r/Imperator • u/Kloiper Senātus Populusque Redditus • Mar 08 '21
Help Thread Senātus Populusque Paradoxus - /r/Imperator Biweekly General Help Thread: March 8 2021
Please check our previous SPQP thread for any questions left unanswered
Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears!
Welcome to Senātus Populusque Paradoxus, The Senate and People of Paradox. Here you will find trustworthy Senators to guide your growing empire in matters of conquest and state.
This thread is for any small questions that don't warrant their own post, or continued discussions for your next moves in your Ironman game. If you'd like to channel the wisdom and knowledge of the noble Senators of this subreddit, and more importantly not ruin your Ironman save, then you've found the right place!
Important: If you are asking about a specific situation in your game, please post screenshots of any relevant map modes (diplomatic, political, trade, etc) or interface tabs (economy, military, etc). Please also explain the situation as best you can. Alliances, army strength, tech etc. are all factors your advisors will need to know to give you the best possible answer.
Bibliothēca Senātūs:
Below is the library of the Senate: a list of resources that are helpful to players of all skill levels, meant to assist both those asking questions as well as those answering questions. This list is updated as mechanics change, including new strategies as they arise and retiring old strategies that have been left in the dust. You can help me maintain the list by sending me new guides and notifying me when old guides are no longer relevant!
Getting Started
New Player Tutorials
General Tips
Country-Specific Strategy
- Help fill me out!
Advanced/In-Depth Guides
- Help fill me out!
If you have any useful resources not currently in the senate's library, please share them with me and I'll add them! You can message me or mention my username in a comment by typing /u/Kloiper
Calling all Senators!
As the game is very new, we are in dire need of guides to fill out the Senate Library, both general and specific! Further, if you're answering a question in this thread, consider contributing to the Imperator wiki, which needs help as well. Anybody can help contribute to the wiki - a good starting point is the work needed page. Before editing the wiki, please read the style guidelines for posting.
7
u/Coyote-Cultural Mar 20 '21
Does anyone have any lets play they suggest to relearn the game? I haven't played since about a month post release and it looks like a lot of stuff has changed.
Mostly interested in playing tribes
5
u/Porygon- Mar 11 '21
New player here, have some experience with eu4 but zero with I:Rome.
I started as Syracusae and conquered every province in the island except for those of Carthage.
What is the next step? Collecting Gold, build buildings in my cities and wait until either the nexyt opportunity for war? (When rome is in another war to expand there, or cartharge in another war to attack them).
Should I build a navy, so I can attack catharge, conquer their land on the island and then hold off any reinforcement with my navy?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
Is it possible to change the default tactics for your levies? It makes sense to be using Shock Action if I'm Macedon or something, but playing as a nation that relies less on Heavy Infantry its a little obnoxious to have to change the tactics of all the levies every time I raise them.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
Major bug
When reinforcing an army, if your army arrives on the exact date that you initial army is defeated, the reinforcing army will be immediately defeated as well.
If the initial army is stack wiped, it doesn’t matter what the size of the reinforcing army is; it will get stack wiped as well.
4
u/DarmokAndJaladAtTana Mar 21 '21 edited Mar 21 '21
So if I'm roman and embrace greek traditions, will I keep the traditions even after I revoked the integration status of the greeks?
So could I integrate cultures in order to get their military traditions and later disintegrate and assimilate them while keeping those traditions?
Edit: Okay I tried it. I unlocked the greek traditions by integrating 512 macedonian pops from the roman tradition tree. After I revoked the integration status for the macedonians the greek tradition tree was still available. So it should work for any other tradition tree. The greek one might actually be usefull for the other techs.
3
u/h3lp3r_ Mar 09 '21
I've been trying to create Phoenicia in 2.0 as Byblos but I can never get past 10 or so years after the Diadochi Wars. Either the Seleucids or (most likely) Egypt will eat me up, and not even three or four mercenary armies that I've saved up to be able to afford can really do anything. Mercenary morale ticks up so frustratingly slowly that I'm always fighting with at most 50% morale against better armies anyway. Is there any viable strategy for someone who isn't an expert on the mechanics of the game? I don't think I'm super bad at the game, although it kind of feels that way right now.
3
u/Lewa263 Mar 13 '21
Does the Civilization Effort policy still civilize adjacent barbarian wastelands so they stop spawning? I don't see that anywhere in the UI anymore, but I know it was the case when I played last year.
