r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • • Apr 21 '20

Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x06 "Part 6" - Episode Discussion

Season 1 Episode 6: Part 6

Aired: April 20, 2020


Synopsis: As riots and conspiracies spread across the country in the lead up to election day, Herman takes measures to keep his family safe. Bess does all she can at a great distance to help a small child caught in a maelstrom of anti-Semitism in Kentucky.


Directed by: Thomas Schlamme

Written by: David Simon

170 Upvotes

911 comments sorted by

188

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

Holy shit. Can we just take a minute to realize how heartbreaking Seldon's phone calls were?

76

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 21 '20

That long take of his call with Bess while she slowly kneeled on the ground was brutal

50

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 21 '20

the tension of that scene was unreal, the sadness for Seldon and off camera violence happening outside the house had me on fucking edge...the entire time i was waiting for a brick or something to come crashing through the window behind her

→ More replies (1)

27

u/976-EVIL Apr 21 '20

I got high before the episode and was starting to have a panic attack during that scene

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

71

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

someone finally said it. Seldon has been tugging at my heart strings since he was first introduced.

40

u/par5ul1 Apr 21 '20

Omg yes! The kid plays the shy little boy role perfectly. You can see the dispair in his eyes the whole time.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/thrill_murray Apr 21 '20

I was tearing up. That was amazing on both actors’ parts, juxtaposed against the gunshots in the night. I’m awestruck of that kid actor being that powerful through voice only.

12

u/ItsBobDoleYo Apr 21 '20

That kid has been too freaking adorable the entire series

7

u/savethemouselemur Apr 22 '20

On a lighter note, he’s also super cute in John Mulaney’s Sack Lunch Bunch on Netflix. He’s a natural.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/fede01_8 Apr 22 '20

If it was hard to watch for us dudes without kids, I don't want to imagine what it must have felt like for young mothers.

3

u/concernedPOC Apr 25 '20

Yea I was in tears. He’s been an annoying little shit the whole series, of course it’s not his fault but they did a good job of realistically portraying how annoying he could be. But those calls brought me to tears. He would literally die without supervision. I’m glad they went and got him. I know Philip felt so guilty because he basically caused him to get sent there

→ More replies (19)

150

u/Hekrjejdjs Apr 21 '20

Tommy the new neighbor is so cool

95

u/maxlot13 Apr 21 '20

Best character, we need a spin off of him handing people guns

44

u/SpoofedFinger Apr 21 '20

He can hand Johnny Boy and Junior guns in '60s Newark.

25

u/SawRub Apr 22 '20

All of his interactions were so wholesome. Like they were at home and heard what happened, and he wanted to give them a gun, but then was like no let's bake a whole cake first too.

→ More replies (1)

73

u/Pulp-nonfiction Apr 21 '20

I feel like you were supposed to feel uneasy as they were moving in and then they turned out to be the best neighbors.

63

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

Yeah. I think that his presence was supposed to imply that the Jews were being displaced from their neighborhoods. He even removes the mezuzah. But then, as a fellow minority, he shows immense solidarity.

→ More replies (8)

35

u/grendel-khan Apr 21 '20

Same with the tour guide in DC--part of what's so corrosive about the rising tide of fascism is that it gives people this justified fear of their neighbors. So when they turn out to be a decent neighbor, it's a combination of relief that you're safe, and shame that you thought so little of them.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

32

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

hey paisan

41

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

He represented what an American should be. He recognized the Levins as fellow countrymen even though they didn't belong to the same ethnic groups.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Naggers123 Apr 21 '20

must be cool to have your house looked after by a guy the size of said house

4

u/rbevans May 09 '20

My moms side is Jewish and she grew up in Brooklyn. She tells me stories of growing up in a neighborhood of Jews and Italians and the Italian mafia looked over them. Similar to the guys walking the streets in the final episode.

→ More replies (1)

112

u/SerPizza Apr 21 '20

Bess keeping it together for Seldon over the phone while hearing gunshots in her own neighborhood was fantastic television. She showed so much strength in the entire series, but this episode we truly saw that she was made of. Her confrontation with Evelyn ("I will always love you... But I will never forgive you") was acted so effectively. I was fighting back tears from how that broken relationship was portrayed as it finally ended for good.

What a finale.

56

u/Chaosmusic Apr 21 '20

Why don't you ask von Ribbentrop for help?

I loved that line.

17

u/ccharlie03 Apr 23 '20

I literally screamed fuck yea when she said that.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/AlllyMaine May 07 '20

I loved that line, but clearly Evelyn isn't deep enough a person to even understand why Bess said that. She seems to lack the ability to be introspective and I doubt she'll ever feel any responsibility for the situation she put her family in

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/sulls_s Apr 21 '20

Yes!! I was frustrated with her character at the beginning because she never spoke up and refused to be confrontational when her husband went ballistic. But when she started to find her voice, and especially the scene where she slaps sandy and tells him off, I was so PROUD of her character development and how she could so fiercely stand up for what she believed in. She was my fav character by the end of the series.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/april-kang Apr 22 '20

I love Bess! Her lines have been mentioned here. I have one more to add:

Herman: Bess, you are right. We should be in Canada now.

