r/formula1 • Randy Singh ✅ • May 21 '20

AMA I'm an F1 Engineer/Strategist, Ask Me Anything...

My name is Randy Singh and I’m “Head of Strategy and Sporting” at McLaren Racing. I have been working in F1 since 2013 and am coming up to my 5th anniversary with McLaren – having taken part in over 125 Grand Prix, in over 25 different nations.

My role involves being responsible for leading and developing the “Strategy” team, where we aim not only to determine and execute the best race strategy during a given weekend, but also wider strategic decisions, such as picking tyres for a Grand Prix, months in advance, powerunit usage, etc. as well as leading our efforts when it comes to “Sporting” matters, these are quite varied but can range from attending meetings with the FIA and F1, evaluating and analysing new ideas, such as potential changes to the race format and knowing the Sporting Regulations inside out.

Having wanted to work in F1 desperately as a student, I know how hard it can be to get your foot through the door – I also am fortunate enough to work with some of our most talented young engineers (and physicists and computer scientists and…) being responsible for our talent schemes in Engineering, which cover our 2 year rotating Engineering Graduate Scheme, 1 year Undergraduate Placements (rotating and not) and our Summer Internships.

Please ask me anything, from Strategy, to Sporting matters, from being an engineer and travelling trackside, to working in Mission Control, to the best way to prepare yourself to target a career in F1, or anything else of interest.

I will try and answer as many questions as I can (please be aware there are some things I may not be able to answer) starting from tomorrow, Friday 22nd May and for however long it takes to get through the majority.

Update 1: Technically its Friday 22nd May - so I'll start answering questions, I'll do my best to get around to all of them when I can - don't worry if you don't get your question in today, I'll be doing my best to answer everything over the coming days.

Update 2: Thanks for all the amazing questions - I'll come back and try and answer some more tomorrow and on Sunday also. Apologies if I've not gotten to yours yet - I'm trying to answer as wide a breadth of questions as I can.

Update 3: I will try and answer another bunch of questions today and then am afraid I will call it a day (Wednesday 27th May)! Thanks.

Final Update (I think): And now my watch has ended. Thanks all for the questions, they've been tough and interesting and I've really enjoyed answering them (which is why it's past midnight and I'm still doing a few more). I'm really sorry I could not answer every one, but I need to get back to trying to get to those "perfect" strategies that we have talked about - I've done my best to mix up the answers to try and hit the different types of question. If I've not answered you I may have answered a very similar question in the thread. Any feedback on the AMA is also appreciated. I'll try and pop back every now and then to answer any questions.

If you ever see me at an airport, at the track, at the calculator store, then please do say hello - provided I'm not too busy it's always my pleasure to have a chat about F1 and McLaren.

3.7k Upvotes

959 comments sorted by

441

u/VirtualFrenchFry I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 21 '20

What was your career path like from college to present? What was your main disipline? How does one begin to make a career in F1?

881

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

A long and boring answer (I apologise in advance):

I studied Maths and Engineering, Economics & Management at the University of Oxford and was lucky that I could persuade my professors to let me do a final year project with a F1 team. Getting a project was slightly harder and I was a bit sneaky by sending letters marked "Confidential" and "Private" to the team principals - long story short, Williams offered me the chance to write their strategy software from scratch which is what I had pitched.

I worked at Williams for 6 months and loved it, had a really great boss who knew racing inside out and that I learnt a lot from. I was offered a job, but I wanted to go back to university to finish my degree and when I had there wasn't the job that I wanted (strategy).

I ended up working for a small engineering and management consultancy which taught me so much about being self-sufficient and problem-solving before moving into finance of various kinds and beginning to qualify as an actuary - I learnt a lot about modelling and quantitative analysis. I moved to Australia and had literally just gotten my citizenship when I received a call from Williams asking me if I wanted the strategy job.

It was an offer I couldn't refuse, so I left Australia pretty quickly, went back to sign my contract and the person who had offered me the job had left Williams by the time I arrived in the UK. Long story short they still hired me eventually and I went on to be a Trackside Strategist a couple of weeks later with no experience whatsoever - thrown in at the deep end. I ended up running the Strategy team at Williams before moving to Force India (at the time) a couple of years after joining Williams to try and take on a larger role.

Unfortunately, Force India were going through some tough times and I (somewhat naively at the time due to how bad things seemed like they would get) decided to try and move and ended up at McLaren as Fernando's strategist - in hindsight, this was a great move for me personally.

From there I was promoted to be Head of Strategy and then to Head of Strategy and Sporting.

In terms of how to start a career in F1 - I won't lie - it's difficult. Perseverance is key, many of us thought at the time we were applying/being turned down that we would never make it in - but you have to keep trying. Internships and placements are a great way to start to get your foot in the door (but are themselves not easy to obtain), as are the various things you can do to gain useful experience or skills (which I have listed in other answers here).

As a quick disclaimer, there are a lot of questions about route into F1, career paths, useful skills and experiences. I intend to answer all of these as I understand how important these are - I'm taking my time to make sure I give the best advice I can and apologies if some of this is repeated across different responses.

→ More replies (8)

521

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

Private/Confidential

___________________________________________________________________________________________________

22/05/2020

Dear Mr. Singh,

I would like to apply for a 6-month internship, working as your personal assistant. I have 10 years experience in law & accounting, and five years of film and TV production. I'm also a great cook and make the best pizzas and homemade pasta. I believe after 6 months training under your mentoring and tutelage, I can then apply to replace Mr. Cyril Bitesabull at Renault, and be successful on application thanks to the valuable experience under your wing.

If the Renault application fails however, you and I will join forces, and stage a coup d'état at the McLaren Technology Group. When we have succeeded, we will then rehire Mika Hakkinen and David Coulthard once again, and power our way to another 3 championships. I believe both drivers would fit in the car. I had considered our Nige, but alas, his FIA responsibilities would be a conflict of interest. I have full faith we would be successful and get Mika another 2 championships, while David holds the rest of the field up behind him.

It is time for Mika's sabbatical to end.

I await hearing from you in early course.

Signed:

PapaKeth

___________________________________________________________________________________________________

397

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Haha this is brilliant (and a good taste of my own medicine). We'll of course consider your application.

I'm afraid you may have some competition on the pizza front - as one of our strategists has a talent in this area!

→ More replies (4)

215

u/annasiaa May 22 '20

Hey Randy

So I’m currently studying Aerospace Engineering and my aspiration is be a f1 trackside Engineer. I was wondering if there was anything I could do to make myself stand out or supplement my application when applying for grad jobs next year? Also would it be harder for me as a female? Are there many females in the Engineer teams?

278

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20 edited May 22 '20

Excellent - I'd like to answer the point about gender first! There are fewer females on the engineering side of F1 than men and unfortunately I think this reflects the recent situation with the number of females in STEM and particularly engineering subjects at university.

This is changing and there are some very talented female engineers in F1 and at McLaren and especially in the younger cohorts, which to me suggests that things are moving in the right direction. I can't say how hard it may be because you're a female - all I can say is that your gender should not affect the opportunities available - it may be harder in the sense that there may not be as many female teammates as male teammates for you.

In terms of what kind of things you can do to improve your chances of getting into F1 - here are a few ideas, I have to say none of these are necessary, they are examples of the kinds of things that may help - but we will take people with/without these (many of these things I have not done myself):

  1. Internships and placements do exist in F1 and lower formulae and can be very useful to get your foot through the door.
  2. Professional motorsport experience, albeit difficult to come by, can be really useful.
  3. Involvement with Formula Student, there are many areas to get involved in these teams.
  4. Taking something that you enjoy to a good/high level, it doesn't matter what it is, whether its playing sport, baking, research, etc.
  5. Working in and/or leading a team.
  6. An understanding of F1 and motorsport in general.
  7. Demonstration your smartness and ingenuity, proactive nature and any other factors you think would hold you in good stead for a job in F1.

As a quick disclaimer, there are a lot of questions about route into F1, career paths, useful skills and experiences. I intend to answer all of these as I understand how important these are - I'm taking my time to make sure I give the best advice I can and apologies if some of this is repeated across different responses.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

187

u/JevanSnead May 22 '20

In your experience, would adding flame decals to my truck make it go faster?

222

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Where are you going to place them? What colour are the flames?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

363

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

I'm a "software engineer" (supposedly... don't really deserve such a title imo) so I'm curious about the software you guys use for strategy.

Tyre strategy for example - I assume you have models where you plug in the pace of a given compound at a given track temperature and fuel load etc, plus how that pace degrades over time etc. And then presumably you run that model umpteen times for all the combinations of 1 stop / 2 stop / starting with prime / starting with option / hot day / mild day etc to decide the likely best strategy.

So my questions are:

  1. anything I've said so far that's totally wrong?
  2. is this bespoke software written by internal coders for each team or do you use some off-the-shelf / open-source platform (matlab, R etc) or both?
  3. what kind of stack/languages are you using?
  4. what other things besides tyre strategy do you have this kind of software for? is it one big sophisticated piece of software that can model every "what if" (tyres, weather, safety cars etc) in one go, or lots of smaller bits of software for different aspects?
  5. to what extent is this software used real-time during races? like are you constantly updating these type of models with actual lap-time / tyre temps etc during a race, to get continually more accurate predictions of how your or your competitors stints will go? or maybe the process of turning raw data into useful decisions is too slow for that to be realistic under the hectic conditions, so instead you're more about absorbing the learnings in between races to improve your 'instincts'?

399

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Sneaking 5 questions in - efficient.

  1. Nothing you've put is totally wrong at all. There are many approaches to modelling and optimising strategy and the one you suggest isn't at all crazy. The number of permutations ends up being quite high, very quickly though...
  2. We use bespoke software written in-house, although we may use platforms like MATLAB to write some of the code.
  3. It varies depending on use case, I personally will range from C++ to Javascript/Node to C# and maybe some Python.
  4. Because things interact and interplay so heavily in the strategy space you'll tend to want to model everything together in one tool.
  5. The software can and is used real-time during races. I plan to answer some of the other questions relating to this as well, so may provide some more detail in one of those if you're interested, but there is still a large element of human expertise as well as the modelling and although I can't talk too much about the balance between the two areas as it would give too much away - both are important.
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (5)

342

u/Ryukai May 22 '20

Hi Randy.

Who is your favourite member of the IT team?

Sincerely,

Definitely not a member of the IT team.

271

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Trick question! I don't have a favourite member of the IT team. 😁

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

389

u/imShyness Carlos Sainz May 21 '20

How excited is the team for Daniel to come next year?

912

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 21 '20

I have to say first of all, that it is sad to see Carlos go - working with him has been an absolute pleasure and he has brought with him a technical intelligence that rivals his driving skill. I am confident he will go on to win many races, which he deserves and the shame is he'll be wearing the wrong colour overalls when he does so.

The team, and I, are also very much looking forwards to welcoming Daniel. You can only have enormous respect for someone who has already won 7 races, those 3 wins in 2014, I think, showed his ability to make the most of any tiny chance and he seems to be an excellent character and motivator both of which are also crucially important to a team. There is a real sense of excitement and anticipation rippling through the team about Daniel joining.

→ More replies (12)

129

u/1320Fastback May 22 '20

Have you ever driven a F1 car or any other race car?

What is your personal vehicle?

556

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I was fortunate enough to get to sit in the FW26 when I was at Williams and to "drive" it in for pitstop practice. For a long time this was my favourite car ever (views expressed here are my own and not necessarily shared by McLaren) - it was the "Walrus"-nosed car - so this was a fairly special day for me.

I've never driven an F1 car or a race car, but based on my spreadsheets I think I'd be pretty quick and I imagine it's only a matter of time before I end up in the car (views expressed here are my own and should be shared by McLaren).

Recently I have been trying not to drive too much and using my bike much more - but I drive a Mercedes GLA.

This is a photo of someone called Montoya, driving the FW26 I drove for pitstop practice:

https://flic.kr/p/CW3zv

→ More replies (8)

342

u/Popotixovo69 May 22 '20

What do when car go boom?

410

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

As much as everyone would like to get upset, go into "Hulk" mode or throw something, typically there is still another car in the race - so those of us who work across the team will take into account what has happened and continue to try and maximise the result for the car that remains in the race.

Those of us who may work on the car that is no longer participating will make sure that the driver is safe, etc. and then also focus on helping the other car - this may mean you debrief the driver/engineers to find out what has happened and see if it can be avoided, it may mean that you help your counterpart on the other car by buddying up with them or helping them out with menial/background tasks, etc.

Even if its your second car that "go boom" there's still a lot to learn and observe during the race - whether that is roleplaying as other cars and trying to understand what they would/should do, etc. or using the opportunity to do some training/practice in a live situation and so on.

→ More replies (3)

110

u/TKTimmy Ronnie Peterson May 21 '20

What is your view on Ferraris strategies over the past few years? What are they doing wrong?

336

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

I've wanted to answer this question since you posted it (and others asked similar) but have wanted to make sure I communicated exactly what I thought, apologies for the delay.

We track our performance in strategy and have some methods for tracking other teams as well. We actually spend a considerable time doing this as its a valuable learning opportunity. Strategy is a strange beast, as you can't really outperform your natural car position without fortune or the mistakes of others - neither of which you can control (much...) - so in essence you are always trying not to "underperform" rather than every "overperforming".

You also, I strongly believe, cannot judge a strategy on the outcome - I don't think our strategy for the podium in Brazil 2019 was anything special compared to our strategy in races where we may have finished well outside of the points with both cars in recent years.

However, both of these factors make it easier to get a poor opinion of teams, especially top teams, from the "outside" - because they can't finish much higher than their "natural" position, but they can finish much lower and because mistakes should be more prevalent than successes, because successes are just achieving what is "natural" (which is really hard to do).

It's even bad inside the sport, when I moved teams one of the first things we did was run through races that the new team thought I had gotten wrong at my previous team and those I thought they had gotten wrong when I was at my previous team - needless to say in many cases we were simply missing information (although in some cases there were mistakes of course).

However, that's not to say that teams aren't better/worse than others nor do I think strategy is harder at the front of the field, I think if anything its harder in the midfield (perhaps I am biased, as you have to look around you, ahead and behind), but there is more scrutiny at the front.

We spend much time working out how well a team has done (or not done) based on the information available and estimating what may be unavailable etc. and we do have a ranking of teams for strategy skill/execution - but I won't reveal what the order is.

→ More replies (3)

314

u/DarkOperator618 Ferrari May 21 '20

What’s it like from an engineers perspective, right before the lights go out

731

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 21 '20

It's really stupid - I can't affect what happens at the start, whatever happens we will have plans or be able to formulate plans to deal with the situation and I've done 140 Grand Prix - but I get butterflies every single time.

The formation lap itself isn't too bad, as you're checking that cars have gotten away cleanly, that nobody overtakes and positions are regained by the required points if they are swapped, etc. etc. but from the point the cars are parked up and the light sequence starts the anticipation is immense.

I am fortunate enough to sit on the pitwall and watch at least the first few seconds of the start before we dive into trying to understand what has changed and what we are going to do - it's one of the most awesome moments of the whole weekend.

→ More replies (6)

107

u/[deleted] May 21 '20

Hi Randy! Thanks for doing this.

My question for you is how did you become an f1 engineer. What are your qualifications and how exactly did you manage to get this job? Were you or your colleagues ever a part of student racing teams (like formula student) and if so did it help you to get this job?

Thanks in advance!

  • An engineering student aspiring to work in f1

106

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I'll try not to repeat myself so a couple of comments already written about what can help you get in (https://www.reddit.com/r/formula1/comments/go6c9m/im_an_f1_engineerstrategist_ask_me_anything/frh3gl8?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x) and what my route was (https://www.reddit.com/r/formula1/comments/go6c9m/im_an_f1_engineerstrategist_ask_me_anything/frh45hn?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x).

I was never able to do Formula Student (to my disappointment) as there was no team at my university at the time and we were not allowed to set one up - many others have done it and many haven't. By no means is it necessary, but it does provide both useful skills and experience and gives you a good taste of motorsport.

As a quick disclaimer, there are a lot of questions about route into F1, career paths, useful skills and experiences. I intend to answer all of these as I understand how important these are - I'm taking my time to make sure I give the best advice I can and apologies if some of this is repeated across different responses.

104

u/Rioton May 23 '20

First of all, thanks for doing this AMA and your effort in answering in such great detail! I'm a bit late to the party, but here are my questions anyway:

  1. In the past, teams have used evidence containing competitors' GPS data in discussions with the stewards. So I assume there is an official data stream at each event delivering certain information about all cars on track you can use as an input for your strategy algorithm? What does that data contain other than position?
  2. Maybe a bit of an odd one, but I've always wondered: do F1 teams employ lip readers?

152

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20 edited May 23 '20

Thank you.

  1. GPS data is provided to all teams for all cars. We get it at 10Hz (10 data points a second) and as far as I remember (it's been a long time since I looked at the actual raw data) you get position and velocity, as well as the type of data it is (true GPS, dead-reckoned, etc.). We also can run our own sensors on the cars and powerunits and can collect data from those, so those may include things like wheel speeds, steering angle, etc.
  2. My lips are sealed. But no - I don't know that for sure of course, but I think I can say with some level of confidence that there are far more useful things to spend our limited resources on (talking about teams as a whole).

96

u/SirLoremIpsum Daniel Ricciardo May 22 '20

Hi!

What are your feelings on the super mega packed calendar?

There has been a lot of talk recently, not just in F1, about the increasing demand on staff, drivers in regards to being away from home and families for a huge portion of the year. Super long hours and all the pressure that comes with that. Mental health as a topic is becoming increasingly more public and important in the Western worlds mind.

The counter argument is that if you want to be the best you have to sacrifice, if you have a problem with the long hours, well there's someone else who will jump on that opportunity and work themselves to the bone.

Obviously more races means more cash, more viewers etc, but I would be one of those people that would be happy if F1 perhaps said '21 races this is too many, our people need some work life balance'.

176

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

In terms of the calendar - it will be tough, but we're also going through unprecedented times and we all need to play our small part in making sure that F1 comes through this situation fit and healthy - so we can all enjoy it in the future.

It's easier for me to say that, as I don't have kids, I'm not at the Grand Prix for as long as some of my teammates (like mechanics and support crew) and I have to acknowledge that when I share my personal opinion.

It is stressful, long hours and it can take its toll but F1 and the FIA are aware of that as they experience the same issues as well and I trust in them to find the right balance with the calendar and I have to say I do not envy them over this task as it is incredibly difficult.

I think we will end up with a calendar that may be packed but that will also be enjoyable and provide exciting racing - and I believe there will be sufficient room to recuperate as well, even though it may be tough at times.

The point about mental health is an important one and I'm glad that this is an issue that is easier to talk about and discuss openly and one that McLaren and F1 really do acknowledge. Mental wellbeing is not something that can be overlooked because its a job that many, many people want to do.

→ More replies (1)

90

u/Apocaloctapus I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

First I want to say that this is one of the best AMAs I’ve seen, it’s awesome how you’re giving such detailed answers and answering so many people!

I’d like to know how many members are there roughly in the strategy team? Also, how does it deal with ‘both sides of the garage’ - are there strategists dedicated to one driver that would keep info from the other?

94

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

Most teams will have around 3 to 6 people and there's nothing to give away by saying that we currently have a core team of 5.

Some of us work across both cars and others are more centred on a single car/driver. It does get competitive in the sense that you really form a bond within your engineering team and with your driver if you are allocated to one (I remember from my time on Fernando's side of the garage) - but it's a team sport - nobody in the team would ever keep information from the other side and the opposite is true, the team is proactive in helping the other side where possible.

180

u/Bunjireddits I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 21 '20

How many times in a year do you think you get race day strategy 100% correct?

457

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 21 '20

I would say we never get it 100% correct. Race day strategy isn't just about picking the correct number of stops and stop laps for both cars.

Did we take every last drop of grip out of the tyres before we pitted? Did we pressure cars ahead the right amount at every point? Did we back off and protect the tyres the right amount at every point? Did we communicate to the driver exactly what we were trying to achieve and therefore get 100% out of them at every instant in the race? Was the modelling accurate and useful? etc. etc.

We will always be searching for marginal/incremental improvements in everything we do.