3
u/Abangerz Mar 16 '21
i forgot to sack pella as sparta and now i realize i can't get an achievement forming the Argead Empire as sparta, already crush egypt and got the needed cities got a 100 year left in the game. fml.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
As a tribe, can you raise levies before starting a migration, and if you uproot all your provinces, do the levies stay or disappear?
3
u/Willem_van_Oranje Barbarian Mar 20 '21 edited Mar 20 '21
Not a question, but a complaint!
If you merge cohorts that have no general with an army that does, the general of the army will receive a -5 temp loyalty malus (revoked offices) IF he/she was leading a smaller amount of cohorts than the ones merging in. Each time you do it will add another -5 loyalty, it stacks.
This makes no sense. A general shouldnt lose loyalty for given more units under command (except regarding power base ofc). The result is that reorganizing your army will often lead to temp -10 to -20 loyalty deductions.
You can only avoid it by splitting the army that will merge into the general into smaller units than the general currently commands.
I only started noticing the problem when I switched religion for the first time in I:R, which is almost always done shortly after a war due to the needed new religion pops, which means states will often be reorganizing armies afterwards, which in turn leads to disaster because theres a -15 loyalty for all characters after converting (except the 8 or so that convert to the new faith from the decision). The revoked offices loyalty malus on top of that made my state go civil war.
2
u/Jaggedmallard26 Rome Mar 08 '21
Does "The garrison was allowed to march out" actually mean anything or is it just fluff? I seem to always get it even if I win by completing an assault where I would have thought they'd all have been killed.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '21
Is there any way to manage treasures in holy sites that I own without either sacking the holy site or adding the deity to my pantheon?
2
u/Abangerz Mar 11 '21
Being a republic is actually better than a monarchy you get access to legions quickly when modernization event happens.
2
u/grinch12345 Mar 11 '21
Any tips how to get the senate support to 51%? I got 20 tyranny without even noticing (apparently you act like tyrant even when you improve relations with vassal.) Monarchies seems so much simplier, you just shouldn't give any titles to pretenders, that's it.
2
u/LuckyLuigi Mar 12 '21
Is it still possible to 'assign troops to a governor to increase province loyalty' ?
I raised the levies of a province and it seemed to have no effect.
If it is possible to do this, can someone explain how in detail ?
2
u/Thibaudborny Mar 13 '21
Question on mission trees. Was playing the Macedonians and at one point you had the mission for Alexander’s empire.... but it is stuck with the finding pieces of Alexander’s armour and the Hemhem Crown.
I cant find these? There is 0 tooltips on how to acquire these. If this is working as intended it is pretty obscure....
2
u/JimmySplodge03 Mar 14 '21
Mercenaries. How do I get the ability to use them now in 2.0.2?
2
u/Leptomeninges Mar 15 '21
Is there any consensus on if it's better to cherry pick from the two tradition trees available versus trying to fill out enough of another tree to unlock a different culture? Or is it too culture specitic?
2
u/Nimex_ Mar 16 '21
Any tips or tutorials on legion unit composition? I'm playing my first game in ages and I'm lost when it comes to what unit types to use. I've been winging it so far in my Armenia game, but now that I can raise more legions and am trying to conquer the seleucid empire, I need to professionalise my army. Right now my two legions are a mix of heavy inf, archers, light cav and horse archers, with supply units and engineers for support.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '21 edited Mar 17 '21
How would you rank the uses of political influence in order of importance? (newbie so I'm missing some)
Is it worth it to change laws, policies, ideas liberally? Or is PI too important to waste
2
u/Markerers Mar 18 '21
Is one city per province still the best strategy? Can it cause issues later in the game to have 2 or 3 cities per province, in an area like Egypt regarding food supplies?
2
u/durkster Eburones Mar 18 '21
Anybody got any tips or strats for Syracuse in the new update. by the time i control sicily rome has already conquered all of southern italy. how can I destroy them before they get too strong?
2
u/InvictaML Mar 19 '21
For some reason my legions are not receiving distinctions , for example my 1st legion did not receive the primigenia distinction and has fought 40+ battles and still nothing. Are there any fixes / reasons why ? (I have all DLC as well)
2
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
My ally won’t stop white peacing when we have 44% warscore. It’s pissing me off. Im trying to take land, but they refuse to give me any land either
2
u/redruby01 Mar 20 '21
Had a random major house enter my empire that came out of the blue. Bir Tarqridi. And the weird thing is that their name is in bold so it has a tool tip. As rome there are only the Julii, Cornelii, Claudii, Fabii and their major family is no where. Weird this is that they also have the "scorned" family debuff if im not giving them jobs?!