Bess: No. Seldon is our responsibility now.

I am deeply touched by Bess.

→ More replies (1)

86

u/Doctor-Strangedick Apr 21 '20

Interesting. I know it was a miniseries, but I feel like a few things should’ve been fleshed out more. Alvin’s story especially seemed rushed, and I think an update on how the war was going would’ve been nice.

Overall though, I enjoyed the series.

33

u/SoySauceSHA Apr 21 '20

According to the book, Pearl harbor happened then history resumed as normal.

9

u/joey1405 Apr 21 '20

Give me a page number for that because I didn't read that in the book, it ended before the election.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

9

u/trimonkeys Apr 21 '20

I found his story pretty uninteresting after he came back from the war. It felt too disconnected.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/yungamerica6997 Apr 21 '20

last episodes should have been 2-3 separate episodes

4

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

The whole fucking last 3 episodes seemed rushed

→ More replies (44)

70

u/Tinkmama22 Apr 21 '20

“Sis, it’s me, Evelyn”

“New phone, who dis?”

I love, love, love Bess. Especially how she handled things with her sister. Too often I see forgiveness touted as being necessary to live your life to the fullest, and that to forgive makes a person morally just... I’m so glad they tackled the concept of loving someone, but realizing that they fucked up past the point of return and no one should have to put up with that if they don’t want to.

44

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 21 '20

If the Feds really were looking for Evelyn, she was actively putting Bess and her family in even more danger at that point.

So Bess disowning her wasn't just justified, it was necessary.

10

u/ManitouWakinyan Apr 21 '20

I'm surprised she never fully articulated that. It felt like it was hanging in the air over all of their conversations.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/ButDidYouCry Apr 21 '20

Too often I see forgiveness touted as being necessary to live your life to the fullest, and that to forgive makes a person morally just...

I could be completely wrong, but I think it helps that Bess is Jewish and Jews have an entirely different relationship to the concept of forgiveness compared to Christians, who are practically required to forgive people because it's a huge part of Christ's New Testament teachings. Bess isn't required to forgive Evelyn, especially since Evelyn has done nothing to redeem herself for betraying her family and her larger religious community.

21

u/SpoofedFinger Apr 21 '20

She isn't repentant in the slightest, either. She even yells something about doing nothing wrong when Bess slams the door.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/WYWildcats Apr 22 '20

I thought Zoe Kazan's performance was phenomenal.

114

u/JamesHRoss Apr 21 '20

Zoe Kazan has been thoroughly amazing on this show and she'll be shamefully robbed of an Emmy nom come morning of nominations. What a brilliant little show. For me it's easily the biggest surprise of the year

49

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 21 '20

She has been brilliant. And to think she was also in The Big Sick!

My heart was racing the entire time, especially when Herman and Sandy went to KY.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/MickeyPineapple Apr 21 '20

Zoe Kazan was phenomenal! For me she was the lead of the show.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/facu_draper Apr 21 '20

The MVP of the show easily ( there are many highlights though)

→ More replies (15)

49

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 21 '20

I always hated the ending of the book, so I'm glad they ended it where they did instead of going down the original magic reset button route.

16

u/afictionalcharacter Apr 21 '20

Haven’t read the book but that’s disappointing... Not much of purpose if history on a macro scale goes on as usual besides a populist blip.

32

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 21 '20

Yeah, that's why I've always hated it.

Honestly even the idea of FDR pulling a Cleveland and coming back post-Lindbergh doesn't necessarily bug me, but the book is very clean and just sort of "yeah 1940-42 was a wild time but it all turned out okay in the end".

→ More replies (12)

26

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

besides a populist blip.

Populism and fascism aren’t equivalent.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (3)

48

u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 21 '20

i want to give a shoutout to Sandy, he was easy to dislike the whole time but in the end he was just an adolescent that didn't fully understand the gravity of what was going on around him and I think we can all relate to that.

The moment riots and violence broke out against Jews he started to have doubts about his personal beliefs and he started seeing the world for what it was, hearing his formal hero speak at that airfield in Kentucky solidified the fact that what his father was saying was true, Lindbergh didn't care about him or his people.

Watching him tear up his sketches of Lindy was a powerful moment, we were watching a once naive boy become a young man with the critical thinking to form his own conclusions

9

u/ArcticRhombus Apr 21 '20

This may just be an example of how even wonderful television cannot convey the nuance of literature. I read the book many years ago and had my memory jogged by the show.

There’s so much sympathetic about Sandy, to me, in both the book and the show, as a secular Jew who has strong residual dislike for certain aspects of Jewish insularity.

He’s absolutely right that his father is parochial, and tribal, and didactic. He’s absolutely right that his father is frightened of non-Jewish culture and is subliminally passing that on to his family. And at the end of the day, he’s a sensitive child who doesn’t want to hurt a fly, and loves drawing and nature, and his father is an insurance man, not at all an artist or a romantic.

And that’s the tragedy, I suppose. That someone who is by disposition peaceful and non-violent becomes allied against his family on behalf of a cause of hatred and violence.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Notre_Dame_Football Apr 22 '20

I agree.

When he tore up those sketches I said out loud to myself "bout fucking time. there you go, kid."

→ More replies (7)

91

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

Why don’t you call Von Ribbentrop.. DAMN

16

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

I liked that too. Burnnnnn

→ More replies (4)

43

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

I loved the Italian neighbors. Wish we saw them more. If I weren't a Jew, I'd want to be Italian. I love the culture and just how they interact with each other.

24

u/perfunctorium Apr 21 '20

I'm a third generation Italian American... My family has always talked about how similar we are in culture. To the point where my mother always wanted me to settle down with a "nice Jewish boy" haha.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/ButDidYouCry Apr 21 '20

Wait. You aren't a pregnant Mexican teen? Darn.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/berry_well_then Apr 22 '20

Yes! My mom always says that the Italians are the lost tribe of the Jews, our cultures have so much in common.

Tommy was such a ray of light coming in and immediately letting the Levins know that he was on their side. That was daring and brave. Gotta love that Italian/Jewish solidarity

→ More replies (3)

29

u/DJ_BB Apr 21 '20

Loved the episode but what’s going on with the ballot burning at the end? And just want to make sure Lindbergh’s kid sing kidnapped is a false conspiracy right?

40

u/aw3man Apr 21 '20

The ballot burning and removal of voting machines was an effort to stop the communities (it seemed like black, brown and immigrants) certain people didn't want to vote.

18

u/zkela Apr 21 '20

it looked like a general effort by the FBI/g-men/Wheeler backers to rig the election against Roosevelt.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/revolverzanbolt Apr 21 '20

It’s vote tampering; it’s a commentary on current voter suppression laws and jerrymandering done in America today.

You aren’t supposed to be sure who wins the election in the end

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (24)

27

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 21 '20

Omg a cliffhanger?!?! Like that??!!? Nooooo!!!!

23

u/SoySauceSHA Apr 21 '20

Roosevelt won. Pearl Harbor happened, history went forward as normal.

19

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 21 '20

But the voting conspiracy? Is that part of the book too??

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/Stealth70 Apr 21 '20

And it's good because it's better In my opinion. The "handwave" in the book is jarring.

24

u/rugbypike11 Apr 21 '20

I’ve been having weird dreams about dystopia. This episode won’t help.

12

u/zsreport Apr 21 '20

It light of being stuck home for several weeks (I live alone) with few outings and the fact that the industry I work in tanked today my nerves are super raw and this whole episode had me on edge. Didn’t help when blue and reds started coming through my front door’s windows, thankfully it was just a traffic stop.

7

u/rugbypike11 Apr 21 '20

It was like watching a very slow moving horror film.

Good luck with the industry. I’m told by some market friends that today was a contract expiration date and prices should normalize... at least somewhat.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

24

u/cappo40 Apr 21 '20

So in the end...it happens again

21

u/SoySauceSHA Apr 21 '20

No, you can hear them say districts that lindberg won were being won by roosevelt.

37

u/cappo40 Apr 21 '20

"conflicting reports"

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/Naggers123 Apr 21 '20

It's left purposefully ambiguous.

Voter suppression/ ballot burning vs. 'conflicting reports' that R's are losing previously safe districts.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

This show was too fucking good.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Moatt Apr 21 '20

Eyyyy paisan

20

u/JoeyMcSqueeb Apr 21 '20

“Pull da trig”

8

u/Moatt Apr 21 '20

Ahh pulling trig. Reminds me of College

43

u/Thatoneguy241 Apr 21 '20

Bruh wtf was with that fight between Alvin and Herman. Completely out of the blue.

31

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

I saw it as Alvin getting annoyed at Herman's judgement on Alvin essentially marrying (I think) a well connected girl, doing what seemed like shady work which brought Alvin to say that he actually fought for his people, while Herman just complained.

25

u/Gatesleeper Apr 21 '20

It was understandable from both sides.

Imagine you're Herman who just went through all that shit in Kentucky and you see your nephew acting like some loud braggart gangster without a care in the world.

Then imagine that you're Alvin who is trying to desperately hide and forget about his role in a treasonous (and successful) plot to kill or kidnap the President, so you're play acting the carefree citizen. Herman says his shit to you, and you can't tell him "well actually I helped take Lindbergh down so stfu". That would be excruciatingly frustrating.

→ More replies (6)

48

u/SpoofedFinger Apr 21 '20

Herman tied the shadiness to some kind of notion of apathy for Jews on Alvin's part. Herman kind of strikes me as the type that can't just have a decent conversation. Throughout the show, he takes principled stands, but those are just convenient vehicles for him to find interpersonal conflict. The dude would probably get into shouting matches about baseball, the weather, or whatever before the events of the show. The time period of the show is just one of the times where the broken clock happened to be at the right time.

→ More replies (57)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/yungamerica6997 Apr 21 '20 edited Apr 24 '20

Alvin was 100% right, and Hermann looked lame as hell for picking a fight with a cripple. To make the Lindbergh/Trump comparison as has been made, think of how many times people have said "Trump is horrible, he's unfit to be president, yada yada," w/o actually doing anything, which is what Hermann was basically doing throughout the story. Yet until he drove to Kentucky, he didn't do a single thing that actually made a real difference, and Alvin did(even ignoring the shooting down the plane plot line) Alvin lost a leg fighting for his freedom, and now has every right to enjoy his freedom. Hermann is just being whiny, as he was before. And reasonably so, but Alvin took real action against the Nazis, and is the one that actually made an impact

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

I wonder if they planned for this to air on Yom Hashoah or if that was just a really poignant coincidence.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/aw3man Apr 21 '20

Herman and Alvin are on the same side of the fight. Both of them had differing views on how to make it safe for themselves and both thought their way was right. It shows that all the infighting one sees on one side of the political aisle, the other side just has to wait to pick up the pieces.

13

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

I agree. For me, Herman was a father and a husband first. Alvin though, didn't have anyone to take care of.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/trimonkeys Apr 21 '20

The scenes with the Klan when they were driving back where incredibly harrowing.

38

u/coco-mama Apr 21 '20

Bess is Boss. Her strength throughout everything was amazing.

25

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

That scene where she comforts Seldon while gunshots are going off in the background is just incredible.

15

u/coco-mama Apr 21 '20

Oh my gosh her composure! Her delivery of “I will always love you, but I will never forgive you” cut deep

37

u/crispytoast9 Apr 21 '20

I don’t know if anybody else caught this, but after Lindbergh’s 20 second speech, the mayor of Louisville thanked “fine people on both sides” of the incident for coming together. Now where else have I heard that??

3

u/CUROplaya1337 May 11 '20

Whoa, that is awesome catch by you. Thanks.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/aw3man Apr 21 '20

For anyone confused or wanting more clarification, I highly recommend the accompanying podcast. David Simon goes into great detail about many of the questions posed here.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

I liked the ambiguity in the show vs the books original ending (fdr wins, Pearl Harbor happens and history goes back to normal)

The Alvin storyline felt so odd. They changed and added things but kept the fight with Herman, but moved it to the end of the episode. I am curious to hear why Simon made the choice

In the book, they fight as the tension in the outside world is ramping up, pre Lindbergh disappearing. The idea being that Herman, who demoted himself to being this produce stock man, picks a fight with Alvin, who got in trouble in NJ and became almost like Steinem with his car and nice suit. The show kinda did that, but made no sense now that the world was coming back to normal.

9

u/Tambien Apr 21 '20

I think the point was that all this had caused irreparable damage to both families and America and that it wasn’t just “going back to normal”

→ More replies (1)

17

u/nite_ Apr 21 '20

Poor Seldon. Just hearing him talk about his birthday and not having any friends was gut-wrenching.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

When Herman was on that dirt road to get Seldon, did anyone think he'd driven into a klan rally? I've never felt more anxious watching the show, which is saying something.

As as aside, Alvin's conclusion felt odd to me. Not much time passed during the bulk of the episode, yet he was acting completely different at the dinner.

5

u/markydsade Apr 23 '20

It was a mixture of relief he wasn’t caught, fear he still may be caught, anger over losing a leg while Nazis still control Europe, and pride for his actions both visible and unspoken.

14

u/facu_draper Apr 21 '20

I really liked the show. It seemed so relevant with everything that has been happening today and the last couple of years. The only thing , I think was unnecesary, was the fight between Herman and Alvin. I mean, they will never see eye-to-eye and that's ok . Especially with Alvin not being able to tell how we was a part in the taking down of Lindbergh. But this could have been represented with an argument !! Imo the fight was totally unnecesary.

11

u/trimonkeys Apr 21 '20

I agree about the fight, I think an argument makes sense. Since those two never saw eye to eye and they have a lot of pride. But the physical fight was too much it made Herman pretty unlikable there.

However the Bess Evelyn scenes were handled really well. Kazan was the highlight of the series.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/slumper Apr 21 '20

I wanted to see Bengelsdorf suffer more.

42

u/awilliam_75 Apr 21 '20

He suffered the greatest losses he could have. As a rabbi he was damned by losing his congregation, as a husband he was damned by losing his wife. Bengelsdorf aspired to become the savior of the Jewish people, and instead became a pariah. Consigned to history as a deranged idiot spouting conspiracies to others who see him as he was, a damn fool.

10

u/revolverzanbolt Apr 21 '20

I don’t really see him losing his wife. Him and Evelyn are both pariahs now, the only people they have is each other.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/Neurotic_Marauder Apr 21 '20

I think he lost enough.

He was shown to be a fool on the national stage and is now a pariah to his people. He will forever be associated with the horrors that came at the end of the Lindbergh administration and will probably be considered the new "Uncle Tom."

His wife basically married him because of his connections, of which he now has none.

His friends and colleagues will avoid him because of his toxic baggage and his conspiracy theories.

He lost everything.

13

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

I thought he was going to get killed and that Evelyn was going to kill herself.

13

u/owen_core Apr 21 '20

I loved the series, but it just felt too short!

13

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

So like... Ford tried to stage a coup right? That happened?

→ More replies (9)

13

u/grimpala Apr 21 '20

I really loved this show, and I wish it was longer, but I'd rather have too short than too long. It really was incredible and very frightening

24

u/leaffeon Apr 21 '20

The ending montage made me actually sick.

36

u/JoeyMcSqueeb Apr 21 '20

Yep. Right wing election fraud is a US tradition apparently.

→ More replies (26)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

I was so worried the Nazis were using Alvin and the brits going after Lindburg as a justification for the Ford Coup

12

u/toughguy375 Apr 21 '20

In episode one, FDR said Lindbergh will regret that he even learned to fly.

Good foreshadowing!

22

u/leflyingbison Apr 21 '20

Oh my God. The KKK really killed Sheldon's mom. 😳 When Herman saw those cars I suspected it was them because of the fire but I wasn't sure since I didn't see any white outfits. This episode had some poignant moments, the kind that restores your faith in humanity. From Sandy telling Seldon to look at his shoelaces to Bess on the phone while the gunshots were going off.

It's a good thing Sandy went with his dad though. Imagine is Philip found out how Sheldon's mom died. And Bess kinda knows that there's a connection between the two, but she isn't badgering her son for his sake.

One thing I didn't like was what they did with Alvin. It proved for a very good debate at showing how people deal with political conflict, I guess. But the sudden suit and business talk sounded weird, because the last time we saw him he was conspiring with crown agents.

17

u/Knopwood Apr 21 '20

Sandy telling Seldon to look at his shoelaces

Omg I lost it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ManWithNoName113 Apr 21 '20

I think he suppressed all that stuff with the crown agents into his subconscious. His overcompensating bravado was a way of dealing with what he had been through. That whole scene kind of felt out of place and I wasn't sure what the point was either.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/DCouri Apr 21 '20

Loved the finale. One thing I’m confused about is why the First Lady all of a sudden called for the violence to stop and for the president to step down?

6

u/zkela Apr 21 '20

In the book the FBI backs Wheeler and the Secret Service backs the First Lady, who gains the upper hand.

5

u/savethemouselemur Apr 22 '20

I think she definitely is a not-so-innocent bystander to her husband’s actions (or rather lack thereof), but I also think it kind of reflected how a woman (generally and hopefully) wouldn’t allow harm to innocent people continue. Unlike Lindbergh who proclaimed peace still existed while tensions turned into violence against the Jewish people. But her detainment definitely had a lot to do with it.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

That ending.... Could have two very different meanings. Either that democracy could still lose due to tampering and fear mongering, or that in the end people find their better judgement.... a little on the nose for 2020

8

u/markydsade Apr 21 '20

The series was full of allusions to 2020.

10

u/Knopwood Apr 21 '20

So, I didn't read the book. For those who said it looked like a twist in Bengelsdorf's plot was going to be cut: was it?

6

u/PersuasionNation Apr 21 '20

I'm assuming his revelation of what happened to Lindbergh? In the book it's stated that he publishes his account of the events in his memoir, which becomes a big bestseller, but which is officially denied by Anne Lindbergh's people. Evelyn also tells the whole story to Bess when she goes to their house after he the rabbi gets arrested. It's also a little more detailed in the book.

9

u/afictionalcharacter Apr 21 '20

I rather liked the cliffhanger... It’s interesting to imagine the different possibilities. Obviously if FDR won, the ultimate course of history wouldn’t change. But what ifLindbergh won again? Find myself wondering the same thing come this November. There are lots of parallels to our current time with the populist president etc. The final dialogue is reminiscent of 2016 Election Day.

10

u/Ecualung Apr 21 '20

Lindbergh is disappeared though.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

That last scene was perfect, great show all around

9

u/DrKennethNoisewater- Apr 21 '20

The calls with Seldon were hard as fuck to watch, great acting though. The Herman and Alvin fight seemed pretty unnecessary and forced.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

Everyone seems to have missed that on the Republican side it was Ford who ran, not Wheeler. The ambiguous ending with vote rigging taking place would make sense. He probably convinced the industry that he'll take care of their interests and asked them to give him the throne. https://imgur.com/a/MX1c6hA

7

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

It could have been the British/Canadians not leaving anything to chance by that same token. It’s possible both sides were engaging in voter suppression.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '20 edited Apr 23 '20

To me, the fight at Dinner at the end just shows that getting rid of the supervillain in the White House doesn't magically solve all your life's problems. It's not a lovely, happy ending for all just cuz they've gotten rid of Lindbergh.

