r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • • Apr 14 '20

Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x05 "Part 5" - Episode Discussion

Season 1 Episode 5: Part 5

Aired: April 13, 2020


Synopsis: After learning the family has been selected for an essentially forced relocation to Kentucky under the Homestead Act, Herman looks to make a challenge in court, while Bess and Philip appeal to Bengelsdorf and Evelyn, respectively. Later, Bess gives Herman an ultimatum when violence breaks out at a rally for Lindbergh's most public liberal challenger.


Directed by: Thomas Schlamme

Written by: Ed Burns


Please use spoiler tags when discussing elements from the book and any episode previews.

Use this format: >!Spoiler!< - it will show as Spoiler.

76 Upvotes

307 comments sorted by

81

u/JamesHRoss Apr 14 '20

Best episode so far. Rabbi Bengelsdorf is the worst

55

u/fuckitiroastedyou Apr 14 '20

I hate Sandy even more

35

u/trimonkeys Apr 14 '20

Fuck that kid his reaction to everything is to run off.

→ More replies (19)

26

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 14 '20

I keep reminding myself he's just being a teenager, but goddamn is he such an uppity little punk sometimes.

He's also terrible to Phillip, he's never once been anything close to a decent older brother to him throughout the show.

12

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

...he's never once been anything close to a decent older brother to him throughout the show.

Ehh that's going too far. Their interactions in the first episode were pretty wholesome, especially about the stamp for the Arbour Day illustration.

4

u/TheBrownSeaWeasel Apr 14 '20

Of course it's easy to hate him. But as a father of a 13 year old, he is acting perfectly normal. Hes actually a good kid. In a healthy society, he would rebel against his father and not be Jewish or hate school. But in this world, he has the opportunity to be influenced by something much deeper and sinister.

If he lives in the inner city, he would probably be hanging around a gang. In the suburbs he would probably be smoking weed. In this world, hes a future nazi.

7

u/grendel-khan Apr 15 '20

In this world, hes a future nazi.

I guess nowadays he'd be enjoying edgy wink-wink-nudge-nudge 4chan Nazism.

5

u/WelshiePack Apr 15 '20

This is so spot on. It's pretty terrifying how widespread the 4chan Nazism is. I have two teen sons that are biracial (black/white Jewish) who hear horrible comments online daily in their gamer activities.

3

u/Creaphor Apr 14 '20

Well said. Of course a young kid is gonna rebel against his parents in some way. You know, becoming a ultra vegan or environment-warrior in modern, more peaceful times. "This is IMPORTANT!"

3

u/TheBrownSeaWeasel Apr 14 '20

I raised my 13 year old to be an atheist. He rebelled against me by embracing church for a bit. "You can't tell me what to believe!". My parents were believers, I rebelled by not believing. Sandy wants to challenge his father. He could have went the Alvin route and wanted to fight nazis, but he ended up the opposite. Totally normal kid. I feel bad for Phillip because who knows where he will end up. Probably has PTSD already. Great show.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/savethemouselemur Apr 22 '20

The Rabbi and Evelyn are way worse though. They’re adults with some influence. Sandy’s still a kid even though he supports the people who hate him (I.e., the Jewish community). At least he can redeem himself still. Hard to say the same for the Rabbi and Evelyn.

2

u/intecknicolour Apr 22 '20

sandy is the most ungrateful, selfish little shit.

everything is about him. "why can't i go to kentucky?"

his father makes so many sacrifices for him to have a home and he bitches all day about stuff he doesn't fully understand.

herman is a tough dad but the guy has only ever wanted to keep his family safe and his sons literally are the worst.

→ More replies (12)

27

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

I wonder if he will have a "come to jesus moment" (Pun intended) where he realizes the damage he has done

11

u/ayoz17 Apr 14 '20

I think he did have it in small amount this episode when he spoke to Ford.

39

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

Evelyn is right up there imo. She's not as calculated as Bengel, and certainly is not making as big of an impact, but she is completely disregarding every red flag in favor of her own vanity and self-gain. She is quite literally selling her only remaining family up the river so she can swipe after-dinner mints from the State Dinning Room.

23

u/petielvrrr Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

You have to remember, at that time, women were typically defined by the sort of family they had created. As a 28 year old woman in 2020, I honestly enjoy the idea of never getting married or having children (even though it’s still a bit of an abnormal thing to do). But to a woman my age in the 40s-50s that was not okay and it made them a social pariah. Also, keep in mind that women were almost completely unable to earn a living that allowed them to survive on their own at that time— it wasn’t a problem while they were young, but their careers had an expiration date (hence why Sheldons mom literally didn’t have a choice to move like the Levin’s did).

Evelyn has been painted as a woman who has struggled to find a connection with men who are actually willing to settle down with her. She’s been lonely and desperate for a while, and Bengelsdorf came out of nowhere, gave her life security, purpose and opportunity. She clearly doesn’t understand the implications of it, but she also doesn’t feel like she has any other options. So to her, this is a great thing even though it seems slightly sketchy at times.

EDIT: verbiage (changed “meaning, purpose and opportunity” “security, purpose and opportunity”).

10

u/gbfk Apr 15 '20

Exactly it. Went from being the unsuccessful one when compared to her sister with the family who seemed to have it together. Now she’s going to the White House, a part of national programs, on a first name basis with the First Lady.

She doesn’t have sinister motives but is an active participant in sinister things because she’s basically starstruck and naive so she’s easily manipulated.