1
u/Willem_van_Oranje Barbarian Mar 17 '21
I think I found an exploit the other day that needs fixing. Migratory armies have access to all territories regardless of owner. Now, while at peace, if you occupy every territory with a single cohort in a province of a state, then declare war, they can't raise any levies. This means that with migratory tribes you can conquer any state in the game that has no standing army right from the start. I haven't moved from Germanica to Rome yet, but it seems that as a tiny tribe I could even conquer all of rome about 2 years into the game without taking a single loss.
The fix would be to make it possible to raise levies even when theres an enemy cohort busy occupying the territory.
1
u/bloody_yanks2 Mar 08 '21
Is there a workaround for minor characters randomly replacing my great family governors? It’s no fun to realize some 2 martial 1 finesse gibbering lump has taken over my Macedonian levies in the middle of a campaign.
1
u/Teach_Piece Mar 08 '21
Hi all. Is the starting democratic republic of Athens as terrible as it seems? Monarchies get to use the stats of their stats in place of their own, and most republics get the co-council. But Athens has no one to buff their fairly weak ruler.
1
u/DangerTrousers Mar 08 '21
Can we repeal cultural decisions that have been applied to non-integrated cultures?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21
anyone else having trouble with achievements? I definitely sacked Carthage as Rome and the achievement didn't fire.
1
u/DangerTrousers Mar 08 '21
Is there any way to take wealth away from characters?
1
u/Leptomeninges Mar 08 '21
How do you build wonders? I can't find it in the interface.
1
u/Chihawks2015 Mar 09 '21
Is there a way to check assimilation progress? I was trying to assimilate but I couldn’t tell how long it would take
1
u/Blueknight1706 Mar 09 '21
is there anyway to see who is up for election like the possible candidates, im trying to role play oligarchs but its difficult if i cant see who the candidate is
1
u/redruby01 Mar 09 '21
How does one remove certain units from a legion without dispanding and rebuilding it?
1
u/lukelhg Mar 09 '21
I'm still on my first game as Rome, but it seems to be a period of expansion followed by double that time just dealing with disloyal provinces launching independence wars.
I've replaced governors, built court houses, changed the province focus to harsh treatment, and this just keeps happening.
It causes my war exhaustion to fill up which causes my stability to stay low, and it's like an endless loop, it's infuriating.
Is there a quicker or easier way to stop this that I'm missing? Because as it is I can't even bring myself to load up my save knowing I'm going to spend my evening just fighting my own provinces.
1
u/PsypherPanda Mar 09 '21
Are there any good guides, either high level or in depth, on what to build/develop in different scenarios?? I feel like I’m just picking randomly based on the pops of the city at the time which would give me the most benefit, such as a library with lots of nobles, etc.
1
u/barcased Mar 09 '21
Subjected to Casus Belli penalty / -25
I have some of the subjects I've acquired through Rome's first section of quests. However, I also had acquired CBs on them before getting them to submit. Now, they have a permanent -25 opinion penalty on me - Subjected to Casus Belli, which curbs my ability to reach +190 opinion and integrate them. I know I can release them and then conquer them, but I would prefer to do it peacefully. Is there any way I can remove this malus?
1
u/epursimuove Mar 09 '21
How does aggressive expansion (the country stat) relate to aggressive expansion (the diplomacy relation modifier)? Like, the first one definitely gives you the second one, but what's the formula?
1
u/Pruppelippelupp Mar 09 '21
What's the best strategy with roads? Do you connect big cities with all neighboring territories? Each connection gives twice as big trade route bonus as a marketplace.
1
u/Dagorha Mar 09 '21
Is there any reason to keep Merc stacks around after you use them? I'm playing Judea and I needed to grab an emergency stack when Egypt attacked but now I'm not sure if I should be keeping it to dissuade the Selukids from attacking or w/e
1
u/JTDestroyer5900 Mar 10 '21
Hey so I'm gonna declare war on nation A, who are allied to nation B. Nation B is in a defensive league. Will they drag their entire league into the war also? Also, is there a way to tell if a nation is gonna get additional allies mid war cause that's some vicky 2 bullshit and pretty annoying :/
1
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '21
Can any nation (theoretically) declare Empire? What are requirements? Can I have the map say "Athenian Empire" if I do things correctly?
1
u/Leptomeninges Mar 10 '21
What determines and how can you produce high stat heirs? Breeding? The stats on the tropheus?
1
u/Darth_Dangus Mar 10 '21
I’ve had the game since launch, but never played as the Seleucids. After buying the Heirs of Alexander DLC, it makes a lot of sense to play them. I think I have a fairly good idea on how to balance culture and religious assimilation to ward off rebellion or disloyalty, but the Legacy of Alexander CB confuses me. If applied, territories that fall to me automatically become part of my land. Is there an effective way of defeating the Antigonids and their vassal swarm?
1
u/Jari1444 Mar 10 '21
Anyone else having a visual bug in MP where you see only about 50% of the cities on the map if you aren't the host?
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Rome Mar 10 '21
I notice when I take territory the AI will have built ports all over the place. Am I safe to just remove these ports from Settlements or am I missing something?
1
u/epursimuove Mar 11 '21
Has anyone confirmed if you can get 2.02 achievements with a save from 2.01?
1
u/ReginaldWestford Mar 11 '21
So I asked this on the last thread and never got an answer, how does one edit a country to change its starting primary culture? I'm trying my best to read the code but it's like slamming my head against a wall at this point; I have no idea what I'm doing and the wiki is really not much help, unfortunately. Thanks to any that read this and even more thanks if they can help!
1
u/Jokkekongen Mar 11 '21
Do you have to have a certain amount of money to disband mercenaries? The war is over and they’re draining my coffers and I can’t find a way to get rid of them or any tooltip that indicates how much they need.
1
u/Acoasma Mar 11 '21
How do I reliable change the ruling dynasty of my monarchy?
1
u/Gavetta0 Massilia Mar 11 '21
New player here. Is there any consequence for not contributing to an ally's war? I mean answering the call of arms and then doing nothing.
1
u/Kiempesten One small village of indomitable Gauls Mar 11 '21
Is there a good way to deal with 1 city single tile states? I feel the cost for fabricating claims on them being prohibititive, and resulting in me expanding around them.
1
u/olwitte Mar 11 '21
Are the guides here still generally good after 2.0?
1
u/KingKCrimson Mar 12 '21
Are there any MEIOU-like mods for this game?
1
u/Leptomeninges Mar 13 '21
Two questions. First, is it still possible to release a governorship as a client state?
Second, what's the downside of having a region without a governor?
1
u/JTDestroyer5900 Mar 13 '21
How do I increase the concentration of a religion that isn't the dominant one? More specifically, I'm going for Pillars of Asohka and I cannot seem to find a way to raise buddhism. I have Siddhartha as my Culture deity but converting 5 people in 5 years seems very suboptimal :/
Other than conquering the tribes full of Bhuddists is there a way to convert quicker? Cause I'm at like 45 AE from conquering the eastern Bengal nation and the one above it...
1
u/Wolog2 Mar 14 '21
A client state of mine had a province rebel against them, I automatically got pulled in to the war and made war leader. How can I end the war with my the client getting their province back? I occupied all the forts but I don't want the aggressive expansion from taking it myself.
1
u/Caeser5 Mar 14 '21
What is the best laws for Rome in 2.0 ?
1
u/Gavetta0 Massilia Mar 15 '21
Playing as Massilia. I'm allied with rome and suddenly they get claims on my home province, Alpes Maritimae. Is there a trigger that makes them get claims?
This run will probably be game over soon, so the next one I would like to know what's the trigger to try and prevent it.
1
u/Leptomeninges Mar 15 '21
Any consensus on the most valuable wonder bonuses?
1
u/luigitheplumber Mar 16 '21
Am I misremembering or are there events for rome that change the military laws? I want to use legions but don't want to waste PI if I can get it via event, anyone know what the requirements for the event are
1
u/Tsukix Mar 16 '21
I need to get the last quarter of the Iberian peninsula from Carthage, I can probably take them head on, but they are guaranteed by Egypt. Is there a way to make Egypt break the guarantee? I can only match my army with Carthage and not both.
1
u/Stonewyrm Mar 16 '21
Hello Everyone
Is it still recommended to only build one city per province? If so, why?
Are there exceptions?