→ More replies (3)

177

u/brakedust12c Pirelli Hard May 22 '20

Hey Randy,

Be honest, how did you do in college, were you always at/near the top of the important engineering classes, did you have a couple “C’s get degrees” classes?

Also, did Lando keep your face as his homescreen until the end of the season?

397

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Hi "mum" 😂 .

So, to be honest I did ok at university and managed to get a first - but it didn't start off that way - I couldn't do the homework before we started our first term for Mathematics, the first term felt overwhelming in terms of difficulty, etc. but everything can be turned around.

There were some parts of engineering that I really found difficult at the beginning too (bode plots and engineering drawing!) but that got better with time and effort.

In answer to your second question, Lando did keep it for the whole season, he clearly has no shame whatsoever.

→ More replies (4)

176

u/Redbiertje Charlie Whiting May 21 '20

What kind of people do you have in the strategy department? Are they mostly engineers, or like mathematicians and computer scientists?

294

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 21 '20

Although we are largely engineers by degree, we don't really discriminate against other backgrounds and are often quite keen to add a diversity of ideas and backgrounds into the mix - a numerate degree is going to be very helpful though.

We are 60% mechanical engineers, 1 engineer/mathematician hybrid and 1 physicist.

→ More replies (7)

86

u/Tomero Lance Stroll May 22 '20

Hello, Do you go on reddit and check this sub sometimes?

243

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I would say more frequently than sometimes and I'm not the only one who works in F1 than does.

The content on here can be amazing at times - from some of the photos, to some of the data visualisations - and sometimes it is just fun to read comments and see how different our perspective of a race/event can be to that of fans.

→ More replies (1)

249

u/_pixeld May 22 '20

Hi Randy! Thank you for doing an AMA! As a social scientist, I would like to know how much do you and the team take into account the psyche of the drivers with regards to your strategy. Do different drivers prefer different types of strategies? And how much do y’all take into account the drivers feedback!

Thank you!

674

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

We have a very special filing cabinet for drivers' feedback - 🚮 .

Of course, I'm kidding.

Drivers' feedback is very useful, they are the ones in the car and they often have access to "data" that we don't. The engineering team for each driver will spend a lot of time reviewing and improving the communications with the driver, inside and outside the cockpit to ensure we get the most useful information from them.

I have to say though that when it comes to strategy, the driver's feedback is one of many sources of information and data we have - that's why you may hear Lando complain about the tyres and we leave him out anyway - obviously we weight his feedback with the due respect it deserves, but we also understand he will often be missing information as well.

I think drivers tend to prefer strategies that are quick - first and foremost 😀 and with the small sample of drivers I've worked with they then tend to prefer more stops over fewer stops (which kind of makes sense, as they get to go faster on the timed laps overall and it must be much more fun to drive at the limit than to eke a set of tyres out).

→ More replies (5)

79

u/jalexandref May 22 '20

Super thanks for your availability on this AMA !!

How does impact a team to be running in the front, on the middle and at the back of the grid.

I am thinking in terms of strategy, but also for example less TV cameras to follow your both drivers. Please answer on any perspective you think is more interested.

132

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

This is a very interesting question and one we do often muse about!

I will be biased, having been in the "midfield" more than at the "front" - although I've had experience of all 3 situations you mention.

I believe that strategy is harder in the midfield, with the current level of field spread and fundamental strategic parameters - not only are you racing many more cars directly than you would at the front or the back, but you're also affected by the cars at the front and the back strategically much more frequently.

At the front, you're typically not affected by the cars in the midfield and at the back of the field during the more strategically difficult parts of the race, which I believe makes things easier strategically - and of course you're typically racing fewer cars directly. However, the pressure to perform or not mess up may be much higher than in the midfield as you fight for podium places.

At the back, often your hands can be tied and strategic choices can dwindle down to avoiding traffic and deviating as much as possible from cars ahead to try and get further up the classification.

As I said, I'm probably biased on this matter - and you may get different answers from other strategists.

→ More replies (1)

79

u/[deleted] May 25 '20

Day 5: Mr. Singh is still answering questions.

He's now one of us.

LEGEND, and thanks to McLaren for allowing this.

-Best AMA yet?

DC answered 4 questions.

46

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

Haha thank you!

I will probably have to stop soon - but have a few more answers coming on a few families of question I haven’t yet answered. 🙂

→ More replies (1)

152

u/[deleted] May 21 '20

What are your thoughts on refueling?

463

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 21 '20

I'm a little sad that I never really got to do strategy under the 'refuelling' era, irrespective of the impact on racing there was an extra element in the strategy role in setting fuel loads, estimating others' fuel loads, etc.

However, we (as a sport) have considered bringing back refuelling numerous types in my tenure and the analysis has always shown that it is typically worse for exciting racing and strategies.

Whereas at a high level refuelling may seem to present an extra variable to play with in terms of strategy, really what it does is tend to constrain your stop lap and races become a lot more "deterministic".

Outside of strategy and with my "sporting" hat on, I also have to say that the safety aspect of refuelling is also a genuine concern (as well as potential cost impacts also) and I think the sport has made the right decision, many times, to leave refuelling off the table.

145

u/DL14Nibba I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

So uhhh..... what does the team boss/driver tell you if you make a mistake?

436

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

You don't get told off, not at McLaren at least!

Normally, if you make a genuine mistake the person who is most upset is yourself as you want to do better and not let the team down. I don't remember a time where Andreas or Zak, for example, have told me off for a bad strategy or a mistake, they trust us to work out when there are mistakes and to fix things to make them better.

There have even been occasions where I've been strongly disagreeing with my boss(es) about what to do if there were a safety car, then a safety car was deployed and I made the decision I thought was best. I didn't get told off but rather got told that I did the right thing in making the decision as I thought was best, as I should have more knowledge on the matter than they do.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/restitut Fernando Alonso May 26 '20

Hi Randy, this is the best AMA I've ever seen. Thanks for doing it, and apologies if you've already answered this question, but there are 700 comments!

There have recently been talks of getting rid of some of the Friday practice sessions, limiting everything to what is now FP3 on Saturday. The idea behind it would be to reduce the data you guys have on tyre wear, leading to more unpredictable strategies and better races.

This seems to be supported by the fact that, whenever there's a lot of rain in those sessions, that indeed happens (or at least it seems so from the outside). However, I've watched too much F1 in my life to know that, whenever there's a seemingly impossible problem, you guys struggle at first (and the grid gets mixed up) but then develop ways around it and things get back to normal.

So the question is: would that also happen if you got rid of those practice sessions, that is, after a year nobody would notice (except the spectators at the track, and you of course)? Or would it really have a lasting impact, in a way that e.g. the private testing ban didn't? If so, would you welcome it?

86

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Thanks for the kind words.

So to cover off your points (I pretty much agree so apologies for the short answer):

I think there is a correlation between good racing and missed Friday sessions/lack of information, I'm not sure there is causality there but I can understand the logic if there were.

I think teams will find a way to adapt and so over time the impact of missing those sessions would reduce, however, it would still be as least as bad for teams (in terms of the information/their predictions) than it can be now with the same effort (albeit more effort may be put in after such a change).

For the reason of creating more exciting race (but unknown really to what extent over the long-term, I believe) I would welcome it, however, circuits and fans (at home also) appreciate Friday running (perhaps less so than weekend running) and losing out on that would be a big hit I think - so overall, I don't think this is an idea we should pursue (and it's one we have discussed at Sporting Working Groups in recent times).

→ More replies (1)

62

u/Gh0st1y_ I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 22 '20

Have you ever sat on the pitwall at the start and said (even to yourself) "And it's lights out and away we go."?

87

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I haven’t! I imagine I now will at whichever Grand Prix we get the pleasure of starting first this year.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/SantoEng May 22 '20

Hi Randy, we´ve heard a couple times last season that one of the drivers race was "compromised" in order to maximise the other drivers result?

At what point in the race do the team come to the conclusion that what is best is to "sacrifice" one driver in order to obtain whats best for the team? Whats the thought process behind all of that?

Just to be clear, I´m not implying you get to the race with the idea of benefiting one over the other, the question relates to in-race incidents that lead to that kind of decisions.

111

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Hi - to be fair, sometimes we know before the race, sometimes even earlier in the weekend, that it could be an event where optimising the overall team outcome may not be the same as optimising the outcome for each of the drivers.

We're all (including the drivers) on the same page - our aim is to get the best outcome for the team - which makes it really simple for us - we discuss these situations very openly and so often you can see the relevant situations approaching in the race before they happen. As you note, sometimes there is an incident in the race that makes these kinds of strategies more viable all of a sudden and having them in the toolbox and knowing everyone understands what you're trying to do makes it easier to execute them.

I would also say that "sacrifice" is rare, more frequently you tend to hedge certain risks, or split the cars.

→ More replies (1)

125

u/DarkOperator618 Ferrari May 21 '20

The strategy with sainz in Brazil was amazing man

94

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Thanks for the kind words but the strategy in Brazil (I hope) was as good as in Austria, or Hungary, etc. We didn't do anything particularly special but in this case the outcome was particularly good - we try and judge ourselves on our decisions/processes/analysis rather than the outcome as the outcome/result can be dependent on chance which is outside our control.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Shaddix-be I failed to serve my Monaco penalty May 22 '20

Do you think Stoffel deserved to still be in F1? (Not necessarily with McLaren)

149

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

100% - he is a great talent and I'm very glad that he is doing so well in Formula E.

118

u/yaraalhajali May 22 '20

how does the whole trackside team travel to each race? like is it together or staggered, and can you stay longer in a city if you would like? and how often do you travel back to the mtc/england? just wondering since there’s not too much public info on this topic thanks randy !!

178

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Good question!

We will typically all fly to races, albeit there are some European races where some will drive/train but those people tend to be the exceptions. Normally groups of people from a team may fly together, so the set-up crew who set-up the garage, etc. will fly out first together, followed by mechanics and support crews and then by marketing and engineers.

Often we'll end up travelling on the same flights as our counterparts from other teams, or fans too.

Personally, I'm normally at MTC between every race, except double-headers where we don't come back - often we'll go in straight after we land or before we take off. That's pretty typical for engineers, but other areas may be at HQ a bit less.

Occasionally people will go out early, stay out later or between races for a holiday/trip - this again depends on role (engineers don't get as many opportunities to do this due to debrief/briefing requirements).

→ More replies (1)

52

u/ska8erman Default May 23 '20

Hi Randeep! Thanks for this AMA. Has been such an interesting read. I do have a question. While every team works on their strategy during the race, I would assume you also have people trying to decode the competition’s strategy. How much of that goes into deciding your strategy? Are a lot of resources dedicated to this?

114

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

It is really simple to work out the optimum strategy for a car if you were racing alone on a track - you could do this, literally, on the back of an envelope (and the maths is actually quite neat too).

However, when other cars are introduced and there are interactions between cars (notably overtaking and following) then things get a bit more interesting and more difficult to model also.

The strategies of your competitors is vitally important, because of these interactions and how the current strategy landscape (no refuelling) enables the "undercut" - you can gain track position by pitting earlier than the racing alone optimum and then other cars may have to overtake or follow you, which impacts on their race time.

But, it's not only the strategy of your direct competitors, but of their direct ones also (who may influence their decisions), of cars a pit window behind and ahead and their competitors and etc. etc.

Game theory and understanding what your competitors are doing or may do is a fundamental part of formulating a strategy.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/ClevinStorm Tyrrell May 23 '20

As head of sporting, what were your thoughts on reverse-grid qualifying races that were proposed last year?

123

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

It's complicated.

This is quite a big topic, but a few high-level considerations are mentioned below, as with all changes of this ilk there can be some unintended consequences.

From a "racing" point of view there are two schools of thought, the first that this would damage the "pureness" or "sanctity" of F1 and the second that this would lead to better racing as it would lead to more overtaking.

We conducted modelling that showed that with the right parameters more overtaking would be prevalent and that actually much of this overtaking would be between cars of relatively similar paces, rather than with really large pace differences (as those overtakes add less excitement, we believe, due to their ease).

Setting the parameters though was shown to be a complex business, which events would you pick (more below), how long would the reverse grid race have to be to get you into the range between a normal qualifying grid and a fully reversed grid (say if you set the race to be only 0 laps long), etc. etc.

Picking events is not easy, each circuit has different characteristics, so the pace difference required for overtaking at the Circuit de Monaco is vastly different to that at the Bahrain International Circuit and you need to balance the race length with the "overtaking difficulty" to allow for the desired level of mixing. There are even second order effects, you're likely to have cars battling with cars of similar pace as they make their way through slower cars, some circuits with multiple driving lines and track width available may be more suitable than others to encourage this (probably very exciting) fighting between cars.

And then unfortunately, there can often be other unintended snags that add some inertia to changing the rules, as we, as teams, will try and exploit every change to our advantage. If you did reverse grid races early in the year then there would be the potential for gaming the system, i.e. trying to get a lower position in the Drivers' World Championship such that one starts in a higher position for the reverse championship order race.

Personally, I think F1, the FIA and the teams made the right decision. There are many changes already agreed and planned that should make racing closer, we don't need to rush changes at the expense of this great sport we all love, so let's see where we get to and then judge whether we should make further incremental changes.

100

u/3z_ Oscar Piastri May 21 '20 edited May 21 '20

Thanks for doing this AMA Randy!

  • What's the riskiest call you've had to make/be a part of? The biggest unknown?
  • Which F1 drivers in your experience have impressed you the most with strategic input? Oftentimes drivers like Lewis are criticised for questioning their engineer during races, do you think it's important for drivers to trust the team more?
  • What's it like working with Andreas Seidl?

Hope we see big success with Danny and the new regs soon :)

89

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

No worries. Thanks for the questions!

  • Really, I'd hope that everything is a balanced risk/reward trade. So I don't think we ever really "throw the dice". The biggest unknown is also a difficult one, it can vary from tyres at one race, to weather uncertainty at the next.
  • All of the drivers I have worked with have been excellent. Fernando, in particular, seemed to have a passion for strategy and would even play F1 strategy games on his phone. But he didn't like 1 stop strategies...!
  • Great - I enjoy working with and for Andreas. He's a fellow engineer, so there's a shared understanding which makes things a lot easier.

44

u/skibodybop May 22 '20

Speaking from a career standpoint, does having a background in something like biology factor into a possible role at all? Something of a mix of Biology and Engineering (Biomed, Bioengineering etc)? Thanks!

97

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

It can do - I specialised in Biomedical Engineering as one of my electives in my final year at university, by the way.

Especially in strategy, different viewpoints/experiences/backgrounds can be very useful.

157

u/Joe_O_24 Dan Gurney May 21 '20 edited May 21 '20

I’m in high school and am planning on going to school to become a mechanical engineer, so my question is this: how available are engineering jobs in F1, or just motorsport in general? Of course, being an F1 engineer would be a dream, but I have no idea how difficult it would be to actually find a job

213

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I have to be honest and say that jobs in motorsport and especially F1 are not plentiful and that they are often oversubscribed many times over.

I would not let that put you off though, at your age you have a lot of time to pick up skills, experiences and knowledge that will help you in the endeavor of getting a job in motorsport.

I would also say that perseverance is almost an essential quality in finding a job in F1. I, and many others I know, were turned down for roles multiple times and at various points thought we would never get our dream jobs in F1.

→ More replies (4)

39

u/AbrarHossainHimself Sebastian Vettel May 22 '20

Hey, Randy! Thanks for doing this awesome AMA. You have talked a lot about getting into F1 for a career as an Engineer. I was hoping you could shed a bit of light in what skillsets/qualifications you look for in candidates who work as the mechanics and the pitstop crew on a given race weekend.

Again, Thanks for doing this. I have read through every one of your answers and they were as much fun to read as they were enlightening about the sport we love.

67

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

So this is not my area of expertise, although I do spend a lot of time working with the pitcrew - so please take this with a pinch of salt but I think below are the main things we look for:

  • Some prior experience in building and servicing of race cars or bikes.
  • An ability to understand and follow (often complex) procedures.
  • A proactive nature (e.g. when reporting faults or build issues).
  • Dealing well with a high pressure and time constrained workload and environment.
  • An attention to detail and a willingness to learn.
  • Ability to read and interpret technical drawings.
  • Fabrication and machining skills.

35

u/IcyPilgrim May 23 '20

Hi Randy. Thanks so much for doing this, the answers so far have been really insightful. Can I ask, as an armchair fan, what can I look for over the course of the weekend to help me predict likely strategic calls on race day?

59

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

The main 2 factors are tyre behaviour (degradation, wear life and pace difference) and pitstop loss. From here you can get a basic understanding of the strategy before competitors are thrown into the mix.

Pirelli kindly provide some of the information each weekend on tyres and you can estimate the rest from FP2 long runs towards the end of the session. Pitstop loss is also often given by some teams (maybe rounded or slightly noisified - but close enough to give you the right number of stops).

With those 2 things you can work out the baseline strategy if you were racing alone and then you want to be considering the cars that are a pitstop window ahead and behind and see whether you would stop earlier or later than the baseline based on undercutting, traffic and so on.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/Bunjireddits I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 21 '20

How contagious is Landos laugh?

176

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I don't know about you but I find it quite grating. Do you know the feeling you get when you hear someone scratch their nails across a blackboard, or when your alarm goes off and you're still tired?

In all seriousness though, Lando is a funny guy and does always keep the mood nice and light.

29

u/juwere 🏳️‍🌈 Love Is Love 🏳️‍🌈 May 22 '20

Who won the bet where Lando had to have ur face as his lock screen till Abu Dhabi last year?

68

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Lando won the bet, but he also clearly has no shame. 😃

57

u/Shabigity I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

Do you employ many Americans on the team, and if so what does it take? Assuming they have the technical credentials of engineering.

279

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

So we have nothing against Americans, nor people of other nationalities - having the right to work in the UK is sometimes required although we do also help with visa applications this isn't always possible for us to do.

In terms of Americans on the team, we have Zak Brown, of course and I'll be honest and say I can't think of any others at the moment, although we have had a few placement students in recent years from the United States.

There's no extra requirement for Americans, especially as we're moving to Mercedes powerunits soon, we won't have too many issues with the pronunciation of Renault anymore.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/cleaningProducts Mika Häkkinen May 22 '20

Is it unusual to go from entry-level engineer to head of strategy in 6-7 years? What do you think drove your success?

52

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

I think it actually happened even a bit quicker than that - which had never been my expectation when I started.

It's hard to say what is unusual, there are so few "race strategists" in the world, let alone in F1 that I think there's not really a "usual" and often timescales can be quite variable based on circumstance (e.g. someone leaving/changing role).

I guess the success is driven by the confidence and belief in the strategy team, of which I am just a part - so the fact that the other members of the team are so good, that management above us let us independently improve and change our processes without blame nor interference etc. is what has really driven it. Also have the much wider strategy team that includes 10s of volunteers to thank - it truly is a team effort and no single person would have the impact they do without the team around them.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/Luke_4686 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

Really cool to hear from you Randy. How have you and the team at McLaren been spending your time with everything that’s been going on with Covid-19? Hope we can see you go racing in Austria in July!

154

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

So F1 teams have all been subject to an extended "shutdown" meaning that most of us haven't been allowed to work on F1 projects and many of us, consequently, have not been working in recent weeks.

Personally, I've used the time to try and get fit, having averaged c. 4 hours and 15 minutes of exercise every day since April 1st (yes I do have a spreadsheet), as well as trying to learn some new skills like React.

Many of the team have used the opportunity to spend time with their loved ones, which can be difficult with hectic schedules, to improve their cooking skills (I have eaten the best pizza I've ever had during lockdown!), do gardening and so on.

Everyone seems eager to get back to it and most teams will be returning to work over the next fortnight.

→ More replies (3)

130

u/[deleted] May 21 '20

How many times have you rejected Ferrari headhunting job offers?

Today, the official Autosport podcast, were highly critical of Fernando Alonso, and the male podcaster/journalist stated that something along the lines of all the track staff/engineers hated him and don't want him on the team, so much so, it sounded pretty libellous the entire podcast to be honest. (source: https://youtu.be/FMZDi7RWsc4?t=1847)

So my real question is, how was it like to work with Fernando Alonso? and was the journalist right in what he stated?

