r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • u/NicholasCajun • Apr 14 '20
Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x05 "Part 5" - Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 5: Part 5
Aired: April 13, 2020
Synopsis: After learning the family has been selected for an essentially forced relocation to Kentucky under the Homestead Act, Herman looks to make a challenge in court, while Bess and Philip appeal to Bengelsdorf and Evelyn, respectively. Later, Bess gives Herman an ultimatum when violence breaks out at a rally for Lindbergh's most public liberal challenger.
Directed by: Thomas Schlamme
Written by: Ed Burns
Please use spoiler tags when discussing elements from the book and any episode previews.
Use this format: >!Spoiler!< - it will show as Spoiler.
81
u/JamesHRoss Apr 14 '20
Best episode so far. Rabbi Bengelsdorf is the worst
65
u/westthebest Apr 14 '20
Every time I watch this show, time stands still. Second by second a felling of discomfort builds in me. This is top notch TV and it is a shame that it is going completely under the radar.
Every show and film nowadays is all about a main protagonist taking control, making a difference or being important in is own universe. The Plot Against America is a remainder that we are small cogs and sometimes we can't make a difference no matter how hard we try.
As for next week my expectations a very low. One episode for everything that is left is not enough... hope to be wrong.
58
u/leflyingbison Apr 14 '20
Philip felt so guilty. He just learned what the KKK was and basically got his friend sent to Kentucky. That's rough.
41
u/Wyatt821 Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20
I was an extra in that rally scene! One of the brownshirts. Two very hot summer nights shooting under a railroad bridge in Cranford, NJ. The attention to detail that the producers/crew put into the show was amazing. And the stunt people did not fuck around. It felt very real. My throat was sore for like two days afterwards from all the yelling and the herbal cigarette smoking. A really intense, but rewarding experience!
36
u/DBClayton Apr 14 '20
This episode, as well as the last have me thinking a lot about how stripping away systems of support— schools, synagogues, kosher food, etc.— places a burden of Jews, and one that creates a disparity in accessibility to the right to practice based on power. The greatest sacrifice the Rabbi has made is setting a cup of shrimp cocktail aside. He has power and resources— unlike Seldon’s mother he is not dependent on one company for support, unlike Herman he could wait out a court decision, or petition the president. Worst comes to worst, Bengelsdorf likely has the wealth to carry the burden of inaccessible Jewish resources— importing kosher food, traveling to form a minyan, etc. that others couldn’t. When Bengelsdorf says he could live anywhere, he is projecting his privileged position. Still not sure whether he is aware his case is rare and his intent is to completely unravel the fabric of Jewish life, or he is holding onto his delusions— Turturro is such a great actor, I can’t make up my mind.
34
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20
If Herman doesn’t decide to go to Canada after the rally and how the media portrayed it.. he is blind. As a Jew, I’d have been like him. But at that point enough is enough and it’s time to leave.
32
u/samspopguy Apr 14 '20
I feel like there’s so many more stories to tell yet we only have one episode left.
29
u/facu_draper Apr 14 '20
It kills me to see how awfully poor Philip is loosing his innocence
28
u/MickeyPineapple Apr 14 '20
The rally scene where those troublemakers entered the scene and the police just stood by, was just too hard to watch. I have seen similar things happen in my country and the police responding in the same way. It's unnerving how realistic this scene was!
24
u/aw3man Apr 14 '20
I'm totally engrossed in the episode that I'm still kind of speechless. Growing up in NJ and learning the histories of race riots and economic depression in parts of Newark and almost all of Paterson makes me realize how the persecuted Jews would feel in this series. Not everything has to be so black and white in racism and antisemitism. Sometimes it is a set of institutions and sets of laws and programs and sets of bad actors which can be the instigators for full on discrimination and persecution against a group of people.
24
u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20
This is not only one of the best shows on TV in 2020, it's one of the best shows I've ever seen.
This is some Singing Detective-level stuff we're watching, folks.
Remember these days. This is art history.
We may also be witnessing John Turturro's best performance, in a career of brilliant performances.
22
u/owen_core Apr 14 '20
This show is absolutely fantastic, I do not understand how almost no one has heard of it. Did HBO not advertise about it or something?
21
u/jtrachtenberg Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 15 '20
The show runners have set Bengelsdorf up for a turn in the final episode. We've see the president all but ignore him, Henry Ford make anti-Semitic and racist comments toward him and then completely disregard his concerns at the OAA meeting. All of this occurs in front of Evelyn too. Bengelsdorf has served his role for Lindy and now they don't need him anymore. Alvin put it best early on in the series when he said that Bengelsdorf's endorsement wasn't for jews, but for gentiles to feel okay with voting for Lindy.
