous strongmen is bipartisan policy.

24

u/mattyice522 Apr 07 '20

It's what people most forget. It's the boiling frog metaphor for the descent into authoritarianism. Not a sudden jump off the cliff.

32

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

It wasn't because he was nice...it was for publicity. Just like Lindbergh 's act of being friends with Lionel. He ignored him at the dinner. Ribbentrop deliberately wanted to dance with Evelyn because it's good PR that could be used as propaganda which the Nazis were good at. They could air that in Germany and use it to show that Nazis are cool with Jews. It's all an act.

40

u/zkela Apr 07 '20

it was perhaps more for US news media. Germany was committed to anti-semitism for their domestic propaganda.

9

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

Yeah I agree, I'm just saying that could show that anyway to look like there really was no tension. The Nazis had the art of propaganda down.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

if they follow the book at all, his relationship with the first lady should be genuine, but they've made small, clever diversions from the book so far.

2

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

What are some differences you have noticed? I've liked Roth's movies but have never read any of his books.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

the book is told entirely through Phillips eyes, so stuff like the dinner- we only get that scene through Phillip watching the newsreel after he snuck in. The show actually fleshed it out, gave some depth to the Lionel/Evelyn relationship and showed us that, yes, there are indeed Anti Semites in the government (the asshole that insulted them was Henry Ford - real life inspiration for Hitler when it comes to anti semtisim- and sec of interior in the book/show)

Basically, any scene that does not have Phillip there at all, is new for the show or heavily expanded upon for the show. All of Alvins stuff - Philips talks about what he heard his dad mention about visiting Alvin, or hearing about his parents arguing about his street gambling- but the show gives us all that

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/rasheedsunflowers Sep 13 '20

Yea no he only danced with her as a publicity stunt. Also remember even genocidal war criminals can be civil. I loved the interactions at the ball though. It showed how the Lindenbergh administration really feels about bengalsdorf and Evelyn especially when they are around their Nazi friends.

20

u/RoboDodos Apr 07 '20

Sandy seems to really admire alvin. I think its weird that alvin doesnt talk to sandy and set him straight.

14

u/MickeyPineapple Apr 07 '20

Maybe he would have if he had stayed around to see Sandy going off to Kentucky. I had been hoping they would have a talk in this episode.

2

u/RoboDodos Apr 07 '20

Alvin was in the states after sandy came back from kentucky. He was the first person to hug alvin

9

u/MickeyPineapple Apr 07 '20

Yes but not when he was going to Kentucky. When Alvin comes back he's not in a condition to really care about what's happening with his cousins. But I think he would have had a lot to say when Sandy threw a tantrum to go to Kentucky.

19

u/samspopguy Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

Can someone give me a quick WW2 refresher were concentration camps a known thing that Germans were doing when this takes places? Or was that just something that was found out towards the end of the war?

29

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 07 '20

The existence of camps was known. Nazis set up the first camps shortly after taking power and years before the implementation of the final solution (they were basically German gulags initially). The general American public wouldn't have known about mass genocide, but Allied governments were aware before the camps were liberated.

11

u/samspopguy Apr 07 '20

Yeah I was thinking of the mass genocide cause I always remember the scene from Band of brothers when they come across it and all the soliders we’re in disbelief.

9

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 07 '20

I don't think there was a whole lot of photos of the camps before the allied forces found them. I think it's one thing to hear about them and another to see them.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

The Years of Extermination: Nazi Germany and the Jews, 1939-1945 (2007) One of the premier historians who has studied the Shoah is Saul Friedlander.

He tackles this major question scholars have about the Final Solution. Did it begin as soon as Hitler claimed the Chancellorship? Or, was the Final Solution an Nazi exigency that developed because of the war?

Friedlander attempts to demonstrate that the Nazi goal to exterminate Europe's Jewish population became part of the Third Reich shortly after Hitler took emergency powers following the Reichstag fire.

Civil liberties ended, political parties were outlawed, as were various newspapers and radio outlets, and the only legal labor union was the Nazi labor organization. Eventually, the Nazis got around to passing ethnicity laws and other pro-Aryan policies.

The first concentration camps, or gulags, were for mainly socialists, communists, other political dissidents like anarchists, as well as prostitutes, homosexuals (especially former SA leadership), and physically and mentally disabled. Many of these were established by 1934, and influential Jews might have found themselves as residents along with other so-called rabble rousers that the Nazis needed to control.

The Final Solution put the Holocaust into practice, shortly after the war began in 1939, but it wasn't called that until 1941. At first the Nazis tried all kinds of ways to exterminate Jews, such as Einsatzgruppen Waffen SS machine gunning people in pits, and they had these mobile gas vans -- both of which were inefficient and bothered the SS troops carrying out the mission. But it wasn't until 1941 that they developed the concentration camp/ghetto model that Allied armies liberated in the final stages of the war, and this was done as an efficiency measure as well as to insulate the SS "soldiers" from the crummy detail of having to murder defenseless men, women, and children.

To answer the question, following my reading of Friedlander's books on the topic, yes, Americans knew the Nazis were bad, especially after the 1937 Kristalnacht -- a nationwide pogrom that destroyed Jewish businesses. Einstein had made the trip over and personally warned Roosevelt. But the industrial and systematic method of killing via the camps was more of a World War II creation.

→ More replies (13)

8

u/zkela Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

This episode takes place around the same time that the Nazis started mass killing of Jewish people, and the full extent of the massacres taking place would not have been common knowledge in the US. But people knew a lot about what the Nazis were about.

10

u/ArcticRhombus Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

Concentration camps would not have been widespread, or widely known about, by 1941.

But other abuses of Jews would have been known about, including: organized state violence on Jewish people and businesses, expulsion of Polish Jews, intermarriage bans, restrictions on civil service jobs and freedom of movement, the mandatory Jewish Star, etc..

8

u/flying_shadow Apr 07 '20

Yes, they would have been. When the first concentration camps opened in 1933, the newspapers wrote about them openly.

7

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 07 '20

Yep the Nazis literally put out a press release when they opened Dachau, and even openly admitted they were going to put the commies and other enemies of the state in there. Anyone who was paying attention would've known the Germans were opening prison camps.

5

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

Prison camps, yes.

Death camps, no.

The were unbelievably secretive about what preceded and what came out of the Wannsee Conference.

1

u/frenchchevalierblanc Apr 09 '20

people knew about concentration camps. But "concentration camp" was a wide concept that encompassed "refugee camps" to "POW camps". There weren't supposed to be "place to die" camps except after the war when now it is used only in this context.

For instance in France there were lots of "concentration camps" in 1939. They didn't hold jews but spanish republicans and their families, also czech and polish army in exiles. They were trained there to fight war with France against Germany. It was just places to put people.

5

u/SamanthaLores23 Apr 07 '20

It was something that was found out toward the end of the war. Yeah

1

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

I don't think the extent was widely know before/during the war. With Lindberg in power the extent was even less likely to be publicized.

The Nazis did quite a bit of propaganda show the camps as being benign "reeducation" camps. I saw a documentary once about a Jewish orchastra that was forced to put up a front as happy prisioners for cameras.

1

u/Esterhowse Apr 08 '20

Can someone give me a quick WW2 refresher were concentration camps a known thing that Germans were doing when this takes places?

There was a great deal of denial about what the Germans where doing in Poland.

Also the "camps" weren't as machine like in how they exterminated people at the time of the story.

1

u/Esterhowse Apr 08 '20

Numerous reports and pictures of Germans killing people in Poland and shipping people to eastern Europe were being leaked out into the press at this time.

Thing is there was so much debate about the pictures being real and also as horrible as this may sound, NO ONE CARED.

We are on the other side of WWII and we release how horrible it was but prior to WWII persecution of Jews was not something anyone cared about.

1

u/frenchchevalierblanc Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 09 '20

There were tons of different camps during WW2 and people got confused. There were POW camps, forced labour camps, russian POW camps, political camps, extermination camps, women camps. Sometimes it was all in the same place.

And the living in those camps varied, you could be in force labour wih ok condition or in force labour with horrible conditions. Same for POWs. Even after the war, when people came back from "camps", it was not clear in which camps they were (where they in the same camps as POWs? Forced labour? hard camps for jewish people to die there after a few months?).

So in 1941:

  • people knew there were camps and conditions were harsh
  • it wasn"t clear that some of those camps were aimed at people to slowly die, or to die quickly

For instance in France there were camps since 1939 for instance, so people knew about concentration camps. But those camps were used:

before June 1940:

  • for spanish republican and their families, sometimes to train them to war
  • to train the czech army in exile
  • to train polish army in exile

then after the armistice:

  • for foreign jews
  • for political opponents
  • for colony workers (for instance indochina workers )
  • still for spanish republican and their families

then after 1942 and the total occupation of France:

  • for french jews in transit to Germany

1

u/Bellacinos Apr 11 '20

The allies knew about the camps but felt the best way to end the holocaust was to defeat Germany as fast as possible. They attempted bombing the camps and railroads but back then bombs weren’t accurate at all, and they just rebuilt the railroads. Also most of the camps were so far behind enemy lines that they couldn’t reach them on a one way street. I do agree with FDR that the best way to end the holocaust was to defeat Germany.

18

u/leaffeon Apr 07 '20

Interesting shot of the circle in the glass of the door landing right on the Rabbi's forehead,,,

1

u/arobot224 Apr 08 '20

I noticed that too, what did you think of the shot?.

18

u/MickeyPineapple Apr 07 '20

I realized I had been holding my breath when the FBI agent finally drove away and left Phillip. So much anxiety in that scene! This show keeps getting better.

17

u/idle_wanderer Apr 07 '20

Can anyone translate what Evelyn retorted to the man who made that offensive remark to her and the rabbi in the state ball?

17

u/piemandotcom Apr 07 '20

9

u/idle_wanderer Apr 07 '20

Haha I can understand their reactions now, what a nonsensical insult

20

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

David Simon said on the podcast that Winona Ryder agreeing to play the part of Evelyn was conditional on her being able to use this phrase

3

u/JoBabbel Apr 09 '20

As a German i was really laughing. "Geh kacken" roughly translates to "fuck off"

2

u/piemandotcom Apr 09 '20

I'm curious, what about literally? It must be close to the Yiddish

4

u/Tommie015 Apr 10 '20

Dutch here, "Ga kakken" means "Go shit"

0

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ThePantsThief Apr 10 '20

Pound sand is a good similar nonsense phrase

16

u/badguymaddox Apr 07 '20

One thing I like about the show over the book is Herman's relationship with Alvin during Alvin's time in the Canadian military. I always found it odd that though Herman is very obviously and very vocally against Lindbergh the novel never seemed to talk about Herman's view of Alvin when he left for the Canadian military.

Meanwhile, in the series, there are several moments in this episode where Herman outright declares Alvin as a hero and I always found that lack of admiration lacking or missing from the book.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

in the book, doesn't Herman decry Alvin for his gambling & degeneracy? I know we haven't gotten there yet, but i assume the relationship will get bad, fast.

5

u/badguymaddox Apr 08 '20

It's definitely going to get bad, but in the book, I was always left with the impression that Herman was disappointed in Alvin "running away" to Canada. At least I wasn't with the impression Herman approved of Alvin's decision to participate in the war and I always found that odd considering Herman's own view of Lindbergh.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20

I can easily see them making Monty the sole family member who has an issue w/ alvin. Even then, they really toned down Monty and made him not as asshole-y (that may just be Krumholtz being inherently likable lol)

3

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

Simon talks about this in the podcast. It is one of the changes he made from the book.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/allthenviousfeelings Apr 07 '20

That was the best episode yet. the slow build-up was well worth it. it's all paying off now and i can't wait to see what happens next.

37

u/couscous200 Apr 07 '20

This show truly is the definition of a slow burn

11

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

That's David Simon to you

4

u/datniggymanaj Apr 07 '20

I think it's on the edge of being too slow to watch for me. There's 2 more episodes and I feel like there should be more happening? I don't know (I didn't read the book)

2

u/Sorge74 Apr 07 '20

I also didn't read the book, is this a limited series? I'm thinking things get bad real fast, and there's not a happy ending....

4

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

I'm thinking things get bad real fast, and there's not a happy ending....

whistles innocently

I also didn't read the book, is this a limited series?

If it stops where the book stops, it'll be a single season, about the length of a classic British serial.

That said, there's no reason they couldn't do a second series by continuing the alternate history forward, if Roth's estate is agreeable.

3

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

I heard they changed the ending from Roth's book.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/physicallyatherapist Apr 07 '20

I know you're bring downvoted but I agree, I think this show has been slow

6

u/tetraourogallus Apr 07 '20

I think it needed to be slow to have us buy all the changes.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

We understand it's the beginning of American Internment Camps, but "officially" what is the reason for the relocation homes the Rabbi was pitching? Why would he say it's necessary?

11

u/zkela Apr 07 '20

It's apparently a plan to make Jewish Americans living in cities ""more American"" by ""relocating"" them to rural states (details TBD).

21

u/zsreport Apr 07 '20

I’ve always hated this golden notion that rural America is “real America” - if that’s the case, then we’re all on the road to ruin.

11

u/devnulld2 Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

The pretext for permanently relocating Jewish people is that the Jews are moving for work. The US businesses that Bengelsdorf mentions will move their jobs.

11

u/anthm17 Apr 07 '20

They need to assimilate. They aren't American enough. They need to experience "real" America.

7

u/devnulld2 Apr 07 '20

That isn't a pretext. Bengelsdorf actually believes that.

20

u/anthm17 Apr 07 '20

Of course he does, he's son of a man who fought for slavery and reveres the south and the confederacy.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

That isn't a pretext. Bengelsdorf actually believes that.

whooosh

It is a pretext that Bengelsdorf will believe. Both the pretext and Bengelsdorf were selected for one another.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/zkela Apr 07 '20

no, he says companies will help with the relocation, but that's not the pretext.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

no, its more like they are working with those businesses the rabbi mentioned to relocate the Jewish workers on their payroll to "the heartland"

It isn't mandatory, but the implication is the jew who denies the move will lose their job.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

What are you saying no to?

3

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

To dilute Jewish political power.

1

u/hooplah Apr 26 '20

i’m super late to this thread and this isn’t directly related to jewish relocation, but i know japanese people we’re allowed to leave the internment camps early if they agreed to be released into the midwest as opposed to returning to their original coastal hometowns. the thinking was that they wouldn’t be able to coordinate as well with japan from deeper inside the US.

lol.

11

u/JamesHRoss Apr 08 '20

The FBI following the Levins around made me so tense. Poor Philip, he's the purest of the bunch. My heart breaks for him. This show is amazing at making you feel for all the characters, except for the rabbi, for whom I feel absolutely nothing but contempt.

1

u/ThePantsThief Apr 10 '20

They'd better go somewhere with the rabbi. They've been expanding his character a lot lately with his dead wife stuff.

11

u/thatmillerkid Apr 09 '20

The most powerful moment in this episode, for me, was when Lindburgh snubbed Bengelsdorf. You could see a moment of understanding on the Rabbi's face for a second, the brief intrusion of reality into his fantasy world. But then he immediately gets over it and is back to acting as if everything is gravy.

That really affected me because I've seen that same reaction from the Trump supporting Jews I know. Something awful happens and they almost come to the truth, but then their brain goes into damage control mode to avoid cognitive dissonance and after a day or so they've rationalized it away.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

Man I didn’t know Henry Ford was such a racist piece of shit.

17

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

Hitler's favorite American. Ran an AntiSemetic newspaper. He even got Nazi Germany's highest civilian honor.

https://antizionistleague.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/henry-ford-receives-grand-cross.jpg

11

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20

Hitler was inspired by Ford when it came to Anti Semitism - Ford is name dropped in Mein Kampf as an example to follow. The man inspiired hitler, which tells you enough

6

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20

They don’t tell you that in HS US History. Should be a tag line

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Esterhowse Apr 08 '20

Oh yeah this is something a lot of people don't realize.

There is a reason Cadillacs were once called "Jew Canoes" Jewish people refused to buy fords.

1

u/BenTVNerd21 Apr 28 '20

Walt Disney as well.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

Smh

8

u/pennylane8 Apr 07 '20

I'm not sure if this is significant, but did Alvin and the other soldier succeed in retrieving the German device they were sent to find in episode 3?

I can see why Alvin wanted to come back home instead of staying in Canada - as he said himself, war was over for him, in addittion the girl he fell in love with left him, he had no friends or family in Canada. But I can see him committing suicide, with how everyone except Herman seems to underestimate that he fought in an actual war, how his own country makes a lower class citizen out of him (communist because he fought against Germany) and doesn't let him work.

It's good to know that nowadays people who lost legs or even hands is close to normal, in the north-western part of the world of course.

7

u/Razorback121 Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 09 '20

What does it means when Ford says "If this were the South, you Jews would be out back, rilin' up the niggers"?