404

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Any really good headhunter will storm your village at sunset with overwhelming force and cut off your head with a ceremonial knife - I've managed to avoid that.

I have to say that I certainly didn't hate Fernando nor do I know of anyone who did at McLaren - in contrast, the level of respect and admiration I have for Fernando is extremely high. I don't think it's easy to describe working with someone who has such an extreme level of talent, Fernando is a true racer, he has the outright speed of anyone, he has the intelligence to understand "the race" whilst he's driving flat out and he has a way of encouraging people to perform at their best.

There were, of course, difficult times - we disagreed on the strategy many times and yet Fernando still executed what we asked to 100%, we made mistakes and had good races too and Fernando acknowledged both kinds internally and helped us improve.

I feel really privileged to have had the chance to work so closely with him.

→ More replies (10)

49

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

Can we get McLaren's Tooned back? Next year with Lando and Dan Ric would be fun!

87

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I've already asked a few times. I love Tooned!

→ More replies (1)

67

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

Whats it like working for the most positive and happiest team?

188

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Let me ask some of my friends at other teams and I'll get back to you soon.

Only kidding 😁 ! I can't say if McLaren is the most positive/happiest team as I've not been everywhere, but its certainly the most fun, positive, happy, smart, etc. etc. team I've ever worked at.

I love it. It's the people that make McLaren (and I know that's a cliche) special and I enjoy working in such a tight-knit, funny, motivated team.

23

u/AlanTheBlank May 22 '20

So we're hearing that Austria and maybe Britain is going ahead, is McLaren prepping for this or are they waiting for official word from Formula 1

64

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I can't comment on the calendar as it stands as that would be breaking confidentiality. However, I can say that Liberty and the FIA are working tirelessly to bring a calendar together and it was something that we all discussed yesterday in the Sporting Working Group and is no doubt being discussed on a daily basis in other forums also.

The teams, including McLaren, are trying as well to prepare for the season starting soon whilst remaining flexible such that if there are changes we can adapt to them quickly and well.

46

u/FCIUS Kamui Kobayashi May 21 '20 edited May 21 '20

Thank you so much for doing this AMA!

During last year's German GP, I remember that a lot of us fans were interested in contrasting approaches made by two teams as the track started to dry up.

One driver saw that the track was dry enough for slicks, called it in, and got the go ahead to take the gamble; he ended up coming very close to a podium.

Another driver made similar observations and appealed repeatedly to his engineer to make the switch, but was instructed to stay out for several more laps, costing him points.

I understand hindsight is 20/20 here, but if you were the engineer, would you be more inclined to take the driver's word when they potentially contradict the data, or vice versa? Do you believe there's a "correct" approach in situations like these, or a personal preference?

Again, thank you so much!

(Typed from my “Mclaren Edition” phone...I can't wait for the season to start, and I really wish you guys the best!)

44

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Thank you for the kind words!

I think there is a lot you don't see (not your fault) when it comes to strategic decisions, this is amplified many times over in a wet or changeable conditions race, where decisions are extremely difficult, with lots of information, of varying quality/frequency.

I think we have learnt that it depends. Sometimes, we will weight the driver's input higher than anything else, sometimes it will be the least valuable information.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/deckerjeffreyr I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

Is Ferrari’s strategy as much of a running joke in the paddock as it is by the fans and here on reddit?

Maybe you can’t really answer that truthfully but I’ve always been curious. It’s obviously a difficult job but I do wonder if they shoot themselves in the foot as often as it seems from the fans perspective.

47

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Answered elsewhere in the thread.

It's a difficult, stressful job, so you always have respect for your competitors.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Likaonnn May 22 '20

Does race strategist cooperate with aerodynamics department in any way?

98

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

So, I can't go into details but yes we do. Strategy is a really cool role because we end up dealing with pretty much all other areas - as we also cover things like Competitor Intelligence and Sporting matters.

In a more typical sense, just thinking about race strategy, there are a few areas that spring to mind, aerodynamicists and other engineers will be setting things like the wing level and the trades made here can affect performance in qualifying vs. the race, something that we as strategists are well placed to comment on the value of and also for setting cooling levels, we're responsible for weather forecasting and interpretation and so will often liaise with our aerodynamics colleagues about the risks of it being hotter than certain limits.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/UnsaltedCuriousity May 22 '20

Hi Randy, I don't know if this is already over but I'll try anyway. It's no surprise that working in F1 in any capacity must be extremely competitive. Is there any chance for someone considering a career change to be able to get a foot in the door?

I work in investment management and realise that I want to be as close to my passion as possible. I'm open to pretty much any job just to get in. Naturally Id hope to have some transferable skills but i would focus on the chance to build skills and potentially go from there. Any advice? Thanks!

65

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I think perseverance and desire are key and yes it is possible. Coincidentally, I was working in the investment industry when I was offered the chance to take a full time role in strategy for the 2013 season.

I had worked at Williams for my final year project at university, but had been "out of the game" for a couple years when I got the offer to return.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/farmerMac I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 24 '20

I understand you may not answer because this may be sensitive, but Which method of steering the ship do you think is more effective ? The steely dictatorial grip of Ron Dennis or the More lenient managerial approach of Zak brown ? From a fan perspective, I love that mclaren drivers aren’t on such a tight leash.

52

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 24 '20

I never really worked under Ron as I joined in mid-2015. I have to say that the management style I’ve experienced throughout has been great - no blame culture, very open and understanding, letting the experts make decisions, etc.

38

u/GearMed McLaren May 22 '20

Is there any role for physicians/doctors on race teams?

91

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

As doctors, I would probably say no. Most teams won't employ their own doctors anymore or will do so in a very limited capacity.

However, that doesn't mean we don't have medical support, it tends to come through external organisations that support F1, such as Formula Medicine, for example, or the FIA's Medical Programme.

We also occasionally get applications for strategists who have a medical background - and that isn't something we look down upon, if anything it may provide a skillset/experiences that would be complementary to those of 'mostly engineers'.

18

u/C9_SneakysBeaver Heinz-Harald Frentzen May 21 '20

Have you found any books in particular helpful when it comes to the soft skills required working in a multi-department environment, also when it comes to the overarching strategic principles.

Building on that, how often do you find yourself acting against the data/conclusions presented to you in favour of your own observations or “common sense”

49

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20 edited May 28 '20

I think the most useful book has been Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix as it really demonstrates the importance of teamwork. Mark Corrigan's seminal "Business Secrets of the Pharaohs" and Michael Scott's "Somehow I Manage" are also essential reading.

Seriously though, a difficult one, I think a lot of skills are picked up outside of books, things like logical problem-solving, being extremely pro-active, etc. however, some books that I find have been useful are:

  • Thinking Fast and Slow (almost essential reading, Thinking in Bets is also good)
  • The Intelligent Entrepreneur (very inspiring)
  • Outliers (to try and replicate some of the factors)
  • Legacy (a great book about teamwork and management)
  • Resonant Leadership (given to me by manager and a great read)
→ More replies (2)

36

u/Luke_4686 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

What’s your proudest moment in F1 to date?

94

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Another tough one!

What makes me proudest is the Strategy team at McLaren. The team consists of around 5 people at its core and I can honestly say that they are the most talented, motivated, most passionate and smartest collection of individuals I have ever had the pleasure of working with. Everyone's level naturally rises when you work with people of this calibre and although the team is constantly looking for areas of improvement, challenging each other - it is also really just fun. I am very proud that I've played a part in pulling in each of my strategy teammates.

One other thing that gets close (other than Grand Prix which I'll cover in another answer) is Mission Control. McLaren were kind enough to give me the opportunity to manage the project to design a new Mission Control from scratch, build and deploy it. We were responsible for building contractors, ventilation, budget, aesthetic, even unpacking and setting up over 30 machines. The Mission Control room is an awesome facility and we built it together as a team. A lot of it is secret but here's a photo you are allowed to see:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EKssMOfWkAAwPE6?format=jpg&name=large

→ More replies (3)

17

u/camcam52 May 22 '20

Hello Randy,

I am sorry if this has already been asked. But I would like to know your thoughts on:

  1. The new strategy involved on the new regulations/ground affect designs on the new Formula 1 vehicles? Is this a step in the right direction?

Love to hear an professional / insider view on these new changes to the sport as the team Engineers do not seem to have a big say in the acceptace of the design limitations from FIA.

34

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

I personally think the new regulations (Sporting, Technical and Financial) are moving the sport in the right direction and so am looking forwards to them being introduced over the coming years.

I would also say, as it may not be obvious to fans, that teams and engineers are heavily involved in these regulations. Whether that is us helping to draft parts of them, sense check them, vote on them, etc. it is a very open, constructive forum between the teams, the FIA and FOM (and other external experts as required).

→ More replies (1)

16

u/gnumunny I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 21 '20

Can you speak on how the sport has changed in the past few years in aspect to big data. How has data gathering and manipulation changed the sport? Specifically when it comes to making decisions based on past and current strategies. What kind of software and hardware have made the biggest changes, and how do you see the future of F1 benefit from AI/Big-data? Thanks for any info you may be able to share.

19

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

McLaren have always been data-driven, so things haven't changed too much recently. We are finding better ways to analyse the data we have and to draw insights from it. I'm afraid I can't say too much more.

16

u/tuna1905fish I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 22 '20

You've talked about refuelling in a previous answer, and how it might affect strategies, but what is your opinion on the current tyres, and how they basically force the teams to do a two-stop strategy? Would you prefer if the tyres were manufactured in a way that makes them more durable?

Thank you!

37

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

So, I would start by saying the tyres don't force teams into 2 stop strategies, however, the front-runners will have a higher propensity for 2 stops over 1 stops in the current regime, which may present a more skewed picture to fans.

I believe and I think my colleagues and competitors agree, that good racing does involve some strategic flexibility and variety and a good sweet spot is to have races that are at crossover between 2 an 3 stop strategies (crossover means the timings and track position work out such as to be roughly equal).

However, Pirelli are in an unenviable position with regards to giving us tyres that would encourage 2 or 3 stop crossover events, as the drivers also need to be able to push the tyres lap after lap to get good racing.