31
u/trimonkeys Apr 14 '20
The Winchell riot scene was harrowing, with the crowd erupting in chaos. Kazan stole this episode especially with her acting in the final scene. Props to the kid who plays Philip I had a lump in my throat when he gave Seldon the stamp collection.
29
u/facu_draper Apr 14 '20
The rabbi has become one of my most hated tv- characters of all time
11
u/YouJabroni44 Apr 14 '20
Ugh I hope Foghorn Leghorn and is little Golem have a true comeuppance
10
u/CooCooMachoo Apr 14 '20
Is there going to be another season?
I can't imagine how this can get wrapped up in one last episode.
10
u/NZsupremacist Apr 14 '20
That scene with the brownjackets...gosh, and the police just letting it happen. I can only see this ruining Winchell's chance at running for president with that fight. It seems like either way people like Hermann are screwed. Can't follow the system as it's rigged from the top, cant use violence or risk getting beaten and killed. Only so much you can push a group into a corner before they have to come out fighting though.
9
u/mattyice522 Apr 14 '20
Is it just a coincidence that the kid went on a retreat to Kentucky where this forced relocation is going to be?
9
u/Adrian_FCD Apr 14 '20
Man, the show's slow burn is HAUNTING.
I'm don't know if i can handle the finalle.
8
u/JamesHRoss Apr 14 '20
So tensed about Alvin
8
u/couscous200 Apr 14 '20
Another tense episode, can’t wait for the finale
8
u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 14 '20
Can someone explain to me everything involving Alvin in this episode? I had a really hard time following his storyline.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20
Lot of book changes. Idk what they’re doing with Alvin anymore, I assume he’s in Philly already but can’t tell if the show established that.
Phillip giving his stamps to the small weird kid means a big moment from the book probably won’t happen, which I’m not mad at since it seems super unneeded with how much story they have to tell.
20
u/Thatoneguy241 Apr 14 '20
The last three episodes have been amazing.
But I can’t forgive the people who decided the first two episodes needed to revolve around Bitch Boy Sandy and his drawing skills and Alvins shaky relationship with his uncle. And that one wealthy kid who followed people around and collected stamps.
10
u/mattyice522 Apr 14 '20
Is this the penultimate episode?
5
u/ironyfree Apr 14 '20
This show is legit giving me stress.
7
u/buy_gold_bye Apr 14 '20
I HATE SANSY OML THAT BOY NEEDS TO SHUT HIS BRAINWASHED ASS. he deserved that slap.
6
u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 14 '20
I find the I find myself holding my breath every single episode. What a show this is.
3
u/CooCooMachoo Apr 15 '20
Does anyone listen to the podcasts afterwards.
This one was for Part 5. It really adds to the experience imo.
https://youtu.be/AzR_IsYY_1A
3
u/DrKennethNoisewater- Apr 15 '20
The Rabbi can get fuckin bent
3
u/Esterhowse Apr 16 '20
It is interesting that we are now past the date that the attack on Pearl Harbor should have happened.
2
u/kds405 Apr 17 '20
This makes me hope for an adaptation of Phillip Roth’s “Nemesis” with the same team....it would be another perfect reflection for these times.
2
u/XxAnon5861xX Apr 17 '20
The wife and husband are BOTH right, just like most arguments in real life. This show has to win an Emmy(s).
2
u/XxAnon5861xX Apr 17 '20
Am I the only one assuming people will start to be gathered up by the last episode?
1
u/Mentioned_Videos Apr 15 '20
Videos in this thread: Watch Playlist ▶
Play All | Info | Get me on Chrome / Firefox
1
u/brianwilliamsibrowse Apr 18 '20
For some reason I thought the FBI were going to try and recruit Alvin. Like they'd say Hoover is powermad and feels threatened by the SS, so he's recruiting secret agents like Alvin for whatever purpose
1
u/_handsomeblackman_ Apr 20 '20
How they intend to everything together in one episode I do not but wow this show is amazing
As others have said, time stands still watching this show, it demands my full attention every time. The acting is truly out of this world from all involved!
I love how they depicted the rise of fascism, slow and gradual in its acceptance with the population which is really frightening but also a far better representation of reality.
Herman’s idealism is a tad frustrating, at every road block he reverts back to his faith in the American constitution, bizarre but incredibly admirable.
Sandy? No words really, what an annoying kid but I guess that should be expected somewhat, teenager growing up during any period of time wants to rebel against their parents
I honestly cannot wait for the finale
1
u/jbraden09 Apr 14 '20
People with HBO Now, when does it typically show up?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment