r/ThePlotAgainstAmerica • u/NicholasCajun • Apr 21 '20
Discussion The Plot Against America - 1x06 "Part 6" - Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 6: Part 6
Aired: April 20, 2020
Synopsis: As riots and conspiracies spread across the country in the lead up to election day, Herman takes measures to keep his family safe. Bess does all she can at a great distance to help a small child caught in a maelstrom of anti-Semitism in Kentucky.
Directed by: Thomas Schlamme
Written by: David Simon
170
Upvotes
188
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
Holy shit. Can we just take a minute to realize how heartbreaking Seldon's phone calls were?
150
u/Hekrjejdjs Apr 21 '20
Tommy the new neighbor is so cool
112
u/SerPizza Apr 21 '20
Bess keeping it together for Seldon over the phone while hearing gunshots in her own neighborhood was fantastic television. She showed so much strength in the entire series, but this episode we truly saw that she was made of. Her confrontation with Evelyn ("I will always love you... But I will never forgive you") was acted so effectively. I was fighting back tears from how that broken relationship was portrayed as it finally ended for good.
What a finale.
86
u/Doctor-Strangedick Apr 21 '20
Interesting. I know it was a miniseries, but I feel like a few things should’ve been fleshed out more. Alvin’s story especially seemed rushed, and I think an update on how the war was going would’ve been nice.
Overall though, I enjoyed the series.
70
u/Tinkmama22 Apr 21 '20
“Sis, it’s me, Evelyn”
“New phone, who dis?”
I love, love, love Bess. Especially how she handled things with her sister. Too often I see forgiveness touted as being necessary to live your life to the fullest, and that to forgive makes a person morally just... I’m so glad they tackled the concept of loving someone, but realizing that they fucked up past the point of return and no one should have to put up with that if they don’t want to.
114
u/JamesHRoss Apr 21 '20
Zoe Kazan has been thoroughly amazing on this show and she'll be shamefully robbed of an Emmy nom come morning of nominations. What a brilliant little show. For me it's easily the biggest surprise of the year
49
u/TiberiusCornelius Apr 21 '20
I always hated the ending of the book, so I'm glad they ended it where they did instead of going down the original magic reset button route.
48
u/wavvvygravvvy Apr 21 '20
i want to give a shoutout to Sandy, he was easy to dislike the whole time but in the end he was just an adolescent that didn't fully understand the gravity of what was going on around him and I think we can all relate to that.
The moment riots and violence broke out against Jews he started to have doubts about his personal beliefs and he started seeing the world for what it was, hearing his formal hero speak at that airfield in Kentucky solidified the fact that what his father was saying was true, Lindbergh didn't care about him or his people.
Watching him tear up his sketches of Lindy was a powerful moment, we were watching a once naive boy become a young man with the critical thinking to form his own conclusions
91
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
Why don’t you call Von Ribbentrop.. DAMN
43
u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20
I loved the Italian neighbors. Wish we saw them more. If I weren't a Jew, I'd want to be Italian. I love the culture and just how they interact with each other.
29
u/DJ_BB Apr 21 '20
Loved the episode but what’s going on with the ballot burning at the end? And just want to make sure Lindbergh’s kid sing kidnapped is a false conspiracy right?
27
u/TwinkiesForAmerica Apr 21 '20
Omg a cliffhanger?!?! Like that??!!? Nooooo!!!!
24
u/rugbypike11 Apr 21 '20
I’ve been having weird dreams about dystopia. This episode won’t help.
24
u/cappo40 Apr 21 '20
So in the end...it happens again
23
u/devnulld2 Apr 21 '20
This show was too fucking good.
22
u/Moatt Apr 21 '20
Eyyyy paisan
43
u/Thatoneguy241 Apr 21 '20
Bruh wtf was with that fight between Alvin and Herman. Completely out of the blue.
19
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
I wonder if they planned for this to air on Yom Hashoah or if that was just a really poignant coincidence.
19
u/aw3man Apr 21 '20
Herman and Alvin are on the same side of the fight. Both of them had differing views on how to make it safe for themselves and both thought their way was right. It shows that all the infighting one sees on one side of the political aisle, the other side just has to wait to pick up the pieces.