4

u/petielvrrr Apr 15 '20

Yes! That’s a much better way to explain the last part than what I did. Even though things seem sketchy at times she won’t denounce it, in part because she doesn’t feel like she has other options, but also because this is actually uplifting for her after feeling defeated for so long, which makes those red flags seem like tiny bumps in the road rather than major pot holes that could actually destroy your car.

This also helps elaborate on why she’s so defensive of it—when you’ve been feeling defeated for a long time and something comes along that makes you feel great about yourself, you’re going to defend it rather than just let others criticize it. It’s the natural instinct to combatting cognitive dissonance.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

Agreed. Ryder and Turturro are really doing a great job selling their characters, they're absolutely detestable.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/greetedworm Apr 14 '20

I really wish this show wasn't a miniseries, If they had a full 10-12 episodes they could've fleshed out Evelyn a bit more. I get the sense that a major reason she defends the rabbi so much is because she was lonely for so long and finally found a man she loves and now she's blinded by that but without the time to flesh her character out that does come through as much.

23

u/kimand85 Apr 14 '20

The reason you get the sense that that’s her motivation is because it’s pretty clear based on what we’ve seen from the show. Her character is pretty well fleshed out already, and any more attempts to flesh her out becomes redundant. There’s not much more to add. There’s no need to make her an overly complex character with a deep backstory. Her motivations are clear and simple. Ryder plays it beautifully and you almost pity the character.

9

u/AlbertoRossonero Apr 14 '20

Yeah extending a series unnecessarily just drags something out to the point it feels like a chore watching. For example the Outsider should have been 6 episodes imo.

5

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 14 '20

I do think there's a case to be made for TPAA being more than 6 episodes, although 10-12 is definitely a bit much. Knowing the ending, I'm a little concerned next week's episode is going to feel a little rushed if they continue to hew close to the book. A little more time and budget could've also let us see Alvin actually lose his leg (although tbh I'm fine with how it was done), or actually show Sandy spending time with the Mawhinneys.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/formlex7 Apr 14 '20

It's more to do with spending her youth dating emotionally unavailable married men, taking care of her sick mother, and then finally getting the chance to be somebody.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 14 '20

I think he is realizing he made a Faustian Bargain.

22

u/devnulld2 Apr 14 '20

I think so, too. I think that the reason he was so offended by Winchell’s remarks is that they hit a soft spot. He knows, more or less consciously, that he really is persecuting his people.

However, I think that he revels so much in his power and position that he will continue to persecute them in order to keep his place near the sun.

14

u/BlackWhiteCoke Apr 14 '20

He really did go to bat for them at the meeting, even tried pushing back a little but was ultimately ignored. It might be the first time he felt not everything going to his plans. Him going after Winchell was to alleviate his own guilt of what he had done. I also think he realizes he is not as powerful as he thought.

18

u/devnulld2 Apr 14 '20

He really did go to bat for them at the meeting, even tried pushing back a little but was ultimately ignored.

Yes. The evidence is that he really thought that he was helping Jewish people. During that meeting with Ford, it began to dawn on him that the Homestead program won't be beneficial.

Him going after Winchell was to alleviate his own guilt of what he had done.

Could you expand on that idea? I'm not so sure that he was trying to alleviate his guilt, so much as he was lashing out after feeling like Winchell had landed a hit on him.

It might be the first time he felt not everything going to his plans.

I also think he realizes he is not as powerful as he thought.

That is an interesting point. Bengelsdorf is ultimately just a token and a tool, and Ford's victory over him in that meeting shows, not only that the Lindbergh administration isn't benevolent, but that Bengelsdorf doesn't have the influence that he thought he did. I think that Bengelsdorf is only partially aware of these facts, because his position in life depends on him being ignorant of them, but maybe he went after Winchell in part to reassure himself that he is powerful.

14

u/BlackWhiteCoke Apr 14 '20

I think he felt guilt because he wasn’t expecting the relocators to deprived of the incentives that were promised.

He told Bess in his office that her husband would keep the same salary, paid expenses for relocation costs, “fundamental economic incentives”.

After the meeting with Ford he learns they will get nothing, and he even counters Ford that it has now turned into an involuntary transfer with no economic benefit.

He did nazi that coming. He did tell Evelyn after the funding would be denied until after the midterm elections that “the promise I made will he a promise I kept.” I’m betting he does feel bad for what awful news is about to come for his sister-in-law.

I believe he intends to keep fighting, but the delusional narcissist in him gets his feelings hurt for being rightly called out by Winchell and he ends up focusing his energy on fighting him instead of helping his people, proving Winchell right.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/Take_Some_Soma Apr 14 '20

The dude is the Jewish Uncle Tom

11

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 14 '20

Yep, Alvin put it best when he said he was propped up by Lindbergh to make non-Jews feel better about voting for him

9

u/Take_Some_Soma Apr 14 '20

Like this guy they paid to stand around.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/FoggyForestFreak Apr 15 '20

His “oh shit I was wrong moment” is going to be great.

1

u/larchmontvandyke Apr 15 '20

I hate him so much. He is a fucking snake.

1

u/fede01_8 Apr 15 '20

A race traitor.

1

u/ben1204 Apr 17 '20

As a Jewish guy myself I can't stop thinking of Jared Kushner and Steven Miller when he appears, both when I read the book and when I watch the show.

1

u/keny427 Apr 15 '20

True. He's so unbelievably naive.

→ More replies (1)

65

u/westthebest Apr 14 '20

Every time I watch this show, time stands still. Second by second a felling of discomfort builds in me. This is top notch TV and it is a shame that it is going completely under the radar.

Every show and film nowadays is all about a main protagonist taking control, making a difference or being important in is own universe. The Plot Against America is a remainder that we are small cogs and sometimes we can't make a difference no matter how hard we try.

As for next week my expectations a very low. One episode for everything that is left is not enough... hope to be wrong.

23

u/Rshackleford22 Apr 14 '20

It seems to real. It’s been a slow turn towards fascism the whole time. Really hits home and makes you realize how fragile freedom is.

26

u/SpoofedFinger Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

If this had come out five years ago, I'm pretty sure I would have been rolling my eyes about how it's a little over the top. I would have argued that a country would have to be in a great deal of turmoil to turn to fascism. Then the last five years happened. We're in the biggest emergency since the Cuban missile crisis and our leader thinks he's still in a reality show. I don't think I'd bat an eye if I saw the cartoon hammers from The Wall marching down my street tomorrow.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20

One episode for everything that is left is not enough...

I thought the first two episodes were poorly paced, but since then I've realised that was kind of the point. You said it yourself in your second paragraph - the individual is incapable of making a difference. That's why the family was kept so distant from the 'action' for half the season. They don't represent a solution in any meaningful way; they represent the failure of a nation of individuals to make things better.

As such, I don't think anything's truly going to be resolved. I think things are going to get more violent until the family decides to head to Canada, and that's where it will be left. I suppose we shall see.

2

u/___Waves__ Apr 15 '20

The Plot Against America is a remainder that we are small cogs and sometimes we can't make a difference no matter how hard we try.

When Bess and Herman were arguing about whether Herman should write to Winchell and Herman said something along the lines if they leave then Lindbergh wins I was hoping for Bess to say something about how at this point it's about surviving not winning.

1

u/RichieW13 Apr 21 '20

As for next week my expectations a very low. One episode for everything that is left is not enough... hope to be wrong

I haven't watched it yet, but I was surprised to see in the description for Part 6, that it was the final episode. I thought this was going to be 10 episodes.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Its why I've dropped shows completely, most are overrated jokes that people think only 10/10 are allowed. While being the most mediocre crap.

Meanwhile I just now discovered something like this thats actually great. Made by the same guy who did Generation Kill of all things which is also great.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/976-EVIL Apr 14 '20

I've been thinking the same thing, I gotta stop smoking weed and watching this show it's giving me existential crises

58

u/leflyingbison Apr 14 '20

Philip felt so guilty. He just learned what the KKK was and basically got his friend sent to Kentucky. That's rough.

36

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

and tbf Phillip might have done alright in Kentucky, but poor Seldon is a walking stereotype.

He's like Kyle's cousin Kyle Two from South Park. Poor little dude doesn't stand a chance

Edit: been a while since I saw any of his south park eps

14

u/Take_Some_Soma Apr 14 '20

His mom calls New York Kyle, Kyle, and her own son Kyle 2.

But yeah, perfect reference lol. 10/10

8

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

lol I forgot Sheila just calls her own son Kyle 2

10

u/CleverZerg Apr 14 '20

It's actually insane how similar Seldon is to Kyle, basically a live action version of him.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/WelshiePack Apr 15 '20

I love Seldon's character so much.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

No one:

Kyles cousin:“It’s so dry out here..does anyone else feel like it’s dry??”

3

u/NotKanz Apr 15 '20

The moisture in the air is fogging up my glasses

→ More replies (1)

4

u/piemandotcom Apr 14 '20

Actually, the one you're thinking of is just Kyle. https://youtu.be/gnow7YXuSes?t=20

2

u/fede01_8 Apr 15 '20 edited Apr 15 '20

It was so cute how he turned down Bess' offer for breakfast.

3

u/Naggers123 Apr 14 '20

you mean it's not a cool duck club?!

41

u/Wyatt821 Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

I was an extra in that rally scene! One of the brownshirts. Two very hot summer nights shooting under a railroad bridge in Cranford, NJ. The attention to detail that the producers/crew put into the show was amazing. And the stunt people did not fuck around. It felt very real. My throat was sore for like two days afterwards from all the yelling and the herbal cigarette smoking. A really intense, but rewarding experience!

8

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

Did they have to build a set for those downtown scenes with the movie theatre?

15

u/Wyatt821 Apr 14 '20

I'm not sure I was just there for the rally scene...I doubt it though. Pretty sure they just shot out on the streets of Newark, maybe dressing up the storefronts and whatnot to look more of the time period.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

That makes much more sense.

3

u/markydsade Apr 15 '20

They also use CGI to demodernize street scenes. They did it a lot on Mrs. Maisel. Remove window air conditioners, add old store signs, etc.

36

u/DBClayton Apr 14 '20

This episode, as well as the last have me thinking a lot about how stripping away systems of support— schools, synagogues, kosher food, etc.— places a burden of Jews, and one that creates a disparity in accessibility to the right to practice based on power. The greatest sacrifice the Rabbi has made is setting a cup of shrimp cocktail aside. He has power and resources— unlike Seldon’s mother he is not dependent on one company for support, unlike Herman he could wait out a court decision, or petition the president. Worst comes to worst, Bengelsdorf likely has the wealth to carry the burden of inaccessible Jewish resources— importing kosher food, traveling to form a minyan, etc. that others couldn’t. When Bengelsdorf says he could live anywhere, he is projecting his privileged position. Still not sure whether he is aware his case is rare and his intent is to completely unravel the fabric of Jewish life, or he is holding onto his delusions— Turturro is such a great actor, I can’t make up my mind.

26

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

On top of all your well put points Bengel didn't build his wealth himself, I think he's supposed to portray the decedent of already wealthy German Jews that migrated to the South in the early 19th century. He never faced any adversity in his life and was always in a position of comfort and luxury so naturally something like relocation would just seem like an inconvenience to him and not an immense burden that could break a family financially and emotionally.

I think he genuinely believes (at least initially) he is helping them, he brings up how they can finally buy their own home and live the American dream, but what good is a home of your own without any sense of community? There are plenty of places in America today that I could afford to purchase a house, but those places aren't my home.

8

u/DBClayton Apr 14 '20

Ooh so true about that, I wasn’t even thinking about how his wealth is also (highly likely) generational. I’m writing a paper for school on rebuilding Jewish communities after the Holocaust, and it’s clear all of these different, specific elements need to be present for a Jewish community to maintain itself, so it is definitely on my mind right now.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

so if it was fine for him, then why are all these families from New Jersey and New York complaining about Kentucky?

first difference is he was born in South Carolina to an established and wealthy family. he wasn’t forcefully migrated there, it was all he knew.

but the biggest reason growing up in the South wasn’t bad for him was money. it doesn’t matter what ethnicity or religious background you have if you’re rich you are going to have a much easier time in life than your poor contemporaries.

I also feel it is pretty telling that at some point in his life he moved to Jersey

10

u/JoeyMcSqueeb Apr 14 '20

Bengelsdorf is slowly beginning to see he has been duped into selling his people out.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

Still not sure whether he is aware his case is rare and his intent is to completely unravel the fabric of Jewish life, or he is holding onto his delusions— Turturro is such a great actor, I can’t make up my mind.

Without spoiling anything, I will say that the equivocality of Turturro's performance on this very point is perfect.

2

u/paracelsus53 Apr 14 '20

The one thing I cannot understand about Bengelsdorf is why he would think it would be a great idea for Jews to be sent to a place where they would have no opportunity to form a minyan. I don't know about the book, but I often think watching the show that he is intended to be an old-school Reform rabbi who would not consider traditional practice to be important, even if underneath it all, he might actually despise East European Jews like Herman and his family.

34

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

If Herman doesn’t decide to go to Canada after the rally and how the media portrayed it.. he is blind. As a Jew, I’d have been like him. But at that point enough is enough and it’s time to leave.

24

u/Take_Some_Soma Apr 14 '20

There's standing up for what's right, which is honorable. But then there's a certain level of responsibility attached to being a partner/parent that he's letting fall to the wayside.

You gotta recognize a hostile situation and do what's in the interest of your family.

6

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 15 '20

My thoughts exactly, starting the revolution is best left to the younger generation or strong military/political minds. Herman isn't a young man anymore and you can see that in his day of work at his brother's market. Herman is still thinking like a 22 year old single man with nothing to lose when in reality he's pushing 40 (early/mid-30s at the youngest) and he has EVERYTHING to lose.

His fight is admirable and totally justifiable to a point, but when you have a strong loving wife and kids that are all in emanate danger you have to cut your losses and GTFO as much as that may bruise your pride.

3

u/pleasedontabbabme Apr 16 '20

If you think the Jews that ran to Canada are safe you haven’t been paying attention to history. Herman is in a position of damned if you do and damned if you don’t. He could keep his head down and move along like a good little jew with the rest of the herd or die standing up for his beliefs.

We’re talking about a timeline where the U.S backs the Axis powers... There’s no Jewish state in Palestine/Uganda/wherever on the horizon and there will be no Cold War.

Once the neutrality charade is over the first order of buisness is a strategic invasion of Canada. It’s nothing personal but the U.S can’t risk Canada turning “red”. After that I can only assume that Mexico will be repurposed as a Ford assembly line factory state.

“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.”

The fate of the Levins and the world hase been sealed off-screen between episodes two and three.

8

u/Rshackleford22 Apr 14 '20

And the preview for next week shows it’s too late for him to go north

6

u/geometicshapes Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

It’s made especially clear in the juxtaposition between Herman and Alvin.

Alvin is a single man who made the choice he was willing to sacrifice his life to fight for his beliefs. That’s noble, even if short sighted.

Herman is married with children. His choice to stay and continue fighting for the sake of his own pride, after his wife repeatedly asks that they move, his youngest child is being routinely traumatized, and his oldest son is being brainwashed, is more than just not noble, it’s selfish AND short sighted.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ButDidYouCry Apr 14 '20

Usually by the time things get to "enough is enough", there are no options left to leave.

19

u/shooter9260 Apr 14 '20

Granted I’ve never lived in a political climate like the one in the show, but to me Herman is one of those annoying people who care way too strongly about his beliefs and puts them above all else — family, life, etc.

9

u/devnulld2 Apr 14 '20

At this point, his own pride is his priority. He told Bess that he won’t go to Canada because then they win. I hope that he sees the light.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

His pride will kill them all, imo I wish they would’ve immigrated when Bess asked him to. They would’ve had an easy entry with his nephew already fighting for the British

→ More replies (1)

26

u/awilliam_75 Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

Charlottesville, Pittsburgh, immigrant children separated from their families, 'fake' news, etc. Maybe we're not living in the exact political climate depicted in the show, but we're not too far from it. I think that's what makes the show so riveting and terrifying.

11

u/Rshackleford22 Apr 14 '20

It’s so eerily similar to what’s happens here the past 4 years you’d think this show was written recently but nope it was written before all this. Explains how fascism takes over. Not quickly but slowly.

10

u/SpoofedFinger Apr 14 '20

Not just that but the blowback the creators have received about "America First" being used in the show by people that don't know the current president lifted it from literal fucking nazi sympathizers and fascists back in the 40s.

9

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 14 '20

The show is a prime example of the boiling frog metaphor:

If you drop a frog in a pot of boiling water, it will of course frantically try to clamber out. But if you place it gently in a pot of tepid water and turn the heat on low, it will float there quite placidly. As the water gradually heats up, the frog will sink into a tranquil stupor, exactly like one of us in a hot bath, and before long, with a smile on its face, it will unresistingly allow itself to be boiled to death.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 14 '20

The police letting the fascists attack the crowd reminded me of some modern day things..

25

u/JoeyMcSqueeb Apr 14 '20

“knock the crap out of them, would you? Seriously, OK? Just knock the hell ... I promise you I will pay for the legal fees” -Donald J Trump 2016

8

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

Bruh. The American government is allying itself with Nazi Germany, and were beginning to see the American political and socioeconomic system turn against the Jews just like Nazi Germany did. What happens if Germany wins the war? Do they pressure America to start working toward their own “final solution”? Would clown ass Lindbergh comply?

We’re far tf off from that^ political climate, thank fucking God.

7

u/grendel-khan Apr 15 '20

It doesn't map well to the situation American Jews face now. But it does map well enough to the situation with the current class of not-quite-American people, who are currently being held indefinitely in terrible conditions, who various citizen "militia" types have taken it upon themselves to harass, and who currently deal with a combination of trying really hard to be Americans and finding out that they're not... and who roughly half of the country thinks that we should be harsher to.

A more competent executive could do much worse. We're fortunate this one is evil and stupid.

9

u/Breaking-Away Apr 14 '20

Put yourself in the mindset of the time and remember that Nazi Germany wasn’t universally considered taboo and a villain for the last 80 years like it is for us today.

Honestly, the closest thing today is probably how Trump is comfortable cozying up with Authortarian leaders like Xi, Kim Jong Il, Erdogan, and Orban when convenient.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (34)

6

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 14 '20

I agree he's annoying. His wife is the only rational one.

13

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

Bess is my girl, seems to be the only one not clouded by some ideological stance or moving up the ladder.

She is a strong Mother who wants the best for her family and nothing else

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20

He still believes in not only the importance of the ideals that the United States stands for, but the power of those ideals as well. He thinks that freedom and democracy will save the day.

He also believes in the goodness of people and that the average American will care enough about the plight of the Jews or other minorities.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BenTVNerd21 Apr 28 '20

Imagine if the Suffragettes, Civil Rights activists ect. had this attitude.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Rshackleford22 Apr 14 '20

Agreed. Not everyone can run. Sooner or later gotta fight back.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/devnulld2 Apr 14 '20

What's happening is definitely worth taking a stand against, but how effective can Herman be? Social progress doesn't occur because a lone crusader took a courageous stand. Even if he were able to form or join a movement, the odds are against him succeeding. I think that discretion is the better part of valor in this case.

6

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 14 '20

Even if he were able to form or join a movement, the odds are against him succeeding.

Well, that's true of most social progress movements, particularly at the outset. If everybody decided it wasn't worth trying we'd still have Jim Crow and no 19th amendment.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

If Herman doesn’t decide to go to Canada after the rally and how the media portrayed it.. he is blind. As a Jew, I’d have been like him. But at that point enough is enough and it’s time to leave.

Potentially massive spoiler, but it was included in the teaser for the next episode, and it is in the source...

The border is closed before they can leave.

2

u/ironyfree Apr 14 '20

Time is a funny thing, it's only been a year and a half since Lindberg was elected. I can understand how he still thinks things can't possibly be that different. It's hard for people to accept change as huge as that over such a short period of time.

1

u/Esterhowse Apr 16 '20

Herman clearly doesn't know this, but going north is pointless. Once Germany crushes Europe, the rest of the world is next and Canada is already at open war with Germany.

1

u/dualsplit Apr 20 '20

My instinct says to send Bess and the boys to Canada, and stay to fight. My instincts are usually wrong and I’m a doughy middle aged woman. So...

→ More replies (1)

32

u/samspopguy Apr 14 '20

I feel like there’s so many more stories to tell yet we only have one episode left.

23

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

I have no idea how they can wrap this in one more episode, I feel like I'm just beginning a deep world building and character driven show that was meant to go for 5 seasons.

9

u/samspopguy Apr 14 '20

yep exactly, I have no clue if they only planned for 1 season or if this one season is pretty much the book. But i feel like if you have good writers which seems like they do they could extend past this season.

10

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 14 '20

This is pretty much the book. They've always billed it as a miniseries so I'm pretty sure they're going to end it with where the book ends.

4

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 14 '20

Preview for next episode said "series finale" so this is it

0

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '20

This... won't become a huge hit.

I'm expecting them to keep it sort of open at the end, not resolve everything.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Gatesleeper Apr 14 '20

I haven't read the book so I don't know how it ends, but I feel like it can only end very badly. There's not enough time for things to turn around in only one episode. If this show was slated for multiple seasons I could at least imagine the possibility. But given the trajectory of the first 5 episodes, anything even approaching optimism would only be a jarring change of directions.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/leflyingbison Apr 14 '20

I think Alvin's storyline is gonna be left in the dust. They didn't even show how Sandy felt about him once he came back.

7

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

They didn't even show how Sandy felt about him once he came back.

They did, though. Sandy has been avoiding him. Avoiding him means relatively little screentime together, but we did get a shot of a rather sad reaction from Alvin.

29

u/facu_draper Apr 14 '20

It kills me to see how awfully poor Philip is loosing his innocence

26

u/trimonkeys Apr 14 '20

The scene where he handed Seldon the stamps was pretty powerful.

28

u/MickeyPineapple Apr 14 '20

The rally scene where those troublemakers entered the scene and the police just stood by, was just too hard to watch. I have seen similar things happen in my country and the police responding in the same way. It's unnerving how realistic this scene was!

19

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

When I first saw the blonde brownshirt comes down the stairs leading to the Winchell rally, my blood ran cold.

Their slow infiltration of the crowd and the gradual escalation of violence was eerily apt.

6

u/No_volvere Apr 15 '20

When have the police not been on the side of the right wing?

3

u/varro-reatinus Apr 16 '20

When they and local military units used to get their kicks after work by changing into civilian clothes and beating the living shit out of local white supremacist groups in Ontario and Quebec.

2

u/No_volvere Apr 16 '20

Everyone's gotta de-stress after a long day.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/aw3man Apr 14 '20

I'm totally engrossed in the episode that I'm still kind of speechless. Growing up in NJ and learning the histories of race riots and economic depression in parts of Newark and almost all of Paterson makes me realize how the persecuted Jews would feel in this series. Not everything has to be so black and white in racism and antisemitism. Sometimes it is a set of institutions and sets of laws and programs and sets of bad actors which can be the instigators for full on discrimination and persecution against a group of people.

24

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

This is not only one of the best shows on TV in 2020, it's one of the best shows I've ever seen.

This is some Singing Detective-level stuff we're watching, folks.

Remember these days. This is art history.

We may also be witnessing John Turturro's best performance, in a career of brilliant performances.

22

u/owen_core Apr 14 '20

This show is absolutely fantastic, I do not understand how almost no one has heard of it. Did HBO not advertise about it or something?

23

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

It's a short series, and for all its many merits, it's not flashy TV like, say, Westworld. It's a harder sell.

I suspect this series will become a massive critical success and be often repeated, but it will take a while to gain traction with the public, and, again, being a shorter series works against it. Even The Wire took time to catch on.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Fuck flashy tv its for the brain dead imo.. people need to use their head more not less.

I personally don't care what party you're for cause I think they're nothing but tools to force ppl against one another. Probably why washington hated them so much. An example ofc

21

u/jtrachtenberg Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 15 '20

The show runners have set Bengelsdorf up for a turn in the final episode. We've see the president all but ignore him, Henry Ford make anti-Semitic and racist comments toward him and then completely disregard his concerns at the OAA meeting. All of this occurs in front of Evelyn too. Bengelsdorf has served his role for Lindy and now they don't need him anymore. Alvin put it best early on in the series when he said that Bengelsdorf's endorsement wasn't for jews, but for gentiles to feel okay with voting for Lindy.

4

u/markydsade Apr 15 '20

Even today we see “useful agents” used by foreign governments to manipulate domestic opinions and voting.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '20

Hell, we even see certain people in the WH administration so that Trump can pass himself off as not racist.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/trimonkeys Apr 14 '20

The Winchell riot scene was harrowing, with the crowd erupting in chaos. Kazan stole this episode especially with her acting in the final scene. Props to the kid who plays Philip I had a lump in my throat when he gave Seldon the stamp collection.

29

u/facu_draper Apr 14 '20

The rabbi has become one of my most hated tv- characters of all time

28

u/jbraden09 Apr 14 '20

I hate Evelyn almost as much. And I know he’s just a kid, but Sandy is on my last nerve.

13

u/chicityman09 Apr 14 '20

I literally said out loud tonight Sandy is a shit head.

18

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 14 '20

I don't think Evelyn is malicious, but I do think she is stupid. I hate discussing parallels especially in today's political climate, but she reminds me of how Stepford wives/the wives of politicians are supposed to be....just looking pretty, don't have an opinion, and support your husband. Melania Trump seems like she honestly has no idea what's going on in the world. Eva Braun (Hitler's wife for 1 day), was supposed to be a moron as well.

8

u/SpoofedFinger Apr 14 '20

I dunno, she did rock a face mask a day or two after dipshit made a big deal about not wearing one himself.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/SoySauceSHA Apr 14 '20

I hate Evelyn more, the rabbi looked like he was doubting things in the meeting about the OAA and the preview for the next episode.

14

u/jbraden09 Apr 14 '20

I think they (Rabbi, Evelyn, and Sandy) will all start to feel doubt, regret, shame in the final episode as the situation deteriorates.

10

u/SoySauceSHA Apr 14 '20

Yeah, at least according to the preview, Sandy completely 180s

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lolVerbivore Apr 14 '20

Maybe it's a good thing I'm not a parent because I cant see myself not slapping the absolute shit out of Sandy. Kid's got his head so far up his own ass

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Christ how many times has this kid run off and cussed out his dad only to come back like a spoiled brat.

I applaud the dad for not kicking him out or hitting him like his wife did.

11

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 14 '20

Ugh I hope Foghorn Leghorn and is little Golem have a true comeuppance

10

u/CooCooMachoo Apr 14 '20

Is there going to be another season?

I can't imagine how this can get wrapped up in one last episode.

9

u/shooter9260 Apr 14 '20

It just said “series finale” sadly

6

u/chicityman09 Apr 14 '20

Yeah this is a one-off limited series.

20

u/shooter9260 Apr 14 '20

The mini series are always so good but too short. Chernobyl was the same way

10

u/CooCooMachoo Apr 14 '20

Chernobyl was soooooo good.

Did you listen to the podcasts as well? There are podcasts for this series as well. An extra treat.

10

u/NZsupremacist Apr 14 '20

That scene with the brownjackets...gosh, and the police just letting it happen. I can only see this ruining Winchell's chance at running for president with that fight. It seems like either way people like Hermann are screwed. Can't follow the system as it's rigged from the top, cant use violence or risk getting beaten and killed. Only so much you can push a group into a corner before they have to come out fighting though.

9

u/mattyice522 Apr 14 '20

Is it just a coincidence that the kid went on a retreat to Kentucky where this forced relocation is going to be?

14

u/shooter9260 Apr 14 '20

Probably not. I assume Evelyn did that some it worked be near where Sandy went and it working seem all bad.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

She knows he is vulnerable to supporting the move if he knew the area, and she exploited it to get someone in the family to want to move.

2

u/Esterhowse Apr 16 '20

No not at all.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

It was probably some youth nazi thing I bet.

9

u/Adrian_FCD Apr 14 '20

Man, the show's slow burn is HAUNTING.

I'm don't know if i can handle the finalle.

8

u/JamesHRoss Apr 14 '20

So tensed about Alvin

8

u/couscous200 Apr 14 '20

Another tense episode, can’t wait for the finale

8

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 14 '20

Can someone explain to me everything involving Alvin in this episode? I had a really hard time following his storyline.

24

u/hibachi2723 Apr 14 '20

Alvin got an new job. Not sure the full extent of the business, but a portion of it has to do pinball machines. Alvin finds out that people have been stealing coins from the machine from scratches near the keyhole not caused by the actual key.

He informs the boss, who is skeptical at first. The boss installs the new locks, telling Alvin this better result in more coins in the machines. Alvin recommends raising the price per play, but the boss mentions it's not the simple. I don't recall all the names he mentioned, but def heard Waxey Gordon, who is a well known gangster of the era (Boardwalk Empire shoutout). Boss mentions that stuff like that needs approval and Gordon, etc. get a cut of everything.

Alvin also flirts a bit with the boss's daughter, which the boss notices. Last scene was the FBI tailing/following him around due to him fighting in the war for Canada

11

u/Gatesleeper Apr 14 '20

That one conversation he had with his boss about raising prices was actually really hard to follow. I rewound and listened to it several times and I'm still not 100% on it. There's a lot of exposition missing here, they're asking a lot of the audience to pick up on.

So the boss doesn't own or run the bars where those pinball machines are. He just owns the machines, and rents them out to places of business. "Pinball Billy Schapp". It's not just random customers who are stealing from the machines, it's the bar owners themselves stealing from the machines, which they do not own.

So when Alvin talks about raising prices, he's not talking about raising the prices to play the machines, but to raise the price to rent them, a Lincoln ($5 bill) per pinball or vending machine, a Hamilton ($10 bill) per slot machine.

Schnapp opposes the idea and says the bar owners would complain too much if he does, even though they've been stealing from him, and presumably a few of them haven't. Alvin suggests violence/intimidation, and Schnapp says he doesn't like rough stuff, and also that him upping his "take", it will result in his bosses taking more cut or 'ante'.

4

u/devnulld2 Apr 14 '20

I think that you understand the scene perfectly.

4

u/hibachi2723 Apr 14 '20

This is a much better/in depth analysis of the conversation with the boss than what I had. Thanks.

4

u/Grsz11 Apr 16 '20

Here's an article on the mafia's use of pinball machine.

The Deuce had a similar subplot, but by that time they were porn machines.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

Lot of book changes. Idk what they’re doing with Alvin anymore, I assume he’s in Philly already but can’t tell if the show established that.

Phillip giving his stamps to the small weird kid means a big moment from the book probably won’t happen, which I’m not mad at since it seems super unneeded with how much story they have to tell.

15

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

it’s established that he’s in Philly, when he goes to his boss to tell him about how easy his machines are to break into he mentions all the places he went to check it out, he rattles off 4 or 5 Philly neighborhoods

3

u/formlex7 Apr 14 '20

I thought they were hinting at it by having sandy draw the horses but yeah I guess they've decided to skip that part, or at least not have him lose his stamp collection there.

20

u/Thatoneguy241 Apr 14 '20

The last three episodes have been amazing.

But I can’t forgive the people who decided the first two episodes needed to revolve around Bitch Boy Sandy and his drawing skills and Alvins shaky relationship with his uncle. And that one wealthy kid who followed people around and collected stamps.

