r/Anarchism • u/quangli • Jun 03 '21
Meta A mod's introduction to why we don't want pro-capitalist or pro-authority arguments in this sub
This was in response to a comment in our weekly free talk:
The whole world is overall authoritarian and capitalist. We listen to arguments like yours all the time, and they are embedded in the very way that most people live. On the other hand we have already engaged with them and done a lot of work to build up our world view, and your engagements are forcing us to talk about basic first principles that we want to be able to take for granted in our conversations.
Sometimes, we want to just have conversations about our own ideas. The reality is, though to an outsider you see things as an echo chamber, there is a huge amount of disagreement among us about how we want things to look. We choose purposefully to have a space for conversations limited to a certain set of topics.
If you call a regular meeting with like-minded people to discuss how to resolve the issue of a new giant building development happening that will raise the floodplain and endanger your houses, but at the meeting there are people there who are derailing conversation by talking about why they actually think there's no issue with the floodplain rising, we would say, hey, that's not what this meeting is about, please stick on topic, and we have a weekly meeting already dedicated to that kind of question - r/Anarchy101. Others insist they want to have the development because of the jobs it will bring, and we simply don't want to deal with those arguments when we know the development in fact will reduce jobs by destroying local businesses - even before we talk about the huge amount of other issues we have with the giant development (gentrification, whatever), and actually we have made a meeting space for you to discuss that if you want - r/DebateAnarchism. Then they complain that we are an echochamber and insist that they want to talk about their thing during our meeting about another topic.
In reality, we get dozens if not hundreds of people every week like you trying to talk about stuff we have not made the space specifically for. It's taxing telling you all one by one why we do what we do, so we make a rule.
Even more simply, If a group of people who love dungeons and dragons come together in their own space to play dungeons and dragons, and people (constantly) crash the party to insist we play settlers of catan, asking why we won't play their game and insisting that we should, we would just say, hey, no, that's not what we're doing here, go play your game with the people who like settlers of catan, that's what those people should do. When people then say that they still want us to play catan, they come off like assholes.
> [some anarchists] do support structure and authority [so we should be talking about that here]
On this point, the actual fact of the matter is that anarchists reject all authority. All. There are however vastly more non-anarchists participating on this sub than anarchists, and many of them think they are anarchists because the internet/world is a cesspool of bad information, and they simply do not understand that they are misinformed. The point of structure is somewhat different and there are disagreements there among anarchists, I won't go into that now, because this is becoming too long a post. Unfortunately the same goes for people answering questions in r/anarchy101 and r/DebateAnarchism. Non-anarchists participate and vote and so the most upvoted stuff is generally the least anarchist, because they are agreeable to most people by virtue of being watered-down lowest-common-denominator shit.
•
u/quangli Jun 03 '21
This is not up for debate, btw, it is just policy here, so don't waste your time, just go to the appropriate subs to engage.
163
u/Buzzerbea Jun 03 '21
This will fly over the heads of those it’s aimed at.
106
u/therift289 soros unpaid intern Jun 03 '21 edited Jun 03 '21
Ngl, I'm pretty sure like 90% of the issues in this context result from the fact that there are two different definitions of authority.
Edit: To clarify, since there seems to be a bit of noise in the child comments:
A lot of the authority/hierarchy discussions, to me, seem to break down as a result of the two definitions getting crossed. Person A says "reject all authority and hierarchy" talking about definition 1. Person B says "what about a medical professional directing people to save somebody's life?" talking about definition 2. It all turns into an unproductive argument from there.
62
u/AMeaninglessPassage Anarcho-Bidenism Jun 03 '21
Anarchists reject authority, but recognize expertise. If an electric engineer tells me that I am about to set my house on fire, Imma listen to them for they know better than I do.
79
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
Good mod post. I'm fucking sick and tired of so called anarchists saying "yh bruv justified hierarchies are cool tho" like fuck off with that shit. No self professed anarchist will ever want someone to be above another. What in "no god's no masters" did you not understand?
Idk bruv like you look at the anarchists subs and I swear half the time it's libs masquerading as "woke warriors" feeling good cos they said ACAB or defund the pigs or some shit, or people with the vaguest comprehension of anarchism. Not to gatekeep or anything like we were all baby anarchists at one point and comrades will educate you, it's just frustrating witnessing the same arguments day in and day out. Like raa bruv read the fucking sidebar and the FAQ! Begin your anarchist journey with some research, formulate your own opinions then break them down by researching some more!