19
u/trimonkeys Apr 21 '20
The scenes with the Klan when they were driving back where incredibly harrowing.
38
u/coco-mama Apr 21 '20
Bess is Boss. Her strength throughout everything was amazing.
37
u/crispytoast9 Apr 21 '20
I don’t know if anybody else caught this, but after Lindbergh’s 20 second speech, the mayor of Louisville thanked “fine people on both sides” of the incident for coming together. Now where else have I heard that??
17
u/aw3man Apr 21 '20
For anyone confused or wanting more clarification, I highly recommend the accompanying podcast. David Simon goes into great detail about many of the questions posed here.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
I liked the ambiguity in the show vs the books original ending (fdr wins, Pearl Harbor happens and history goes back to normal)
The Alvin storyline felt so odd. They changed and added things but kept the fight with Herman, but moved it to the end of the episode. I am curious to hear why Simon made the choice
In the book, they fight as the tension in the outside world is ramping up, pre Lindbergh disappearing. The idea being that Herman, who demoted himself to being this produce stock man, picks a fight with Alvin, who got in trouble in NJ and became almost like Steinem with his car and nice suit. The show kinda did that, but made no sense now that the world was coming back to normal.
17
u/nite_ Apr 21 '20
Poor Seldon. Just hearing him talk about his birthday and not having any friends was gut-wrenching.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
When Herman was on that dirt road to get Seldon, did anyone think he'd driven into a klan rally? I've never felt more anxious watching the show, which is saying something.
As as aside, Alvin's conclusion felt odd to me. Not much time passed during the bulk of the episode, yet he was acting completely different at the dinner.
14
u/facu_draper Apr 21 '20
I really liked the show. It seemed so relevant with everything that has been happening today and the last couple of years. The only thing , I think was unnecesary, was the fight between Herman and Alvin. I mean, they will never see eye-to-eye and that's ok . Especially with Alvin not being able to tell how we was a part in the taking down of Lindbergh. But this could have been represented with an argument !! Imo the fight was totally unnecesary.
27
u/slumper Apr 21 '20
I wanted to see Bengelsdorf suffer more.
13
u/owen_core Apr 21 '20
I loved the series, but it just felt too short!
13
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
So like... Ford tried to stage a coup right? That happened?
13
u/grimpala Apr 21 '20
I really loved this show, and I wish it was longer, but I'd rather have too short than too long. It really was incredible and very frightening
24
u/leaffeon Apr 21 '20
The ending montage made me actually sick.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
I was so worried the Nazis were using Alvin and the brits going after Lindburg as a justification for the Ford Coup
12
u/toughguy375 Apr 21 '20
In episode one, FDR said Lindbergh will regret that he even learned to fly.
Good foreshadowing!
22
u/leflyingbison Apr 21 '20
Oh my God. The KKK really killed Sheldon's mom. 😳 When Herman saw those cars I suspected it was them because of the fire but I wasn't sure since I didn't see any white outfits. This episode had some poignant moments, the kind that restores your faith in humanity. From Sandy telling Seldon to look at his shoelaces to Bess on the phone while the gunshots were going off.
It's a good thing Sandy went with his dad though. Imagine is Philip found out how Sheldon's mom died. And Bess kinda knows that there's a connection between the two, but she isn't badgering her son for his sake.
One thing I didn't like was what they did with Alvin. It proved for a very good debate at showing how people deal with political conflict, I guess. But the sudden suit and business talk sounded weird, because the last time we saw him he was conspiring with crown agents.
11
u/DCouri Apr 21 '20
Loved the finale. One thing I’m confused about is why the First Lady all of a sudden called for the violence to stop and for the president to step down?
20
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
That ending.... Could have two very different meanings. Either that democracy could still lose due to tampering and fear mongering, or that in the end people find their better judgement.... a little on the nose for 2020
10
u/Knopwood Apr 21 '20
So, I didn't read the book. For those who said it looked like a twist in Bengelsdorf's plot was going to be cut: was it?
9
u/afictionalcharacter Apr 21 '20
I rather liked the cliffhanger... It’s interesting to imagine the different possibilities. Obviously if FDR won, the ultimate course of history wouldn’t change. But what ifLindbergh won again? Find myself wondering the same thing come this November. There are lots of parallels to our current time with the populist president etc. The final dialogue is reminiscent of 2016 Election Day.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
That last scene was perfect, great show all around
9
u/DrKennethNoisewater- Apr 21 '20
The calls with Seldon were hard as fuck to watch, great acting though. The Herman and Alvin fight seemed pretty unnecessary and forced.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
Everyone seems to have missed that on the Republican side it was Ford who ran, not Wheeler. The ambiguous ending with vote rigging taking place would make sense. He probably convinced the industry that he'll take care of their interests and asked them to give him the throne. https://imgur.com/a/MX1c6hA
8
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '20 edited Apr 23 '20
To me, the fight at Dinner at the end just shows that getting rid of the supervillain in the White House doesn't magically solve all your life's problems. It's not a lovely, happy ending for all just cuz they've gotten rid of Lindbergh.
The end with the election being rigged shows me that you can love and believe in America all you want, but it will keep inevitably betraying you sometimes.
Also.......honestly I would have immediately hung up on Seldon as soon as I heard the gunshots. Cool of her to keep it together for him. Great scene.
14
u/buy_gold_bye Apr 21 '20
Can we just talk about how amazing of an actress the person who plays Bess is? Through out the whole series she was amazing but that part with the gunshots while talking to Seldon on the phone really hit.
7
u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20
In the end what did happen to Lindbergh and his wife?
6
u/alou87 Apr 21 '20
The episode was so good up to about the time Alvin and Herman start fighting. Those storyline completions were all incredibly rushed.
6
u/buy_gold_bye Apr 21 '20
The ending at first made it seem as if everything was going to be ok but I think it will be far from that since we saw those ballots being burned. Also can we talk about how gut wrenching the whole trip up to Kentucky and back was, especially when Seldon was in the bathroom and Sandy was rushing him because there was a KKK member in uniform right next to them, terrifying. Even worse, when Sandy played that game with Seldon so he wouldn’t need to see his mothers car that never made it home. I think Sandy realized the error of his ways from that trip. Part of him supporting Lindbergh was probably just to spite his parents in that teenage rebel phase.
16
u/mattyice522 Apr 21 '20
I don't understand what Alvin is doing and who he is doing it for. Im about half way thru this episode. Anyone help me out? Thanks
11
u/rumham22 Apr 21 '20
Man, I could have watched 5 seasons of this. Lots to process.
Anyway, glad I watched it.
10
u/bhkuang Apr 21 '20
Two theories about the ending:
It's obvious David Simon meant to end on an ambiguous cliffhanger about the election result, but there's no way you're tampering with the vote in 1940s Newark without the New Deal-era NJ Democratic Party machine knowing of it. Realistically speaking, it's likelier that local Dem bosses were punching up the vote for their candidate than federal G-men waltzing into polling places and destroying ballots.
As for Lindbergh's fate: there's no way the British would want to take him alive and risk revealing their conspiracy. They must have intercepted and shot down his plane (or used experimental radar-guided anti-air weapons), brought it down into a body of water, then cleared the debris from the ground.
10
u/trimonkeys Apr 21 '20
I didn't really like the confrontation between Alvin and Herman. Felt like Alvin's actor was really overacting and it made Herman really unsympathetic to attack Alvin like that. I thought that scene was too much.
10
u/ChuuAcolypse Apr 21 '20
Alvin is right tbh
5
u/YouJabroni44 Apr 21 '20
So who was behind the ballot burning i wonder? Wouldn't make any sense for FDR's guys to do it..
9
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
Any chance that the ambiguous ending is leaving this open to a season 2 despite this being billed as a limited series? Odd they wouldn’t wrap this thing up like the book...