So you can see that Pirelli have to try and balance both concerns and I think with that in mind they are doing a good job of finding a balance.

15

u/sumana16 New user May 23 '20

Hey randy,

i am a 15 year old girl who lives in india and my dream is to become a formula one engineer or work in f1 in anyway.

What do u think are the educational qualifications needed to become a formula 1 engineer and what exposure do u think i need to even be close to full filling my dream. I have been following mclaren f1 team for quite some while now and love the friendly environment inside the team.

47

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

As PapaKeth says, hopefully there are some answers to your question about what qualifications are required in my other comments.

Can I say though, don't let being 15, female, or living in India deter you - none of those things are a blocker to getting a job in F1 in the future.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/bektour Lella Lombardi May 24 '20

Hi, Randy,

Your answers are great, thank you! One of my most favorite McLaren performances of recent years was Fernando's insane race in Azerbaijan in 2018, when he had a double tyre puncture but still managed to finish 7th. Were you still his personal strategist back then? What was your role in his success? What were you thoughts when you saw him limping to the pits on two wheels? What did you do after that?

38

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

What a race, eh? "Personal" strategist, you make us sound like mathematical butlers... 😁.

I wasn't Fernando's strategist at that time, Chris (one of our team) had already taken over by then and I was leading the team. It was not an easy race, although it may look like we sat back and watched, there's a lot of decisions made that you don't see and a lot of decisions made not to do stuff.

It was a good team effort from everyone to stay calm and try and pick up the pieces after the incident on the first lap, when the car rolled into the pits we did consider retiring it - but as a famous paper salesman once said "you miss 100% of the shots you don't take". What outsiders (who get special access) often notice is that the team stays calm, you can't get wobbly or excited over the incident/accident, you need to be calm, methodical and logical.

15

u/[deleted] May 28 '20

Why is it that you still see signs being held out to the drivers at the pit wall? Surely there can’t be anything said on these signs which can’t be said over the car radio? There’s gonna be a simple answer id imagine. I’ve always thought that it would be hard to try read a sign while travelling at 200 mph?

31

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 28 '20

It happens so rarely nowadays but the radio can fail, so the pitboards are a backup for that. The drivers should always give them a look as they go past (and they rarely do!) in case the radio has failed.

In the current times, where radio is public to other teams they could also be used as a way of passing coded messages, but we do watch them and that doesn't seem to be the case.

14

u/beelseboob #WeSayNoToMazepin May 22 '20

Is AI (by which I mean applied neural networks) making inroads into how strategy calls are made in F1? It seems like it could be super useful for analysing how and when the tyres are going to degrade.

24

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

It is. I am a strong proponent of machine learning and artificial intelligence and we are getting some good benefits in this area. I can't say more.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/C0d24 May 24 '20

How do you judge a mandatory 2 pit stops instead of only one? Can this make the races more enjoyable in your opinion? Thanks

43

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

I don't think mandatory 2 stop strategies are a good idea. I can talk about this openly as its something we have debated with other teams, the FIA and Liberty as well and as a group we decided against it.

The reason I don't like mandatory 2 stop strategies is that it is artificial and artificial constraints (I believe) will lead to more strange/bad occurrences than good ones.

The benefit of mandatory 2 stop strategies is that everyone will make 2 stops which on average is more stops than we currently do and we believe that more stops (to a limit) typically lead to more exciting races.

However, the downside is that this is purely artificial. If the race is a clear 1 stop and we add a second stop artificially then its more likely that that stop could be placed in a strange spot, because the sensitivity to its timing could be low - you may see cars pitting very early or late into the race and therefore the race is still like a 1 stop (you don't get the full benefit on racing of the second stop) - especially with a point for fastest lap.

You may then argue that we could force the second stop into a particular window, or set a limit on stint lengths. This also has issues, with cars likely to be concentrated on one side of the window and then there may need to be more artificial constraints.

I very firmly believe that the best way to encourage more stops is to keep constraints on strategists light and influence the primary factors that determine how many stops there are, that is:

  • Pitloss (decrease = positive pressure on number of stops).
  • Tyre behaviour (worse behaviour = positive pressure on number of stops).
→ More replies (1)

12

u/ART_Jake New user May 26 '20

Very broad question, but what are your thoughts on simracing and how seriously some team/people take it?

31

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

I think simracing is a great thing, especially with the relative ease of access (cost and location issues) compared to typical motorsport. There is some mounting evidence of a correlation between simracing and physical racing talent as well.

I'm impressed by how seriously some people take it and how good they are - I think it can also be quite addictive - there's a guy in our team Oli who plays pretty much all the time, we think by next week he'll be able to complete a full lap of one of the easier circuits.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

Hey Randy! Big fan of your work last season! My question is:

Other than focusing on optimising strategy through the various instruments you have for every next race, what portion of your work is dedicated to improving the tools you have to work out strategies, or developing new technologies and methods?

Is this something done consistently or over the winter?

And lastly, how much does McLaren Applied work with you in using the newer tools in their work?

Thanks :)

16

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

Thank you.

With how busy the season is, often it is difficult to spend too much time doing development in the season, so big projects are typically tackled over the Winter period between seasons (although this is also getting compressed).

However, we are constantly, both in race weekends and between, developing our analysis techniques, smaller pieces of software, our understanding of competitors' behaviours, etc. so there is a constant ongoing development battle.

We do work with McLaren Applied fairly frequently across the business - we're not currently doing that on strategy projects.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/doubleb_43 Lando Norris May 23 '20

What was the most difficult race strategy wise in your F1 career?

39

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

My first race, I think stands outs - the 2013 Australian Grand Prix. I started work on January 2nd that year (my first real job in F1), had no strategy experience, had to do lots of winter reporting and had no strategy mentor (as the previous strategist had left already). I'm not sure "baptism of fire" and "thrown into the deep-end" are mixable metaphors but that's what it felt like.

To make matters more "interesting", the data showed and I was convinced that it would be a multiple stop (probably 3 stop) grand prix, based on what we had observed in Winter Testing and during Friday and Saturday running. This was in sharp contradiction to recent history at the Australian Grand Prix - so there were many heated discussions over this (with the majority of the team heavily disagreeing with it being more than a 1 stop race and every member having much more experience than I).

Turns out lack of experience can be an advantage sometimes. Teams tended to do a 2 or 3 stop race, but the latter was much better. Teams were reluctant to add stops given experience and recent history of the Australian Grand Prix and this pushed many into poor strategies, rather than adapting to the tyre behaviour we were observing.

2013 was an interesting year for strategy, with empirical data and lack of bias being really important to getting the strategies right. If you were to look through those races there are certain teams that flip-flopped a lot and others that quickly adapted to the new 'normal'.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/assiraN I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 24 '20

Hi, thanks for doing this Q&A. Working for an F1 team is the dream, though I understand it's very difficult to get in. I'm disabled, would this matter to an employer? Do you have any advice on how I could approach this to someone as I'm just finishing my first year at University and hoping to apply for internships.

Also, (sorry if you've answered this question already) I am studying Mathematics probably going to move into Mathematics and Statistics. Would it be possible to apply for a strategist position with a Mathematics degree?

27

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

Your disability should not matter to an employer and I really believe it will not. We have people with disabilities working at McLaren. Perhaps if it is something you are concerned about or if its a disability that a team (or McLaren) could help make easier to manage (apologies if my wording is not sensitive) then I would highlight that in your application when you apply for a role.

Mathematics is entirely sensible as a background for a strategist role. I started off in Mathematics (& Statistics) before I moved over to Engineering (I found Mathematics at university to be too abstract for my liking). If you are doing Statistics anything that covers stochastic modelling would be particularly relevant to strategy.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/bart2000003 Ayrton Senna May 22 '20

How did it feel to be part of mclaren last year? Like it has been in an incredible year with outstanding results.

76

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I have to say, I have enjoyed every year at McLaren and I started in 2015 when the results weren't outstanding - I am working with really awesome people and even through the bad times it is great to see the team spirit that pervades through everyone.

Last year was incredible and it's good to get an upswing in performance and to see teammates celebrating the thick after making it through the thin!

→ More replies (1)

20

u/twiloph May 22 '20

Hi ! Thank you for answering some of our questions ! I've been wanting to ask, in the event of a car failure ( engine failure, hydraulics failure, etc) how do you become aware of it ? Do you have a real time data link to the car as an engineer ? Or is it something you see on a TV ?

46

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

So we get data from the cars "live", there are hundreds of sensors on each car and this data is transmitted to us at the track and we also transmit it back to HQ in Woking. There are tens of people looking at the data and typically we will spot problems in the data, or based on feedback from the drivers, before we see them on TV.

That doesn't mean that we never spot stuff on TV first - sometimes you don't have instrumentation for certain things and so you may spot it visually first and the TV feed is a good way of sense-checking in some cases as well.

10

u/[deleted] May 21 '20

What exactly does a CS do in F1? Asking for a friend

25

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

I think many roles could be applicable, but most teams will have fairly substantial Software Engineering departments, as well as lots of modelling and computation activities in Vehicle Science and CFD - all of these may be quite well suited.

10

u/therealfilo May 22 '20

Hi Randy

My question is, if there's for example safety car deployed and the decision whether pit or not have to be made quickly, can the race engineer and the driver make a decision without asking you?

35

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

They can but they shouldn't and I can't think of an occasion when they have.

Strategy decisions are made by the strategy team (not necessarily by me) and we have processes in place for making decisions where we have lots of time (normally measured in minutes), down to decisions where we may have 2 or 3 seconds to decide what to do for both cars and execute the communications/actions to do it.

Sometimes we may pre-make the decision and sometimes we have to make it on the fly or override our original intent - the thing about safety cars is that the cause of them can often change your variables/strategy.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/fettes_Grummel Formula 1 May 26 '20

Dear Randy,

I would like to ask what is your opinion concerning driver's influence on development of the car.

And are there any big differences between the driver's feedbacks?

Which driver was the best one you have been working with during those 5 years, concerning the feedback?

Thanks in advance for your answer.

22

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Driver feedback has a big influence on the development of the car, after all, if the driver can't exploit upgrades/developments/the car then you won't see any laptime gains - nobody else is in the car and so this feedback is vital. However, it is part of a multitude of tools, experience, analysis, etc. that we have, so you can't underestimate the other contributors to development also.