The end with the election being rigged shows me that you can love and believe in America all you want, but it will keep inevitably betraying you sometimes.

Also.......honestly I would have immediately hung up on Seldon as soon as I heard the gunshots. Cool of her to keep it together for him. Great scene.

14

u/buy_gold_bye Apr 21 '20

Can we just talk about how amazing of an actress the person who plays Bess is? Through out the whole series she was amazing but that part with the gunshots while talking to Seldon on the phone really hit.

7

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

In the end what did happen to Lindbergh and his wife?

7

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 21 '20

Lindbergh is dead. His wife rode off into the sunset.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20 edited Apr 21 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (8)

6

u/alou87 Apr 21 '20

The episode was so good up to about the time Alvin and Herman start fighting. Those storyline completions were all incredibly rushed.

7

u/formlex7 Apr 21 '20

It worked a little better in the book IMO. In the book that scene happens before they go get seldon, when tensions are at a height. Also there's no secret alvin spy shit, after he loses his leg he just gives up and becomes a full time hoodlum.

Plus the dad was always a bit more unhinged in the book so him getting into a physical fight is less of a leap.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sorge74 Apr 21 '20

Agreed....you going to beat up your crippled war hero nephew?

6

u/buy_gold_bye Apr 21 '20

The ending at first made it seem as if everything was going to be ok but I think it will be far from that since we saw those ballots being burned. Also can we talk about how gut wrenching the whole trip up to Kentucky and back was, especially when Seldon was in the bathroom and Sandy was rushing him because there was a KKK member in uniform right next to them, terrifying. Even worse, when Sandy played that game with Seldon so he wouldn’t need to see his mothers car that never made it home. I think Sandy realized the error of his ways from that trip. Part of him supporting Lindbergh was probably just to spite his parents in that teenage rebel phase.

16

u/mattyice522 Apr 21 '20

I don't understand what Alvin is doing and who he is doing it for. Im about half way thru this episode. Anyone help me out? Thanks

34

u/Sent_by_Large_Marge Apr 21 '20

Tracking lindy’s plane using the equipment he was trained on during the war. Since the equipment could only surveil a small area, there were other trackers and one of them must have intercepted the plane and the British/Canadian agents made it disappear.

16

u/JoeyMcSqueeb Apr 21 '20

Yes, exactly. It’s why he operated for a short time then they had him stop and pack up quickly

16

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 21 '20

He was recruited by Allied intelligence to help bring down Lindbergh because they need America in the war but with Lindy at the helm it's not going to happen.

13

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 21 '20 edited Apr 21 '20

Alvin is working for a conspiracy of Canadian, British and Americans opposed to Lindberg. He is using an electronic location device. I'm not sure if he is using it confuse the navigation on Lindburg's plane or to target the plane so it can be shot down. Regardless Alvin's station failed and another station succeeded.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

He did something to hamper the logistics of Lindbergh’s flight. He knew how to operate the machine to do so, but was not given the reasoning behind it, before doing so.

Which is weird, because if the people that knew what it was going to do, why didn’t they do it themselves? I’m thinking it’s all a layer of protection between each other, so that no one really knows everything and everyone..

10

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

He did something to hamper the logistics of Lindbergh’s flight.

No, he was just tracking Lindbergh.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/SerPizza Apr 21 '20

It was my understanding that he was part of the effort to track Lindbergh's plane. When they told him to only worry about his track, that seemed to imply that there were other people attempting to track the plane in other areas. So when they told Alvin to shut it down, I took it that one of the other outposts had successfully tracked the plane.

9

u/Ecualung Apr 21 '20

This is what I took from it. They must have shot it down and also had pretty massive cleanup crews standing by for debris cleanup.

→ More replies (12)

5

u/aw3man Apr 21 '20

Alvin tried to help (presumably) the OSS bring down Lindbergh's plane

11

u/___Waves__ Apr 21 '20

Seemed more like MI6 than the OSS with the lines about getting men in from Canada.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

I had a hard time following this too. TBH I had difficulty understanding the last couple of episodes with Alvin.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/rumham22 Apr 21 '20

Man, I could have watched 5 seasons of this. Lots to process.

  1. Bess tells Herman that Seldon’s relocation city in Kentucky wasn’t a “coincidence.” That stuck out to me, is it possible the program was purposely relocating Jewish families to places with a strong KKK presence? Possible coordination of riots between Lindy supporters and the administration? May be looking too far into that.
  2. Fuck Evelyn and Bengelsdorf. Bess telling her sister off was super satisfying.
  3. I think it’s all but guaranteed that the end of this show is different from the book. The last scene was a montage of voting, ballot bots being burned, voter suppression (the one guy not being registered and dragged out), the computer looking object, and the final mention of “conflicting reports,” showing the fascists were able to throw the election.
  4. Alvin and Herman’s final scene kinda sucked, just a weird ending to a rushed storyline.