8
u/caldo4 Apr 21 '20 edited Apr 21 '20
Kazan was amazing and the first 45 minutes were great
But Simon didn’t seem to try to address why there’s just random election rigging or why it’s happening or for whom? Besides just “lindbergh is bad”. Trump is bad too and if anything the election is rigged for him. They’re trying to make a comparison to today but I don’t think they quite nailed it at the end and if anything devalued parts of what came before
If anything, capital would be rigging it for the republican after the country was still doing fine under Lindbergh economically. Maybe that’s what he was going for but the deep state kills Lindbergh ten minutes before? it seemed out of step with the rest of the show
Edit: why are the rabbi and Evelyn become QAnon people at the end? They knew the wife and knew that wasn’t true presumably since it wasn’t as Lindbergh wasn’t kidnapped by nazis?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
So did Roosevelt win????
4
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
In one scene, they showed a Jewish owned shoe-store smashed up, and a pile of shoes on the ground, which brought to me images of concentration camps, and the piles of shoes of the victims.
16
u/theAlexrh Apr 21 '20
Saw the news after watching the finale: Trump announces he will temporarily suspend immigration... Surreal
6
u/bluntbutnottoo Apr 21 '20
I am so glad it ended on a message of hope. They took us to the edge of the abyss and yet somehow brought us back. They left us tottering near the edge, but those last words were so fucking optimistic.
Wow! Just freaking wow!.
6
u/par5ul1 Apr 21 '20
Tommy was a great character but the whole family's intro was very cringy with the awful Italian.
6
u/Chrisixx Apr 21 '20
Really good mini series. Enjoyed it a lot.
3
u/cappo40 Apr 21 '20
This gonna be good!
3
u/backhander16 Apr 21 '20
What a great scene
3
u/Damon242 Apr 21 '20
Greatly enjoyed the episode but was heartbroken to learn that was the finale
I think for all the build up (and the somewhat jarring time jump), the events of this episode really ought to have been stretched over two episodes.
3
u/kvetchinghobbit Apr 21 '20
What exactly is it that Bess couldn't forgive Evelyn? Is it because of what happened to seldon? Is it due to her blind following of Lindberg?
3
u/Grsz11 Apr 22 '20 edited Apr 22 '20
I was convinced Alvin was being set up and they were all Mr. Hoover's men.
3
u/greatalica012 Apr 22 '20
The fight between Alvin and Herman reminded me of Parasite where the two families fight each other as rivals even though they have common problems and a common enemy with the real parasites sitting at the top...
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
Seldon I love you brother. I feel your pain, seriously :(
I think Plot Against America's true MVP is Bess. Also Evelyn is such a bitch charachter.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20
So we can assume that Alvin helped crash Lindbergh somewhere, or are the conspiracies true?
5
u/PregnantMexicanTeens Apr 21 '20
Seldon reminds me of Kyle's cousin Kyle on South Park.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
What about the conspiracies re Lindbergh which Evelyn and Bengglesdorf were trying to tell other people? I didn’t get that part.
4
u/Damon242 Apr 21 '20
Hearing claims by the characters that the Jewish helped build the pyramids in Egypt pains me so - it’s such an insult to the ancient Egyptians who were in fact responsible for their own constructions, and who were subsequently slandered as having owned and used Jewish slaves to construct their monoliths before the great exodus - all supplied by religious text with no archaeological evidence in support of it.
This isn’t an expression of prejudice at all, it’s simply something that is rarely acknowledged in media (the trailers for ‘Exodus’ a few years back labelling it as one of the greatest events in history...that didn’t actually happen). Just something worth sharing at any opportunity.
Overall a fantastic miniseries though, greatly enjoyed it.
2
u/ayberms Apr 21 '20
So were the Lindberghs actually “good”? If their kid was kidnapped and they were being blackmailed the entire presidency until he finally went to Germany/faked his disappearance in order to force another election (aka not have his anti-Semitic AF VP run the show), does that make him.... sort of good?
2
u/ThePantsThief Apr 21 '20
Questions:
2
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '20
Am I the only one who thought the show should have moved a bit faster so most of the episodes were like the finale? Or stayed the same, but with one or two more episodes?
2
u/noah_drive May 22 '20
Anyone else noticed the at the end the radio started to glow bright “orange”?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '20
Zoe Kazan deserves so many prizes for her work on this, she had me literally at the edge of my seat on every of her scenes