All of the drivers I have worked with have been quite different in terms of their feedback, I don't think I can pick a best one as they all have great qualities, Fernando seemed to instantly know what was wrong/where to improve, Lando is very open and easy to talk to, etc.

9

u/PaulCocaign May 23 '20

Hello, First of all, thanks for answering all those questions. It's nice for us students dreaming of F1 to have something to look up to. So I am studying mechanical engineering in France and I am really looking forward to become a Motorsport Race engineer, and obviously F1 would be the dream.

What I like the lost in that job is the trackside aspect, travelling, living the race. As I imagine, you need some years of experience to become a trackside F1 engineer. So do you think building experience in lower formulas like F2/F3, FE, or prototypes, GT...as performance/data engineer in smaller teams is a good way to line up for a trackside job in F1 ? Or is it recomended to start as an engineer at the lowest level directly in F1 and try to climb the ladder from there ? What is the proportion of your trackside colleagues that come from other motorsport categories ?

Thanks !

27

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

Great - I look forward to working with you, or competing against you in the future!

That's a tough one. I wouldn't say trackside experience, per se, is very highly desired for trackside roles, but rather a demonstration of the deep technical/operational knowledge, the ability to deal with stress, etc. that makes people successful in those roles.

For this reason, I would say it's better to be in an F1 team and then attempt to try and go trackside, than to be trackside in a 'lower' formula.

The data, from my experience, suggests the same, the vast majority of engineers are in F1 first and then go trackside, rather than being trackside outside of F1 and moving to be trackside in F1.

That is not to say that experience in 'lower' formulae is not immensely useful to securing a job in F1 (just, I believe less preferred than F1 experience).

9

u/-Andar- I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 24 '20

How often do you pick a strategy that is not the fastest (by the models), but is counter to the other team(s) that you are trying to beat that race?

15

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

If you are referring to the "free air" quickest strategy - i.e. if I was racing alone, how many pitstops should I do and what tyre sequence should I use then we will almost always not use that strategy.

That strategy would be quickest if you have no other interactions with other cars, which is rare for any car in an F1 race - as you have interactions from battling/overtakes, lapping, etc. but it is not the best strategy (and potentially not the quickest) when interactions with other cars are present.

Depending on the types of interactions there will be a force that acts on the "baseline" strategy mentioned above, the propensity to drop into traffic, for example, may push a stop lap later to avoid getting stuck or battling, etc. But all of these will need to be weighed up to come up with an "optimum" strategy.

8

u/Alpha_Jazz Yuki Tsunoda May 21 '20

I’m currently at uni studying Mech Eng to hopefully work in F1 some day, and applied for a summer placement at McLaren this year. Of course that’s been cancelled now, and I’m gutted, but am still hoping to be doing an undergraduate placement year in the 21/22 academic year. Ideally, a summer placement this summer would have been a way for me to get my foot in the door and add some much needed experience to my CV, but what would be your advice now, to make myself as appealing a candidate as possible in the decreasing amount of time I have until the application?

18

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Try and find something else, that you enjoy and that is relevant if possible - go fix up an old car, do some formula student, learn a programming language, etc.

Nobody is as gutted as me that Covid is meaning we won't get to work with some very talented summer interns this year.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/collimated May 24 '20

Hi Randeep, first of all, thanks for your deep insights into the world of Formula 1 and McLaren.

My question to you is, how do McLaren (or any other F1 team for that matter) ensure a stable electrical power supply in the case of a loss of normal power supply (Diesel Generators/UPS/battery banks) at both the factory and less likely to occur but still possible, at the track?

Bonus question; how do teams (McLaren) prepare for different types of electrical outlets, voltages and currents all around the world?

23

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 24 '20

To start - I’ll say I’m not an electrician - take the below with a pinch of salt.

Most teams will have generators at the track (actually various kinds - to run stuff on the grid, in the trucks at European events and external ones at fly away races) and some kind of UPS system as well. Power supplies at circuits can be ‘temperamental’ and often there are power outages for specific reasons too.

In terms of for electrical outlets - we as end users just bring our UK stuff and plug it in! There’s an electrician and IT team who ensure that everything is set up and good to go and sneak with different voltage, phase, etc. supplies.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

I want to work in F1 in the future and preferably an engineer role. Would studying Mechanical Engineering be the best course to get a chance? Thanks

44

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I would say the majority of F1 engineers have studied Mechanical Engineering but that doesn't necessarily equate to it giving you the best chance of getting in. Engineering skills (and particularly mechanical engineering skills) will make you suitable for a multitude of roles in an F1 team (from strategy, to design engineering, to race engineering and performance analysis), so naturally you would expect more mechanical engineers.

I would have a think about the role that you would like to do and what qualifications would give you the best chance for that role, it could be that its Computer Science instead, or Aerodynamics, or maybe it is Mechanical Engineering. I would also think heavily about how interested you are in said degree - a degree is not a small investment of time, money and effort and its important you do something you enjoy.

As a quick disclaimer, there are a lot of questions about route into F1, career paths, useful skills and experiences. I intend to answer all of these as I understand how important these are - I'm taking my time to make sure I give the best advice I can and apologies if some of this is repeated across different responses.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/doland3314 Nico Rosberg May 21 '20

Hi Randy, thanks for taking the time to come on here. One of my biggest interests in the sport (aside from the racing) is the commercial side of it. Specifically sponsorships but also the negotiations behind them and just the general business of the sport. What college degrees would be most useful to enter the commercial side of a team, and how often would such positions open? What kind of positions would someone be aiming for to enter an entry level role? I'm about to enter college next year and need to finalise my course choices now, and am hoping for some insights on how to break into that world...thanks again!

7

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

I think anything focusing on the business side could be helpful (e.g. economics) but I think you also have some freedom to do something you enjoy. My impression is that relevant experience will be more useful than degree choice.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/andre_w21 New user May 22 '20

Hi, I'll go right to the point, I'm from Colombia and finishing my last year of Mechanical Engineer, I've worked as a Mechanic for 2 years and understand quite good vehicle dynamics, I'm good in mathematics and I like to code on python and Matlab, and I keep improving my English. Do you think I have an opportunity as an intern in any racing team? Data analytics, vehicle dynamics something, I just want to get in haha, cheers.

29

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

Don't rule yourself out. Many of us never thought we'd get our dream jobs in F1, many of us never thought we were smart or able enough and many of us probably feel like that even once we're in - especially for me, seeing all of the young talent applying for jobs each year. Perseverance is key - you're doing the right things.

"No. Try not. Do or do not. There is no try." - Yoda

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] May 23 '20

Hi Randy. Are there routes to get into motorsport and F1 without the usual maths/engineering route; asking as someone who loves the though of F1 but was shit at DT and intends to study politics?

15

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

Based on some of the stories I had read before working in F1 it had seemed that a degree in politics may have been the way of surviving the 'Piranha Club' - however, that is not the case, thankfully.

It will depend on the kind of role, without gaining engineering knowledge or scientific knowledge you'd struggle to work in the core technical or operational areas but we have a finance department, planning department, HR department, etc. and there may be roles in those other areas that are more suitable.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/mikelops8 May 23 '20

Hi Randy!! I wanted to ask you how hard is predict the degradation and overall performance of this generation Pirelli tyres. Also, are you excited for the new rules?

I was also wondering how international the McLaren team really is in terms of staff.

Thank you!!!

20

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

I would say it's not super difficult in the current generation of tyres to predict degradation and overall performance - this is done by our tyre experts and the strategy team together. Things change, however, through the weekend and sometimes you have to be very much into the empirical data to spot shifts in behaviour because of this.

I am excited for the new rules - change keeps us on our toes and presents opportunities. Even though I thought single-shot qualifying was a bad idea before we implemented it, it presented an opportunity to really adapt your strategy in qualifying to take advantage - as an example of these opportunities.

The team is really quite international, thinking about the people I work with on a regular basis, most are from the UK, but they also include Italian, Japanese, French, Spanish and German as nationalities.

7

u/orzpsd Charlie Whiting May 26 '20

This is probably way too late. Do you require a chemist/physicist, my credentials includes but not limited to growing up on Bruce McLaren road.

How do you handle inter Strategy-team disputes when/if there is a split between differing choices of strategies. What would you consider to be your go to technique to settle these/bring the team back together after maybe choosing a strategy that it becomes quite clear later on that it was not the optimal choice?

12

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Well done on having parents who chose to live on Bruce McLaren road - they're welcome to get in touch 😀 .

I'm assuming you mean disputes inside the strategy team at McLaren (intra? My Ancient Greek is a bit rusty.)?

I think we are fortunate to have very few disputes whatsoever (thinking about any kind of disagreement) - the team atmosphere is really great and we are all just quite honest with each other and open - if one of the team tells me that I made a mistake, or could have done something better then that's probably some of the most useful/trusted feedback I will ever get to get better. It's kind of a nice feeling knowing that you have to do everything really well, because some of the best people in your field work with you and will call you up if not - so you are constantly improving.

Sometimes we will disagree on stuff, there's a lot of data but a lot of things become subjective, as its a case of weighting some factors over other and the weightings can't always be determined. We may disagree sometimes on (mostly non-strategy) stuff and tend to just work out which underlying assumptions/beliefs/knowledge are different and align if we need to.

I think strategically we have very few disagreements - I can't really remember any. If one of the guys told me something could be better, I'd go away and try and work out how to improve it/avoid making the same mistake/ask them to help me fix or improve it, etc. so any disagreements we do have don't really linger.

7

u/KekistanEmbassy Jules Bianchi May 27 '20

Did Lando keep the screensaver or did you get to keep your £250?

20

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Lando has no shame (and may have forgotten how to change the screensaver) and won that particular bet.

7

u/Wouterr0 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 28 '20 edited May 28 '20

Just wanted to say I really appreciate you answering so many questions. What race of the (original) 2020 calendar did you most look forward to? And what is your approach when determining a strategy for a new F1 track, such as Zandvoort?

13

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 28 '20

Both Vietnam and Netherlands GPs were very much up there, because of being new to the calendar. This always adds some extra challenge and can lead to more mixed performances compared to the baseline pace of each car/driver.