12

u/EndsTheAgeOfCant Apr 08 '20

It's a common white supremacist trope that jewish people manipulate "inferior races" (black, hispanic, asian, middle-eastern, etc) into destroying the white race and white countries through immigration, interracial relationships, stuff like that. So he's saying that they're traitors to the US and would be encouraging the black "help" to ask for rights and stuff.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20

he was saying that they did not deserve to be at that dinner, and if this were the south, they'd be in the back looking after the only people "below them" on the racist ladder.

7

u/EndsTheAgeOfCant Apr 08 '20

"Riling up" does not mean "looking after". He's calling them traitors/agitators.

7

u/Grsz11 Apr 09 '20

How is Henry Ford being the most prominent anti-Semite in U.S. history not better know?

2

u/trimonkeys Apr 10 '20

It's honestly crazy I remember in elementary school learning about how he was a great man for creating the Model T and the assembly line. Never heard that he was incredibly racist.

1

u/BennButton Apr 10 '20

Because he's an American Hero. And there wasn't enough room in textbooks to include anti-Semite, under his photo.

But seriously, the American History taught in schools tries to glorify a lot of it's well-known figures. Benjamin Franklin, for example, was a womanizing adulterer who sought mistresses on his trips to France. You don't learn that in the history books because it doesn't really relate to the "good" he has given to our society, so it remains a fact behind closed doors.

4

u/varro-reatinus Apr 10 '20

I'm pretty sure being a philanderer ranks at a less damning level than virulent anti-Semitism and Nazi-worship on the scale of moral turpitude.

12

u/SJWagner Apr 07 '20

Herman continues to be the best character.

8

u/trimonkeys Apr 08 '20

He's very well portrayed, Morgan Spector really sells the character.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20

I like that he's actually become less explosive in the last two episodes. Before that, he reminded me of people who think the only way to get their point across is to yell. Nobody listens to those people.

8

u/trimonkeys Apr 08 '20

Morgan Spector is a great actor he does a really good job.

2

u/ThePantsThief Apr 10 '20

I agree, I'm loving him in this.

2

u/JonVoightKampff Apr 12 '20

Does he remind anyone of else of Oscar Isaac? Sort of a similar voice and manner. Anyway, I agree that he's been excellent; really holds the screen.

1

u/trimonkeys Apr 12 '20

I don't see too much of an Isaac comparison, Isaac has a bit of a softer voice. But Spector definitely commands a lot of screen presence.

8

u/ilovebowlsofpasta Apr 07 '20

I hate to be that guy...but Judah Benjamin was a senator from Louisiana, not South Carolina lol

13

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

You are correct.

That said, there's a reason Roth made Bengelsdorf get that wrong, and a reason the show kept it.

14

u/mattyice522 Apr 07 '20

Also, FDR won the election. Not Lindberg.

19

u/SnakeEater14 Apr 07 '20

Damn they really dropped the ball with research on this show

3

u/zkela Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

lol, fair point. he did live in SC at one point, but the show had it wrong that he represented SC.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

31

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

dts, just a mistake by the show.

Incorrect.

In the book, Bengelsdorf makes the same mistake. The show follows the book almost word-for-word in that speech.

Philip Roth doesn't 'make mistakes' like that. It's intended to make Bengelsdorf out to be the grandstanding blowhard he is. He doesn't know what he's talking about, and he's making it up as he goes along.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20

You were spot-on.

Gauging the relative spoilinees of a spoiler on someone else's behalf is always tricky, but if it stays close to the book, here's the general view:

It's both: Bengelsdorf does genuinely believe he'll be protected, come what may, and he is deluded in that belief: specifically in thinking that he can use his position of special privilege to protect others, and in general about Lindbergh's plan-- which isn't really his plan at all.

The exact mechanism, however, by which those things play out is rather mysterious.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/habern Apr 07 '20

What was the thing with Phillip and the movie theater at the end of the episode? Did I miss something or are we going to find out about that on the next episode?

23

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

I think Phillip wasn't supposed to be there viewing the clips. He forged a note that his parents approved of him being there (those were different times). The owner knew it was bullshit based on being friends with Herman and immediately called him. That's how I saw it anyway.

12

u/Dorontauber Apr 07 '20

I think you're correct! I tried to catch a clear picture of it and blow it up -- it's a forged letter from Bess giving him permission to see the Lindbergh newsreel by himself.