19

u/jbraden09 Apr 14 '20

Haha. Though I love the show, some of that does seem unnecessary as the show comes to an end with so much story left to tell in one episode.

12

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20 edited Apr 14 '20

But I can’t forgive the people who decided the first two episodes needed to revolve around Bitch Boy Sandy and his drawing skills and Alvins shaky relationship with his uncle.

That was absolutely necessary. They had to show Sandy as a reasonably good-natured kid to create the tension of his subsequent corruption.

And that one wealthy kid who followed people around and collected stamps.

I agree that wasn't as well done, as an element of the overall adaptation, but it did help to Philip's gradual slide into subterfuge and guilt.

16

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

that kid was so fucking weird for nothing to come from it. straight up raiding his mom’s panty drawer and trying to get Phillip to do the same.

all i can think is that the stamps he gave Phillip when he went away are valuable and Phillip giving them to Seldon shows that he knew that what he did (inadvertently) led this weak and poorly adjusted kid to have to move to Kentucky.

but yeah that still doesn’t explain why they had to make big kid such a fucking creep

10

u/Halgrind Apr 14 '20

Could be that the kid existed in real life. Phillip Roth wrote the book semi-autobiographically, it's entirely from his perspective as a 10 year old kid. All the names and relations were his real family, hard to say what was fictional and what was childhood memory that he grafted into the alternate reality.

2

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 14 '20

thanks for clarifying, i have wondered that since i saw the boy’s name was Phillip just like the author. hard to write a character with the same name as your and not make it even a little biographical.

i wanted to look into it but i don’t want book spoilers until after i’ve finished the series.

3

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 15 '20

In the book the family is named Roth not Levin. It is super autobiographical.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24

Thought for sure some sicker shit was gonna happen with that kid ngl

8

u/devnulld2 Apr 14 '20

I don't think I will ever understand why this show included Earl.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 14 '20

Yeah, Phillip's friend didn't feel like it went anywhere.

Only real payoff was Seldon immediately asking Phillip "am I your best friend now?" after his rich friend moves away.

7

u/varro-reatinus Apr 14 '20

Spoiler-free friendly warning re. Seldon:

WAIT FOR IT.

7

u/paracelsus53 Apr 14 '20

I love Seldon's character. He feels so real. And you know IRL he would be eaten alive in KY.

10

u/mattyice522 Apr 14 '20

Is this the penultimate episode?

6

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 14 '20

Yes, it's only 6 episodes.

5

u/ironyfree Apr 14 '20

This show is legit giving me stress.

7

u/buy_gold_bye Apr 14 '20

I HATE SANSY OML THAT BOY NEEDS TO SHUT HIS BRAINWASHED ASS. he deserved that slap.

6

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 14 '20

I find the I find myself holding my breath every single episode. What a show this is.

3

u/CooCooMachoo Apr 15 '20

Does anyone listen to the podcasts afterwards.

This one was for Part 5. It really adds to the experience imo.

https://youtu.be/AzR_IsYY_1A

3

u/DrKennethNoisewater- Apr 15 '20

The Rabbi can get fuckin bent

3

u/Esterhowse Apr 16 '20

It is interesting that we are now past the date that the attack on Pearl Harbor should have happened.

2

u/kds405 Apr 17 '20

This makes me hope for an adaptation of Phillip Roth’s “Nemesis” with the same team....it would be another perfect reflection for these times.

2

u/XxAnon5861xX Apr 17 '20

The wife and husband are BOTH right, just like most arguments in real life. This show has to win an Emmy(s).

2

u/XxAnon5861xX Apr 17 '20

Am I the only one assuming people will start to be gathered up by the last episode?

1

u/Mentioned_Videos Apr 15 '20

Videos in this thread: Watch Playlist ▶

VIDEOCOMMENT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5UufS9gURmU+6 - Skip to around :38 in this clip.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnow7YXuSes&t=20s+3 - Actually, the one you're thinking of is just Kyle.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzR_IsYY_1A+1 - Does anyone listen to the podcasts afterwards. This one was for Part 5. It really adds to the experience imo.
I'm a bot working hard to help Redditors find related videos to watch. I'll keep this updated as long as I can.

Play All | Info | Get me on Chrome / Firefox

1

u/brianwilliamsibrowse Apr 18 '20

For some reason I thought the FBI were going to try and recruit Alvin. Like they'd say Hoover is powermad and feels threatened by the SS, so he's recruiting secret agents like Alvin for whatever purpose

1

u/_handsomeblackman_ Apr 20 '20

How they intend to everything together in one episode I do not but wow this show is amazing

As others have said, time stands still watching this show, it demands my full attention every time. The acting is truly out of this world from all involved!

I love how they depicted the rise of fascism, slow and gradual in its acceptance with the population which is really frightening but also a far better representation of reality.

Herman’s idealism is a tad frustrating, at every road block he reverts back to his faith in the American constitution, bizarre but incredibly admirable.

Sandy? No words really, what an annoying kid but I guess that should be expected somewhat, teenager growing up during any period of time wants to rebel against their parents

I honestly cannot wait for the finale

1

u/jbraden09 Apr 14 '20

People with HBO Now, when does it typically show up?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/zkela Apr 14 '20

they're just sticking to what's in the book and doing it in 1 season.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/dualsplit Apr 20 '20

That could be SO good, with the Winchell character on the radio narrating what’s happening outside.