For example if I need to build a bigger fort to defend a choke point or if the big city is inland and I want a port nearby. Other exceptions like for trade or something like that?
1
u/Dagorha Mar 17 '21
Kinda new at keeping pace with Paradox updates but when can we expect the next dev diary?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '21
What should I do with my money? It's my first campaign with Rome and I've been very conservative with my money because I don't know where to spend it.
I am doing a wide, no-integrate (only assimilate), max research efficiency run. I am rushing the inventions which give me research efficiency.
I don't know if I should use the money to improve relations, build a navy, build Academies or Libraires, build Theaters for assimilation etc.
I don't really want to stack income modifiers, i'm mostly focusing on researching, expanding and assimilating
1
u/innerparty45 Mar 17 '21
Can I complete the final task in Pearl of Greece mission as Sparta? It says I need 4 religious province investments in Boetia, but it calls them Religious Endowment, while as Sparta with Magna Graecia it is called Heroic Freeze. I am not sure if the mission will register the investment, since it'll cost me like 215 political influence?
1
u/JimKlo83 Mar 17 '21
With buildings like the academy and forum and settlements like the barracks, does the desired pop ratio bonus apply to the specific region or the entire province in general?
1
u/JimKlo83 Mar 17 '21
Whenever I use mercenaries the entire stack dies the second they go into battle. How are you supposed to use them?
1
u/JimKlo83 Mar 18 '21
When playing as a republic, is there a way to either get remove a party or remove their agenda? I'm playing as Massalia and when I integrate Salluvian culture the Traditionalists constantly demand revocation and when I refuse I lose all my support and then I can't do anything without gaining a bunch of tyranny.
1
u/Leptomeninges Mar 18 '21
Playing another Sparta run. The Ancient Rivals mission has been buggy in the past. My understanding has been that you needed two of the three for it to successfully launch: an independent macedon with thessalonica and pella, an independent athens, and an independent thebes. In my current game the mission isn't being offered at all. Macedon and Thebes should make criteria although macedon did suffer through a revolution and thebes was briefly my vassal before being released. Anyone know if anything has changed?
1
u/clockmann1 Mar 18 '21
What is a decent late-game levy size (per region)? I want to know how well I'm doing in my Judea game as I'm about to go against the Seleucids.
1
u/iron-carbon_alloy Mar 18 '21
What's the best way to decide if you need to integrate a culture? My last Egypt game more or less went down in flames due to provincial revolts in areas I thought were secure because I integrated the culture, but the pops still generated unrest that outpaced the Harsh Treatment.
Also, should I have focused more on getting inventions that improved culture happiness over discipline and other military buffs?
1
u/TheUnbrokenCircle Mar 18 '21
Is playing the tutorial and continuing as Rome the best way to learn the game at the moment?
1
u/Darth_Dangus Mar 19 '21
Trying to go for some achievements after forming Argead for the first time. Campaign is winding down, it’s 86 BCE. Why won’t Holy Fire pop after I’ve desecrated at least 12 different religions? Thought it was bugged at first, but I quit and restarted and it still didn’t pop. Also, the four deified rulers is a real tough. Seems like I never have the 300 PI along with ruler popularity at 90.
1
u/happyhalfway Mar 19 '21
I don't know how but I got Ptolemies successor kingdoms claims on my second ruler. I think it might have to do with a force terminate program I did when the succession happened (it didn't stop the succession...). It now says I have these claims until 727. I'm a little confused how this happened, does anyone else have any experience in this regard?
1
u/Saeko-Saeba Mar 19 '21
Where do you see the total bonus of troops ? I have many tradition who gifted x% to attack, moral, research etc, i'm unable to find that now !
1
u/Kiempesten One small village of indomitable Gauls Mar 19 '21
Is there any way for players to change their country in multiplayer?
1
u/Mayan_Fist Mar 20 '21
What are the best diplomatic stances for when you're not at constant war?
1
u/Orpa__ Mar 21 '21
How do you deal with holy sites? I end up removing them by midgame because they draw a lot of migrants from nearby settlements, which is nice early game when it's your neighbors' pops but not so nice when you can't properly distribute your own pops.
1
u/h3lp3r_ Mar 21 '21
It feels like it's basically impossible to expand into India as Bactria once you're independent. Maurya simply has one trillion pops for armies. No amount of money can stop them!
0
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '21
[removed] — view removed comment