7

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 07 '20

I'm just assuming. I remember my Boomer parents telling me that when they were kids, they could just go to the corner store and get cigarettes for their parents as long as they had a note.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/walterwilter Apr 07 '20

I’m guessing it was a note from Evelyn that says he should see it/has permission to see it he newsreel

3

u/habern Apr 07 '20

He doesn't need nor would he seek the permission of Evelyn. Phillip is still a young child and still seems the approval of his parents and not yet his peers as most of us transition to in puberty. This is clear with the older brother.

3

u/walterwilter Apr 07 '20

I’m not saying Phillip does. I doubt Phillip sought the letter. It’s pretty clear that Evelyn has some of her own issues which are being demonstrated with her relationship with her sisters children.

3

u/habern Apr 07 '20

I think what we are seeing is a very real example of a gold digger. You see the movie version of this a lot but I think she is supposed to be a more true to life version of a gold digger.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/sunnymentoaddict Apr 07 '20

Most likely Herman didn't want Phil to see his aunt dancing with a nazi. Because Herman is always at the theater, and he knew how the newsreel would be framed; in a positive manner, because two nations are getting along. The theater owner is good friends with Herman and instantly knew who the kid was and saw through the clearly forged note.

2

u/Llamabanger Apr 07 '20

Wondering this too!

2

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 07 '20

This Herman got worried and had his friend who run the movie theater keep an eye on him

3

u/habern Apr 07 '20

Uhh can you clarify. That doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me as a standalone statement.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Dorontauber Apr 07 '20

Did anyone catch what the letter says? You'd have to get a really clear shot to read it, but I remember people turning inscrutable GOT parchments into legible text

3

u/fede01_8 Apr 08 '20

it's unreadable. i paused it.

1

u/fridaysareforambien Apr 07 '20

I believe it was going to show footage of the state dinner where Evelyn was dancing with von Ribbentrop, which for obvious reasons Herman didn’t want his son seeing. Once he realized that’s where Phillip was, he went to the theatre and pulled him out of there.

3

u/habern Apr 07 '20

No dude. He was mad about the note that he gave to the ticket girl. That was very clear. They just didn't explain it at all.

3

u/methmouthjuggalo Apr 10 '20

One of the songs the band played in the white house scene was "My Blue Heaven" which is so good.

5

u/mattyice522 Apr 07 '20

I like how everyone wore suits back then. When did that stop?

31

u/Sorge74 Apr 07 '20

Idk when they realized it was way too hot for all them layers?

6

u/samspopguy Apr 07 '20

This is a new front runner for my favorite reddit quote.

1

u/ThePantsThief Apr 10 '20

Why did it take them so long to realize?

2

u/Sorge74 Apr 10 '20

Idk I was joking but really I assume it's something you get used to. I'm from NW Ohio, always have AC or heat when I need it and dress comfortably as a for 33 year old.

I can go to the country fair in 90 degree weather and I'm super hot in shorts and a beater, meanwhile farmers are in jeans and a tucked in botton down....

11

u/varro-reatinus Apr 07 '20

It started stopping in the 60s, more or less.

Basically, two things converged: we started making suiting in shittier ways with shittier fabrics (fused aka glued synthetics instead of properly canvassed natural fibres) coinciding with a general push against formality and tradition in European and North American cultures.

2

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 08 '20

Mid 90's when business casual came it. People stopped wearing hats in the mid 60's after President Kenndey stopped wearing hats.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20

In this episode, Sandy maybe right for his behaviour, dude could some opportunity for his career but perspective of his parents ; Herman and Bess. He totally deserved the struck.

Also Evelyn such a ignorant person. She is a jew and although she next to Bengesldorf, Henry Ford and people like him hates them.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20

I keep catching myself saying “Evelyn..you dumb bitch”

1

u/keny427 Apr 11 '20

This episode is brilliant for patient viewers.

1

u/TheSpermWhoWon Apr 13 '20

So what exactly was the point of the Earl storyline?

1

u/Technical-Outside408 Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26

Kid really went "you're worse than Hitler."

I really thought Evelyn would eventually see the harm the rabbi was doing, but she's too far gone. Sad.

1

u/mattyice522 Apr 07 '20

Was there a big fast forward in the time line or did I miss something ? I don't remember seeing when Lindbergh became president...

18

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20

He won the election at the end of episode 2.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/habern Apr 07 '20

Every episode there is a large fast forward. We started in Summer 1940. Episode 2 November 1940. Episode 3 is May 1941 and I believe the most recent episode was September 1941.