This sub amongst a few others are the only places online where I feel like I can share my views as they are, not watered down for work or for the general populace. There was definitely an influx of libs after the US election and Bernie got dicked over, then the whole Biden shit. (Also another gripe about Reddit in general, shits so UScentric). Anyway Im rambling lmao, big up to you mods, not a fun or rewarding role, can only begin to imagine some of the shite you have to see and deal with
51
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
Given the length you might want to ad a TLDR for those who may have issues reading massive paragraphs
29
u/piiig Jun 03 '21
I'm glad to see our space being defended.
18
u/0xdeadbeef6 anarcho-syndicalist Jun 03 '21
Bold of you to assume the they're gonna read that lol
9
u/SeriousGesticulation anarcho-communist Jun 03 '21
I always worry when I read stuff like this that it’s aimed at me lol, but I think I’m relatively safe now. I think I was definitely in the “thinks they’re an anarchist but isn’t” camp for a while answering questions on the 101 sub after I’d only read the bread book and watched BreadTube. I’ve come a ways and read/done more since then.
6
u/ladipn Jun 03 '21
Beautifully said.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
You had me at Dungeons and Dragons, I'll bring snacks...
7
u/Swoly_War Jun 03 '21
Thank you for taking the time to write this. I get tired of seeing people who roundly miss the point come in here and try to explain how they are actually anarchist even though they want to be the boss of their small business, have a traditional hierarchical atomic family, and still live in a world exactly like this one driven by a need for money or labor to survive, but because they don't want the government to regulate them they think they are anarchist. I hate to break it to them, but if your view of what anarchism is, is simply unbridled capitalism at its worst, you are not an anarchist in any meaningful way, you are just someone that wishes they were billionaire.
9
u/gizzardsgizzards Jun 03 '21 edited Jun 03 '21
Anarchism incorporates structure all the time. It just has to be horizontal.
7
u/scire_inimicum Jun 03 '21
The last sentence is very true. Anarchism is a "fringe" ideology, so any post truly representing it shouldn't be logically approved by most people. Good post mod 🤘
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
Well said! Have a nice day everyone
2
u/daddyfailure Jun 03 '21
THANK YOU. This is a problem beyond Reddit, pretty much present whenever anarchism is brought up on the internet.
Try making an anarchist-specific discord, and you'll be accused of needing an echo-chamber because you don't want to have the same tired arguments with people who fundamentally disagree with your worldview over. And over. And over.
Maybe we want to progress our ideology and movement, rather than let those opposed suck up ALL of our time and energy?
4
u/InfinitePoints Jun 03 '21
The argument presented in this post makes sense but it would be good if you clarified a couple things:
to deconstruct/criticize them?
-3
u/mdj9hkn Jun 03 '21 edited Jun 03 '21
I think basically the form of "anarchism" here is based on more macro/institutional/class/etc. analysis, vis a vis influence from Marxism, while the "ancap" strain is based on more individual analysis. It's a key point I think. While the ancaps, coming from a place where they're reasoning based on individual behavior, can often get things wrong on emergent outcomes - like, if we do X and Y with private property etc., we optimistically think this must provide the best outcome - traditional anarchists on the other hand, I think, tend to gloss over the fact that they're working with abstract concepts, when all those abstract concepts ultimately boil down to human beings (and other animals) and their behavior, versus misc. inanimate objects.
That's why you constantly see these same debates - ancaps come in talking about force and the NAP and so forth, while the anarchists come back at them talking about capitalism and hierarchy and so forth. It's essential that your reasoning about these abstract concepts is actually grounded in the units of the systems of you're describing - humans and their behavior - which is why I think both perspectives are crucial, and shutting down interaction with other people absolutely is just a way to create an echo chamber. Examining norms for individual behavior is literally essential for any practical anarchist system, while understanding how behavior can stratify social groups, cause inequality, power imbalances, etc. is crucial for creating those norms.
Frankly, I can count the number of "anarchists" of whatever stripe that I've met, who understand both schools of thought, on my right hand - I don't think walling off dissenting opinions is going to serve the purpose of advancing theory. It's easy to point a finger at an "other" group, assume bad faith, assume you know better, but in practice, well, I'm watching this sub and there are other dynamics than that playing out.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
-28
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21
[removed] — view removed comment