Anyway, glad I watched it.

8

u/zkela Apr 21 '20

Bess tells Herman that Seldon’s relocation city in Kentucky wasn’t a “coincidence.”

she was alluding to Seldon's relocation city being chosen to match Philip Levin's (though the Levins didn't comply with the relocation).

7

u/PersuasionNation Apr 21 '20
  1. It’s not a coincidence as in Bess figures out it was Philip who was responsible for sending them out there.

7

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 21 '20

Ha, Ha the "computer looking object" was a mechanical voting machine. No computers involved. The last time I used one was 2008.

4

u/nautilus2000 Apr 21 '20

For #3, it didn’t show that the fascists were able to throw the election. They specifically said on the radio that in a part of the country that went heavily for Lindbergh in the past election, there were now conflicting reports of who was ahead. This is good news for Roosevelt, though doesn’t definitely show that he won.

10

u/bhkuang Apr 21 '20

Two theories about the ending:

It's obvious David Simon meant to end on an ambiguous cliffhanger about the election result, but there's no way you're tampering with the vote in 1940s Newark without the New Deal-era NJ Democratic Party machine knowing of it. Realistically speaking, it's likelier that local Dem bosses were punching up the vote for their candidate than federal G-men waltzing into polling places and destroying ballots.

As for Lindbergh's fate: there's no way the British would want to take him alive and risk revealing their conspiracy. They must have intercepted and shot down his plane (or used experimental radar-guided anti-air weapons), brought it down into a body of water, then cleared the debris from the ground.

8

u/vadergeek Apr 21 '20

but there's no way you're tampering with the vote in 1940s Newark without the New Deal-era NJ Democratic Party machine knowing of it.

Knowing of it, sure. But if they've gone to the point where pro-Lindbergh cops are gunning down pro-Jewish mobsters to prove a point I'm not sure the local party can feasibly out-rig them.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/trimonkeys Apr 21 '20

I didn't really like the confrontation between Alvin and Herman. Felt like Alvin's actor was really overacting and it made Herman really unsympathetic to attack Alvin like that. I thought that scene was too much.

7

u/Burneraccount1857 Apr 21 '20

Herman was just the worst to me. The entire series he acted like a loudmouth idealist, refusing to adjust to the realities around him and act appropriately. He actually seemed to endanger the family during their trip. Then at the end of the series he picks a fight with Alvin who actually gave a pound of flesh for their people with no real outside influence compelling him to do so.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/ChuuAcolypse Apr 21 '20

Alvin is right tbh

5

u/YouJabroni44 Apr 21 '20

So who was behind the ballot burning i wonder? Wouldn't make any sense for FDR's guys to do it..

9

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

Any chance that the ambiguous ending is leaving this open to a season 2 despite this being billed as a limited series? Odd they wouldn’t wrap this thing up like the book...

16

u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 21 '20

on one of the podcast episodes, david simon talks about how he approached Roth himself and talked about changing the ending of the miniseries.

also, knowing david simon, i think he's going to keep it as is, no season 2.

7

u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 21 '20

There's the potential there if they really wanted to, but I doubt it.

3

u/FrontPussy Apr 21 '20

It was a good ending but I'd like to see more. They could easily keep it going

→ More replies (3)

8

u/caldo4 Apr 21 '20 edited Apr 21 '20

Kazan was amazing and the first 45 minutes were great

But Simon didn’t seem to try to address why there’s just random election rigging or why it’s happening or for whom? Besides just “lindbergh is bad”. Trump is bad too and if anything the election is rigged for him. They’re trying to make a comparison to today but I don’t think they quite nailed it at the end and if anything devalued parts of what came before

If anything, capital would be rigging it for the republican after the country was still doing fine under Lindbergh economically. Maybe that’s what he was going for but the deep state kills Lindbergh ten minutes before? it seemed out of step with the rest of the show

Edit: why are the rabbi and Evelyn become QAnon people at the end? They knew the wife and knew that wasn’t true presumably since it wasn’t as Lindbergh wasn’t kidnapped by nazis?

17

u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20

But Simon didn’t seem to try to address why there’s just random election rigging or why it’s happening or for whom?

They were burning votes that were cast in areas where people were likely to vote for FDR.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ManitouWakinyan Apr 21 '20

But Simon didn’t seem to try to address why there’s just random election rigging or why it’s happening or for whom?

Did you need this spelled out? Because Wheeler and his team are fascists. Of course they're going to try and rig the election. Of course they're going to try and disenfranchise minority voters.

the deep state kills Lindbergh ten minutes before? it seemed out of step with the rest of the show

It's not a parallel for the deep state. It's just other fascists who think Lindbergh is balking at what needs to get done.