You tend to rely a lot on Friday data where you are more pressured than usual to learn as much as you possibly can as you've not run their before. There's also a fair amount of prediction and forecasting before you ever leave (as you have to pick tyres, etc.) and a lot more scenario analysis than normal (and there's a lot normally too). Most teams will have the tracks in their simulators and offline simulations weeks, if not months before the actual event as well.

24

u/Hacker_BoyF1 Pirelli Hard May 22 '20

hello. as a 16 year old student doing a levels what would u say helped u the most in terms of getting to the position u are in now? im intestered very much in working in f1 when i grow up and im looking to do mechanical engineering in uni. thank you

54

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

I would say that Maths, Further Maths and Physics helped and will help the most - especially in preparing you for engineering at university also.

If you have other subjects to choose as well, then I can also put in a word for doing what you enjoy as well as what you 'need'.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/schlumpf78 May 21 '20

How many have strategies are developed for every race?

22

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

We will easily simulate millions of races, if not billions of races for each race. Unfortunately the number of permutations of races possible far exceeds this number, so we have to employ some smart methods to make each simulation more useful than it would be if we just tried to simulate everything.

13

u/Alfonsou Franco Colapinto May 22 '20

Are there any members of the traveling team that have a business / not engineer background? Would love to work in F1, but being an economist does not help. Right?

33

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 22 '20

Being an economist is not common and I don't know of anyone who is travelling who is an economist by background. But for reference I did Engineering, Economics & Management with a fair amount of Economics and Econometrics. It's not impossible, but as long as you're smart, motivated and can pick up the engineering knowledge you have a shot.

12

u/daGonz I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 21 '20

Having worked with the likes of Jenson and Fernando, how much did their feedback work into your calls?

Is jenson really brilliantly nice as he comes across?

13

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Jenson was my favourite driver growing up, so it was a privilege to work with him - he's a really nice guy.

Their feedback is really important - often (and Jenson would attest to this) we would disagree on how many stops there would be but never would you not value the feedback or use it (even if you decided other things were more important).

6

u/[deleted] May 21 '20

Hi Randy, thanks for the AMA! When do the drivers get the last word for a chosen strategy? Is it only in the race, is it before too, given they know the tracks? How the strategy team work alongside all the valuable input from the guys behind the wheels, so you could as a team be always certain about a given strategy? How much drivers and strategists disagree about something? Best of luck in July, I will be rooting for you guys.

EDIT: Grammar.

10

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Nearly always the strategy is decided by the strategy team, I can't really remember occasions where the driver or someone else has chosen the strategy. That doesn't mean that the drivers don't have input, before the weekend when we nominate tyres, during the weekend with feedback and during the race over the radio - but we let the experts in each area make decisions and so the strategy is driven by the strategy team.

There are sometimes disagreements, for example, we may think a 1 stop strategy is possible and the driver may think its not, like with all things we'll discuss it rationally and then decide what to do. Sometimes the driver is correct and the 1 stop is too slow to make it work and sometimes we are correct and the 1 stop is the right choice. We try and have the right expertise, skill and feedback coming into the strategy group such that we are correct most of the time (otherwise what is the point of having a strategy group).

Thank you!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/PHF1_ I was speeding in the Monaco pit lane May 23 '20

How faster cars could go if they had track specific geat ratios like they used to have?

27

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20 edited May 24 '20

With the current generation of cars and powerunits - it's not a huge amount (I can't give numbers). Locking down ratios was and is a great cost-saving measure with little noticeable impact for fans or spectators.

6

u/jndubruyn Jacques Villeneuve May 24 '20

Is Hamilton really that good or is it the car?

Would he be as good if he was in, say, a McLaren?

35

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

I think the evidence stacks up to say that Hamilton really is that good. I imagine he would be as able in a McLaren, but we have to admit that our car isn't yet as quick as his car - but don't worry we're working on it and going in the right direction!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/xdxd08 May 24 '20

Thanks for doing this AMA!

Since most F1 teams are based in and around the UK, how often do teams hire Canadians/Americans for intern level or full-time engineering roles?

P.S I am currently a Canadian software engineering student in Montreal working towards a career in F1 someday.

14

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

I would say it's fairly rare, but I think a lot of that will be based on volume of applications, we get a lot and from memory they are largely non-US/Canadian.

For some internships and placements we require the right to work in the UK which may also be more difficult for Americans/Canadians to achieve - unfortunately this is because we are quite limited in what we can do in this space.

For other roles, including full-time roles it shouldn't be a detriment to your application - especially not if you are able to address it as well in your cover letter.

6

u/SimplyAir I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 24 '20

Hey Randy! I am a big F1 fan and am very interested in what is one thing you hate about being F1? Could be anything just curious since I am not planning to do anything related with F1 (want to become a coder) but want to know something you dislike about being/doing/involved in F1.

Also I know that you already answered something like this but are you going to miss the Carlos/Lando memelord group? Also what are you expecting Riccardo to bring in the meme side.

I like to focus on the silly things about F1 hehe.

17

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 25 '20

I think the one thing I do dislike about F1 is that more people can't be involved in it. I'm so fortunate to work with our young, extremely talented and proactive graduates, intern students and placement students but my role means I am also responsible for turning away swathes of talent as we have such a limited number of roles.

It's not fair that we are turning away people who are far more talented and would have far more positive impact than, for example, myself and it can be quite upsetting. However, as the sport continues to grow and prosper I'm sure there will be many more opportunities coming up.

I will miss the Carlos/Lando pairing just as I miss the Stoffel/Fernando pairing and many of the others. I have been fortunate enough to work with some extremely talented and friendly drivers so in a way you miss every one and every pairing. On the other hand I'm sure it will be just as great, in a different way with Ricciardo - I'm looking forward to some bonza Aussie slang and pulling out the "Chopper does the weather" video each year!

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

How many Gigs of data are generated after a race? Does it vary a lot per race? (provided no failure of some sort)

31

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

It can vary but we're roughly talking between 100 and 200 gigabytes of car data, and lots of other types of data such that its probably 1 to 2 terabytes of total data per weekend.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/choeger May 21 '20

Ok, so one thing bothered me for a while now. In many races we see sudden safety cars or double yellows. More often than not, the commentators turn this into a "everyone has to decide real quickly what to do now" situation.

Do you really decide just then whether or not to pit a car? If yes, why? I imagine you could easily run multiple real-time simulations that tell you at every given moment with a high precision whether pitting is beneficial or not. Is that not possible or is it just the commentators playing up the situation?

17

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Really both things are correct. We try and simulate and analyse what to do in the future, even as humans, every second of the race we'll be thinking what we would do if there were a safety car, probing each other in the strategy team to test our strategies and so on, so in a way we are trying to be prepared before the safety car is deployed, if it is.

However, safety cars can be quite disruptive, depending on who has crashed or what has caused it, etc. your simulations and prior analysis may no longer be useful because the race state has changed too much. In this case you operate from first principles and (hopefully) a deep understanding of the key factors in the race that would sway decisions one way or another.

Safety car decisions are also very game theoretic which can make things more difficult as you typically won't know your competitors' decisions until some time after the safety car is deployed, reducing your time down even further.

11

u/harveyoc_ May 23 '20

F1 never stops, obviously, but are there any cities or circuits that you especially enjoy visiting because of the facilities or culture, rather than the racing?

35

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

In terms of cities, it's so hard to pick just one, we are fortunate enough to travel to some amazing places.

I have to say that Melbourne (Australia), Suzuka (Japan) and Austin (United States) have to definitely be up there though! But there are so many others that are up there too.

10

u/Karolmo Pirelli Wet May 21 '20

I have heard the radios from Sainz at Brazil 2019 and i know he didn't pit during the SC because he didn't have a delta behind, but i still don't understand one thing about the strategy followed that race.

My question is, what led you to put Lando on the hards and Carlos on the mediums? Were you aiming to do a 2-stopper with Carlos originally and changed your mind after the Safety Car "shortened" the race? Or did you believe he was better and keeping the tyres alive?

21

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

There are reasons, but I'm afraid these lips have to be sealed on this one.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/rerowthagooon May 24 '20

Hello! I am currently working for Honda Performance Development where we develop and build the Indycar Honda engine. I got in through an internship from my community college and I have been tearing down and inspecting the engines when they come back to us. I am young and have only taken little math classes so far because I want to become an engineer one day and work in F1. I just don’t know what kind of engineering I should try to get into. I’d love to become one of the engineers who push our engines to the limit at the track. People have told me mechanical engineering can quite basic just designing parts while electrical engineers deal with stuff like engine mapping. What should I do and pursue?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/chute_mi536 Red Bull May 25 '20

Hey Randy!

I've been reading through all these questions ans answers, they're all awesome. I also might be a bit late, sorry.

I'm 16 and have dreamt(literally) of being a f1 aerodynamicist when I grow up! I have a knack for physics and calculus.

What kind of degree do I try to persue/study? I am absolutely bewildered by the amount of information out there. Is mechanical engineering the right place to study fluid dynamics, or engineering science?

Thank you in advance!

P. S. I live in New Zealand

8

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

It can vary between general engineering, mechanical engineering, aerodynamics, aeronautics and so on. I would suggest you find something you enjoy and also interrogate the course content to see how applicable it may be to your career desires before committing.

5

u/falseman0001 May 27 '20

hi randy quick question are there any legal related jobs in f1 in specific for lawyers

13

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 27 '20

Yes, most teams will have (small) legal departments.

9

u/[deleted] May 22 '20

Is there like a kill switch for the car that the team can use to shut off the car

34

u/RandeepSinghF1 Randy Singh ✅ May 23 '20

Yes there is, you may hear race engineers telling their drivers to go from "P2 to P1 or P0" and that is effectively what is happening (turning the car off). This procedure is drilled into every driver and race engineer as its very important for safety too.

We can't turn it off remotely as we're not allowed to communicate from the pits to the car (otherwise we'd probably be making all kinds of changes all the time).

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Ashbones15 I was here for the Hulkenpodium May 21 '20

What was the biggest mistake you've done and what were you able to do to correct it? Or in other words how do you deal with mistakes during the race in order to get evetything back in order?

→ More replies (1)