Edit: why are the rabbi and Evelyn become QAnon people at the end? They knew the wife and knew that wasn’t true presumably since it wasn’t as Lindbergh wasn’t kidnapped by nazis?

I don't think it's clear that they did actually know what the truth about Lindbergh and his baby was. But the story they believe allows them to rationalize their position on Lindbergh - yes, terrible things happened, Lindbergh seems complicit, but if he was being blackmailed by the Nazis, he can still be the hero they thought he was and also complicit in the anti-Jewish violence they feared.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

So did Roosevelt win????

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20

In one scene, they showed a Jewish owned shoe-store smashed up, and a pile of shoes on the ground, which brought to me images of concentration camps, and the piles of shoes of the victims.

16

u/theAlexrh Apr 21 '20

Saw the news after watching the finale: Trump announces he will temporarily suspend immigration... Surreal

6

u/leaffeon Apr 21 '20

ARE YOU KIDDING ME. Sheeshus.

→ More replies (58)

6

u/bluntbutnottoo Apr 21 '20

I am so glad it ended on a message of hope. They took us to the edge of the abyss and yet somehow brought us back. They left us tottering near the edge, but those last words were so fucking optimistic.

Wow! Just freaking wow!.

3

u/fede01_8 Apr 22 '20

Hope? They rigged the elections!

→ More replies (7)

6

u/par5ul1 Apr 21 '20

Tommy was a great character but the whole family's intro was very cringy with the awful Italian.

6

u/Chrisixx Apr 21 '20

Really good mini series. Enjoyed it a lot.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/cappo40 Apr 21 '20

This gonna be good!

3

u/backhander16 Apr 21 '20

What a great scene

4

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

You mean episode?

3

u/Damon242 Apr 21 '20

Greatly enjoyed the episode but was heartbroken to learn that was the finale

I think for all the build up (and the somewhat jarring time jump), the events of this episode really ought to have been stretched over two episodes.

3

u/kvetchinghobbit Apr 21 '20

What exactly is it that Bess couldn't forgive Evelyn? Is it because of what happened to seldon? Is it due to her blind following of Lindberg?

8

u/metric-puppy Apr 21 '20

She picked them to go to Kentucky for one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Grsz11 Apr 22 '20 edited Apr 22 '20

I was convinced Alvin was being set up and they were all Mr. Hoover's men.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/greatalica012 Apr 22 '20

The fight between Alvin and Herman reminded me of Parasite where the two families fight each other as rivals even though they have common problems and a common enemy with the real parasites sitting at the top...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20

Seldon I love you brother. I feel your pain, seriously :(

I think Plot Against America's true MVP is Bess. Also Evelyn is such a bitch charachter.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

So we can assume that Alvin helped crash Lindbergh somewhere, or are the conspiracies true?

5

u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20

Seldon reminds me of Kyle's cousin Kyle on South Park.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

What about the conspiracies re Lindbergh which Evelyn and Bengglesdorf were trying to tell other people? I didn’t get that part.

12

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 21 '20

All bullshit. Bengesdorf is trying to justify his actions. Although Lindbergh's son really was kidnaped as baby and was killed. Was one of many "Crimes of the Century".

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Damon242 Apr 21 '20

Hearing claims by the characters that the Jewish helped build the pyramids in Egypt pains me so - it’s such an insult to the ancient Egyptians who were in fact responsible for their own constructions, and who were subsequently slandered as having owned and used Jewish slaves to construct their monoliths before the great exodus - all supplied by religious text with no archaeological evidence in support of it.

This isn’t an expression of prejudice at all, it’s simply something that is rarely acknowledged in media (the trailers for ‘Exodus’ a few years back labelling it as one of the greatest events in history...that didn’t actually happen). Just something worth sharing at any opportunity.

Overall a fantastic miniseries though, greatly enjoyed it.

2

u/ayberms Apr 21 '20

So were the Lindberghs actually “good”? If their kid was kidnapped and they were being blackmailed the entire presidency until he finally went to Germany/faked his disappearance in order to force another election (aka not have his anti-Semitic AF VP run the show), does that make him.... sort of good?

20

u/TheSingulatarian Apr 21 '20

Benglesdorf in nuts and invented a crazy conspiracy theory to jusify his actions. The story is bullshit.

2

u/ThePantsThief Apr 21 '20

Questions:

  • What really happened with the president? Was he actually "kidnapped" and taken to Germany? And was that bit about his kid being raised in Germany true too?
  • Who was the acting president in the absence of Lindy? Why did Mrs. Lindy want him out?
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20

Am I the only one who thought the show should have moved a bit faster so most of the episodes were like the finale? Or stayed the same, but with one or two more episodes?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/noah_drive May 22 '20

Anyone else noticed the at the end the radio started to glow bright “orange”?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '20

Zoe Kazan deserves so many prizes for her work on this, she had me literally at the edge of my seat on every of her scenes